o
y^,
S. Hrg. 103--i35
RESOLUTION TOUST CORPORATION
^ WHISTIEBLOWERS
Y 4. B 22/3: S. HRG. 103-435 ^
Resolutioo Trust Coporation Mhistle
BEFORE THE
COMMITTEE ON
BANKING, HOUSING, AND URBAN AFFAIRS
UNITED STATES SENATE
ONE HUNDRED THIRD CONGRESS
FIRST SESSION
ON
WASTE, FRAUD, ABUSE, MISMANAGEMENT, MISCONDUCT, HARASSMENT,
AND DISCRIME^ATION AT THE RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
SEPTEMBER 23, 1993
Printed for the use of the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs
^4y
%
'i
S. Hrg. 103-^35
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
WHISTLEBLOWERS
HEARING
BEFORE THE
COMMITTEE ON
BANKING, HOUSING, AND URBAN AFFAIRS
UNITED STATES SENATE
ONE HUNDRED THIRD CONGRESS
FIRST SESSION
ON
WASTE, FRAUD, ABUSE, MISMANAGEMENT, MISCONDUCT, HARASSMENT,
AND DISCRIMINATION AT THE RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
SEPTEMBER 23, 1993
Printed for the use of the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs
U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE
76-818 CC WASHINGTON : 1994
For sale by the U.S. Government Printing Office
Superintendent of Documents, Congressional Sales Office, Washington, DC 20402
ISBN 0-16-043945-0
COMMITTEE ON BAhfKING, HOUSING, AND URBAN AFFAIRS
DONALD W. RIEGLE, JR., Michigan, Chairman
ALFONSE M. D'AMATO, New York
PHIL GRAMM. Texas
CHRISTOPHER S. BOND, Missouri
CONNIE MACK, Florida
LAUCH FAIRCLOTH, North CaiDhna
ROBERT F. BENNETT, Utah
WILLIAM V. ROTH, JR., Delaware
PETE V. DOMENICI, New Mexico
PAUL S. SARBANES, Maryland
CHRISTOPHER J. DODD, Connecticut
JIM SASSER, Tennessee
RICHARD C. SHELBY, Alabama
JOHN F. KERRY, Massachusetts
RICHARD H. BRYAN, Nevada
BARBARA BOXER, California
BEN NIGHTHORSE CAMPBELL, Colorado
CAROL MOSELEY-BRAUN, Dlinois
PATTY MURRAY, Washington
Steven B. Harris, Staff Director and Chief Counsel
Howard A. MenelL, Republican Staff Director
Patrick J. Lawler, Chief Economist
Patrick A. Mulloy, Senior Counsel / International Affairs Adviser
DouGU\s Nappi, Republican Counsel
Edward M. Malan, Editor
01)
CONTENTS
THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 1993
Page
Opening statement of Chairman Riegle 1
Opening statements, comments, or prepared statements of:
Senator Kerry 2
Senator Bond 6
Senator Campbell 7
Senator Sasser 8
Senator Metzenbaum 9
Senator Murray 13
Senator D'Amato 82
WITNESSES
Patricia Schroeder, Representative in the Congress of the United States,
from the First District of the State of Colorado 11
Prepared statement 82
Michael J. Koszola, Resolution Trust Corporation, IG Agent, Chicago, IL 15
Prepared statement 83
Thomas O'Bryon, Resolution Trust Corporation, Costa Mesa, CA [former em-
ployee] 19
Prepared statement 99
James Romer, Resolution Trust Corporation, Contracting Officer, Dallas, TX
[former employee] 24
Prepared statement 101
Debbie Sherrill, Resolution Trust Corporation, Claims Settlement Agent, At-
lanta, GA 28
Prepared statement 121
William A. Henderson, Resolution Trust Corporation, Legal Information Tech-
nician, Atlanta, GA 33
Prepared statement 123
Deanna Smith, Resolution Trust Corporation, Legal Division, Administrative
Assistant, Atlanta, GA [former employee, currently with FI)IC] 36
Prepared statement 124
Annette LePique, Resolution Trust Corporation, Section Chief, Affordable
Housing Unit, Newport Beach, CA 37
Prepared statement 125
Sandra Crisman, Resolution Trust Corporation, Department Head, Contracts
Department, Newport Beach, CA 40
Prepared statement 127
Hans Mangelsdorf, Resolution Trust Corporation, Asset Specialist, Newport
Beach, CA 42
Prepared statement 130
Thomas Bumside, Resolution Trust Corporation, Senior Attorney, RTC PLS
Program, Dallas, TX [former employee]^ 51
Prepared statement 131
Supplement to statement 441
Bruce J. Pederson, Resolution Trust Corporation, Attorney, formerly in RTC
PLS Program, Denver, CO 64
(III)
IV
Page
Jacqueline P. Taylor, Resolution Trust Corporation, Attorney, RTC PLS Pro-
gram, Denver, CO 68
Prepared statement 179
John Waechter, Resolution Trust Corporation, Computer Services Specialist,
Denver, CO 75
Prepared statement 195
Additional Material Supplied for the Record
National Treasury Eniployees Union 215
Letter to Janet Reno, U.S. Attorney General, U.S. Department of Justice 216
Letter to Stanley G. Tate, nominee, CEO, RTC 218
Letter to RTC Inspector General John J. Adair and FDIC Inspector General
Robert D. Hoffman from Senator Riegle dated November 19, 1992 228
Office of Inspector General, John J. Adair, Inspector General, response to
allegations regarding the OIG 230
Letter from The Deputy Secretary of the Treasury, Roger C. Altman to
Senator Riegle, dated September 28, 1993 311
Letter from Assistant Director — Investigations, Diane M. Mendoza 314
Stanford Law & Policy Review, magazine article entitled "A Never Ending
Story," by G. Christian Hill 448
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
WHISTLEBLOWERS
THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 1993
U.S. Senate,
Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs,
Washington, DC.
The committee met at 10:05 a.m., in room 538 of the Dirksen
Senate Oflfice Building, Senator Donald W. Riegle, Jr. (chairman of
the committee) presiding.
OPENING STATEMENT OF CHAIRMAN DONALD W. RIEGLE, JR.
The Chairman. The committee will come to order.
Let me welcome all those in attendance this morning.
As luck would have it, we are going to have a vote shortly.
I want to start and make an opening statement, and invite my
colleagues to do so as well. I know Senator Kerry is on his way.
We have our distinguished House colleague, Representative Schroe-
der here, who also may be facing a vote on the House side, but we
very much want to get her statement and testimony today.
So let me begin now, and we will go as long as we can. When
we have to adjourn for a vote, we will do that very rapidly. And
I would hope, Congresswoman Schroeder, if you do not get caught
with a House vote, that you will be able to stay so that we can go
right on into your testimony.
This morning the committee is going to hear allegations of waste,
fraud, and mismanagement at the Resolution Trust Corporation.
These issues have been brought to our attention over the past year
not only from today's witnesses — and I thank them all for coming —
but from a number of Senators both on and off the committee, as
well as a number of members of the public at large.
Concerns about the RTC are not in any way partisan concerns.
They have been raised in hearings before this committee for the
past several years by Republicans and Democrats alike.
Most recently, during the course of the committee's consideration
of the RTC funding bill back in March, Senators John Kerry,
Bryan, Boxer, Campbell, Moseley-Braun, Murray, and Metzenbaum
among others, highlighted them at that time.
In their additional views and statements on the Floor, these Sen-
ators and others on both sides of the aisle stressed the need to im-
prove the management at the RTC. Thev indicated that reform of
RTC management was a condition for their supporting additional
funding.
Among the many issues they focused on was the need to ensure
proper financial management and direct accountability at the RTC.
(1)
Another overriding priority they highlighted was the need to re-
form and reinforce the RTC's contracting controls.
Other weaknesses they pointed to included the RTC's inadequate
asset recovery, marketing, and information systems, the impor-
tance of an effective, independent inspector general, the need to
provide real opportunities for minorities and women to participate
fully, professional liability issues, and finally whistleblower protec-
tion.
The Banking Committee in turn incorporated all of these protec-
tions in the Thrift Depositor Protection Act of 1993. I know from
conversations with the Clinton administration that it is absolutely
committed to making these improvements.
In hearings before the committee, Senators D'Amato, Domenici,
and Bond have repeatedly stressed their concerns, as have virtually
every other Member of the committee, with certain RTC manage-
ment problems.
Shortly we will be considering the nomination of Stanley Tate to
be the new Chief Executive Officer of the Resolution Trust Cor-
poration. It is vitally important — and I underscore that — that he be
made directly and lully aware of the many areas for improvement
that we have identified.
I want to particularly acknowledge my colleague. Senator John
Kerry from Massachusetts, for his really outstanding work in help-
ing put together this morning's hearing. He and his staff, and the
staff of the committee, have worked closely together.
That has been much appreciated by me. I think the importance
of today's hearing, as the facts roll out, will illustrate that point.
I also want to commend all of our witnesses for their willingness
to testify today. It takes courage for people to step forward, as they
are doing today, to tell the things that need to be heard that they
know about, and the committee greatly appreciates their coming
forward.
The witnesses here today are people who worked at five of RTC's
regional offices, including Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas, Denver, and
Newport Beach, California. They include employees from RTC's
Legal Division, from Asset Management, and from Administrative
Services of various kinds.
In addition, we will receive testimony from one individual from
the RTC's Inspector General's Office who has made some disturb-
ing allegations concerning that office's effectiveness.
We are especially pleased to be joined this morning by our very
distinguished House Colleague, Congresswoman Pat Schroeder. I
want to particularly welcome her, and I will have more to say when
we call on her.
Let me now turn to other Members for opening statements. Let
me start, if I may, with you. Senator Kerry, for your important role
in this, and then I will go to Senator Bond.
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR JOHN F. KERRY
Senator Kerry, Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
I am particularly grateful to you for holding this hearing, and for
your interest and support in the effort to try to examine the RTC.
You have held many, many hearings on the RTC, and you have
tried diligently to provide the oversight that is necessary, and I am
very, very appreciative to you for your commitment to do that, and
for being willing to do it today. I would like to share some thoughts
about why I think this is important, and not just sort of another
kind of hearing.
We are, all of us, increasingly reminded by the public of the enor-
mous gap between what we come here to do and what we are per-
ceived as accomplishing. This is not a problem that can be taken
lightly. It really cannot. It is the heart of what this Country is all
about. As you watch the Soviet Union, the former Soviet Union,
going through upheaval, as you watch other countries struggling
with this notion called "Democracy," it is rather interesting to
watch here at home how we treat it ourselves.
I know you, Mr. Chairman, and all of us have come here with
a particular set of ideals and a particular set of beliefs about what
we want to accomplish. At the center of that I think is really our
notion that we are here holding the public trust responsible for
how our citizens' dollars are spent.
Increasingly we are finding that our citizens are angry about
that: angry about a Grovernment that seems to act as if it is be-
holden only unto itself, or to the people who are temporarily in
these seats that we hold.
I think that all of us need to be a heck of a lot more sensitive
to our responsibilities in delivering to people. I want to particu-
larly, therefore, single out and thank those who have chosen to
come forward and testify today.
We have all served in institutions. I spent 4 years in the military
and I spent 6 years in the Prosecutor's Office. We all know the turf
tensions. We all understand how pressures in the work place are
brought to bear, and each institution creates its own culture, you
know.
Do not upset the apple cart. Do not go out and say that. Well,
gosh, you are going to hurt people here within the institution. You
are going to jeopardize your job. Why make life miserable for peo-
ple? It is a lot easier just to go along and get along.
That culture begins to destroy the heart of the public trust that
we have all been given. Ultimately it begins to destroy people's
faith in the process itself, which destroys our ability to make deci-
sions, because there is no legitimate consensus in this country for
what we are trying to do because there is no credibility.
So I think this is not just an isolated kind of event. This is my
personal observation of it. If we cannot prove to people that we are
somehow holding the system accountable, that we care about how
those dollars are spent, that we can establish an ethic that is big-
ger than just that sort of internal culture of the institution, but
rather a larger ethic about the larger ideals around which our Grov-
ernment was founded and who we are responsible to, I do not take
it lightly and I do not think any of my colleagues take it lightly,
but I want to make it very clear that those of you who come here
today who are called "whistleblowers," which is in itself a terrible
term
I think you are "Patriots" in the best sense of the word. You are
people who want to hold the system accountable. You are citizens
who pay your taxes who are outraged by practices that you have
been made a party to, and are somehow expected to condone, that
are contrary to the very best sense of what all of us ought to be
delivering.
You are public servants who do not believe that "public service"
entitles you to rip off the public. I think that deserves to be ap-
plauded, not discouraged, and it definitely deserves to be protected.
There is no other way we are going to hold the system account-
able, if the people within the system do not feel that accountability.
So I say that this committee has a special sense of responsibility
to guarantee that when you go back to that workplace you are not
victimized, that you are indeed protected, and that we go forward
from here understanding our own obligations.
Now, why are we here today?
We have all heard from the GAO that, gee, there are some prob-
lems down at the RTC. We hear people say there is waste and
fraud and abuse, but these are words that have become so common-
place they almost do not have meaning now.
I am not sure that there is an agency in Grovernment where we
do not hear about waste, fraud and abuse. It is a cliche, but it does
not have meaning until you begin to g^ve life to the incidents and
practices which constitute that waste, fraud and abuse.
Now I reluctantly voted for additional money to continue to fund
the RTC, recognizing that there were big problems down there, and
all of us at the time expressed our sense that the Treasury really
did not have an adequate picture of those problems.
I thought I did. Candidly, until many of the folks who have come
here today to testify, and indeed until many of those who are not
even here today because they fear to testify — just to make people
clear on the gap between those who corroborate what is going to
be said here today versus those who had the courage to come for-
ward, there is a gap — there were many who told us things but who
said I cannot put myself in that position, or I fear for retribution
to my company, and so they are not here today.
But the RTC has failed to operate according to the law that was
established by the U.S. Congress. They were supposed to maximize
recovery on assets, and GAO has concluded that they have not —
for a lot of the reasons I just articulated.
We required the RTC to minimize its negative impact on local
markets as they sell off properties. In fact, we have heard from one
experienced RTC real estate manager in California that there is
substantial reason to believe, or at least it is a question whether
the RTC has not really contributed significantly to a certain drop
in real estate prices as a result of forced sales.
We required the RTC to make efficient use of funds. We found
enormous failures there. We have actually learned how some RTC
managers leave funds sitting in interest-free accounts, literally
costing the Taxpayers thousands of dollars, for no reason at all.
We required the RTC to minimize losses in resolving cases by
going after wrongdoers, and we found that it disrupted its own
ability to do that through a reorganization that resulted in demor-
alization of staff and loss of some of those cases.
Early this year, we asked our staff of this committee to go out
and really try to talk directly to RTC employees to determine
whether the kinds of problems that were identified by the GAO
were indeed being cleared up. Did we understand those problems
thoroughly? I wanted to determine whether there were ongoing
management problems in addition to the obvious difficulties that
the RTC was having.
Well, we found, to our dismay, that literally dozens of managers
and employees from RTC across the country were candidly
confessing to our office that the GAO's reports of disarray literally
only scratched the surface; that the reality is worse. As one re-
cently departed official from the RTC in Washington told my staff,
it is not only a catastrophe, but it is a snakepit.
We were told of case after case of waste, fraud, and mismanage-
ment, many cases involving people at senior levels. We heard alle-
gations of steering contracts from RTC personnel to former or fu-
ture employees.
We heard of major accounting firms receiving enormous contracts
ill-equipped to do it, and then going out and hiring inexperienced
people to do what they had promised to do, and doing incompetent
work, and padding their bills, to boot.
We were told of RTC managers telling lower level employees to
pay bills, regardless of the quality of the work, even when that
work was being questioned and when there was sufficient cause to
question the quality of the work.
We were told about faulty computer systems for legal billings
with thousands of lost invoices so that the RTC could not even de-
termine if a bill was legitimate or not.
We were told repeatedly about cases of sexual discrimination,
and even sexual harassment at the RTC and in the workplace.
Now I cannot vouch for every allegation, but I can tell you when
this many people are willing to come forward who currently work
somewhere and take an oath and testify under oath, and as many
people corroborate that testimony who cannot come forward be-
cause of the fear that they expressed, there is, as the old saying
goes, fire where there is smoke.
I think it is, at the very least, important to have a full-fledged
administrative internal investigation of these, or even some of
them, through the Justice Department. There have been disturbing
suggestions that the Inspector General's office itself has not func-
tioned as it should have, and we will hear some of that today.
I would just like to take a couple of minutes, Mr. Chairman, to
relay to my colleagues some of those things that people who would
not come here today, but who have testified to us privately, were
willing to say. There was one real estate auction specialist at the
RTC who said, and I quote him:
RTC's auction sales are costing the Taxpayers 15 percent or more in relation to
the real value of the real estate. The data is massaged to hide the losses through
appraisal mechanisms that narrow the difference between the real value and what
the RTC actually sells it for. And my office in California
Quoting him:
— has probably wasted $500 million of its own and Taxpayers' money due to this
process.
Second, the statement of an RTC real estate manager:
Managers at RTC have consistently yelled and cursed at staff, physically and sex-
ually abused staff, targeted women and minorities for abuse, attempted to force staff
to break RTC rules and regulations, attempted to force the award of contracts to
their friends, attempted to force others to cover up their actions.
A statement of a senior PLS investigator with extensive experi-
ence in Government:
I have worked for the Government all my life. Is the RTC worse? Yes. It is the
worst I ever saw. This is not the real Government. They don't have any rules. They
do their own thing. Places I come from, people are very tight with a aoUar. At the
RTC, there's no attempt to save the Taxpayer any money. The organization defies
any command structure. People aren't held accountable for their actions, and they
aren't getting their job done. I've never been in an oi^anization that, when someone
brings a problem to management's attention, instead of fixing the problem they try
to get rid of the person who brou^t the problem to their attention.
Finally, the statement of a bankruptcy RTC lawyer who left the
RTC employ earlier this year to go to the FDIC, He said:
When I was at the RTC, it was the blind leading the blind leading the blind. We
had a receptionist who wound up becoming the person who qualified our attorneys
for RTC contracts. She knew nothing about the law, and the lawyers we hired
viewed us as nothing but deep pockets. We would pay a lawyer $46,000 for a collec-
tion action that could be done for $2,500 to $4,500 in the private sector, for work
that did not need to be done, and which was done incorrectly. Then we'd hire the
lawyer again. I used to say that the RTC was a theater of the absurd.
Now there are good people at the RTC, and the great difficulty
in this kind of effort is always distinguishing between rampant
practice and good people who are trying to make things work.
I also appreciate that it is difficult for this committee, or any
committee in this instance, to sort out every allegation and every
statement. We cannot determine every part of what is fact, and
this is not a jury, and this is not a court of law, but we are respon-
sible ultimately for how these dollars are spent.
One of the great roles of the U.S. Congress — not sufficiently pur-
sued I think today — is oversi^t. We tend to come to the crisis. We
tend to respond to it, and then we all go away as if it has all taken
care of itself More often than not, it is not, and it has not been.
So we are here today, and agEiin I thank you, Mr, Chairman, to
fulfill that role of oversight and to raise important questions, to
probe, and to try to set the stage somehow for some effort to try
to guarantee to the citizens of Uiis country that we are not fools,
that we are not willing to just waste their dollars, that there is a
process in place, and that some people care enough to try to hold
it accountable.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Kerry.
Senator Bond.
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR CHRISTOPHER S. BOND
Senator Bond. Mr. Chairman, thank you very much for calling
the hearing today. Obviously there is much to be discussed. I want
to express my appreciation to our friend, Representative Schroeder,
for taking the time to appear before the committee today, and I
hope. Congress woman, that you will have an opportunity to provide
your testimony.
I have to apologize in advance that I am going to have to leave
because my Appropriations Subcommittee has a markup starting
right after the vote, but I assure all of you I plan to review the tes-
timony and the record.
The hearing today is intended to hear testimony from a number
of witnesses concerning allegations of employment discrimination,
complaints of sexual and racial discrimination, and significant
other complaints concerning waste and abuse at the Resolution
Trust Corporation.
While I do not yet have the full information, I am not in a posi-
tion, nor do I intend to stand in judgment, on any of these com-
plaints. I do believe very strongly this committee has an obligation
and a duty to provide appropriate leadership and oversight regard-
ing the actions and policies of agencies over which we nave juris-
diction.
I emphasize that we expect all agencies of the Federal Govern-
ment to comply with all the laws and other applicable require-
ments, including those relating to the conduct of their employees.
Where an agency or an employee of that agencv fails to comply
with the law or a legal requirement, we demand that the agency
take whatever steps are necessary to ensure that the situation or
the circumstance is remedied.
I want to stress that I have another concern about the hearing.
We have generally before us testimony of 13 witnesses, some
former employees of the RTC, and some current employees of the
RTC. Each has a complaint. As I understand it, some of the com-
plaints have been addressed, and some are pending. The RTC has
assured me that it takes all complaints seriously, and that it at-
tempts to find equitable solutions, and that it does remedy cir-
cumstances or situations where warranted.
The problem I have, Mr. Chairman, is that neither the RTC top
management nor the RTC's Inspector General are present today to
testify. I do not know whether they have been invited to testify, but
I do believe that for us to have a full and fair hearing on these is-
sues we do need the testimony of the RTC and the RTC's Inspector
General.
With respect to these and other allegations and complaints that
have been made, again, Mr. Chairman, I think this is a veiy vitally
important oversight hearing. I look forward to reviewing tne testi-
mony and the record, and I commend you for holding the hearing.
The Chairman. We have every intention of following up on what
we hear today. That is the whole purpose, really, of laying it out,
so that we can go down this trail and get to the end of it.
Senator Campbell.
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR BEN NIGHTHORSE
CAMPBELL
Senator Campbell. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I certainly appre-
ciate your efforts and Senator Kerry's efforts for this hearing.
I wanted to welcome my friend and colleague from the great
State of Colorado, Pat Schroeder, who has been a terrific warrior,
on many battlefields, whether it is for people that are abused in
the RTC or the U.S. Navy.
I would point out to her that my dad's people, the Ancient War-
riors, when they would vanquish their enemy they would often take
their clothes. I was interested in your jacket.
[Laughter.]
Representative Schroeder. You noticed.
Senator Campbell. I noticed.
I, like several of my colleagues, had to vote very reluctantly for
the $26.8 billion for the RTC this year. When I was on the House
8
side, I never voted for it once. I voted against it every time because
I felt that their performance simply caused a lot of resentment and
anger, not only among the constituents but also among the people
in Congress, too, and I would not support it.
Former Senator Bentsen, now Secretary Bentsen, assured me be-
fore I voted for it, as he did many of the Members of this commit-
tee, that there was going to be a major overhaul and a lot of re-
form, and I took his word for it.
I think he is still trying to do that, but certainly we have a long
way to go. That is why I did vote for it. But we have ourselves a
continued mess. The largest city in our State, Denver, recently mis-
placed, if you can imagine this, $7 bilUon in real estate assets.
When they hired an outside firm to clean up the mess, they
ended up getting taken by that company, as well. It just seems to
me that RTC — the name commonly given to it in Colorado now
does not stand for what it stands for, it stands for RIPOFF THE
CONSUMER. We have the fifth worst asset recovery rate in the
Nation, despite the fact that Colorado's real estate market has
weathered the recession better than most States.
Just last week I received a letter firom a constituent telling me
that the RTC had been bought into a limited partnership in a real
estate deal. I asked him to comment on the legality of the deal.
But, legal or not, some people are pretty mad that the RTC is buying into real
estate rather than liquidating the real estate.
Today the Denver office of course is no better off than it was be-
fore. It is still in hot water for trying to harass RTC employees —
and, by the way, some of them are here, and I applaud them for
coming to testify.
Bruce Pederson, Jackie Taylor, and John Waechter are here be-
fore this committee, and will be on a later panel. I certainly want
to commend them for the courage that it took to bring the light of
day to some things that should have been taken up a long time
ago. I certainly give them my word as a Member of this committee
that we are going to make every effort to protect the right that you
have as Americans to be able to say what is wrong in Government.
I would also like to welcome Jim Romer, who is the brother of
Governor Romer, the Governor of our State of Colorado, who is
very active in public service, as his brother is, and look forward to
these hearings.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The Chairman. Thank you very much.
Senator Sasser, the Chairman of the Budget Committee.
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR JIM SASSER
Senator Sasser. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
This morning, I want to welcome Representative Schroeder and
our witnesses.
To those whistleblowers firom the Resolution Trust Corporation,
I want to commend them for their courage and dedication in com-
ing forward this morning and appearing before the committee and
telling us their stories.
The RTC, as we all know, was set up to clean up the mess in
the savings and loan industrv. We are discouraged and chagrined
to learn that the waste, firaua, and abuse in the S&L industry now
appears to be making inroads into the Resolution Trust Corpora-
tion that was conceived to clean up the mess.
So in this environment, Mr. Chairman, we in the Congress and
in Government generally can have zero tolerance for mismanage-
ment, for waste, and for abuse.
The Taxpayers are demanding that we get 100 cents worth of
value out of every dollar spent. So I look forward to hearing from
the witnesses today and getting some of these first-hand accounts.
Perhaps from their testimony here this morning, we can design an
action plan to put trust back into the Resolution Trust Corporation.
So I thank you, Mr. Chairman, and I thank our witnesses for ap-
pearing this morning.
The Chairman. We are joined also this morning by Senator
Metzenbaum, who has had a keen interest in this subject and who
has done a lot of work from his subcommittee position over on the
Senate Judiciary Committee.
He has joined us before as a much-esteemed colleague. We are
pleased to have you this morning, and would be pleased to hear
any opening comments you would like to make, Senator Metzen-
baum,
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR HOWARD M.
METZENBAUM
Senator Metzenbaum. Thank you very much, Senator Riegle.
I want to compliment you. Senator Riegle, and Senator Kerry as
well. These are issues that have been before the Congress time and
time again, and with no exception you have provided a leadership
role. You have been supportive in your concern for protecting the
Taxpayers' interest, and I think we all owe you an everlasting debt
of gratitude.
Senator Kerry has certainly taken a very active role in exposing
some of the problems that not only existed in yesterday, but that
continue to exist at the RTC as we meet here today.
And of course Congresswoman Pat Schroeder is always in the
forefront of every right issue in Congress, and we are so glad that
she is over there and her voice is consistently being heard on issues
of this kind.
I must admit, Mr. Chairman, that I do not have those same
words of praise for the efforts and the actions of the administration
to date.
I am a great supporter of the President of the United States, and
have been a strong supporter, but I am not satisfied that those
charged with the responsibility in the area of the RTC today, that
their shoulder has been put to the wheel and has been as effective
in protecting the public interest and being concerned about it. That
particularly has to do with the issue of the statute of limitations
and the retroactive aspects of it. They should have been with us
and fighting on that issue, but instead they have been against it.
As you know, the Senate Conferees and the House Conferees will
shortly meet with respect to the whole question of the budget and
how much is going to be provided in order to bail out, to pay for
some of the continuing problems in the savings and loan industry,
as far as the RTC is concerned.
10
Now some of the most important testimony today will be about
the serious failure of the RTC's Professional Liability Program
which is supposed to sue malfeasant savings and loan officials.
The National Commission on Financial Institution Reform, a bi-
partisan panel, reported this July that 10 to 15 percent of the costs
of bailout are due to culpable misfeasance. That is $30 to $50 bil-
lion.
Today's witnesses include three lawyers who used to work in the
Professional Liability Section. They will tell us how the section was
reduced to a shambles by a so-called "reorganization." Management
be|jan to dismantle the unit just as the statute of limitations and
suits against hundreds of savings and loan officials were about to
expire.
Let me give you an example of the chaos that the reorganization
caused.
Four RTC lawyers in the Baton Rouge RTC office were notified
in 1992 that the office would be closed in 4 months; that the head
of the office would be moved to Washington, and the other three
lawyers would be let go. The supervising lawyer quickly moved to
Washington. Two other lawyers took private jobs immediately.
That left one lawyer in charge of the investigation of 92 failed
thrifts. Even his secretary left immediately, leaving him to make
do with temporary secretaries.
Of course the workload is impossible, and the RTC in Washing-
ton had to know that. There were an estimated 30 or more poten-
tial defendants to be investigated at each of the 92 thrifts, and
hundreds, or perhaps thousands, of transaction loans and apprais-
als to pursue at each saving^ and loan.
My staff asked the former RTC Baton Rouge lawyer what it was
like to handle that workload alone for 4 months without even a
permanent secretary while looking for another job. He answered by
saying:
It was triage. We grabbed what was on fire at the time and put it out. We looked
at the big transactions. We didn't look deeper. There wasn't enough time.
I want the American people to know that the 1992 reorganization
of the RTC's Professional Liability Section made it impossible to in-
vestigate hundreds, possibly thousands, of potential cases, and to
recover millions of dollars. Instead of recovering that money, we
are left to ask the Taxpayers to pay up.
I also want the American people to know that the former direc-
tors and officers of failed savings and loans — and I think this is the
most important part of my comment this morning — ^have friends in
State houses around the country. Those State legislators have
taken their side against the Taxpayers by passing bills to block
suits by the RTC and FDIC to recover Taxpayers' money from neg-
ligent savings and loan operators.
The most egregious legislation went into effect on the first day
of this month in Texas. It was enacted without opposition on an
emergency basis that allowed it to bypass public review.
A week ago. The National Law Journal had an excellent article
on this wave of State legislation. I have provided each Member of
the committee with a copy. I urge you to read it.
The Texas law says that a director or an officer of a failed thrift
or bank may not be sued for negligence "by the Federal Deposit In-
11
surance Corporation, the Resolution Trust Corporation, or any
other Federal banking regulatory agency" unless the director per-
sonally profited from the transaction.
If Texas voters are not outraged by that, then the rest of the
country should be. A grossly disproportionate number of all failed
RTC thrifts and potentially liable thrift officials can be found in
Texas.
Let me again read from the July report of the Bipartisan Na-
tional Commission on Financial Institution Reform on the causes
of the savings and loan disaster:
The system was most out of control in Texas, which became a breeding ground
for imprudent and abusive practices. The savings and loans it chartered were al-
lowed to engage in hig^-risk activities virtually without limit and supervision and
examination were essentially nonexistent for several years. It was no accident that
40 percent of all Taxpayer losses came from Texas savings and loans.
It is outrageous that the Federal Government and the Federal
Taxpayer is providing Federal insurance to cover losses caused by
negligent savings and loan operators in States which have enacted
laws to shield those operators.
Those laws make a mockery of Congress' intent to keep the
RTC's cost to innocent Taxpayers to a minimum. They are shame-
ful laws. They are a testimony to the complete route of the RTC's
Professional Liability Program.
I am grateful for this chance to hear from the rank and file of
the RTC. These are dedicated people. These are courageous peo-
ple— to hear from them how difficult it has been for them to protect
the Taxpayers and get the word out.
As we are about to go forward with a new RTC management, I
hope this hearing serves as a beacon for change.
Thank you.
Senator Kerry. [Presiding.] Thank you very much. Senator
Metzenbaum.
Let me just say that you have really been extraordinarily sup-
portive and vigilant bn this, and we are very, very appreciative.
This is about your thlird hearing. I think I have seen you here as
a non-member of the committee, and I think it is a tribute to your
efforts to create accountability.
Congresswoman, thank you for your patience. We have been a
little interrupted here. We have a vote on right now. The Chairman
is on his way to vote, as is Senator Sasser. They will be returning
forthwith. So if we could start your testimony, hopefully they will
/ be back and I will be able to get to vote without having to recess.
STATEMENT OF PATRICIA SCHROEDER, A REPRESENTATIVE
IN THE CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES, FROM THE
FIRST DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF COLORADO
Representative Schroeder. Thank you very much, Senator. I
want to thank the whole committee for allowing me to be here and
for focusing on this.
I am going to ask unanimous consent to place my statement in
the record, because this is a hearing from the heroes of the day,
from the people who have had the courage to come here and, in the
bright lights, tell us what is wrong with the Resolution Trust Cor-
poration.
12
Everybody knows that there is something wrong. Everybody
smells a rat. We could visit every single office in America and
waste would jump out at you. You have to have people who have
a lot of courage and who are willing to come forward to talk about
it, or you are never going to find it.
Obviously the two people that I am very proud of are Bruce
Pederson and Jackie Taylor who are from Colorado, who testified
in front of this committee before. What their great "crime" is, ac-
cording to the Resolution Trust Corporation, is that they raised
some questions about the Professional Liability Section.
We all know that there were legitimate questions that should
have been raised about that.
They have worked very closely with my office. They have cooper-
ated with the General Accounting Office. They have cooperated
with the Inspector General.
But let me tell you how they have been treated: Since they first
raised the questions, instead of the questions being dealt with, they
were dealt with — they were demoted; they were isolated in a sepa-
rate building; they were threatened with transfers to Kansas City;
and most recently, which I think is really egregious, RTC broke
into Bruce Pederson's computer and copied all his files.
That jeopardizes communications with the House and Senate, or
anybody else.
There is a very clear message that went out to every other em-
ployee of the RTC in my region, and that is: Don't you dare blow
the whistle on waste or fraud.
The big problem is, we still have not seen anything happen from
this. I have asked the Department of Treasury to investigate the
break-in, and in August they said that, oh, this was not retaliation.
I do not know how they could say that. It does not pass the giggle
test.
I am still waiting for the Inspector General's report. Maybe the
Senate has more clout than we do, but we certainly have not been
able to get the Inspector General's report, which is long overdue.
I have written the Justice Department and asked why in the
world they are not concerned about this computer break-in. We
have yet to hear from them, either. So maybe this committee hear-
ing today with these very, very courageous people, can help do it.
I have worked to protect wnistleblowers from retaliation for a
very long time. I do not know how we do oversight without people
who can talk to us. Unfortunately, there is a mentality in the West
about rumps together horns out. That often is how every agency
wants to approach any inquiries or criticism. It is like: Out of our
way! We will do what we want!
Therefore, whistleblowers end up isolated and unprotected. We
are trying very hard now in the Congress on our side to pass whis-
tleblower protection for employees in Federal corporations like the
RTC. Unfortunately, every time you pass one whistleblower act,
they find some new form of retaliation. So I just hope we can move
along and get that done.
Like many of you, I was very interested in information that whis-
tleblowers had told me. I have got a whole file of stuff. We would
be happy to share it with you. These are documents about the con-
tracts that were signed, about personnel decisions that were made,
13
about fee bills, about people who are going to make the most
money out of this — ^law firms, and how they hire former RTC em-
ployees, or have friends that are on the inside.
I think the Taxpayers are really sick about this. If we are going
to reinvent Government, we had first better clean up Grovemment.
We had better be sure it is responsive, and put this incredible
thing behind us.
I thank you for your sincere interest in this, for calling these
hearings, and let me put the rest of my testimony in the record.
The witnesses who have been there and who have been through
the pain are the heroes of this hearing, and they should be the
ones who are heard from.
Senator Kerry. Congresswoman, thank you very much. Without
objection, your full testimony has been placed in the record.
Thank you particularly for your supportive efforts and leadership
on this issue. It is very helpful, obviously. I am glad you came and
celebrated the appearances of those from Colorado, who indeed de-
serve congratulations.
Thank you, very much.
Representative SCHHOEDER. Thank you.
Senator Kerry. What I will do is ask the Members, all of them,
of the panel who are going to testify all together on one panel, to
come forward and take your places.
While you do that, I will recess temporarily while I go over to
vote. As soon as Senator Riegle reappears, he will reconvene and
start the testimony.
We will stand in recess while you take your places.
[Recess.]
The Chairman. [Presiding.] The committee will come to order.
I thank everyone for their indulgence as we had to adjourn brief-
ly for the vote on the Senate Floor.
Let me call on Senator Murray for any comments she may want
to make before I swear in the witnesses and we begin with their
testimony.
Senator Murray.
OPENING STATEMENT OF SENATOR PATTY MURRAY
Senator Murray. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I apologize for being late. I was asked to preside this morning,
and I just got out of the Chair.
I appreciate your holding this hearing, Mr. Chairman. I think ev-
eryone knows how strongly I feel about reforming the RTC. As a
new Member of this committee, I reluctantly voted for the funding
of the RTC. I am not sure everyone knows how strongly I feel that
the RTC should go out of business and we should move on as
quickly as possible.
This mess should be straightened out, and we should move on.
But until that time, the Resolution Trust Corporation must be an
organization that we the Taxpayers of this Country can be proud
of and trust.
I have heard many stories of whistleblowers at the RTC. I hap-
pen to believe in underdogs and I believe that one person can make
a difference. So you should know, up and down this long panel of
14
witnesses, that your public service is recognized by Congress, and
I appreciate your coming today.
The Chairman. Thank you very much. Senator Murray. I know
I should acknowledge the strong concerns you have expressed both
in this committee previously and to me as Chairman when we were
working on the legislation earlier this year, and about the need to
move ahead with precisely this kind of inquiry. So we are doing
that today. But I appreciate you for that leadership, along with
Senator Kerry, that I have acknowledged earlier.
Let me now introduce our witnesses one by one. After I have in-
troduced them, I am goin^ to ask them each then to make their
presentation in the order m which I introduce them. Once I have
introduced all of you, I am going to ask you all to stand together
and take the oath, and I will do that at the end of these introduc-
tions.
Our first witness is Mr. Michael Koszola, who is an Agent in the
RTC Inspector General's Office in Chicago, IL.
Mr. Thomas O'Bryon, who was an asset manager for the RTC's
Costa Mesa, CA, office. He is now self-employed and resides in
Eagle, CO.
Mr. James Romer, who served as the Contracting Officer in the
Dallas, TX, office of the RTC. He has since retired and now resides
in Carrollton, TX. As has been noted earlier, Mr. Romer is also the
brother of the Governor of Colorado, Buddy Romer.
Ms. Debbie Sherrill is the Claims Settlement Agent in the At-
lanta, GA, office of the RTC. She is responsible for the reviewing
of contracts to ensure that the requested job has actually been com-
pleted.
Mr. William Henderson, who is an FDIC employee on assignment
to the RTC and handles documentation on legal contracting for the
Atlanta, GA, office of the RTC.
And, Ms. Deanna Smith, who served as an Administrative As-
sistant in the Legal Division for the Atlanta, GA, office of the RTC,
and is currently with FDIC's Atlanta office. She was responsible for
detecting waste and fraud in RTC vouchers.
Then, Ms. Annette LePique, who is the Section Chief of the Af-
fordable Housing Unit in the Newport Beach, CA, office of the
RTC.
Ms. Sandra Crisman, who is also located in the Newport Beach
office of the RTC. She is the Department head of the Contracts Di-
vision.
Mr. Hans Mangelsdorf, who is the Senior Property Manager in
the RTC's Newport Beach, CA, office. He was the first person hired
by the RTC in California to handle its real estate asset disposition
program.
Mr. Thomas Burnside, who was a senior attorney in the RTC's
Professional Liability section, and was located in the Dallas office
of the RTC. Mr. Burnside is now in private practice in St. Louis,
MO.
Then, Mr. Bruce Pederson, who is from the RTC's Denver office.
Mr. Pederson gave very important testimony to this committee pre-
viously in August 1992, during the review of the RTC's reorganiza-
tion. In June 1993, Mr. Pederson was recognized as one of four re-
cipients of the Cavallo Prize for Moral Courage. This award is
15
given annually to whistleblowers in either the public or the private
sector, and we very much welcome him back and look forward to
his testimony.
Ms. Jackie Taylor, from the RTC's Denver, CO, office who also
testified before this committee in Au^st 1992, again very impor-
tantly, to discuss the RTC's reorganization. We appreciated that
then, as we do today. She also was recognized as one of the four
individuals who were granted the Cavallo Prize for Moral Courage.
We welcome her back before the committee today and look forward
to what she will have to say to us.
Finally, Mr. John Waechter is located in the Denver office of the
RTC and was the Computer Services Specialist that was instructed
to conduct a search of Bruce Pederson's office computer earlier this
year.
This is a very impressive and compelling list of witnesses. You
have heard other Members express already their appreciation of
your coming forward and being here today.
Let me ask all of you to stand now, if I may, and I would like
you, once you are standing, to raise your right hands. I would like
each of you to respond in the affirmative at the end of this ques-
tion: Do you swear that the testimony you are about to give is the
truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so Help you,
God?
[The witnesses answer affirmatively in unison.]
The Chairman. Very good. Thank you, and be seated.
Mr. Koszola, we are going to start with you. We welcome you,
and we are going to make your full statement a part of the record.
We would like to hear from you now.
TESTIMONY OF MICHAEL J. KOSZOLA, RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION, IG AGENT, CHICAGO, IL
Mr. Koszola. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and Members
The Chairman. Let me just do this so we start our procedure.
These mikes can move right around. I would like you to get the
mike right in front of the person speaking. Just pull it. It will
move. So you can be well heard. I want you to be heard in the back
of the room.
You may proceed.
Mr. Koszola. Thank you.
Mr. Chairman, and Members, my name is Michael J. Koszola. I
am pleased to have the opportunity to testify before you today. I
have been a Federal Enforcement Officer for nearly 10 years. I
have worked as a Special Agent for the U.S. Customs Service for
5 years. Since December 1991, I have been employed as a Special
Agent for the Office of Inspector General of the Resolution Trust
Corporation.
When I first joined the IG's office of the RTC, I viewed it as an
opportunity to help uncover waste of the Taxpayers' dollars. Unfor-
timately, I found that the RTC/OIG is not doing its job.
In fact, the RTC/IG has spent more time covering up or commit-
ting fraud than it ever spent investigating it. In today's testimony
I will describe how the RTC/IG engaged in rewriting reports, mis-
leading Congress, covering up misconduct, shredding incriminating
documents, and grossly distorting agency investigative priorities.
16
I witnessed cases in which agents at the RTC/OIG were in-
structed to rewrite reports to have them read a particular way that
would be less likely to require further investigation.
Investigative reports were altered in order to avoid embarrassing
or politically sensitive disclosures. I was personally told by Clark
Blight, Assistant Inspector General for Investigations, that it was
the function of the Headquarters RTC/OIG to revise reports to out-
side agencies, including the GAO, the Senate, and House Congres-
sional Committees, in order to make sure the reports were favor-
able.
At that time, Blight was in the process of revising one such re-
port to Congressman Gonzalez, Chairman of the House Banking
Committee, to reflect a more favorable outcome.
Another time, top RTC/OIG officials were sent to the Denver Re-
gional Office in order to assist other special agents in writing a re-
port of investigation involving the Bush family.
The RTC/OIG attempted to mislead Congress in other ways, as
well.
The Chairman. Let me just ask you at this point, before you go
any further. Those are very important statements you have just
made. Have you retained in your records copies of these initial doc-
uments, or findings, or the work that you did that was then later
changed, or not accepted in the form that you had prepared it? Do
you still have those materials?
Mr. KoszOLA. Sir, some of those files — all of my files, I was basi-
cally kicked out of the office, and I may have some information, but
a lot of this I witnessed firsthand — all of it. I mean, I had that con-
versation with Clark Blight last year.
The Chairman. All right. Well, we will go through that. I will
also say to the rest of you that, in situations that may be similar
to what he has just described, if you have documents or written
materials that would illustrate and substantiate the points you are
making, I want to make sure we ask for and get all that may be
available. So why do you not continue.
Mr. KoszoLA. In fact, generation of make-work reports was a
common practice in the RTC. I was personally assigned three cases
that were previously closed to which new case numbers were as-
signed, despite the fact that there was no new evidence to warrant
reopening the investigations. I brought this to the attention of
management and was told the RTC/OIG was trying to keep Con-
gress happy in order to secure additional funding.
I found instances in which we at the IG's office were told not to
tell the truth to the General Accounting Office. Indeed, I was spe-
cifically instructed by my supervisors at the IG's office, Daniel
Sherry and George Sullivan in 1992, not to provide information to
the GAO concerning RTC employees who had criminal histories.
I was further instructed not to say anything about the thefts in
the building. The IG did not want to open up a case on the thefts,
and it did not want the GAO doing so, either.
I learned of the political manipulation of investigations. Manage-
ment would send agents to look over the shoulders of other agents
when they were reviewing S&L matters that might pertain to polit-
ical figures.
17
Before the Presidential election in 1992, the RTC/OIG was ac-
tively seeking criminal or other negative information from special
agents on the Clinton family.
At some time in February 1993, an anonymous male telephone
caller stated that Patricia Patterson was buying RTC properties in
Dallas as a straw purchaser for Albert Casey, the Chairman of the
RTC. Ms. Patterson was allegedly Mr. Casey's girlfriend.
The caller said he was an employee of the RTC and had reported
this information to the RTC/OIG in Dallas, TX. The caller stated
that, to his knowledge, no investigation was initiated by the RTC/
OIG because no auditors or special agents reviewed records re-
maining at the Property Sales Department. I sent my supervisor,
Mr. George Sullivan, a memo regarding this information. To my
knowledge, no investigation was ever initiated.
Another investigation I tried to initiate involved reports of
overbilling and sleeping on the job by employees of another RTC
contractor. Coopers & Lybrand. I saw Coopers & Lybrand account-
ants hired by the RTC perform little or no work at exorbitant cost.
I saw accountants sitting and reading nongovernment literature
and being paid for it by the RTC. When I investigated this, I was
told that their contract permitted them to sit there and read when
there was no work to do. It was an obvious ripoff.
When I tried to do something about it, I was told by my super-
visor, George Sullivan, not to bother with it. The RTC employee
who approved the payments to Coopers & Lybrand is now em-
ployed by them.
An incident which epitomized for me the blatant disregard for
the law in the IG's office occurred on August 24, 1992. I was on
detail in DC shortly after Grerald Jacobs, Greneral Counsel of the
RTC, had resigned under a cloud of allegations concerning personal
and official impropriety— despite the fact that an Inspector Gen-
eral's report said that it found no information showing any impro-
priety with respect to Jacobs' dealing with a failed Arizona S&L.
I was working at the IG headquarters in Roslyn, VA, when I
overheard Lew Sherman, Deputy Inspector Greneral for Investiga-
tions, and Clark Blight, the Assistant Inspector General for Inves-
tigations, laughing and making jokes about how they had taken
care of the Jacobs' case by shredding documents all weekend with
the help of several other agents. They joked how they had needed
a second shredder from another office to handle all the shredding.
Shredding documents following the conclusion of an investigation is
not unusual. However, the circumstances of this shredding oper-
ation raises a number of questions.
What was the hurry? Why did it occur over a weekend? Why did
it take an entire weekend for two Assistant IG's and three Special
Agents with two shredders to carry out a routine shredding? The
three Special Agents received letters of exemplary service for their
expedient response and professionalism in conducting the Jacobs'
investigation.
On April 19, 1993, I was placed on indefinite administrative
leave pending investigation into allegations of which I still have
not been officially informed.
18
On April 5, 1993, 2 weeks before I was placed on administrative
leave, I was ordered by my supervisor, George Sullivan, to dis-
continue any contact with the Senate Banking Committee.
Since being placed on leave, I have received threatening phone
calls. I alerted the police after each call, and was able to tape one
of the calls which consists of nothing but the sound of a machine
gun. On another call the caller stated something to the effect:
We're going to get you.
For the past several months I have not been permitted to work
at all by the RTC. The Taxpayers are still paying my salary. I am
ordered to come to work each Wednesday morning, and then or-
dered to go home as soon as I arrive.
I have worked for a number of Federal agencies but never have
I seen an agency managed so poorly and with such profound con-
sequences for waste, fraud, and abuse as the RTC.
The Chairman. That is a very powerful statement.
Let me ask you this. What is the length of time of your Govern-
ment service from when you first started?
Mr. KoszoLA. Ten years. Over 10 years.
The Chairman. And what would your record be over that 10
years in terms of your conduct, your ratings, your performance gen-
erally?
Mr. Koszola. Overall, very good.
The Chairman. And prior to joining the Government? Can you
just give me a little sketch as to your background?
Mr. Koszola. I went to school and paid for my own tuition. I
worked part-time/full-time at banking brokerage houses and insur-
ance companies.
The Chairman. You have a personal record that essentially is
without any blemish? Is that a fair statement?
Mr. Koszola. Unless you are talking to a corrupt law enforce-
ment official or some other manager that I worked under.
The Chairman. No, but with respect to your conduct and the way
your conduct has been assessed by others and just your record, you
come in with a clean record, do you not?
Mr. Koszola. Yes.
The Chairman. I wanted to draw that out, because I think when
a person, a citizen who also is a Government employee, sees the
things and hears the things that you did, I think you nave an obli-
gation to do exactly what you have done.
I think your obligation is to not — is, rather than looking the
other way or, you know, just going along with practices that you
saw that were improper, I think your direct obligation is to do ex-
actly what you are doing today. That is, to come here under oath,
tell us the truth as you understand it to be, and as others here will
do today, and to put the bright light on practices that you've seen
that you know and believe to be improper and incorrect.
So I want the record to clearly show that what you are doing
here today is a very important public service, and it is appreciated
by this committee.
I want to make sure that we take whatever steps we can to put
an end to any harassment or intimidation in any way, shape, or
form that is being directed at you. We have a Justice Department
and an Attorney Greneral in which I have confidence who I think
19
would be very distressed to hear what you have said, and we in-
tend to so inform her of what you have said in terms of some of
these threatening activities that are going on at the present time,
because that is not America. It should not be America.
Does anybody else want to make just a brief comment before I
go to the next witness?
[No response.]
Next is Mr. Thomas O'Bryon, who as I said earlier was an Assets
Manager for the RTC's Costa Mesa, CA, office.
Mr. O'Bryon, we would like to hear from you now.
TESTIMONY OF THOMAS O^RYON, RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION [FORMER EMPLOYEE], COSTA MESA, CA
Mr. O'Bryon. Good morning. Senators, and thank you for letting
me be here today.
In the 1980's I worked with a lot of the S&L's in the Pacific
Northwest trying to deal with a lot of the non-earning asset prob-
lems, much in the same way that the RTC is trying to deal with
the assets of failed institutions.
In 1990 when I heard that the RTC was opening an office in
Costa Mesa, CA, I decided to apply, seeing as how this was my
background.
Senator Kerry. [Presiding.] Do you want to give us just a little
sense of that background?
Mr. O'Bryon. Basically what I would do would be to go into an
institution that was having
Senator Kerry. What are you trained as, and how long have you
worked at it?
Mr. O'Bryon. I am sorry, sir?
Senator Kerry. What are you trained as? And how long have you
worked in that capacity?
Mr. O'Bryon. I have been in the real estate finance mortgage in-
dustry since about 1976. That later translated into working as a
consultant for savings and loans, actually all over the country, but
specifically in the Pacific Northwest and in California.
I was involved in handling what are called REO Disposition
Transactions, which is Real Estate Owned, foreclosed assets, and
the like; and I have handled several billion dollars worth of assets
during the 1980's for failed — or savings and loans that were in fi-
nancial trouble and trying to save themselves before the RTC was
formed.
I was offered a position in June 1990, with the Costa Mesa RTC
office to come in and try to deal with the non-earning asset prob-
lems, but I absolutely became fed up and disgusted after about a
year. I left.
I decided that I could possibly work with individuals who were
trying to buy assets fi-om the S&L's, because I certainly was not
having any luck selling property for the RTC while I was there, as
I had brought in offers of in excess of $50 million within the first
month of my accepting the job at the RTC. Those properties were
still on the books over a year later when I left the RTC.
The manapment of the RTC can only be described as "crisis
management' from where I sit. During my tenure there and my
subsequent dealings with the RTC, I experienced fits of rage, rude-
20
ness, yelling, sexual innuendo, and generally demeaning and
harassing behaviors. This was done by senior staff as well as other
staff.
Many people were threatened with firing, as was I, on more than
one occasion. These are fear tactics. Fear tactics don't have any
place in management, especially when you are trying to get a job
done, and especially with one tnat has the magnitude of the RTC.
From time to time, the RTC in Washington or the Denver office
would request reports of information having to do with real estate.
I was the individual that those requests would come to. There have
been many times those requests would take 2 weeks to get to me
from Washington.
By the time the request got to me, many times that request was
due the day before I received it. Many of these reports were going
to take 4, 5, 6, 7 days to complete. I had one day to complete wiem.
There was absolutely no way in the world that I could complete a
report of the magnitude that I was asked for in one day. So, as a
result, the report would go in incomplete.
I would refuse to put my name on it saying that this was 100
percent accurate. In fact, I would put statements on there saying
that I felt that this information was 60 percent accurate, or 50 per-
cent, or whatever it might be. I was told that if I did not remove
those statements and sign it saying it was 100 percent complete,
I would be fired. This was ridiculous. If I signed it and sent it up
saying it was correct, I am going to get in trouble with Washington
for sending in fraudulent information. If I do not put my name on
it, I am going to get fired. This is an untenable situation. Not only
was I in this situation, but I know that many of the people at this
table were placed in that kind of a compromising position.
After about 3 or 4 months in the RTC, I was asked to be involved
with the REGIS program, the acronym called REGIS stands for
Real Estate Gwned Inventory System. This was a precursor to the
system that is now in place called "REGMS," which is the Real Es-
tate Gwned Management System.
The REGIS was a temporary system just to get by until REGMS
could come on line. This system was flawed from the beginning.
Too many people from too many areas of the RTC tried to be in-
volved in the design and absolutely knew nothing about computer
design and what a computer could or could not do.
As I was involved in the implementation and the setup of the
RIG system on the West Coast, I was asked to come back to Wash-
ington to help them put controls in place that would make the sys-
tem more effective.
At the same time I came back here, I asked to maybe be a part
of the team that was designing the REGM system. I was not con-
sulted. I was not asked to be a part. In fact, I was told that anyone
having to do with the RIG system would not be allowed to be in-
volved with REGMS.
The REGM system, ladies and gentlemen, is going to cost the
American Taxpayers in excess of $100 million. It never had to cost
that much. It could have cost a fraction of that. But because they
would not consult with people who really knew what they were
doing, because management had their own agenda on how it was
21
going to be put together and what was going to be done with it,
the American Taxpayer is really taking it in the shorts.
As to the inappropriate behavior, more than what I have just
said, I am currently a witness in a Grovernment case that involves
inappropriate behavior of a sexual nature, abuse of position by at-
tempting to inappropriately influence subordinate-level employees,
abuse of position by inappropriately accessing files, and abuse of
position by attempting to harm other employees' careers.
I do not think it would be appropriate to discuss the details, but
I am involved in a lot of the information that hopefully will keep
some of the upper management out of the RTC since they have
been dismissed.
As to the subject of waste and what Senator Kerry was saying
earlier, the waste, to put it in as graphic terms as I can, I men-
tioned the RIO system and the REOM system: $100 million for a
single computer system that does not work.
When I was taken off of the RIO system because I kept bringing
these issues to light, I was given a number of apartment buildings
in Phoenix, AZ — 6, to be exact. The total value of these apartments
were about $9 million. When I took these over and I started inves-
tigating, I found $1.4 million sitting in checking accounts earning
absolutely no interest for the Taxpayers. That money had been sit-
ting there for over 9 months. Now that money could have — the in-
terest that that money could have earned would have paid my sal-
ary and a number of my colleagues' salaries.
I was constantly told that we did not have the budget to do what
we needed to do. The reason we did not have the budget was be-
cause management was not paying attention. Management was not
doing what FIRREA, RTC's legislation, calls for us to do — which is,
to keep all the moneys in interest-bearing accounts.
When I asked the manager who had been taking care of this why
he did it, why he did not move the money to the Department of Ac-
counting, he said that: Because if I have to write a case study, the
paperwork is going to be ridiculous just to be able to fix a water
pump or a pipeline or whatever it might be, and I don't want to
have to deal with all that paperwork.
I have had two contacts with the IG's office where I have filed
two complaints. One was the waste of the example I just gave you,
that of money sitting in non-interest-bearing accounts. The other
was, I have currently notified the IG that there is an individual
currently working for the RTC who is illegally bujdng properties
from the RTC using front men. I know of this because I was asked
by one of the front men if I wanted to participate. They did not
know that I used to be an RTC employee, and they did not know
of my involvement in this hearing, nor in the case I am testifying
in out in California next month.
To get into the real waste, however, let us talk about auctions
and sales. While I was at the RTC, as I said, I brought in $53 mil-
lion worth of offers on three different apartment buildings in the
first month I was there. I was told that they were not assets that
I was handling, and therefore it looked inappropriate for me to be
trying to get these properties sold. What was my vested interest in
doing this?
22
I went to my boss and I said, lookit, my vested interest is, this
is my job. This is what we are supposed to be doing. Thirteen
months later, those properties were still on the books. I found out
that just last month one of those properties finally went to sale,
and it went to sale for $10 million less than the offer I had pre-
sented back in 1990. That is waste, and that is a lot of money.
A lot of the assets that had good offers coming in on them would,
from time to time, just subsequently be pulled to be put into an
auction because somebody wanted a good looking, high profile piece
of property in that action.
You would have a piece of property that had a good, solid con-
tract of sale pending, and they would pull it; put it in the auction;
the sale would take place at the auction for a substantially reduced
jrice, and you would then be left with the loss that never should
lave taken place. But this was a common occurrence. This again
las cost the Taxpayers not millions, not tens of millions, not hun-
dreds of millions, but billions of dollars.
One specific example of another piece of property that I
The Chairman. [Presiding.] Let me just stop you there for a
minute and ask you, as you recite this, and as you try to figure out
in your own mind, as you were doing at the time, how could things
be so badly managed: How could so much money be wasted and
squandered?
I would be interested in knowing, as you were thinking all this
through, the degree to which you were deciding that it was just out
and out incompetence. I mean, managers who did not know what
they were doing, versus something beyond that, somebody who was
deliberately in effect manipulating the process, or seeing to it that
either things were steered a certain way, or in some fashion just,
for whatever the purposes, making sure that things did not work
right?
How would you divide it generally speaking between iust out and
out incompetence, and somebody that was venal or had some other
angle they were shooting here?
Mr. O'Bryon. I would have to say that probably 50 percent could
be considered incompetence on the part of middle management;
and the other 50 percent I would have to say was deliberate, people
who said: We need a high-profile auction. We have got to make our-
selves look good, because we looked so bad. We are in a fish bowl.
We want to put together an auction, and we want to sell hun-
dreds of millions of dollars of properties, all high profile, good look-
ing stuff so people can see we are doing our job.
Now I was told that specifically by the Washington sales office
on one of my trips back here when I was dealing with the real es-
tate inventory system. They came right out and said it. They made
no bones about it. I said, yes, but it does not make sense to pull
this property out, lose $10 million just for the sake of looking good,
and they said "$10 million is nothing in the overall scheme of
things."
Well, Senator, when I took over the REOI system in August
1990, there were 55,000 pieces of property within the RTC. There
have subsequently been many tens of thousands more since then.
The Chairman. I am going to ask you to just stop at this point,
because we are finishing a vote and we are on the second bells. But
23
I also — I do not want you to say this until we get some of the other
Members back in here. I want Senator Metzenbaum to hear this,
who I think is en route back, and I want the others to hear this
as well.
What you are saying is very important. We will take the time
that it takes if we have to be here all day, or however long it takes.
I want to go through this carefully and thoroughly.
So if I can ask your indulgence, I am going to put the committee
into recess now briefly. When Senator Kerry and the others come
back we can go ahead and resume, but I want to get the Members
here as you go through this next part, which is very important.
The committee stands briefly in recess.
[Recess.]
Senator Kerry. [Presiding.] Mr. O'Bryon, you are still testifying?
Mr. O'Bryon. Yes, sir.
Senator Kerry. Go ahead.
Mr. O'Bryon. I was getting ready to explain to Senator Riegle
that we had in 1990, when I took over the real estate owned inven-
tory system at the RTC, 55,000 pieces of property listed in the in-
ventory. Some of those were listed as "sold." Many of them were
listed as "available," but the majority of them were listed in some
sort of a "pending" status of litigation or problems, whether they
be environmental, wetlands, and what have you.
I testified that in 6 apartment buildings, we found $1.4 million
in cash not earning a penny's worth of interest. That is 6 out of
55,000.
I have another example of one R&D building, a research and de-
velopment warehouse building in Colorado Springs, CO, that in
1991 sold at auction for $12.50 a square foot. Within one year, the
purchaser syndicated that property for $50 a square foot. One year.
He managed to make $4.5 million profit on one piece of property.
So far we have talked about 7 pieces of property accounting for lit-
erally millions and millions of dollars of Taxpayers money that has
been wasted and lost.
If it was one or two pieces of property that this happened on a
rare occasion, it would be one thing; but this is happening on hun-
dreds and thousands of pieces of property accounting for billions of
dollars of waste.
People who talk about the RTC costing the American Taxpayers
$150-$ 170 billion? I defy them to go out and really do the honest
accounting because, Senators, it is going to cost the American Tax-
payers several hundreds of billions, if not trillions, of dollars.
Now it is easy to criticize, and it is much more difficult to
produce workable solutions. I am here to not only talk about the
problems, but I am also here to try and help with any of the solu-
tions that I can.
Thank you for your time.
Senator KERRY. Thank you very much, Mr. O'Bryon.
Mr. Romer.
24
TESTIMONY OF JAMES ROMER, RESOLUTION TRUST COR-
PORATION, CONTRACTING OFFICER [FORMER EMPLOYEE],
DALLAS, TX
Mr. RoMER. Mr. Chairman and Members of the committee, it is
an honor and a privilege to address this committee regarding con-
tracting irregularities, management improprieties, contractor collu-
sion, and conflicts of interest at the Dallas office of the RTC during
the early years of its existence.
The testimony I am about to give is based on first-hand knowl-
edge and reflects my personal experiences while employed as a con-
tract specialist in the Dallas Metroplex Consolidated Office of RTC.
Senator Kerry. What years were those?
Mr. RoMER. 1990, 1991, 1992, and 1993.
Senator Kerry. So you have just left there?
Mr. RoMER. Yes. I have just been dismissed.
Senator Kerry. You were dismissed?
Mr. RoMER. Yes.
Senator Kerry. What was the cause of your dismissal, if you
know?
Mr. RoMER. Irregularities — Mistakes on the time sheet. I nor-
mally go to work at 6 o'clock in the morning and work on Satur-
days, and probably put in 45 hours a week, and sometimes I sign
up for leave ahead of time to go to a meeting or something for an
hour or two, and I am too busy that day and I might go the next
day, so my time sheet was not accurate. So that was an excuse to
let me go.
Senator KERRY, And this occurred after you had raised these
questions publicly, or not?
Mr. RoMER. Oh, yes. I mean, yes, they had personally had the
IG tail me for 14 months to find these "irregularities."
Just as one example, they, in the testimony I lefl my office — I
normally go to lunch at 11 o'clock, after I go in at 6 a.m. I left the
office at 10:28 a.m. and had an IG agent timing when my vehicle
left, and I met two people at the Infomart down the street, which
was a sting operation. They had invited me over and offered me a
big contract to go overseas on an airplane because I had been a
pilot for 50 years, and that's my interest, and I told them, no, I
couldn't do that because they were offbase on what they were try-
ing to ask me to do, and I was gone an hour and 18 minutes, and
our lunch hour is only 45 minutes.
But I would estimate they spent $100,000 in 14 months to try
to find enough reason for me to go.
Senator Kerry. OK Why do you not go ahead with your testi-
mony.
Mr. RoMER. Prior to working for RTC, I had over 30 years' expe-
rience in the area of
Senator Kerry. Pull the mike a little closer to you, Mr. Romer.
Mr. RoMER. Prior to working for the RTC, I had over 30 years'
experience in the areas of real estate brokerage, appraisals, con-
struction, business development, and computer applications.
Computer applications was business planning and applying com-
puter technology, which today you call process re-engineering, is
what I have been doing for 30 years.
25
I have owned several businesses and have been directly super-
vising up to 80 employees.
I began employment at RTC in February 1990, approximately 4
months after the Dallas office was opened. My first assignment at
RTC was to organize and staff a contractor registration department
for the Southwest Regional Office, which was also headquartered
in Dallas.
I established an organization of six people, developed registration
procedures, designed a computerized data base, and supervised the
registration of the first 12,000 contractors in Texas.
My team also completed the solicitation and award of 75 con-
tracts. As a result of this effort, I received the first gold star — the
first Gold Star Achievement Award granted in the Southwest Re-
gion.
However, all is not well in the co-located Dallas Metroplex Con-
solidated Office, especially in the Contracting Department.
First, contracting was not and could not operate objectively since
it was organizationally reporting directly to, and was fully respon-
sible to, the Asset Management Department whose mission was to
dispose of assets. The contracting managers were essentially told
what to do and who to contract with. Contracting was little more
than the conveyor's of paper that documented and validated deci-
sions that Asset Management had already made.
For most of 1990 and 1991, the concept of fair and open competi-
tion was a joke. This was especially true for minority contractors,
since most asset managers were predisposed to conclude that mi-
nority contractors were not capable of performing asset-related
work.
Even though FIRREA had dictated the maximum-use criteria,
senior management in Dallas would not permit contract registra-
tion reports to reflect minority identification even though I had de-
signed the data base to do so.
Second, the general hiring policy at the time was that anyone
that had a FAR, a Federal Acquisition Regulation background, was
not suitable for consideration to be hired in the Contracting De-
partment. The reasoning was that, since RTC was not required to
operate under FAR rules, it would be counterproductive to have
people around with that kind of discipline.
People with FADA, the Federal Asset Disposition Agency, or
banking backgrounds, the good buddies, many who were involved
in creating the savings and loan crisis, were hired with abandon.
Third, the contracting operating environment clearly was driven
by time pressures and deadlines dictated by Senior Asset man-
agers. Contract specialists were fearful of losing their jobs if a con-
tract, especially a SAMDA, was not awarded by the designated
date set by Asset Management.
No matter if there were loopholes that permitted the contract to
operate with little or no controls. I will recite the pillar incident.
My first insight into the buddy arrangement for awarding con-
tracts came in October, 1990. During that month. Solicitation 761-
9966-90139-140, 141, 142, 143, and 144 were issued to secure con-
tractors to perform computer corrections to the Assets at six loca-
tions.
26
I was the contract specialist assigned to work the sohcitation.
One firm was the lowest bidder and the best qualified on all six
of the solicitations. I performed the required verification and rec-
ommended to the Asset Department that the contract be awarded
to the low bidder.
Assets rejected the recommendation and requested that four of
the contracts be awarded to the lowest bidder and two contracts be
awarded to the second-ranked bidder whose chairman was friends
with several of the senior staff of RTC.
In reviewing and checking the required certifications pursuant to
FIRREA and 12 CFR 1606, there were obvious conflicts with the
second-ranked bidder.
The Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of the second-ranked
firm was currently employed as a Senior Vice President of a sav-
ings and loan and had not disclosed this employment as required
by RTC Regulations.
During my inquiry into the information on the second-ranked
firm's certifications, I physically went to the S&L loan office and
obtained a letter from the personnel department confirming the
employment of the Senior Vice President, and also obtained a copy
of the institution's financial statement which listed the bidder^
chairman as Senior Vice President. These were obvious conflicts.
Finally, in response to my protests and refusal to award the two
contracts to the second-ranked firm, I was given permission to
award all six contracts to the lowest bidder as it should be. How-
ever, the senior manager at the Dallas Metroplex Consolidated Of-
fice had decided that the second-ranked firm would be awarded
other business.
A major SAMOA contract was awarded to this firm, in spite of
independent reports from the Investigations Department validating
the conflicts of interest created by the firm's chairman working for
a savings and loan. These reports were sent to the Senior Asset
Manager, the Senior Contract Manager, and the Ethics Officer in
the Dallas office.
The power of SAMOA: An illustration of the kind of unethical
practices used by some SAMOA contractors is summarized in my
memorandum dated July 9, 1991, which is attachment 2, which I
will turn in.
In the memo to the assistant director of contracts at the Dallas
Metroplex Consolidated Office, the asset management contractor is
demanding a nonrefundable option fee of $3,000 to process a sales
contract for the purchase of property. My memorandum was not re-
sponded to, nor any action taken on, this petition.
A second illustration of the awesome power of the SAMOA Con-
tractor is provided in a letter from Mr. Mike Doan, attachment No.
3, dated July 16, 1991.
In the letter, Mr. Doan states that not only is the SAMOA Con-
tractor arbitrarily deciding who gets discounted deals on the prop-
erties being sold, but the SAMOA contractor bragged about the fact
that it would do no good to complain to the RTC.
In fact, in the past, complaints have been sent to former CEO's,
but the purchaser still has to come back and deal with the
SAMOA. This is the SAMOA which was number two in the bid I
turned down.
; 27
Such impunity was widespread, and it was one of the reasons
why many subcontractors and buyers became discouraged and
stopped trying to do business with the RTC.
The power of the contractor over friendly RTC's senior manage-
ment- is further illustrated when you consider a letter that this
same SAMDA contractor wrote, dated July 1, 1991, attachment No.
4, to the Dallas Regional Director.
The preliminary internal memorandum that I had written on
June 25, 1991 [attachment 5], detailing wrong-doing, was already
in the hands of the contractor to the extent that they had heard
about the contents from several sources at the RTC's regional office
and the Metroplex Consolidated Office.
It is probably just a strange coincidence that the special assistant
to the then-regional director was also a former supervisor of the
Chairman of the SAMDA Contractor who just happens to be in the
direct pipeline for receiving RTC internal information.
Retribution measures: This is in November 1990. Suddenly, with-
out formal explanation, I was relieved as contracting team leader
and assigned duties as a librarian and FOIA response writer.
While I was hired as an LG-14 Contract Specialist and per-
formed at that level, my new duties were those normally given to
an LG-9 or LG-11 Apprentice Specialist.
As an illustration of how deeply ingrained this vindictiveness
was with the assistant director of contracts and his two direct re-
ports, I refer you to my memorandum dated April 8, 1992 [attach-
ment 6], which addresses two shortcomings of RTC's information
systems. As you are aware, timely information is a cornerstone of
RTC being able to do business.
I observed that huge amounts of space was being used to store
documents, £ind many hours of clerical time was spent retrieving
documents. Also, many proposals, contracts, and other important
documents are submitted to RTC by FAX. Because of the time zone
differences, many of the FAX'd documents came into automatic ma-
chines during off-duty hours.
There were times when I arrived early in the morning, as I usu-
ally came in at 6 a.m., that FAX documents were literally strewn
on the floor because the receiver box had overflowed. I suggested
using a new imaging software and computer FAX board, since each
contract specialist has a terminal.
A significant savings would result from reducing file storage
space, document retrieval time, minimizing lost files, reducing lost
time of standing at FAX machines, and having a chronological
record of the FAX messages sent and received. The savings of the
system was estimated to pay for the system in 90 days or less.
My immediate management would neither discuss the feasibility
of these improvements, nor forward the analysis to the experts in
information systems.
Recommendation: In closing, Mr. Chairman, I would like to state
that there are still many dedicated, hardworking people within
RTC who could do a much better job of restoring the confidence
and resolving the crisis if, number one, the hard-core senior man-
agement at the field offices and headquarters, who were respon-
sible for the problems that I have addressed, were removed.
28
They do not believe that the new initiatives that Secretary Bent-
sen introduced will work, since they have an inherent vested inter-
est in maintaining the old system. After all, it was the system —
it was they who designed the old system, and to make any new^sys-
tem work would be absolute proof that their former approach was
wrong. This is tantamount to self-incrimination, and no one can ex-
pect them to put a diligent effort into such a cause.
Second, contracting should be placed on an equal basis with asset
management, operations, and legal.
Since the majority of the RTC's business is done by outside con-
tracts an objective, independent contracting group is essential.
This is a fundamental management flaw to have the contracting
officers identified as organizational second-class citizens.
The pressure from over-zealous managers who are quick to let it
be known that they control your paycheck can subvert even the
most objective contracting officers.
Again I thank you for the opportunity to appear before this com-
mittee.
The Chairman. [Presiding.] Thank you, very much, for your
statement. It is a very important statement, and we are grateful
to have it.
Let me now go to Ms. Debbie Sherrill who, as I said earlier, is
a Claims Settlement Agent in the Atlanta, GA, office of the RTC.
She is going to go ahead and give her testimony at this time.
Thank you.
TESTIMONY OF DEBBIE SHERRILL, RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION, CLAIMS SETTLEMENT AGENT, ATLANTA, GA
Ms. Sherrill. Thank you. Chairman Riegle. I am Debbie
Sherrill, and I am from the Atlanta office. I am currently employed
with RTC. My contract will be up November 9.
Because, like several other people on this panel, I raised ques-
tions, they told me when my contract was up. They told me that
they didn't have to give me a reason. So I really don't know why.
But I am here today basically as a concerned Taxpayer as well
as an RTC employee to explain to this committee all the waste, and
abuse, and the fraud, and mismanagement that I have seen and
that I have personally experienced at RTC.
I have three areas of concern that I would like to discuss. My
first one is unqualified personnel in key management positions.
Second, contractor fraud and abuse. Third, waste and abuse due to
mismanagement.
A prime example of unqualified managers is that we now have
a director who, prior to working for RTC, held a position as a sec-
retary-receptionist. We had another director, and his job prior to
RTC was a butcher at a meat market.
Now there is nothing wrong with these positions. I am not saying
that. But I am saying it does not lend the experience that is needed
to be a manager in a corporation such as RTC.
So what you have is unqualified, incompetent managers just con-
tributing to the chaos that already existed and losing more money
because they don't have the background necessary to make a sound
business decision. Because of these types of managers, I also found
that employees would make suggestions for improvement and
29
would be reprimanded and ridiculed in front of their peers for
doing so.
It was basically from the insecurity of these managers, who took
that as criticism because they did not know enough about the posi-
tion to know it was really a good suggestion and that it might
work, that suggestions for improvement were discouraged.
So the result of having these types of managers is that you get
a fearful and demotivated staff who are afraid to say anything
when they find a problem.
They only promote the people who are more incompetent than
they are, so they will look good. And then you drive away the more
qualified, experienced people through intimidation, or discrimina-
tion, or harassment, you know, whatever they can get to work to
make you leave.
The second point I wanted to talk about was contractor fraud
and abuse.
One of the most common areas there is padding of bills. I have
had bills submitted where I had one lady tell me that — well, when
I questioned her bill — she did her work when she went back to the
hotel. She had charged 6 or 7 hours overtime every night for 2
weeks. We were working at the bank until 7 or 8 o'clock that night.
I am sure she was not staying up 6 or 7 hours more after she got
in at night, and she never produced anything on paper to show me
what she had done during that time, but she was studying, and she
was formulating a memo.
I mean, you know, you do not sign off on those types of bills. You
would have bills where a project should take 2 hours, and they
would bill you for 6 hours. When you would raise questions like
this with the managers that I am under, these bills are being paid
anyway.
They will talk to the contractor. The contractor will produce a
memo to justify why they have got that bill, even though you do
not have the backup to prove that they really did that.
My result was that I would refuse to sign off on the bills, which
caused me a lot of problems.
The next item of abuse would be underbidding of contracts. Once
they have been awarded the contract, then they would increase the
cost.
I had one bank where, just my department only, bid $95,000 to
do the contract. Well, 2 weeks into the job they came back and re-
submitted and they said, well. Debs, it looks like it is going to take
about $270,000 to complete this project.
Well, that is not a whole lot of money, you know, considering ev-
erything, but when you let me get away with it once, then they get
another bid and they do it again and again. It does not take long
for it to all add up. The idea is that you have opened the door for
abuse, and you have given them an avenue to use.
Another large waste we have is delaying review of contractor
work and responsive action when a problem occurs.
A prime example of this is, we had a firm who contracted to do
appraisals on a branch facility, and the furniture, fixtures, and
equipment in those facilities.
The project should have taken 3 to 4 days to complete. This guy
did it in one day. We could not figure out how he did it.
30
The people at the site, once they got the work product, were so
upset because it was inaccurate and so inferior they did not want
to pay the bill. They talked to the people in Atlanta.
The office in Atlanta decided to pay the gentleman, anyway. So
now this is my bank, and it is time for me to find a purchaser for
these branches and the assets.
When you look at the data that was on this appraisal, it was so
inaccurate, furniture was listed that did not even exist. So I am sit-
ting there trying to sell furniture that I do not have to people.
The RTC's response to this, when I questioned them about it,
was to hire another contractor to do another appraisal. Then you
will have a true picture of what you can sell.
Senator Kerry. Let me just ask you. You are saying that on this
particular appraisal, items were appraised that you knew did not
exist?
Ms. Sherrill. Right. When we checked the inventory listing,
then the people at the site said, well, this is an old listing. This
furniture does not exist anymore. It was broken; it was thrown
away; it is not here. I mean the items were not physically there.
Just the proximity of the branches of the facilities where this
work had to be done, there is no way they could have gotten to all
the branches in one day. I mean, you physically could not even
travel to them, much less try to do an actual appraisal on them.
Senator Kerry. What did people say to you when you raised the
question about the fraudulent appraisal?
Ms. Sherrill. About doing another appraisal?
Senator Kerry. Well, did you say this appraisal was fraudulent
and not valid?
Ms. Sherrill. Yes, we did. They said, well, we have already paid
them for it. We will just have to get a second appraisal. I mean,
the appraisal is worthless if you cannot use it.
Senator Kerry. Was a person hired again to do appraisals?
Ms. Sherrill. Yes, he was.
Senator Kerry. The same person was hired again to do apprais-
als, even though they appraised things that did not exist?
Ms. Sherrill. Yes, sir. Another example of this is, we had a Big
Six accounting firm that we should have canceled the contract on.
The work they turned in was inaccurate. They did not meet dead-
lines. They were very poor presentations.
I refused to sign off on a lot of the bills because they could not
justify the hours. I refused to sign off on a lot of the data they
turned in because it was wrong. We would send it back, and it may
or may not be right.
But I discussed this with our managers and I discussed it with
the accounting firm's managers, too, telling them: You need to re-
place these people, or we need to cancel your contract. My manage-
ment got very quiet and did not want to support that, even though
I had documentation to prove the work was poor.
So the end result was that they got paid for the job; the contrac-
tor, just as well as the appraisal people, are still submitting bids
on other jobs and they are being awarded those contracts which,
as a Taxpayer, makes me really angry because we are seeing them
do this.
31
This is a very fixable problem. That is why it upsets me so much,
because we could put these people on a hold list very easily, pend-
ing an investigation to clear their name over any work that is not
correct, and not allow them to submit a bid until they have done
so. It is not a hard thing to do. It is just that there is no one in
my management that is willing to take that responsibility and put
their name on a piece of paper that says this is what we have got
to do.
Instead, what they do is say, well. Deb should have handled that
differently. She should have talked to them sooner, or she should
have done something else, because that is a much easier thing to
do than to take responsibility yourself. When you have incompetent
managers, that is what happens.
Another area of concern I have is that they hire contractors to
audit other contractors. In my department we use contractors, so
I have to audit their work. Then there is the PCR Review Commit-
tee that comes in. It is an Internal Committee that audits my
work. An IG comes in and audits the other work. Then GAO comes
in and audits it ageiin. Then we hire a contractor to audit it one
more time just to make sure everybody is right.
You know, it is ludicrous. If there is a problem, you do not need
five audits to determine there is a problem. You will know it way
before then.
Much of the work conducted by the contractors could be done in-
house. We already have the trained staff to do it. Many times we
find, just like in this case we were discussing with the appraisers
and the example of the contractor, you are paying these people
$100 to $125 an hour. They are untrained and inexperienced in the
field. It is much cheaper for us to go out there and do it ourselves
because we have to go out there and train them anyway.
Personally, I have a real problem sitting there training a gen-
tleman who is getting paid $125 an hour for something I can do.
He should be teaching me something, I do not need to be spoon-
feeding him.
When I have talked to the managers about this type of thing,
their reaction is: Don't worry about it. Congress wants us to hire
more contractors. Well, that is good. In some cases we need more
contractors, but not this type of attitude. The attitude is: If you
have a task that you do not want to do, you hire a contractor to
do it. You do not worry about the money.
The joke around the office is that you call Congress and tell them
to go to the basement and print more money.
Now to me as a Taxpayer, I did not think that was funny. It real-
ly ticked me off, because I see the money going out the window.
If you do not conduct a timely oversight of the contractors, you
might as well not do the audit at all, because it is just like in these
cases where we have given them new jobs.
If you refuse to pay a bill and they sue you and you do not audit
them until a year later, even if you can prove they are wrong, if
you hired them for three more jobs it does not matter. The point
is, then, what is the difference? It could not have been too bad; you
hired them again. We shoot ourselves in the foot everywhere we go.
My last topic is waste and abuse due to mismanagement. I will
make this brief. I know we could have stories all day long.
32
I had one assignment where I was to wait for them to bring a
permanent person into the field. So we set up deadlines and key
meetings with purchasing banks to do the transition.
The gentleman never showed up. So we finally got concerned
about it. I called the offices in Atlanta, and they said, well, come
on by.
After I got back to Atlanta, the banks called and said, well, we
found the gentleman that we were looking for. He had a drinking
problem and he had passed out, and the local police had taken him
back to the hotel.
He still did not show up for kev meetings where he was needed.
He was abusive to the staff verbally. They were afraid of him.
I wrote a memo to the director. The president of the acquiring
bank called our director. Nothing was done about it. It finally got
to the point where the president of the acquiring bank got so angry
he decided the best thing to do was call CNN, and he put it on the
news. He thought if he put it on the news, it would get him out
of town.
So when the managers realized that they really were going to do
something drastic, they pulled the gentleman back in and replaced
him with someone else. A few months down the road, the gen-
tleman gets a promotion. In the private sector he would have been
fired that day. There were no reprimands.
The last point I would like to make on the mismanagement is
that I have heard so many times, between the directors and the de-
partment heads and the supervisors at all levels, thev sit down and
they will tell all of us, that RTC is a special entity that is not held
accountable under the regular rules and regulations of other Gov-
ernment agencies. Well, if we are not held accountable under those
rules and regulations, where are we held accountable? Most of the
time, we are not.
The policies and procedures are written. The manuals are sitting
around, but no one is enforcing them because it goes back to the
incompetent managers. Again, everyone is afi"aid to make a state-
ment and take responsibility for anything.
Senator Kerry. Let me just ask across the board here. Is there
anybody who disagrees with that in this entire group?
Panel Members. [Simultaneously.] Not at all.
Senator Kerry. Not one person disagrees. This is imiform. No-
body is enforcing any of the regs? Is that correct?
Panel Members. [Simultaneously.] Right.
Senator Kerry. And you are saying that this fellow who was an
alcoholic, who repeatedly had problems, who did not show up for
work for weeks at a time, was promoted?
Ms. Sherrill. Yes, sir. He was brought back into the office.
Then, later when it was time for his evaluations, he got a pro-
motion.
Senator Kerry. Not withstanding that the police had held him
at one point when he did not show up, and that there were re-
peated occurrences?
Ms. Sherrill. What can I say? It was not my decision.
Senator Kerry. Thank you.
Ms. Sherrill. But your bottom-line result from this is that when
you have managers doing this type of management style to your
33
employees, your only retaliation is to abuse sick time. They abuse
overtime. And then the employers, the managers' retaliation is
through intimidation, harassment, and discrimmation. So in one
way or another, they will get you to leave if you raise questions.
In conclusion, I guess what I really wanted to get across to this
committee before I left, to me RTC is operating strictly on a crisis
management basis. I wanted to motivate this committee to realize
how serious it is and to try to get it to take some measures to cor-
rect the problem.
Thank you.
The Chairman. [Presiding.] Thank you very much, and thank
you for coming forward and giving us that testimony today.
Mr. Henderson, you are an FDIC employee. You are on assign-
ment to the RTC and vou handle documentation on legal contract-
ing for the Atlanta, GA, office of the RTC. May I ask, sir, how long
have you been in Government? How long has your career spanned?
TESTIMONY OF WILLIAM A. HENDERSON, RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION, LEGAL INFORMATION TECHNICIAN, AT-
LANTA,GA
Mr. Henderson. Since 1981.
The Chairman. So you are finishing 12 years or so of Govern-
ment service?
Mr. Henderson. Correct.
The Chairman. You have that span of history yourself over
which to make the observations you are about to make?
Mr. Henderson. Correct.
The Chairman. Very good. We are pleased to have you, and we
would like to hear your statement now.
Mr. Henderson. Thank you. My name is William A. Henderson.
I reside in Atlanta. I am presently working with the RTC office in
the Legal Division of Atlanta as a Legal Information Technician.
My responsibilities are to input and monitor financial data of fees
and expenses from outside counsel involving cases that arise out of
failed S&L's.
With all good intentions of FIRREA, which is better known in
our office as diarrhea, because it wipes us out. It is cleaning us out
financially, since its inception, the RLIS unit for which I work has
been plagued by mismanagement.
Attorneys representing outside law firms with overdue RTC bills
have been allowed to enter the RLIS unit, oftentimes unescorted.
This is a breach of security and also a violation of delegated au-
thority to approve payment of bills. Only attorneys are supposed to
initiate authorization for payment of bills. Support staff has been
seen authorizing fraudulently, payment of bills.
Due to management's negligence, I have seen duplicate, even
triplicate payments dispensed to law firms for a single invoice for
legal services. Such blatant negligence and unethical practices di-
rectly violates the RTC's mission to maximize return and minimize
the losses of managed and resolved savings and loans.
Senator Kerry. Were these duplicate and triplicate payments
ever recouped?
Mr. Henderson. No.
Senator Kerry. Ever recouped?
34
Mr. Henderson. Never.
Senator Kerry. Were they brought to management's attention?
Mr. Henderson. They were brought to management's attention,
and a memo was E-Mailed and sent from Washington to encourage
everybody to try and recoup payments that had been processed.
Many times the firms had gone out of business anyway. It was
really a scam.
The Chairman. What size checks would these have been?
Mr. Henderson. Anywhere from $5,000 to $50,000.
The Chairman. So these were big checks? These are not small
checks?
Mr. Henderson. Whoppers. Yes.
The RTC was inundated with many moves of personnel, and this
boils down to a physical waste as well as a financial waste. Several
sections in the Division of the RTC were required to move three or
more times in a year from one floor to another. Professional movers
were hired. Boxes were loaded on trucks and moved from one
building to another, from one floor to the next floor. Generally the
moves lasted approximately 8 hours per trip.
The professionals moved, the contractor billed, and the RTC paid.
The employees of the moved section or division were unable to per-
form their designated tasks for the entire work day. Therefore, the
entire section or division was incapacitated for an entire work day.
There is a total disregard for Federal rules and regulations.
The flagrant disregard for rules and regulations is pervasive
throughout the RTC. Managers oflen chide: "We are RTC, not
FDIC." Or, this does not apply to the RTC. Therefore implying that
RTC does not have to abide by the same rules and regulations as
the FDIC.
Management's perception that RTC is a quasi-organization has
bred an atmosphere of arrogance. Since they believe they are not
a full-fledged Governmental agency, they have a mandate to pick
and choose which Federal regulations and rules they want to fol-
low, and those they wish to disregard. This has led to numerous
EEO complaints and to Office of Personnel violations.
In regard to EEO and some of the oversight agencies, the RTC
has reduced the EEO to a puppet operation. EEC's autonomy to re-
solve complaints without management interference is nonexistent.
Currently the RTC's EEO office is clogged with complaints that
are still in the informal, preliminary stage of the complaint process
and have been stalled in that stage for more than a year.
As an EEO representative, I have represented at least five com-
plainants in the past year and a half. During that time, I have wit-
nessed management's refusal to cooperate with EEO officials. This
refusal to cooperate includes failure to provide investigators with
requests for documents and oral testimony.
As a result, investigators have difficulty following the EEO time-
table which governs every step of the complaint process. Therefore,
employees have no viable means of resolving discrimination com-
plaints against RTC.
Even in its investigatory stage, each complaint costs $70,000.
With these five complaints alone, the investigation is costing
$350,000, which they had no business incurring at all. With the
35
proper management and the proper counseling, these complaints
could have been resolved at the drop of a hat.
In conclusion, reprisals and nonrenewable contracts, harassment
and intimidation are the risks many will bear here today. The
RTC's discriminatory practices and unethical behavior have bred
an atmosphere of distrust and paranoia within the organization.
Management's disregard for regulation and business ethics is a
direct result and an insult to legislative authority and sets a dan-
gerous precedent which undermines the authority of elected offi-
cials.
The RTC was created to rid the banking establishment of sick
S&L's. Instead, it created a sick agency. Taxpayers are hemorrhag-
ing financially externally, and now they are nemorrhaging inter-
nally.
It is my hope that my testimony today illustrates the need to
provide meaningful solutions to the problems which ail the RTC. In
my opinion, there may be a need for an appointment of a Special
Prosecutor.
Thank you.
The Chairman. Thank you very much, Mr. Henderson.
I have some thoughts about what you have said here, and some
ideas. Senator Metzenbaum and I are both discussing how best to
follow up on the various things that are being set out here.
I think I will hold that until just a little bit later.
Senator Metzenbaum. If I could, Mr. Chairman, could I take just
a moment to congratulate you and your staff and these people?
Each of them deserve a chapter in that famous book of John F.
Kennedy's Profiles in Courage. It takes guts to come before a Sen-
ate Committee and talk about your present employer, or your
former employer.
You people are absolutely wonderful. You give me some reassur-
ance that there is some hope in our Government. But some of the
things that you are telling us cause us to just want to sit here and
cry because, while we fight so hard aroimd here to find some
money for some needed program — whether it is education, or feed-
ing, or health, or whatever tne case may be — this is an agency that
has been wasting, wasting, wasting money.
No matter who is at the head of it, we could not get any action.
We have just blown not "millions" but "billions" of dollars on law-
yers and accountants who have been working with them and who
have ripped off the system. The people working the system have
ripped it off, and you people are absolute giants.
Mr. Chairman, I want to tell you that you and your committee
staff deserve a lot of credit. I am sure it was not easy to find some-
body in one city, and somebody some place else, but you have done
a magnificent job. It is a privilege for me to have an opportunity
to sit here and work with you.
The Chairman. Thank you very much.
I think it should be noted, too, that everybody who has testified
is testifying under oath. People do not do that lightlv. I take what
is being said to be the truth, even without the oatn, but I think
the fact that people have come in here and understand that they
are testifying on that basis adds great weight to the credibility of
what they are saying.
36
I think, too, as we listen to these individual stories from different
areas, we see this pattern. You see a clearer pattern emerging here
where the same difficulties are infecting the RTC all over tne place.
That is why I think it is so important. We will hold until later our
thoughts as to what we will do next.
Let me now turn to Ms. Deanna Smith. We are pleased to have
you. Pull that mike right up close. We would like to have you go
ahead and make your statement.
TESTIMONY OF DEANNA SMITH, RESOLUTION TRUST COR-
PORATION, LEGAL DIVISION, ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT
[FORMER EMPLOYEE, CURRENTLY WITH FDICl, ATLANTA,
GA
Ms. Smith. My name is Deanna Smith, I am pleased to appear
before the committee today in response to your request concerning
my experience at the RTC.
I am today employed by the FDIC in the Atlanta Regional Office
as Administrative Assistant with responsibility for payroll and
travel vouchers,
I had one particular experience at the RTC which I believe rep-
resents a clear case of waste, fraud, and abuse. I held a similar po-
sition at the RTC to the one I have now at the FDIC.
I was originally hired by the FDIC Legal Division in the Atlanta
Regional Office. FDIC trained me in the handling of vouchers and
receipts by employees when they claim reimbursement for busi-
ness-related expenses.
Obviously one of the main things you are looking for when you
handle such vouchers is to protect the FDIC insurance funds by
making sure that people are not getting paid by the Government
for personal business. I was trained by the FDIC to look out for
such practices. Our office was converted from the Atlanta Regional
Office of the FDIC to the Eastern Regional Office of the RTC,
which is Taxpayer funded.
After management was changed from FDIC to RTC in 1991, I
found an apparent problem on a travel voucher submitted by the
new Deputy Regional Counsel. The nature of the problem was
charging a rental car for personal use and billing the RTC.
I was asked to review the manager's travel voucher prior to its
formal submission, and I did so. When I did, I confronted him
about the rental car charge. He acknowledged that he had used the
car for personal business, I told him he was not authorized to
charge personal expenses on the Government's Diner's Club charge
card, and I wanted to give him an opportunity to correct the vouch-
er before he submitted it for reimbursement and auditing.
He screamed at me and he told me that I didn't know my job.
I told him that it was very hard for me to confront someone in his
position with this, and hoped it would not be held against me. I
told him that I would call Washington about this. He told me that
he would call Washington, as well, I called Washington and spoke
with the person in the Travel Unit. I asked if the charge was ap-
propriate, and whether I was correct.
They told me I was, I told them they might want to start pulling
his vouchers to check them. They told me to tell him the charge
was wrong and that he should not do it again. I relayed the mes-
37
sage to him and it made him even madder. Nothing was ever done
to discipline him that I know of. I do not recall seeing the voucher
again. I have no way of knowing whether he corrected the voucher.
If he did not correct the voucher, I do not know whether he ever
paid the charge back.
I later heard from employees in other offices that he had a prob-
lem with travel vouchers. As of today, this manager is still at the
RTC.
Needless to say, I believe I experienced retaliation as a result of
having insisted on following the rules and reporting the travel
voucher problem. Several times it had been suggested to me by the
head of the office that I would be selected for an administrative as-
sistant training position which had promotion potential. I was not
selected.
RTC later sought to relocate me to the Philadelphia RTC office,
which I fought. About 18 months after the incident, I was fortunate
to be returned to the FDIC. This experience was very chilling to
me. It makes me hesitant to pick up the phone to report waste,
fraud, or abuse to the Inspector General Hot Line because, if I do,
someone may find out and I may be punished.
As a Taxpayer, I was also very angry because it was a case of
the Grovernment being ripped off.
I would like to thank the committee for the opportunity to testify
today.
The Chairman. Thank you very much.
I want to thank you, as well as I have said to the others, for com-
ing forward today.
Let me now go to you, Ms. LePique. Annette LePique is the Sec-
tion Chief of the Affordable Housing Unit in the Newport Beach,
CA, office of the RTC. We welcome you, and we want you to give
us your statement now.
TESTIMONY OF ANNETTE LePIQUE, RESOLUTION TRUST COR-
PORATION, SECTION CHIEF, AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNIT,
NEWPORT BEACH, CA
Ms. LePique. Thank you, Chairman Riegle, and thank you to all
the Members of the committee for inviting me to appear here
today.
I am here to speak about my personal experiences at the RTC
regarding waste and mismanagement specifically as it relates to
the handling of claims of discrimination and sexual harassment at
the California office.
I was promoted in July 1990, to the California offiice in the posi-
tion of an affordable housing specialist. I have a Masters Degree
in Administration. I have 15 years experience in affordable hous-
ing. I considered this a tremendous career opportunity.
RTC's Affordable Housing Program was created by FIRREA in
1989. I was proud to be a part of it then, and I am proud to be
a part of it now. We have developed housing opportunities for thou-
sands of low- and moderate-income Americans and Taxpayers, as
well. It has been considered a silver lining to the cloud of the sav-
ings and loan crisis.
But there is one storm cloud that has hovered, and I believe it
is the result of the California office's total lack of any affirmative
38
action hiring, which has led to gender-based discrimination and
sexual harassment at that office.
For 2V2 years I was subjected to sexist remarks, suggestions, and
actions, creating a hostile work environment at the most senior
level. A previous complaint against one particular individual re-
sulted in absolutely no action, and he was promptly promoted. His
actions always involved subordinate women. But then women are
virtually nonexistent in senior management at the RTC.
As a witness in a previous EEOC complaint in 1991, I was a
prime target for retaliation. My harasser wheeled tremendous
power in the California office, especially with the arrival of Mr.
A. J. Felton from the Atlanta office, a close personal friend of Stan-
ley Tate's and Phillip V. Jones, Jr.
Friends were promoted, and others were not. Among those "oth-
ers" could always be counted females and minorities. Even though
I was recommended for promotion by my current supervisor, it was
denied by Mr. Phillip Jones.
In filing my EEO complaint in November 1992, I found that the
California office had never even bothered to appoint EEO coun-
selors. So my complaint was handled by an investigator in the Kan-
sas City office. The investigation was thorough. It was well docu-
mented, and it was completed in 30 days. It affirmed my complaint
and the results were given to senior managers over the phone the
same day it was completed.
Filing an EEO complaint is sometimes referred to as "protected
activity," but I had to ask: Protected activity for whom? The same
day I filed my complaint I received my first ever adverse personnel
action fi-om Mr. Jones, within 7 hours of the filing. He is not even
my supervisor. I dared to take a swing at the good old boy system,
and my pimishment was about to begin.
During the EEO investigation, senior managers began investiga-
tions of their own of me personally and my department. When this
produced nothing they could use against me, I was made — forced
to attend a meeting and given four back-dated annual performance
reviews, all showing progressively deteriorating performance on my
part. Two of these were for a period I had already been reviewed,
and although my attorney attempted to attend the meeting — be-
cause by that time I was forced to retain counsel — ^he was thrown
out by senior managers of the office.
At the very same time, during this very same period, nothing
was being done to the harasser other than a transfer to another ex-
ecutive level position.
In a letter to my attorney, Mr. Felton, the Vice President of the
California office, denied the existence of an original annual per-
formance review, even though it was submitted as an attachment
to my EEO complaint.
In terms of waste and mismanagement relative to this complaint,
a total of four EEO investigations were done and were filed by Ms.
Sandra Crisman, who will speak next. These alone have cost the
Taxpayers tens of thousands of dollars.
In addition, management ordered four additional reviews in-
tended to discredit us, rather than getting to the truth. They al-
ready knew the truth. These additional needless reviews involved
39
over 100 employees of the RTC's California and DC offices, took
months to complete, and cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Each additional review only confirmed what the EEO office had
established. Both female department heads had more than accept-
able work records to be promoted. Sexual harassment and discrimi-
nation and retaliation had occurred. And Ms. Crisman and I were
the victims, not senior management, and it emanated from the very
top.
The last report that was done actually found several more vic-
tims of sexual harassment who had never reported that. Reactions
by the senior management of California was swift. My harasser
was put on special assignment to Home Fed Bank in San Diego for
a period of 5 months, which translated to a 5-month vacation be-
cause he did not go to work during that period.
All expenses were paid. That was at an approximate cost of
$2,700 a week to the Taxpayer. These were two more months of ad-
ministrative paid leave until he was finally terminated by the
Washington, DC, office as California senior managers remained si-
lent on the issue.
In conclusion, I want to say that the senior managers most re-
sponsible for the situation in California have received no sanctions
at all.
My personnel file, on the other hand, is full of adverse actions
since November 1992. In fact, one of the people found to have dis-
criminated, Mr. Phillip Jones, was recently promoted to our DC of-
fice.
Victims in California remain uncompensated, although settle-
ment discussions with myself and Sandra Crisman have com-
menced.
I would like to commend our EEO office in DC for their handling
of this, but they cannot unring the bell. Many people have lost.
Valuable employees have lefl, totally frustrated by the system. One
woman lefl shortly after her filing because she could not get a pro-
motion or a significant job assignment.
A female attorney was fired for asking that women be promoted.
Another female manager was demoted after filing her complaint
and resigned and moved — Kozak style like the Soviet Union, per-
haps in search of more freedom than the RTC offers.
Most just suffer in silence, afraid of termination or other tjrpes
of retaliation. I have suffered. At the RTC, boys will be boys, and
when they get in trouble they all take care of each other, and we
all have to pay for it.
Please, even as the RTC prepares to sunset, for those of us who
have never been members of the boys club and never will be, help
RTC management at the highest level recognize the value in a di-
verse workplace, one that reflects the face of America.
Thank you, very much.
The Chairman. Thank you for coming forward. It is the intention
of this committee on all the items that are being presented today,
f>ersonal and more broadly generic items, to initiate actions to fol-
ow up on each of them.
I do not want this stuff buried under either a wall of silence or
anything else. So your coming and talking is not the end of this
process. We will take these things forward. I want you to under-
40
stand that we hear what you are saying. I am very upset about
what you have said.
So let me now proceed
Senator Metzenbaum. Mr. Chairman.
The Chairman. Senator Metzenbaum.
Senator Metzenbaum. Ms. LePique, in your statement you refer
to the fact that Mr. Felton was a personal friend of Mr. Stanley
Tate.
Ms. LePique. That is correct.
Senator Metzenbaum. Mr. Tate at that time was on the Board
of Overseers of the RTC?
Ms. LePique. That is correct.
Senator Metzenbaum. Do you read anything more into that,
other than your statement? You know he is up tor confirmation to
be Chairman of the RTC?
Ms. LePique. Absolutely.
Senator Metzenbaum. Being a personal friend in and of itself is
not necessarily a negative fact, unless there was some way he was
involved, or he should have shared some responsibility in this situ-
ation.
Ms. LePique. That Mr. Felton should have shared some respon-
sibility?
Senator Metzenbaum. Mr. Tate.
Ms. LePique. No.
I am just saying that Mr. Felton has been protected, I believe,
because of his association with him, as has Mr. Jones, as have most
of the people involved. As I said, they stick together. They are all
culpable in my evaluation. That is what I have read into the EEO
investigation that was done by the RTC.
Their own internal EEO Department did an investigation using
an outside contractor, and that is what the contractor found.
Senator Metzenbaum. Thank you, very much.
The Chairman. Thank you very much, Senator Metzenbaum.
Ms. Crisman, we would like to hear from you, now. Thank you
for coming.
Just pml that mike around. When you are ready, we would like
your statement.
TESTIMONY OF SANDRA CRISMAN, RESOLUTION TRUST COR-
PORATION, DEPARTMENT HEAD, CONTRACTS DEPARTMENT,
NEWPORT BEACH, CA
Ms. Crisman. Good afternoon. My name is Sandra Crisman. I am
a Manager in the Contracts Department of the RTC's Newport
Beach, CA, office.
I would like to begin by thanking the Chairman of the committee
for the invitation to appear today. I am here to describe my per-
sonal experience with gender-based discrimination at the RTC.
I believe my experiences can be summarized in five statements.
First, I was denied a promotion that I had earned. Second, man-
agement's attempts to justify the denial were false and inappropri-
ate. Third, management's stated standards of performance were
not applied consistently between male and female department
heads. Fourth, following the filing of my EEO complaint, manage-
ment engaged in acts of reprisal against me. And fifth, despite the
41
RTC's confirmation of discrimination and reprisal in my case, the
RTC's executive management here in Washington promoted the in-
dividual who discriminated against me.
My professional career spans both the public and the private sec-
tors. Prior to joining the RTC, I had 5 years' experience with the
Internal Revenue Service in human resources management, and 3
years' experience in aerospace contracting with a private contrac-
tor. I possess a Bachelor's Degree in Management, and a Master's
Degree in Finance.
My employment with the RTC began in July 1990, when I was
hired by the California office as a contract specialist. In July 1991,
I was promoted to Department Head and told by my supervisor
that if my performance was satisfactory, I would be promoted to
the full working level of the position in 1 year.
During that year, I received a "Superior" performance award,
and at the end of the year I received an "Excellent" performance
review from my supervisor, with laudatory comments from her su-
pervisor.
My promotion was recommended by two levels of management
above me. However, when it reached the desk of Mr. Phillip Jones,
Assistant Vice President, it was denied. I was told that Mr. Jones
wanted to wait and see if the California office had met its sales
goals. However, I had never been told my performance would be
tied to the sales of the office. This requirement was not in my posi-
tion description, nor was it a factor on my performance evaluation.
I was aware that a promotion in the Contracts Department had
just been approved for a male contract specialist. I was also aware
that male department heads in the California office were routinely
promoted.
Therefore, in August 1992, I filed an EEO complaint. During the
EEO investigation, management changed its reasons for denying
the promotion. Mr. Jones stated that a poor program compliance
review and findings in the Inspector General's report were the rea-
sons for the denial, but the facts do not support this.
The program compliance review was fully acceptable as con-
firmed by the lead reviewer in the EEO investigation. The Inspec-
tor General's office has confirmed that there was no derogatory in-
formation about me or anyone who worked for me in the report ref-
erenced by Mr. Jones.
In a further attempt to justify their actions, senior management
stated that they do not promote supervisors whose program compli-
ance reviews showed deficiencies until those deficiencies are cor-
rected.
If this is management's policy, then it must be consistently ap-
plied to males and females. This is not happening in the California
office. The EEO investigation confirmed that male managers whose
departments had significant deficiencies noted in their formal re-
views did not have their promotions withheld pending resolution of
the deficiencies. Instead, they were promptly promoted.
After filing my complaint, management took actions which con-
stituted reprisal. Senior management immediately ordered a re-
view of the contracts department by a local team. Although the out-
come was favorable, they ordered yet another review, this time
42
from the Washington oflRce and at least ten individuals came for
one full week. The final report rated the department as excellent.
Needless to say, these reviews consumed countless hours for both
the auditors and the 35 members of the contract department staff.
No other department, with the exception of affordable housing
which is also headed by a female, Annette LePique, has been sub-
jected to multiple reviews such as this.
The EEO investigation has now concluded and confirmed dis-
crimination in my case. A resolution is pending.
I would like to comment that the RTC's Washington office of
Equal Employment Opportimity has been very responsive since
January 1993. They have made efforts to educate all managers
within the organization about sexual harassment and discrimina-
tion.
Until recently, I believed that management throughout the orga-
nization was making a good-faith effort to eradicate the discrimina-
tion. However, I am here today because this is not the case. The
individual who denied my promotion, Mr. Phillip Jones, has been
recently promoted to the Washington, DC, office.
I am personally outraged by the Corporation's decision to pro-
mote this individual. He not only discriminated against me, but he
was found to have discriminated against Annette LePique, who just
spoke. By its actions, the RTC is clearly saying that its managers
are not held accountable for their discriminatory actions. I find this
situation untenable.
I believe that RTC supports the good old boy network, at the
most senior ranks of management, which is wny Mr. Jones was
promoted in spite of his discriminatory activity. Clearly manage-
ment at RTC has abdicated responsibility for correcting discrimina-
tion and reprisal within the organization.
I am thankful to the Members of the committee for their concern
and exhort you to put an end to this heinous conduct.
Senator Kerry. [Presiding.] Thank you very much, Ms. Crisman.
I appreciate that.
Let me just say, as a Senator I am outraged enough — I think if
I were a woman, I would be feeling very powerless and very frus-
trated and super angry at this notion
Ms. Crisman. Yes.
Senator Kerry. — ^that there seems to be a reward, not with-
standing findings, and it is certainly something that the committee
will inquire about.
Ms. Crisman. Thank you.
Senator Kerry. Mr. Hans Mangelsdorf is the Senior Property
Manager in the Newport Beach, CA, RTC.
Mr. Mangelsdorf
TESTIMONY OF HANS MANGELSDORF, PESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION, ASSET SPECIALIST, NEWPORT BEACH, CA
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I would like to first express my
appreciation
Senator Kerry. If I could ask each of you, I know we are almost
toward the end of the line, but if you could keep it tight, as most
of you have, and it has been very helpful.
Thank you.
43
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Thank you for allowing me the opportunity
to speak here today. My comments are based on my tenure at the
RTC and 17 years experience in California real estate and the sav-
ings and loan industry
Senator Kerry. Pull that mike a little closer and speak up a lit-
tle bit.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. The stated philosophy of RTC's management
is that nothing will stand in the way of the RTC, Nothing. Not the
rules, not the regulations
Senator Kerry. How long did you work there?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. At the RTC?
Senator Kerry. Yes.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I am still an employee at the RTC. I started
in June 1990.
Senator Kerry. 1990?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. That is correct.
Senator Kerry. Your job is what?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I am an Asset Specialist and Institutional
Oversight Manager.
Senator Kerry. Your background?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Asset management in the savings and loan
and real estate industries.
Senator Kerry. How long have you been involved in that?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Seventeen years.
Senator Kerry. What is your educational background?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I have 106 college units including the Uni-
versity of Southern California.
Senator Kerry. You say you have worked in this area for 17
years?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes sir, I have.
Senator Kerry. Ever in the public sector, previously?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. No sir, I have not.
Senator Kerry. In the course of your 17 year experience in the
private sector, did you work for any corporate entities?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes, I did. Wells Fargo Bank and American
Savings & Loan.
Senator Kerry. Have you ever run into any similar management
practices in the course of those 17 years?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Absolutely not.
Senator Kerry. Now why don't you describe what you ran into.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. OK. As I started to say, the stated philoso-
phy of the RTC's management is that nothing will stand in the way
of the RTC. Not the rules. Not the regulations. And certainly not
RTC's employees. Consequences can be seen in the EEO arena, in
RTC's operations and in the local economy.
I have served with the RTC since 1990. I have worked at Colum-
bia Savings, Pacific Savings, Santa Barbara Savings, and Great
American Savings, some of the largest savings and loans to come
across our office.
During this period, a pattern of covert activity, mismanagement,
and misconduct has developed in the California office. I have ob-
served illegal acts, and I have reported them to the Inspector Gen-
eral's office. I have been asked to do things that I simply just
wouldn't do.
44
Charges of harassment and reprisal are pervasive. The place is
really out of control. It is abusive, and it is completely demoralizing
for an employee.
RTC's own independent investigations have confirmed these alle-
gations. However, RTC has limited its corrective action.
As an example, I have supported Annette in the EEO process
through testimony to the Inspector General's office, GAO, the
EEOC, and numerous in-house investigations. Since then, I have
received reprimands, written warnings, my first-ever poor em-
ployee evaluation, and continual denial of promised promotion. I
have always been a top producer at the office.
While independent EEO investigations have validated my
allegations
Senator Kerry. Let me just ask you. Did your negative apprais-
als only begin after you became a thorn in the side, so to speak?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Absolutely.
While the independent EEO investigations have validated my al-
legation and recommended settlement, no corrective action has
been taken. It is the RTC's price for telling the truth.
Voicing my opinion is part of my job description. It seems that
every time I do, I suffer. My supervisors are hostile and they open-
ly call me a "native," meaning
Senator Kerry. Call you a what?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. A "native" — meaning that constructive criti-
cism has no place at the RTC.
RTC is dumping assets as rapidly as possible through auctions.
Structured sales transactions have endangered the local economies.
Unfortunately, not only have the past real estate auctions disposed
of property using steep discounts, but high operating costs have
substantially reduced return to the Taxpayers.
Property slated for auction is taken off the market for months at
a time, regardless of market interest. In other words, we could
have an offer pending, and they would send it off to an auction,
like Mr. O'Bryon was saying earlier, to create a pretty auction for
the public.
A typical minimum bid for property at the RTC is 30 percent less
than the appraised value. Auction selling costs are reportedly 22
percent, and sometimes even more, of the selling price compared to
an industry auction at 17 percent. Using a local real estate broker
costs about 6 percent. That is a big difference.
In effect, the RTC and the American Taxpayer pay a high cost
of sale to achieve a discounted sales price. The difference means
millions.
A little earlier we talked about a $500 million difference. I would
concur with that figure for the present. I think if the RTC contin-
ues, that will easily be $1 billion, or maybe even more. I think that
is a lot of money.
Senator Kerry. Is that the necessary price of disposing of this
property? Or could something else be done?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Oh, ^solutely there are alternative meas-
ures available to the RTC.
Senator Kerry. Such as what?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Well, direct sales for one thing.
45
The public comes to the RTC and the demand is high. I receive
20, 30, sometimes 50 and 100 calls every dav. I talk to at least 20
and 30 Taxpayers every dav. I could readily sell the property. I
have the wherewithal to do it. Instead, I have to send them
through a complex and convoluted system, which is frustrating for
the Taxpayer and frustrating for the employees of the RTC.
Senator Kerry. To what degree does that svstem protect against
a kind of — an alternative kind of fraud or mvoritism that might
enter the system of people just cutting their own deals without a
systemic approach? I mean, could you have accountability?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I worked at American Savings just prior to
coming to the RTC. I was their corporate broker in handling the
disposition of their real estate assets.
I was accountable to the Taxpayers. I was also accountable to the
shareholders of the Association. My work was an open book, as it
is at the RTC. There really is no difference except that in the pri-
vate sector there is one guy I look to, myself. In Government, there
are dozens. The ability to find out who might be culpable in any
action is difficult.
Senator Kerry. But what you are saying is that there could have
been an alternative structure of sale that would have been equally
as accountable, but far more profitable? Is that correct?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Absolutely.
Senator Kerry. Do you concur with that, Mr, O'Bryon?
Mr. O'Bryon. Absolutely.
Senator Kerry. I do not mean to interrupt his testimony.
Mr. O'Bryon. The RTC has so many different levels of delegated
authority, and so many of the people who are involved within that
level of delegated authority in making a decision about something
as simple as selling a $50,000 condo, as an example, you may have
to go through 7 or 8 different steps and layers.
You might have to go in front of a committee who absolutely has
no experience and knowledge of what is happening in the market-
place, no experience or knowledge of what is happening to real es-
tate of that particular type, making a decision and asking you, the
asset specialist, to justity your accepting an offer.
Now when I was working there, I remember one time I had a
full-price offer on a condo. I sent it up to my boss. He sent it back
saying you need to write a case study, and if you have got a full-
price offer then something is wrong. We cannot accept the first
offer.
I never got the property sold, quite honestly. The levels and the
layers are archaic and ridiculous.
Senator Kerry. Let me come back, if I can, to Mr. Mangelsdorf.
I understand there were occasions where fraudulent information
was passed on to the U.S. Congress in its efforts to try to evaluate
this process. Is that accurate?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I recall a time that I was asked to produce
sales documentation where we were reporting to the Congress of
the United States, however, it was taking too long for us to manu-
facture the numbers. Management asked us to stop where we were,
double it, and add 10. Those were the numbers that were presented
to you.
Senator Kerry. So it was just a total ballpark figure?
46
Mr. Mangelsdorf. An unqualified guess.
Senator Kerry. An unqualified guess?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Absolutely.
Senator Kerry. And that guess was as to what? The amount of
sales value? What was it pertaining to?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Amount of the sales value, yes.
Senator KERRY. The amount of sales value
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes.
Senator Kerry. — that had been produced? Or was to be pro-
duced?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Sales production that had been produced.
Senator Kerry. That had been produced?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes.
Senator Kerry. So in effect, you were providing us with figures
alleging production that had not in fact taken place?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Production was overstated.
The Chairman. More than "overstated." You say that it was dou-
bled, and then they said to add 10. So it was misstated by
Mr. Mangelsdorf. A bunch.
The Chairman. Yes.
[Laughter.]
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Another avenue involves structured sales
transactions where the RTC evaluates property based on its in-
come.
Senator Kerry. How many times did that happen, to your per-
sonal knowledge?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Overstating the production?
Senator Kerry. Yes.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Personally, once. I imagine several times in
the early days. We just didn't have the ability to produce the type
of information you all were looking for.
Senator Kerry. Is that ability there now?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes.
Senator Kerry. It is there now?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes.
Senator Kerry. Do you think this has been corrected at this
point?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes. I'll add that it's at a substantial cost.
The Chairman. What do you mean by that? Is there something
we should know about the cost to get it fixed?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I think the amount of money that we spent
on the computer system, not being a computer expert, of course, is
a great deal of money more than we probably had to spend.
The Chairman. You know, that issue has come up, if I may, sev-
eral times today. Do you have the impression that there were con-
tracting relationships here where friends, pals, or whatever tended
to get these contracts, or was it just that there was such a gross
level of incompetence that people were coming in and ripping off
the agency and charging them, whether it was for legal work, com-
puter work, or what have you, just a lot more than they should
have been charging in terms of what they were delivering?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I think my colleague from the Atlanta office
hit the nail on top of the head. I think the quality of the manage-
ment level of the RTC has got a lot to be desired. I feel that many
47
managers are promoted not for their wherewitiial but with the like-
lihood that they will be sympathetic to existing management.
The Chairman. But I am interested in the question of whether
or not this waste is just sheer incompetence or whether this kind
of pattern of waste has to do with funneling money, in effect
through inflated contracts, to favored people? And if any of you can
cite examples of that, I want to hear that.
In other words, there's different ways to waste money. It's one
thing to waste it just because it is sort of a Keystone Cops oper-
ation at the management level, which is what you're describing.
But I am also concerned that for the amounts of money that we're
floating around here, if money was being passed out like that, that
there may well be other patterns of where the money went, who
got it, who didn't get it, that kind of thing. And I am concerned
about the degree to which that may be part of this story. And, to
the extent it is, that we get it identified and documented.
Mr. Mange LSDORF. OK
Mr. Henderson. I think it's a combination of both.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I would agree with that.
Mr. Henderson. From the legal aspect, there have been numer-
ous cases where large cases were funneled to a particular law firm
that the head of the legal division had an interest in.
The Chairman. You mean actually had an interest in that law
firm?
Mr. Henderson. He had a personal relationship with that law
firm.
The Chairman. How do you mean?
Mr. Henderson. To put it blimtly, the person that she was fun-
neling the cases to was a familiar acquaintance of hers.
The Chairman. So there was a personal relationship?
Mr. Henderson. Correct. And it's a combination. It's more like
the Keystone Cops than anything else. It's a combination of things
that go into this pot. Having worked for FDIC prior to going over
to RTC, I can make the comparison and it's like night and day.
We had one particular case where there was a young lady, it was
a paralegal, that caught an error in a $45,000 appropriation to a
law firm. It turned up on the system as $450,000. The firm had al-
ready been paid $60,000 over the $45,000. Her hell began when she
found the error.
The Chairman. In other words, instead of giving her a pat on the
back and maybe a promotion, she got hassled because she found
the mistake.
Mr. Henderson. Correct.
The Chairman. Was that money ever reeled back in?
Mr. Henderson. No.
The Chairman. Do you want to try to finish, Mr. Mangelsdorf?
I'm sorry.
Excuse me, you wanted to say something?
Mr. Pederson. I'm sorry, I know I'm out of order. But I wanted
to refer the committee's attention to Exhibit six to the written
statement which Ms. Taylor and I have provided this morning. It's
a clear piece of evidence which goes directly to what you're refer-
ring to. Friends at the RTC ^ving business to other personal
friends on the outside to the detriment of the Taxpayers.
48
The Chairman. Pull that mike right around, Ms. Taylor.
Ms. Taylor. I would like to add to that. In the Denver office
there are several examples of legal business being sent to ex-man-
agers from the legal department of the Denver office. I have not
heard of that occurring with ex-lawyer members that were just
staff attorneys. But there are several ex-department heads or sec-
tion chief managers that have received business after they have
left from the RTC.
And some of the people that worked for those people have told
me that the business that they received was the business that they
did not complete or were working on while they were at the RTC
in many instances.
The Chairman. We will go into that when we get to your state-
ments.
Mr. Romer.
Mr. RoMER. Yes. To add to this level of incompetence, at the de-
partment head up in Dallas they had an automation committee,
which normally takes care of how we can maybe save some money
with computer technology. I have been working in computer tech-
nology for 30 years. I made a definite request to serve on that com-
mittee three different times. I was never given the opportunity and
I know the computer capability of the total committee and they
know nothing of the industry.
But I was not able to serve. The reason I joined RTC is because
of my background. I thought I could make a contribution because
I knew we had real record problems coming because I'm a member
of the Record Management Association, the independent consult-
ants, and AIM, which is an imaging association. And I thought I
could make a contribution, but they would not give me a chance.
The Chairman. It sounds like that's why they didn't want you.
[Laughter.]
Mr. RoMER. Absolutely.
The Chairman. It sounds like that was your disqualification,
that you knew what you were talking about.
Mr. Romer. I did know.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I didn't come to speak about computers, but
I will add that when we started out, we had this little computer
system and then we made this really big computer system. Re-
cently, we decided that was too big and we cut it back. Every time
we did that, we incurred extra expenses. Now it's kind of a me-
dium-sized computer system. It did what the little system did, but
it just does a little bit more of what it used to do. So I guess we
couldn't really decide what we wanted the computer system to do
before we ordered it up and just spent money until we figured out
how it would work.
The Chairman. Go ahead, Ms. Crisman. Then we're going to let
Mr. Mangelsdorf finish, then I want to get the other witnesses to
speak.
Ms. Crisman. I would like to add just one comment with respect
to contracts flowing to friends and acquaintances.
Most of the examples given here today were with respect to legal
contracting. I just want to point out that the procedures for legal
contracting are practically nonexistent. Whereas, there are very
tight procedures for asset-type contracting. And I personally
49
haven't found that those procedures allow for contracts to flow to
friends and relatives. But I agree that there is a big problem with
the legal procedures.
The Chairman. You wanted to say something. Then we're going
to have Mr. Mangelsdorf finish.
Mr. KoszoLA. Thanks. I never met any of these witnesses before
and some of them I haven't known for more than 24 hours. As far
as legal contracts, I know personally that in Chicago alone the
chief of the legal section was involved in one law firm that was
awarded approximately $3 million in fees. And one contract that he
was in the process of awarding to the law firm was a quarter of
a million dollars. Just 2 to 3 days after that contract was awarded,
he began employment negotiations with that firm. It was a com-
mon practice to award all this money to a law firm where they ei-
ther worked before working at the KTC or worked right after the
contract was awarded.
The Chairman. Senator Metzenbaum, in particular, has really
tried to track down these legal contracts and the fact that so many
of them seem to be excessive on their face. There are a lot of ques-
tions about the pattern of where these contracts went. But it seems
to me that what he's just cited sort of fits right in.
Senator Metzenbaum. Absolutely. And, Mr. Chairman, I must
tellyou that when Bill Seidman took over the chairmanship of the
RTC, I thought they were bringing in a class act, a former account-
ant, to run the RTC. I begged him, I pleaded with him, I knew Bill
Seidman before he came to the RTC. He'd been an accountant. He
owned some newspapers up in Michigan.
But I have to say to you that this is just such an abomination,
such an abdication of responsibility. We have just thrown away
hundreds of millions of dollars, billions of dollars, to law firms in
this country, that we shouldn't have done so. This is confirming
evidence, but the fact is that there's so much more and the law
firms of this country have ripped off" the RTC and in most in-
stances, it was the major law firms, not the little guys around the
comer.
The accounting firms ought to be embarrassed for what they
have done to the RTC. And these people again, this confirms it, but
the worst part is I don't know what we can do about it. But I would
like to suggest, Mr. Chairman, some of what has been said here
today, and my guess is some more of what's going to be said, has
to do with either violations of the law or that that borders on viola-
tions of the law.
We are Members of Congress. We don't enforce laws. But I would
like to stronglv surest something that you. and I were talking
about previously an^that is that this entire record be printed up,
that the entire statements be included, that you. Senator Kerry,
and I meet either with Janet Reno or Phil He3anan, sit down and
talk with them.
There have to have been some violations of law in the way the
RTC was conducted. And I think going through this record it may
not be too late to prosecute some of these people for ripping off the
Taxpayers and the Federal Government. I would like to work with
you in that connection. And I would like to work with Senator
Kerry as well.
50
I think this does call for law enforcement as well as just expo-
sure here in this committee room.
The Chairman. Senator Kerry.
Senator Kerry. I was going to recommend that to you, Mr.
Chairman, at the end of this hearing of all the testimony. I couldn't
concur more with Senator Metzenbaum.
I don't think — I mean, it's clear from other testimony that we
have from people who were too frightened to come forward who
have also made some very strong statements. So what we are deal-
ing with are not uncorroDorated statements here. We have 2- and
3- and 4-person corroboration. And as we all know, that's with staff
that's extremely limited up here in its capacity to investigate.
But it is rather remarkable when you have a group of people
coming from California, from Greorgia, from the central part of the
country, I mean, this is all over the country. These are folks, each
of whom I think witnessed, by their history, where they've come
from, and how they came to the RTC, trying to make a contribution
after years of service in the private sector, the public sector, or a
combination of the two. There is a universality to the management
practice, which contrary to somebody who summarized it in total
as being a snake pit, I think it's a cesspool. It's incredible what's
going on or not going on down there.
And I gather to date, how many of you are still working there?
Raise your hands.
[Show of hands.]
Senator Kerry. Are these things still happening today?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Yes, they are.
The Chairman. Let's get audible answers. We won't get the nod
of the head.
Mr. KoszoLA. Yes.
Ms. LePique. Yes.
Voices. Yes.
[Laughter.]
Senator Kerry. So for everybody who is still working there, you
sense this is continuing. Taxpayer dollars are still being wasted.
Mr. Henderson. Business as usual.
The Chairman. Are you nearly finished? Because I want to go
ahead.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. I'm nearly done. Really, I am,
[Laughter.]
The Chairman. We have four more and I want to get them in
and we are under some time pressure.
Senator Metzenbaum. Do you want to give us the specifics with
respect to that sale at the asking price and that it was turned
down? That was just an incredible situation. Make that available
to the committee.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Senator Metzenbaum, that's common prac-
tice.
Senator Metzenbaum. To turn down offers at the asking price?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Absolutely.
The Chairman. Where do the asking prices come from? Why are
they setting the asking price at a certain level, then somebody
shows up ready to buy it and then they back away? I think people
find that
51
Mr. Mange LSDORF. It's very uncommon for the RTC to swing at
the first pitch.
The Chairman. Even if they've set the asking price and some-
body walks in that's wilHng to pay it?
Mr. Mange LSDORF. The thou^t would be that if somebody is
willing to pay the asking price, obviously the asking price is too
low.
The Chairman. So let's ask a price that somebody is not willing
to pay?
Mr. Mangelsdorf. You bet. Let me just go ahead and finish up
here.
[Laughter.]
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Another avenue involves structured sales
transactions. This is where the RTC evaluates property based on
its income and not its market value. This leads to more discounting
compared to the true value of the property. Because of the ex-
tended escrow periods, straw buyers, and secrecy involved with
these transactions, it takes more than a year to close.
Local communities feel that the RTC's continued discounting
practices, with the option of structured sales, are depressing an al-
ready fragile marketplace. Where I live, Los Angeles, it's started to
look like a ghost town.
I don't think it's too late to reengineer this process and I do think
that RTC stands ready to change. That's probably the rank and file
for the panel here. I think, by the way, I can speak for the panel,
we would like to join you all in a corrective process. I know that
I would and I think everybody here would too.
Thank you for the opportunity to speak.
The Chairman. Mr. Bumside, we would like to hear from you
now.
STATEMENT OF THOMAS BURNSmE, RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION, SENIOR ATTORNEY, RTC PLS PROGRAM
[FORMER EMPLOYEE], DALLAS, TX
Mr. BURNSIDE. I was in RTC in Texas in the Professional Liabil-
ity Program. I was in the Professional Liabihty Program before
they had the big expansion. I was one of the original 17 attorneys.
I was in Texas the entire time that the RTC was investigating
Texas S&L's.
And, Senator Metzenbaum, you had read something from the
presidential commission that said in general terms how bad things
were in Texas as far as the S&L's. You have no idea how bad it
was and how bad the looting was.
I was going through some numbers. Forty-one percent of all of
the losses from S&L's were fi:-om Texas. Forty-one percent. I started
calculating some numbers to see what that meant. Every man,
woman, and child in the United States is going to have to pay
$2,200 for Texas S&L's. That's not Texas banks, of which nine out
of 10 failed. It's not the other 49 States. $2,200.
Well, I was there when we were trying to recover the money. My
cases represented 73 percent of all the RTC professional liability
recoveries in Texas, 73 percent. I went throue^ and looked at the
published RTC figures on recoveries of the directors and officers
52
cases that were brought in Texas. Of that $2,200, four cents of that
was recovered from the directors and officers.
Of the attorneys in Texas who had papered all the deals for an
entire decade, one penny of that was recovered. Of the securities
brokers and the investment bankers in Texas who just looted it —
I mean, if you've ever read Liar's Poker, on Wall Street they were
making jokes about how easy it was to go and get Texas money.
There was six cents from them. There was 21 cents from the ac-
countants.
There was a lot of real estate problems in Texas. You've all read
Inside Job. In that, there was one tenth of 1 percent that was re-
covered from the appraisers.
All told, there was 36 cents recovered from the wrongdoers in
Texas by the RTC. Now, the FDIC was down there too and they
were working on it. But I worked side by side with some of those
FDIC people. They didn't do a lot better.
If you go and look at those recoveries, there was almost no recov-
ery. Why was that? There were a lot of reasons. But I would like
to talk about three. The most egregious was it just wasn't inves-
tigated down there.
The Chairman. Say that again.
Mr. BuRNsroE. It wasn't investigated down there. The RTC has
been down in Texas for 4 years and they've got this recovery to
show for it. Sure, they will probably get some more recoveries.
Guys, the statute of limitations has expired. It expired for most of
the thrifts a year ago. The story is over. Now we're looking at it.
But as far as investigations, Senator Kerry, I think you said you
were a prosecutor. You know how important subpoenas are to go
out and get information. You go into a billion dollar thrift, you got
a bunch of dead records there. You're not going to understand that
thrift until you get out and understand what happened, talk to the
people, go out and find documents.
You know, the biggest thing you do when you are investigating
is follow the money trail, figure out where the money went, then
you build your case. The only way you can follow the money trail
in Texas or anywhere else is to issue a subpoena.
If I want to go down the street to a bank and get some tracing
records, they say, send me a subpoena, which is fine, that's what
the law says. Well, let me tell you how little the subpoena power
was used in Texas. In the Houston field office in Texas, which was
handling I think about 37 or 40 thrifts, they issued three subpoe-
nas out of the entire office. Three subpoenas. Do you think those
institutions were investigated?
In Dallas where they had the largest bank fraud task force ever
formed by the Department of Justice, that office issued 43 subpoe-
nas. There was no investigation down there. And then when the
limitation expired, people would write these memos saying there
doesn't appear to be enough evidence to support a viable claim.
Let me ask you, if you sent out three subpoenas, what kind of
evidence is there going to be? There was none.
In Houston, there were three subpoenas issued. I had one case
in Houston where I issued 100 subpoenas on one case. I followed
the money trail. When I went to the settlement table, I had the
people on the other side, and whenever they would talk to me
53
about a case, I would say, look, we've talked to those people, we
know, we've got the money. We ended up settling the case.
Hundreds of subpoenas on one case, and three for the rest of the
office. What the hell happened?
There's another case in Texas, and I will talk about this later,
but it just shows you how important the subpoenas are. This was
a pretty quiet thrift in Texas, no one had ever really heard of it.
It was unique in that it wasn't even Federally insured until Decem-
ber 1986, which meant the Taxpayers were not even on the hook
for that institution. December 1986, it failed.
The Chairman. Could I stop you just for one minute?
The 41 percent was the figure you used of the total losses in the
whole system that came from Texas. Virtually all of that came from
State chartered thrifts in Texas as well. In other words
Mr. BURNSIDE. That's exactly right. I don't recall ever running
into a Federally chartered thrift down there.
The Chairman. So there was this quirk in the law where the
State could give an S&L a broader charter to do additional things
than the Federal charter would allow. And, in fact, the vast num-
ber of losses took place in those State chartered thrifts.
Nevertheless, it was all covered by Federal deposit insurance.
That was one of the gaping holes in our regulatory system which
we've since dealt with. But that's what really set the system up for
these kinds of absolutely astronomical losses. But go ahead and
then I want to pursue something with you here in a minute.
Mr. BURNSIDE. Senator, they not only gave them broad charters,
they gave them a blank check.
But on this other thrift I was telling you about, on this thrift,
I was an inside Government attorney. I probably spent a thousand
hours working on this one case alone. It was a big case for me, it
was really important to me. We issued subpoenas on that, we went
out and talked to people.
Just a few weeks before the statute of limitations expired, we fi-
nally got hold of the auditors workpapers of the holding company
and, as much as we knew there were problems in this thrift, we
were absolutely stunned to learn that two of the officers in the
holding company were minority owners of the thrift, and had
pulled out $18 million in compensation and stock benefits and that
sort of thing in an 18-month period. If we hadn't issued the subpoe-
nas, we wouldn't have known about that. We had to follow the
money trail. Once we followed the money trail, the whole case came
together.
Yet, I get back to the fact, how are you going to investigate these
institutions unless you're following the money trail and getting out
there and figuring out where the hell the money went.
The Chairman. Who was tanking these cases or this investiga-
tive effort? It sounds to me, with so much money at stake, that it
almost takes conscious decisions to not do the work as opposed to,
you know, just people being asleep at the switch, especially when
there are people like you working day and night to try to track this
stuff down. What was going on here?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Senator, I was just a line attorney. I don't know
what happened. Any time that people ask me the intent question,
I truly don't know.
54
One thing I can say is that I have been practicing law with the
directors and officers in the professional liability area my entire ca-
reer. That's what I have been doing for the last 11 years. The FDIC
has always taken the position in those cases that people intend the
natural and probable consequences of their act, and that's how peo-
ple prove intent. You don't nave the smoking gun memo that says,
let's tank the program. You go and look at the consequences and
then you look at the foreseeability of that.
Senator Kerry. Did you ask for subpoenas?
Mr. BuRNSiDE. I was issuing subpoenas.
Senator Kerry. Were they being asked for in these other cases?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Not that I know of
Senator Kerry. Why not?
Mr. BURNSIDE. I have no idea.
Well, Senator, if I could, Senator Kerry, subpoenas were being
asked for. The investigations unit down in Texas was begging their
attorneys to issue subpoenas, absolutely begging people because
they would be looking at records inside the thrift and they couldn't
go outside and figure out what happened until they got the subpoe-
nas.
They were told by one professional liability manager down there
that he didn't want to send out subpoenas because, "it would send
out the wrong message." He came to me. He was flabbergasted.
And he said, Tom, what kind of message are we trying to send out
by not sending subpoenas?
The Chairman. Let me ask you this. I understand you graduated
from a top law school. What law school did you graduate from?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Washington University in St. Louis.
The Chairman. Am I right in understanding you were 18th in
your class?
Mr. BURNSIDE. That's right.
The Chairman. So you bring very considerable legal skill, at
least based on that placement.
Is it your sense that there were hot cases down there that were
not pursued because either they were likely to lead to people that
would be embarrassing or things of that kind? I'm not asking you
to surmise what you don't have any basis to do so with some mean-
ing. But it's so implausible that people who are hired to track down
the losses and who are asking for the subpoenas are shut down and
not allowed to do so. There has to be a reason. I'd like to know
what the reason is. Was it because people were being protected?
What was going on here? What's your best judgment?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Senator, I really don't know. I will say, and I was
going to deal with this at the end of my statement, I was a pretty
damn good professional liability attorney down in Texas and I
worked real hard with the investigators, I worked real hard with
my lawyers. And on the case that I was telling you about where
we had found this $18 million, we went after those people pretty
hard. I mean, we wanted to get some recoveries and in fact the re-
coveries out of that case are second only to Lincoln Savings for the
RTC.
One week before the statute of limitations was supposed to ex-
pire, 1 week, and we had gone through several other agreements
and we were going to go to court on it, I was told to fire two key
55
fee counsel on my case. I said, it's going to gut my case. I'm not
going to do it.
Senator Kerry. Who told you that?
Mr. BURNSIDE. My managers in the legal division.
Senator Kerry. Was there a rationale? Did they offer you a ra-
tionale? You must have said, why would they do that.
Mr. BuRNsroE. It was the most bizarre rationale I had ever seen.
What had happened was two of the attorneys were working at a
large Dallas law firm and were going to move over to a small His-
panic law firm that was working on the case. Essentially what they
were going to do was submit their bills to me under a different let-
terhead. Rather than the big law firm, they were going to submit
it to me imder the Hispanic letterhead and that firm was going to
share in the profits of it. They were also going to reduce their fees
because they were going to a smaller office that had lower over-
head by about $30 an hour.
Well, they couldn't negotiate their rates with the RTC and they
said, since we can't negotiate the rates, get rid of them and hire
someone else.
What I did was, I said, I am not going to do this. I am going to
go to the clients, because in the RTC the business side is the client,
not the lawyers. I said, they are not going to put up with this.
I was given a written order that I was not supposed to discuss
this with the client. I was flabbergasted. So I called Washington
and I told them the problem and I said, I am not going to follow
this order. It's illegal for someone to tell another lawyer not to com-
municate to his client.
A few days later, I was given written instructions that I was not
supposed to talk to the PLS management in Washington, DC, un-
less there were two managers in Dallas that were present for each
and every conversation. It was a circus. I had a case where the
statute of limitations was expiring, it was a high profile case, it
took me 5 days to discuss that case with Washington.
So I followed the internal grievance procedure. That became a
joke. They assigned the person that was supposed to adjudicate the
grievance who was a subordinate and close personal friend of the
very person who was giving me the gag orders.
Finally I said, I've had enough of this. I called the General Ac-
coimting Office and sent them everything I had.
By this time, the investigations unit in Dallas was absolutely
livid about what was going on and they called the General Account-
ing Office. Within less than 2 weeks of us calling them, they had
three investigators down there. They were stunned at what they
saw. They went over to the investigations unit.
Senator Kerry. Did you get the case filed?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Actually, we ended up settling it.
Senator Kerry. Before the statute of limitations?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Oh, no.
Senator Kerry. How many cases were lost by virtue of the stat-
ute of limitations expiring?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Senator, if you go to the RTC and ask them, they
will be able to show you a closeout memo on just about any case
and they will say, well, we investigated it and, here, we have a
56
memo in our file that's dated before the Hmitation expired that
says this case was closed, we didn't miss the statute.
But let me ask you this. If you have an office that's issuing three
subpoenas and then they write a memo that says, we haven't found
any evidence that warrants pursuing this, is that missing the stat-
ute of limitations?
Senator Kerry. Let's come back for a minute. What was the per-
centage of loss in Texas?
Mr. BuRNsroE. I think it's 41.19 percent.
Senator Kerry. How much is that in money?
Mr. Burnside. Well, I had a tough time finding that. I went to
the Stanford
Senator Metzenbaum. $51 bilhon.
Senator Kerry. It's about $51 billion, correct?
Somewhere in that vicinity?
Mr. BuRNsroE. I would say if you include interest and everything
else on that, it's way, way above that.
Senator Kerry. Of the $51 billion, what is the amount recov-
ered?
Mr. Burnside. In Texas, we have recovered less than $10 million
from the directors and officers. We have recovered $1.6 million
from the attorneys. We have recovered $150,000 from the apprais-
ers. We have recovered about $4-5 million from the securities bro-
kers. And we've gotten about $66 million from the accountants. All
told, in Texas, from RTC cases, there have been $90 million in re-
coveries as of the last report from the investigations unit.
The Chairman, And two thirds of that from the accountants?
Mr. Burnside. That's exactly right.
Senator Kerry. Let me just addf you're saying that out of 43 sav-
ings and loans that amounted to tne $50 billion of loss, only three
subpoenas were issued?
Mr. Burnside. Senator, the cases were divided among offices.
There were a lot more than 43 thrifts in Texas. That was 43 han-
dled by that office.
Senator Kerry. Forty-three cases in that office. So, out of 43
cases in that office, only three subpoenas were issued?
Mr. Burnside. That's right.
Senator Kerry. Do you happen to know what the record is over-
all?
Mr. Burnside. I believe that if you were to look at the records
for Texas that there may have been about 325 subpoenas issued in
Texas institutions, and about 240 of those were issued by me.
[Laughter.]
The Chairman. If I may say, what you are describing is the Gov-
ernment, in effect, taking a dive here in terms of not aggressively
going out and doing what it was charged by law to do. We wrote
a law right here in this room to put people like you to work doing
exactly what you're trying to do and we also provided a special
grant of appropriations money to the Justice Department to hire
the people to go out and literally track down these losses of the
kind you are describing.
What it sounds like to me happened here was that somewhere
along the line the inference is — I certainly draw the inference —
that somewhere along the line the decision was made not to ag-
57
gn*essively pursue these cases, not to do the logical things to do
when you're out seeking financial recoveries.
Even in the case where you were hot on the trail of one and you
put the subpoenas out and you built your case, then you ran into
these roadblocks right at the very end that seemed to be impossible
to understand in any logical sense other than the fact it looks like
they were trying to sidetrack your effort or stall your effort and
maybe run out the statute of limitations.
I want to know what was the name of that case?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Could I tell you in chambers, because I am not
sure at this point that it would be appropriate for me to identify
the case that specifically? I just don't know.
The Chairman. All right. Well do it that way and then we'll
make a decision.
What I want to know is, I want to know who these officers and
directors are and I want to know who the officers and directors are
in the other cases where, in effect, nothing was done and where,
in effect, the Government ended up taking a dive, letting the stat-
ute of limitations run, getting these inconsequential recoveries
when you look at them in the face of the scale of the losses.
You know, this has cropped up in here before a different way, be-
cause there has been a lot of discussion about whether we should
have extended the statute of limitations, especially on officers and
members of the boards of directors, to go back and catch people
who either were complicitous in this decisionmaking or were just
derelict in their duty and were, in effect, there and not performing
as they should have.
That's a very hot issue because a lot of those directors are high
profile people. They are prominent people, they are politically ac-
tive people. If you go out £ind throw the net out and you grab that
crowd, you set off all kinds of shock waves, all kinds of repercus-
sions. And we're talking here about one State. We're talking about
Texas, which is a State with the lion's share of the total losses for
the whole country.
And, I suspect, when you look at the names and faces and rela-
tionships, you're talking about a veiy potent sort of cross section
of individuals, a lot of political implications, particularly at that
time and in that place. I mean, am I not describing accurately the
situation?
Mr. BURNSIDE. I understand what you're saying.
The Chairman. That's why I think we need to know. The worst
of all sins here would not just be the failing to perform and to go
out and, in effect, the Grovemment taking a dive and not seeking
these recoveries on a timely basis and letting the chance for recov-
ery get away. But the worst of all worlds would be that all of this
was parked in an unmarked grave so nobody ever knew or under-
stood any of it. It was all just tossed over the side and we go on
to new business.
It seems to me at a minimum, both for the sake of the losses that
took place and also for people like vourself who did the best you
could to try to go out and do your job and were thwarted, were ac-
tively thwarted from doing your job, somebody ought to be held ac-
countable at whatever level up and down the chain of command
that kind of obstruction was coming from.
58
If people walked away because they had special connections or
because they were somehow in a favored position and the statute
of limitations was allowed to run, I think we ought to get to know
about it.
Senator Kerry. Let me add to that, Mr. Chairman, and I ap-
plaud what you're saying. But you said that two of the officers were
compensated for $18 million each?
Mr. BuRNSlDE. That's with stock options and everything else.
Senator Kerry. For the span of a year-and-a-half? This is in a
savings and loan. This is not Disney Corporation or some major
venture capital effort. This is a savings and loan.
Mr. Burnside. They ran it up through the holding company.
That's correct.
Senator Kerry, Within a savings and loan for 18 months, $18
million for that period. For each of them?
Mr. Burnside. Combined.
Senator Kerry. This is what you uncovered, only by virtue of the
subpoena, correct?
Mr. Burnside. We never would have known if we hadn't subpoe-
naed it.
Senator Kerry. So for all those other banks, for all those $50 bil-
lion of losses, we don't know how many other officers took $18, $20,
$25 million or whatever it was over similar spans of time. Is that
accurate?
Mr. Burnside. That's correct.
The Chairman. Excuse me. And they still have it?
Mr. Burnside. That's exactly right. These people had the money
when we were going after them. They didn't have all of it, they
didn't even have most of it, but they still had money.
Senator Kerry. And you described it earlier, I think accurately.
This is not compensation. This is looting. Because who has turned
around £Uid made up for that "compensation" that they looted over
the span of 18 months but the average Taxpayer of this country,
who had to bail out the people who lost the money that they looted,
correct?
Mr. Burnside. Exactly right.
Senator Kerry. Here you are. How many years had you been
practicing at that point in time?
Mr. Burnside. Eleven years.
Senator Kerry. So 11 years, you're a young, aggressive attorney,
who saw this as an opportunity to really practice your profession,
correct?
Mr. Burnside. That's correct.
Senator Kerry. You come in and the system thwarts you.
Mr. Burnside. That's right.
Senator, if I may, I'd like to complete my story.
We went to the GAO, the investigations unit who had been
watching this thing going on and had been pleading for subpoenas,
all came forward as a unit. One by one they went through and
said, look at what happened in this case. The next day they came
over to the legal division. I had prepared a memo which I have sub-
mitted in there that said, this is what happened with the Texas
cases. I then went back to St. Louis for the weekend to firm up
coming back to my old law firm.
59
The Monday when I got back into the office, my superiors who
were the subject of my criticisms came in and said, we understand
you're thinking about resigning. I said, that's right. They said, well,
when do you think you'll leave? I said, I've got 20 institutions with
billions of assets. Ill work with you on a leaving date so well have
a transition. They said, that's not necessary. We want you out now.
My computer was shut off while I was in the office, I was locked
out. The investigations unit was livid. They sent over five inves-
tigators with boxes. They were going to move all of my files over
to the investigations unit so I could continue working on the cases.
We ended up not doing that. But I did go over to the investigations
unit and finished out my Grovemment career, locked out of my of-
fice, over in another building. I finally left.
I had 73 percent of all the recoveries in Texas and I was locked
out of my building when I reported my superiors and said, why are
they making me fire my counsel.
Senator Kerry. Who locked you out?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Arturo Vero-Rojas was the general counsel and he
had three levels of subordinates under him that were all part of the
decision.
The Chairman. It should be noted for the record that in 1991,
2 years ago, you received an award from the FDIC for sustained
superior performance. Is that correct?
Mr. BuRNsroE. That's correct.
The Chairman. I think what you're telling us is that there's a
huge story here. The question is, is there any way to go back and
get it now? I mean, dig out what happened, who took the dive,
why, who was protected? You know, who was allowed, in effect, to
make off with the money?
You'd have to look at all the holding companies, wouldn't you, in
effect to figure out the answer to Senator Kerry's question, who ac-
tually grabbed these large amounts of money and ran?
Mr. BURNSIDE. Follow the money trail wherever the trail takes
you.
The Chairman. But it sounds to me from your experience that
you went down to do that and the people that you were working
for really didn't want you to do that.
Mr. BURNSIDE. Some of them did, others didn't. I don't know
what happened.
I will say this, if you want to find out what happened, go down
to the line investigators, the poor people that were sitting in there
with the documents trying to put together the case. Those people
worked like hell trying to put together those cases and were frus-
trated. And when I was locked out they came, to a person, to my
support and they are being brutally punished now for that. But if
you want to figure out what happened in Texas, go down and talk
to those people and they will take you case by case, memo by memo
on each case of what was happening.
Senator Kerry. I think you hit the nail on the head. I mean, I
can tell you and I think I have had this conversation a little bit
with some folks here previously in discussing this issue. But, you
know, there is a difference between a legitimate investigation and
a lot of what we see in this process. We saw that in BCCI, we saw
it in a lot of narcotics efforts 5 or 6 years ago. You know, there is
60
just a distinction between saying we're looking at something in a
legitimate aggressive effort that issues subpoenas, calls people in,
and sends out a message of its intent to get to the bottom of some-
thing.
I mean, I have seen it. I have presented evidence to a grand jury
and I know the difference of what you can do if you're plotting
carefully and thinking carefully with a strategy of where you sub-
mit a subpoena when and how you're going about building that
trail that you've talked about. That just has never happened in
this. It hasn't happened.
Billions and billions of dollars, an extraordinarily obvious politi-
cal interconnecting network. And somehow, somewhere, this thing
got shut down. I think, you know, I'm not one of those who leaps
to theories around here, but I think it's one of the great untold as
yet, un-fully discovered, and unwritten about coverups and there
was a lot of very careful obfuscation that targeted other folks and
did a lot of other things to kind of cloud the trail during a period
of time here.
But, you know, when somebody of your capabilities is telling us
a story that you are handling 73 percent of this stuff and you've
got three subpoenas out in X number of cases, I am frankly mind
boggled when I think about what the repercussions of that are to
the taxpaying citizens of this country, not to mention just the sys-
tem.
You know, all of you are just living testimony to the lack of credi-
bility in the system today.
The CHAraMAN. And more than that, it goes back to this question
of how much of this is just sheer incompetence and how much of
it is deliberate tanking of serious effort, because that is obstruction
of justice. Laws were written to empower you to do exactly what
you were trying to do. We appropriated money to provide for the
kind of legal talent that you represent to go out and do exactly
what you were doing, and that's to follow these money trails, track
down these cases and get the financial recoveries.
So to the extent that that was thwarted, it was thwarted con-
sciously and actively by anybody up and down the chain of com-
mand, that clearly obstructs the process of justice that we had set
in motion. That's not — that can't be excused by just sheer incom-
petence or stupidity. You're describing a pattern that, to me, has
to be a conscious pattern, not just a random accidental pattern.
Mr. BURNSIDE. Senator, to the extent that you're following that
trail, I was just a line attorney, so I don't know what was happen-
ing at the higher levels, but if you take a look at that reorganiza-
tion that happened in 1992 and you look at what that did to Texas
and a number of turnovers that you had on cases
Senator Kerry. Let me interrupt you there. It's my understand-
ing that they're shutting down the PLS now with a second reorga-
nization. And even as we're sitting here there is a process that is
going to diminish even what is left. Is that accurate?
Mr. BURNSIDE. That's exactly right.
Senator Kerry. So even as we sit here there's another sort of
process going on that is going to diminish the ability to get the re-
patriation of money back. Is that right?
61
Mr. BURNSIDE. That's correct. Senator, to my count, there have
been five reorganizations, some major and some minor, on the at-
torneys handhng the S&L cases in Texas. Five reorganizations.
What kind of continuity do you have on those cases?
Senator Metzenbaum. Mr. Bumside, isn't it a fact that the man
who hired you, Arturo Vero-Rojas, is he the man that fired you?
Mr. BURNSIDE. He didn't fire me. They just locked me out. I was
going to resign anyway.
Senator Metzenbaum. But he's the one that failed to give you co-
operation so you could go forward?
Mr. BuRNsroE. That's right.
Senator Metzenbaum. Where is he now?
Mr. BURNSIDE. It's my understanding that he's been detailed to
Washington. I don't know what he's doing here. My immediate su-
perior in Dallas was subsequently transferred to Washington and
I understand the RTC places a $55,000 cost for each and every
transfer. They're transferring the people out of there. I don't know
why, but they are transferring people out of there.
Senator Metzenbaum. They're bringing them here to Washing-
ton?
Mr. Burnside. And bringing them to Washington.
Mr. Mangelsdorf. Good luck, Mr. Metzenbaum.
Senator Metzenbaum. Mr. Chairman.
The Chairman. Let me just say this to you, Howard, and to John
and all of you, because we happen to care very much about what
we're talking about here and we've got a nominee pending for the
RTC. I don't intend to confirm anybody, I don't care who it is, until
we have a plan here that's going to put a stop to this kind of thing,
period, once and for all, and I want the attorney general to be part
of it, as we have discussed, and every other official of the Govern-
ment needs to be part of it. We are not going to just roll along with
this kind of a situation out there and good people trying to do their
jobs being harassed, thwarted, locked out, blocked. And nobody
ever able to quite figure out where the signals are coming from to
put in the fix. But we have to figure out a way to change that.
Senator Metzenbaum. We wHl work together to get the Depart-
ment of Justice into this matter. But I want to say to the chairman
something I commented on earlier.
The present administration is not doing all that they could do or
should do with respect to these issues. As a matter of fact, the
present administration has opposed the extension of the statute of
limitations in the matter of making it retroactive. I do not give
them any credit for that. It is my considered opinion that the Presi-
dent does not have the slightest idea what's going on.
But there are people in positions of high authority who have ac-
tually opposed the effort to extend the statute. And when I have
gone to the floor on that issue in the past, both you and Senator
Kerry have been very supportive. But the administration has not
been.
We have a difference of opinion with the House because the
House didn't accept it, and how could we expect them to when the
administration was not doing its job.
So I say that, although I support the President, he doesn't know
that this is going on. The Vice President doesn't know. But those
62
who do know, and I will be pleased to tell you who they are pri-
vately, they know and they haven't been on the side of the Tax-
payers. They have been on the side of protecting the officers and
directors who have ripped off the system.
The Chairman. Mr. Bumside, have you finished or do you have
more?
Mr. BuRNSroE. I have a few more remarks. I will just briefly con-
clude.
The failure to investigate is obviously the biggest problem. The
second problem was the reorganizations. You Ibiow, when you're
putting together groups of people to go in and investigate billion
dollar thrifts, you just can't simply pass the file on, no matter how
good the people are.
The Chairman. Might this not have been deliberate? We had
hearings in here before. We've talked with some of the other people
who are witnesses here today and the clear appearance to me, at
least, was that some of these reorganizations were actually a kind
of a cover to get people like you off these key cases at key times.
In other words, we've heard that from other people who were out
there trying to do these kinds of things, who feel as if their job as-
signments were being shuffled at a particular time, essentially to
thwart them from getting their job done, and it was being done in
the name of reorganization, which gave it kind of a surface legit-
imacy. But it was basically to yank people off cases because they
were about to nail somebody.
Mr. BURNSIDE. I can't disagree. There was certainly a vendetta
in the RTC to get rid of professional liability attorneys.
The Chairman. You finish any other remarks you want to make
and then I want togo to our next witnesses here.
Mr. BURNSIDE. The last thing that I would say is, I was locked
out. I am gone. I am going back to practice with my old law firm,
so this is over for me.
But there are good people down there in Dallas who have stood
by me and have come forward and have cooperated with everybody
that's come down there. They have cooperated with the GAO, they
did everj^hing they were supposed to internally. They cooperated
with your staffs, and they are being brutally punished down there
for standing up and saying this is wrong.
To give you an example, and this is so absurd, there were three
managers in the investigations unit down there who showed up as
a group and supported me. After this whole thing was over, they
sent in the people from Kansas City to supervise these people and
now they've got nine management positions down there.
To go from three managers to nine managers and they're cutting
back staff You think those people aren't being punished? Talk
about reinventing Government, you know, downsizing your staff
and tripling your management, that makes no sense.
The Chairman. I think we'll call those three up here and give
them a chance to get out and tell their story in the light of day.
Mr. BURNSIDE. They'd be wonderful witnesses.
The Chairman. I suspect they will.
I want to be able to juxtapose what they say to the managers
who have been making your life miserable. I want to yank them
out into the light of day too.
63
Mr. BURNSIDE. The last thing I would like to do is just conclude
with this comment. After I went back to St. Louis, I received a
package at my law firm. I opened it up and inside was a simple
portrait. It had a simple black fi'ame, a white background, and let-
ters saying "he who is silent is understood to consent." And I got
that from the Dallas management of the investigations unit. I did
not consent. The people down in the investigations unit did not
consent.
The Chairman. I also want to use this moment through you, to
you and your colleagues and anybody else out there in the ranks,
that we want all the information that anybody has. I want people
coming forward. I want them to come forward anonymously, if they
are more comfortable with that, to give us what facts and informa-
tion they have. I want those who are willing to come forward open-
ly with whatever they have.
But I want to make this an open request and invitation to every
person out in the RTC that has other factual information of this
kind that would fit these patterns with times, names, places, cir-
cumstances to get that information to us. That's what I am asking
for. This is a blanket request out through you to all your colleagues
out there so we can assemble as much of this information as we
possibly can.
Mr. ROMER. I would like to add iust one comment to him, since
I have dealt considerably with the legal department that he's talk-
ing about.
The general policy was, if you had a simple one-page contract,
you take it down to legal and they'd assign it to an outside firm
and in a few weeks or days it would come back and they'd OK it
and they'd bring it back to you. But one that I'd like to point out
significantly, when I was refusing to give a contract to a vice presi-
dent of a savings and loan and they called me in and they said,
you can go ahead, and I said, over my dead body I'll give them a
contract because they're illegal.
I was called over to an outside law firm to discuss, you know,
why I was doing this. And I said, well, I was in charge of the reg-
istration. It says in 1606 you've got to list any savings and loan
that you were in in the last 5 years, you've got to write it down
and give the list. And I said, that's what they didn't do. In the
verbal and the whole thing, they covered it all the way.
Chicago was forward enough to turn them down, but Dallas
wasn't. They had too many friends down there.
But, she says, that's not right because, yes, it does say you have
to list, you know, the 5 years. They're listed on the front of the pro-
f-am because they own the program. So they're listed over here,
ut it doesn't say anything about savings and loans. She said, no,
it doesn't say that. It says you have to have them on a list some-
where.
I just threw up my hands and went away. That was not the in-
tent. The intent of the law was to list if you've been in a savings
and loan for 5 years, not just listed on a back page with a list of
people, of employees, that doesn't cover it. That is not the intent
of the 1606 written by Congress, but that's the way it was inter-
preted by outside law firms. And most of our attorneys assigned
the work outside and served as clerks.
64
The Chairman. We must in the interest of time go forward now.
Mr. Pederson, you've been here before. You were a very important
and helpful witness the last time. We told you we were going to
follow up on this. We hope today's hearing is evidence of the fact
that we meant what we said.
Then we want to hear from Ms. Taylor, who has also testified
here before and we have been grateful for that.
And, finally, Mr. John Waechter will be our last witness.
Go ahead, Mr. Pederson.
TESTIMONY OF BRUCE J. PEDERSON, RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION, ATTORNEY, FORMERLY IN RTC PLS PRO-
GRAM, DENVER, CO
Mr. Pederson. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I wish we could meet
under more pleasant circumstances than we've had the last 2
years.
I do want to thank you and the committee for your continued in-
terest. I think it has been considerable and significant. It has
played a major role in my ability to stay on the RTC payroll.
I also want to express my gratitude to Senator Metzenbaum for
being here today, as well as to Congresswoman Schroeder, both of
whom also have taken an active interest in the issues and people
involved.
They tell me today is the first day of fall. I want to tell you that
I come from a slightly different season of the year. I come from a
very long, cold, and dark winter, a winter of retaliation at the RTC.
For the last 12 to 15 months, my life has been a living hell at this
agency. They have done everything they could to drive me out of
the agency or to trump up charges that would enable them to dis-
cipline me and hopefully fire me.
I come today with two messages. Message one is that there is
rampant retaliation at this agency. This panel has heard eloquent
testimony for that proposition. Those who think on their own at the
RTC are suspect. Those who question authority are punished. And,
Grod forbid, those who dissent are crushed.
I know from my personal experience, having ridden my bicycle
up to the Tienamin Square at RTC that management's tanks roll
freely and with wild abandon. It is a sick and dysfunctional cor-
porate culture which stifles dissent and employee efforts to improve
the system.
Message two is, we need accoimtability. I think Senator Sasser
had a most appropriate term earlier this morning. We need "zero
tolerance" for the kind of abysmal conduct which management en-
gages in to punish people who, as loyal public servants, are trying
to improve the system.
If this agency can't be reinvented with more accountability then,
I submit, it ought to be killed. Take its vital programs and give
them over to a more responsible agency, which has the mature
management team in place to handle these programs in the best
interests of the Taxpayer.
By way of brief background, I think it is already well known that
I was here last year on August 11, 1992, together with Ms. Taylor
and Mr. Bradley Smolkin testifying before this committee in open
session that the RTC's reorganization in 1992 gutted the Profes-
65
sional Liability Program. We later followed up with a detailed 53-
page rebuttal statement in November 1992, rebutting each and
every one of the RTC's flimsy excuses and rationales for what went
down.
We also note with some degree of bittersweet satisfaction that,
since those events, two independent authorities have come in and
substantially vindicated our testimony from last year. The GAO
submitted a report earlier this summer and the RTC Inspector
General, regardless of its problems, couldn't ignore the evidence
that the program was substantially compromised and that future
claims were placed at risk with the arbitrary and ill-advised reor-
ganization of PLS that went down in 1992.
We told you what was coming, but I think the most eloquent tes-
timony this committee could receive has just come from Mr.
Burnside. He didn't tell you what was coming. He told you what
came. And now you know how the RTC operates and how they tell
this committee one thing and proceed to do another. They can tell
you they haven't missed a deadline, but now you know why they
can make that flimsy and feeble statement. They don't bother to in-
vestigate the claims.
Senator Kerry, you're right on. There is an untold story here and
we continue to make what efforts we can with our meager re-
sources to fill in those gaps. There's a lot that ought to be found
out about an organized lobby out there that's doing everything in
its power to put sticks in the wheels of the FDIC and the RTC's
Professional Liability Sections in their efforts to recover money for
Taxpayers.
Senator Metzenbaum has referred to a trend in the State legisla-
tures to pass statutes which are going to water down the standards
of liability. That's yet one more piece in the mosaic which has
formed over the last year which allows us to continue making the
argument and raising this issue.
Someone earlier this morning made the comment, "judge people's
intent by the results of their actions." I think that's damn good ad-
vice for the RTC. Look at what the results have produced, and I
think that will tell you a lot about their original intentions.
I also add by way of footnote that I have had the honor to serve
as Mr. Bumside's grievance representative while he was still em-
ployed at the RTC. Notwithstanding the shabby treatment which
Ms. Taylor and I have received, I was still shocked by the disgust-
ing conduct which he received from management in Dallas in lock-
ing him out, effectively forcing him out of the agency a mere few
days after he had openly cooperated with a GAO investigation, an
obligation which I think any public servant has.
With respect to the detailed messages I have, number one, retal-
iation is rampant. Ms. Taylor is going to provide you with a de-
tailed list of all the examples we have endured, and I won't belabor
them right now. I simply want to remind you that when you hear
that list, in the back of your mind, remember that every time man-
agernent retaliates against an RTC employee Taxpayer dollars are
funding their unacceptable behavior.
I do want to speak very briefly on one type of retaliation, though,
which this committee, as a matter of public policy, ought to more
closely scrutinize. In addition to the laundry list of reprisals we
66
have endured, this committee is also aware of the break-in of my
computer at the RTC. It seems like management wanted Watergate
returned back to the headlines. They effectively, without my con-
sent, without a court order, without a search warrant, got access
to my WordPerfect files, files which contained work product and
thought process, if you will, and correspondence which I had writ-
ten between myself and Ms. Taylor and a variety of oversight enti-
ties. They included the RTC Office of Inspector General and a law
enforcement agency. They included this very committee and its
staffers. They included the General Accounting Office, and they in-
cluded Congresswoman Schroeder's office.
All of those work products concerned public policy issues, whis-
tleblowing efforts on our part, and a general attempt to improve
the operation of the RTC.
Management at the RTC saw fit to have free license to just wade
in and help themselves. I was always intrigued, whatever the
trumped up reason was that they have given this committee and
others for doing what they did, why they never came to me and
simply asked me, "could we please have a copy of the XYZ file in
your WordPerfect which we think has to do with a particular sub-
ject." That would have been too decent gmd up front.
Instead, they had to do it in, I guess, the middle of the night or
after hours, behind my back. It raises issues of criminal violations
of wire tap statutes that are designed to govern unauthorized ac-
cess to computers. It raises profound constitutional issues and
rights to privacy which may have been violated in this case.
One of the exhibits to the joint statement which Ms. Taylor and
I have provided the committee today consists of a detailed memo-
randum I composed last spring detailing many of these legal is-
sues. And finally there are the public policy issues.
What does this say about Government acting as a "Big Brother"
with respect to all Federal employees? Are we going to allow mana-
gerial prerogative, whatever that might be, to be stretched to allow
any manager to retaliate against a given employee with this tool?
I think not. And what does it say about law enforcement agencies
and their abilities to work with cooperative witnesses?
My products for the IG were stolen by management, the very tar-
gets of my concern. This committee and others on the Hill have had
their relationship with me interfered with by the actions of RTC
management.
I hold in my hsuid a memo which I wrote to Congresswoman
Schroeder's office on March 12, 1993. To the best Ms. Taylor and
I can determine, that's the exact day when my computer was bro-
ken into by RTC management. I don't know whether they got a
copy of this document or not.
The point is, they were traipsing through some pretty sensitive
stuff which I don't think they had a right to look at. I think if this
conduct is either sanctioned or unquestioned, it can only encourage
a grotesque chilling effect on all public employees.
Message two: Accountability.
The system is broken and the fact that everything you're about
to hear from Ms. Taylor could go down is quite persuasive with re-
spect to showing what's wrong right now.
67
First of all, you've got dysfunctional management. I hope this
committee, in confirming wnomever becomes uie next CEO of the
RTC, will pay close attention to the culture of deception which
lower ranked managers freely engage in at present at the RTC.
They are spin control artists in the truest sense of the word. I hope
that vou will not be deluded by their efforts to backfill, their efforts
to tell you that here are all the facts and at the same time they
will be leaving out certain key elements. Take a very jaundiced
view to what they tell you based on today's testimony. I think you
know why.
The grievance system at the RTC is horribly broken. Mr.
Burnside provided you with an elegant example. We, too, have gone
through that system to no avail. It needs to be junked. It either
needs to be replaced with an ombudsman, an administrative law
judge, or some true legitimate third party who will be there to hear
both sides of the story. At present, it's a game played by manage-
ment for the benefit of management.
The OIG has its own problems. Its focus, based on our experi-
ence, seems to be confined narrowly to only criminal issues or easy-
to-prove cases involving time and attendance.
I will offer Mr. Romer to my right as an example of that mind
set.
We believe that the IG does not consider its mandate to include
protection of whistleblowers. Whether that's legally supportable or
not isn't the issue. It ought to be, and I think Congress through
its statutory amendments can change that.
We also have been told by IG agents that they can never even
recommend actions to agency management and, if they could,
there's no way to enforce it. Perhaps there are ways we can change
that with some well placed statutory changes.
With respect to whistleblowers, we know that the Merit Systems
Protection Board and the Office of Special Counsel jurisdictionally
cannot address RTC employee whistleblowers. They are barred by
statute. We recommend amendments to cure that. We also heartily
endorse language now contained in the Senate Fimding Bill de-
signed to broaden whistleblower protections to RTC employees. At
present, those protections are limited only to reports of violations
of law. They ought to be expanded to include waste, fraud, and
abuse which are all activities that cost the Taxpayer billions of dol-
lars, but which may not necessarily rise to the level of criminal ac-
tivity.
I will conclude, in the interests of time, Mr. Chairman. Earlier,
you expressed interest in Exhibit 6 to our written statement. We
will be happy to take questions on that if you like with respect to
steering of legal contracts to friends and buddies of legal division
managers.
I will just conclude by saying this: In my opinion, the members
of this witness panel to the right and left of Ms. Taylor and I are
real American heroes. Unlike us who came last year and for whom
it's too late to do anything about our retaliation, these people came
here today to tell you their stories. They came knowing what hap-
pened to us, in spite of knowing how we had been beaten by the
RTC. They still had the guts to come here today. And I am in deep
respect of that. I think the committee has well recognized that fact.
68
Over the past months, people have asked me, how do you keep
going, how do you keep trying to be the shadow of RTC manage-
ment, to be their conscience and to hold them accountable? I will
tell you, that's a very difficult task. But I have kept a copy of this
card up on my desk in my office. It's a Chinese character, which
translates roughly with the following expression: "Crisis is oppor-
tunity."
This agency is in profound crisis. The waste, fraud, and mis-
management that you've heard about today pervades almost eveiy
program in the agency. But I think at the same time, if we look
at it from a more positive angle, it's a good opportunity for this
committee and the new administration's UEO, whomever that hap-
pens to be, to "take the bull by the horns" to try to restore account-
ability. The Taxpayer and the American people require no less.
The Chairman. Thank you very much.
Ms. Taylor.
TESTIMONY OF JACQUELINE P. TAYLOR, RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION, ATTORNEY, RTC PLS PROGRAM, DENVER, CO
Ms. Taylor. I want to thank you, Mr. Chairman, and the com-
mittee for inviting me here today. I would also like to thank Sen-
ator Metzenbaum for his continuing interest, and Congresswoman
Schroeder for hers. All of you have stood between Bruce and I and
disaster, at the RTC, over the last year as the RTC management
attempted to get rid of us.
By way of briefly explaining my background, I have been a prac-
ticing lawyer for over 15 years, both in Government and in the pri-
vate sector. I have been at the RTC since August 1991, when I was
appointed the Denver field office's Professional Liability Section
chief.
I served in that capacity imtil May 1992, at which time the dis-
astrous reorganization of the Professional Liability Section oc-
curred at the RTC. You heard eloquent discussion from Mr.
Burnside describing the ultimate results of that reorganization. His
comments echoed many of those that Bruce Pederson and I made
last year when we testified to you.
When we testified to you last year, when I was here last year in
this committee room, I told you about the Taxpayers losing hun-
dreds of millions of dollars to waste, fraud, and aouse as the Pro-
fessional Liability Section was being reorganized. Today, unfortu-
nately, I am here again. And this time I am here to tell you about
waste, fraud, and abuse due to the retaliation against Bruce
Pederson and I and against others who question the programs and
practices of the RTC.
RTC's pattern is to kill the messenger instead of focusing on the
problem. We have heard eloquent testimony from the people here,
some of whom have been dismissed for questioning RTC's practices.
RTC management has thrown everything they could at Bruce and
I over the last year in attempting to kill us. Like Nero, RTC contin-
ued to fiddle while the Taxpayers' money was being burned.
The RTC's behavior is chilling. It chills people speaking out. It
chills the Senate committee's ability to find out what is going on
in the agencies that Congress has created and which are supposed
to be accountable to the Taxpayers.
69
RTC management used a variety of tactics against us and
against others in order to chill our dissent, in order to chill our
questions. RTC management used tactics to shut us up, shut us
out, and shoot us down. This creates silence.
And yet some people, the people who sit at this table, have had
the courage to come forward. Like Mr. Pederson, I commend them.
I implore you to stop the abuse. Do not let happen to them what
has happened to Bruce and to me.
In an effort to get ready for this testimony, I decided that some-
times you can tell what is going on by looking at patterns. The
process of retaliating against Bruce and I for our testimony in-
volves patterns. The retaliation has come from many directions and
was of many different types. In the process of looking at those pat-
terns, I prepared a time line which is based upon my notes and the
documents that are in my possession. The time line shows what
has been going on and what has been aimed at Bruce Pederson and
at me over the last year-and-a-half since we testified to you and
since the reorganization occurred at the RTC.
The time line is in very small print. Bruce and I have attached
it to our written statements to you. It is over 60 pages long. It has
over 300 entries in it, and it is not all inclusive. It shows extreme
patterns and multiple versions of abuse and retaliation aimed at
us. It is my opinion that it was aimed at us because we had the
courage to step up and say what is going on at the RTC and what
is happening to the Taxpayers' interests.
I recommend that you read just a couple of pages. I recognize
this is a long document. I mean, it's going to be difficult for anyone
to peruse this. It will take hours. And this is what has been going
on just to Bruce and I. Think of the money. Think of the loss of
money. Think of the loss of morale. Think of the impetus and the
impediments that this behavior throws up against the other people
at the RTC, who also have stories to tell.
Some of the types of abuse they have thrown at us — ^There are
so many I won't bore you with the list. Some of the more important
ones and the ones that I think you will see the negative impact on
Bruce and I, are for instance when we were banished from our
peers for months on end. At one point, we even received a memo
that told us we would be the only two employees in the RTC on
two floors, two empty floors, of a large, downtown Denver office
building. We were told that we were to forward our telephones to
a receptionist in another building because there would be no one
in our building to answer our phones if we were using them.
You can imagine what this means if we got an emergency phone
call. I swear, we could have had a heart attack in that building and
no one would have found us for days. We were going to be the only
two people on these two large empty office floors for an indefinite
time.
RTC turned around and later rescinded this. But first, they gave
us this notice. They told us this was our fate. Then they turned
aroxmd and they backed off of it. It was like the hostages where
they tell you the/re going to shoot you. They put the gun to your
head. They click it and there's a blank in it. We went through the
feelings of utter abandonment and ostracism that occurred when
they told us that was our indefinite fate and we sat there for a
70
week by ourselves. There was one administrative person that
would come on occasion. But basically, it was just Bruce and I.
Senator Kerry. So you spent a week there on these two floors?
Ms. Taylor. And we were told it was going to be indefinite.
There was no time limit placed on it.
The Chairman. Sort of solitary confinement.
Ms. Taylor. Exactly. We had been banished all over Denver
prior to that. From building to building, we were always the only
members of the only section of the legal department. Our section
consisted, at its maximum, of 10 members of the legal department.
More often than not, it was more like only four or five lawyers that
were on the pull-back Ust. They would move us from building to
building to keep us away fi-om the rest of the legal department.
When we finally were invited to return to our brethren in the
legal department after our little exile totally by ourselves, it was
late November 1992. It was shortly after the election. Then, they
decided to physically return us.
After that, the problems continued. When I was invited back, I
had a secretary come up to me and tell me
Senator Kerry. When was it in November that you were moved
back?
Ms. Taylor. We were literally moved back — it's on the time
line — my recollection is it was a Monday, which I believe was No-
vember 24. We were told about our move back to the legal depart-
ment, I believe, it was the previous Thursday evening. That was
the week of Thanksgiving, by the way.
The Chairman. And the national election had just happened?
Ms. Taylor. It had just happened, that's correct. And we had
just turned in our testimony to this committee.
When we were returned to the arms of the legal department, I
was told by at least one clerical worker, a secretary in the office,
that she had been approached by management and asked to keep
track of my comings and goings. In other words, I was being sub-
jected to physical surveillance.
She said, no. She said she didn't think that was right. But she
wanted me to know because there would be others that probably
had said yes.
Our privacy was invaded in multiple forms. I was told by others
in the legal department that our telephone calls during this entire
period, to and ft"om us, to the extent that they could be tracked,
the numbers were monitored — and I am not aware of the computer
system. I know that our outgoing phone calls are all tracked. Ap-
parently there is some mechanism for tracking incoming phone
calls also. Nonetheless, I was told that this tracking system was in
place and that they were watching very closely to see who Mr.
Pederson and I were talking to, to see who our friends and support-
ers were, and who we were in contact with.
Our mail was tampered with. I doubt that there was a single
piece of mail that we received over that entire period of time that
had not been opened and routed to others prior to us even knowing
that it existed.
I had an EEO claim filed against this agency and the very man-
agement that I was complaining about was reviewing my mail.
They had admitted it in front of other people.
71
One of the procedural things that occurred during this period of
time was that I had to appeal my EEO action within a specific pe-
riod of time from the time I received notice by mail. RTC managers
took my EEO mail and passed it to manager after manager. The
notice was ultimately found in another manager's office, on his
desk, opened and reviewed. The secretary who gave me that mail
was transferred out of the Professional Liability Section imme-
diately upon them finding out that she had done this and after I
had just gone to the OIG. She resigned in disgust from the RTC.
There are multiple other employees who have been retaliated
against for assisting, cooperating, or being seen with Bruce
Pederson or with me. It's guilt by association when it comes to
Bruce and Jackie. We have had friends in professional positions in
other departments, as well as in the legal department, threatened
with their jobs for being seen with us. One person was told that
he was associating with the enemy and when you lay down with
dogs you get up with fleas. And he was talking about me, the per-
son that made that comment. I was the dog and the other man was
going to get the fleas.
We have been bogged down in interminable grievance processes,
which is grievance by surprise. The grievance procedures at the
RTC are very unclear at best and they do not give any kind of pro-
cedural protections.
The RTC has had a history in its grievance process of stalling
and stalling and failing to discuss anything with us. Then RTC
turns around and imposes impossible deadlines on us. Deadlines
that take away any rights we would have or any remedies of re-
dress we would have from the process.
My EEO claim includes the fact that when I was the PLS section
chief under John Beaty, I was one of seven, I believe, women man-
agers. After the 1992 reorganization, I filed an EEO complaint
based on the fact that only one female manager remained in the
Professional Liability Section. The RTC management has resisted
throughout all of this, the attempts by the EEO office to investigate
this claim and my attempts to seek information related to it.
In one instance, right after the presidential election when I had
just returned to the legal department, I asked the administrative
unit, in writing, multiple times, to provide me with time and at-
tendance reports from May through November so that I could dem-
onstrate to the EEO how much time I had been forced to take off
to pursue the EEO claim, I also wanted a copy of my current job
description.
RTC told me, no. They were much too busy to give me what I
had asked for. They would not even give me a deadline as to when
I could get this information. I told the EEO office this. When EEO
asked for the same information, RTC management told the EEO of-
fice the same thing and refused to give them the information.
The thing that was very interesting is that during this very same
period of time — Bruce Pederson and I worked very late on many
nights. During this time, that same administrative legal depart-
ment office was so busy shredding documents and taking out bag
after bag of shredded documents in the evenings and on weekends,
that they didn't have time to respond to my or the EEO investiga-
72
tors' requests for information. I don't know what was in those docu-
ments they were shredding.
Senator Kerry. When did — ^the shredding, I gather, took place
right after
Ms. Taylor. It took place over the course of a number of weeks.
It started — I don't know when it started because we were in an-
other building. But when we were moved back to the legal depart-
ment in November, that week of Thanksgiving, it was ongoing. And
it continued through December.
Senator Kerry. For the 2-week period or so after the election?
Ms. Taylor. Yes, until late December or early January.
Senator Kerry. Was this a regular practice down there?
Ms. Taylor. I had never observed it. I don't know. I am not a
member of the administrative unit. But it seemed excessive and it
was happening a lot in the evenings and on weekends.
Mr. Pederson. If I could just add. Senator Kerry, it came to our
attention largely because when we came back to the main building,
management located me in an office that had been previously used
to store cardboard boxes. Thev kindly took the boxes out, then sub-
stituted me. This office was located right across the hallway from
the shredder room, which also had a Xerox machine. I had occasion
to personally witness high volumes of shredding going on at all
times of the day and on those days when Jackie and I would be
staying late at work, doing oversight work, if you will, doing the
IG's work for them. I would witness these administrative employ-
ees carrying in large handfiils of documents and carrying out large
bags of trasn.
Senator Kerry. This is one of those things hanging out there. I
mean, offices all over the Government shred on a daily basis, cor-
rect?
Ms. Taylor. Yes, they do.
Senator Kerry. Was there daily shredding going on?
Ms. Taylor. There is daily shredding going on.
Because of the volume of shredding that Mr. Pederson and I ob-
served on the evenings and weekends at the offices of the Denver
RTC, the legal department, we continued to watch for a period of
time, at least I did, and I believe Bruce did also, afterwards. And
the volume at a certain point decreased.
There is certainly — in the legal department you do shred docu-
ments. This was an unusual amount of document shredding going
on.
Senator Kerry. Are you saying to us that you watched this be-
cause you were particularly struck by the level?
Ms. Taylor. Yes. There are manv fine employees in the RTC and
many of them work long hours or overtime. There are other em-
ployees in the RTC that do not put in more than their duty hours.
This excessive overtime to shred large numbers of documents was
unusual. The people who were doing the shredding were not accus-
tomed to being in the offices that Tate. Mr. Pederson and I know
this because we have always stayed very late.
It was my practice to stay at the office working until 8 or 9
o'clock at night on many nights. So it struck me as strange that
these people were staying as late as they were.
Senator Kerry. Was there any weekend shredding?
73
Ms. Taylor. The way I found out about the weekend shredding
is that on occasion Bruce and I were there. But I also was told
about it by other lawyers within the RTC legal department in Den-
ver. These other lawyers also thought it unusual that these admin-
istrative people were staying around on weekends shredding docu-
ments. I mean, this was like constant, I'm told, shredding of docu-
ments.
The Chairman. Mr. Koszola, you looked to me as if you wanted
to maybe say something at that point.
Mr. Koszola. Not at that point. But the other witnesses, what
they've said so far about the time and attendance subpoenas, the
investigations, I know first hand about the time and attendance in-
vestigations. They tried to stop me from serving a grand jury sub-
poena that was on RTC personnel. They wouldn't give the docu-
ments to the RTC OIG and get a grand jury subpoena. When the
RTC found out that they had a grand jury subpoena, they said it
was too embarrassing and attempted to stop me from serving it.
But I had already served it.
The Chairman. Did you witness any shredding of the kind she's
talking about?
Mr. Koszola. Oh, yes. There was shredding going on when I was
at RTC headquarters regarding Grerald Jacobs. He was already
cleared on an investigation, you know, maybe a week or 10 days
earlier. But they were still investigating him supposedly and shred-
ding documents before I got there. That's what I was told by the
managers there.
The Chairman. Did any of the rest of you run into a burst of
shredding activity of the kind that Ms. Taylor has just talked about
that would have occurred late last year?
Mr. Koszola. There were documents that I know were missing
on sales. They'd sell an asset and a sale could have taken place a
month or two ago and the documents would be gone or there would
be no documentation. They were supposedly shredded.
The Chairman. I want to get to our last witness, so Ms. Taylor
are you nearly finished so we can get Mr. Waechter here?
Mr. Pederson. Mr. Chairman, I just wanted to completely an-
swer Senator Kerry's question.
The other quality about these documents which attracted my at-
tention to the shredding was not only the volume but the fact that
they appeared to be originals. One could see in the trash multicol-
ored types of paper that suggested that entire forms with built-in
carbon type capabilities were being shredded. And so after the vol-
ume became apparent to me, I then poked around in the trash and
that's what came to my attention.
Senator Kerry. You were actually so struck by the volume that
you poked around in the trash it was producing?
Mr. Pederson. That's correct.
Ms. Taylor. They're in these plastic bags. They bag up the
shredded documents in transparent plastic bags. You can see
through the bags what has been shredded. It's obvious. We talked
about it, in fact.
We were so concerned about it that I wrote — I have documentary
evidence at about that time, where I wrote to the EEO office say-
74
ing: **I can understand why they won't give me my information,
they're too busy shredding documents."
And in the March 12 memo to Congresswoman Schroeder's office
that Mr. Pederson has discussed, we again raised the issue of
shredding of documents at the RTC office. It struck us as very un-
usual. I, myself, and everybody else there, if you're in a sensitive
position, occasionally shred documents, but this was unusual.
There were many other types of retaliation, such as geographical
relocations. You're well aware of these, since this committee has
tried to help us in that matter. We were demoted while the very
people that were harassing us were promoted, given large bonuses,
and were subjected to all sorts of praise. They were encouraged by
these rewards.
I mean, the message that the unrestrained retaliation sent to the
rank and file is that these RTC managers were doing right by
harassing Bruce and Jackie.
One of the more difficult ones for me to withstand has been the
slander that has been thrown at me by members of RTC manage-
ment. I hear from people in Washingfton, DC, and other parts of the
country, about outrageous statements made concerning Bruce
Pederson and me. One of the ones that upset me most of all was
made shortly before I decided I was going to take a 2-month unpaid
leave of absence from the RTC because I was just exhausted. The
press office of the RTC told a national reporter that: "He should go
talk to Mr. Pederson because he thinks he's Gandhi."
A comment that Mr. Pederson had made at the Cavallo Award
presentation was that he admired Mahatma Gandhi's mechanisms.
He admired the nonviolent ways that Gandhi approached public
dissent and questioning of improper practices. The press office ap-
parently felt that this was sufficient basis to make what I consider
to be a very slanderous comment to the press about Mr. Pederson.
I could go on and on and on, but I won't bore you with the rest.
The Chairman. We'll put it in the record. I want to read it all.
Ms. Taylor. The time line is in the record. And, like I say, it's
not all inclusive. I just want to beg the committee to help somehow,
either in the confirmation process of Mr. Tate or in the drafting of
legislation, or in any way they can, to halt such retaliatory prac-
tices. Please, please, do not let them do this to the rest of the em-
ployees at the RTC. The committee's work will be so hard if this
continues to go on in Government. There should be zero tolerance
for this behavior.
Also, I really would prefer not to have to come back here again
next year to testify. It's been a long and debilitating process and
I hope that somehow we can correct these problems so this doesn't
have to happen again.
Senator Kerry. We'll just put you all in charge of the RTC.
Ms. Taylor. Thank you.
The Chairman. Mr. Waechter, you're last but by no means least.
We'd like to hear from you now.
75
TESTIMONY OF JOHN WAECHTER, RESOLUTION TRUST COR-
PORATION, COMPUTER SERVICES SPECIALIST, DENVER, CO
Mr. Waechter. Thank you, Mr. Riegle, and your committee, for
providing me this opportunity to testify here before you today. My
name is John Waechter.
As Bruce Pederson stated, I am the systems administrator in
what has been called the Computer Gate scandal.
I worked for the RTC information service unit at the Denver field
office. For almost 3 years, I have been a devoted and highly recog-
nized employee of the RTC. I stand before you today to tell you
about the Computer Gate incident and the actions taken against
me.
My parents brought me up to tell the truth and to accept the con-
sequences. In this Computer Gate situation, I asked myself, why
am I getting fried for telling the truth? Is it guilt by association?
All I had done was blown the whistle on an ethical issue. I had
been cleared of all wrongdoing by the Denver Inspector General's
office, although I have not received any paperwork on this.
This nightmare started March 12, 1993, over 6 months ago. I
was called into the office of the Denver legal assistant general
counsel, Barbara Shangraw. She informed me she was being di-
rected by someone in the Washington, DC, RTC office to retrieve
the files of counsel, Bruce Pederson.
I trusted Barbara Shangraw's knowledge of professional ethics
and morals, not only because of her senior level position but be-
cause I assumed she was a competent lawyer. I was wrong.
I was shocked by this request, given the fact that I knew Bruce
and Barbara were involved in a conflict. I requested an electronic
mail message fi'om Barbara Shangraw before I would fulfill her re-
quest.
After I received her electronic mail request, I proceeded to copy
all of the personal files of Bruce Pederson into Barbara Shangraw's
veiy own directory. After all the files were copied, I began to feel
as if I had just violated the privacy of an individual's rights.
The Chairman. Just take your time. I appreciate the fact that
you are here to tell us this and it's important. Take your time.
Mr. Waechter. I left the offiice for the day and thought about the
situation on my long drive home. I mentioned the story to my wife
who, just as I, felt this was an invasion of someone's rights. My
wife advised me to talk to someone at work on this matter.
I spoke with Jackie Taylor, another counsel of the Denver legal
department, about this situation. She advised me to immediately
report this incident to the Inspector Greneral's office in Denver. The
situation was reported to the IG and, from that time on, my life
and my job have gone bitterly to hell.
Retaliation started almost immediately after someone had leaked
the investigation to Barbara Shangraw. I have been receiving and
continue to receive verbal harassment, removal of job duties and
special tasks, false accusations, denial of overtime, and loss of
training, and I fear my livelihood is in jeopardy. I have been retali-
ated against by management for my actions. My question is, why?
I do not know.
76
In closing, my image of the RTC has been shattered like glass.
I am asking you for your help to pick up these pieces and try to
put them back together again as best as we can possibly do.
Finally, I would like to say I am sorry for not being able to stand
up and say no to something that I believed was wrong, something
that was an act of terrorism to Bruce, of personal terrorism, to
Bruce Pederson. Again, I stress I believed in Barbara Shangraw's
professional ethics and morals and her position that she was cor-
rect in instructing me on what to do.
The Chairman. Let me just tell you, I appreciate your courage
in coming and saying it today. The fact that you've said it today,
I think, says everything that needs to be said. You've said it in a
fashion that makes it clear how you feel. I appreciate your coming
forward. So that is an act of courage. You should feel good about
that and good about yourself And we feel good about your being
here.
Senator Metzenbaum. Mr. Chairman, I feel pretty bad that our
Government — damn it, this is horrible for these people to have to
come before us here and speak out this way. Where the hell is the
RTC? What are they doing? What is the Secretary of the Treasury
and the Assistant Secretary of the Treasury doing? They have been
in charge of this thing for months and all they do is nothing, as
far as this is concerned. This is one of the most embarrassing mo-
ments that I have experienced since I have been in Government,
when people have to come here and talk out about how they have
been treated on their iob.
I just think this is norrible. And I demand that our Government
who, not some months from now, not some weeks from now, but
now should clean house with some of these people who have come
down so hard on these decent people.
Senator Kerry. Let me ask you a question, John, if I can. Just
tell me a little about yourself. What's your background?
Mr. Waechter, My backgpround is almost 11 years in the com-
puter industry. I had to drop out of college because both of my par-
ents had passed away and I could not afford to finance myself. I
took an entry level job in hopes that I would strive to make ends
meet and to keep moving on.
I have never been subjected to such nonsense before in my life.
I just can't understand why this takes place and there is no protec-
tion for us. As Bruce had stated, the whistleblower act does not do
anything for RTC. I was informed after I had spoken to the IG that
this was the case.
Senator Kerry. Let me just say to you, I share Senator Metzen-
baum's feelings. For somebody who wants to make the system work
and somebody who has 11 years of experience and tries to abide
by the rules, to have to come before a Senate committee and drag
out of your guts a public apology to another employee for some-
thing that you knew and felt was wrong at the time
The Chairman. And had been ordered to do.
Senator Kerry. — and had been ordered to do, is embarrassing
and disgraceful for the Grovernment.
Yet you folks are up here in agony while the folks who are perse-
cuting you, literally, are being promoted and nmning around with-
out any retaliation.
77
Now I don't know how others feel, but I think they're the folks
who ought to be fired.
Mr. Waechter. Absolutely.
Senator Kerry. Something is wrong here. I understand that now
they are not, but the accountability process, something is askew
here. Even if there was a legitimacy, let's say, to some gripe they
had about your performance or your work product or maybe there
was, you know, even if there were, this is not the way you go about
the process of resolving it in any normal management structure.
Mr. Waechter. And unfortunately, I have been removed from
my job that I did like. I enjoyed working with the legal department.
Senator Kerry. What was the reason they gave you for removing
you?
Mr. Waechter. Because Barbara Shangraw had started to make
false accusations and called Mr. Del Arnold. I am not sure of his
title. And said, he is a security risk for the legal department. I
want him out now.
Senator Kerry. Now the legal department gave a rationale, ap-
parently, of supposed probable cause for the intrusion into your
computer. Is that correct?
Mr. Pederson. That's correct. Senator, although the rationale
seems to change. Every time one gets shot down, they come up
with a new one.
Senator Kerry. The original rationale for the intrusion was that
you supposedly had done something — ^personal use or something. Is
that correct?
Mr. Pederson. The original rationale was that a hard copy of an
E-Mail I had written was found lying around on a printer. That E-
Mail contained some critical comments, my personal opinion about
then CEO Casey's representations to Congress about how quickly
he could shut down RTC. Attached to that E-Mail and referenced
on there was a copy of an article reporting that testimony by Mr.
Casey.
As I was then told by Ms. Shangraw, she believed that this E-
Mail, this hard copy, somehow raised issues of my loyalty or per-
formance as an employee which then entitled her under this vague
notion of managerial prerogative to suddenly copy each and every
one of my WordPerfect files.
The simple answer would have been to just come to me and say,
"Hey, I understand you wrote this, did you?" I would have said,
"Yes, and if you would like a copy I'll print one out for you."
Ms. Taylor. I would like to add also that the E-Mail attached
congressional testimony. The management of the RTC legal depart-
ment, Ms. Shangraw, as well as others, fairly regularly send
around that same kind of testimony attached to E-Mail and hard
copy memos and things. And so, if it's not a personal use of RTC
computers to inform employees of congressional testimony by the
management of RTC, I don't imderstand how it's a personal use for
Mr. Pederson. We were talking about RTC issues with RTC em-
ployees.
Mr. Waechter. And why is the assistant general counsel worried
about personal files? That was the second excuse given, that he
had personal files in his directory. That's my job. That's my job to
clean up the network, not hers. She could tell me that there is per-
78
sonal files on the network and I could go ahead and verify that and
pass it on to management. But it's not her responsibility. That's an
outright lie. It's a way to go around people to make up an excuse
to pinpoint them and try and remove them to just retaliate.
Senator Kerry. I think it's very obvious when you have people
geographically relocated and all the other things your time line
shows. There s not much mystery as to what was going on,
I think the saddest part of it is that the motivations were not
somehow to prevent the RTC from doing what it's supposed to do.
Your motivations, all of you, were to get the job done better. And
what's so remarkable about this is that those who seemed to favor
the inefficiency and incompetence and the waste have stood in your
way.
This is not a management team that has set up a structure that
is seeking constructive criticism or better ways of making this
work. And that is so disturbing it's mind boggling.
The Chairman. Senator Kerry, if you will yield at that point, it's
even worse than that. And I think Mr. Burnside has underscored
this in sort of a different way. It's too purposeful to be just gross
incompetence. It's just too purposeful and too focused.
The fact that cases were being tanked and investigative efforts
were being stymied by professional liability attorneys who were
really doing their work, that conveys an intent and a purpose that's
very specific and very clear. We'd have to be fools not to see it.
That, to me, is as disturbing — I mean, everything I've heard is dis-
turbing. But that falls into a different category, because that has
to do with essentially stealing money from the public or allowing
somebody else to get away with it.
You know, just my own view is I have confidence and faith in
this new President. I think if he were sitting here today. President
Clinton, he would be as appalled as we are. No question. He would
be as offended and outraged as the three of us are offended and
outraged. So I have every confidence that he would feel as we feel
in terms of not wanting to tolerate that and getting to the bottom
of it.
So we want to take what you've given us. I'm in the middle of
your comment, so I'll withhold
Senator Kerry. No, no, no. All I wanted to add to that is, Mr.
Chairman, that at the outset of this hearing I said that one of the
problems is that I'jn not sure that a lot of folks have the full view,
at the higher level, of what has been happening over here. I am
confident, obviously, that the President doesn't. I don't know
whether the secretary does or not. I suspect also doesn't. But you
told us today and have given life to what I said at the outset of
this hearing that we wanted to understand, which is what really
are the depths of the problem here.
Now, we've been receiving information here in Congress that we
shouldn't extend the statute or there's no need for review because
deadlines have been met, because sufficient reviews have been con-
ducted. And so, indeed. Secretary Altman, the interim CEO of the
RTC, can write a letter to Congressman Stark regarding his legis-
lation to extend limitations and he says in it that the RTC has
been increasing PLS staff to meet the demands of its workload. I
see you smiling when you hear that.
79
The Secretary of the Treasury, in his capacity of the thrifts, has
further committed to review and recommend improvements in the
organization and the plan recently announced, et cetera, et cetera.
Consequently, the RTC has no need at this time either to revisit
"closed claims" arising from institutions in which the limitations
period has expired, or to extend the limitations period prospec-
tively, as the RTC will continue to meet all upcoming deadlines.
What you have said, Mr. Bumside, and others have said, is that
is totally — ^that is a conclusion based on totally false input. Is that
accurate?
I see all heads nodding.
In point of fact, the deadlines aren't really met, the information
is not real, the reviews are not ftill;^ conducted, and the claims are
closed when in fact they aren't sufficiently investigated. Therefore,
we cannot trust the input to that judgment. Is that accurate?
Mr, Pederson. Senator Kerry, I agree. And if I could just add
to demonstrate the spin control which this committee is experienc-
ing. On March 30, 1993, Acting General Counsel, Richard T.
Aboussie, testified over on the House side before the House Bank-
ing Subcommittee with RTC oversight. In the question and answer
period which followed his statement, he made two interesting state-
ments. One is that they are having terrible difficulties attracting
and recruiting skilled, experienced PLS attorneys. Things have got-
ten so bad that they nave been forced to go back to the FDIC and
beg them for warm bodies which the FDIC promptly refused to do
because they are busy enough, thank you very much. He then also
went on to make a big point about how heavily used subpoenas are
in the legal division's prosecution of professional liability cases.
How can he make those statements and Mr. Altman write that
kind of letter? Someone is not coming clean.
Senator Metzenbaum. Isn't it a fact that Bill Roelle and Lamar
Kellv who have been running the RTC since its inception are still
in place and still running the RTC?
Mr. Henderson. That is correct.
Ms. Taylor. The management at the RTC, for the most extent,
is the exact same management that was in place when Mr.
Pederson and I came here a year-plus ago to tell you what would
happen to the Professional Liability Section £ind tell you what had
already happened in the reorganization. They're the very same peo-
ple in place. The only difference is that we now have the Clinton
administration with some Treasury oversight that has some people
that he appointed. But the RTC itself is the same.
Senator Metzenbaum. Mr. Chairman, that's the reason for my
outburst of dismay that the present administration has not taken
hold of this agency. There is an acting head, Mr. Altman, but the
fact is that Mr. Roelle and Mr. Kelly are still running it just the
same way it was before and that's the reason these people have
this continued sense of frustration.
Ms. Taylor. You can see that the problems at the RTC are
rampant and widespread. I don't know. The Treasury officials have
been good to Mr. Pederson and I in terms of meeting with us to
hear some of our concerns and keeping a continuing dialog. But
they are very few in number and the RTC has many, many prob-
lems and many, many locations. As a consequence, I think it has
80
been very difficult to get their arms around the bad behavior of
management.
And, like this committee, they hear those same stories. Whether
they're true or not, it's my opinion, that many of the stories that
you hear and they hear are untrue when they come from the man-
agement of the RTC. The stories of the management of the RTC
and how well they are behaving is similar to the investigations of
the PLS.
Senator Kerry. Based on the GAO report alone, but coupled with
the corroboration to the GAO report that has come not just from
you but from many other quarters, I fail to understand why the
same management is there. It is absolutely beyond my comprehen-
sion.
There is something in the American Government that when you
waste a lot of money, you can get promoted or you can somehow
stay forever. We do not hold people accountable.
The Chairman. Well, I think there is this great tendency to want
to bury the mistakes in these unmarked graves and to keep it
tidied up for as long as possible until the statute of limitations
runs out or until the focus changes and we've got new issues and
people are washed out or forced out or intimidated out and then
it's forgotten and it's all behind us, I mean, that seems to me to
be the pattern of what we are facing here. The notion that these
cases should not be pursued. I mean, clearly I think they should
be pursued. I think they have to be pursued.
Mr. Romer.
Mr. Romer. The basic thing that I have observed in 3 years is
all the information comes down to the worker level where I was.
There is no way to put back up without getting it rewritten eight
times before it gets to the top. So that information that you have
down here never gets there, where the facts are, because each
layer — and I think there's nine or ten lavers to go through — each
one rewrites it to his own. So the story — ^tnat's how come you've got
this information that he's given the Congress, because it's been re-
written by every level of management.
The Chairman. We're going to conclude now.
With the testimony that you've given us, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 13 wit-
nesses across this table from across the country, different back-
grounds, all people with fine work records that have won awards
at different levels of your professional career and development.
I think what you've given us tods^ is very important and we ob-
viously are very serious about it. This is not a hearing that has
happened by accident. It happened by either your coming or our
convening it and working with you to arrange for your testimony
today.
We will continue to pursue these issues, individually and taken
as a whole.
Senator Metzenbaum, Senator Kerry, and I will consult with one
another and other Members of this committee as to the next steps
that we want to take.
I want to again extend the invitation to every other person who's
out there who has knowledge and information that we should have.
That would be anything along the lines that you've given us today.
That it's important that they bring that forward and give that to
81
us. They can do it either anonymously, if the/re more comfortable
with that, or if they want to give it to us directly and identify
themselves with it, I would prefer to have it done that way. But
I want to again ask that any information anybody has be provided
to us so we can take and fill in more of this picture.
Senator Kerry. Mr. Chairman, before you sign off, let me just
say to all of you, if there are any further instances of interference
or retaliation of any kind, we would like you — expect you — ^to let
this committee know.
I hope people will be on notice that there is a discussion here
about whether or not some of those folks shouldn't be called in here
to account for the measures they have taken thus far. And people
should be on notice that this committee isn't going to tolerate inter-
ference with witnesses that come before the committee.
Second, I would like to just say the staff has worked hard on
this. I would particularly like to single out Jonathan Winer of my
staff who has spent an awful lot of time with all of you, who has
put a lot of energy into helping to understand this issue. And I par-
ticularly appreciate him for his effort.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
The Chairman. I know you want to make one final comment.
Mr. KoszoLA. I appreciate the time.
As far as retaliation, I tried to refinance my house about 6 weeks
ago and the RTC and the FDIC have still refused, after several
written requests and oral requests, to verify that I have been em-
ployed with them. That process normally takes a few days and you
get a response back witnin a week. And they are interfering with
me refinancing with a credit union where I already have an ac-
count to get a Tower interest rate.
But the slander, like what these people have said, I have experi-
enced that myself. All this is true, what they're saying.
The Chairman. Again, thank you all. This has been a very im-
portant hearing day. We will proceed accordingly based on what
you've given us.
The committee stands in recess.
[Whereupon, at 2:35 p.m., the hearing was adjourned.]
[Prepared statements and additional material supplied for the
record follow:]
82
STATEMENT OF SENATOR ALFONSE M. D'AMATO
Mr. Chairman, I would like to thank you for holding this important hearing today.
I would like to also take this opportunity to welcome aU our witnesses, including
our colleague from the House, Representative Pat Schroeder.
Mr. Chairman, this Conmiittee has engaged in a great deal of oversight of the
Resolution Trust Corporation during the RTC's four years of operations. Few can
argue that this attention was unwarranted, as the RTC has frequently made head-
lines due to perceived mismanagement and waste in its operations.
No one can claim that the task that the RTC inherited — cleaning-up the savings
and loan crisis — is an easy one. The RTC inherited a massive, ongoing problem and
had to "hit the ground running." Nevertheless, the RTC is a trustee of the public.
The RTC carries out vital work — ensuring that depositors in failed thrifts have their
hard-earned savings returned. But we must never forget that the money spent re-
solving failed institutions is ultimately taxpayer's money.
Mr. Chairman, we can not allow waste, mismanagement or improprieties to con-
tinue, and we must uncover all evidence of waste and abuse. That is why it is im-
Sortant for us to have hearings like this one; such hesuings raise issues that the
TC must address, and by ad(fressing these issues, improve its operations.
The RTC operations have been the subject of much scrutiny. Testifying before this
Committee last March, Treasury Secretary Bentsen outlined a 9-point plan for im-
proving efllciency, and fighting waste at the RTC. The members of this Committee
and this Chamber incorporated, and expanded upon, the Secretary's plan in the
RTC fiinding legislation that the Senate passed last spring. Included in the legisla-
tion is expanded "whistleblower" protection.
Hopefully, the scrutiny received in hearings like this will help improve RTC oper-
ations through the remainder of the RTC's existence. I look forward to their testi-
mony.
TESTIMONY OF REPRESENTATIVE PATRICIA SCHROEDER
Mr. Chairman, thank you for holding these hearings and for allowing me to tes-
tify. I am honored to be here. I am especially honored because I am in the company
of government employees like Jackie Taylor, Bruce Pederson and others, who risked
their jobs in order to bring to light waste, fraud, and abuse at the Resolution Trust
Corporation (RTC).
I would like to focus on the case of Bruce Pederson and Jackie Taylor. Their sto-
ries, and the stories of all of the other whistleblowers, raise serious concerns about
how whistleblowers are treated. We need to better protect whistleblowers and we
need to hold officials responsible for retaliating against employees.
Bruce and Jackie have raised legitimate questions about the reorganization of the
Professional Liability Section (PLS) and have testified before this committee in the
past. They have worited closely with my office and have cooperated with investiga-
tors from the General Accounting Office and the RTC Office of Inspector General.
Since first raising questions about RTC activities, Jackie and Bruce were de-
moted, isolated in a separate building, and threatened with transfers to Kansas
City. And in the most recent example of what I consider to be retaliation, Bruce's
computer was broken into and his files were copied.
Call me crazy, but breaking into a whistleblower's computer sounds a little like
retaliation. It also compromises ongoing investigations with the General Accounting
Office and the Office of Inspector General, as well as communications with Congres-
sional offices.
That's why I asked the Department of Treasury to investigate the break-in. In Au-
gust, Roger Altman, Interim CEO for the RTC, wrote to me that the investigation
was complete and that, "RTC management did not retaliate against Pederson."
Mr. Chairman, I am not satisfied with this conclusion and I hope you are not sat-
isfied. I hope that the Committee will look into this further.
By the way, I have yet to see the IG report. Maybe you can help me get a copy.
They can't seem to find one to send me.
I also wrote to Attorney General Janet Reno in May concerning the Justice De-
partment's involvement in the decision to break into Mr. Pederson's computer. I am
still waiting for a response from Justice.
Throughout this ordeal, it has been painfully apparent that there are insufficient
protections for employees who woric for the Resolution Trust Corporation and other
government corporations.
83
We are currently working to reform the Federal Employees Whistleblower Protec-
tion law to include government corporation employees. It is little consolation for cur-
rent whistleblowers, but it is a commitment that we can make for future employees.
The other commitment we can make to these employees tmd to taxpayers is to
investigate allegations of waste and abuse.
I have been contacted by many whistleblowers who are concerned about question-
able activities at the RTC. As a member of the Civil Service Committee, I have also
received extensive materials from the RTC concerning contracts, personnel deci-
sions, and fee bills. The Committee may want to look at some of this material. Some
of the questions that whistleblowers have raised include:
— ^Allegations that former RTC employees are now working for law firms that
receive million of dollars in contracts from the RTC.
— ^Allegations that certain preferred law firms have bUked the government and
the taxpayer out of huge sums of money.
— ^Allegations that certain cases have been transferred away from regional RTC
ofiices to the Washington office to protect firms that may have over billed the gov-
ernment.
— ^Allegations that former RTC employees who have received government con-
tracts are being evaluated by employees they used to supervise.
Many of these allegations have been raised by employees who are concerned about
waste and fraud.
There is a lot of talk about reinventing government. These people are on the front
lines when it comes to reinventing government. It is our job to not let them down.
I thank the Chairman and the Committee for letting me testify today and offer
any assistance I might give the Committee in the future.
TESTIMONY OF MICHAEL J. KOSZOLA
Mr. Chairman and Members:
Mv name is Michael J. Koszola, and I am pleased to have the opportunity to tes-
tify before you today. I have been a Federal enforcement officer for nearly ten years.
I worked as a sfiecial agent and auditor for the U.S. Customs Service for five years
investigating money laundering, commercial fraud, narcotics trafficking, copyri^t
and trademark cases. Since December 1991, I have been employed as a special
agent for the Office of Inspector General of the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC/
OIG). I am currently assigned with the Office of Investigation of the North Central
Region in Kansas City, Missouri.
When I first joined the IG's office of the RTC, I viewed it as an opportunity to
help uncover and prevent waste, fraud and abuse of the taxpayers' dollars in con-
nection with the cleanup of the Nation's Savings & Loans institutions. Unfortu-
nately, I found that the RTC/OIG is not doing its job, and that there is no incentive
for the RTC/OIG to do the job. In fact, the RTC/IG spent more time covering up,
or committing, fraud than it ever spent investigating it.
In today's testimony I will describe how the RTC/IG engaged in rewriting reports
to avoid embarrassment, misleading Congress, covering up high level misconduct,
shredding incriminating documents, and grossly distortmg agency investigative pri-
orities.
As a preliminary observation, I found that whistleblowers at the RTC who
brought matters to the attention of the IG did not receive whistleblower protection.
I was specifically instructed by my supervisors Daniel Sherry (Regional Inspector
Greneral for Investigations) and George Sullivan (Assistant Regional Inspector Gen-
eral) to avoid giving confidentiality to sources. The IG's office was unwilling to pro-
tect the identities of those who disclosed information concerning waste, fraud, and
abuse, exposing the whistleblower to retaliation before an investigation could even
take place. Time and time again, I heard of cases of retaliation.
I found cases in which agents at the RTC/OIG were instructed to rewrite reports
they had written, to have them read a particular wav that would be less likely to
require further investigation. I saw facts taken out of particular reports. Investiga-
tive reports were altered in order to avoid potentially embarrassing or politically
sensitive disclosures.
Once an IG agent writes up a report the process goes through about 6 people up
to the Assistant Inspector General who signs ofT on the report. After producing a
report, an agent, like myself, turns the report over to his supervisor, who turns it
over to the Regional IG, who then submits the report to a desk oflicer at Head-
quarters who is a liaison with the Regional IG's Office. From the Headquarters desk
84
officer, a report is typically forwarded to the Deputy Assistant IG (Lew Sherman)
and he turns it over lor review to the Assistant IG (Clark Blight). From there a re-
port goes to Counsel for the IG and finally to the IG, John Adair. K anyone along
this chain of command doesn't like something in the report, it gets kicked back to
the agent to change or is simply changed by someone else. The report is ultimately
signed by the Regional Assistant IG and may not resemble the original report of
investigation at all.
I was personally told by Claris Blight (Assistant Inspector General for Investiga-
tions) that it was the function of the Headquarters KTC/OIG to revise reports to
outside agencies including the GAO and Senate and House Congressional (Jommit-
tees in order to make sure the RTC/OIG reports looked favorable to Congress. At
that time, Blight was in the process of revising one such report to Congressman
Gonzalez, Clhairman of the House Banking Conamittee. Bli^t would highlight areas
of reports that were already approved and request that the report be revised, rewrit-
ten, or changed to reflect a more favorable outcome. Another time top RTC/OIG offi-
cials were sent to the Denver regional IG's office in order to "assist" other RTC/OIG
special agents in writing a report of investigation involving the Bush family.
The RTC/OIG attempted to mislead Congress in other ways as well. I saw case
numbers falsely generated by the IG's office to make it appear as if we were doing
more than we were doing. In fact, generation of "mEike-work" reports was a common
practice in the RTC. Several special agents had a reputation for opening frivolous
investigations in order to inflate the number of reports issued by their office.
I was personally assigned three cases that were previously closed to which new
case numbers were assigned to create the impression before year end 1992 that the
R'TC was actively investigating every day. I was ordered by management to
reinvestigate despite the fact that there was no new evidence to warrant reopening
the investigations. We reinvestigated it for no reason other than to build up the
numbers. We found nothing there the second time. This happened at least three
times that I know of. I brought this to the attention of RTC/OIG management and
was told that the RTC/OIG was trying to "keep Congress happy" in order to secure
additional funding.
I found instances in which we at the IG's office were told not to tell the truth
to the (General Accounting Office. Indeed, I was specifically instructed by my super-
visors at the IG's office (Daniel Sherry and CJeorge Sullivan) not to provide any neg-
ative information about the RTC to CiAO in 1992. I was told not to provide informa-
tion to the GAO concerning RTC employees who had criminal histories. I was fur-
ther instructed not to say anything about thefts in the buildings. TTie IG did not
want to open a case on the thefts and they did not want the GAO doing so, either.
In June 1992, teleconferencing equipment valued at over $50,000 was stolen from
the RTC Chicago office. The equipment was "secured" in a RTC office that required
a key. The equipment was allegedly stolen by RTC employees and/or RTC contrac-
tors. The Regional Inspector (General for Investigations, Daniel Sherry, did not want
to document the theft in RTC/IG records. Eventually, at the request of my super-
visor, Georve Sullivan, Sheny allowed the theft to be documented. Mr. Sullivan said
he had to beg Mr. Sherry to open a file on the theft of equipment, because I was
told the RTC/OIG needed to show that they were active in investigating and needed
statistics.
The RTC/OIG did not actively investigate the theft and delegated the investiga-
tion to the local police department. As Tar as I know, the theft investigation was
not solved by the local police department or the RTC/OIG.
Thefts of RTC computer equipment were common in every RTC office. There were
no internal controls or investigation systems in place to prevent the thefl of RTC
property from RTC offices by RTC employees or contractors. The thefts and the total
value of the loss can not be exactly determined, but it was estimated to be over
$1,000,000 nationwide.
I made an oral and written presentation to Mr. Sherry and Mr. Sullivan to imple-
ment a couple of internal controls to deter the thefts. Both Mr. Sherry and Mr. Sul-
livan told me that it was not the function of the RTC/OIG to prevent the thefts.
When I presented the same internal controls ideas to Clark Blight, Assistant Inspec-
tor General, and Lew Sherman, Deputy Assistant Inspector General, they said that
it was a good idea and that internal controls should be developed. To my knowledge
no internal controls were ever implemented as I continued to receive information
frona other RTC/OIG special agents that thefts of computer equipment were still oc-
curring on a regular basis.
I learned of the politicization of investigations, when management would send
agents to look over the shoulders of other agents when they were reviewing S&L
matters that might pertain to political figures. Before the Presidential election in
1992, the RTC/OIG was actively seeking criminal or other negative information from
85
RTC/OIG special agents on the Clinton family. After the election, Clark Blight trav-
elled to other RTC oflices and stated that after Inspector General John Adair openly
criticized Albert Casey, CEO of the RTC, before Congress, that Adair was going to
be easily nominated as the next FDIC IG. Adair was expected to take over the
FDIC/OIG after the RTC/OIG and FDIC/OIG merged.
Sometime in mid-February, 1993, an anonymous male telephone caller stated that
Patricia Patterson was buying RTC properties in Dallas as a straw purchaser for
Albert Casey, the Chairman of the KTC. Ms. Patterson was allegedly Mr. Casey's
girlfriend. Tne caller stated that the properties were being purchased from a prop-
erty development caUed The Blue Bonnet. The caller was not sure of the name of
the savings and loan that was associated with the projperty.
The caller stated that he was an employee of the RTC and had reported this infor-
mation to the RTC/OIG in Dallas, Texas. The caller stated that to his knowledge
no investigation was initiated by the RTC/OIG because no auditors or special agents
reviewed records or made inquiries of the property sales department. The caller
stated that he intended to call aU the RTC/OIG oflices to notify them of these alle-
gations.
I sent my supervisor, Mr. George Sullivan, a memo regarding this information.
To my knowledge no investigation was ever initiated.
In order to mmimize embarrassments to the agency, management sometimes sim-
ply declines to investigate. For example, after one of RTC's contractors pled guilty
for theft of RTC properties, I worked up the financial data on other areas of possible
theft of taxpayer assets by this company and asked the Regional IG to do an audit.
Despite the clear potential for adoitional recoveries. Regional refused to do the
audit. I never asked them for another audit.
Last year I received information that Albert Casey, the former Chairman of the
RTC, was involved in obtaining a million dollar plus contract for a company in
which he had a personal and possibly financial interest. The name of the company
is First Gilbraltor Realty Advisors located in Dallas and Irving, Texas and the con-
tract involved the asset management of Trans Ohio S&L, a failed thrift.
The services of First Gilbraltor were not needed and the RTC officials at Trans
Ohio and in the Chicago Consolidated Oflice objected to the contract and refused
to approve the contract. RTC headquarters signed the contract rather than the RTC
officials in Ohio and Chicago and chareed the contract out of the DC budget. The
services which were provided by First Gilbraltor were either not performed or were
performed in a poor manner. The RTC was billed approximately $1 million under
this contract. I reported this information to my supervisor, George Sullivan, who
was not interested in pursuing the matter.
Another investigation I tried to initiate involved reports of over billing and sleep-
ing on the job by employees of another RTC contractor. Coopers & Lybrand. I saw
Coopers & Lybrand accountants, hired by the RTC, perform little or no work at ex-
orbitant costs. I saw accountants sitting and reading non-government literature and
being paid for it by the RTC. When I investigated this, I was told that their contract
permitted them to sit there and read when there was no work to do. It was an obvi-
ous rip-off. When I tried to do something about it, I was told by my supervisor,
George Sullivan, not to bother with it, that it was too embarrassing to merit inves-
tigation. The RTC employee who approved the payments to Coopers & Lybrand is
now employed by them.
I regularly saw bills being paid by RTC without any documentation verifying that
services had been performed. For example, RTC would pay very large legal services
bills every month without any backup. It was like found money for any law firm
lucky enough to get that kind of contract.
In one case, I investigated a situation where the RTC was paying $10,000 a
month and other RTC officials blocked every attempt I made to investigate. After
receiving information concerning false billing by the law firm. Barrack, Ferrazzano,
Kirshbaum & Perlman, I attempted to obtain relevant records from the RTC Profes-
sional Liability Section (PLS) in Kansas City. The RTC/PLS repeatedly denied the
RTC/OIG access to the records. Previously, PLS denied access to the records over
a year long period to other RTC employees. After months of being stonewalled, I
finally obtained a grand jury subpoena to get the documents. The RTC/OIG at-
tempted to stop the subpoena from being served because it was too embarrassing
to subpoena the RTC/PLS according to RTC/OIG managers.
At the same time that the RTC/IG was ignoring major fraud cases, the IG's oflice
was vigorously investigating an employee who was recycling RTC trash and using
the money he received to buy coffee and doughnuts for other RTC employees. I saw
an IG's oftice that would insist that agents pursue small amounts of losses, like time
and attendance cases of RTC employees. It was safer to investigate penny ante mat-
ters and to find a lower-level worker whom you could show was a few hours oft on
86
his hours than to respond to the much more significant cases of waste, fraud, abuse
and wrongdoing involving millions of dollars.
An incident which epitomized for me the blatant disregard for the law in the IG's
office occurred on August 24, 1992. I was on detail in D.C. shortly after Gerald Ja-
cobs, General Counsel of the RTC, had resigned under a cloud of allegations con-
cerning personal and official impropriety despite the fact an Inspector General's re-
port saia that it had found "no information" showing any impropriety with respect
to Jacobs' dealings with a failed Arizona S&L. I was worKing at the IG Head-
quarters in Rosslyn, VA, when I overheard Lew Sherman, Deputy Assistant Inspec-
tor Greneral for Investigations and Clark Blidit, the Assistant Inspector General for
Investigation, laughing and making jokes about how they'd "taken care of the Ja-
cobs' case" by shredding documents aU weekend with the help of several other spe-
cial agents. They joked about how they had needed to borrow a shredder from an-
other office to handle all the shredding. The borrowed shredder was in the office
in which I was working and though I did not witness the actual shredding — I saw
them remove the borrowed shredder to return it to the other office. Shredding docu-
ments following the conclusion of an investigation is not unusual. However the cir-
cumstances of this shredding operation raises a number of questions. What was the
hurry? Why did it occur over a weekend? Why did it take an entire weekend for
two assistant IG's and three special agents, with two shredders, to carry out a rou-
tine shredding? (The three special agents received "letters of exemplary service" for
their "expedient response" and "professionalism" in conducting the Jacobs' investiga-
tion.)
On April 19, 1993, I was placed on indefinite administrative leave pending an in-
vestigation into allegations of which I have still not been officially informed. On
April 5, 1993, two weeks before I was placed on administrative leave, I was ordered
by my Supervisor, George Sullivan, to discontinue any contact with the Senate
Banking Committee.
Since being placed on leave I have received at least ten threatening phone calls.
I alerted the police after each call and was able to tape one of the calls which con-
sisted of nothing but the sound of machine gun fire. On another call, the caller stat-
ed something to the effect of "we're gonna get you." A number of callers repeated
obscenities over the phone.
For the past several months, I have not been permitted to woris at all by the RTC.
The taxpayers are still paying my salary. I am ordered to come to work each
Wednesday morning and then ordered to go home as soon as I arrive.
I have worked for a number of Federal agencies but never in my career have I
seen an agency managed so poorly and with such profound consequences for waste,
fraud, and abuse, as the RTC. I have been asked sometimes how much taxpayer
money the RTC has wasted. I cannot tell you. I have only seen a tiny comer of the
RTC's operations. But based on what I have seen, I can only conclude that the total
must be in the billions.
87
OPFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GSSNKRAJL.
UUKK»KA'iiUN
OATS: AuAuat 31. 1992
TO: Pat Wagner. Spoolal Aaent
FROM: Clark W. Bll«ht , Aaelotaftt Inep«ctor General
for
Inveotlgatlon
SUBJHCT: Kxomplary S«rvice
I want to ooaxnend you on your vrofaaaloaallaa In
cooductln* the Jaooba Invaatlgatlon. Your axpadlont
responsa to our raquaat for aaalat&noa is sraatly
appreclatad. The eommltiaant of support you displayed,
helped to complete the Invaatlcatlon in a tinoly nanner.
Pac. we look forward to your continued ouocaeo with tha
RTC/DIG.
88
!•: BlVMIELKEM.I TK WPS.l Revl»«di 00-20-92 OmSln
iTE: Autjumt ~1 , l<77r
li Eric R. SI 1 •» 1 •> i»r> , gpuclal rtqen t
•■OMi ClarK Ul. might. rt>55l'»tant Inspector Oenvral -for-
InvcstlqAtion
IBJECTi GKWmplairy 'Jei-vicn
wont to comnMrnd you on your pro-fessional isra in conductlnq tho Jacobs
ive'3tiq*tion . Vour expedient i-B«pon»« to our r«qu»»t for «9ailatAncc Is gre*tl
iprpclotvd . Th« convni tm«n t o-^ oupport you displayed, hplpvd to co<ti()l<»to the
ivratiqrt tiof* in a t±m*?ly ni«nn«rr .
•ic, w» loo^; -foi-WArd to your continued «vicc*«ii with th» nrrC/OIG.
joks i Ne«t Dkici TZ P"rtfv I>oc i O
llci &1\HARTEELL.L1R Wrp.l r<evi»edi 00-CO 92 0Ai30p
*TEl August Jl, 17V,:
Is riacK HArt-.ik.-ll. C'Ipwi.iol i^ijen t
tOri» ClArk W. Dlight, rtasj slant In»ipe( tor Omiwr«] foi-
InvH^!. ti(]i»ticiri
IDJECT c E!xc»mpl<M^y *i>»»rvicu
WAot to cnmmond yon on your pri--f cist; looj 1 i om in crartifu c t inq thw -.''uti.uljB
iver.tl g.itl on , Your & x fit-d i <ai-> t rouponiso to our raqucmt Vor j.»i.i a tjvn ce is qrentl
)pr(jti*t<»(J . The coimn i I ni«n t o-f «iii;>pnrf you diapi*yQd, holpod to complete the
iv«jat.iq«ti.on in « linit-iy m^nntir.
iCK, uu» look- fcirwixrd to your continued •ucte'ss Mith t.hif RTC/OIG.
>oks 1 Ntx t r><3<:i Z Prev Doc: O
89
OFFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
E■^\^. 2
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
OfTlce of InTsugauon ■ Nonh Central Region
DATE:
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
January 19, 1993
George F. Sullivaji
Asst. Regional Inspector General for Investigation
Michael J. Koszola
Special Agent
Coopers and Lybrand
Bob Contractor, RTC facilities employee, alleged that Coopers and Lybrand is
currentJy employing sub-contractors who are allowed to "sit and read" while
being employed by the RTC (see attached email message). Contractor is
concerned that the Coopers employees are falsely billing the RTC for stnicti not
performed.
Should we Ofwn a complaint on this information?
90
E \\-. 3
OFFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
OfTice o( Inveugaiion ■ Nonh Central Region
DATE;
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT;
January 21, 1993
George F. Sullivan
Asst. Regional Inspector General for Invesugauon
Michael J. Koszola
Special Agent
Coopers and Lybrand
Bob Contractor. RTC facilities employee, alleged that Coopers and Lybrand is
currently employing sub-contractors who are allowed to "sit and read' whiie
being employed by the RTC. Contractor is concerned that the Coopers
employees are falsely billing the RTC for services not penormed.
I discussed with Coopers and Lybrand managers whether there was an agreement
between the RTC and Coopers and Lybrand allowing RTC contractors,
specit"ically Coopers and Lybrand employees or sub-contractors to 'sit and read"
while being compensated by the RTC. I discussed the "sit and read agreement"
issue with Coopers and Lybrand managers Wesley Kee, Percy Berger, and
panner-in-chaige Sheree Speakman. Wesley Kee stated that a "sit and read"
agreement does not exist between the RTC and Coopers and Lybrand. Mr. Kee
stated that approximately 80 sub-contractors were terminated recently because
there was a lack of work to pen'orm at the RTC. Mr. Kee suted that Coopers
and Lybrand emciloys approximately 30 employees and approximately 130 sub-
contractors. Mr. Percy Berger stated that the agreement to "sit and read" was an
agreement between Coopers and Lybrand officials only, which he established.
Bob Contractor stated that a former Coopers and Lybrand employee. James
Kennedy, was discharged by Coopers and Lybrand in C>ecember 16, 199Z, after
Kennedy made racial slurs to Bob Contractor.
91
Uh. V
OFFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
OfTice of biTestigation ■ North Central Region
DATE:
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
February 16. 1993
George F. Sullivan
Asst. Regional Inspector General for Investigauon
Michael J. Koszola
Special Agent
Patricia Patterson
An anonymous telephone caller (male voice) stated that Patricia Patterson is
allegedly buying RTC properties in Dallas, Texas as a straw purchaser for Albert
Casey, the Chairman of the Resolution Trust Corporation. Patterson is allegedly
the girlfriend of Casey.
The caller stated that the properties are being purchased from a property
development called The Blue Bonnet. The caller was not sure of the name of the
savings and loan that is associated with the property.
The caller stated that he is an employee of the RTC and has reported this
information to the RTC\OIG in Dallas. Texas. The caller stated that to his
knowledge no invesugauon was initiated by the RTC\OIG because no auditors or
special agents reviewed records or made inquires of the property sales
depanment. The caller suted that he was calling ail of the RTC\OIG offices to
notify them of the straw purchasers.
Should we open a complaint on this allegation? Should we make a referral on
this allegation to headquaners?
92
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
Pron:
Subjacc:
D»ta:
Attach:
CwtiCy:
rorvartl«<a by:
Karcalla A. SngllahtlqSRTCKCMID
Micha«l J. Koazola9IG9RTCXCCHI
acrs check requast
Wadnasday, Fabruary 17, 1993 9:35:49 CST
ef\^-
c:
plaasa checic ACTS for tha following nanas;
PATRICIA PATTERSON DALLAS, TEXAS
PATRICIA PATERSEN " "
PATRICIA PATTERS EN " »
PATRICIA PETTERSON " "
PLEASE CHECK THE FOLLOWING NAME, IT IC AFrLIATED WITH A PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT
AND OR A SAVINOS AND LOAN:
THE BLUE BOKNIT LOCATED IN DALLAS, TEXAS
THANKS
MIKE
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
Prom:
Subject:
Data:
Attach ;
Certify:
Forvarded by :
Michael J. Ko«2ola«lC9RTCKCCHl
Marcalla A. Bngli»hlig«RTCXCMID
Wadnesday, Fabruary 17, 1993 10.01iS7 CST
J
L
Hello.
I havB chacJced for ACTS information
lolloving:
PATRICIA PATTERSON
PATRICIA PATERSEN
PATRICIA PATTERS EN
PATRICIA PETTERSON
on your rcquootcd nanic=. I have found the
DALLAS, TEXAS WA-00-0133/WA-92-0012
NOTHING
NOTHING
NOTHING
93
Ei^h. 7
OFFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
Office of Ijiveligation ■ North Central Region
DATE;
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
March 2, 1993
George F. Sullivan
Asst. Regional Inspector General for Investigation
Michael J. Koszola
Special Agent
Professional Liability Section
I made several requests to Julie Yanda, Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC),
Section Chief, Professional Liability Section (PLS), for records of RTC
contractors performing legal services for the RTC. Yanda stated that she would
obtain the records but stated that she had other duDes besides obtaining records
for the RTC\OIG.
I made - request to the RTC Chicago Consolidated Office for copies of records
of RTC contractors performing legal services for the RTC. Caryn Rodenck,
litigation suppon, Chicago Consolidated Office, was told by Yanda not to provide
records to the RTC\OIG but to send the records to PLS in Kansas City.
I have been informed that there have been previous requests for records from the
PLS by the RTC\CCO Investigations Department. The requests made by the
RTC\CCO Investigauons E>epanment were denied. Some of the requests were
for the same records that I requested.
A grand jury subpoena was issued to Julie Yanda to obtain the records. Deputy
PLS Chief B.J. Hickert received the subpoena on February 24, 1993.
94
£xA. ^'
To: HarlBha A. Prico»CONTREC«RTC0C
Cc:
Bcc:
rroBi Hlcha«l J. Ko«iola«ICiRTCICCCHI
Subjao&t raqucsc for g1 Ibracor invoices
Data: Tuaoday, March 2, 1393 10:21:56 CST
Attach:
Certify: Y
Forvnrded by:
Plaase provlda copias of all paid and unpaid invoic«e cogradiru} a contract
With KTC contractor nRST GIBRALTAR REALITY ADVISORS, IMC, looatod in Toxas
at RTC institution TRAKS OHIO, Cl«vland , Ohio.
Plaase awnd a copy of the contract and tha list of CIBHALTOR anployeae and any
other documents subnittad by CIBRALTOR.
thanJcs
mDca
/ ■
/ JFIrslClbroitorRoolfyA^v^y^,^^ .^
Sepiefflb«f 30, 1992
Anjol* Difiel \^ X '' '
. Admlnijindon Orflccr /— '
Re»oludon Trusi CorponuJon
Niaonil StIeJ C«ntof • . .
Wl I7ih Street. NW, Room 233
Wuhlnjfon, XiC 20434
^^' Sk o'^defOiT'*'" '^^'" Contact # 700-91-0037^)2
Dm: Angela:
""^"^^'^(tu^^S^^, "^' ^-•^^ ^^«^^' P~i- for ^^ ^^
95
( First Gibraltar Realty Advisors, Inc.
Resolution Trust Corporation
National Sales Center
Invoice Number: LHCW08-100
ATTN: Angela Ditzel
RE: Transohio Oversight Project
CONTRACT # 700-91-0037-02
Task Order 021
HOURS HnTTRi.YRATE TOTAL
Senior Managers
Senior Professional
Junior Professional
Paraprofesstonal
Clerical
Travel Expenses
Balance due
234.00
832.25
755.25
431.00
56.25
S190.00
$100.00
5 60.00
5 30.00
5 20.00
$ 44,460.00
$ 83,225.00
5 45.315.00
S 12.930.00
$ 1,125.00
^ i^ ^7.4S
F^S.7f)2.48
Approved:
Remit Payment to:
First GibraJiar Realty Advisors, Inc.
Arm: Cindy Poynter
1925 W. John Carpenter Freeway
irvmg, l-x 75063-3224
96
t.>:Ii. K
OFTICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLUTION TTIUST
CORPORATION
OfTicx of lii«e(igation ■ North Cenlral Region
DATE:
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SUBreCT:
March 15, 1993
George F. Sullivan
Assi. Regional Inspector General for Invesogauon
Michael J. Koszola
Special Agent
REMOVAL AND SEARCHING OF RECORDS
Per our conversation on Fnday, March 12, 1993. 1 am requesung that you inform
me when you xzich my office and remove records without my knowledge.
I was not able to locate records which you tooic from my office wunout telling
me. You did not explain why you took the records. I asked you several umes
whether you took the (Trailer) records. You responded that did not take any
records from my office. After an hour had passed sino. 1 onginaJly asked you
about the missing records, you finally admitted that you removed files from my
office during the past week. You stated that you were amiss and returned the
Fraaer records.
You admined that you removed records pertaining to (KC-93-00161 witnoui my
knowledge. I previously reported that records were missing from this file.
Please check your records and office to determine whether there are other records
you have removed from my office without telling me.
97
OFFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
ox/7. //
OrTiu of InTcstigiiion ■ North Central Region
CONFIDENTIAL
DAT1E:
April 8, 1993
MEMORANDUM TO: Senator John Ken7 and Jonathan Winer
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Michael J. Koszola
Special Agent
RTC Office of Inspector General
I was given a direct order by my Supervisor George Sullivan on Monday, April
5, 1993 instructing me not to call your office and not to have any contact with
your office. I was also ordered not to give my office telephone numt)«r to
anyone. Sullivan stated that the Regional Inspector General, Daniel Sherry
instructed him to prohibit me from using the government phone for government
business. I was ordered to give the office secretary telephone number to callers.
The secretary docs not have the capability to transfer telephone calls to my
telephone.
My immediate supervisor, George Sullivan, told me that the RTC\OIG has
obtained a copy of all my office telephone calls that were made from and to my
old telephone number, 708.290.7746. Sullivan slated that I should not be
cooperating with your office.
I was told and believed that my communication with your office would be
confidential. I do not like being harassed by my supervisors for communicaung
with your office regarding RTC matters. Also, 1 am not allowed to meet with the
U.S. Attorney regarding invcstigauve matters.
As I previously reported to your office, the RTOOIG does not pursue
investigabons of fraud, waste and abuse involving the RTC. The RTC has
repeatedly hired contractors who had cnminal histories and were convicted felons.
The RTOOIG has investigated me ever since I objected to their unethical and
possibly illegal actions. If you have any questions and/or want information of
wrongdoing at the .RTC\01G, please conuct me at my new office telephone
number 708.427.9278. Please do release my identity to RTC officials.
98
OmCE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
L^h ■
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
OfTioc of Iii*eti(a(ion ■ North Centnd Region
DATE:
MEMORANDUM TO:
From:
SUBJECT:
April 19. 1993
Michael J. Kouola
Special Agent
George Sullivan Xf f^^
Assistant Regional Inspector General
for Investigation
Placement in Non-Duty, Paid Stanis
This is notice that, effective immediately, I am placing you on administrative paid
leave. As you Imow, an investigation has been initiated which concerns various
allegations made against you. Placement on administrative paid leave staais will
continue until further nooce or until the investigation is completed and a decision
is made regarding your contL^.ued employment with RTC GIG. In order for this
office to keep you advised of your sows, you may want to notify us if you plai:
to be away for any extended period of time.
Pursuant to this notice, you must immediately provide me with your credit cards
(Diners Club and telephone), building access keys, and GIG credenaals.
cc:
Daniel L. Sheny
Clark W. BUght
99
OPEND^G STATEME^^^ OF THOMAS O'BRYON
Good Morning Senators:
In the early 1980'3, I woriied with many S&L's in the Pacific Northwest, as well
as in California as a consultant helping to resolve non-earning asset problems. The
largest of these institutions was State Savings of California, which eventually was
taken over by the Bass brothers and became American Savings as the "Good Bank"
and New West Bank as the "Bad Bank."
In 1990, I applied to work with the RTC in the Costa Mesa, California oflice and
was accepted in June of that year. I woriced for the RTC for just over a year before
I became completely fed up and decided that I could not do much that could be con-
sidered constructive. I felt that mav^e, do to my employment with the RTC, I could
help individuals and companies that were interested in doing business with the
RTC. That work continued until November of 1992 when again my frustration level
grew to such a point I decided I wtis completely wasting my time and my clients
money.
I was a guest speaker at the National Home Builders Association Annual Con-
ference in Nevada in 1992. My co-speaker at that Conference was Mr. Rick Wolfe,
who at that time was head of Asset Sales in the Denver Sales Oflice of the RTC.
I also was a guest speaker at the California BuUding Industry Economic Forecast
Conference in San Francisco, in 1992. At both of these conferences my topic of dis-
cussion was "How to do business with the RTC."
I hope that this shows you that I have not been a stranger to the RTC since my
resignation. Now, on with some of my thoughts about the RTC.
Management
The style of management at the RTC during my tenure and subsequent associa-
tion through my clients, was one of crisis management.
I have been a manager of a number of my own companies, and I like to think
that I have learned a little something about what coula be considered appropriate
behavior on the part of a superior. During the time I was working for, and doing
business with the RTC, I witnessed and was subjected to fits of rage, rudeness,
yelling, sexual innuendo and generally demeaning and harassing behavior on the
part of more than one member of the senior stalT of the RTC. I saw individuals
threatened with firing, as was I on more than one occasion. I saw senior staff saying
that they would put an end to peoples careers. These are fear tactics, and were
rampant throughout the RTC in the areas that I worked. It was quite common for
employees to gather and talk about the threats that they received, or of the sexual
advancements by superiors.
Reporting/Fraud
From time to time, the RTC in Washington, or at the regional office, would re-
quest information on RTC's real estate portfolios. The information was nearly im-
possible to gather due to lack of adequate time and a clear definition of what the
material needed to include or what the material would in fact be used for. This cre-
ated a tremendous amount of waste, as individuals would have to stop what they
were doing and rush to get the data that was demanded. As a result of not having
enou^ time to produce uie reports properly, I was repeatedly asked to misrepresent
the numbers in my reports that were to be delivered to Washington.
On one occasion, I was told that I had to complete a report in one d^ that needed
at least five days to complete. I was given only one day because we had just received
the request from Washington even though the request had been ordered two weeks
before. As a result, I would not send the report with my name attached, because
I knew the information in the report was inaccurate and incomplete. When I re-
sisted sending the inaccurate report in, my superiors told me I was not doing my
job and if I did not cooperate, I would be fired.
My attitude was, that if I didn't get fired for producing the documents without
my name on them, I would get fired Tor turning in fraudulent information. Needless
to say, this is a very compromising situation. It was, however, not uncommon.
As you can see this speaks to both management and fraud.
REOISmEOMS
The REOIS, or Real Estate Owned Inventory System, was the primary method
of reporting and tracking of real estate assets at the RTC until 1991 when REOMS
(Real Estate Owned Management System) was introduced. I was given the job of
management and implementation of the system.
100
The system was flawed from the beginning. Too many people with too many ideas
of what they thought the system should or could do were involved in the design.
This created a system that would not work, because it had inadequate controls. To
correctly implement the controls that were necessary, Bill Sutton, of the Denver
RTC ofiice, and I went to Washington to assist the programmers with the system
and met with Lamar Kelly and Mr. Cook, his assistant. The purpose of the trip was
to discuss simplifying the system and establishing controls to insure data integrity.
As the REOlS system was a precursor or temporary system until REOMS could
be set up, we felt that we could also help in the design and controls of REOMS.
We were not consulted, and as a result the REOMS system will eventually cost the
American TsLxpayer $100 Million Dollars. This number could have been far less, but
the decision was made without full consideration of the ramiiications and long term
impact. It was that RFP that was ill-conceived and caused the problem.
Again, this goes to waste and mismanagement.
Inappropriate Behavior
I am currently a witness for the government in a case that involves: Inappropriate
Behavior of a Sexual Nature, Abuse of Position by Attempting to Inappropriately
Influence Subordinate Level Employees, Abuse of Position by Inappropriately
Accessing Files and Abuse of Position by Attempting to Harm other Employees' Ca-
reers.
I don't think it would be appropriate for me to discuss this matter with you in
any Sjpecifics at this time. I would be willing to give some general types of informa-
tion if you think that would be alri^t.
I can honestly say, however, that I have seen and heard about these types of
abuse in more than one of the oflices of the RTC.
Waste
After I was asked to turn over REOIS to a new employee, I was given six apart-
ment buildings to manage in Phoenix, Arizona. At that time, the individual that was
managing them was being promoted to Department Head and was no longer able
to manage these assets.
When I did my review of the apartments, I noticed that the rents had been dras-
tically changed by the previous asset manager. This had created a tremendous va-
cancy and the RTC was losing a significant value due to the decline in rents, not
to mention the reduced cash-flow. As I further investigated the properties, I discov-
ered that the six properties combined had approximately $1,400,000.00 (One Million
Four Hundred Thousand Dollars) sitting in checking accounts earning NO INTER-
EST. The funds had been in the account earning no interest for nine months.
Under FIRREA, RTC's authorizing legislation, RTC is supposed to earn interest
on all of its funds. Due to incompetence on the part of the manager, the taxpayers
lost all of that interest.
When I questioned the person who placed the fiinds in the non-interest account
about his decision, the person, who was now my boss, replied that placing the funds
in an interest-bearing account would have required too much paperwork. The inter-
est that could have been earned could have paid a lot of salaries. This also illus-
trates managements ability and style.
This is just one of several situations that I ran across on a regular basis.
IG's Office
I have filed two complaints with the IG's office. The first was to report waste as
in the example above, and the second was to report that a current employee was
buying real estate from the RTC and hiding this illegal activity by using front men
who are not connected with the RTC.
On the first complaint, I have no idea as to the outcome except that the person
I turned in has been promoted at least one more time. As to the second complaint,
which was filed in May of 1993, 1 also have no idea of its outcome.
Auction/Sales
One of the tasks that I performed for my clients after leaving the RTC was to
help them buy assets. The average real estate purchase takes between four and five
times as long from the RTC as it does from the private sector.
Buying assets from the RTC almost always became a personality contest. Except
for the auctions, it was a question of how much time you were willing to spend with
the asset specialist handling the asset. In part this is due to the amount of paper
101
work that an asset specialist has to do to justify his or her accepting an offer. If
I, as the representative for a buyer, was willing to do some of the work for the asset
specialist, tnen I was a hero to him. He would then go out of his way to help me
secure the asset. This did not always help however, on several occasions the asset
would be pulled and then put into an auction even though a good offer was pending.
Action such as this cost the taxpayers millions of dollars, and I am not referring
just to the lost revenue on the sale, but as a result of the exorbitant costs of the
auction. I have also witnessed the auctions doing a tremendous damage to an entire
maiiet areas due to the substantially reduced prices that some auctions have pro-
duced. San Diego, California is a prime example of this. It may take years for the
effects to be mitigated.
Another example is Colorado Springs; Colorado. At one point in time the RTC
held as much as 43 percent of the commercial real estate in the downtown area.
An auction was held and the properties were sold at a time when the market was
severely depressed. Since then, Colorado has turned around emd now has the strong-
est real estate market in the country. It has only been two years. The RTC managed
to sell these properties at the very bottom of the market netting approximately 40
percent or less oi what they would bring today.
One specific example was the purchase of a 125,000 square foot R&D Warehouse
building in Colorado Spring in 1991 for $12.50 per square foot. Within one year the
purchaser syndicated the building to an investment group for $50.00 per square
foot. The RTC left $4,687,500.00 (Four Million Six Hundred; Eighty Seven Thousand
Five Hundred Dollars) on the table because of RTC's managers orders to sell prop-
erty as fast as they can regardless of price.
This policy of "speed at any cost" has cost the taxpayer BILLIONS.
It is easy to criticize. It is much more difficult to produce creative workable solu-
tions. I am here today to discuss these problems as well as workable solutions.
I will be happy to answer any questions that you may wish to ask.
STATEME^^^ of JAMES ROMER
September 23, 1993
Mr. Chairman and Members of the committee:
It is an honor and a privilege to address this committee regarding contracting
irregularities, management improprieties, contractor collusion and conflicts of inter-
est at the Dallas Ofnce of RTC during the early years of its existence. The testimony
I am about to give is based on first-hand knowledge and reflects my personal evperi-
ences while employed as a Contract Specialist in the Dallas Metroplex Consolidated
Office of RTC.
Background
Prior to working for the RTC, I had over 30 years experience in the areas of Real
Estate Brokerage, Appraisals, Construction, Business Development and Computer
Applications. I have owned several businesses and have directly supervised up to
80 employees.
I began employment at RTC in February 1990, approximately four months aft«r
the Dallas Office opened. My first assignment at RTC was to organize and staff a
contractor registration department for the South West Regional Office which was
also headquartered in Dallas.
I established an organization of six people, developed registration procedures, de-
signed a computerized data base and supervised the registration of tne first 12,000
contractors. My team also completed the solicitation and award of 75 contracts. As
a result of this effort I received the first Gold Star Achievement Award granted in
the South West Region.
However, all was not well at the co-located Dallas Metroplex Consolidated Office;
especially in the contracting department. Besides the normal organizational start up
pains of new people learning to work together, obtaining office space and developing
operating procedures, there were fundamental philosophical problems that seriously
affected contracting. These were reflected in the basic organizational structure: the
general hiring guidelines and the loose operating practices.
First, contracting was not and could not operate objectively since it was organiza-
tionally reporting directly to and was fully responsible to the Asset Management De-
partment whose mission was to dispose of assets. The contracting managers were
essentially told what to do and who to contract with. Contracting was little more
than the conveyors of paper that documented and validated decisions that asset
102
management had already made. For most of 1990 and 1991 the concept of fair and
open competition was a joke.
This was especially true for minority contractors since most asset managers were
predisposed to conclude that minority contractors were not capable of performing
asset related work. Even though FIRREA had dictated the "maximum use criteria"
senior management in Dallas would not permit contractor registration reports to re-
flect minority identification even though I had designed the data base to do so.
Second, the general hiring policy at the time was that anyone that had a FAR
(Federal Acquisition Regulation) background was not suitable for consideration to
be hired in tne contracting department. The reasoning was that since RTC was not
required to operate under the FAR rules it would be counter productive to have peo-
ple around with that kind of discipline. People with FADA (Federal Asset Disposi-
tion Agency) or banking backgrounds, the good buddies, many who were involved
in the creating the Savings and Loan crises, were hired with abandon. Even apply-
ing the FAR contracting principles, without the actual regulations, was considered
sacrilegious.
The first and second tier contract managers had minimal contracting background
and as such did not understand the need for appljnng the fundamental principles
of good contracting such as, limiting RTC liabihty, finite contracting periods, well
defined statements of work, cost realism, negotiation techniques and post award
contract administration.
Third, the contracting operating environment was purely one driven by time pres-
sures and deadlines dictated by the senior asset managers. Contract specialists were
fearful of losing their jobs if a contract, especially a SAMDA, was not awarded by
the designated date set by asset management. No matter if there were loopholes
that permitted the contractor to operate with little or no controls.
The Pillar iNcroENT
My first insight into the buddy arrangement for awarding contracts came in Octo-
ber 1990. During that month Solicitations 761-9966-900139, 140, 141, 142, 143 &
144 were issued to secure contractors to perform computer identical corrections to
assets at six locations. I was the contract specialists assigned to work the solicita-
tions.
One firm was the lowest bidder and the best qualified on all six of the solicita-
tions. I performed the required verifications and recommended to the Asset Depart-
ment that the contracts be awarded to the low bidder. Assets rejected the rec-
ommendation and requested that four of the contracts be awarded to the lowest bid-
der and two contracts be awarded to the second ranked bidder whose chairman was
friends with several of the senior staff at RTC.
In reviewing and checking on the required certifications pursuant to FIRREA and
12 CFR 1606, there were obvious conflicts with the seconds ranked bidder. This was
brought to the attention of the Dallas Deputy Ethics Officer on November 19, 1990
(Attachment 1) afler preliminary checks revealed inconsistencies between the firm's
proposal and the facts. The (Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of the second
ranked firm was currently employed as a Sr. Vice President at a Savings and Loan
and had not disclosed this employment.
During my inquiry into the information on the second ranked firm's certification
forms I physically went to the Savings & Loan oftice and obtained a letter from the
personnel department confirming the employment of the Sr. Vice President and also
obtained a copy of the institution's financial statement which listed the bidder's
Chairman as a Sr. Vice President. These were obvious conflicts.
Later at my RTC ofUce, I was confronted by my Department Head and admon-
ished for physically going to the bidders office to verify this questionable informa-
tion. When I informed* the Department Head of my findings and the need to inform
the Ethics Department, he advised me that there was no need to check out the firm
because it had already been decided that they would soon be awarded a major
SAMDA contract for the management and disposition of assets.
Finally, in response to my protests and refusal to award my two contracts to the
second ranked firm, I was given permission to award all six contracts to the lowest
bidder. However, the senior management of the Dallas Metroplex Consolidated Of-
fice had dictated that the second ranked firm be awarded business.
A major SAMDA contract was awarded to this firm in soite of independent re-
ports from the investigations department validating the conflicts of interest created
by the firm's Chairman working for a Savings & Loan. These reports were sent to
the senior asset managers, senior contracts manager and the ethics officer at the
Dallas Office.
103
This example is just one of many that resulted from the fact that the majority
of the initial Dallas RTC staff consisted of ex FADA employees who took great pains
to look out for the friendly contractors that they had previously done business with.
The same people who were deeply involved in creating the Savings and Loan crises
in the first place.
The Power of SAMDA
An illustration of the kind of unethical practices used by some SAMDA contrac-
tors is summarized in my memorandum dated July 9, 1991 (attachment 2) to the
Assistant Director of Contracts at the Dallas Metroplex Consolidated Office. The
asset management contractor is demanding a non-refundable option fee of $3,000 to
process a sales contract for the purchase of properties. My memorandum was not
responded to nor any action teiken to correct these practices.
In interviews with Jim Douglas (attachment 3), the purchaser's broker, I was told
that the asset manager indicated that they would accept $1,5(X) instead of the
$3,000 to process the sales contract. When Mr. Douglas refused to pay he was not
f)ermitted to compete for listing agreements on which he had previously been the
isting agent prior to the assets being assigned to this asset manager.
A second illustration of the awesome power that SAMDA contractors wielded is
provided in the letter from Mr. Mike Doan (attachment 3) dated July 16, 1991. In
the letter Mr. Doan states that not only is the SAMDA contractor arbitrarily decid-
ing who will get discounted deals on the properties being sold but the SAMDA con-
tractor bragged about the fact that it would do no good to complain to the RTC. In
fact, in the past, complaints had been sent to former CEO Seidman, but the pur-
chaser still had to come back and deal with the SAMDA. Such impunity was wide-
spread and is one of the reasons why many subcontractors and buyers became dis-
couraged and stopped trying to do business with the RTC.
The power that the contractor had over the friendly RTC senior management is
further illustrated when considering the letter that this same SAMDA contractor
wrote dated July 1, 1991 (attachment 4) to the Dallas Regional Director. The pre-
liminary internal memorandum that I had written on June 25, 1991 (attachment
5) detailing wrongdoing was already in the hands of the contractor to the extent
that they had heard — about the contents from "several sources at the RTC Regional
Office and the Metroplex Consolidated Office." It is probably just a strange coinci-
dence that the special assistant to the then RTC Regional Director was also a
former supervisor of the chairman of the SAMDA contractor who just happens to
be in the oirect pipeline for receiving RTC internal information.
Retribution Measures
Suddenly, without formal explanation, I was relieved as Contracting Team Leader
and assigned duties as a librarian and FOIA response writer. While I was hired as
an LG-14 contract specialist and had performed at that level, my new duties were
that normally given an LG— 9 or 11 apprentice specialist. I was not permitted to do
any contracting or to have contact with any of our contractors even though as a re-
sult of my involvement in setting up the initial contractor registration program con-
tractors were constantly calling me with their inquiries or complaints. In met, many
of the facts that I am able to present today are the result of contractor's complaints
being sent to me.
As an illustration of how deeply ingrained this vindictiveness was with the Assist-
ant Director of Contracts and his two direct reports, I refer you to my memorandum
dated April 8, 1992 (attachment 6) which addresses two shortcomings of RTC's in-
formation systems.
As you are aware, timely information is the cornerstone of RTC being able to do
business. I had observed that huge amounts of space were being used to store docu-
ments and many hours of clerical time spent retrieving documents. Also, many pro-
posals, contracts, and other important documents are submitted to RTC by Fax. Be-
cause of time zone differences many of the Fax documents come in to our automatic
machines during non-duty hours. There are times when I arrived in the office in
the mornings that fax documents were literally strewn over the floor because the
receiver box had overflown.
I suggested using the new imaging software and computer boards since each con-
tract specialist has a terminal. Significant savings would result from reducing file
storage space, document retrieval time, minimizing lost files, reducing lost time of
stancung at fax machines, and having a chronological record of fax messages sent
and received. The savings, if the system was adopted, was estimated to pay for the
system in 90 days or less. My immediate management would neither discuss the
104
feasibility of these improvements nor forward the analysis to the experts in informa-
tion systems.
Recommendations
In closing, Mr. Chairman, I would like to state that there were and still are many
dedicated, hard woiking people within RTC who could do a much better job in Re-
storing the Confidence and Resolving the Crises if:
1. Tne hard core senior management at the field oflices and headquarters who
were responsible for the problems that I have addressed be removed. They do not
believe tnat the new initiatives that Secretary Bentsen introduced will work since
they have an inherent vested interest in maintaining the old system. After aU, it
was they who designed the old system, and to make the new system woric would
be absolute proof that their former approach was wrong. This is tantamount to self
incrimination and no one can be expected to put diligent effort into such a cause.
2. Contracting be placed on an eaual basis with asset management, operations
and legal. Since the majority of the RTC business is done via outside contracts an
objective, independent contracting group is essential. This is a fundamental man-
agement flaw to have the contracting ofiicers identified as organizational second
class citizens. The pressure from overzealous managers who are quick to let it be
known that they control your paycheck can subvert even the most objective contract-
ing ofdoer.
Again, I thank you for the opportunity to appear before this committee.
105
Exhibit i
MEMORANDUM
TO: Wayne Fogle
Deputy Ethics Officer
FROM: Jim Rcmer
Contract Specialist
DATE: November 19, 1990
SUBJECT: CERTIFICATION PURSUAMT TO FXRR£A AKD 12 CFR PART 1606
PARTS 1606.6(6), 1606.7(b), 1606.10
REVIEW OF REQUIRED CERTIFICATIONS AMD REGUUVTORY
COMPLIANCE FOR; SOS #761-9966-900139 - 143
Proposals responding to the above-referenced solicitation resulted
in one of the solicited firms having some question as to compliance
vith the Regulatory Compliance phase of the solicitation (Conflict
of Interest and Required Certifications) . I have listed the firm
and the questions vith regard to their conflict of certification
belov. Also attached is Part B, "Background information and
Regulatory Compliance Section" of their responses to the
solicitation for your review. Please review and advise of your
determination of the is lues in question on the respective firm.
FIRM CONFLICT OR CERTIFICATION PROBLEM
Pillar Investment Co. 1. False statement of employment 1989 to
present in part B.
2. Mon-disclosxire of employment at an S&L
as 8r. VP in charge of REO property
from 1989 to present time.
3. Claising KWOB status when not active
in the daily business.
4. Experience qualifications in Pillar
Real Estate Services not in Pillar
Investment Co., who was the bidder.
5. Pillar Investment Co. and Pillar
Properties, Inc. both dba as Pillar
Real Estate Services. Two separate
corporations cannot ethically use the
same dba. Pillar Investment was
incorporated in 1979. Pillar
Properties, Inc. was incorporated in
1989.
106
6. Under Asset Management Experience in
Section B, it is stated the Chairman
Dianne Landen supervised the Asset
Management/Disposition Department
of 3 institutions with assets of 2.4
billion and managed portfolios of l
billion for large pension funds,
offshore investors and public firms.
These are not listed under her stated
experience in Section B.
The folloving is copied from section B Technical Section submitted
October 2S, 19 9 0 to RTC in MCO Contracting in reply to sos 7€l-
9966-900139-CS and verified as correct by Ronald Landen.
OZAKNE M. LAKDEN
2900 Glencliff Drive
Piano, Texas 7S07S
EXPERIENCE
PZX.IAR REAL ESTATE SERVICES - 1989-PRESEKT
Chairman\Chief Executive Officer
- Supervised the reporting, planning, and submissions to the
Financial Assistance Division of FHLB, for a Southwest
Plan Institution.
- Consulting work with 2 r^jor Southwest Plan Institutions
to include:
Financial assistance Agreement Compliance Officer/Covered
Asset Portfolio Manager for a Southwest Plan Institution
with a Portfolio of 300 Million.
- Review and prepare all submissions to FDIC in conjunction
with Financial Assistance Agreement.
Establish Marketing Strategies for Portfolio Dispositions
of Assets.
- Review all Sales Contracts received on Assets to
determine disposition viability.
- Analyze third party management companies to insure compe-
tent, professional management of Assets.
- Coordinate and review of Quarterly Yield Maintenance
Reports with Accounting Personnel.
- Conducting Asset management Seminars for banking and
Real estate executives.
Dianne M Landen was from 1989 and is still employed by Americity
Federal Savings Bank. On November 15, I visited the offices of
Americity Federal located at 750 N. St. Paul, Dallas, Tx. and
verified with Dianne Landen 's secretary and with the personnel
department that Dianne Landen was fully employed as Senior VP in
charge of REG and had been working there since Dec. 1, 1989.
Failure to disclose this employment is a very serious violation of
RTC regulations.
107
Attached is a Statement of Financial Condition, dated June 30,
1990, for Americity Federal Savings Bank, showing Dianne Landen
listed as Senior Vice President in the officers list. This
statement was picked up by me in the Bank office on November 15,
1990 when contacting the personnel office.
Seven phone calls to Pillar Investment Co. for Dianne Landen from
me were made over a 2 week period. Dianne was never in to answer
the phone and never returned a call. Her husband Ronald Landen
returned one call left for Dianne. I have never been able to talk
to Dianne because she was never at the place of business when calls
were made at different times during working hours.
Page 24 in Section B states the firm maintains in excess of
$100,000 in banks and money market accounts for purposes of
providing Adequate Liquidity. With a total assets as listed in Dun
& Bradstreet in the amount of $109,349 there is not much above the
$100,000 in an operating company. My visit to the office at 11910
Greenville Ave., Suite 200, that was 90% vacant would verify the
above statement. The Dun & Bradstreet report is attached.
On November 19, I called the Corporation department of the
Secretary of State for Texas and obtained the following
information:
Pillar Investment Co. incorporated June 11, 1979
Registered Agent - Ronald Landen
President - Ronald Landen
Treasurer - Ronald Landen
Director - Ronald Landen
Secretary - Dianne Landen
Director - Dianne Landen
Pillar Properties, Inc. incorporated January 19, 1989
Registered Agent - Ronald Landen
President - Ronald Landen
Vice President - Ronald Landen
Director - Ronald Landen
Sec/Treas - Dianne Landen
Director - Dianne Landen
Pillar Real Estate Services is not registered with the Secretary of
State as a corpcratign or as an assumed name.
In chapter 36.1-1 of the Texas Business and Commerce Code it states
that any corporation doing business in the State of Texas under an
assumed name staall file with the Secretary of State- -
The civil penalty in Chapter 36.25 of the Texas Business and
Commerce Code states that the dba not registered cannot defend or
bring a lawsuit in the State of Texas and has to pay all court
costs on any action brought against it.
108
T^e criminal penalty in Chapter 36.26 of the Texas Business and
Conunerce Code for failing to file a dba used by a corporation doing
business in Texas is a misdemeanor with a fine of $2,000.00.
Attached is a letter I received today from Karrey Turner, Personnel
Director for Americity Federal Savings Bank at 750 N. St. Paul,
Dallas verifying the employment of Dianne Landen as Senior Vice
President -Cover Asset Department. Americity Federal Savings is
Southwest Plan No. 11.
Attached is a memorandum from Elise Perkins thru Howard Blacker,
MCO Investigations Unit, dated Nov. 9, with reference "to Pillar
Investment Co., Contracting Fitness and Integrity Verification
Request.
Attached is a memorandum to Anna Croteau, Deputy Ethics Officer,
from J. Robert Yenco, Contract Specialist MCO, for review and
signed by Anna Croteau on Oct. 12, 1990. Many new facts have been
discovered by further investigations and a new ethics review is
warranted and requested.
Oualif ication of. Ethical Standards of Conduct for. and
Restrictions on the Use of Confidential Information by Independent
Contractor3.
1606.6 Organizational conflicts of interest.
(a) The following information shall be required about the
contractor and its related entities.
(3) The names of any contractor's related entities who have been
or are directors or officers of an insured depository institution.
- Dianne Landen is a related entity, and is and has been
employed by Americity Federal since Dec. 1, 1989. This
employment appears to be an organizational conflict of
interest.
(4) A list of all competing property of the contractor and its
related entities, if the contract relates to the valuation,
disposition, or management of real estate.
- Dianne Landen is Sr. VP, Americty Federal Savings Bank in
charge of REO department. This appears to be an
organizational conflict of interest.
(5) Information concerning any other business or financial
interest of the contractor, or its related entities, which could
adversely affect the contractors ability to perform under the
contract or to represent the RTC.
- Dianne Landen as head of the REO department of Americity
is selling to the same market as RTC is selling. This
appears to be an organizational conflict of interest.
109
(b) Certification required.
The contractor shall also provide the following certification:
(1) That no organizational conflict exists as a result of the
contractor's interests, relationships, or other RTC contracts.
- It appears that the failure to disclose the enployment of
Dianne Landen as Sr. VP or Americty Federal Savings is a
conflict of interest.
1606.7 Personal conflicts of interest.
(b) Information required.
A contractor shall obtain from its management officials and key
employees the following information about the personal, business,
and financial relationships of themselves, their spouses, and minor
children.
(2) Relationships within the last five years with any other
insured depository institution, or depository institution holding
company, as an officer, director, or controlling shareholder or
employee.
- No statement was made about the employment of Dianne
Landen as SR. VP of Americty Federal Savings but it was
stated that she worked for Filler Real Estate Services
1989 to present and certified correct by Ronald Landen
Registered Agent, President, Treasurer and Director of
Pillar Investment Co. dba Pillar Real Estate Services.
It appears that information about the employment of
Dianne Landen was purposely withheld to avoid having a
conflict of interest -
l\pi]
In view of the above facts, t I recommend \ Pi liar Investment Co. not
be used as a contractor for RTC for SOS /761-9966-,900139 - 143,
and the firm be removed from the Contractor Data Base as a MWOB
designation. / y f /
cc
Howard Blacker
William Roher
Janie Thomas
Don Epperson
Gary Gibson
^^j
'7
Ttoer 27, 1990
land vrit;ten statement on the right of
note was dictated by Gary Gibson and
written by Ed Isaacs as a substitute
the last paragraph, Instructions were
n to change this wording before taking
o the Deputy Ethics Officer Wayne Fogle.
/
L
^a,
&^^
c.
-V r
/,-
/
Ir-
,; r
< <
(^ .
r.A
110
(b) Certification req-uired.
The contractor shall also provide the following certification:
(1) That no organizational conflict exists as a result of the
contractor's interests, relationships, or other RTC contracts.
- It appears that the failure to disclose the employment of
Dianne Landen as Sr. VP or Americty Federal Savings is a
conflict of interest.
1606.7 Personal conflicts of interest.
(b) Information required.
A contractor shall obtain from its management officials and key
employees the following information about the personal, business,
and financial relationships of themselves, their spouses, and minor
children.
(2) Relationships within the last five years with any other
insured depository institution, or depository institution holding
company, as an officer, director, or controlling shareholder or
employee.
- No statement was made about the employment of Dianne
Landen as SR. VP of Americty Federal Savings but it was
stated that she worked for Piller Real Estate Services
1989 to present and certified correct by Ronald Landen
Registered Agent, President, Treasurer and Director of
Pillar Investment Co. dba Pillar Real Estate Services.
It appears that information about the employment of
Dianne Landen was purposely withheld to avoid having a
conflict of interest.
We request that you render a firm opinion as to the viability of
using Pillar Investment Co as a contractor for the MCO.
cc: Howard Blacker
William Roher
Janie Thomas
Don Epperson
Gary Gibson
Ill
Exhibit 2
MEMORANDUM
TO: Don Epperson
FROM: Jim Romer
DATE: July 9, 1991
SUBJECT: Non-refundable option fee to process cash sales offer.
It has been brought to my attention that an Asset Manager for RTC
has requested a non-refundable "option" fee in order to process a
cash sales contract for presentation to the review coitunittees of
the AMC and RTC.
The following are the facts and are obtained from the attached
documents:
1. Pillar Real Estate Services offer for sale of Asset #141. This
asset is 54 remaining lots in Prairie Creek Addition Phase II.
A price list on the 54 lots is attached.
2. Prairie Mound Limited Partnership, through their broker Jim
Douglas of Douglas Properties on May 14, 1991 made an offer to
Pillar Real Estate Services of $12,500.00 each for
approximately 50 lots for a total of $625,000.00.
3. On May 16, 1991 in a letter to Prairie Mound Limited
partnership, c/o Jim douglas. Pillar Real Estate Services
stated the May 14, 1991 offer had been reviewed and rejected.
Included in the same letter was a proposal from Pillar Real
Estate Services to sell the property for $790,000.00. No
mention was made in this proposal about non-refundable fee to
process the sales offer.
4. Prairie Mound Limited Partnership immediately accepted, signed
and returned Pillar's proposal, along with a contract of
Purchase of Sale on RTC form.
5. In a letter dated June 6, 1991 from Pillar to this prospective
purchaser, Pillar stated that, in order to process the
document for presentation to the review committees of Pillar
and the RTC, the following items were needed:
1. Signed personal financial statement of the buyer
2. Resume and background history of the buyer
3. Non-refundable option fee of $3,000.00
Jim Douglas states that after receiving the June 6 letter from
Pillar, he was told by Pillar the offer by his customers would not
be considered until the $3,000.00 was paid. In a later telephone
call Douclas was told Pillar would now accept $1,500.00 in lieu of
the $3,000.00
112
Next, I wrote to Ms. Sullivan, RTC Regional Director, and
hand delivered the letter to Ms. Sullivan on June 06. Her
assistant, Ms. Mary Kiesewetter promised to look into the
matters but not to my satisfaction. From the letter I
received on 6/25 signed by Mr. Joel James, I have the
impression that the letter was dictated by Ms. Diane Landen
(Chairman of Pillar) . Price was the only issue discussed
and that issue was no longer valid. Pillar, since then has
cut prices in half to sell to Builders! (See attached
letters)
At this point, the internal investigation of Pillar R/E
started:
• Somehow, Pillar R/E learned of my grievances against
the company within 24 hours. Mr. Ron Landen called me on
June 7 and he laughed at my efforts. Some of his comments:
« RTC can not do a damn thing for you! RTC has their
own problems to worry about, they don't worry about your
little offer! we have the authority to sell and make
decision, not RTC!
• Your Chinese buyers want something for nothing! If
they want to buy something cheaper then you need to take
them somewhere else!
• It doesn't matter how long will it takes to sell the
lots! We will be here!
• To save you time, there were people complained about
us before. They wrote to everybody: RTC, Congressman, Mr.
Siedman, everybody you can think of but President Bush.
But they did not get any results and they still have to come
back to deal with us.
The lot that I was negotiating was priced at $84,000 like
the others 3 corners lot of the same intersection. All the
lots were reduced to s75,00O except the one I worked with.
It stayed at the counter offered price 578,750!
" Mr. Ron Landen told me: Good things happened if you
deal directly with Pillar instead of wasting your time going
behind Pillar's back! It sounds like Mr. Ron Landen
penalized me for going to RTC?
• Mr. Ron Landen also mailed me a letter dated 6/26 and
gave me two days to submit a full price offer. I received
the letter on 6/28, the deadline in the letter!
All of the above statements represented indications of
discrimination from Pillar R/E Services. RTC is a
government agency and I don't understand how discrimination
can be practiced by a contractor doing business with the
go /ernme.nt?
Enclosed are all the ccrrespcndences and the new price list.
I hc?e ycu can help and I look forward to hear from ycu
soon.
C -i
ncsreiy yours.
\
I
113
Exhibit 3
July 16, 1991
Mr. Jim Romer
Contract Specialist
RTC Regional Sales Center
3500 Maple Avenue
Dallas, Texas 75219-3935
RE: Marketing Practice & Discrimination of Pillar R/E.
Dear Mr. Romer:
I have had a lot of difficulties in dealing with Pillar Real
Estate Services. I would like to call your attention into
the matter.
Problems arose when I submitted a offer on behalf of buyers
for lot 16, block C of The Hills of Indian Creek. The offer
was a cash purchase for S68,000 for the above lot. Pillar
R/E rejected the offer and they said they will not take
anything less than the $78,750 list price. Because I was
dissatisfied with Pillar's cold attitude, the inexperienced
of their Marketing Director, Mr. William Mach, (Mr. Mach
told me he was new on the job and knew little about the
subdivision), and Pillar's understanding about market
conditions, I contacted Mr. Corky Barton of RTC. He
referred me to Mr. Joe Williams but I did not get any
results. Mr. Williams told me about Pillar's promises with
a land developer not to discount lots at The Hills. The
result :
• In early June, Pillar R/E reduced prices unevenly.
Let 16A, block B, a golf course lot was reduced from 596,200
to S49.00O and was sold to Builders. Several other golf
course lots was reduced from $113,000 to $60,000 and again
sold immediately to Builders (Lot 2,3,30,31,32,39,40 of
block B, lot 1 of block D). There are others goT ^ courgp
lets reduced from 5115,000 to $75,000 (lot 23,24,25,26,27,28
29 of block E) . When I asked Mr. Ron Landen about these
lots and hope he would consider for the Buyers to change
lot, he then told me that he would not pay my office full
commission.
' A worthy note: The reduction was not publicized -on
Multiple Listing Services or News media nor Pillar informed
me about it. I only knew about the price change from a
builder.
• Their sub-contractor, Clarem Realty Partners is not a
member of Dallas nor Collin County Board of Realtors as RTC
stated in SOS requirements. There are no signs posted from
Clarem or Pillar R/E at the subdivision. The only signs
which the public would see since early 2/91 are from A G
Allen. (Mr. Alien is a Builder not working for Pillar).
Anybody called from the sign then have to deal with A G
Allen. (He likes to tell orospects that he owns all the
lets: )
X
114
4^
Eifi
'Dlt 4
Av
PILLAR REAL ESTATE SERVICES
:.::5 N Csniral Eiprtssviav. Sunc li% • Riciirflson. Teiis 750SO • :i«'6-^-"S:-5 • FAX '.\ii(>^-
1 1 V 1 19 91
Ms. Car-nen Sullivj
Regional Direocor
Resolution Trust Corporation
3500 Maple ;>venue
Dallas, Texas TSIIS
Dear Ms. Sullivan:
• JUL-
'^
yj
This letter is to advise you of an occurrence in the Dallas
Metroplex Consolidated Office which requires your ianediate
attention. v»e have been infonaed froa several sources at tne RTC
Regional Office and the MCO that Mr. Jira .Rocer has issued a
aenorandun which accuses representatives cf this firz of asKinc
for "bribes" m connection with the processing of REC Sales
Contracts. The "bribe" refers tc an Optio.". Fee requested froE a
prospective buyer m connection wit.h the sal. of land in the
Prairie CreeJc Subdivision m Flower Mound. The standard RTC
contract provides for taki.-.c an Option Fee i.n connection wit." the
sale of real estate. Pillar has done this on several occasions
and all funds received as Option Fees have been placed m ac-
counts designated for the RTC as Receiver.
The action take.n by this enployee is sla.nderous to the reputation
of t.his fira and its principals a.nd represents a defamation of
character assault.
This situation is ridiculous when one considers t.hat representa-
tives of the RTC Inspector General Office have been virtually
"livmc" m tiie ;ffice of Pillar during the last three aont.^s,
and would have reported any aisapprcpr lation cf funds. Adciticn-
ally , this fira .las been awarded a second .i.sset Management and
Disposition Agreer.ent froa the Kansas City Consolidated Office.
We seek t: have the contents of t.he foregoing aencrancur. to _e
publicly disavowed bv its writer and by yourself. Since t.^.e
riiaors m t.-.e Metroplex Consolidated Office have becoce so wide-
spread, we are ccncerned about its' future i-plicaticrs that r.ay
hinder Pillar's arilitv to obtain additional Asset Manaceaent
assicr.-er.t5 .
Caraen, our reputation is extreaely iaportant to us. Therefore
we must request a neetirc wit.h ycu as soon as possible. The
seriousness *of t.-.is situation cannot be ic.-.cred.
LOOK :or"-'arc to
'.earinc rroa
.■ou .
trulv yours,
115
Exhibit 5
MEMORANDUM
TO: Corky Barton
Jim May
Brent Ciurlino
FROM: Jim Romer
DATE: June 25, 1991
Subject: Phone inquiry - Jim Douglas on $3,000 Non-Refundable
Option Fee before a sales contract would be considered,
by Pillar Real Estate Services a SAMOA contractor.
June 24, 1991 - Jim Douglas inquired of Jim Romer, Contact
Specialist about RTC's requirements of non refundable processing
fees to get a cash sale of 50 lots considered by Pillar Real
Estate Services, a SAMOA contractor for RTC in charge of the lots
for sale.
In 40 years as a Real Estate Broker and Appraiser, I had never
encountered a processing fee having to be paid to the selling agent
before a sales contract would be considered. Not being in a
position of authority on RTC sales of assets, I contacted Corky
Barton in the RTC Sales Department. Corky Barton took me to Jim
Mays of f i> e where Brent Ciurlino was meeting. I presented the up
front fee problem to Corky, Jim and Brent. Brent Ciurlino stated
that if I could get written proof he would take appropriate action.
I drove to Jim Douglas office to get copies of the payment request
from Pillar. Attached are the following:
1. Pillar Real Estate offer for sale of Asset #141, 54 remaining
lots in Prairie Creek Addition Phase II. with an attached
price list on 4 6 of the 54 lots.
2. May 14 offer of $12,500 each for 50 lots or a total of
$625,000 with a contract drawn on RTC forms
3. May 16,1991 counter offer received from Pillar stating they
would consider $790,000 cash offer. The proposal was
accepted, signed and returned to Pillar along with a Contract
of Purchase of Sale on RTC forms. No mention was made in the
counter offer about up-front non-refundable fees.
4. June 6, 1991 letter from Pillar Real Estate Services to Jim
Douglas, the selling broker, stating that in order to process
the sales offer a non-refundable fee of $3,000. would have to
be paid.
116
5. June 14, 1991 letter from Jim Douglas to Pillar about bank
contacts regarding the buyer.
In a personal interview with Jim Douglas the following facts were
stated:
1. When Jim Douglas said he would not pay the $3,000, Pillar
stated that they would consider the offer for §1,500. Without
payment of the $1,500 the offer would not be considered when
the Pillar committee met on Monday June 24.
2. Douglas refused to pay the $1,500.
3. Jim Douglas was listing agent on three properties prior to
Pillar SAMOA contract and was excluded from the opportunity to
compete for the listing agreements when Pillar took over.
A. Bethany 409, Allen, Texas
Douglas had previously sold two tracts, one for $40,000
per acre for 50 acres and 25 acres for $25,000 per acre
in the previous year. There is a lawsuit on the property
involving RTC and Wayman Lavell who has offered to settle
the lawsuit for $8,000 per acre. Bill Lacy now has the
listing and is now trying to sell at $10,000 per acre on
a bid sutuation that requires a $5,000 non-refundable
option fee. The new appraisal is $21,000 per acre.
B. 1000 Oa'-s Subdivision, Lake Dallas & Cornith. Jim
Douglas l.as sent in two offers to Pillar but has received
no response. On this subdivision there are a number of
unresolved problems, an illegal sewer line across the
property and a $4 0,000 fee is owed to the City of Lake
Dallas. Douglas has offered information to Pillar to
help resolve these situations, which Pillar declined.
C. West Gate at Wiley. Jim Douglas sold 100 lots to Fox
Jacobs Builders and submitted contracts on the balance of
the lots to Pillar and was told they were not part of the
assets. After 6 or 7 weeks Douglas convinced Pillar that
the lots were part of their assets but Fox & Jacobs is
now out of lots and Pillar states that they cannot sell
any more lots until they get a new appraisal, by that
time Fox & Jacobs will be gone.
It appears the new agents do not know any of the past history of
the property and Pillar has told Douglas they do not care what
happened in the past. Ron Landon told Douglas the reason he was
not considered to continue listing the properties was that he did
not come up on the list.
117
Jim R'omer checked on the selection of a broker by Pillar for
property located in Lewisville one half mile from the listing
brokers office. The list of brokers for the property were selected
from a zip code in Denton, Texas which is several zip codes away
from the property.
To get further information in writing, I drove to ERA First City
Realty, 2312 Trinity Mills, Road, Carrollton- Tx. and visited with
Mike Doan and his broker Fred Marsh. Below is what I learned from
the conversation.
Mike Doan had a customer for a lot in Hills of Indian Creek. Mike
drove to the lot sites and the only for sale signs that were on
the property were those of R. G Allen. R. G. Allen told Mike the
lots belonged to RTC but would not give him the name of the agent.
Mike learned that Pillar was in charge of the RTC lots. On
contacting Pillar, Mike talked to William T. Mach, Jr. marketing
manager for Pillar about a lot for his client and was given a one
page outline of the project the only information Pillar had
available for a prospective buyer although Pillar had been managing
the property since last December. Mach explained that he was new
to the job and knew very little about the properties.
Mike Doan produced a copy of a letter to Carmen Sullivan dated June
2, 1991 explaining his not being able to get an offer accepted for
$68,500 cash for a lot not joining the golf course that was
appraised at $84,000 when a lot that was appraised at $103,000 was
sold for $49,000 to the b>-ilder, R. G. Allen who had his for sale
signs on the RTC properties for months. It was also learned that
the same builder had purchased several lots at $60,000 that were
appraised at $103,000.
Ron Landon told Mike Doan he liked to sell to builders and not to
individuals but if he would work with him he would get a better
deal than with RTC.
Joe Williams told Mike that his offer was a good offer but that
Pillar is not going to sell that lot because Pillar promised to
sell only to builders.
Mike talked to Ron Landon, Thursday, 20th of June and was told that
he had sent letter to RTC and it does no good and he knows the man
who will do the investigating.
Mike talked to Dianne Landon and she said she wanted to sell the
lot but he needed to get buyer to go up on price.
Ron Landon called back and laughed at Mike, stating contacting RTC
doesn't do any good. Bring the price to full price and you will
get paid 6%. From now on he will only get 3% and the other 3% will
go to Clarion Realty after July 1. Ron said he will decide who
gets a contract.
118
Attac.'ied are the following documents received from Mike Doan:
1. June 2, 1991 letter to Carmen Sullivan.
2. June 6, 1991 answer to letter by Mary Kieswetter.
3. Copy of Pillar Price list for Hills of Indian Creek.
4. Copy of a new June price list from Clarion Realty Partners
showing lot F16A priced at $49,000 and marked sold with the
adjoining lots priced at $84,000.
5. Copy of lot plans for Hills of Indian Creek.
6. Copy of letter to Mike Doan's friend Richard.
After the meeting with Mike Doan, I drove to the subject lots and
took pictures to show the comparison of the two lots, the one sold
for $49,000 located on the golf course and the one refused at
$68,500 located off the golf course. I also took pictures of the
builders for sale signs on RTC property and noted that there is no
way for a prospective buyer to know that the lots belong to RTC and
are for sale by a broker.
Attached are following:
Copy Pillar's price list for Asset /114
Copy price list from Claren Realty Partners
Pictures of Lot C 16 taken from W, N, E i S. priced $78,750 to
Mike Doan. This lot is off golf course and not level.
Pictures of Lot F 16 A taken from W, N, E i S. Sold for
$4 9,000. This lot is located on golf Course and is flat.
Pictures of Lot B 39 taken from W, N, E & S. Located on golf
course sold for $60,000.
Pictures of Lot B 40 taken f re n W. N, E & s. Located on Golf
course.
Normally golf course lots are priced from $15,000 to $40,000 higher
than the lots not on the golf course. Because of view and golf
course location of the three lots sold above. Lot C 16 which Mike
Doan is trying to buy value is at least $15,000 less than the lots
sold.
Pillar Real Estate Services is discriminating against a Minority-
Oriental Real Estate Agent. If this discrimination continues, it
will cause a lot of bad publicity for RTC and possible
Congressional investigation.
On Monday, June 24, 1991, Ron Landon and Dianne Landon in a phone
conversation with Mike Doan demanded full price on the lot of
$78,750.
I believe these are the written facts that Brent Cirlino asked for
so that he could take the proper action.
cc Fred Born
Lloyd Edwards
Don Epperson
119
Exhibit 6
TO: Fred Born
Lloyd Edwards
Don Epperson
FROM: Jim Romer
DATE: April 8, 1992 \^/Jk^
SUBJECT: TnnlTil 1 iniT an- ijBa<7in<7 system on Banyon Netvork,1* reduc«>-^ ,
operating costs and ispe«7e quality .-of-vorit y «
Production of RTC personnel can be increased by over 30% by usin?
inaging software on the computer netvorlc.
Please review this neae for presentation to the RTC Automation
Committee at its next meeting. ^~~^_
Installing and using an imaging system for storing and retrieving
documents will reduce operation 'costs. •
• Save time in document retrieval
• Reduce file storage space and costs
• Eliminate lost files
• R^<5ord chronologically faxes sent and received
• M^Jce disaster recovery quick ana inexpensive
Time saved in document retrieval time will reduce costs. ^
A document c«i be retrieved by any word or combination of
words in less than 15 seconds. That is less time than it
takes to tell a secretary to bring a file. Time for action can
be increased from 20% to 60% by reducing the time finding
document from 50% of our time to 10%. Time saved will pay for
the total system in less than 60 days.
Storage space and cost of file cabinets will be reduced.
An optical disk the size of your hand will store 20,000
documents or the equivalent of a 4 drawer file cabinet. File
space will be saved" and cost of file cabinets will be reduced.
y
Eliminating lost files will improve productivity.
Three per cent of all files are lost. Lost files cost time
and money. In the future files will be permanently stored on
optical WORM drives for permanent legal record. Any file can
be brought up on computer screen quickly.
120
Time wasted standing at the fax machine will be eliminated.
May hours are lost by people standing at the fax machine. On
the proposed software system faxes are received automatically
on computer. Fax is relayed to the correct person or persons
on the network where it can be read or printed. Any document
can be sent by fax by typing the phone number and pressing F.
The time saving from hours lost at the fax machine will pay
for the installation.
Disaster recovery vill be a reality at a very low cost.
Duplicating the optical disk and storing at another location
will insure recovery of records should a disaster happen.
Disaster Recovery without duplicate records could cost
millions.
I
<
Please present this program at the next meeting of the RTC
Automation Committee. This investment will increase productivity
by over 30%. The software to cover 20 users can be purchased for
$8,000.00. The savings in personnel costs will pay for the
installation of the system in less than 60 days.
Thank you for your consideration of this document imaging plan. If '
you desire further details please call Jin Romer at 443 2298.
Sirtcere/y,
121
TESTIMONY OF DEBBIE SHERRILL
My name is Debbie Sherrill. I am from Russellville, Alabama, near Florence, and
I work at the RTC office in Atlanta, Georgia as a Claims/Settlement Specialist, I
have been at the RTC three years. Previously, I worked for a bank.
I came to the RTC in 1990 in hopes that I would be able to help the government
take over the failed savings and loans and sell off their assets and learn something
in the process. I expected that RTC would do its job according to the law and rea-
sonable business practices. I found, unfortunately, that RTC could not do this job.
So I am here today, as a concerned taxpayer as well as an employee of the RTC
to tell this committee of the waste, fraud, abuse and mismanagement that I have
personally seen. Frequently, managers were promoted to positions that they could
not perform properly. Because unqualified people were hired, they were often not
competent to perform their jobs, and very substantial sums of money were lost. I
also found that unqualified people were especially unlikely to accept suggestions for
improvements. Such suggestions were taken very personally and rejected, often with
the employee being reprimanded for making the suggestion. Because unqualified
people were hired, they protected one another, promoted one another, and too often
drove out the good people.
The following stories are only a few examples of the waste, fraud and abuse I
have encountered at the RTC. ^me of the examples are directly due to incompetent
management. Others are fundamental institutional problems.
• One example of management incompetence: RTC is legally required when
it sells financial assets to a bank to pay interest on any assets that are not delivered
on time. When a deal is made, assets must be moved within a certain time frame
so that RTC does not have to pay interest to the acquiring bank. Our staff is not
competent to make decisions, and often defers making those decisions. While the
staff waits, because of the department head's ability to make decisions, the money
sits there. Deals that should take place the next business day instead are taking
three days to three weeks or more, and during that time, the RTC is accumulating
liabilities to the acquiring bank. We have to pay the acquiror interest based on the
T-bill rate plus 100 basis points. At one institution I had over $4 million dollars sit-
ting in an account paying approximately 8 percent, interest on. The RTC wastes
tens of thousands of dollars a aeal.
• Contractor waste, fraud and abuse is a rampant problem. For example:
1. Padding of bills. Firms are billing for more hours than were actually worked
and/or billing for more hours than is reasonable to complete the task.
2. Unqualified, incompetent staff. Firm sends untrained and unqualified personnel
to field site even though contract calls for experienced personnel. Result is inac-
curate data and inferior work product.
3. Under bidding for contract, then once awarded contract firm is re-submitting
an amendment to contract increasing the cost 2 to 3 times. Example: A Big Six ac-
counting firm original bid was $95,000 for the Claims/Settlement portion only. They
were awarded the contract. Within the first few weeks of the contract the firm sub-
mitted an amendment for over $270,000. That's an increase cost of $175,000 for just
mv department. I shutter to think of what the entire contract cost was! RTC accept-
ed the adjustment.
4. Delaying review of contractor work and responsive action when problems occur.
Example: Firm was hired to conduct an Furniture, Fixture & Equipment appraisal
and branch facility appraisal in South Ctirolina. When the appraisals were submit-
ted it was evident that the appraisals were blatantly wrong. There was furniture
and equipment listed that didn't even exist. Furniture and equipment items were
listed as being located in one branch when in reality they were at another location.
Due to geographic location of the branches a reasonable time frame to complete this
pTOjject would he three to four days. The project was completed in one! The presen-
tation and quality of work submitted was very poor. Yet knowing all of this, RTC
paid for the appraisal anyway. RTC's response was to hire another contractor for
a second appraisal; costing the RTC approximately $100,000 for a project that
should have cost approximately $30,000.
Another example of RTC management's unwillingness to take action to confront
contractors was with a Big Six accounting firm hired to complete a project in Rich-
mond, VA. RTC needed to cancel the contract. The quality of work was very poor,
inaccurate data, deadlines were not met. Even the acquiring institution complained
about the contractors performance. I discussed these problems many times. I re-
fused to sign-off on bills submitted by the firm. I refused to sign-off of actual institu-
tion work submitted by the firm. I discussed these problems with the firms man-
agers and RTC managers. RTC paid the firm anyway.
122
These type of incidents are very disturbing to me because these same contractors
and appraisers are submitting bids for new jobs and getting them even though the
work product has been proven to be sub-standard quality. We hired these people,
we could also fire these people. But because of the insecurity and incompetence of
the management staff they are not willing to take responsibility for firing or cancel-
ing a contract. We are tedking about hundreds of thousand of dollars of waste on
this single project.
5. Hiring of too many contractors to audit other contractors. This is ludicrous be-
cause someone in my position audits the work, then PCR audits the work, IG audits
the work and GAO audits the work. Despite all of these audits, we hire a contractor
to audit the work again. These audits are costing hundreds of thousemds of doUars.
We already know what the problems are long before these extra audits reveal them.
But although we know it, too often nothing is done about it because no one is willing
to take the responsibility for initiating any action. Why, because incompetent man-
agers are often too afraid to make a decision.
6. Much of the work conducted by the contractors could he done in-house. We al-
ready have the trained staff to do what the contractors are hired to do. But we hire
the contractors anyway, usually more than are needed for the job. When I expressed
concern about this, my manager said, "don't worry about it. Congress wants us to
hire contractors." The consensus of the office is: If we don't want to do a particular
task simply hire a contractor. The result: We wind up paying them when they do
no work and unnecessary work to justify hiring them so it doesn't look bad.
When you don't conduct timely and stringent oversight of the contractors the
waste, abuse and fraud are going to happen. I cannot say for sure how much fraud
there is, but when you give people an open door to rob you, how many people are
going to take advantage of you? Audits six months later won't protect you.
The most frustrating part of all of this many of these problems are very fixable.
But all too often, when suggestions are made to correct these problems you are rep-
rimanded and criticized by management for doing so. Because you are asking man-
agers to do what managers are supposed to do: To make decisions that may require
certain actions to be taken to either correct or prevent a problem. Unqualified, inse-
cure managers are not capable of doing this. Result: The problems get worse.
• Other examples of upper managements lack of response to complaints
and issties of concern. I was given an "detailed" assignment in West Virginia
which required that I stay at the field site until a person could be hired to perma-
nently fill that position, llie person hired had a severe drinking problem. He missed
key meetings with the banks staff and the acquiring institution. His secretary found
liquor in his desk. Twice the local police found him on the street "passed-out" and
had to take him to his hotel. Many complaints from the president of the acquiring
bank, his own staff and myself were brou^t forward. I discussed these problems
with our director, wrote memo's; yet weeks went by with no action taken by man-
agement. Action was finally taken when RTC realized the acquiring bank was going
to take the issue to CNN media news network. Result: The employee transferred
back to the office in Atlanta, no reprimands were given, and within six months was
given a promotion. I could go on and on with similar stories.
• Other areas of waste and abuse due to mismanagement. The key person-
nel's apathy for RTC rules and regulations and their display of this apathy to their
peers and subordinates. I've had two supervisors who blatantly disregarded policies
and procedures. Who practiced intimidation, various forms of sexual discrimination
and harassment to manage their staff, reprimanding or firing anyone who ques-
tioned these actions. Yet, no actions were taken by the supervisors for their conduct.
Result: The managers are promoted, your most qualified employees either leave or
are fired, the employees that do stay are too afraid to do anything about problems
they encounter for fear of losing their jobs.
Often Fve heard these supervisors and other department heads say, "RTC is a
special entity that is not held accountable under the same rules and regulations as
other government agencies. This type of attitude leads to abuse and waste at every
level. From employees abusing sick time and overtime to management discriminat-
ing and harassing employees. Written policies and procedures are in place at RTC
but they are not enforced.
As I have told Committee staff, I have seen various form of sexual discrimination
and harassment at the RTC and other personnel problems there, some of which has
been quite serious, which I would be willing to discuss to some extent in the event
that you wished to question me about it.
123
TESTIMONY OF WILLIAM A. HENDERSON
RTC Employment History
My name is William A. Henderson. I reside in Atlanta, Georaa, I am a legal in-
formation technician in the Resolution Trust Corporation's (RTC) Atlanta office,
Legal Division. Prior to my RTC assignment, I worked as a case management techni-
cian in the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation's (FDIC), Atlanta Office, Legal
Division. I was an FDIC employee from September 2, 1986 through August 9, 1989,
the date the RTC was established under the Financial Institutions Reform, Recov-
ery, and Enforcement Act (FIRREA). In order to staff its newly created offices, hun-
dreds of experienced FDIC employees, including myself, were "loaned" to the RTC.
Mismanagement
As a legal information technician, I was reassigned to the RTC to input, and
maintain data pertaining to legal biUs submitted by law firms hired to perform legal
services for the RTC. I currently work in the RTC's Legal Information System
(RLIS) Unit. Since its inception, the RLIS Unit has been plagued with mismanage-
ment. Attorneys representing outside law firms with overdue RTC bills have been
allowed to enter the RLIS Unit, often times unescorted. Presumably a breech of se-
curity, they have been allowed direct access to the RLIS computerized system which
enabled them to have access to confidential billing, and pajmient information. As a
result, these attorneys were given the authority to use the RLIS system to pay their
own bills.
Due to management's negligence, I have seen duplicate, and even triplicate pay-
ments dispensed to law firms for a single invoice for legal services. Such blatant
negligence, and unethical practices directly violates the KTC's mission to maximize
return, minimize the losses of managed, and resolved savings & loans.
Waste
Following the restructuring of the RTC, which closed and consolidated several of-
fices around the country, the RTC had been inundated with numerous gratuitous
moves. Several sections, and divisions of the RTC have been required to move three
or more times in less than a year. Most of the moves do not unite these sections
or divisions, nor do they generate additional work space for them. Although the
moves are often within a close proximity, and do not involve furniture to be moved,
professional movers are hired. Professional movers, under contract with the RTC,
move employee boxes from one building to another, or from one floor to the next
within the same building. The moving section or division's computers, and tele-
phones are moved or electronicallv reassigned internally. The internal
aepartment(s) bill the time for moving tne equipment to the movmg section or divi-
sion.
Generally, the moves last approximately eight hours which means the profes-
sional moving contractor bills the RTC eight or more hours for every move. The in-
ternal department(8) responsible for moving the computers, and telephones bill the
moving sections or division for the move, and any preliminary time spent to prepare
for the move. All moves, necessary or otherwise unnecessary, are billed at taxpayer
expense. In addition, during a move the employees of the moving section or division
are unable to perform their designated tasks for an entire work day. Therefore, the
entire section or division is incapacitated for an entire work day.
Disregard for Federal Rules and Regulations
The flagrant disregard for rules and regulations is pervasive throu^-out the
RTC. Managers often chide "we are RTC: not FDIC or nJiis does not apply to the
RTC," therefore implying the RTC does not have to abide by the same rules and
regulations as the FDIC. Management's perception that the RTC is "a quasi govern-
ment organization" has breed an atmosphere of arrogance. Since they believe they
are not a full fledged government agency, they have a mandate to pick and choose
which Federal government rules and regulations they want to follow, and those they
wish to disregard. This has led to numerous ethics, Equal Employment Opportunity
(EEO), and Office of Persormel Management (0PM), violations.
When addressing the concerns of career Federal employees (General Graded em-
gloyees), and their return to the FDIC, commonly referred to as the "putbadc," the
TC's actions not only demonstrate a disregsu-d for, but an ignorance of, 0PM guide-
lines, rules, and regulations. As a result, the RTC did not use 0PM guidelines.
124
rules, and regulations to plot the course of the "putback" when it began over a year
and a half ago.
EEO: Inefficient and Ineffective
The RTC has reduced EEO to a puppet operation. EEO's autonomy to resolve
coniplaints without management's interference is nonexistent. Essentially, the
RT(7s EEO office is a pro-management organization used by management to quash
rather than resolve EEO complaints. Currently, the RTC's EEO Office is clogged
with complaints that are still in the informal preliminary stage of the complaint
process, and have been stalled in that stage for more than a year.
As an EEO representative, I have represented at least five complainants in the
past year and a half. During that time, I witnessed management's refusal to cooper-
ate with EEO officials. This refusal to cooperate includes the failure to provide in-
vestigators with request for documents, and oral testimony. As a result, investiga-
tors nave difficulty following the EEO timetable which governs every step of the
complaint process. Therefore, employees have no viable means of resolving oiscrimi-
nation complaints against the RTC.
Conclusion
The RTC's propagandist tactics, discriminatory practices, and unethical behavior
have bred an atmosphere of distrust and paranoia within the organization. Manage-
ments attempts to address the problems I have just discussed are nothing more
than superficial remedies used to cloud the issues and pacify its employees. It is my
hope that my testimony today illustrates a need to provide meaningful solutions to
the problems which ail the RTC. Thank you.
STATEMENT OF DEANNA SMITH
I am pleased to appear before the Committee today in response to your request
concerning my experience at the RTC. I am today employed by the FDIC in the At-
lanta Regional Ouice as an administrative assistant with resjponsibility for payrolls
and travel vouchers. I had one particular experience at the RTC which I believe rep-
resents a clear case of waste, fraud and abuse. I held a similar position at the RTC
to the one I have now at the FDIC.
I was originally hired by the FDIC Legal Division in the Atlanta Regional Office.
FDIC trained me in the handling of vouchers and receipts by employees when they
claim reimbursement for business related expenses. Obviously, one of the main
things you are looking for when you handle such vouchers is to protect the FDIC
insurance funds by making sure that people are not getting paid by the government
for personal business. I was trained by the FDIC to look out for such practices.
Our office was converted from the Atlanta Regional Office of the FDIC to the
Eastern Regional Office of the RTC, which is taxpayer funded. After management
was changed from FDIC to RTC in 1991, I found an apparent problem on a travel
voucher submitted by the net Deputy Regional Counsel.
The nature of the problem was chai^ng a rental car for personal use and billing
the RTC. I was askea to review the manager's travel voucher prior to its formal sub-
mission, and I did so. When I did, I confronted him about the rental car charge.
He acknowledged that he had used the car for personal business. I told him he was
not authorized to charge personal expenses on the government's Diner's Club charge
card, and I wanted to give him an opportunity to correct the voucher before he sub-
mitted it for reimbursement and auditing. He screamed at me and told me that I
didn't know my job. I told him that it was very hard for me to confront someone
in his position with this, and hoped it would not be held against me. I told him I
would caU Washington about this. He told me he would call Washington as well.
I called Washington and spoke with the person in the travel unit. I asked if the
charge was appropriate and whether I was correct. They told me I was. I told them
they might want to start pulling his vouchers to check them. They told me to tell
him the charge was wrong, and that he should not do it again. I relayed the mes-
sage to him and it made him even madder. Nothing was ever done to mscipline him
that I know of. I don't recall seeing the voucher again. I have no way of knowing
whether he corrected the voucher. If he didn't correct the voucher, I do not know
whether he ever paid the charge back. I later heard from employees in other offices
that he had a problem with travel vouchers. As of today, this manager is still at
the RTC.
125
Needless to say, I believe that I experienced retaliation as a result of having in-
sisted on following the rules and reporting the travel voucher problem. Several
times it had been suggested to me by the head of the office that I would be selected
for an adnoinistrative assistant, training, jxjsition which had promotion potential. I, ^
was not selected. RTC later sought to relocate me to the Philadelphia RTC office, \i.
which I fought. About eighteen months after the incident, I was fortunate to be re- ';
turned to the FDIC.
This experience was very chilling to me. It makes me hesitant to pick up the
Fhone to report waste, fraud, or abuse to the Inspector General hotline, because if
do, someone may find out and I may be punished. As a taxpayer, I also was very
angry, because it was a case of the government being ripped-oii. I thank the Com-
mittee for the opportunity to testify today.
TESTIMONY OF ANNETTE LePIQUE
Hello, my name is Annette LePique, I am an employee of the RTC Newport
Beach, California Office. I wish to begin by, thanking Chairman Reigle, Senator
Barbara Boxer and all the Members of the Committee for the invitation to appear
this morning. I am here today to speak about my personal experiences at the RTC
regarding fraud, waste and mismanagement, specifically as it relates to the han-
dling of claims of discrimination and harassment.
Professional Background
I am a native of St. Louis, Missouri, with an undergraduate degree in Social
Work, and a Masters Degree in Public Administration from the University of Mis-
souri. I came to work at the RTC in February, 1990, after many years experience
in the affordable housing field. I transferred to the California Office from the Kan-
sas City Office to assume the position of Affordable Housing Specialist, responsible
for that program in the states of California, Hawaii, Oregon, Washington and Alas-
ka. After enjoying years of success working primarily in the Midwest, Southeast and
Colorado, I viewed this as a tremendous opportunity to truly gain a national per-
spective on Affordable Housing issues. I felt particularly challenged and excited
about working in California, a state with a tremendous need for affordable housing.
I left family and friends to begin my new life and career in California July 2, 1990.
Personnel Perspective of RTC's Affordable Housing Program
RTC's Affordable Housing Program was created in 1989 in the original Financial
Institutions Reform, Recovery, Enforcement Act (FIRREA). The program has proven
itself to be one of the truly bri^t spots in the Savings and Loan clean up, providing
rental opportunities for thousands of low-income Americans, and home ownership
to low- and moderate-income taxpayers who had previously only dreamed the Amer-
ican dream. I was proud to be a part of this program in the early days, establishing
sales guidelines, pwlicies and procedures. We successfully took the message of our
program to the local communities in California, so desperately in need of this pre-
cious commodity. I worked closely with the staff of all the offices, including D.C. The
California Ofiice found itself the owner of affordable housing in over thirty states
besides California. This was a result of California savings and loans having made
or purchased loans with underlying collateral in other parts of the country. My af-
fordable housing experience was to oecome truly national in a very short time.
Sexual Harassment and Gender Based Discrimination
Over a period of nearly two and one half years, I endured the sexist remarks, de-
rogatory statements and actions of my supervisor, as senior management look on
and did nothing. One complaint filed against this individual in September, 1991 re-
sulted in a settlement with the woman, who left the REC shortly after that. He on
the other hand, was promoted several times. His actions were totally inappropriate
for the work place, and almost always involved women subordinate to him. The
truth is, given the hiring policies of the REC, it would have been difficult to find
any women who weren't subordinate to him. Women simply do not exist in the
upper levels of management at the REC.
As a witness in one of his previous EEO actions, I was targeted for retaliation.
With the arrival of Mr. A.J. Felton, personal friend of Mr. Stanley Tate, and Philip
V. Jones Jr. to the California office, as Vice President and Deputy Vice President
respectively, the stage was set. Having no knowledge of the operations of the Cali-
76-818 0-94-5
126
fomia ofiice, my harasser became the de facto head of the ofiice. My harasser wield-
ed tremendous power and influence in the office, promoting friends and punishing
enemies, usually women and minorities. When I was reconunended for a promotion
to the LG-15 in July 1992, commensurate with my duties as now Department Head
of the Affordable Housing section, the silence from top management was deafening.
Finally in November, 1992, after searching, several months for a reason, Mr. Philip
Jones Jr. informed me that I would not receive the promotion to LG-15. In that
same two week period, rumors of my alleged sexual activities again surfaced at the
office, and I was once again subjected to a sexist comment, this time in the presence
of my family and friends at an REC sponsored function. Enough was enough. On
November 19, 1992 at approximately 10 a.m. I called Washington D.C. and initiated
a claim of sexual harassment, gender based discrimination and retaliation against
three most senior managers at the REC California Office.
Filing an EEO Claim
Since California senior management had never bothered to appoint EEO coun-
selors, I requested an EEO counselor from the Kansas City office, one I knew to
have a fairly strong commitment to affirmative hiring and a fair and equitable work
place. Of course everything is relative when you work at the California Office! A
counselor was assigned immediately, and the investigation began.
The investigation was informal, but comprehensive and weU documented. The as-
signed EEO counselor, Don Sears, was objective, thorough and completed the inves-
tigation in a timely manner. EEO staff from our D.C. office, were professional and
very responsive to my questions and concerns. The investigation was completed on
December 18, 1992 a month after it began. During that thirty day period, my har-
asser was transferred to another Executive level position. The final report affirmed
my claims of harassment, gender based discrimination and retaliation. The findings
where presented to senior management over the phone the same day.
Retaliation
On November 19, 1992 at approximately 5:30 p.m., I was handed what was to be
the first of many adverse personnel actions taken against me. Less than eight hours
after filing for protected activity under Title VII, Philip V. Jones Jr. led the charge
against me, in the form of this first action. I had dared to challenge his decision,
and I had taken on the "good old boy" system.
Before the EEO counselor could begin his investigation, Mr. Felton and Mr. Philip
Jones began an independent, unauthorized investigation of their own. My depart-
ment, as well as myself were the subject of this investigation.
Throughout the remaining days of'^November into the first week of January 1993,
my entire operation was reviewed, every transaction put under a microscope, and
every file was pulled for review. The final investigation was completed and pub-
lished in early January. Since there were no negative findings, it was never men-
tioned again, and I was not given a copy of it until March 22, 1993, long afler I
gave up asking for it.
Having failed to turn up information to support the claims against me, a meeting
was scheduled to review my performance. Four separate performance reviews were
completed, all back dated, some for periods I had already been reviewed. All showed
progressively deteriorating performance. A letter of termination was prepared as
well, but was not given to me at that meeting. At that time I was represented by
counsel, and attended the meeting with my newly hired attorney, John W. Lewis.
I was to receive in the next two and one half months, a total of seven reprimands,
all of which I added to my EEO complaint, or filed administrative grievances. Not
once did senior management grant me any type of relief. In a letter to my attorney
Mr. AJ. Felton denied the existence of my signed annual performance review. He
refused to acknowledge the existence of the original signed document, regardless of
the proof offered.
Fraud, Waste and Mismanagement at the RTC
My reason for appearing today is not to discuss in any great detail the afTect these
events have had on me personally, rather to outline for you the costs to the corpora-
tion in time wasted, actual dollars spent, and staff turnover resulting from severe
moral problems related to these injustices.
The investigation of the Affordable Housing Department took approximately six
weeks with three stafT persons working full time on it. In addition, my entire staff,
then four people devoted a significant amount of time daily to assisting the inves-
127
tigative team. This represents a needless waste of thousands of dollars of taxpayers
money, simply in an act of retaliation.
This was not the only investigation ordered by Mr. Jones and Mr. Felton relative
to my complaint. Ignoring the findings of the EEO investigation, and against the
advice of REC legal staflVMr. Jones launched an internal investigation of the sexual
harassment claim. Interviewing only certain employees, ultimately totalling ninety-
four persons, a court reporter documented answers to a series of questions osten-
sibly to get to the truth. Employees who did speak out, even with the promise of
confidentiality, were inmiediately summoned to Mr. Jones' office and queried about
their statements. In spite of the adversarial nature of the proceedings, some thir-
teen hundred pages confirmed what management refused to oelieve. Sexual harass-
ment and improprieties were widespread and unchecked in the California Office.
After spending several more thousand dollars on this investigation, something had
to be done.
The senior manager alleged to have harassed me was never at any time rep-
rimanded by his superiors, Mr. Scott Darling, Mr. Jones and Mr. Felton. On the
other hand, I had a personnel file, prior to November 19, 1992 unblemished, full
of adverse actions. They had something a little different in mind for him.
Following the third investigation, the alleged harasser was "detailed" to a subsidi-
ary of Home Fed Bank, Home Capitol, in San Diego, California. Here he was to re-
main for the next seven months, on fiill pay, ostensibly on a "special assignment."
Travel records that I have attached to my written statement clearly show that his
assignment did not include going into the office, he was hiding out in San Diego,
courtesy of Mr. Jones, Mr. Felton and most importantly, the Federal taxpayer. At
a cost of approximately $700 per week in lodging, per diem, and travel expenses,
in addition to his approximate $2,000 a week salary, he was kept in hiding in San
Diego, California. Travel records clearly show there was no "special assignment" he
in fact was not even going in to the office.
These events related to an EEO claim, have now cost the taxpayers hundreds of
thousands of dollars in excessive and sometimes useless investigations, lost staff
hours, and plummeting moral at the California Office.
TESTIMONY OF SANDRA CRISMAN
I would like to begin by thanking the Chairman and the Committee for the invita-
tion to appear this morning. I am here to describe my personal experience with gen-
der based discrimination at the RTC and Senior Management's response to my fuuig
an EEO complaint. I believe my experiences can be summarized in five statements.
1. I was denied a promotion which I had earned.
2. Management's attempts to justify the denial were false and inappropriate.
3. Following the filing of my EEO Complaint, Management engaged in acts of
reprisal against me.
4. Management's stated stsmdards of performance were not applied consistently
between male and female Department Heads.
5. Despite the RTC's confirmation of discrimination and reprisal in my case,
RTC's Executive Management here in Washington promoted the individual who
discriminated against me.
Promotion Denied
My professional career has spanned both the public and private sectors. Prior to
joining the RTC, my career included five years experience with the Internal Reve-
nue &rvice in Human Resources Management and three years experience with
Hughes Aircraft Company in Aerospace Contracting. I possess a Bachelor's Degree
in Management and a Master's Degree in Finance.
My employment with the RTC began in July 1990, when I was hired by the Cali-
fornia Office as a Contract Specialist LG— 13. m March 1991 I was appointed as Act-
ing Department Head for the Contracts/REO Department. The position was posted
at the LG— 15 level in June. I applied, was selected for the position, and promoted
to LG-14 in August 1991. At that time I was told by my supervisor WiUiam
Sylvestre, Assistant Director, Contract Management, that if I performed satisfac-
torilv I would be promoted to the LG-15 in one year. Working one grade below the
level of the position was not uncommon as 0PM regulations prohibited advancing
more than one grade per year. Mr. Sylvestre left the Contracts Department in
March 1992, and Janie Thomas was appointed as Acting Assistant Director, Con-
tract Management.
128
In June 1992, I received a Superior Performance Award. On July 13, 1992, I re-
ceived an excellent performance review from Ms. Thomas. Her supervisor, Al
Porterfield, Director of Administration, added the following comment to my ap-
{iraisal Thank you for the fine performance, please keep up the outstanding per-
ormanoe next year." Ms. Thomas recommended mv promotion to LG-15 and Mr.
Porterfield submitted the recommendation to Phil Jones, Assistant Vice President,
California Ofiice. On August 11, 1992 I was informed by Janie Thomas that Mr.
Jones had denied my promotion.
Management's Attempts at Justification
I believe that Mr. Jones' reasons for not promoting me were contrived in failed
attempts to justify his discriminatory actions.
Sales Goals'
At the time my promotion was denied, I was told that Mr. Jones would not con-
sider approving my promotion until after September 30, 1992, at which time he
would know whether the California Office had met its annual sales goals. However,
I had never been told my performance would be tied to the sales of the office. This
requirement was not in my position description, nor was it a factor on my perform-
ance evaluation. I was aware that a promotion in the Contracts Department had
been approved in July for a male Contract Specialist. I was also aware that made
Department Heads in the California Ofiice were routinely promoted to the LG-15
level after one year in grade at the LG-14 level. Therefore, in August 1992 I filed
an EEO complaint. However, because there were no EEO counselors at the Califor-
nia Office, my complaint was assigned to a counselor in the Kansas City Ofiice.
During the EEO investigation I was informed that management fabricated new
reasons Tor the denial of my promotion. Mr. Jones stated that a poor Program Com-
pliance Review and Inspector General's Office investigation were sufficient grounds
to deny my promotion. The facts do not support this aflegation.
Program Compliance Review
A Program Compliance Review (F*CR) is an annual review of each department
that is conducted by Washington Ofiice staff. The Contracts Department PCR took
place in June 1992. The rating scale is compliant, substantially compliant, ade-
quately compliant, or noncompliant. Upon completion of the review, it is customary
for the leader of the review team to have an exit conference with senior manage-
ment. Mr. Bert Stacey headed the review of the Contracts Department. In the June
1992 exit conference with Messrs. Felton and Jones, President and Vice President
of the California Office, Mr. Stacey indicated that the Contracts Department re-
ceived a "substantially compliant" rating. Mr. Stacey noted that during his review
he became aware of the fact that officials outside tne Contracts Department were
taking inappropriate actions that ultimately impacted the Contracts Department.
For example, program officials were making contractual agreements without proper
authority. The Contracts Department was affected because we were forced to fix
problems created by these unauthorized agreements. Mr. Stacey stated that these
problems were the result of improper actions by the program areas, not the Con-
tracts Department. He suggested that Messrs. Felton and Jones address the issues
directly with the program offices and take appropriate steps to ensure that program
officials stopped these unauthorized contracting activities.
In his affidavit, Mr. Jones was asked to state the specific deficiencies noted in the
PCR. He responded that there had been some sole source contracting, contracts
awarded and increased without following proper contracting guidelines, and inad-
equate oversight on some of the contracts. Mr. Jones's statement was blatantly
wrong, as there were no such findings in the PCR. Contrary to his allegations of
poor performance, the PCR actually supported the Contract Department's solid per-
formance. It was the Program Offices — not Contracts — whose performance was criti-
cized.
Inspector General's Report
The Inspector General's (IG) investigation referenced by Mr. Jones involved my
former supervisor William Sylvestre, Assistemt Director, Contract Management, his
former supervisor Fred Douglas, Deputy Director, and David Stewart, Contract Spe-
cialist. These three men acted together to award sole source contracts without prop-
er authority and increase fees on awarded contracts without foUowing proper con-
tracting guidelines. I know this for a fact because it was one of my employees who
referred the issue to the IG ofiice, and that employee and I discussed the issue in
advance of reporting it. During the investigation, I was interviewed by the IG on
seversd occasions. However, I was never the subject of the investigation, nor were
129
the contracts in question handled by staff in my department. Upon learning of this
allegation, I called Harry Shields, IG Inspector in Charge at tne California Office
who confirmed that there was no negative information about me or anyone who
worked for me in the report.
At the conclusion of the investigation, Mr. Sylvestre was transferred out of the
Contracts Department, Mr. Douglas was transferred to Washington, DC and Mr.
Stewart resigned. I understand that the IG recommended firing the individuals, but
Messrs. Felton and Jones refused. Why am I to be held accountable for the covert
actions of these individuals?
Reprisal
After filing my complaint, management took actions which constituted reprisal
and were apparently an attempt to intimidate me. Those actions demonstrate the
California Ofnce's blatant disregard for the EEO process. The EEO Investigator's re-
port of my case has confirmed the following acts of reprisal.
Loccd Office Review
In early September 1992, Senior Management ordered another review of the Con-
tracts Department. This review was headed by a local team. Each unnecessary re-
view prohibits me and my staff from doing the job that we were hired to do. Al-
though I was never given a copy of the report, I was told by my supervisor that
the outcome was favorable.
Yet Another Review
Following completion of the local office review in late September, Senior Manage-
ment initiated yet another review. This time they requested that the Washington
PCR team return to the Ctdifomia Oflioe immediately for another PCR of the Con-
tracts Department.
A team of ten individuals, again headed by Bert Stacey, arrived in February 1993.
The review lasted for one wedt. At the conclusion of the review, the Contracts De-
gartment received a compliant rating and the team leader noted that the California
office had one of the best Contracting Departments in the country.
No other Department, with the exception of Affordable Housing, who is also head-
ed by a female, has been subjected to multiple reviews.
Inconsistent Performance Standards
In his affidavit, Mr. Robert Hughes, Director of Administration and my second
line supervisor stated "Management believes that when a formal PCR shows defi-
ciencies, then the supervisor's performance had not been entirely satisfactory and
should not result in a promotion until the deficiencies have been corrected."
K this is management's policy, then such policy must be consistently applied to
males and females. This did not happen in the California Office. Male managers
whose departments had significant deficiencies noted in PCR's were promptly pro-
moted, with no follow up local reviews" or second PCR's. The EEO investigation
confirmed this fact as evidenced in the following statement from the Investigator's
Report:
"During the period in which deficiencies were noted in the SAMDA and REO
Program Areas, the promotions to LG-15's of male Department Heads were not
held pending a resolution of the deficiencies."
Rewarding Illegal Behavior
The EEO investigation has concluded, and confirmed discrimination in my case.
A resolution is pending. I would like to comment that the RTC's Washington Office
of Equal Employment Opportunity has been very responsive to my complaint, and
has made eflorts to educate all managers within the organization about sexual har-
assment and discrimination. Until recently, I believed that management throughout
the organization was making a good faith effort to eradicate the discrimination.
However, I am here today because this is not the case. The individual who denied
my promotion, Mr. Phil Jones, has been recently PROMOTED to the Washington,
DC oflice. I am outraged by the Corporation's decision to promote this individual.
He not only discriminated against me, but he discriminatea against another female
manager in the California Office, who is also here today.
My attorney has contacted Senator Boxer's office requesting an explanation. Sen-
ator Boxer promptly requested a response from the RTC in Washington. Unoffi-
cially, the RtC has said that Mr. Jones was not the individual responsible for dis-
crimination. If not him, then who? Two levels of management above me gave affida-
130
vits stating that they recommended my promotion. Next in the chain of command
was Mr. Jones. He was the most senior management oflicial who gave an affidavit
during the EEO investigation. In his affidavit, he stated the reasons why my pro-
motion had been denied. Mr. Jones was the management official who denied my pro-
motion.
By its action, the RTC is clearly saying that its managers are not held account-
able for their discriminatory actions. I find this situation untenable. I believe that
RTC supports a good ol' boy network at the most senior ranks of its management
which is why Mr. Jones was promoted in spite of his discriminatory activity.
Clearly RTC Management has abdicated responsibility for correcting discrimina-
tion and reprisal within the organization. I am thankiul to Members of the Conmiit-
tee for their concern and exhoil you to put an end to this heinous conduct.
STATEMENT OF J. HANS MANGELSDORF
AssEn" Speciaust, OAM/REO, California Office, RTC
I would like to express my appreciation for the opportunity to meet with you. It
is both an honor and a pleasure to be here. Before I begin I would like to say that
the RTC is staffed with dedicated, hard working employees. I am proud to serve
with them.
A pattern of mismanagement and misconduct has developed at the California of-
fice. Charges of harassment and reprisal are pervasive. RTC's own independent in-
vestigations have confirmed these allegations, however, the RTC has been real slow
when taking corrective action. My supporting the EEO process through testimony
to the Inspector General's Office, the EEOC and the numerous in house investiga-
tions has resulted in reprimands, written warnings and the continual denial of a
promised promotion.
Voicing my opinion is part of my job description. It seems that every time I do,
I suffer Tor it. My supervisors are hostile and I'm called a "native," meaning con-
structive criticism has no place at the RTC.
Fm here to discuss RTC's operations and its impact on the local marketplace —
primarily commercial property in the Los Angeles, Orange and San Diego, Califor-
nia, counties. My comments are based on my tenure at RTC and more than 17 years
in the California real-estate and savings-and-loan industries. I am the senior Asset
Specialist in California's REO department.
I started with the RTC in June of 1990. Since then I have served at a dozen insti-
tutions including Columbia, Pacific, Santa Barbara, and Great American. I've read
a lot of appraisals and spend a lot of time with real-estate brokers. I probably talk
to 20-30 taxpayers every day.
After RTC opened its doors, out of necessity it expanded its operations to meet
its obligations and goals. Since then sales have been brisk and operations have pro-
duced results. This year alone, we've already met our goals by disposing of more
than 17 billion worth of loans and real-estate.
This amount represents a significant sector of the marketplace. According to local
sources the RTC holds a 17 percent market share. In hind site, RTC's policy of dis-
t>osing assets as rapidly as possible has achieved its goals, however with risk to
ocal economies. With RTC's sunset at hand, it's time to consider alternatives for
its remaining inventory.
For example, one avenue RTC has taken when disposing properties are auctions.
Unfortunately, not only have past real-estate auctions disposed of properties using
discounts but the high operating costs compared to listing property with a local
broker, have reduced the return to the taxpayer while negatively impacting the
market.
To be specific, a typical minimum bid for property at RTC auction is 70 percent
of the appraised value; auction selling costs are reportedly 22 percent of the selling
price, compared to an industry average of 17 percent. Listing with a local broker
generally costs 8-10 percent of the sales price and properties are sold closer to ap-
praised market value. In effect, through tnese auctions, the RTC and the American
Taxpayer, pay a high cost for sales only to achieve discounted sales prices. The dif-
ference equates to millions.
Another avenue involves structured sales transactions, where the RTC vaduates
property based on its income strength. For example, using this approach, if the RTC
has an 80-room hotel that sits on 5,000 prime acres, it would determine the selling
price based on the income the hotel produced without consideration to the value ol"
the land. This leads to more discounting compared to the true value of the property.
131
Because of the extended escrow periods, the straw buyers and the secrecy associ-
ated with this process, these transactions also take more than a year to close, com-
pared to a more typical short-term transactions. Once again discounting property re-
quires more attention than the typical local sales approadi.
The local communities feel that RTC's continued discounting, through auctions
and structured sales, are depressing an already fragile msirketplace. According to
local appraisers, discounting the value of real estate to enhance sales, can depress
real-estate values. L.A. and San Diego are starting to look like ghost towns. It's not
too late to re-engineer the sales process that the RTC is using. RTC is "Ready To
Change."
The solution requires management that will support the real-estate market.
Workable solutions are available. I would be happy to address any questions. . . .
STATEME^^^ of THOMAS J. BURNSIDE
Failed Texas S&L's could cost the American taxpayers $560 billion over the next
forty years. Yet, after spending tens of millions of dollars, the RTC and the FDIC
combined have only recovered one tenth of 1 percent of the Texas losses from the
insiders and professionals for the Texas S&L's.
Stated differently, Texas S&L's could cost every man, women, and child in the
United States $2,200 each. The Texas insiders and professionals that caused the
problems will pay back about $2 of that $2,200.
What Happened?
Early this year, several RTC managers and I reported serious flaws in the RTC's
pursuit of Texas S&L officials and professionals who presided over the gutting of
an entire industry. The RTC reaction to such memos was swift and violent. Yet high
level RTC documents now reveal that RTC managers concede the total breakdown
of the RTC efforts to investigate the collapse of the Texas S&L industry. Only the
finger pointing remains.
The top RTC lawyer in Dallas directly responsible for the investigation and pur-
suit of civil cases against S&L insiders recently told other high-level RTC managers:
... we share similar concerns raised by increasing evidence of deficiencies in
the management of the investigation and pre-litigation stages of professional li-
ability matters in the Dallas Oflice. . . .
It seems evident that some cogs are either worn or broken and need immediate
fixing.
I really think it is imperative we inspect the soundness of the foundation now,
rather than face an autopsy of the rubble after."
An RTC Vice President reportedly issued a caustic response to the lawyer's bla-
tant attempt to 'Svash his hands" of any blame for the collapse of the Dallas profes-
sional liability program:
"I will be the first to admit major management failures on the part of Investiga-
tions in Dallas. I am, however, distressed by the conclusions you have drawn that
level charge after charge at the Investigations side of the equation while failing
to find the slightest fault in your own managers.
Let me remind you of the turbulent history of Dallas PLS, exemplified by the
Tom. Bumside matter, that wrought changes in PLS management and constant
turnover in line attorneys resulting in the current cadre of newly hired, inexperi-
enced PLS attorneys.
The one-sided arguments and self-serving solutions presented in your memoran-
dum lead me to conclude that you and your staff need to significantly rethink
your methods of operation in order to better address the shared goals and re-
sponsibilities implicit in carrying out a productive PLS program. We will be close-
ly monitoring this situation until we are comfortable the Dallas PLS and In-
vestigation staffs are back on track,"
This memorandum outlines the "Tom Bumside matter" and, more importantly,
describes the total disintegration of the civil pursuit of Texas S&L insiders and pro-
fessionals.
Unfortunately, the Texas statutes of limitations on insider abuse have expired.
The issue is not getting the program "back on track" but rather the recognition of
a "i-rain wreck." Or, to paraphrase the RTC lawyer in Dallas who helped cause the
train wreck, this report is "an autopsy of the rubble."
132
I. The Texas S&L's
A. The Costs of the S&L Bailout
Estimates of the "cost" of the S&L bailout have varied widely. In 1988, M. Danny
WaU claimed that the taxpayers would not have to pay any of the costs for failed
S&L's. These cost projections have increased exponentially ever since. Surprisingly,
most of these estimates "omit" the cost of interest in funding the S&L bailout.^
A Stanford Law & Policy Review report, however, has calculated the interest cost
of the S&L bailout as follows:
"Table 2.
Cost of the Thrift Rescue Over 40 Years: 1989-2029
[BillionB of Dollars]
Year
1989-1999 Costs (from Table 1)
Non-Treasury Debt, 2000-2029
Treasury Debt, 2000-2029
Total 40 Year Cost
Amount
$ 456.3
256.8
638.8
$1369.9
NOTE: Calculation assumes that all costs except interest end by 1999. It excludes the
interest of borrowing to pay Treasury interest (i.e., the compound effect of paying interest on
interest)."
Other studies may quibble with the cost or conceal the interest component of the
S&L bailout. The fact remains, however, the cost to the taxpayers — whether $1.4
trillion or just many hundreds of billions — is incomprehensible. Even more stagger-
ing is that one state, Texas, caused the bulk of the losses.
B. The Texas Share
The S&L debacle has resulted in the single largest transfer of wealth between
states in history. Insolvent Texas S&L's account for 41.19 percent of total costs for
the S&L bailout from 1986 until 1992. As one observer noted:
"No doubt the bailout has been the nation's largest financial disaster. Less well
understood is that the bailout transfeiTed enormous wealth from the Northeast-
Midwest region to Texas and a few other Sunbelt states.
Yet olenty of other states suffered economically in the 1980's, but their S&L's
didn't become basket cases. Texas simply dropped the regulatory reins on its
state-chartered S&L's, encouraging an orgy of speculative and insupportable in-
vestment. While depositors surely must be protected, no one should overlook the
fact that Texas thrifts sponsored., in essence, an economic development program
for which the rest of the country must pay." Lara Thyagarajan, "Stuck with the
Tab , . . Part III: The Bailout Continues Northeast-Midwest Congressional Coali-
tion Report, May, 1993.
Texas' 41 percent share of the total S&L costs of $1,369,900,000,000 is $560 bil-
lion. On a more comprehensible level, Texas S&L's will cost every man, woman, and
child in the United States $2,200 apiece. On an even more personal level, the bail-
out of Texas' S&L's will cost my wife, myself, and our four children $13,200 over
the next forty years.
Texas S&L's not only led the nation in total costs, it led the nation in fraud and
criminal conduct. In 1990, the Department of Justice announced that 37 percent of
all criminal referrals on financial institution fraud across the United States came
from Texas. The National Commission on Financial Institution Reform, Recovery
and Enforcement described the Texas S&L debacle as follows:
"The situation was most out of control in Texas, which became the breeding
ground for imprudent and abusive practices. The S&L's it chartered were allowed
to engage in high-risk activities virtually without limit, and supervision and ex-
amination were essentially nonexistent for several years. It was no accident that
over 40 percent of all taxpayer losses came from Texas S&L's." Origins and causes
of the S&L Debacle: A Blueprint for Reform, A Report to the President and Con-
gress of the United States, (July 1993).
Any homeowner readily recognizes the cost of interest in proportion to the overall loan."
Homeowners who pay $10,000 a year on house payments find themselves paying very little prin-
cipal in the early years. The Federal government penchant for "forgetting" interest is one reason
why we have the deficit.
133
Texas should have been the focus of the RTC's efforts to pursue S&L wrongdoers.
Instead, the collapse of the RTC pursuit of the insiders and professionals of failed
Texas S&L's in the 1990's' rivaled the same type of abuses that caused the Texas
debacle in the 1980's.
n. The Collapse of the RTC Pursuit of Texas Insiders and Professionals
A. The Recovery Scorecard^
As noted above, Texas had the largest losses and the largest percentage of fraud
and criminal wrongdoing in the country. Yet, almost four years after the failure of
most of the Texas S&L's, the RTC has very little to show for its efforts:
• The RTC has recovered less than $10 million from the Texas directors and officers
that presided over the failure of the Texas S&L's. (4 cents of the $2,200 Texas
S&L bUl for every man, woman, and child in the United States)
• The RTC has only recovered from two law firms that represented failed Texas
thrifts. The $1.7 million recovered from the law firms only slightly exceeded the
RTC's cost of investigating and pursuing attorney malpractice cases, (less than
one penny of the $2,200 Texas S&L bill)
• The RTC has only recovered $150,000 from the appraisers that gave inflated ap-
praisals that underlay many "land flips" and other criminal conduct that allowed
S&L insiders to loot the federally insured thrifts, (less than one penny of the
22,000 Texas S&L bill for a family often)
• The RTC has only recovered $15.5 million from the securities and commodities
brokers and investment bankers that flocked to Texas to get quick profits at tax-
payer expense. (6 cents of the $2,200 Texas S&L bill)
■1
RTC T»x»» R«cov«dM
Atlonwyp
Bond
D&O
AeeointtrtM
'H^^a^ii^
)
1 III!
10 $10 S20 )30 $40
ISO
S60
• Two thirds of all RTC Texas recoveries came from two accounting firms who,
while clearly culpable, may later question whether they caused 66.4 percent of the
Texas losses. (21 cents of the $2,200 Texas S&L bill)
All told, the RTC has recovered slightly more than $90 million from its Texas Pro-
fessional Liability cases. A lot of money for a private citizen! But here, the RTC was
collecting the money for taxpayers faced with hundreds of billions in losses and
nothing to show for the bill that will extend for the next forty years.
B. Analysis of the Scorecard
An analysis of the RTC scorecard in Texas actually reveals much more serious
problems in Texas than meets the eye. Not only are the total recoveries shockingly
low, the distribution of WHO paid the RTC is equally revealing. For example, the
RTC has recovered very little from the former officers and directors of the failed
S&L's. Similarily, recoveries from attorneys and appraisers are almost nonexistent.
'The RTC Texas scorecard figures come directly from the RTC Office of Investigations 1983
Semi-Annual Report as ofJunt 30, 1993, which is attached to this statement.
134
j TYPE OF DEFENDANT
NUMBER OF CASES
AMOUNT OF 1
RECOVERIES
D&O
13
$ 9,995.750
ATTORNEY
2
$ 1.675.000
APPRAISER
1
S 150.000
BOND
8
$9,156,500
ACCOUNTANT
5
$53,940,000
OTHER
8
$15,510,800
TOTAL
37
$90,428,050
As evidenced by this hearing, the RTC often defends itself by "attacking their ac-
cusers." The following numbers preempt any RTC attempts in my case. The RTC
cases under my supervision as a fine attorney for over two years per case have re-
sulted in recoveries in excess of $66 million dollars. The case recoveries represent:
• 73 percent of all RTC Professional Liability recoveries on failed Texas S&L's.
• 37 percent of all RTC recoveries nationwide on the global settlement with Ernst
and Young.
• The second largest collective Professional Liability recovery for any RTC thrift
across the country. It was second only to Charles Heating's Lincoln Savings.
• 70 percent of all RTC Director and Officer recoveries in Texas.
• The two largest RTC settlements with investment bankers who dealt with Texas
S&L's.
• The largest RTC settlement with a commodities broker.
• The largest RTC or FDIC recovery from a single accounting firm attributable to
a failed S&L.
When I left the RTC in March of 1993, the case recoveries on matters under my
sujjervision for over two years exceeded the combined total recoveries of all matters
supervised by the fifty plus field and regional Professional Liability attorneys
throughout the country.
Do I deserve all the credit on those cases? Of course not. Indeed, I can not even
take most of the credit on any single case. Fm proud to say that they were aU truly
"team efforts" that had truly great RTC investigators and wonderful fee counsel. I
also had strong suppwrt from Washington, D.C. Professional Liability lawyers.
The following chart graphically illustrates the distribution of RTC Texas Profes-
sional Liability recoveries according to PLS attorney:
Ttxat PLS R*eov»rlM
»^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^v.^^^^y.v.yAVA^^^v.VAV.^^^^^^^^^^v.v.v.^^^^v.^^^v.'.^^^^
Hou«en
SanAraonle
10
3D 40
70
135
m. The Reasons for the Collapse
A. The Failure to Investigate
The key to any lawsuit is an understanding of the facts. The only way to under-
stand the cause of the failure of a billion-dollar S&L is to interview peoole associ-
ated with the S&L and to obtain relevant records. Congress gave the RTC a simple,
tried and true tool to interview witnesses and to investigate claims — the administra-
tive subpoena.
Subpoenas are the RTC's most powerful tool in evaluating and pursuing Profes-
sional Liability claims. A PLS lawyer may use administrative subpoenas to obtain
documents outside the control of the RTC, compel oral testimony, determine the net
worth of potential defendants, and a host of other purposes. If used properly, the
subpoena power permits the RTC to obtain early favorable settlements. Conversely,
the failure to use subpoenas often results in making decisions with incomplete infor-
mation and inferior recoveries.
The RTC boasts of 99 percent voluntary compliance with its subpoenas and has
won virtually every significant challenge to its use of subpoenas. Courts have ap-
proved RTC use of subpoenas for virtually any conceivable investigatory purpose.
The administrative subpoena coupled with the three-year extension of the statute
of limitations gave the RTC professional liability attorney the ability to completely
develop a case oefore even making the decision to sue.
The use of the administrative subpoenas should have been a routine component
of professional liability investigations in Texas. In some parts of Texas, it was wide-
ly used. I issued over 200 subpoenas on the cases that were under my control.
The issuance of subpoenas in other cases paled in comparison. For example:
• Three RTC attorneys stationed in Houston issued only 3 subpoenas in their inves-
tigation of over 43 failed S&L's. Three subpoenas for an entire oflice!
• The three attorneys in the Dallas field office only issued 43 subpoenas for 37
S&L's.
In retrospect, the taxpayers will receive less than one subpoena for each billion
dollars in taxpayer losses from Texas S&L's over the next forty years. Expensive
subpoenas.
Numbers tell only part of the story. Without subpoenas, what did the RTC law-
yers base their decisions upon? The big question in Texas was:
Who Got the Money and What Did They Do With It?
Without subpoenas, the RTC will simply never answer such basic questions. In-
deed, the RTC never really sou^t the answer.
The importance of subpoenas was readily proved when I subpoenaed the account-
ants' workpapers for the holding company oi a large failed S&L. Our review of the
workpapers revealed that two officers whom we thought had marginal net worth,
in fact nad received eighteen million dollars over eighteen months. The S&L insid-
ers had also concealed that income from the outside directors. That single fact dra-
matically increased the value of the case. Yet how many other Texas cases involved
such gross self dealing that went undetected because tne RTC lawyer never issued
a subpoena.
In case after case, the Investigations Unit begged its lawyers to issue subpoenas.
The Dallas lawyers always found excuses. The most outrageous excuse came from
a DaUas Professional Liability manager who refused because "it would send the
wrong message." The perplexed investigator then came to me and said: "Tom, what
tjrpe of message are we trying to send by not sending out subpoenas?" Good
question.
B. The Purge of Experienced Attorneys and Investigators
The RTC staffing on S&L professional liability cases in Texas doomed most of the
investigations of failed Texas S&L's to failure. In three years, the Texas cases suf-
fered through five "reorganizations" of the lawyers assigned to investigate the fail-
ures. Eventually the fourth or fifth attorney assigned to the S&L could only
halfheartedly "go through the motions" of "papering the file" rather than trying to
conduct a true investigation. The "numbers tell the impact of the "reorganization"
of the Texas Professional Liability office:
• Not one attorney that recommended the filing of a Professional Liability case in
Texas still handles the case today.
• After the 1992 reorganization, the percentage of RTC Texas suits filed dropped
from 37 percent to amiost nothing.
• The use of administrative subpoenas plummeted after the reorganization. Other
than subpoenas that I issued, the four Texas professional offices only issued ten
136
subpoenas on failed Texas S&L's in the seven months following the 1992 reorga-
nization.
• RJC management ordered the closing offices to "box up" many files on failed
S&Ls until thev could find some one to work on the files. Many of these cases,
particularly in San Antonio, were ignored for months afterwards.
The RTC staffing of the Texas Investigations Unit was equally disruptive. In their
pre-election year haste to bury the S&L debacle, RTC management announced their
intention to close three of the four Investigation's offices responsible for failed Texas
thrifts. Suddenly, the RTC abandoned three vears of investigative work and termi-
nated the on-site investigators who had develo^d the cases. The RTC then started
to transfer entire warehouses of documents to Dallas. Local S&L prosecutors vigor-
ously objected to the mass shuflling of files. Some prosecutors stared to issue "blan-
ket grand jury subpoenas on the RTC to prevent the destruction of their cases
through the mass transfer of RTC records.
The Baton Rouge story illustrates the chaos created by the reorganization. In mid-
1992, the RTC announced the prospective closure of the Baton Rouge office. Many
Baton Rouge Investigators found other jobs and their cases bounced among inves-
tigators until they too left the RTC. To solve the problem, RTC officials assigned
Houston investigators to handle the cases. A few months later, the RTC accelerated
the closing date of the Houston office and its investigators started leaving. RTC
then started transferring the files to Dallas. Two weeks after the Houston office
closed its doors and ripped out its computers, RTC management decided to reopen
the ofike. Not surprisingly, many departed Houston investigators refused to return
to the RTC.
The RTC has now announced another cutback of Texas investigators. Simulta-
neous with the cutback of line investigators, the RTC is increasing "field manage-
ment" from three supervisors to ten. Soon Dallas will have "all chiefs" and "no Indi-
ans. Perhaps the RTC has its own spin on "re-inventing government."
C. Failure to Work as a Team
Any professional liability case can only succeed as part of a team effort. The PLS
attorneys were the "quarterback" of the team and had the ultimate responsibility
to investigate failed S&L's and to fUe the official recommendation to sue or not. Be-
cause of this responsibUity, the RTC gave the line attorney the exclusive authority
to issue subpoenas and to supervise outside lawyers. The Investigations Unit pro-
vide the offensive and defensive linesmen to the team. They provide the "heart and
soul" to the investigation.
Before the 1992 RTC reorganization, the Texas investigators and attorneys
worked closely together. In the Spring of 1992, however, the RTC legal managers
ousted the top Texas professional liability manager in a nationwide purge. The new
management radically changed the relationship between the lawyers and investiga-
tors. Suddenly, the investigators were the enemy. Rather than work as a team, tke
Dallas lawyers began concealing information from the RTC business officials that
had the responsibUity to sign off on all significant professional liability decisions.
For example, when I objected to a decision that I believed would gut a Texas case
that was second only to Charles Keating's Lincoln Savings, my bosses ordered me
to conceal my objections from the very business officials that were relying on my
legal advice. When I objected to this gag order to Washington RTC management,
Arturo Vera-Rojas placed me under a second gag order that restricted such commu-
nications. When I reported my concerns to the Government Accounting Office,
Arturo Vera-Rojas locked me out of the Dallas Legal Division.
IV. The Consequences of the Collapse
Poorly investigated claims result in bad decisions on both ends of the spectrum.
Obviously, a failure to investigate can result in neglecting to bring meritorious suits
that the RTC has a fiduciary duty to pursue. Similarly, a poor investigation severely
undermines the RTC to prevail on those meritorious suits that it does file. Just as
importantly, however, pcwr investigation can result in the filing of unjust or frivo-
lous suits. All these problems flowed from the collapse of the Daflas PLS effort,
A. Failing to Pursue Vlvble Claims
The most egregious wrongdoers seldom leave a paper trail in an S&L that they
know will be seized bv the regulators. Rather, the truly big crooks attempt to hide
their theft. Accordingly, a myopic examination of the records remaining in the gut-
ted S&L cannot result in the big cases against those S&L officials who deliberately
fashion schemes that are difficult to detect.
The only way to build a case against someone who had enough foresight to try
to hide the wrongdoing was to go beyond the RTC files. For example, talking to peo-
137
pie who were at the S&L certainly helps the investigation. Additionally, using ad-
ministrative subpoenas was essential. As discussed above, however, several omces
in Texas issued few subpoenas. We will never know what happnened to much of the
money because the RTC lawyers refused to subpoena necessary information.
When the statutes started to expire, case after case was officially closed without
any real investigation. The Texas RTC attorneys issued five or fewer subpoenas on
more than 90 percent of their cases. No wonder the line attorney could honestly
write; "We found no evidence that would justify the pursuit of the case."
B. Pursuit of Poorly Investigated Claims
Just as crooks tend to hide their wrongdoing, honest (albeit, perhaps negligent or
grossly neghgent) S&L officials tend to leave a pretty good paper trail. Accordingly,
a failure to use subpoenas will result in a disproportionate amount of claims against
individuals that dia not have the foresight or incentive to cover their tracks. Indeed,
those individuals may themselves have been deceived by more culpable wrongdoers.
Additionally, a complete investigation coupled with frank and candid pre-suit dis-
cussions with potential defendants can result in the RTC avoiding the filing of bad
lawsuits. Such pre-suit discussions rarely succeed when the RTC has done no inves-
tigation at all. Potential defendants either believe (1) that the RTC is not genuinely
concerned about making a fair decision based on the facts; or (2) that the RTC is
so off base that they perceive a tactical litigation benefit to fighting an unprepared
RTC.3
A prominent Dallas S&L defense attorney, Schuyler Marshall, cogently expressed
the oesire to deal with competent, prepared RTC attorneys because:
. . . this leads to reasonable settlements of cases that should be settled, the op-
portunity for a decision not to file suits that should not be filed and an early un-
derstanding of situations where it is inevitable that suit must be filed and litiga-
tion pursued. Conversely, it is extremely frustrating (and it happens most of the
time) to deal with attorneys who are not prepared, not knowledgeable on the
facts, merely posturing, want a minimum of a hundred million to settle, no matter
what the facts, etc. My reaction as a defense lawyer is that it is impossible to set-
tle or even have a reasonable discussion in these situations and therefore, I sim-
ply prepare to litigate." -Schuyler Marshall letter of September 17, 1993.
Even RTC management has conceded that its decision-making process on Texas
cases had serious flaws. In one major case, the Dallas lawyer failed to issue any
subpoenas or to hire counsel until just months before the statute expired. On the
day the statute expired, Dallas RT(J lawyers presented RTC business officials with
two antithetical recommendations — to sue and to close out the claim.
Understandably, senior RTC business officials were aghast. Jim Messec, the top
RTC business official in Dallas reportedly questioned the Dallas attorneys: "(Gen-
tleman, what is it? Are you recommending that the RTC sue or closeout the case?
It can't be both." He never received an answer. A senior Washington, DC business
official apparently complained that the decision to sue was ". . . made more on
what (could) be done in the short run as opposed to how it should have been han-
dled."
Assistant General Counsel Arturo Vera-Rojas — the lawyer responsible for the
management of the Dallas office, including the Professional Liability cases — later
conceded that the case filed by the RTC suffered from "deficient preparation" and
was based upon ". . . totally speculative factual averments that are in no way sup-
ported Iry provable facts. . . ." He went fiarther to say that: "Three years of inves-
tigation (whether or not diligent) have not produced sufficient facts to siipport the
development of anything resembling an actionable claim.Tet Arturo Vera-Rojas was
the chief lawyer in Dallas. Lawyers that reported to him had the direct responsibil-
ity to investigate the case. Only RTC lawyers had the authority to issue subpoenas.
Only RTC lawyers have the authority to recommend suit. Just months before the
three-year deadline expired, the Dallas lawyers had failed to issue a single subpoena
to investigate the case. The Dallas legal manager that had direct line responsibility
for the case only logged 40 hours in a one year period on the case. That same year,
he logged almost 1,900 hours of "administrative time" supervising two other law-
yers. Stated differently, the "buck stops" with the lawyers.
Was this an isolated case? Arturo Vera-Rojas later confessed that:
' I can readily understand the reluctance to negotiate with a party that appeared to make its
decisions without an investigation. On the other hand, I personally disagree with this "tactical
benefit" of an innocent person going into litigation with the RTC without attempting to dissuade
them. Even a remote chance of persuading the RTC to drop a claim seems worth the risk of
"educating" the RTC. No one wins "in litigation with the Federal government because of the
expense and trauma of defending a suit
138
". . . reports to me have revealed many similar cases evidencing poor investiga-
tory planning and performance."
V. Who Will Bear the Consequences?
Every one sufFered from the failure of the Dallas RTC ofiice to investigate the
Texas cases.
The taxpayers were the most obvious victim of the RTC Texas debacle. They paid
for the bailout of the Texas S&L industiy — in exchange, they expected the RTC to
make a reasonable investigation and pursuit of the wrongdoers. No one expected a
100 percent recovery from the Texas insiders and professionals.
The taxpayers did expect the RTC to at least try to find out who was responsible
for the $2,300 Texas S&L tax on every man, woman, and child in the United States.
Appendix A
The Management Admission of Collapse
The Finger Pointing Begins
After all attempts to coverup the Dallas PLS collapse, RTC management now con-
cedes the existence of the problems — they only disagree on whom to olame.
(1) The July 26, 1993 Vera-Rojtu Memo
In a memo to RTC national management, Dallas Assistant General Counsel
Arturo Vera-Rojas finally admitted that the Dallas Professional Liability program
had severe management problems.
His memo of July 26, 1993 described the Dallas situation as follows:
• ". . . We share similar concerns raised by increasing evidence of deficiencies in
the management of the investigation and pre-litigation stages of professional li-
ability matters in the Dallas Office."
• "It seems evident that some cogs are either worn or broken and need immediate
fixing. ... I really think it is imperative we inspect the soundness of the founda-
tion now, rather than face an autopsy of the ruble later."
• "... I cannot comprehend how any case for initiation of litigation, regardless of
importance, visibility or priority, can be allowed to reach criticality with such defi-
cient preparation. . . . [njeports to me have revealed many similar cases evidenc-
ing poor investigatory planning and performance. A few examples should suffice
to demonstrate the seriousness of the deficiencies."
• ". . . When an investigation is carefully planned and directed by the lawyer who
is ultimately to fashion the culpability or liability theories, excellent results can
be obtained with great efficiency and minimal cost. Lamentably, that has not been
the case with PLS investigations in Dallas ETC."
• "... I can and will ensure that investigational deficiencies not be the cause of
repeated poor preparation of PLS cases assigned to my office."
Arturo Vera-Rojas' July 26 memo then tried to shift the blame for his own mis-
management to high-level RTC managers who designed the system:
• ". . . [T]he severability of reporting lines [of PLS and Investigations] has (not
surprisingly) caused lack of proper planning and coordination. In my opinion,
chaos is inevitable when responsibility ana accountability are not clearly de-
fined. ..."
• "Investigations has been assigned multiple and sometimes unreconcilable respon-
sibilities while being given woefully inadequate resources."
• "Investigations has suffered from conflicting statements of corporate priorities.
Then political imperatives have caused said conflicting priorities to weigh in favor
of support for criminal investigations at the detraction of PLS-civil investiga-
tions.
• "[TJhere has been an incomprehensible bias on the part of the RTC Investigators
against using the contracting process to supplement their meager in-house re-
sources."
(2) The August 1 7, 1993 Resporue
RTC Vice-President of Operations Edward D. Maheney issued a blistering re-
sponse to the charges of AGC Vera-Rojas on August 17, 1993. As with the Vera-
Rojas' memo, Mr. Maheney conceded the existence of severe problems with the Dal-
las PLS program with the following descriptions of the Dallas PLS situation:
• ". . . Apparent deficiencies in the management of PLS claims and investigations
in Dallas which came to light when decisionmakers were confronted with poorly
documented and incompletely reasoned recommendations to either close or au-
thorize litigation ... on the day the statute was to run."
139
• ". . . What appears to be a major failure to communicate and cooperate to
achieve corporate goals."
• ". . . Major management failures on the part of Investigations in Dallas."
• ". . . Seeming inability of Dallas lawyers and investigators to communicate and
do their jobs. . . ."
• ". . . The turbulent history of Dallas PLS, exemplified by the Tom Burnside mat-
ter, that wrought changes in PLS management and constant turnover in line at-
torneys resultmg in the current cadre of newly hired, inexperienced PLS attor-
neys.
• ". . . Managers in both PLS and Investigations failed to direct and motivate their
subordinates to work together."
• "We will be closely monitoring this situation until we are comfortable the Dallas
PLS and Investigation staffs are back on track."
RTC Vice-President Maheney admirably distributed the blame for the collapse of
the Dallas PLS program throughout the RTC:
• "Let me remind you of the turbulent history of Dallas PLS, exemplified by the
Tom Burnside matter, that wrou^t changes in PLS management and constant
turnover in line attorneys resulting in the current cadre of newly hired, inexperi-
enced PLS attorneys."
• "To my way of thinking, our current problem arose because managers in both PLS
and Investigations failed to direct and motivate their subordinates to woric to-
gether."
• ^Tie one-sided arguments and self-serving solutions presented in your memoran-
dum lead me to conclude that vou and your staff need to significantly rethink
your methods of operation in order to better address the shared goals and respon-
sibilities implicit in carrying out a productive PLS program."
/
140
flSOlUTION TRUST COBPOBATION
SjKlyta* r¥r Criui
B/«toHn( The Coandcfiec
March 23, 1993
Thomas Hindes
Assiscanc General Counsel
Professional Liability Section
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
1717 H Street, 10th Floor
Washington, D.C. 20006
Re: Resignation in Protest
Dear Tom:
For the reasons set forth in my memoranda of March 18, 1993 and
March 3, 1993, I do not believe that I can work effectively for the
Resolution Trust Corporation any longer. Accordingly, I hereby
submit my resignation from the RTC as of April 4, 1993 (or at some
other mutually acceptable date.)
I attach the memoranda of March 18 and 3 as an integral part of
this resignation letter and strongly urge you to look into this
matter further. As we discussed, I would like to have an exit
interview with you in Washington to explain more fully my views on
the situation down here and the reasons for my resignation in
protest. Please advise me of a convenient time for such exit
interview.
I look forward to our meeting.
Sincerely yours,
Thomas ii. Bumside
Enclosure
cc: William DePugh (with enclosures)
Diane Mendoza
■ Chris Jones
Mark Gabrellian
Arturo Vera-Rojas
David Stoc)cwell
D. Rex Taylor
Mark Greenwald ■ «
Bruce Pederson "
Thomas Bambrick
Wayne Pogle
John Adair
Edward Stephenson
141
Memorandum to: James R. Dudine
Director
Office of Investigations
and
Thomas Hindes
Assistant General Counsel
Professional Liability Section
Prom: Thomas J. Burns ide
Senior Attorney (PLS)
RTC Dallas Office
Date: March 18, 199 3
Re: Dallas PLS Problems
'^^
I. BZEcnrzvs scxxxry
Why did some PLS investigations in Texas succeed and others fail?
This memorandum seeks to explain some of the reasons underlying
the success and failure of PLS investigations in Texas by
analyzing the impact of the 1992 RTC Reorganization on the
ultimate recoveries from Texas PLS cases. In particular, the
1992 Reorganization had the following consecpaences :
♦ The closing of five offices which contributed to a mass
exodus of experienced PLS attorneys and corresponding
decline in PLS recoveries as files were transferred to
inexperienced attorneys;
♦ The ouster of a successful PLS manager who had
implemented a proven "Teas approach" to PLS cases which
has resulted in recoveries and settlement offers in
excess of $70 million dollars. Such approach involved
working closely with the Investigations Unit,
aggressively using subpoenas, developing novel legal
theories, and early retention of high calibre fee
counsel;
142
♦ The proBotion of a subordinate PLS manager who
advocated an "ostrich approach" to PLS claims that has
resulted in numerous "close-outs", and only $ 2.2
million in recoveries. Such approach involved ignoring
the Investigations Unit, failing to use subpoenas,
resisting any new ideas, and a reluctance to expend
legal fees during the Investigation of PLS claims;
♦ A reduction in the use of administrative subpoenas, a
key tool available to the RTC in developing successful
PLS claims and obtaining favorable pre-suit
•ettleaents;
♦ An almost total elimination of any substantive
supervision by first-line PLS management in Dallas;
♦ The rigid implementation of a "rate schedule" that
recklessly disregarded the consequences of turnover of
experienced PLS fee counsel at the very time that the
1992 Reorganization caused massive turnover in PLS and
the Investigations Unit.
While this memo discusses only 'the consequences of the 1992
Reorganization on the Texas PLS cases over the last eight months,
the long term impact of the current practices of the Dallas PLS
management could result in the collapse of any effective pursuit
of PLS claims involving Texas, Mississippi, and Louisiana
institutions. On the positive side, however, the immediate
implementation of remedial measures could reverse the collapse
and salvage the Dallas PLS program.
XX. TEE IKPACT 07 PLS RSORGAMXSATXOMS
A. TEE KI7LTIPLS PLS REOROAXXSATXOMS
The Texas PLS offices have undergone four major reorganizations
since the formation of the RTC. In 1989, all Texas PLS cases
vcre handled out of Washington. In January of 199 0, many of the
Texas PLS cases were transferred down to a newly formed Southwest
Regional PLS office led by Counsel (Section Chief) Sharon
Howard, who reported directly to Washington PLS. It was the only
PLS office outside of Washington and was staffed with five line
attorneys .
When the RTC established Regional and Field PLS offices
throughout the country in April, 1991, the Southwest Regional
office was partially dismantled in order to form a smaller
Regional Office in Dallas and three field offices located in San
Antonio, Houston, and Dallas. Sharon Howard and I remained in
the Regional Office and Rex Taylor was appointed the Counsel for
143
the "Metr^plex-C-MCO") office in Dallas. In that capacity, he
reported to Sharon Howard and directly euper-visad two attorneys
who transferred from the old Regional PLS office.
As a result of the Reorganization in the Spring of 1992, all four
offices of the old Southwest Region and the for»er Central Region
office in Baton Rouge were collapsed into a single office.
Sharon Howard was ousted as Section Chief and replaced by Rex
Taylor. Of the original 15 PLS attorneys hired in April of 1991
to handle PLS cases in Texas, Mississippi, and Louisiana, only
four reaain. Of those four, I aa the only attorney who works
exclusively and directly on PLS cases.
Under the Winter of 1993 reorganization, the Dallas office will
be staffed with three managers (who survived the previous
reorganizations) and between nine to twelve staff attorneys. Of
those staff attorneys, one has been with PLS for almost two
years; two have been with PLS for approximately eight months; and
one has been with PLS for just a few months. The other five to
eight attorneys have not yet reported for duty.
B. THB IMPACT 07 TKB RBOROAVIBATIOMS
Because of the complexity and extended investigation period for
PLS claims, a change of PLS attorneys almost inevitably leads to
some disruption on the file. Each file must be "re-learned" by
the new attorney while precious time elapses. Many times, the
transfer of the file results in losing much of the intangible
"institutional memory" on the file or in shifts in strategy in
the pursuit of the case. Additionally, a case that may once have
been cost-effective under the original line attorney (who, for
example, may have planned to internalize some of the work) can
lose its cost-effectiveness upon transfer. Further, the new PLS
attorney receiving the transferred case often has little or no
PLS experience or is already overburdened with his or her own
caseload. The problem becomes greatly exacerbated when the
Investigations Unit also suffers turnover on the same file
because of the same reorganization.'
The impact of the turnover of attorneys on results of cases is
dramatic. Those Texas, Mississippi, and Louisiana cases that
have been handled with minimal or no turnover of PLS attorneys in
1992 have resulted in recoveries of $ 69 million or 98.8% of all
' The Dallas Investigations Unit is undergoing a reorganization
of its own, albeit the reorganization has been far less abrupt.
The San Antonio Investigations office recently closed, and the
Baton Rouge and Houston offices are slated to close soon.
Accordingly, cases from those offices will suffer turnover on both
the Investigations and PLS side.
144
PLS recoveries cade in 1992 and 1993 froB those states. Those
cases that experienced turnover of the PLS attorney in 1992 have
recovered less than Si Billion or 1.2% of recoveries froa those
states.
IZI. THS —TtXX XPPSOACH" TO PLS CXBtB
The reorganization resulted in sore than a "Bere" turnover in PLS
line attorneys; it has resulted in a coBplete change in
Banageaent philosophy froB the "teas approach" followed by the
forser Regional PLS office to the "ostrich approach" used by Rex
Taylor during his tenure as PLS Section Chief of the Metroplex
Office. The iapact of this change in Banageaent philosophies of
the results on PLS cases is just beginning to be felt.
A. TEE DXLLXS RBGXOHXL OPPZCS "TSAM XPPROXCH"
A successful PLS investigation usually involves a tightly
coordinated effort by a teaa coaprised of representatives of the
Investigations Unit, the Professional Liability Section, fee
counsel, and outside consultants. The Investigations Unit
provides the Bost internal RTC resources for the investigation
through its line Investigators, Accountant Liability
Investigator, docunents control, asset-search capability, and
other functions. The PLS line attorney provides legal insight
and focus to the investigation and often serves as the
"quarterback" of the teaa. Additionally, the PLS attorney has the
ability to hire fee-counsel or other experts to assist in the
investigation as veil the power to issue administrative
subpoenas. The outside fee-counsel and experts often supplement
the internal resources of the RTC in pursuing PLS
claims.
The Southwest Regional Office PLS personnel from the Counsel
(Section Chief) to the support staff subscribed fully to the team
approach whether it applied to work on individual cases or to
internal office management. Every member of a teaa working on a
particular case took pride in working toward a common goal and
willingly contributed to the overall project.
While most of the Regional projects involved my cases, one high
profile region-wide case was handled directly by Section Chief
Howard with substantial support from our paralegal and secretary
and client representatives. In that case, the RTC seized control
of a corporation owned by multiple thrifts and commenced
liquidation of the corporation and distribution of the assets to
the RTC thrifts that owned stock in the corporation. The RTC
recovered 3.3 million dollars from the case with minimal outside
legal fees. Unfortunately, the ouster of Ms. Howard has resulted
in the case languishing while money is »till to be recovered and
145
th« potential for RTC liability if thv corporation is not
properly dissolved.
B. RSSOLTB or TKZ KSSZOIOL *>'ttXX XPP&OXCH"
The iaportance of teaavork and continuity, including strong
involveaent by the PLS line attorney at the investigative stage,
is best exenplified by the results of cases in which I served as
the PLS aeaber of the RTC teas for over two years. The following
table segregates actual recoveries on cases directed by (1) PLS
attorneys from Washington; or (2) PLS attorneys fron the PLS
regional or field offices:
mnr "cro"
Deslgaatioxt'
©C
Case
Pield
Case
Total
ATL
$63.6
$12.7
$76. 3
DAL-w/O
Burnside
12.4
11.6
24.0
Burns ide
59.1
59.1
DEN
4.4
10.8
15.3
KAK
15.9
16.0
31.9
KEW
124.8
124.8
VAL
1.0
1.8
2.8
- Totals
222.1
112.0
334.3
While I take great pride in ay role in the recoveries on the
cases that I handled, I was only one aeaber of the various teams
that worked together closely in order to achieve the RTC success.
In each case, the Investigations Unit assigned aultiple
investigators to the project who, in aost cases, worked on the
case for over two years. Additionally, the fee-counsel in each
case were ertraordinarily able and experienced. Finally, I
worked closely with various PLS attorneys in Washington during
the final stages of each case.
That such teaawork paid off for the RTC is exeaplified by the
' This table was prepared froa inforaation obtained froa the
PLS case tracking database which usually identifies the source of
recoveries by the Investigations' Office handling the case rather
than the PLS office responsible for the institution. Accordingly,
I adjusted the Washington versus Field Office figures according to
the location of the PLS line attorney assigned to the institution.
146
recoveries for just three natters:
♦ The three natters account for over 50% of all
RTC PLS recoveries on cases supervised by the
seventeen PLS regional or field offices
throughout the country.
♦ The cases presently account for alaost 20% of
all RTC PLS recoveries nationally, and the
RTC is considering an additional $8.6 Billion
in settlement offers on the saae cases.
♦ The cases account for over 50% of all RTC PLS
recoveries fron institutions with total
assets under one billion dollars.
XXZ. TBB "08TRICB XPPROACH" TO VLB CXStS
X. TEE MCO XPPROXCH
The Dallas Metroplex ("MCO") PLS unit' under Section Chief Rex
Taylor adopted an "ostrich approach" that sought ways to avoid
the development or pursuit of claims. In order to justify the
closing-out of cases in which it was stated that there was a
"lack of evidence" of net worth or merit, the MCO PLS attorneys
used a combination of the following techniques:
♦ They waited for the cases to be delivered to them on a
"silver-platter" rather than working as part of a team
in the investigation stage. Instead of working side-
by-side with the Investigations Unit, the MCO PLS
attorneys relied upon E-mail directives designed to
shift, as much as possible, the responsibility for the
PLS investigation of an institution to the line
investigator. Under this method, it was not "the fault
of PLS"^ if a potentially viable claim was not
sufficiently developed when the limitations period
expired.
i
' The MCO PLS and MCO Investigations Unit do not overlap
completely on their cases. The MCO PLS unit continued to handle
some Houston and San Antonio cases, and the MCO Investigations Unit
worked on several cases that were not bandied by MCO PLS.
* This attitude ignored the fact that the ultimate
responsibility for the recommendation to sue or close-out a case
sqn^arely rested with the PLS office charged with responsibility for
the institution. It also ignored the tools, such as the ability to
issue subpoenas or hire fee counsel, available to the line attorney
that were not available to the Investigations Unit.
147
♦ The PLS attorneys under Taylor Beldon hired fee-counsel
without a specific order to hire counsel on a case. In
one case, Rex Taylor waited for over a year and a half
to hire counsel on a nulti-billion dollar institution
when projected losses were in excess of one billion
dollars.
♦ As noted below, MCO PLS attorneys aeldoa used their
subpoena power. They closed out 130 claims without
ever issuing a subpoena on the institution. Indeed,
during 1992, the MCO attorneys only obtained four
Orders of Investigation for all of their institutions.
♦ The MCO PLS attorneys relied alaost exclusively upon
prelininary and limited asset searches and upon
institution records in order to opine that potential
defendants did not have sufficient net worth to make a
case cost-effective. They failed to pursue
aggressively other avenues to determine net worth (such
as interviews or use of subpoenas) that may have
revealed income or non-real estate assets.
♦ The MCO PLS attorneys were loathe to pursue
aggressively "deep-pockets" who had the resources to
fight vigorously against the RTC. The MCO PLS
attorneys only "recommended" one suit against a "Big
Six" accounting firm. In fact, they even tried to close
out that claim, but the client refused to acquiesce.
As Rex Taylor noted in closing out one potentially
viable accounting claim, "Big Six firms take a
scorched-earth policy." Similarly, the MCO attorneys
have yet to file a single successful attorney
malpractice claim, nor have they initiated any claims
against securities brokers. Such fear of risk in
pursuing deep-pocket defendants eliminated any
potential to achieve significant, cost-effective
recoveries on the MCO PLS cases.
♦ The MCO PLS attorneys refused to consider imaginative
or novel legal theories in pursuing claims. Indeed, Rex
Taylor severely criticized the legal theories
underlying the recoveries in two institutions and, in
his opinion, the mere investigation of such claims
(which have resulted in ov*r $60 million in cash
recoveries for the RTC) seemed to b« "... ia Tiolatioa
of the lavs eontrolliag bov RTC moaeT Bay be speat."
Similarly, the MCO PLS attorneys led by Taylor actively
resisted a consolidated investigation of a sec\irities
broker which ultimately resulted in a $6 million dollar
settlement for the RTC and FDIC.
♦ Rex Taylor seldom worked on those institutions assigned
7
148
i
directly to him. For example, he only worked 40 hours
over an entire year on a multi-billion dollar thrift.
B. TES RXST7LT8 07 THS NCO XPPROXCH
The gross "nuiLbers" underlying the performance of the MCO PLS
attorneys reveal the "results" of the MCO "ostrich approach".
At various times, the MCO attorneys had responsibility for 42
thrifts totalling over $10.7 billion in assets and almost $5
billion in projected losses to the RTC. In addition, the MCO
office was the oldest PLS field office in the country and was
staffed by attorneys who each had more than a year's experience
as a PLS attorney (often on the very cases they were assigned
when the MCO office was formed] prior to the staffing of the
office.
The following table contrasts the "opportunity" for recoveries
for each Texas PLS office with actual recoveries:
orricB
TOTAL ABSST8
&EC0VBIXS8 1
Regional
$2.5 billion
$59.7 million
Metroplex
$10.7 billion
$2.2 million
San Antonio
$8.2 billion
$4.4 Billion
Housjton
$4.8 billion
S3. 6 million
TOTAL
$26.2 billion
$69.9 million
I
By all objective criteria, the office should have out-performed
all other PLS field offices. Instead, the office under Rex
Taylor resulted in net losses to the RTC and almost no successful
PLS results.
IV. THB USB 07 SUBPOKHXSi A COXPA&ATrTB AXALT8X8
The contrast between the "team" and "ostrich" approach perhaps is
illustrated best by contrasting the usage of the RTC's
administrative subpoena power by the respective offices.
Subpoenas may well be a PLS attorney's single most powerful tool
in evaluating and pursuing professional liability claims. A PLS
attorney may use administrative subpoenas to obtain documents
i
I
149
outside the control of the RTC, compel oral testimony, determine
the net worth of potential defendants, and a host of other
purposes. If used properly, the subpoena power permits the RTC to
obtain early favorable settlements. Conversely, the failure to
use subpoenas often results in making decisions with incomplete
Information and inferior recoveries.
X, TSS KSaZOUa. approach! XOORBSSZYI TJSB op 8CBP0EKAB
In order to obtain early settlements on PLS claims, the RTC must
convince the potential defendants that the RTC is prepared to
proceed with a well-prepared, meritorious case and that the RTC
has the advantage in litigation. Aggressive use of
administrative subpoenas gives the RTC an enormous advantage
since the RTC can fully prepare its case prior to filing suit and
outside the presence of the potential defendants.
During calendar year 1992, the Dallas Regional office issued
approximately 180 subpoenas. The following table illustrates the
relationship between the aggressive use of subpoenas and early
settlements on the cases:
msTiTtn'.
SUBPOEKA
KK8ULTS 1
B 1
100
Investment bankers settled for $7.5
million cash within days of filing suit
•
n
Accountants settled for $3.55 million in
a global settlement prior to suit
■
u
Two directors settled for $1.15 million
prior to suit; a third director settled
for $300,000 prior to discovery
B 2
35
Five directors offered $7.3 million to
settle prior to suit
m
■
Accountants claim allocated $43.69
million in global settlement prior to
suit
Global
Securit.
10
Securities broker paid $6 million to
settle multiple claims
TOTAL
13S
fC4.«4 millioB
In each of the above cases, ve developed the cases thoroughly
prior to settlement discussions. Accordingly, we could set
150
•arly, infonaed settlement goals with confidence and could
effectively convince the defendants that the RTC was fully
prepared to litigate if the cases did not settle. Stated
differently, the RTC's head-start in the pre-trial investigation
gave the RTC an incredible advantage at the negotiation table.
B. TBS MCO XPPROXCH: THS •*LOXDBO OUV" PHZLOSOPSY
Conversely, the failure of the old Netroplex CFO to prop>erly use
their adainistrative subpoena power prior to filing suit
contributed to their inability to obtain aany significant early
settlements. The three attorneys in the Metroplex CFO only
obtained four Orders of Investigation and issued only 53
svibpoenas for 42 institutions with over $10.7 billion in total
assets during the entire tenure of the MCO PLS program from April
1991 until June 1992. Stated differently, MCO PLS attorneys
issued only 53 subpoenas even though they were investigating
thrifts with projected loses approaching $5 billion. Those
figures translate to only ten tubpoenas per billion dollars in
losses to the Xaeriean taxpaverl To date, the cases handled by
the MCO PLS attorneys account for only 4% of the recoveries in
the Southwest Region.
One MCO PLS attorney who has been promoted to PLS management in
Dallas justified his reluctance to use subpoenas because they
were "intrusive" and sought information about net worth, which is
"....a vei-y private and confidential matter." He opined that the
use of RTC subpoenas are ".... best used wisely and sparingly,
just as a police officer (hopefully) uses his pistol only when
necessary. "
The impact of the failure to use subpoenas is even more striking
when placed in the context of individual cases. MCO PLS
attorneys have formally recommended suit on the following cases
without using their subpoena power:
Type of Claia
Subpoenas
mesults
Atty
0
Sumnary Judgement against RTC;
appeal withdrawn because RTC later
concluded that the law fira had
done nothing wrong.
D&O
0
Settlement at less than RTC costs
atty #1
0
MCO ATS memo rejected within RTC
10
151
atty / 2
0
MCO ATS Beao rejected pending
fxirther investigation under tolling
agreement
D&O
0
Suit pending; no )cnown net worth of
any defendant
Accountant
0
$850,000 settleaent as .7% of
global settleaent with RTC
Bond
15
Suit filed; subsequent fee counsel
projected 10% probability of
success a aonth before suit;
proposed settleaent for less than
the RTC's attorney fees
D&O
0
Strong criticism regarding poor
state of preparation of case prior
to suit
attorney
0
MCO ATS memo rejected pending
further investigation under tolling
agreeaent
accountant
1
MCO ATS aeao pending; projected
probability of success is between
2« and %
0(0
0
Settleaent on eve of trial at less
than 2 to 1 recovery ratio
D&O
0
Pending suit
accountant
2
Suit filed; no settlement offers
TOTALS
18
RTC costs exceed settleaent
recoveries to date
After the 1992 Reorganization, Washington PLS started to obtain
strong judicial support for the use of administrative subpoenas
and actively encouraged the PLS line attorneys to use the RTC
subpoena powar aggressively. Indeed, Washington PLS issued a
comprehensive handbook and gave an oral presentation concerning
the use of subpoenas to aach of the PLS field offices.
Accordingly, the uaa of adainistrative subpoanas should have
draaatically incraasad. In fact, however, the usage not only
failed to rise. It actually droppad in cases handled by the
Dallas Office. Excluding ay subpoanas, the Reorganized Dallas
Office issued only 73 subpoenas over an eight-aonth period for
all the institutions in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi.
11
152
V. ZMTXIUIAL SnVERVZBXOM Or DXLXJLB PL8 BY &XZ TAYLOR
The 1992 Reorganization also inpacted the amount of substantive
supervision of PLS line attorneys handling cases in Texas,
Mississippi, and Louisiana. The PLS Section Chiefs of San
Antonio, Houston, Baton Rouge, and the Dallas Regional office all
caae fron private practice and were very actively involved in the
development of the cases under their first-line supervision.
Conversely, Section Chief Taylor virtually abdicated his
substantive responsibilities. In cases inherited by Rex Taylor,
the RTC was not harmed by this approach. However, in cases
supervised by Rex Taylor for two years, this approach has
undermined the PLS program.
A. TES ZMBERZTEO CABES
As noted above, the RTC reorganization collapsed the Dallas
Regional Office and the Baton Rouge, Houston, and San Antonio
field offices into the new Dallas Office PLS Section under the
supervision of Rex Taylor. To the extent those cases "inherited*
by Rex Taylor were veil developed or the line attorneys were
self- sufficient, the Rex Taylor management style generally did
not affect the cases.'
The following table Illustrates the almost complete lack of
substantive input that I received from Rex Taylor during my
tenure as a Senior Attorney under his direct supervision from
June 1, 1992 until the present.
DATS
TYPB OP MSMO
TAYLOR ZKPUT
6/9/92
ATSettle with Investment
Banker for $2.5 million cash
none
6/9/92
ATSue Inside director
none
* The occasional Input from Section Chief Taylor generally
sought to discourage the pursuit of the claims. For example.
Section Chief Taylor questioned whether some of the larger Regional
cases should have even been investigated by the RTC. The subsequent
success of the questioned claims (with recoveries of almost $60
million) silenced his early criticism.
12
153
DATS
TYPS or KBtO
TAYLOR lir?OT
6/26/92
ATSettl* with insider director
for one million in CAsh and a
note
none
7/21/92
ATSue directors, officers,
borrowers and attorneys
minor
substantive
9/11/92
ATSettle with inside director
none
9/17/92
ATSettle with Znvestaent
BanXer for $5 Billion cash
none
10/2/92
ATSue attorneys
none
11/5/92
ATSue accountants
minor
proofreading
11/16/92
ATSettle with accountants for
$200,000
none
11/16/92
ATSue attorneys
none
11/23/92
ATSue attorneys
none
11/23/92
ATSettle global securities
claim
none
11/27/92
ATSeek Asset Freeze
none
12/7/92
ATOrop claims against D&O's
none
12/7/92
ATDrop count against D&O
none
1/11/93
ATSettle bond claim for
$135,000
none
3/9/93
ATSettle with inside director
for $300,000
none
The "none" under the category entitled "Taylor Input" includes
both oral and written input either before or after the submission
of the memo. Indeed, it was not unusual for Rex Taylor to be
unaware that Z was even working on a memo until I formally
submitted it to him for transmission to his superiors and the
client. Z submitted an ATSue memo seeking to bring a $30 million
fraud claim against a law firm and 40 of its partners ; Rex
Taylor's only response was "Is this your institution?" Within a
few weeks, I had my first and only case review with Rex Taylor
during which time Z identified my cases and their status.
13
154
Substantive conversations between Rex Taylor and nyself never
exceeded two hours per quarter, and it was not unusual for us to
have no substantive discussions for a Konth or two. Written
substantive comments from Rex Taylor were equally sparse.
B. THS MCO CX8ES
If the Metroplex PLS cases under the supervision of Section Chief
Taylor for the last two years are any example, the future results
of the cases under the reorganized Dallas Office led by Taylor
will fall well short of realistic potential recoveries.
The results of the PLS cases under Rex Taylor's first-line
supervisory responsibility for almost two years suggest an almost
complete abdication of his substantive duties as a PLS
supervisor:
♦ The MCO cases resulted in recoveries of
approximately two million (or 3% of all
recoveries on Texas RTC thrifts) at a cost in
excess of $ 2 million.
♦ The MCO PLS attorneys only filed seven
lawsuits of which three will not even recover
the RTC attorney fees and a fourth mav not
recover the fees. The actual or projected
"value" of the remaining three suits is less
than $2.5 million, assuming the original
projections are accurate.
♦ Three MC0/PL5 attorney malpractice cases have
been under tolling agreements for over nine
months and the defendants have yet to offer
any money to settle the claims. In fact, I
just recommended that the RTC drop one of the
claims because we cannot prove liability,
causation or damages.
♦ The three MCO PLS attorneys have issued, on
average, just slightly over one subpoena per
institution under their direction.
▼ZI. TEB DXLLXS TIB COUKSSL PBOBLSM
The proponents of the 1992 Reorganization argued that any
transition problems from the reorganization could be compensated
for through the use of experienced PLS fee-counsel. While such
argument ignored the need for the RTC to internalize the
14
155
supervision of fee counsel, the arguaent at least recognized that
experienced fee-counsel is a key aember of the PLS teas on any
significant setter.
Unfortunately, the 1992 Reorganization has also resulted in
txurnover in the outside fee-counsel that were supposed to
compensate for the turnover of PLS and Investigations.
Locating a sufficient number of competent fee-counsel to handle
PLS cases in Texas has always been a problem because of the
extent of the thrift crisis in Texas. Many of the large firms
have conflicts with the RTC or FDIC because they represented
failed financial institutions and are themselves actual or
potential targets of PLS suits. Other firms simply do not have
the experience or capacity to handle the cases. Still other firms
have elected not to represent the RTC.
The fee counsel problem has been exacerbated by a recent "rate
schedule" policy that the Dallas Legal Division began imposing
several months ago. Under the "rate schedule" policy, the RTC
Legal Division has given law firms the ultimatum to either agree
to the RTC '8 approved rates (from Senior Partner to junior
paralegal) or else they cannot do RTC work. Like many policies,
the original intent of the "rate schedule" policy was
commendable. It did result in an overall reduction in the hourly
rates paid by the RTC for legal services. Unfortunately, the
rigid implementation of the policy will have an adverse impact on
the major PLS cases.
Fee counsel are not fungible coBusodities . Some counsel have the
ability to handle large volume foreclosures cheaply while others
can handle large PLS cases. While the RTC needs each type of
counsel, it is much harder to find experienced, qualified fee-
counsel that have the "intangible" qualities that distinguish
between those attorneys that merely "go through the motions" of
handling a PLS case and those attorneys who can actually produce
results on the high profile PLS matters.
The application of the rigid Dallas rate schedule to PLS cases,
without any consideration of the particular case, law firm, or
potential recovery, ignores the policy considerations underlying
the pursuit of PLS cases.
The recent controversy described in ay Grievance highlights the
problem. In that case, ACC Vera-Rojas wanted to firs fee-counsel
if they did not agree to the rate schedule, even though the
termination would ham the case as well as cost the RTC money.
Additionally, I was: (1) told that the termination of ay PLS
counsel was not ay concern; (2) repriaanded for even bringing the
PLS issues to the attention of the aanagement of the Dallas Legal
Division; (3) told to conceal information from ay client; and (4)
cut-off from communication with PLS management in Washington.
15
156
While I will not restate ay Grievance here, the facts supporting
the Grievance illustrate the problens caused by the 1992
Reorganisation. The controversy over By fee-counsel was not an
internal balancing of conpeting policies or a free and open
discussion of what was best for the RTC. Rather, the Dallas
decision-Bakers sinply did not care to hear about the inpact of
their decision on a aajor PLS case. Further, Arturo Vera-Rojas
and Rex Taylor went to extraordinary aeasures to prevent ae from
even talking to the RTC eaployess who did care about the PLS
case.
While the RTC "dodged-the-bullet" on the above case, the systemic
problen reaained. On soae aajor cases, the RTC needs to be
willing to pay a little acre per hour than the rate schedule
allows in order to get the best results possible for aajor PLS
aatters. These cases are not the same as foreclosures or routine
litigation and deserve proper attention. To paraphrase an old
adage: soaetiaes the RTC needs to be willing to "spend aoney to
aake aoney." The results of the RTC cases illustrate the point
- — - alaost 90% of the PLS recoveries in Texas were froa cases
handled by fee-counsel whose rates exceeded the Dallas rate
schedule.
A second systeaic problea illustrated by the fee-counsel
controversy was the callous disregard of PLS concerns by the
Dallas Legal Division. It was not siaply • case where Dallas
aanageaent listened to all sides and aade an inforaed decision.
In fact, they refused to even discuss the concerns of PLS and
iaposed two "gag" orders. Such disregard peraeates the Dallas
PLS progran and was the very danger that the original structure
of PLS reporting directly to Washington sought to avoid.
▼I. COMCLUSIOV
The Dallas PLS prograa is in serious trouble.
It has lost Bost of its experienced attorneys and lacks any
aanageaent "vision" that will proaote PLS recoveries. Indeed,
the failure to use subpoenas, lack of first line PLS supervision,
teraination of fee- counsel, issuance of gag orders, and the
current "ostrich approach" indicate a virtual collapse of the
Dallas PLS prograa.
Soae of the probleas caused by the 1992 reorganization are
irreversible. Yet, soae cases can still be salvaged if reaedial
measures are activated iaaediately. The first step is to
iaaediately investigate soae of the concerns raised in this
aeaoranduB and ay Grievance.
16
157
cc:
Edward H. Stephenson, Jr.
Assistant Director
Government Accounting Office
John Adair
RTC Inspector General
Edward Maheney
Assistant Director-
Conservatorship Operations
William DePugh
Managing Investigator
RTC-Dallas Office
Diane Mendoza
Assistant Director-
Investigations
RTC-Dallas Office
Arturo Vera-Rojas
General Counsel
RTC-Dallas Office
David Stockwell
Senior Counsel
Litigation
RTC-Dallas Office
D. Rex Taylor
Counsel (Section Chief)
Professional Liability Section
RTC-Dallas Office
Bruce Pederson
Counsel
RTC-Denver Office
Chris Jones
Assistant Director-
Investigations
RTC-Dallas Office
17
7A-flin n _ Q/1 _ c
158
■TZP on &BBUTTXL AMD fTEP TWO XPPKXL 07 OKZrTMICZ
XOXIMST XSSZBTXVT QZXZHXL COUV8EL JJtTUSO TXSA-KOJXS
AKD PBOrSSSZOKXL tZABZLZLTY BBCTZOH CHZE7 D. &BZ TAYLOR
DXLLXB LBSXL PTVIBZOW-RgSOLOTIOH TR08T COBPORATIOM
CRirVANCE APPEAL FROM
THOMAS J. BURNSIDE
PLS SENIOR ATTORNEY
RTC DALLAS LEGAL DIVISION
MARCH 3, 1993
159
ZimtODOCTZOH
The attached materials describe vrongful conduct of Assistant
General Counsel Arturo Vera-Rojas and Section Chief (PI^) Rex
Taylor that is detrimental to the Resolution Trust Corporation and
which foro the basis of my formal grievance. The conduct included:
♦ A gag order intended to conceal material
information from the RTC client
representatives charged with maXing decisions
on a matter under my supervision
♦ A second gag order intended to prevent a PLS
attorney from freely communicating with PLS
management in Washington
♦ Personal attacks on a PLS line attorney whose
cases account for almost $60 million in cash
recoveries for the RTC
♦ Discrimination against a minority-owned law
firm
♦ Actions taken in reckless disregard of the
conseqruences to a PLS case that is second only
to Charles Keating 's Lincoln Savings in total
RTC PLS recoveries
♦ Making a mockery of the FDIC Grievance
Procedure by attempting to appoint the
immediate subordinate and personal friend of
Arturo Vera-Rojas as the Step Two reviewer of
the grievance against Messrs. Vera-Rojas and
Taylor
The attached memoranda seek "full, impartial, and prompt
consideration" of my grievance within the prescribed 15 day period.
Additionally, the materials inform you of improper conduct of RTC
employees under your supervision.
160
Kemorandua to:
Proa:
Date:
Re:
John Lomax
Vice President
RTC-Dallas Office
E. Clion Curtis
Acting VP k Associate General Counsel
(Corporate Affairs)
Washington, D.C.
Thomas J. Burns ide
Senior Attorney (PLS)
Dallas, Texas
March 3, 1993
4
$
step One Rebuttal and Step Two Appeal
of the February 5 Grievance against
AGC Vera-Rojas and Section Chief Taylor
and
Report of Isproper Conduct by RTC
Employees under your Supeirvision
1
I. SXZCUTZVX ■tnOtARY
This meDor£ndum fulfills the dual purpose of: (i) advising you of
improper conduct within the Dallas Legal Division; and (ii)
obtaining a "Step Two" review of my grievance against Assistant
General Counsel Arturo Vera-Rojas and Section Chief D. Rex Taylor.
I understand that you jointly have direct supervisory
responsibilities over the Dallas Legal Division and therefore have
a direct interest in this aatter.
On February 5, I presented a formal grievance against AGC Vera-
Rojas and Section Chief Taylor of the Dallas Legal Division. Among
other things, the grievance objected to two "gag orders" iaposed on
ae after I protested conduct that I believed: (i) iapaired the
probability of success and the cost-effectiveness of a aajor PLS
case; and (ii) explicitly discriainated against a ainority-ovned
law fira.
Under the gag orders:
♦ I was instructed to conceal material inforaation
iapacting the PLS case from the client representatives
who were charged with making decisions on the case; and
♦ Z was placed under extraordinary restrictions concerning
aay coaaunications between ayself and Washington PLS
aanageaent on any matter I was handling.
<
I
161
My attempts over the last thirty days to resolve the natter within
the Dallas Leqal Division have been repeatedly rebuffed and have
resulted in threats, accusations, and retaliatory action against
Be. Additionally, I have yet to receive any legitisate
justification for the gag orders or improper conduct. Finally, the
cover-up activities and i«proper conduct have continued into the
grievance process.
Accordingly, I an obliged to "go over the heads" of AGC Vera-Rojas
and Section Chief Taylor in order to resolve ay personal grievance
against thea and, sore importantly, to bring such wrongful conduct
to the attention of RTC management so that appropriate action may
be taken to protect the RTC and the taxpayers.
The actions of AGC Vera-Rojas and Section Chief Taylor Involve
fundamental issues that impact the very foundation of the Legal
Division and raise questions which must be addressed:
♦ Do lawyers in the Dallas Legal Division have an
obligation to communicate material information to the RTC
client representatives who have delegated responsibility
on the matter?
♦ Does an RTC lawyer/manager have the authority to order a
lawyer/subordinate to violate his or her professional
code of ethics? If so, what is the source of such
authority?
• Does 12 CFR 1605 constitute the sole and exclusive
statement of "ethics" which governs the conduct of
lawyers within the Legal Division? Does 12 crR 1605
pre-empt the Code of Professional Responsibility for
attorneys?
• Did the Dallas Legal Division improperly discriminate
against a small minority-owned law firm when it coerced
the firm into billing 25% less than a majority firm for
the same attorney working en tbe same ease, simply
because the bills were submitted under the letterhead of
• minority-ovned firm?
♦ Did the Dallas L«gal Division act In reckless disregard
of the consequences of their actions to a major PLS case
when they instructed me to terminate two key fee-counsel
only days before a major settlement conference and just
a week before the tolling agreements expired?
* Vhat was the Dallas Legal Division's motivation behind
the gag orders, threats, discrimination, and interference
with the grievance procedures?
162
The tbov* issue* go to th« very core of the Legal Division end
Involve Buch aore than a "siaple grievance." For that reason, I am
suboitting this nemorandua for dual purposes.
XZ. BZOORAPHXCXL BACKOROOVD
The Dallas Legal Division has begun en "attack the accuser"
strategy in order to avoid scrutiny of their conduct. A brief
review of ay record as a PLS attorney for the last two and a half
years belies this recent effort to undersine ay reputation.
Z originally joined the Dallas PLS section In October 1990. My
last Performance Appraisal (co-signed by ACC Vera-Rojas) contained
the following "ratings" on a 1 to 5 scale in addition to very
favorable narrative coaaents:
Perfonnance "warrants special recognition"
14 categories
Perfomance "clearly above that expected
of a coapetent eaployee"
8 categories
Performance "to the extent expected of a
competent employee"
1 category
Performance "acceptable but reflects some
weaknesses that can be overcome"
none
Performance " exhibits definite
weakiesses"
none
I received an award for Sustained Superior Performance in 1991.
Since I received the above Performance Appraisal and award, the RTC
PLS recoveries on cases under ay supervision as a line attorney
have accounted for alaost $60 aillion, or 20% of all RTC PLS
recoveries in the country. The following table illustrates the
distribution of RTC-PLS recoveries for Texas, Mississippi, and
Louisiana thrifts by PLS attorney or office:
PLS attorney/Office
fteoovery
Percent
Burnside eases
(under ay supervision for
over 2 yrs)
$59.7 Billion
701
Metroplex CFO cases
(under the supervision of
Rex Taylor for 1 t 1/2 years)
2.2 Billion
3%
Houston, San Antonio, and
Louisiana CFO cases
9.4 Billion
111
163
Washington O.C.
cases
12.4 Billion
15%
Other
1.2 Billion
1%
TOTXL
$84.9 Billion
100%
Naturally, I was only one Bember of various teaas coaprised of
Investigations, fee counsel, experts, and others that produced such
results. For exanple, 37 % of all RTC recoveries in the Ernst k
Young ("EY") global settleaent were allocated to cases on which I
had worked for two years and had received forsal authority to sue
prior to coBBenceaent of the EY settleaent discussions. ■ (With
respect to all of the results on ay cases. Section Chief Taylor
either actively resisted the cases or added nothing to the result.)
My cases also have generated an additional $8.9 Billion in
settlement offers either under consideration or approved by the
RTC.
In sumaary, I believe that ay record should refute any atteapts to
divert attention froa ay charges by attacking ae. To that end, I
attach ay SF 171 and Perforaance Appraisal.
III. THE UKDEKLYINQ CONTROVERSY
X. TEE 7L8 CX8E
The center of this aatter involves a PLS case that was — and is — a
Bajor highlight of ay professional career.
As the line attorney assigned to the institution since January
1991, I spent over 1000 hours (aany of which were uncoapensated) to
help develop the claias froa the preliainary investigation through
the final stages of settleaent recoveries. Such efforts
necessitated working weekends out-of-town and 16-hour days over a
two-year period. By January 1993, however, the efforts of Byself
and others (including fee counsel) had paid off. Total cash
recoveries and settleaent offers on the RTC PLS claias for this
one institution exceeded $50 aillion and were second only to
recoveries arising out of Charles Keating's infamous Lincoln
Savings debacle.
By January 1993, we were concluding the final stages of pre-suit
settleaent discussions with the inside directors and had recently
obtained authority to seek an asset freeze against one of the
directors. The defendants had collectively offered $5.75 Billion
cash while the RTC sought $7.5 to 8 Billion and expressed a
willingness to discuss teras.
While recognizing the apparent iapasse on the eve of the expiration
of the tolling agreements, both sides agreed to aeet again during
the week of January 25 to determine if we could reach a settleaent.
164
All parties recognized that the RTC would probably file suit at the
•nd of tne week unless the parties were very close to settlement
when the tolling agreements expired on January 29.
The RTC appeared to have the upper hand going into the settlement
discussions because of the pre-suit preparation of the case. The
RTC had reviewed over 7.8 million documents and had taken over 35
key witness statements. The defendants were well aware of the
RTC'B head start and their settlement offers appeared to recognize,
•t least partially, the RTC's short-term advantage in preparation.
B. TKB TSZ COCKSZL PKOBLBN
The PLS case was prepared by a majority fira/minority-owned firm
joint-venture. Prior to the settlement meeting, two of the
majority firm attorneys, who had been intimately involved in the
day-to-day preparation of the case, announced their interest in
becoming members of the minority-owned firm.
Originally, I believed that the move would have absolutely no
impact on the staffing of the case since it involved only a move of
two attorneys between RTC-approved firms already working on the
case. In fact, I thought that the move benefited the RTC because
the minority firm would be in a position to bill over 50% of the
fees charged to the case and because the two lawyers were willing
to reduce their rates by $20 dollars/hour from the RTC rates
approved for the majority firm.
The RTC Legal Division, however, would not agree to pay the
minority firm fees for the two attorneys unless the minority firm
would accept a $4 5 dollar /hour rate reduction from the RTC-approved
majority firm rates. AGC Vera-Rojas later rationalized the 25%
rate reduction for the same attorneys vorkiag ob the same file
merely because they now would be submiting their bills under the
letterhead of a minor ity-o%med firm and, as such, "they will not
have the [majority firm's] overhead to deal with.
■I
By mid- January, I became concerned that the RTC and the minority
firm had reached an impasse and started communicating my concerns
about the impact of the impasse on the PLS case to various members
of the Dallas Legal Division. My concerns escalated on Friday,
January 22 when AGC Vera-Rojas told me that the RTC would not
approve the minority firm rates for the two lawyers and to "Oet en
with [my] job, which is to recommend m local qualified firm from
our approved list to be referred the satter."
X was startled by the decision and had grave concerns regarding
AGC Vera-Rojas' order to replace the two lawyers just days before
the final settlement meeting and the expiration of the tolling
agreements. I believed that the termination of the two lawyers at
that time would have such a dramatic adverse impact on the
165
probability of auccess and th« cost-«ffectlv«ne«s of the PLS casa
that I reluctantly would be forced to recomiDend to eettle the PLS
case for whatever we could get during the week of January 25 rather
than having to file suit utilizing counsel who were unfamiliar with
the case.
I went to Section Chief Taylor to explain nor* fully ay alara and
to determine his position on the natter. At his reqpiest, I
immediately drafted a memo that set forth ay concerns over the
decision to terminate the two lawyers who were joining the
■inority-owned firm:
Substantive iapaet on the ease
♦ The two lawyers had si>ent 1800 hours at a cost of
$315,000 to prepare the case for trial and were two
of the three primary trial lawyers on the case.
Much of their knowledge and "appreciation" of the
facts of the case would be lost in a transfer of
the file to substitute lawyers.
♦ The impending settlement discussions and tolling
expiration did not afford us sufficient time to
educate new counsel. The authorization to seek an
asset freeze complicated the aatter because of a
possible mini-trial shortly after filing.
♦ The defendants vould view the termination of the
attorneys who were most knowledgeable about the
case as a major self-inflicted setback for the RTC
and a sign of the RTC's lack of "will" to pursue
the case. I was concerned that even the existing
settlement offers might evaporate.
♦ I also pointed out that I do not believe that
counsel are fungible and coamunicated ay
observations concerning the quality of the two
attorneys.
♦ Finally, I observed that the termination decision
essentially "hand-cuffed" the business-side and
ayself in the negotiations. We could not be as
vigorous in our positions if we knew that the RTC
was not prepared to litigate as effectively in the
event that the defendants did not meet our
settlement goals.
DialBished oost •ffeetiveaess.
♦ The teroination decision also vould increase rather
than decrease the cost of litigation because of the
166
•stisated cost of duplicating vork for which the
RTC had already paid.
♦ I estimated that the Bat Increase in the cost of
replacing counsel (even deducting the $30/hour
"savings") vould exceed $220,000 even if we
ignored the substantive inpact of the teraination
on the case.
Z felt that the aeoo nade a strong case for keeping the PLS "teas"
intact and believed that ACC Vera-Rojas would change his position.
I was greatly aistaken.
ZZZ. THZ XOAO 0R£>ER8"
A. TES 7ZR8T OAQ OROEK
On Saturday, January 23, I received an E-mail from Section Chief
Taylor that absolutely stunned me. Despite the adverse impact of
the termination decision on the case, Z was told that it was
"...not a matter to be discussed with the client represeBtativee."
Immediately following the gag order instructing me to conceal
material information from the client. Section Chief Taylor
threatened:
"As a warning, your conduct may be considered
insubordination. Please do not make a difficult
situation worse for yourself."
After a sleepless weekend, Z called PLS Senior Counsel
Mark Cabrellian at 7:00 am CST on Monday, February 25, to inform
him of the matter. Then I met with Section Chief Taylor when he
arrived at the office at 9:30 am and informed him that:
(a) Z believed that his gag order was both illegal and
unethical because I was under an obligation both as an RTC
employee and a lawyer to communicate material information to
the client so that they could make informed decisions and
recommendations. In this case, the business side needed to
know of the impact that termination of counsel could have on
the probability of success and cost of pursuing the lawsuit as
opposed to accepting the pending settlement offers.
(b) Z told Mr. Taylor that Z had called Senior Counsel
Cabrellian and that either he or both of us could call Mr.
Cabrellian to discuss the matter.
(c) Additionally, Z told Section Chief Taylor that, in view of
the gag order, he himself had an ethical duty to call Managing
Znvestigator DePugh to advise him of the gag order and the
decision.
167
S«ction Chief Taylor t«nilnat«d the ■eeting without denying the
allegations or explaining his actions. Instead, he immediately
vent to consult with other aemhers of the Dallas Legal Division.
I had no further communication with Section Chief Taylor until 2:00
pm on Friday, January 29, when I hand-delivered an E-mail which
memorialized our Monday conversation to him. I still have never
received any explanation, justification, or clarification of the
gag order from Mr. Taylor.
B. TEE •BTTLSXZKT DX8CU88Z0N8
I carefully considered the matter and sought counsel on the
legality of the gag order. On Monday, January 25, I fully informed
the client of what had transpired. I also Informed the client that
Senior Counsel Gabrellian had advised me "not to worry" about the
termination of fee counsel because, if the matter was not resolved
in Dallas, Washington would try to intervene. He also told me to
go into the settlement discussions with "guns ablating" but to
advise the client of some uncertainty on the fee counsel issue.
The client and I then made the decision to negotiate based on the
premise that the RTC would not terminate counsel. We went into the
discussions with "guns ablazing" and ultimately received settlement
offers totalling $7.3 million (mostly cash) §1.55 million more
than the previous offers.
C. THB 8EC0KD OAO ORDER
AGC Vera-Rojas did not forgive my conversations with Senior Counsel
Gabrellian and my persistence in the matter. On Tuesday, February
2, he sent an E-mail to the DC PLS and the Dallas Legal Division
management which made several bizarre allegations and then imposed
a second gag order:
■In view of the above, I will appreciate that if you have
any questions regarding this matter or any other matter
preeeatly under the oversight of Mister Burns ide, or
otharvise wish to eommumieate with him in your role as
PLS coordinator for the Dallas Office, you do so through
Rex Taylor and David Stoc)cwell together or with mymelf
present, (emphasis added)
This second gag order apparently sought to isolate me further as
punishment for daring to spea)( out against the actions of AGC Vera-
Rojas and Section Chief Taylor. The order has interfered with my
ability to perform my duties.
168
D. a BKXLL KZMORZTY rXRN CXPZTULXTEI . . . .
While th« battl* raged within the RTC, the ninority fira was
undergoing its own private problems and the econoaic reality of
being a aaall fira (without the "overhead" that would perait it to
withstand cash flow concerns^) forced the fira to capitulate as to
the one attorney who Bade the aove prior to the rate controversy.
The other attorney, a feoale partner at the sajority fira,
ultiaately decided to stay at the aajority rate and still works on
the PLS case at an RTC approved rate which is $20 more than the
proposed Binority rate.
The decision had a clear discriBinatory iapact against a Binority
fira. The RTC had decided that each of the lawyers were worth $180
and $l70/hour as long as they billed their tiae under the
letterhead of the aajority fira. Yet the RTC demanded that the
saae attoraeys vorkiag en the saae file were only "worth" 751 of
the aajority firm's rate if they billed their tiae under a
letterhead of a ainority-owned fira. Saall wonder the female
partner decided to stay at the aajority fira!
ZV. THB rSBROXRY S 0RZEVXMC8 and ZMTERXN COKXUVZCATZOMS
X. THB ORZEVXMCE
After all ay inforaal attempts to resolve this aatter failed, Z
reluctantly filed a grievance against Rex Taylor and Xrturo Vera-
Rojas. The FOIC Grievance Procedure allowed ae to subait ay
grievance to ay imaediate supervisor or "...whoever was rkspoasible
for the action being grieved." Accordingly, Z addressed the
grievance to the two individuals who had issued the gag orders and
threats - — ACC Vera-Rojas and Section Chief Taylor. 1 also gave
a copy of the grievance to Senior Counsel David Stoc)cwell, the
ianediate superior of Section Chief Taylor.
The grievance sought the following joint and several relief from
Messrs. Taylor and Vera-Rojas:
"(a) A prompt written response to the matters raised in
this grievance with citations to the purported authority
under which the gag orders were issued;
(b) A deteraination that the gag order of January 22
which sought to prevent ae from coaaunicating aaterial
inforxation to the client was unethical and illegal;
^The case flow probleas iaposed on this particular Binority
fira by the RTC were specifically described in the Aneriean Bar
Association Journal. March 1993, at 18, in an article entitled "RTC
Payments Delayed, Soae lawyers wait acre than a year for fees froa
thrift agency." I attach a copy of the article to this aeao. ,
169
(cl A repudiation of th« February 2 gag order that places
•irtraordinary restrictions on By ability to comaunicate
with PLS Banagenient in Washington;
(d) Assurances that no retaliatory action or reprisal
will be taken against ae by virtue of this grievance or
the Batters which fomed the basis of this aeao;
(e) An investigation of this aatttr by an iapartial
official (•) outside of the Dallas Legal Division;
(f ) The institution of appropriate corrective aeasures to
prevent the recurrence of the incidents described in this
grievance; and
(g) Such other relief that is fair and appropriate
including, if warranted, appropriate disciplinary or
adverse action with respect to the persons involved in
this Batter."
The next business day after I presented the grievance, I once again
went to David Stoclcvell to see if we could aeet to resolve this
Batter without going through the entire grievance process. The
answer was a very eaphatic "no." I later received separate £-aails
froB Messrs. Vera-Rojas and Taylor indicating that they would
respond in 15 days.
B. TES &X7EIUUa TO THE ITHZC8 OmCSS TOR X XCOS OPXVZON
On February 3 nine days after I first confronted Section Chief
Taylor about his unethical and illegal order he referred the
Batter to Wayne Fogle, the Dallas Ethics Officer.
On February 8, David Stockwell sent an E-aail to Dallas Ethics
Officer Fogle which pointed out the distinction between:
(a) "...unethical conduct. . .predicated upon any
regulations iaposed upon FDIC and/or FOIC eaployees
assigned to the RTC..."
and
(b) Unethical conduct predicated "...upon any applicable
code or codes of professional responsibility which are
applicable to attorneys."
Senior Counsel Stoc]cwell then went on to request a liaited
investigation "...to deteraine whether or not any of the
regulations to which we are subject to as eaployees aay have been
involved." He did not request an opinion as to the legal ethical
issues nor did he provide Ethics Officer Fogle (a non-lawyer) any
inforaation concerning a lawyer's obligation to his client.
10
170
On F«bruury 10, Wayn* Pogl« responded to David StocJcwell'g inquiry
concerning the applicability of the FDIC toployee Conduct
regulations with an E-mail that he could "...find no apparent
ethics issues that fall within provisions set out at Part 1605
'Employee Responsibilities and Conduct'..." He vent on to suggest,
however, that the parties examine the provisions of 1605 that set
forth various "general rules" of employee conduct to see if they
might b« applicabl*.
On February 16, Z sent an E-mail to Rex Taylor which reaffirmed the
source of the "ethics" that I felt dealt with the issue:
"There appears to be some confusion over what "ethics"
dealt with the issue of a lawyer/supervisor instructing
a subordinate la%ryer to conceal material information from
client representatives. In order to eliminate such
confusion, I am sending you a copy of [materials from
Modern Legal Ethics and applicable Canons and Rules of
legal ethics.]
For example, the (Modern Legal Ethics) treatise makes the
following observations:
'X client has an equal interest in receiving legal
evaluations and advice from a lawyer about important
steps in the matter and, periodically, about whether
progress is being made or not.
[I}t is clearly also the case that lawyers should not
restrict the flow of information in order to exercise
control over clients or to manipulate client decisions.
[S}everal courts have disciplined lawyers for failing to
communicate with clients or for misleading a client about
the status of a matter.'"
I then gave Section Chief Taylor a copy of the applicable reference
materials so that he could consider them in his response to my
grievance.
▼ . THB TXTLOR RXSPOMBB and BURVSXDB EXPLT
I received Section Chief Taylor's formal response to my grievance
on Friday, February 19. The OHLT portions of the memo that dealt
with the COBSTXHCB of my charges stated:
"This is in response to you grievance, dated February S.
1993. where in fsic^ vou grieve "gag orders." I have
read your 10 page memorandum with its 11 exhibits and
considered your reqpjest therein for relief as set out in
the section entitled 'VIII. CONCLUSION', further
enumerated (a) through (g) . This is ay response.
11
171
...(Taylor Procedural Objections^]...
Your alleoations of ■upervisorv ethical misconduct have
been refuted bv the ethics officer. You are in receipt
of a COPY of his findings." (emphasis original)
Section Chief Taylor's position that the Fogle E-mail completely
exonerated hia ignored the entire course of events over the
previous thirty days. More importantly, however, the implications
of the Taylor position, which totally disregarded the legal ethical
issues, was necessarily premised upon the following fatally flawed
tenets:
♦ Legal ethics do not govern the conduct of lawyers in the
RTC I/egal Division.
♦ Section 1605 is the sole and exclusive source of ethical
principles that govern the conduct of RTC lawyers.
♦ Section 1605 preempts the Code of Professional
Responsibility of a lawyer in the RTC Legal Division.
♦ An RTC lawyer/manager has the authority to order a
subordinate attorney to conceal material information from
the RTC client representatives charged with making a
decision on the matter being handled by the subordinate
attorney.
On the morning of Monday, February 22, I submitted my reply to the
Taylor substantive position to AGC Vera-Rojas, Senior Counsel
Stoc)cwell, and Ethics Officer Fogle. My memo, titled "Status of
Legal Bthics in the Dallas Legal Oivision," begged them to reject
the Taylor position because:
"The very essence of the relation between the Legal Division
and the Business Side of the RTC demands full and free
communications between the "lawyer" and the "client" so that
they can make fully informed joint decisions. As noted in my
E-mail to Rex Taylor prior to his response:
'[I]t is clearly also the case that la%ryers should not
restrict the flow of information in order to exercise
control over the clients or to manipulate client
decisions.' Modern Legal Ethics Sec. 4.5 (Communications
with Clients)
^ Rex Taylor's Response also made some rather strange
"procedural" objections that completely ignored the factual record
and the substance of my charges. I replied to such "procedural"
points in a memorandum dated February 23.
12
172
One? a lavyer/nanager orders a lavyer/subordlnat* to concaal
■aterial infomatlon froD the client, everyone suffers. The
client suffers because they are naking decisions on inconplete
information and are unsure whether they can trust their
lawyers. The Legal Division suffers because they invite the
■istrust of the very clients they have the obligation to
advise. The individual lawyers suffer because they are asked
to abandon their professional ethics. And, ultiaately, the
entire RTC suffers because of the lost public confidence in
the RTC decision-Baking process."
ACC Vera-Rojas refused to respond to ay February 22 aeao or ay
grievance and stated:
"Regarding your sophistic, rambling and specious charges
alleging violations of professional ethics, I find thea
totally false, senseless, and undesexving of any serious
response. If you wish to level any charges against ae
personally, alleging that I have soaehow violated the
professional code of ethics, you can direct your
correspondence to the Ethics Coaaittee of the Bar
Association of the Coaaonwcalth of Puerto Rico. Be
forewarned though, that I will reserve all ay rights as
an individual to pursue redress for any libelous or
slanderous stateaents."
Rex Taylor siaply reaffirmed his position that Ethics Officer Fogle
had refuted all ay charges against hia and declared the aatter
"over."
Ethics Officer Pogle's first reaction to the Taylor position that
Fogle had exonerated Taylor was to ask ae: "Did he put that in
writing?" Wayne Fogle then notified ae that he would send the
aatter to Washington but that it would take soae tiae for the
Ethics section to formally respond to ay aemo regarding the "Status
of Legal Ethics in the Dallas Legal Division."
David Stockwell felt that the issues raised in ay aeao were outside
the "scope of his responsibilities." Recognizing his reluctance to
opine as to aatters relating to the conduct of his direct superior,
I subsequently withdrew ay request for his opinion "to the axtent
that [he b«lieves] that a response aay Involve AGC Vera-Rojas."
▼Z. TSX &XF08XL TO COMFLX WITH TES ORIKVXVCB PROCXDORB
The atteapted cover-up has not stopped with the gag orders and
threats — - it has continued into the grievance procedure itself.
♦ AGC Vera-Rojas has explicitly refused to give
the required "Step One" response to the
grievance against hia.
13
173
♦ AGC Vera-Rojas and Section Chief Taylor hav«
•ought to prevent ne from bring this aatter to
your attention by refusing to identify who AGC
Vera-Rojas reports to in the Legal Division.
♦ AGC Vera-Rojas has sought to deprive ne of ay
right to a "Step Two" review of ay grievance
against hia and Section Chief Taylor by
"appointing" his iamediate subordinate and
close personal friend as the Step Two reviewer
of their aisconduct.
♦ The aanageaent of the Dallas Legal Division
have repeatedly rebuffed ay req[uests for
aeetings or discussions concerning the aatter.
♦ I continue to be the subject of threats and
retaliatory action.
Such conduct hardly comports with the purpose of the FDIC Grievance
Procedure which is to aeet:
"...a continuing comaitment by the Corporation for open
and equitable treatment of all Corporation employees and
its scope, purpose and provisions are to be interpreted
in this light."
The procedure also requires that the grievance be given "full,
impartial, and prompt consideration" and calls for "...every
reasonable effort [to] be made by all parties concerned to resolve
this matter fairly and promptly."
What type of "open and ecfuitable" or "impartial" grievance
procedure permits the subject of the grievance to personally select
his own close friend and iamediate subordinate as the "reviewer" of
his own aisconduct? Ho* "reasonable" is AGC Wtvm maj ■ ^ - .xi:<--^^' '
either to discuss the aatter or to subait the aandated forsaj.
response to ay grievance?
▼IZ. COMCLOSZON
Over the last thirty days, I have often wondered what precipi'tated
this violent reaction to my internal protests over the termination
of the fee counsel on the biggest PLS case in the region? Whet was
the motivation of Arturo Vera-Rojas and Rex Taylor when they
embarked on a course of action that included:
♦ A gag order intended to conceal material
information froa the very client they had an
obligation to serv*.
14
174
« <- A second gag order Intended to prevent a PLS
line attorney fron freely communicating with
PLS management in Washington.
♦ Personal attacks on a PLS line attorney whose cases
account for 77% of all PLS recoveries by the Dallas RTC
Office,
♦ Discrimination against a ainority-ovmed law
firm.
♦ Actions taJcen in reckless disregard of the
consequences to a PLS case that is second only
to Charles Keating' s Lincoln Savings in total
RTC PLS recoveries.
♦ Refusing to explain or defend their actions in
the face of formal charges of unethical
conduct.
♦ Making a mockery of the FDIC Grievance Procedure by
trying to appoint AGC Vera-Rojas' personal friend and
subordinate as the Step Two reviewer.
Originally, I thought that the grievance process would pierce the
cover-up. Yet I am now entering Step Two without any explanation
of the motivation behind the extra-ordinary attempts to silence me.
I suggest the first place to begin looking for the motivation
behind this matter might be the recent battle between the Legal
Division and the business side over the control of the hundreds of
millions of dollars paid to RTC Pee Counsel.
After this whole matter began, I learned that the Dallas L«gal
Division was spending hundreds of hours fighting a decision to
transfer control of the legal services budgets And contracting
authority from the Legal Division to the RTC Corrtrta;»:iW9 -i--*.
Was I simply in the "wrong place at the wrong time" when I
communicated my concerns about the Legal Division's handling of a
law firm to the client at the same time that AGC Vera-Rojas was
engaged in a "turf-battle" over who should control the contracting
process?
Yet regardless of whether the issue was the retention of counsel en
a single PLS case or the control -over Jiundreds of Billions ot
dollars in legal services contracts, the principles of legal ethics
remain the same:
■[I]t is clearly also the case that lawyers should not
restrict the flow of information in order to exercise
control over the clients or to Banipulate client
decisions."
15
175
THOMAS J. BURNSroE
SS# 295-6^2760
SIIRSTANTTVE EXPERIENCE
Resolution Trust CorporitioD (FDIC)
ProfessioDal Liability Section
Southwest Regional Office/Dallas Office
Dallas, Texas 75219
Senior Attorney
10/90 to present
At various dioes, I conducted and supervised the investigation and/or litigation of claims against:
(a) directors, officen, and control persons of 26 thrifts totalling over S8 billion in assets; and (b)
the accountants, anomeys, securities brokers, appraisers, investment bankers, and other
professionals that dealt with such thrifts. I spent approximately 73% of my time during the last two
years investigating, developing, and pursuing the ioUowing ^ues:
wsrmmoN
CLAIMS
KESULT 1
{800 miilioo
Otimi tfixnn Bi^ Six tccouBtia(
fins for duoA^et is exoea of (400
miilioo ahtittt from minttted
fiAuidtJ ctatemenu fubreitied to
re{;iUtor( to isduoe FSUC to iasure
ta unizifured thrift
Oaim ttaisn mcide direaort for
insider tbute
• Suit a^ainti Bia Six firm aad defeodant clan of
iadrviduAl partners for MX) millioD authorued
• (43.69 miQioo eettleiDent with aooountaoti,
•ettlement repreaeoted 34% of all RTC reooveriei
in (lobal teitiemeat with firm
• .:nde directors ooUeoively have made Ktikmem
offers of S4J millioQ baaed oa act worth
traasferrcd ti million to faaiily truit' shortly after
aodfiaboa of RTC daims
SI. 07 billioB
Qtim «{&inn iovenBeot btnkerv
Bi| Six tocouotiiij firm, ud iande
direaon for dama^et of S3S million
from boldiof oompaay ule of five
real eniie terviaai cubodiariei to
thrift
regulatory capital
• SettleiDcais with iavettneat baalun aad
tooouatuts totalling SU.OS miUioa
• Seitleoeat with two directors at SMS BtSioa baaed
• Peadiat Utifatioa a(aia*i remaiaiai two defeadaats
IS thrifts
located
throufbout
United Suvet
comfflisioiit and tradiof lo«et ia a
flf»ed *bed|iax' procrwa marketed
to imall thrifts
• Reoomoeaded aad received approval for fim
aaiioawtde eoatoUtfated RTC avcsifaciae
• Appelated NatiottaJ Coordiastor for daimi afaiast
1^ brokerage houae; (upeiviKd invcfiifatiOB of
hedfiac propaa
• Securities broker haa offered S4.6S miUioB to RTC
aad SI J2 miUioa to FDIC to settle daiat frt>m
profraffl
176
Thomas J. Bumside
295-62-2760
Page 2
Sl.MbUlion
Otim aitinn Bi( Six accouonng
fim for S70 tnilliOB a daaaget froa
CUwed (udit
• Inveingaied clajm and made forrnal
recommendaoon to iue, awaiting authoruation
dcofion
• Pre-«uit aettieisent diioiBioni underway
UJOmUlion
cxccM of S20 millioo umni (roB
(Uwed rt|ulitory advice
• Suit authotued and filed
(430 million
n«i'm t(Ainn lo« fim tad 44
p«niien for daaa|ei la cLom of $30
millioD thfiac from anoreey't
panieiptooB is tcfaeme to mtnipuUte
thrift 'I cipiuJ to tUow po»-th
• Inveitigated cUim and made formal
recommendation to nie; awaiting authoritation
dedtioB
{860 mtlljoa
Otis afainst tmiil Uw fins ind
individuaJ pvmen for dtmagei of
S15 million ansint from flawed
reguliiory advice
• Suit authoriied; ongoing pre-tuii aettlenxnt
diacuoioai underway
S460 milliOD
Gain against RTC law fins for
damajtei of }4 million anting from
disdofurt of confidential information
concerning ule of thrift tubtidiary
• lovcnigated claim and made formal
recommendation to (ue, awaiting authorization
dediion
Namrally, a Senior Anorney is only one member of a team that produced such results.
Nevertheless, my proactive involvement in cases and a willingness to work weekends and 16-hour
days when needed matehaJly aided the achievement of the ultimate results. In developing my cases,
I submitted 8 Authority to Sue memos and 8 Authority to Settle memos; recommended and
obtained more than ten Orders of Investigation; issued almost 200 administrative subpoenas; and
recommended 3 subpoena enforcement actions. In addition to working closely with fee counsel and
various expert witnesses, I personally took witness statements, reviewed documenution, anended
interventions and closings, drafted legal memoranda, and bandied settlement negotiations.
177
Thomas J. Bunuide
295-62-2760
Page 3
SUBSTANTIVE EXPERIENCE (Com.)
Reioert & Duree, P.C.
St. Louis, Missouri 63102
Partner/As foctate
10/83 to 10/90
I had seven (7) years experience as outside fee counsel representiDg fidelity and surety bonding
companies' with an emphasis on financial institution bond claims and related litigation. In that
capacity, I pursued negligence, fraud, and other claims as plaintiff against directors, officers,
professionals, financial institutions, and others. Areas of significant involvement included:
Banking Litigation
Commercial Udeation
Triftl?
Directors it Officers
Liability Litigation
Commodities Litigation
Bond Claims Litigation
Professional Malpractice
(commercial loan, operations, investments, directors and officers
liability, lender liability, trust department, letters of credit, bank
collections, commercial paper, investment securities, and secured
transactions)
(responsible for handling pleadings, discovery motions, pretrial
maners, settlement negotiations, jury and bench trials, and
appellant practice in federal, state and bankruptcy courts in cases
ranging from 45 million down to SIO.OOO)
(Tirst Chair* comroerc.ii jxiry and bench trials including cases
against banks involving a banlcer's standaid of care and owner-
contractor construction disputes)
(pursued directors & officen of financial institutions and their
D&O carriers including recovery of 75% of poUcy limits in MGIC
liquidation)
(insider trading, lack of underwriting due diligence. Blue Sky, the
SISCorp fraud, the Bcvill Bressler fraud and CFTC claims)
(defended claims under Bankers Blanket Bonds, Stockbrokers
Blanket Bonds, Securities Dealers Bonds, Public Official Bonds,
Financial Guaranty Bonds, and Commercial Fidelity Bonds)
(municipal bond counsel, bank counsel, and bank auditor
malpractice cases)
' Companies represented included National Union, Chubb (Federal Insurance), F & D
of Maryland, St. Paul, Seaboard Surety, Capital Indemnity, Crum & Forster, Transamerica,
Travelers, Commercial Union and other fidelity and surety underwriters.
178
Thomas J. Bumside
295-62-2760
Page 4
ACADEMIC
Washington University School of Law, J.D. 1982
St. Louis, Missouri
QassRank: 18 of 173
Managing Editor - Urban Law Annual, volunses 23 and 24.
Extensive editorial responsibilities and supervised staff of 60 law students
Author. Tar Increment Finandng • Rational Basis or Revenue Shell Game.
24 Urban Law Annual (1982) .
Two-time recipient • American Bar Association Urban, State and Local Government Award
REFERENCES
Julie Yanda (913) 344-8437
Counsel (Section ChieO (PLS)
North Central Region - RTC
Kansas City, Missouri
Roberta Qark (202) 736-0312
Counsel (PLS)
Washington, D.C.
Rick Matejka (314) 928-4730
Anomey
3805 Hermiuge Lane
St. Charles, Missouri 63303
QISEK
• Received FDIC Award for Sustained Superior Performance • 1991
• Action-VISTA - Community Organizer (Hannibal, Missouri) 1978-79
179
JOINT WRITTEN STATEMENT OF
BRUCE J. PEDERSON AND JACQUELINE P. TAYLOR
We wish to thank the Chairman and the Committee for the opportunity to testify
about how the Resolution Trust Corporation ("RTC") treats "whistleblowers." These
are pubhc servants in the truest sense of the word who attempt to protect taxpayer
interests by detecting and exposing significant waste, fraud and abuse in RTC oper-
ations. The treatment accorded these messengers and their concerns involves public
policy issues and presents a telling Utmus test on the character of senior RTC man-
agement. To what degree does the RTC want to facilitate this control mechanism?
Having spent over a year "blowing the whistle" on RTC waste and abuse, we be-
lieve that we have much to offer the Committee. We put our careers on the Une by
testifying before this Committee in open session just over a year ago. The unpleas-
ant truth about a bungled agency reorganization, then and now, did not please RTC
management. In clear retahation, the RTC subjected us to many classic forms of
punishment reserved for employees who buck agency "spin control."
These reprisals implicate the ineffective safeguards that failed to protect us in our
efforts to expose waste and abuse at the RTU. Our ensuing treatment as second
class citizens also raises serious questions about the maturity and fairness of certain
RTC senior managers. We trust that our painful experience will help guide the
Committee toward reforming various RTC programs, framing truly effective whistle-
blower protections and holding culpable RTC managers accountable for "killing the
messengers." While we may be the most publicized whistleblowers at RTC, we are
not alone. There are many conscientious, hard working, and ethical employees at
the agency who deserve better leadership and protection.
In our continuing effort at pubUc service we respectfully oresent this statement.
It consists of seven major sections: (i) Summary; (ii) Our Backgrounds; (iii) RTC Re-
prisals; (iv) Absence of Protection; (v) PLS Update; (vi) RTC Chaos; and (vii) Pro-
posed Solutions.
I. Summary
We come before the Committee today as veteran RTC "whistleblowers." For us,
the past year has been a nightmare. Armed with only the truth, we have served
a combat tour of duty on a bureaucratic battlefield. We are exhausted, disillusioned
that those who seek the truth are punished, and anxious to "rotate" to a sane work
environment.
Ever since pubUcly identifying significant waste and abuse inherent in an ill-ad-
vised reorganization of the RTC's Professional Liability Section ("PLS") in 1992, we
have been targeted for retaliation by certain agency managers. For over fourteen
months, adversarial management has trained its collective cross hairs on us. Not-
withstanding this campaign, we successfully remained on the agency payroll in
order to continue our efforts to serve the public interest by working with various
oversight entities with jurisdiction over the RTC. At times, this difficult period has
felt like being stranded oehind enemy lines in wartime.
Using a variety of harassing techniques, our daily lives at work were made as un-
pleasant as possible by RTC managers in the hopes that we would choose to resign
or that trumped up disciplinary charges could be made to force us from the RTC.
We were placed in exile in various remote offices throughout Denver, given make
work projects and then later reassigned to permanent positions whidi underutilized
our professional skills, threatened with forced geom-aphic relocations, slandered pro-
fessionally, subjected to maU censorship, repeatedly passed over for new manage-
ment openings, held to hyper-technical interpretations of time and attendance rules,
threatened with adverse performance evaluations, exploited with sham grievance
and Equal Employment Opportunity ("EEO") proceedings, and hit with an unau-
thorized covert search of computer WordPerfect files.
No well intentioned Federal employee should have to endure this vindictive treat-
ment. We are particularly chagrined at our fate given the accuracy of our initial tes-
timony and the discredited record of those managers who punish emi)loyee8 like us.
As we previously testified, nationwide, the RTC PLS Program was seriously set back
by tlie 1992 reorganization. Whether measured by total filings, timeliness of filings,
empty attorney slots, or program coordination, PLS is now worse off. The remainder
of the RTC has not fared well either. Not a month goes by without new embarrass-
ing disclosures about RTC mismanagement, some of which is created by those who
have tedcen it upon themselves to drive us out of the agency.
While our experience is typical of government whistleblowers, it is still remark-
able for how brazenly RTC management has targeted us for reprisals since our testi-
mony before the Committee in August of 1992. RTC managers either concoct mis-
180
leading renditions of events to justify their retaliation or ignore Congressional over-
sight and legal parameters.
None of the theoretical "whistleblower" protections ever manifested in reality.
RTC management chose to ignore applicable statutes ostensibly because of loose
draftsmanship. Agency grievance procedures were gutted by delay, an examiner
handpicked by RTC management, and the absence of any final decision. The RTC
EEO complaint procedure proved to be an exercise in futility based on repeated
agency delay. Despite diligent rank and file employees, the RTC Office of Inspector
General ("OIG") was unable or unwilling to shield us from attacks by Legal Division
management. The Office of Special Counsel and the Merit Systems Protection Board
were unavailable because their jurisdiction excludes RTC employees. By default,
this Committee was left with the difficult task of policing RTC personnel practices.
The Conunittee has neither the resources nor the appropriate tools to oversee how
individual Federal employees are treated on a daUy basis in their respective agen-
cies.
Several reforms are in immediate order. No effort by the Clinton Administration
to "Reinvent Government" will be complete without remedying the problems we
have encountered. Our Statement outlines internal agency reforms and those which
wiU require CongressionsJ action. Together, they can make it far more difficult for
mean spirited management which feels threatened by the truth to retaliate against
employees would seek to expose waste, fraud and abuse on behalf of the taxpayer.
II. Our Backgrounds
We are no strangers to this Committee's oversight work regarding the RTC. On
August 11, 1992, together with another witness and former PLS manager, we testi-
fied before the Committee about the damage inflicted on the RTC's PLS Program
by the agency's ill-advised reorganization in May of 1992. We argued that the Amer-
ican taxpayer stood to lose millions of dollars in forfeited recoveries because numer-
ous experienced PLS attorneys and managers were jettisoned and most of the cases
were reassigned. On October 1, 1992, we attended a subsequent hearing as observ-
ers and listened to former RTC president and CEO Albert V. Casey oner a faulty
defense of the PLS Program reorganization. Thereafter, in November of 1992, we
provided the Committee with a detailed 53 page Rebuttal Statement (with attached
exhibits) which exposed the numerous omissions, misleading statistics, and con-
tradictions contained in Mr. Casey's Statement and an accompanying RTC Legal Di-
vision Staff Report.^
Those hearings were preceded and followed by a steady working relationship with
the Committee's immediate staff, aides to its members, and various officials with
the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO). Over those many months, we made our-
selves available at their request in order to provide background briefings, rejwrt on
newly discovered substantive problems within RTC operations, and interpret inter-
nal agency events.
Our initial testimony and ensuing analyses of RTC PLS issues have been widely
reported in the broadcast and written media during the past year. The media's on-
going efforts to obtain our thoughts on RTC issues attests to the sound record of
credibility we amassed over these many months. Other oversight officials in the
GAO and RTC Office of Inspector General and Members of Congress drew similar
conclusions. Our concerns always have checked out.^ The same cannot be said of
RTC management. On June 9, 1993 we were recognized for our efforts by being
among the five recipients of the 1993 Cavallo Award for Moral Courage in Govern-
ment and Private Industry.^
Prior to our employment experience at the RTC we had successful legal careers.
Bruce Pederson had compilea eleven years of distinguished service as a lawyer
working for the Federal government. He had the most government PLS experience,
over seven years with the FDIC, of any attorney at the RTC.^ During her fifteen
years of legal practice, Jacqueline Taylor had amassed a highly successful public
^These proceedings were collected and published in a hearing record released earlier this
year. Consolidation of the Professional Liability Section of the RTC Legal Division, 1992: Hear-
ings Before the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban A/fairs, 102nd Cong., 2nd
Sess. (August 11, 1992 and October 1, 1992). This volume hereinafter is referred to as "PLS
Hearings.
* Exhibit 1 consists of letters we received from Representative Patricia Schroeder and the U.S.
General Accounting Office thanking us for the "invaluable" information and insight we provided
to them as well as the Senate and House Banking Committees.
^ Exhibit 2 consists of our Cavallo Awards acceptance speeches.
*PLS Hearings at 122-123.
181
and private sector track record working for the State of Minnesota and several large
Fortune 500 corporations.'*
III. RTC Reprisals
We have identified four distinct periods of reprisal while employed at the RTC.
These steiges commenced with the day we began work at the agency and continued
unabated to the present. Our eras of persecution are as follows: (i) Turf War; (ii)
Put Back Program; (iii) Gulag Exile; and (iv) House Arrest. Each period and its at-
tendant retaliation is described below.
All four periods are depicted in great detail in an attadiment called "Time Line
of Abuse of RTC Whistleblowers and Major Events— May, 1992 to September, 1993"
("Time Line"). It appears as Exhibit 3. The Time line reveals a relentless history
of retaliation, both in terms of inherently mean spirited conduct as well as in terms
of the volume of reprisals. The qualitative feature is compounded by the fact that
we were usuaUy singled out for punishment. With respect to frequency, we counted
over 318 individual acts committed by Legal Division management. The Time Line
clearly demonstrates the patterns of abuse employed against us and illustrates the
fact that numerous offices within the RTC were activehr participating in the agen-
cy's orchestrated agenda. For example, in addition to Legal Division management,
we were unfairly treated by the RTC press office, the RTC Freedom of Information
Act Branch, and the Ofiice of Human Resources Management ("OHRM").^
Turf War
To fully understand the breadth of reprisal against us requires one to start with
the day we began work at the agency. From "day one" we walked into a brewing
turf war which soon broke out into open warfare. Senior managers of the Legal Divi-
sion ("Commercial Legal") decided that they would take over the burgeoning PLS
Program by eliminating its independent reporting lines to Washington, DC. Led by
Acting General Counsel Richard T. Aboussie and his lieutenants who now control
the L«gal Division, a take over effort was launched in 1991 and continued without
pause until victory was achieved in early 1992.
Using innuendo, intimidation, misrepresentations which omitted key facts, and
covert lobbying, elements of Commercial Legal made their case for a take over by
smearing the capabilities and the work performance of the PLS Program under
John Beaty. That conduct was a form of retaliation in response to our defense of
the original PLS Program.
This Statement wul not dwell on the individual examples of abuse we endured
during the turf war. Those acts were well documented in our testimony from August
of 1992 and in the press.' For that reason, the Time Line essentially begins with
the Put Back Program. We only wish to emphasize that we have been pursued as
targets of vindictive behavior which commenced well in advance of our appearance
before the Committee.
Put Back Program
This period of retaliation was a time of mistreatment directed at ousted PLS staff.
It ran from May 11, 1992, the day we were removed from our PLS management
positions, to late July of 1992, when former CEO Casey was pressured by Congress
and the FDIC to rescind the hastily conceived Put Back Program. As documented
in the Time Line, we experienced many different kinds of reprisals during the Put
Back era. This harassment took the form of several forced moves to outlying build-
ings in downtown Denver with little warning, censored mail delivery, unreliable
telephone support, slanderous comments about us by RTC managers or contractors,
failures to answer our information requests, "make work" projects, threats against
other employees for their perceived loyalty to us, and violations of agency grievance
procedures.^
Gulag Exile
After we returned from testifying before this Committee on August 11, 1992, we
found ourselves in true exile. All other put backs who once shared space with us
had gone on to the FDIC or been reincorporated back into the RTC Legal Division.
As the sole Legal Division representatives left in the building, we had no support
■PL5 Hearings at 154-156.
"The Office of Ethics appears to have been enlisted to also participate in searching for
grounds on which to bar us from accepting the Cavallo award. To the credit of Arthur Kuzinski,
the head of that office, we were ultimately cleared to accept the prize.
''See PLS Hearings at 125-130 (Pederson); 151, 157-162, 165-173 (Taylor); 460-61 (Joint Re-
buttal Statement).
*PLS Hearings at 133-36 (PedersonX 179-83 (Taylor).
182
staff and were forced to rely on other RTC offices or courier runs to the main Legal
Division for logistical support. This was our fate for over the next 100 days.
The first major retaliation in this period took the form of renewed threats to relo-
cate us to the RTC oflUce in Kansas City. This had been brewing just prior to the
hearing but was pressed with renewed vigor by RTC management in August and
the following months despite recmests by members of Congress to stay the reassign-
ment process.' The issue finally became moot when we chose one prong of a
"Hobsian Choice." We elected to remain in Denver with the price of being banned
from the PLS Program.
Numerous other examples of retaliation ensued in the month following the hear-
ing. These included fUling management positions with less qualified employees, ban-
ning us from the main building unless we had prior permission to visit, continuing
inadequate maU and telephone support, refusing to rule on Bruce Pederson's step
three persontd grievance, rejecting a PLS class action grievance on a technical rul-
ing without support in the procedures ^° and delaying investigation of Jacqueline
Taylor's EEO complaints. At least one of these areas was compounded by manage-
ment when it blamed us for having to admonish other employees when we com-
plained about the lack of reliable telephones.
Beginning in October, several of our friends at work were threatened by RTC
managers with their careers for having lunch with us. Jacqueline Taylor received
written notice that a PLS job as Section Chief with the FDIC Denver office was
withdrawn from her after she accepted the position. Later in the month, the RTC
denied our request for waiver of search and duplication fees in connection with our
pending Freedom of Information Act (TOIA") request about the PLS reorganization.
We had argued that the subject matter of our request qualified for the public inter-
est waiver standard contained in the statute. Absent our payment of $3,000.00, the
agency would not process the request.^^ Meanwhile, we struggled in October and
November to complete our Rebuttal Statement under the weight of conflicting work
demands from RTC management to explain our earlier testimony.
House Arrest
This period began with our return to the RTC Legal Division office in Denver in
late November of 1992 where we remain to the present. Management's campaign
of retaliation against us continued unabated. In fact, it appeared easier for manage-
ment to retaliate against us once we were present on premises.
The list of retaliation during our house arrest is lengthy and formidable. Despite
management's stated intentions to put our differences bemnd us, their actions have
been louder than their words. We both experienced joint forms of reprisal. For ex-
ample, we were assigned to sections which grossly underutilized our professional
backgrounds and experience. Bruce Pederson was assigned to the regular Special
Projects Section where he was slated to work with environmental law, an area with
no relation to his eight years of experience with professional liability and white col-
lar crime. In that capacity, he received an inventory project better suited for a para-
legal and a training assignment to teach the Denver staff about an obscure statute
entitled the Coastal Barrier Improvement Act of 1990. Jacqueline Taylor was placed
in the Asset Disposition Section where she was assigned responsibility for reviewing
residential real estate contracts. By staric contrast, her prior professional experience
had been in complex commercial transactions and litigation. Neither of us were con-
sulted beforehand for our preferences or reactions to these assignments. We were
not put to our 'liighest and best use." Consequently, we consider our assignments
to be a waste of our expertise and of taxpayer funds given the salaries we receive.
Other forms of joint retaliation included smears on our professional capabilities
by several members of agency management, hyper-technical enforcement of time
and attendance rules, a flawed grievance proceeding in which we had no chance to
prevail, continued stonewalling concerning our FOIA fee waiver request (which
forced us to sue the agency in early 1993), and efforts to prevent us from accepting
the CavaUo award.
We also experienced unique forms of harassment. In Bruce Pederson's case, he
was threatened with a negative performance evaluation, denied reinstatement of
forfeited annual leave which he was unable to use due to heavy PLS worii in 1991,
told to cease his independent contacts with Members of Congress or oversight com-
mittees, and admonished for attempting to commemorate the anniversary of the put
back announcement on May 7, 1992. A purported offer to place him into a PLS slot
'PLS Heanngs at 136-37 (Pederson); 152-53 (Taylor).
^°PLS Hearings at 492-93, 542-48 (Rebuttal Statement).
^^PLS Hearings at 493 (Rebuttal Statement).
183
in Denver now appears to be in Umbo as PLS headquarters contemplates moving
the vacancy to the Washington, DC office.
In Jacqueline Taylor's case, she was unable to enlist the cooperation of the Ad-
ministrative Unit in obtaining documents needed for her pending EEO complaints,
subjected to physical surveillance of her "comings and goings," saddled with compet-
ing work deadlines which she could not hope to meet, assigned projects without no-
tice to her. and enmeshed in an EEO process that became progressively bogged
down in delay followed by the imposition of unreasonable deadhnes on the complain-
ant.
In varying degrees, both of us have been the victims of unauthorized and unrea-
sonable conaputer searches. Bruce Pederson's case is well documented and is fully
set forth in Exhibit 4.
On or about March 12, 1993, Acting General Counsel Richard T. Aboussie told As-
sistant General Counsel Bsu-bara Shangraw to obtain a copy of the WordPerfect files
contained in Bruce Pederson's computer. She then ordered a computer tedinician to
breach and copy ihose files into her computer. This "fishing expedition" v/aa done
surreptitiously, without his consent, and without a court order. 1*0 date, no credible
explanation for the intrusion has appeared. Instead, RTC Legal Division manage-
ment has referred to vague notions of managerial prerogative and unsubstantiated
charges that Bruce Pecferson was allegedly doing personal work on government
time. We have since become awaa:^ of other indications that this break in was not
an isolated incident, but rather, part of an ongoing pattern of harassment of us and
other employees regarded as threats to management.
Computer break-ins by RTC management smack of Watergate and raise a host
of troubling legal and public policy issues. Criminal statutes designed to prevent il-
legal wiretaps may have been violated. Federal and state constitutional, statutory,
and common law privacy rights may have been breadied. At a minimum, public
policies for enhancing effective oversi^t over RTC operations clearly were con-
travened. If management has unrestricted authority to break into employees' com-
puters, then employees who use their computers to document waste, fraud and
abuse for oversight entities such as the OIG, GAO, and Congressional committees
stand to be compromised and subjected to retaliation by the very managers they are
attempting to expose. Indeed, Ofc employees reportedly believe that a court order
is required before they access RTC employee computers in this fashion.'^*
IV. Absence of Protection
Our system of government protections for whistleblowers is broken. In return for
our good faith efforts to improve RTC PLS operations, our reward has been
unremitting harassment designed to drive us out of the agency. Not a single theo-
retical protection was effective in shielding us fiiom the retaliation previously de-
scribed. Each failed control is discussed in order of progression.
Management
The best protection for employees who strive to improve the system is a manage-
ment team or organizational culture that encourages such efforts. This kind of nur-
turing environment prevents or quickly corrects programmatic problems by "nipping
them in the bud."
The RTC, particularly its Legal Division, is radically different from this model.
RTC senior managers operate with an alternative set of values. Individuals in this
mold permeate throughout the orgsmization because hiring "in the image" of a supe-
rior has trickled down management ranks. Their conduct suggests a preoccupation
with raw power, remunerative compensation (whether eamea or not), titles, office
size and turf. At the same time, many exhibit an apathy for public service, taxpayer
interests, employees who are not inmiediate lieutenants, and rules. These individ-
uals employ polarization as a tool of power consolidation. There is a pervasive "we
versus tnem mentality. To their way of thinking, one can be part of the clique only
if one does their bidding without question. Otherwise, you are against them and de-
fined as the enemy. The tui^ war and use of threats against our friends at work
for having lunch with us epitomize this mind set.
The play book used by RTC managers contains several favored strategies for
hushing up employees who question l£e behavior of management and for dealing
with possible oversight inquiries. These ploys work even better when those respon-
sible for oversight are always changing. Every new player offers management a
clean slate Mdth which to employ the tartics described below. In the past year. RTC
managers have been able to brief a new CEO (Albert Casey), Acting CEO (Roger
'See Exhibit 5 which contains an excfaaoge of E-Mails with an RTC OIG official.
184
Altman), CEO designate (Stanley Tate), White House staiT, and Department of
Treasury staff.
The first technique used by manv RTC oflicials is management by intimidation.
Their staff is told in overt and subtle ways that those who think for themselves face
unpleasant consequences. The "Pederson/Taylor treatment" has become a well
known term of art within the agency for referring to the punishment meted out to
those who are not "i^am players." This chilling euect is well documented. For every
witness here today, there are many other employees who could testify about waste,
fraud, and abuse at the RTC. These silent witnesses, however, have chosen not to
speak out for fear of this retaliation.
A second preferred tool of management is aggressive brinkmanship. Certain man-
agers do what they feel is in their best interest and then challenge anyone else to
do something about it. Threats of oversight are perceived to be mere bluffs. The bur-
den of disciplining RTC managers thus shifts to outside parties without the benefit
of any initial deterrence value. Unless these oversight entities have the time and
resources to enforce their remedies, no one is held accountable at the RTC. For ex-
ample, OIG and GAO reports are regularly ignored with no meaningful foUow up
by management.
A third tool used by RTC management is to smear their victims. The recipients
or witnesses of unfair conduct at the RTC are painted to be problem employees. This
somehow justifies inappropriate conduct by management. Needless to say, we have
borne the brunt of this approach. Over the past year, the agency has branded us
as malcontents who sought media attention because we did not retain our manage-
rial positions. ^^ The computer break in, based on trumped up allegations that Bruce
Pederson was doing personal worii on office time, is yet another extmiDle.
A fourth favorite tool is characterizing issues and events with a less than com-
f)lete recitation of the facts. Key pieces of information are usually left out in an ef-
brt to create a misleading impression for a third party. Examples included descrip-
tions of Bruce Pederson's work habits and Jacquelme Taylor's professional judgment
in PLS cases.
A final tool is creating a "moving target." If "caught in the act," management re-
sorts to taking some limited action that changes the original facts so that a criticism
can no longer oe leveled at a procedure (or lack thereof) that no longer exists. "Back
fill" directives are a good example. Once we exposed mail censorship, directives au-
thorizing the opening of correspondence were issued. In the meantime, the core
problem remains uncorrected.
Grievance Procedures
The grievance process at the RTC is a sham. It serves no purpose other than to
delay resolution of legitimate employee concerns. It is a fraud in terms of giving un-
founded hope to employees that the unfair treatment they receive will be remedied
with these proceedings. Our experience with the process was nothing but unsatisfac-
tory. The grievance machinery is a one way street designed to stall matters for man-
agement in the hopes that the employee will give up on pursuing a remedy or that
an excuse can be found for managerial misbehavior.
In general, the grievance process is flawed because management has a conflict of
interest in functioning as both a participant and an umpire. Management holds the
employee to every tedinical requirement of the directive governing grievance proce-
dures.
Conversely, it ignores the rules or makes up self-serving ones where the directive
is silent or ambiguous. The only questions answered are those that produce answers
favorable to management. These problems are best illustrated by Bruce Pederson's
personal grievance, filed in May of 1992, which has yet to be decided. His frequent
requests for a final ruling have gone ignored. The PliS Class Action Grievance wash
summarily dismissed because management had never heard of the class action ap-
? roach. It then converted this grievance into a personal grievance for Jacqueline
aylor which also has not been decided. In another grievance case in which Bruce
Pederson served as the employee's representative, management directed that the
employee's step two appeal actually go to the subordinate of the step one decision
maker!
Things do not improve with the retention of a grievance examiner. That individual
is selected and paid by the agency with no input from the grievant. In our cases,
the examiner imposed arbitrary deadlines (citing a need to expedite the investiga-
tion), chose to interview mostly management witnesses while ignoring the majority
^ We have consistently objected to that characterization of us. Rather than acting Hke mere
malcontents, we have deliberately remained at the RTC, in the face of continuing retaliation,
in order to continue working with oversight entities.
185
of our witnesses, prepared aflldavits for the witnesses usins his words which fre-
quently left out many of their comments, arbitrarily limitea our oral and written
evidence by cutting on oral testimony and refusing to accept documentary evidence,
prematurely closed the record despite our request for time in which to suomit docu-
ments, and engaged in a conflict of interest oy attempting to settle the grievances
while retaining the power to a4judicate them.
EEO
The Equal Employment Opportunity complaint procedure is one of unexplained
delay by the RTC, followed by unreasonable time deadlines placed on the complain-
ant. As with the grievance process, no meaningful redress is offered to the employee
until the proceeding leaves the agency for the Federal courts.
OIG
The RTC OIG remains a mirage of safety for employees seeking whistleblower
protection. Despite having an agenda designed to prevent or detect waste, fraud,
and abuse in RTC operations, the OIG does little to safeguard agency employees
from retaliation for reporting instances of this mismanagement.
Several factors appear to undercut the OIG's ability to protect whistleblowers or
stop abuse of employees. First, there is no clear statutory jurisdiction to do so. OIG
agents freely admitted this position to us. Instead, their stated emphasis was on
criminal behavior or obvious violations of administrative rules (i.e., time and attend-
ance). While we believe that retaliation against a whistleblower is a form of "abuse,"
we do control the priorities of that ofiice.
Second, there is a widespread employee perception that the OIG is unag^ssive.
The OIG headquarters in Washington, DC is seen as a "black hole" from which little
emerges on a timely basis. Individual employees who file complaints are rarely told
of what becomes of their stated concerns. These perceptions were not helped by the
testimony of Inspector General John Adair last year. He admitted that his ofiice
maintains a "zero file" for matters which his ofiice has no intention of investigat-
ing."
Finally, the RTC OIG is hamstrung by its organic statute. OIG agents have told
us that the OIG does not even have tne power to recommend to RTC manacement,
much less enforce needed reforms to cure mismanagement. Instead, the moael pro-
vides that OIG reports are tendered to RTC managers for their information. These
reports are not intended to encroach on the business judgment of the managers and
have no binding effect. As a result, RTC management feels comfortable reading and
then dismissing whatever findings are presented. "^^
Merit Systems Protection Board /Office of Special Counsel
These remedies are not available to RTC employees as a matter of statutory juris-
diction. Consequently, they do not offer the potential of protection. This problem was
documented in a recent GAO Report entitled Whistleblower Protection.'^
GAO/ Congressional Oversight Committees
This form of oversight is ill-equipped to provide protection to individual employees
on a case by case basis. The GAO typically takes many months to complete its
lengthy audits and investigations. These efforts also concern programs and not peo-
ple.
Oversight committees are limited by competing demands for time and resources.
Historicdly, they have relied on the deterrence value of future oversight hearings
and appropriations to encourage lawful and proper agency conduct. This approaoi
breaks down in the case of the RTC where management ihooses to "call the blufT
of oversight committees and act as it sees fit. The Durden then falls to the Congress
to catch up and function as the "cop on the beat." Congressional resources are far
better used in addressing the formidable policy issues inherent to each agency's mis-
sion. However grateful we are, we already regret that so much of this Committee's
time and attention has had to be focused on the wrong doings committed in the RTC
Legal Division.
V. PLS Update
Management retaliation against Federal employees has no place in government.
It becomes eJl the more egregious when committed against public servants who
" PLS Hearings at 387-89.
" Several examples are described in Section VI regarding mismanagement in the Legal Divi-
sion. These instances have been widely reported in the press.
^•United States General Accounting Office, Whistleblower Protection: Agencies' Implementa-
tion of the WhUtleblower StatuUs Has Been Mixed, (March 1993) at 6-7.
\ 186
prove to be accurate in their whistleblowing efforts. This is our case. Third party
investigations of the ill-advised PLS reorganization have since vindicated much of
our testimony before this Committee on August 11, 1992. The GAO, RTC OIG, and
the press all have documented what we stated: The 1992 reoi^anization of the RTC
PLS seriously set back the Program and impaired the claims work of the Section
at a critical time.^' As a result, diminished recoveries will add to the cost of the
thrift bailout and adversely impact the taxpayer.
The corroborations detailed oelow do not come as a surprise. The vehement all
out attack launched against us by the RTC following our testimony strongly sug-
gests that our statements hit the raw nerve of truth. Why else would the vast re-
sources of a large Federal agency be marshalled against two individual employees
in an effort to discredit their revelations and smear them personally? As depicted
in the Time Line, this effort has gone on for over a year. People who have little to
say or who are "off the wall" in their assessments do not receive such muscled atten-
tion. Still, truth persists and patiently waits for others to discover it anew.
In his testimony last year, CEO Casey stated that "due to the reoi^anization, the
[PIS] program is stronger today than it has ever been."^® He based this conclusion
on streanuining of management and increases in attorney slots. The ensuing results
hardly support this ridiculous claim. The contrary conclusions reached by various
observers are detailed below. It is noteworthy that the RTC has subtly shifted from
defending the reorganization as an improvement to now calling it a benign event
that did no harm.
GAO
Following nines months of work, the GAO provided its own assessment on how
the reorganization affected the PLS Program. In its report dated June 28, 1993, the
GAO found nothing to suggest that the Program was improved in any way.^® In-
deed, after noting the turnover and loss of expertise caused by the reorganization,
the GAO Report concluded that there was "risk that the development of future
(PLS) claims may suffer from inadequate stafling and staffs lack of experience."^
The fact that RTC management may not have deliberately intended to produce this
carnage does not detract from the negative result.^^ A bungled reorganization of this
magnitude in the private sector would lead to swift accountability by a board of ^-
rectors.
The particulars are hardly flattering to CEO Casey or the managers in the Legal
Division who devised the PLS reorganization. Set against the bad(drop that most
of the RTC PLS work worth billions of dollars still remains to be done, the GAO
Report noted that:
. . . some of the management action taken by RTC, as they affected PLS, were
ill-conceived and poorly implemented. As a result, RTC's decisions to consolidate
and reassign PLS attorneys demoralized PLS staff and disrupted the program.
One hall of the PLS attorneys have left the program smce March 31, 1992.
While other attorneys have been hired, the high turnover rate has resulted in a
high proportion of PLS attorneys with less experience than needed ... as of the
end 01 March 1993, 45 percent of the PLS attorneys had less than 12 months' ex-
perience.^
Appendices IV and V reveal the wholesale departures and failures to fill author-
izea slots. The PLS never matched its peak stalling level of 76 attorneys on board
prior to the reorganization in the ensuing nine months. Worse, hotbeds of work,
such as Dallas and Kansas City, displayed significant numbers of unfilled attorney
slots.
The downsizing or put back process was undertaken by Legal Division managers
"with no clearly delineated selection criteria." These "poorly conceived and poorly
implemented" actions "call[ed] into question the priority RTC attached to the [PLS]
"See PLS Hearings at 13»-148 (Pedereon); 175-179 (Taylor); 468-487 (Rebuttal Statement).
Another witness before the Committee today, Tom Bumside, is expected to testify on how the
reorganization adversely afTected the work of the Dallas PLS Office where he was formerly em-
ployed.
*PLS Hearings at 405.
^United States General Accounting Office, Thrift Failures: Actions Needed to Stabilize RTC's
Pr^essional Liability Program, (June 1993) (hereinafter the "GAO Report").
^ GAO Report at 21.
'^ Motives are discussed later in this Statement We hasten to add, however, that the meth-
odology used by the GAO in this instance was not designed to uncover evidence of political intCT-
ference. That kind of conduct is not usually reduced to paper and certainly does not appear in
an agency's individual case files.
'"Id. at 2.
187
program."^* The put back decisions "gave little regard to the specific institutions
an<f claims for which the attorneys were responsible." The sixteen experienced PLS
attorneys who were kicked out of the RTC were responsible for 140 thrifts with as-
sets totalling nearly $37 billion. GAO was amazed that "RTC would attempt to put
back PLS attorneys to FDIC at a time when RTC's PLS workload was increasing.
Nothing in the extensive materials submitted by RTC at the October 1 hearing ex-
plains tnese actions."^
The change in PLS reporting lines also promoted the balkanization we warned of
last year. According to page seven of the GAO Report:
. . . the restructuring lessened the direct supervisory and programmatic con-
trol over the PLS attorneys in the field. . . . The restructuring also introduced
many new regional attorneys into the PLS decision-mtiking process, some of whom
lacked prior experience with the professional liability work. As a result, the decen-
tralizecl PLS structure introducea the potential for fragmented program direction,
inconsistent practices and decisions among the regions, and inadequate case de-
velopment."
The GAO also found differing views among field attorneys about what constituted
a negligence claim against outside directors and whether headquarters was recep-
tive to evaluating boraerline cases.
With respect to the reorganization's impact on PLS claims work, the GAO Report
contains telling statistics. First, Appendix II and Figures 2 and 3 in the text display
a formidabledrop off in filed claims after the reorganization. Thrifts with filing
deadlines after the reorganization did not suddenly contain fewer actionable claims
unless relaxed standard of liability, attorney inexperience, or workload inattention
due to staffing shortages began to play a role. Worse, despite touted streamlining,
GAO found that RTC continued to file many of the professional liability claims less
than a week before the expiration of the statute of limitations."^®
In an effort to discredit our earlier testimony, agency apologists have been quick
to seize upon the GAO fmding that PLS litigation policies were unchanged. This
point is hardly dispositive. First, the GAO only exammed seven cases,'^ out of hun-
dreds of PLS matters, in arriving at that conclusion. Second, the finding that ensu-
ing PLS decisions were "plausible litigation judgments" is no guarantee that a^res-
sive pursuit designed to maximize taxpayer recoveries is being undertaken, ^lose
judgment calls" can encompass uninspired work which leaves viable claims un-
touched without involving legal malpractice. This is compounded by field attorney
confiision on liability standams and perceptions that PLS-Washington, DC does not
want to hear about borderline claims. Third, many of our concerns were not specifi-
chair movement of RTC attorneys around the nation. Fourth, the GAO Report does
not appear to address the serious problems that began to appear in the Dallas PLS
office in Msuxih of 1993.
Finally, we believe that the spotlight of public scrutiny, namely the PLS hearings
from last year, were chiefly responsible for what reforms or improvements are de-
scribed in the GAO Report at page eleven. The fact that PLS has now reinstituted
quarterly case reviews, increased review of close out decisions, and coordinated
training attests to the fact that the Ingram was hurt by the reoivanization. In fact,
these actions actudly restored valuable management tools former^^ used by PLS As-
sistant General Counsel John Beaty. In addition, we believe that our testimonv and
GAO oversight served to make the RTC more aggressive in pursuit of PLS claims.
RTCOIG
The RTC OIG completed its report regarding the PLS reorganization on July 20,
1993.'" The OIG Report parallels the GAO Report in many ways, although it is
more detailed in its criticism of the put back process. In general, the OIG concluded
that "(1) friction between PLS attorneys and the rest off the Legal Division caused
by PLS' unique reporting structure apparently was a factor in realignment staffing
decisions, (2) the realignment process was poorly plaimed and managed, and (3) the
"/i at 7-8.
»*/d ate.
»/(t at 16.
^/d at 9. Furthermore, GAOb analysis on the issue of missed statute of limitations filings
was not "a comprehensive review." Id. at 10.
'■'RTC OfRce of Inspector General, Review of Allegations Associated With the Restructuring
of RTC's Legal Division And Its Effect on the Professional LiabUity Section, July 20, 1993 Gn-
spection Report INS93-^05) ("OIG Report").
188
realignment significantly disrupted PLS."^® Our response to the OIG's failure to find
evidence of an intent to disrupt the program and the conclusion that management
decisions in twenty-one cases fell within the bounds of professional judgment calls
is identical to the same point made in the GAO Report.
The Report points to a botched reorganization fueled by the turf war and vindic-
tiveness.
Employees were returned to the [FDIC] despite staffing analyses showing that
PLS haa a continuing need for existing, as well as additional, staff to handle its
workload. Stafdng decisions were made subjectively and without due consider-
ation to the effects the decisions would have on the work force or the inventory
of PLS cases. Overall, PLS lost approximately 50 percent of its exf>erience<i,
trained attorneys; replaced three of its top four senior field managers; and trans-
ferred 43 percent of its caseload from one attorney to another.^
The methods employed in the put back process, especially in Denver and Atlanta,
were most arbitrary and capricious. According to the OIG Report, "senior Legal Di-
vision managers used the process to return PLS employees they did not want with-
out regard to the intent of the 'put back' process or the professional liability work
that remained to be done." The process was subjective and poorly managed.*' As
might be expected under these circumstances, put back selections were made with-
out using criteria, standards, or guidelines ana without regard for the workload." ^^
PLS recommendations to keep us in PLS were ignored and "lacked sound business
purpose." ^^ In sum, the OIG correctly recognized that the put back process was one
that should never have happened. Tnere was a need for additional PLS attorneys
before and after the reorganization.^ Incredibly, the Legal Division managers re-
sponsible for this carnage were rewarded with substantial bonuses at the end of the
year.
Press Investigations
Several interesting articles have appeared in the press which bear on our earlier
PLS testimony. First, the Associated Press reported in May of this year that nation-
wide PLS filings were down, from about 50 percent to 33 percent.*'* Not coinciden-
tally, the drop off occurred just after the reorganization oi PLS. RTC's reply, that
the most egregious cases were picked off for filing earlier in time is implausible and
unsupported. According to the GAO Report, the RTC has historically filed most of
its PLS claims days or hours before the legal deadline. The £igency has been in a
crisis mode for filing PLS lawsuits ever since it came into being. The GAO also
noted that most of the RTC PLS work remains to be done.
A second press story provided evidence of the political interference we described
in our initid testimony. ' We believe that politically prominent and wealthy PLS
targets nationwide have formed a powerful lobby. In their view, FDIC and RTC PLS
cases against them are mere "witch hunts." RTC has argued that no politization of
PLS work has ever occurred. The inability of GAO or the RTC OIG to locate docu-
ments in agency files memorializing political pressure is hardly surprising. Evidence
of that activity is most unlikely to appear in that location. Those dynamics are rare-
ly recorded in that fashion. Instead, one if left to look for circumstantial evidence.
Such an example recently surfaced in former FDIC Chairman William Seidman's
memoirs, Full Faith ana Credit: The Great S&L Debacle and Other Washington
Sagas. According to press reports, Mr. Seidman recounts how the Bush White House
involved itself in Office of Thrift Supervision ("OTS") and FDIC handling of enforce-
ment and PLS proceedings regarding Neil Bush. The FDIC General Counsel was
later disciplined for his ensuing meddling in the pending cases.*®
RTC Legal Management
WhUe hardly an objective third party, the Acting General Counsel, Richard T.
Aboussie, also has made significant "admissions against interest" regarding the
state of the PLS Program. In testimony before an RTC oversight Subcommittee of
the House Committee on Banking, Finance and Urban Affairs, Mr. Aboussie admit-
28/^ at 8.
»OIG Report at 2, 7.
*»/dL at 12.
31 /d
^Id. at 13.
^Id. at 14-15.
**Keil, Richard, "Recovery of S&L Losses Drops Off," San Francisco Examiner, May 14, 1993,
atB-3.
^PLS Hearings at 460-63 (Rebuttal Statement).
^"Tnasury Probe Reveals FDIC Ethics Violations,' Washington Watch, May 31, 1993 at p.
1; 'Lawsuit Timed to Aid Neil Bush." The Denver Post, March 26, 1993, at p. lA.
189
ted to several serious problems in the wake of the reorganization.^"' First, PLS has
had trouble filling empty slots with experienced attorneys at a time when 70 percent
of PLS work remains to be done. Incredibly, the RTC actually went to the FDIC
begging for lawyers to work on detail only months after driving almost half its own
std^ out of the program! ^ Second, as we warned, PLS has made heavy use of secret
pre-litigation settlements. According to Mr. Aboussie, out of 389 thrifts with expired
statute of limitations deadlines, about 52 percent had claims pursued or settled
without litigation.^" Third, little or no streamlining occurred with the touted reorga-
nization. Mr. Thomas Hindes, the current Assistant General Counsel for PLS, testi-
fied at the same hearing that all claims are evaluated, investigated, and approved
by "several layers."*" In describing the quarterly review process, Mr. Aboussie de-
tailed a process top heavy with managers and balkanized between field ofiices. Two
managers from Washington join a PLS Section Chief at the field site in conducting
the reviews in four of the field sites. In the other two, a different procedure is fol-
lowed.
Additional Problems
Recent events also have drawn our attention to other deficiencies in the RTC PLS
Program. Chief among these are the agency's failure to enlist Congressional assist-
ance on two major fronts. These are extending the statute of limitations for filing
PLS claims from three years to five years and confronting a growing number of
state legislatures which are eroding the standard of liability under wWch the RTC
(and FDIC) can bring PLS lawsuits. On June 10, 1993, we were shocked to witness
the RTC actively lobby against statute of limitations extensions before the House
Judiciary Committee. It is most unusual for any agency to summarily turn down
increased authority to better perform its statutory mission.'*^ The mounting threat
to the standard of liability now includes at least seven states.'*^
VI. RTC Chaos
While RTC management persists in its attack on us for our efforts to expose the
truth about the PLS reorganization, many major programs in the RTC and their
managers go unchecked. Not a month goes by without the disclosure of some new
scandal or impropriety. "Rome bums" as the agency continues to spend excessive
time and effort marshalling its resources against a perceived "Bruce and Jackie
Problem."
Time and space constraints do not permit us to provide every instance of RTC
mismanagement disclosed in the past few months. The following areas, however, are
a definitive sample:
• Legal Division conflicts of interest in steering work to an Associate General Coun-
sel's former law firm.'*^
• The Acting General Counsel's trip to the 1992 World Series at taxpayer expense
which resulted in a reprimand.**
• Efforts by a Legal Division Senior Counsel to bill the taxpayer for over $41,000
in legal fees incurred in defending against disbarment proceedings arising from
drunk driving convictions. The OIG also found that the same person failed to dis-
close the conviction on his SF-171 form.**
• Generous bonuses to management in spite of past accounts of mismanagement.*®
^''Professional Liability and RTC Contracting With Lawyers, 1993: Hearings Before the Sub-
committee on General Oversight Investigations, and the Resolution of Failed Financial Institu-
tions of the Committee on Banking, Finance and Urban Affairs, 103rd Cong., Ist Sees. (March
30 1993) CHouse Hearings").
^ House Hearings at 7-9.
^ House Hearings at 10.
*" House Hearings at 10.
*^See Lewis, Michael, "Limitations," The New Republic, August 2, 1993 at 11.
**Lavelle, Marianne, "States Try Shielding S&L Execs," The National Law Journal, Septem-
ber 13, 1993, at p. 1.
*^ Kaplan, Sheila, "RTC Lather's Ties to Ex-Firm Prompt Recriminations, Probe," Legal
Times, August 9, 1993 at 1; "RTC Lawyer's Old Firm Wins Contracts," Rocky Mountain News,
June 29, 1993 at 39A; "Millions Flow to Government Lawyer's Old Firm," Rocky Mountain
News June 28 1993 at 33A.
■** keil, Richard, "RTC Attorney Reprimanded for Trip," The Washington Post, August 3, 1993
at—.
*" "Lawyer, RTC at Odds Over Legal Defense," Los Angeles Times, July 21, 1993, at — .
■^Schmidt, Susan, "RTC Paid 136 Top Officials More Than $1 Million in Bonuses in '92," The
Washington Post, F^ruaiy 24, 1993, at p. — .
190
• Assorted contracting and asset sales snaius.'*''
• Efibrts to steer business by Acting General Counsel to a former RTC employee
now working at an outside counsel law firm.'**
Other events at the RTC range from the ridiculous to the sublime. For an agency
in a downsizing mode, the Legal Division continues to hire attorneys and support
staff in formidable numbers.*' Last year, the agency sponsored a cash award contest
for employees for the design of a new logo. Just last month, an agency inspection
determined that the RTC spends $16,000 a day on Federal Express delivery bills.
"RTC employees used overnight service for credit card payments and to send letters
to family members."^
La Denver, employees were sent to "Auditor Training" classes this past June. The
purpose was to instruct employees on how to deal with auditors. The actual presen-
tation, however, reduced the audit process to a poker game where auditors were por-
trayed as the enemy. Employees were advised not to volunteer information, never
blame Washington, DC for anything, and told that the statement from em auditor
that, 'I am here to help," is a Ue. Support staff were told not to worry about cooper-
ating because they don t know the "big picture" anyway.
Tms past winter, during the transition period between presidential administra-
tions, we observed significant shredding activity in the Denver Legal Division of-
fices. Members of the Administrative Unit staff spent many hours into the evening
and on weekends shredding large volumes of documents.
vn. Proposed Solutions
A detailed discussion of what should be done to "fix the RTC" is beyond the scope
of our testimony today. We do, however, want to precipitate a fruitful discussion of
what can be done to restore order to an agency that remains out of control in many
ways. Each area that failed us is discussed below:
Management
A new CEO represents hope to oppressed employees that their programmatic con-
cerns and endured retaliation will be finally heard. We trust that Stanley Tate, the
new designee, will bring a critical attitude to the briefings he receives from current
management, particularly in the Legal Division. There is no better way to check
agency "spin control" other than to be aware of the management self preservation
techniques we described earlier in Section IV. In particular, we encourage him to
speak one on one with line employees without the presence of their supervisors, to
contrast who received management bonuses in eariy 1993 with their track records,
and to embrace the twin reforms of management accountability and employee pro-
tection.
Grievance System
The present grievance system ou^t to be junked. It serves no productive purpose.
In the alternative, the RTC should consider the creation of an ombudsman oftice to
handle these matters. The individual would be independent of management and
have authority to implement his findings. In the alternative, an administrative law
judge, with attendant due process protections, could be appointed to handle com-
plamts in this area. At a minimum, the RTC ou^t to be required to provide reports
to its key congressional oversi^t committees detailing the status and resolution of
all grievtmces and EEO complaints.
OIG
The RTC OIG needs to be rehabilitated. Rank and file agency employees no longer
trust this office or its leadership. Present management should either be replacea or
forced to change its outlook regarding employee retaliation. The office itself would
benefit from amendments to its organic statute which would clearly expand its juris-
diction to provide for proactive protection of whistleblowers. Its powers ought to be
expanded to provide for active recommendation authority with some degree of en-
forcement. At a minimum. Congress should ensure that appropriate oversi^t com-
mittees receive regular reports from OIG's government wide on how management
at their agency is responding to final OIG reports and recommendations.
*^ Andereon, Jack & Binstein. Michael, "TtTC Troubles.'' The Washington Post, Febniaiy 28,
1993. at — .
*'See Exhibit 6 which is a letter from Richard T. Aboussie to James A. Clark, dated July 23,
1993. In the letter, Mr. Aboussie encourages that more work be assigned to Mr. Jefirey North,
notwithstanding an open RTC OIG investigation regarding Mr. North's post employment job
search.
♦•See Exhibit 7.
"•Hoite Makes For Waste In RTC DtUoery Costs," American Banker, August 9, 1993 at — .
191
GAO I Congress
There is much Congress could do to reduce the incidence of whistleblower harass-
ment. First, Federal whistleblower statutes should be amended to explicitly protect
FDIC and RTC employees for their efforts to report waste, fraud and abuse. At
present, where appUcable, these statutes merely apply to reporting of legal viola-
tions. Many kinds of mismanagement can cost taxpayers millions oi dollars yet not
rise to the level of criminal violations. Merit Systems Protection Board ana Office
of Special Counsel jurisdiction ought to be clarified. Second, we endorse pending leg-
islation known as the "Privacy for Consumers and Workers Act" (HJR. 1900). This
bill would enhance employee privacy protections by providing them with a right to
know when they are being monitored or recorded electronically while performing
their jobs.
vni. Conclusion
The American people deserve government oflicials who are sincerely dedicated to
the public interest. They presently are not getting this at the RTC. There is no
sense of stewardship. First came the gutting of the PLS Program which placed bil-
lions of dollars of claims at risk. Next came the waves of retaliation directed at us
for attempting to speak up on behalf of the public interest. These attacks on us were
paid for with tax dollars and serve to chill future whistleblowers from attempting
to improve our government. All of this wastes taxpayer funds and represents callous
iiyustice for those brave public servants conscientious enough to try and reform gov-
ernment operations. The time has come for management accountability and em-
ployee protection at the RTC.
Traveling the Crossroads: My Times at the RTC
Each of us faces many crossroads in our lifetime. A crossroads is any place you
must make a diflicult, personal decision which has the potential for great harm and
r-eat good. A crossroads can be a lonely and frightening place. Over the last year,
have learned that there is merit in the belief of some cultures that you meet the
devil at the crossroads. I met several devils at my Resolution Trust Corporation
crossroads. The most prominent were the devils of silence, fear, and greed. The first
devil was others' greed for person«d power, money, turf, and influence, no matter
what the cost. The second devil was the echoing silence of many in the face of great
wrongs. The third was my fear, and others, of losing things which were meaningful.
Losing my job, career, reputation, respect of my peers, friends, home, peace of mind,
health, even my future.
I was lucky. While this RTC crossroads was formidable, I did not face these devils
of this crossroads alone. I also met angels in the form of my fellow citizens. These
angels often appeared when and where I least expected them. They helped me to
m^e hard, yet ethical, decisions at this particular crossroads. They supported me
in my election to stand up in public and tell the tale of great harm ana. breach of
public trust I had witnessed at the RTC. They sustained me throughout the trau-
matic aftermath of my decision to tell the truth rather than to quietly walk away.
This has been a time which has been one of the most difficult, yet in many ways
the most rewarding, times of my life. They gave me the moral courage to stick to
the path of a whistleblower in the face of overwhelming and unrelenting opposition.
I do not remember when I first realized that joining the RTC as the Denver Pro-
fessional Liability ("PLS") Section Chief would have a profound effect on my family
and me. I came to the RTC believing that I could do something good for society,
not realizing I would risk my familys welfare instead. I thought I would be able
to use my years of management and legal experience to recoup signiflcant taxpayer
dollars from those persons who had destroyed many western savings and loan asso-
ciations. My extensive experience in private industry would help me to make bal-
anced decisions about real world issues. This was my opportunity to do cutting edge
legal work while helping right the wrongs associated with the greatest financial cri-
sis of our lifetimes. I <£d not immediately suspect that my enthusiasm to do bal-
anced, competent legal work on behalf of the public good would be derailed in the
wake of turf wars, private agendas and political maneuverings. I did not realize my
world would be turned upside down ana that my life would oe profoundly changed
as a result of the this crossroads.
When I started with the RTC in summer, 1991, I met the first of many persons
who have supported me throughout the process in which I learned the hard lessons
of whistleblowing. Foremost is Bruce Pederson who has been my supervisor, teach-
er, foxhole mate and friend. Bruce, along with John Beaty, hired me to become part
192
of a select group of experienced professionals dedicated to PLS work and trained me
in PLS law and RTC procedures. He helped guide my PLS unit throu^out the
times when we worked around the clock to beat the statutes of limitations on the
PLS cases. Then, he shared the pain and disbelief of those bleak days after the an-
nouncement that the PLS section was being unnecessarily reorganized, our fledglins
cases precipitously reassigned and that many of us were to be summarily ejected
from tne RTC. He was there with me as we launched various attempts to stem the
significant cmd costly damage of the PLS reorganization. He, along with Bradley
Smolkin our other foxhole mate, shared the witness table at the August 11, 1992,
Senate Banking Committee hearing. It was at this hearing that our collective con-
cerns about severe problems at the RTC became public. It was at this hearing that
our fate as whistlebiowers became irreversible. Words fail me when I try to describe
how much Bruce's leadership, support, and friendship throu^out this process have
meant to me.
There are many brave and ethical RTC employees who quietly tried to aid us in
our battle to prevent the damage and help to publicize the miscarriage of justice,
costly mismanagement of resources and personnel, and breach of public trust known
as the 1992 RTC reorganization. Some people contributed to this struggle without
apparent personal harm, but unfortunately, others became victims sacruiced in this
euort. Manv are no longer in the government. I cannot name all of these exceptional
people for tear of reprisal against them. I can only thank them for their help. There
are, however, one or two I must mention by name.
Viivinia McCrae was brilliant and a dedicated PLS attorney. She was an unsung
"hero who quietly sacrificed personal advantages in order to pursue the public good.
Despite negative treatment, Ginny risked her job to offer unstinting, public support
to Bruce cmd me in this effort until her untimely death on July 3, 1992. Ingria An-
derson was another tireless PLS worker on behalf of the public good. Her reward
for dedicated public service was to be removed from PLS for delivering to me EEO
mail which was marked "personal and confidential." She too was casually tossed
aside when her actions accidentally conflicted with personal agendas of unethical
RTC management. Most recently, John Waediter has become subject to a vendetta
to fire him oecause he told me about the secretive break in of Bruoe Pederson's com-
puter. The moral courage shown by these three ethical people in the face of extreme
hostility toward them for their selfless actions has helped to sustain me throu^out
this last year. These are only three of the many dedicated RTC employees who suf-
fered personal abuse because they were associated with PLS, Bruce Pederson and/
or with me.
Support came throughout this Faustian event fix>m those Denver legal employees
who snared my exile from the RTC during the attempts to prematurely return us
to the FDIC. these stalwart fellows known as "put-backs" shared with me the pain
and disbelief of the reoivanization. They too met the devils of the RTC crossroads.
When they returned to functional RTC positions, they did not flinch at being seen
with me in public or showing me support even though such courage was not politi-
cally correct in the eyes of RTC management.
From May, 1992 until today, public numiliation, undeserved criticism, slander, in-
vasions of privacy, surreptitious surveillance, threats to our friends and supporters,
exile to various buildings, make-work assignments, and retaliation in countless
cruel and mean spirited ways have become the norm as the RTC tries to fashion
a final solution for Bruce Pederson and me. We continue to plumb the depths of the
whistlebiowers' existence. Throughout this nightmare, however, countless RTC and
FDIC employees and contractors, nei^bors, friends, cmd even strangers have of-
fered a kind word when I was about to give up, defended me to others when I was
attacked, recognized the ethical basis of my motives and £u;tions when management
questioned my truthfulness, or smiled and made my day a little less cloudy. I cannot
naune them all here. I can only thank them and recognize that no one would ever
have the courage to stand up for what is right, ethical, or moral, without the encour-
agement of people such as them.
At my crossroads, many fine and dedicated public servants employed in Congress
and members of the press have stood by me and oflered their support. Senators
Timothy Wirth, Donald Riegle, Jr., Howard Metzenbaum, Congresswoman Patricia
Schroeder and Congressman Bruce Vento are notable for their efforts to provide the
fmblic forum to disclose RTC mismanagement. I am grateful, as well, for their ef-
brts to protect Bruce Pederson and me after we testified. Their stafT members Mike
Perko, Uoug Nelson, Konrad Alt, Neal Peterson and Brian McTigtie are simply won-
derful. Many others, too many to mention all by name, have worked tirelessly with
us for the common taxpayer good. I am proud and honored to have been able to par-
ticipate in my small way in their efforts to oversee the business of government.
193
The press has been equally important in getting this tale of waste, fraud and
abuse into the public awareness. When this ordeal commenced, I was afraid of re-
porters. I somewhat believed the conventional wisdom that the press cannot be
trusted because they will misquote you and harm your story. Happily, this has not
been my experience. I have worked with countless members of the press who have
quoted me correctly and told my stoiy accurately and with compassion. I am deeply
grateful to them even though time does not permit naming them.
In retrospect, I, like many other whistleblowers, li^tly made the decision to go
public. I had witnessed a significant wrong and I wanted to tell my story to someone
who could fix the problem. I naivelv believed that once I told my story, all would
be corrected and the story would have an inmiediate happy ending. I was very
wrong. Fortunately for me, however, Bruce and I had been accepted as clients by
The Government Accountability Project. Jeff Ruch and Tom Devine carefiiUy
schooled me in how to effectively tell my account of events at the crossroads of the
RTC. They gently exposed me to the truth of the long and difficult road ahead. They
held my hand through all the trials of whistleblowing and guided me through testi-
fying, press interviews and all the other circumstances of something this complex.
More importantly for me, they and the other wonderful people at GAP were there
when I was sure I could not go on another day in the pressure cooker environment
in which I was living and working.
I must publicly acknowledge the faith, understanding and unquestioning support
of April, my daughter and Bruce, my husband. Throughout this process I have
risked many things which are dear to them. Like most people, I was not bom
wealthy. Bruce and April already had sacrificed a great deal in order for me to be-
come a lawyer. My paycheck is necessary to my family's welfare. My decision to
stand up for what was ethically and morally correct rather than remain silent has
jeopardized my future employability as an attorney, and in doing so, has threatened
my daughter's return to college, the security of retaining our home, the continuing
financial stability of my family and has invaded our famil/s privacy. Despite these
risks, neither of them has asked me to abandon the path I have chosen. Instead,
they have supported me throughout this ordeal and encouraged me to follow my
conscience, irrespective of the potential consequences to them.
Finally, I want to thank Mr. Cavallo and the Cavallo Foundation for selecting me
for this award. I am awed by the feats of moral courage demonstrated by the
present and past nominees and award recipients. I am honored to be included in
their ranks. Mr. Cavallo is truly a man of vision to use his personal wealth to pub-
licly support and encourage people who face these lonely and often debilitating
crossroads.
I would like to conclude with a few observations borne of wrenching experience.
The people I have thanked are a road map of the positive systems presently in place
to sustain persons who try to tell a truth in order to serve and protect society. My
story of how the public trust was breached would not have been told without these
groups. While each group has been wonderfiil, they are still not enough. There are
countless other people who presently remain silent about the wrongs they have seen
because these mute people have witnessed how difficult, slow and painfiil the path
has been for Bruce, me and for those who speak up.
Bruce and I found that many of the formal mechanisms put into place to aide us
actually became methods to retaliate against us and to subvert or hide our story.
Presently, Congress is looking at ways to correct these weaknesses and strengthen
whistleblower protections in many forums. These initiatives must be enacted. The
process needs to be overhauled and reinforced so that those persons who attempt
to expose injustices are protected from retaliation. There needs to be functional sys-
tems in place to insure timely action is taken to investigate and then correct the
problems exposed. It is not enough to know about injustice. Something also must
be done to redress the problem in timely fashion so that the whistleblowers sacrifice
does not appear to be without purpose. Like most people who decide to publicly
point out that the emperor has no clothes, I risked much to tell the truth. I had
hoped for a speedy resolution to the problems I had observed. That did not happen.
Instead of resolution, I witnessed and experienced unabated retaliation. Somehow,
the system did not work as well as it should. The story of my crossroads at the RTC,
unfortunately, is not unique. Others who have shown the moral courage to speak
up in the face of a serious wrong have suffered as severe or more severe con-
sequences. This should not be. Whistleblowers eflbrts to inform the public need to
be encouraged, protected, and supported. Otherwise people with tne courage to
stand up will become an endangered or extinct species.
194
Don Knox, Business Editor — 892-5242
BUSINESS ■ S3A
Thurs. . June 1 7 , 1 993 Rocky Mountain News
RTC whistleblowers
win 'Courage' award
Two lawyers honored
for exposing 'deliberate
mismanagement of
S&L cleanup' at agency
By John Rebchook
Rocky Mountain Nevus Real Estate Editor
Don't invite Bruce Pederson
and top brass from the Resolution
Trust Corp. to the same party.
Pederson and fellow RTC law-
yer Jacqueline Taylor have
charged that RTC executives cost
taxpayers millions of dollars by
gutting the agency's Professional
Liability Section.
In return. RTC officials publicly
criticized the two, threatened
their jobs and even broke into
Pederson's personal computer
tiut at a soiree last week in
Washington, D.C., the pau" were
appreciated — and rewarded.
They received the national Cavallo
Prize for Moral Courage and spht a
SlO.OOO prize for "exposing delib-
erate mismanagement of the S&L
cleanup," although RTC officials
continue to deny the allegations.
"It's sort of the Academy
.Award for whistleblowers." Pe-
derson said.
Pederson said while the money
is "obviously great," the award
was more important.
Pederson
Taylor
"I don't regard my efforts as
particularly extraordinary," Pe-
derson said ' in his acceptance
speech. "I merely did what I think
was right."
Taylor, who along with Peder-
son testified before a congression-
al hearing last year, said she and
Pederson have paid a high price.
"From May. 1992. until today,
public humiliation, undeserved
criticism, slander, invasions of pri-
vacy, surreptitious surveillance,
threats to our fnends and support-
ers, exile to various buildings,
make-work assignments and re-
taliation in countless cruel and
mean-spirited ways have become
the norm as the RTC tries to
fashion a final solution for Bnice
Pederson and me." Taylor said.
Rep. Pat Schroeder. D-Denver.
presented the award.
"The irony was not lost on her
that while she was giving us the
award, the funding bill for the RTC
was clunking through Congress a
few blocks awav," Pederson said.
195
WRITTEN STATEMENT FROM JOHN L. WAECHTER
I would like to take a moment to thank the chairman and the committee for pro-
viding me the opportunity to testify before you today. I will be describing my beliefs
of fraud, waste, mismanagement, and abuse of the United States taxpayers money
being spent at Resolution Trust Corporation.
As you mav already know, the Denver Legal office was recently involved in what
has become Known as the "ComputerGate" scandal. I'm the person who has been
caught in the middle and have been labeled the "Computer Technician" by the
mecua.
With my presence here, I know that my honest efibrts will be thwarted by retalia-
tion. I know that all my answers will be challenged by the RTC. I'm willing to ac-
cept that challenge. I'm willing because I speak as a Government servant and most
importantly, a tsixpayer of the United States of America. My image of the RTC has
been shattered like glass, but deep down inside I can say ... I TRIED!
The statement I'm presenting to the Senate Committee and the American Tax-
payer will address the scandal and most importantly the retaliation.
Personal Background
I was raised in a subject close knit Air Force family. Family values were preached
in our household. My father taught us to stand up and spetik out on issues if you
wanted to try and make a change. Both my parents passed away after my high
school years, but I still practiced and believed in the family values I had been
taught. My wife and I have a strong belief of our family values and pass this on
directly to our 3 year old daughter.
After my parents passed away, I tried to finance my own way to college with some
success. I started in 1982 with Mid-Continent Computers in a entry level mainframe
environment. I disliked what I was doing, but I always strived to tetter myself. My
hard work and values started to payofF. I was recognized for my talents and was
promoted to Datacommunications Analyst. There, I was taught the security and pri-
vacy of others in relation to the computer industiy. Breaching of security and pri-
vacy of others was not tolerated. These rules applied to all, not iust the maiority.
The three years of this type of training has been, and always will be embedded in
my conscious.
In 1985 I worked for Martin Marietta Data Systems under a contract with the
Department of Energy. I carried on what I had been taught through the years. I
had always been hi^ly respected by my coworkers and because of this I was re-
warded. I steadily rose to a highly respected, senior analyst. I attended a multitude
of classes on computer security and proudly enforced what I had been taught.
Between 1987 and 1991, I worked for Pritronix, a national leader in the computer
sales and service industry. There I began to shape and define my career goals. I
received extensive training on personal computers and Local Area Networks (LAN).
I received numerous awards for my skills and achievements.
In late 1991, I accepted a job with the Resolution Trust Corporation Consolidated
Office.^ I worked for the Information Services Unit (ISU) where I was given the title
of Office Systems Administrator. I enjoyed the daily challenge of taking care of the
network hardware and user problems. I participated in the closing of the Savings
and Loans and worked many long hours and weekends. My dedication and devotion
to the company was highly recognized by my supervisors of the consolidated office
(see exhibit 1). I was highly depended on by my management for problem deter-
mination and resolution. In November of 1992 I transferred to the Regional Office
of Information Services Unit. Because of my strong technical and leadership skills,
I was immediately given the task of site management for the Regional Financial
Services Center (FSC). The FSC consisted of 250 demanding users and three ISU
personnel. I supervised two employees, and as a result, I assisted in managerial du-
ties such as schedules, hiring, and performance reviews. I became known across the
region as the "Answer Man for the ISU department and was depended on for var-
ious projects locally and nationally.^ Long hours and dedication to the users made
the I%C ISU department a big success and was recognized around the nation. Spe-
cial projects, sucn as hardware upgrades, software implementation was given to me
by the Corporate headquarters. Management reflected my success by presenting me
with an Employee award and also in my performance appraisal (See exhibit 2).
After the merger between the Resolution Trust Corporation Consolidated and Re-
gional oflice, to my dismay, I was removed from the successful ISU operations of
^The RTC consolidated ofRce reported directly to the Denver R^onal office.
'The region consisted of Costa Mesa, CA, Phoenix, AZ, Denver, CO.
196
the FSC. Attempts by the senior management of the FSC for reinstatement of my
services failed (See exhibit 3). In November 1992, I was transferred to the Denver
Legal oflice as a site manager. I was the only support person available for the 140-f
legal staff and various other departments located in the 1225 office site. This posi-
tion required a skilled and hi^ily professional person from the ISU staff. The Legal
Department was scheduled to move to a larger site by the end of January 1993. I
coordinated the move of the required computer equipment and miscellaneous pe-
ripherals. Once again, I became a site manager of the Legal Department. I was
highly accepted by the Legal Department and was considered a major role player
in the implementation of the national software package called "HDQ. I enjoyed the
challenge the Legal Department presented, and dedicated my time to them. During
the time period of November 1992 and March 1993, I had never received or hearcC
any complaints of my service from the Legal Department.
Chronology of Events
On March 12, 1993 I was approached by Deanna Whisman, a Legal RTC Adminis-
trative ofllcer, and told to report to Barbara Shangraw the Assistant General Coun-
sel of the RTC legal oflice. I walked over to Barbara Shangraw's oflice and was in-
vited in by her. She closed the door, and inunediately stated that what she is about
to say is strictly coniidential and not to leave her office. I acknowledged what had
been said by Barbara, and she proceeded into her statement. Barbara stated that
she was under the direction of "DC" to get a copy of all the WordPerfect files from
Bruce Pederson, a Counsel with RTC le^gal division. I was shocked by the request,
given the fact I knew Bruce and Barbara were involved in a conflict. I explained
to her, it is nearly impossible to tell what is a WordPerfect file and what is a
spreadsheet file, and I would need to copy all files to her directory. She acknowledge
this. I created a directory called "BRUCE" under her own personal "HOME." I ex-
plained to her how to access the files once they were in her possession. I told Bar-
Dara to send me an Email stating exactly what she had requested (See exhibit 4a).
I spoke to Deanna Whisman aher the meeting and asked her if she knew what
Barbara's request to me concerned. She acknowledge that she did know. I stated to
her my concern about this situation and that I really did not want to be involved.
Deanna agreed, but stated the key statement from the meeting with Barbara was
"DC" is making the request. I agreed with her and waited for the Electronic Mail
message from Barbara. Once I had received the Email, I printed two copies, I kept
one for my own records and gave one to Deanna Whisman. Deanna asked me why
she was to keep a copy of tms request and I stated "If I go to jail for this, I can
depend on you to display your copy for the record!"
I copied Bruce Pederson's files to Barbara's directory and noticed file names called
"Grievance 1, Grievance2. . . . etc. I decided these files were not needed by her and
I tried to deleted most of them. I completed the copy of the files and notified her
of completion.
After accomplishing this directive, I felt as if I had violated the privacy of an indi-
viduals rights. I finished my day at the office and went home. My wife had asked
me if anything was wrong since I had been unusually quiet all night. I informed
her about the situation in hopes she would volunteer to be a "Neutral" party. We
both had come to the conclusion Uiat fMs should be brou^t up to the attention of
someone else at the RTC. I told my wife I would talk to ciadtie Taylor, a co-worker
of Bruce Pederson's about this situation.
On March 15, 1993 I informed Jackie of the situation. She advised me to report
this incident to the Inspector Generals Office.
A meeting was conducted by Wayne Zigler and Bobbi Napier of the Inspector Gen-
erals Oflice. I was informed tiiat this matter would be kept in strict confidentiality.
During this meeting, I was assured that I had not violated any rules or regulations
governing the corporation.
A leak of the investigation was brou^t to my attention by the IG a couple of
weeks after the reporting.
Retaliations
Retaliations from the above statement has been enacted upon me by both the ISU
management and Barbara Shangraw. To this day, Fm still suffering retaliations
that have affected not only my worit environment, but also my family liie.
I have been subjected to verbal harassment, removal of job duties and special
tasks, false accusations, denial of overtime, ignored request and training. The fol-
lowing is a synopsis of the continuing repriscQs along with other supporting state-
ments.
197
On April 7, 1993, Michael Brent the Information Systems Administrator for RTC
Denver office, issued a memorandum to ISU staff iniorming us of a new policy for
the administration of access to personal files (See exhibit 4A).
I received oral harassment from Jim Gardell a Senior Office Systems Adminis-
trator in Denver, and Michael Brent concerning the aforementioned incident. I
spoke with Bobbi Napier of the Inspector General s Denver field office to advise her
01 this harassment. Bobbi informed me that something had been done and if things
did not improve to let her know (See exhibit 5).
On April 30, 1993, the news media printed an article about the legal investigation
of the computer violation in the Denver Legal office. Management quickly notified
me by Email (See exhibit 6). This prompted more verbal harassment from Jim
Gardell and Michael Brent.
On May 5, 1993, Michael Brent sent an electronic maU message to inform all Den-
ver office Network users that all computer data is the property of RTC. This made
it appear as if I broke the rule of confidentiality by telling Jackie Taylor of the inci-
dent (See exhibit 7).
On May 12, 1993, I was removed from my position as site manager for the legal
division under the pretext that it was "for my own good." I stated to management
for the record that I disagreed with the decision to remove me from the legal divi-
sion because I felt that this would appear that I was admitting guilt. This removal
was prompted by Barbara Shangraw s accusation that I was a security risk and her
subsequent efforts with top senior executives to have me terminated. A meeting was
scheduled between Dillard Sims, a Senior Manager and Sarah King a Director of
Administrative Services, to discuss the concerns of the issues of Barbara Shangraw's
accusations. I advised Dillard and Sarah of the incident and informed them that I
had been cleared of any wrong doing by the Denver Office Inspector General and
that there was an ongoing investigation.
I was then placed at the 1225 17th St. Office Building. My job duties were not
clearly defined as I was advised that this was a temporary move until the situation
in the legal division had been resolved. A senior level contractor for the ISU Depart-
ment was site manager for this building and I received direct orders from him. This
is a conflict of RTC standards and policies.
On May 13, 1993, I met with Jim Gardell a ISU Senior Office Systems Adminis-
trator, who advised me that I was incompetent and immature, and that he had no
faith in my ability. He also informed me tnat "he did not know what to do with me."
On May 16, i993, another meeting was conducted between myself and Jim
Gardell. Jim told me that I needed direct supervision and would be removed from
the 1225 office and would be sent to the Park Central Office by May 18, 1993. The
ISU staff was informed by Electronic Mail of this move (See exhibit 8). I informed
Jim that I felt that was a retaliatory action by management.
On May 17, 1993, I met with Dillard Sims and Sarah King who stated to me that
they did not feel that my removal from the legal division was warranted but they
were forced to remove me for my personal welfare. They also expressed their appre-
ciation for my job performance. I expressed to Mr. Sims and Ms. King that Jim
Gardell had informed me earlier in the day, that I would be relocating to Park
Central and he did not feel I was doing a good job. Ms. King told me tnat there
must be a misunderstanding concerning this move as she has just spoken with Jim
Gardell and Michael Brent. I informed the Inspector (General of this alleged move
and stated that it was in retaliation. The IG agreed and stopped the move. I was
also advised at this time of Barbara Shangraw's ftirther allegations that I sabotaged
the phone and broke into an office that held Bruce Pederson's personnel files.
On June 15, 1993, an investigation was held by the Inspector General's office of
the Treasury Department (See exhibit 9). I met with Larry Glisner who informed
me that I had not broken any rules or regulations and that no retaliation acts
should occur.
On July 7, 1993, an Email was sent to a manager of the Legal Department apolo-
gizing for the poor support that had been relevant to all of the Legal Department
(See exhibit 10). The manager was promised half day support of all of the 160 users.
Lack of expertise was a major concern of the site. A Office Systems Technician
(lower grade) was put in charge of site management.
On July 21, 1993, a national news broadcast was aired concerning ethical dilem-
mas in the workplace. After the airing of this show my job responsibilities and com-
munication from management had almost ceased to exist. My access rights to the
Inspector General computer server was deleted. A special national contract project
was removed from my authority and given to a technician.
During this period I volunteered for overtime to help assist other ISU staff in a
lai^e move project. No response was ever given to my request. The ISU staff com-
plained to me of not having adequate help for the move.
198
On August 17, 1993, I received a memo from Jim Gardell notifying overtime
weekend coverage at the Republic Office (See exhibit 11). All Contract System Ad-
ministrators and RTC System Administrators were included on the list except my-
self. Technicians were also excluded due to lack of ejcperience.
On August 24, 1993, I received a telephone call from Jim Gardell who informed
me that ne had found a security problem on a network server log. He accused me
of entering the ISU server for administration rights. Jim badgered me about the sit-
uation ana told me that it would look badly for me given my prior situation. I ex-
plained that after the removal of my legal office login it was not possible for me
to access a reouired program used by all ISU staff. I had created a new login that
did not have tne necessary access rights required for this program. I attempted to
add myself and failed. Immediately I informed the ISU help desk whom in turn
granted my access. I asked Jim Gardell if I were cleared of this accusation and he
informed me that it would be up to Michael Brent, although I had once again not
done anything wrong. I requested training from Jim Gardell and was informed that
I would never receive additional training. When I confronted Jim about no conrunu-
nication between management and myself either verbal or written in a period of one
month, Jim corrected me and stated that it had been more then eight weeks. I also
confronted Jim regarding projects being removed from me and was told that I would
not be undertaJcing any new projects as he did not trust me. I was also advised that
I would not be eligible for any overtime. Feeling frustrated I expressed to Jim that
I would be filing a grievance and he laughed and asked me "For what, lack of com-
munication?".
On September 16, 1993, I informed Dillard Sims of my ongoing problems with
management. I requested his prompt attention to this matter and advised him I
would be preparing a grievance. This action prompted the removal of the ISU con-
tractor from the building that I currently occupy (See exhibit 12). A RTC employee
now assists myself and a technician to assist 180 users (See exhibit 13).
Closing
I made the mistake of trusting Barbara Shangraw's knowledge of professional eth-
ics and morals not only because of her senior level position, but because I assumed
she was a competent lawyer. This judgment call has caused a great deal of suffering
to me and most importantly, my family. My ftmiily continues to support my decision
thus helping me create a sound commitment to the taxpayer.
Last but not least, I would like to enlist your support in helping to resolve the
disaster currently inflicted not only upon myself, but upon those who spoke in front
of you today. I thank you for vour support and to thank the many others who sup-
port and stand behind me, and my family.
199
SIX y.ONTH RE
XNHUXI, PER70RMAMCE XFFRAISXL
(Evaluation of EapXoyaa Farfomanca for SG-S and Xbova Positions)
JcMl lili irm«f
TITIE UO CJLUIC
Offica IvitaB h»in.
I.C11
oauiiiLtriowu. unit
miC/ITC ln«arKCian I«rv<cM
NIOMfS IT (Staralun) 1. ^
TITU MO SUM
Info. Soorie— Jt^liin.
ICIJ
OtbUIUTiaui. UIIT
rVIC/ITC tn<or«tion Swirica
uDK HLAuaoair TO or\.ora
miOD covFifD IT ni] cvtuMTica
rrai
TO
1
incsuTf sj>nvisai
n.
D*T
Tl.
■o. -
MT
Tl.
oria (Cjiplain)
11
19
90
OS
1»
»1
TO rtc ura
Tha infor«wtiv> on tnit 'or* sarvM «• tn« •rrXMl p«rfomwv« rvBluaCien «na •/« «l«n*nt in rtnkir^ cw^idattt for
potitioftS vw^JVtd vj-ocr tn« Merit Prtvution Plan, latum tn« onginai to tft« Offiet of Ptrionnal Har«9«m*nt
for filing in tn« fl*vloy««'t Official Panorral Foloar. ilio. if tha aaciovaa indieicaa tnac a ceoir mould ba
placad in hit/har Hant Pranoiton fila, tard • OkoUeata eocrv vitn tha original to tha Offlei of Ptrtomai
Managavnt. It U laoortwit that r^rrativa cowHanii ba mmom to clarify aaen aaaignad ^t^wricti racing. Hark
• acn aiwnont with tha i\M^ur of tcatMant bavo« mat baat daaenba* tna OTDiovaa't parformanea:
(1} Tna Mciovaa't parfonnarct ticaadt your aiDactatlona to tvxh an axiant tnat it aarranct tpacial
racognition. (Thata ratings mould M iU>^crtta4 &y txaaoiaa.j
(2) The arctoyaa hat dantfucrttad aonity to i oagrt* tnat i« cltarly aoovt tntt txocctao of a coaoatant
gndoyaa and you trt confioant tnac Aa/ifta >iU contin^ to parfom at tnit lavai.
(3) Tha «icioya« ha* d«<wwtritad aoility to tna «xt«nt tftcactao of a corroattnc tmpioyaa and \ i wA>ld
raeortmand hi*/har for anotnar xau'ort in wiien tna aoitity is iiroortant.
(4) Tha anDiovaa'9 parfor^nwa n acetotceia, out raflacti toiw MaaKnaasaa tnat can ba ovarco«a mtnin a
panod of tix aontht to a yaar.
(5) Tha Kioloyaa't oarforaMKa tk/iibita dafinita «aaKna«»at thac cannot b* corractad within a panod of
BIX iiionthi to a yaar.
(X) Tha awDloyaa nad a imitad ocporti#^iiy to ihow ability in thii raspaet.
Aftar tha rating ii coaolatad. dfacua* your tvaluation -ith tha •mloyaa «o tnat tha «ralova« knowt how ha/sha
U Jtwaiing tha job parforiwrct ttanaarda. fiWa tha amployaa tha oooort^jMtv to add ramarKt m tna sooca provtdad
for tnat purooit. Tha diicu»»ion can larva at a guioa to tna weloyra m raanatic caraar planning.
PCXFOBVUiCE
\. JOi tMOJLEDCt
1 a. Has brtadtn and daoth of kmowladga of ganarsl occisational fiald.
2 &. Has txoaricnct and knowlaOga n«aoed for soacific job.
(In narraiiva, aascriba fitlds of spacial coaoatanca and, aa aCDroorUta. contnant on oeval
in current joo).
tal progress
COWCHTS:
j»in cvNaistantly J— Ji utratii a ^Ty high lfv«i of occi.eatianal OOMiaoga in tna ganaral and soacific asoacts of
hii job. la nas laversi years of aacBgro«-rd aioernnee m LAK design, installation ana nanagamant. His
Kno«i.eoge of LAa aosmtstration oractiees nas siaved a "lajor roie m neieing I SU mett our service goals. Areas
where ;onn oossesses cioart iXiUs are l** snd lUii taieccawijiicatiof^. itr^tr configuration and set i*, LAM
systaM ooarating software and PC haroware construction ana namtenanca.
2130/U (Page 1) (12-85)
200
2. MODUCTI
t •. ivtm ouc e«»i«», fii«ii-«Miitv I
2 b. ^pooucn itrf« 9^«ticv of vOtk, or cwitCM pro|«ctB «uicktr.
2 s. ■•«ts 4*«dlin*«.
JQAA It wtrv conseiMW* aDout tft* OMi'tv «f <M<*t ft« orodUEM. Mt i« tftofou<n •ra orteit* m nit tODfOAcn t*
totviriQ orooimm w o»v*iaotn« toiutitns ta Mtctr nanagt infar««cion. 'raiactttno tatcktrt coHoitttd an tiM
9ra •ecoroinfl to to»ct#iettian. jtriM ct^ i« l«t «««MD»r ourinf « vvry ausv ti«t. «• tflPvotstttv «»««a to
eontnauto towtroi ^C canrigwracton and inataUation. t«rw*r canf tfwration ana »ott«ar« iiocaaancocian. 1 ••
vary piaatad «)tn tna VMiity and wjancitv af jodn'a motk.
S. OMUIICATIOB KlUt
t. Oitelay* acilt in o^ai «i8ra«aiQn 9* ioaaa. aoapctnt ca tn« littartar and tituation, etarity of
2 «A0r>«taion. «ffactt«« u»« at la
2 0. Can adSrtat frg««a farvatlr.
S c. wricat vatl: uriitng ia cImt, corract. «aU orianitad, cowiatt, aoeroDriact in •»yia v>d lanQuaflt.
C9«iCMTSt
jonn It on affactiv* coaawiieacar. n* ltttar« vail and hat cht aoility co «ast '«n<ttcnnieal ovoeit faal
eoMfo^ttoia in oncvMtionB aoaut ttcftnicai cooiet. Ht not tweeaaafuUv cau«nt tawrot CS and lanv«^ f^cwork
eitttaa *itn eana>tconeir poattiw caMantt aoeuwntad on tha clatt turvav for«a ov t:;jb«ntt. Ha rtgutariy
Dartteipatat in tna tt«af uaa^ Cra« «a«tinf« iivtna praaantationa ana jwiuiiatrationa. ^itin« tcUla naad as
drraijtwiit.
UDKIK l£UTI«Sitrt
a. witnin invdiact orfantutian, «ati aLanf witn co-«orcart, it 9oaa Qfs^A morttr, haaet otnart' points 9*
viai*.
b. OuttJdt i^aadiata of'faniution, wina *as0oct and eaoearatian of »a«rt. managanant e^fieialt in ocnar
sartt af 'OtC, :n acna^ a««ne>*«. a^ sanarai OhAnc. (in narratwa, ttatt tyea or natura af santactt).
c. 9iaei«v« a «illin«n«»a and aeilitv to train atna^t.
Qftn not dovatooad an aKcailant raoDort aitn nit oavt and tiAafiort. Mit tantc of n^jwr halaa to data a vary
treat^ul vorc f<vvironi«nt totaraeia. jann fouowa di^octian aitraMiaiv aail. Ooaa MOtl vttn paodit tn e«'>*''>l«
:a include '•wnagtmant, dvoeie fr^ outttdt aganciaa ana «anaort.
fOtC 2130/15 <»a9a 2^ <*.2-85)
201
i. AAOXXT AA fVCBlXH SOLVIK
2 •. C«tt to tht root of tno proeiiM ond aaiM tou^ oroootoit, dootioni.
2 b. forw^t prooMito conooouanctt of octiono or rtcowndotiofxa.
2 c. AAoirttt situations, dottrvinct isiuvt. gatn«r« tu'Hctcnt focts, w«ignt •Ittrnativt* on) irriv«« at
utaful concluaiena in studtaa or ttaff-tvpa ••oigrwanta.
2 4. loco«ni2t« aituationa tnat it««rviior aftould b> conaultaa on or tnfonnad o'.
C9«iCNTS:
JoAn't problaa dtttrvtnation and analviU tkiUa ara vary strong, locausa of his bocKgroLTd and txoarianea ha's
had tha ocaperti^iity to saa • graat oaai and aKpannant with tna ootions. On tavaral occanena n* ftaa o'ftrad
idaas that eircuMrantad DrodicMa snd spaad tiMa. SpactfieaLly nit vorK m configurinq to Svstaa >ro fr**r%. Ma
hat tha aoHity to ttao bacK fro« a coneiai proelaa. anaiyza tha eonoonants, aaign tna aittrnacivaa and acply tna
risnt fix.
6. AOAfTAIlLIR AM atEATIVlTT
2 a. Oitolava eraativity and originality in attaining tiork oejactivas.
1 b. idaots raadity to changaa in progra* dir«ction or in procadurts.
1 e. Clvaa on aitra affort vnan tna joe raguiraa.
COWCMTS:
ionn has adaotad vary wail to his na« job and working anvirorvnant. Ha daow titritas a fiir tmocrt of eraativity
in sDoroacn nis asiignad task. Jonn tt to bo tsDaciallv cenwanaad for hit MiilingrMts to Mtx and ehanga with
tha worK flow. Ma is txtronaly comittad to tna causa is vas saan on j^#^a 19 wnan nt aaikaa from ckfiicia to
ceieia oitn hi« I month old oaugnttr taarening for vinjaaa tnat had infaciad tna natwort. Savarai hours O.T.
hava baan contnbutad to conoiata critical proiacts.
ituiTT Am m
s. Carrin out sstignaantt on his/har o<^; luccaatfuUy works indaoanoandy.
D. aaactt vitn vroarstanding to ocapoatng viawa or oootaclas to aceonvi isnnant.
c. Saaa tnat nacaisary things gat dono.
4. It daoanoaoia, in tariH of praaanca on tha joo snd affactiva usa of cima.
a. Accepts raspensibiUty.
C9WCIITS:
jonn works vary wail with ■iniaoi skoarvision. M« followa througn on assignments without sroffcting. Ma knows
^lat to 00 ano gats it dona. n« naa affactivalv ^anaiao soma ratnar mtcnsa confrontations witn irata usara,
oafuting tna situation and solving thair prooiams.
fOIC 213C/13 (Paga 3X12-85)
202
I. onici rrtncTM <wr<~.'rm m»ih4 »»»ti»<
Thrn grtttMt etoMidtiM (n
11
<k
-
tWlOTEl levlEVl
(iKord vtT cijimnti r«u lav* in tK* te*c< baloa, rtftrrinf la n* r«<n*r and Ittttr o> en* <t« you trt
di»cuB»in«, or acttcfi • tcoaratt tAavt.)
I h>»« rtvitMd (Hit cavKtM ractnt and 't hu
>«raBt<an fUt (cireit on>) 'm • Da. (Only awl
th» nair *utuf« tnouc5 eTrct% T*»).
diievaiM aitn «>. I aould liit • caey Btacad In ay writ
itfto nav* or aioect Co ottaeUtJi a «*fit proaotion fUa in
tieiurutti
-ii
W ^^Vl
I
ntt on tftit tvaiuactcn:
SECO«0-t.EVC!. SUPEIVIsaiT tCVlEU
(If yog trt utt to MO tisnificanc caw ntt batto on yo^r o*rior>«l kr««i«09t o' trie anDiovM't Mf'for«v>ei, or
DOt«nti«i. yow would oo so. If vow tod t^v ^eq»cw« cyr»^t». '•ttum cnt •voiuocion to tnt OTOiay*«'t iiwaoittt
ttjptrvttor. ^•/»M atll lAon tn« fera co trt« •q>ioy*« racM, and gtv* niai/n*r onotnor oaoor:v/^ttr to co^wnt in
tn« sooct ioo««.)
ny cji—nt» on tntt «valuoti«n *rt •• foltawt:
-. tj
: '^*t 'e*iew«c (-It rarwr^tt of Trtt tacora
'.t«ti t..oarvi«r.
EKHSTEE'S SISa«H,«E
;»:e
FOi: 21IC/1] Otga .) I12-9S)
203
AKKUM. PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL
(Evaluation of Enoloye* Perfonnanco for GG-9 and Aiova Positions)
RECEivEtr
JUN 1 a '992
WJ....
««"£ 0< £»»1.0tEE
JoAn wa«cnc»r
TITLE Aao CKOE
a<''C« TnlOM *i»in. 11
OSOIZlTICNtL U>IT
FDIC/ITC Inforwtion $«rvter
'■EPOED ST <!<9n4Iur<j
'^ ■
TITLE AHO CaAOE
Info. S«f-riCM A
ORLlMl2AnON*L JMIT
FOIC/irC Inforaitian Services
U0»K 1EI.AT101SMP TO E»»l.OrE£
><>IQO
C3VEIE0 9T tnis «v»i.u»IIO«
OW i TO
z
IKXEOIITE SUPE"VI50»
"0.
0«T
Ti. >ia. 1 o«T
It.
1 OTHE) <E<0ll'n)
11
1«
90
07
IS
«
TO TM£ OTEl
The mrormjtion on tms tofm sc^es as trie imxni D«r fsi-iTanef evaluation *na »n •'.e»*«ent m rmiing canaitfatts for
positions jnnouncefl ^jno*'" tne "e-'t Proinotion *lan. aetu''n tn* o^'qinji to tne Ot'tce 3f *efSOnne, <*«naqe'nenc for 'tlinq
in t-ie fffcioyee's Of+'cai Persorvnei foiotr. Also. :* :n« «»TBiove« inaicites tn«t « coov snouta D< otacM m ni$/her
■en: Promot'O" *'i«. send J 3uoi>cjce eoov «'tn me originjt to the Office o* 'erso^nei '••nageinenc. It tj inwortant
t-^at nerrit've rornnents M inaoe to Clarify e«e- •ssiqneo ^xrwricai ritinq. "jrs eacn element witn tf^e >xirotr a#
st»:*<T<ent oeiow tnat oest 3escriocs tne ewoiovee's performjnc*:
(1) Th» emoiovee's serfo'-mance exceeds your eioectat'onj to suc.i an e«tent tft«t Tt warrants so*eial
recoqnit'on. [These 'atmqs $nouia 0* iUwstr»ted 5v e»*«^»es.)
(21 The e«nDiovce ^as oe«non«i rateo aonity to a oeqrec that ^\ clearly aoo«e mac eaoected o^ a eoncetent
e^ciovee ar»a vou a''e cr'^'toent that "e/She •>ii ;snti'*ue to se^'orfh at this ^e-^et.
(3} 'f^e cToiOvee ^as 3e<Tions:.-ate4 aoi 1 1 ty to the extent eaoectto st a :3)toetent ewioyce trc you -ould
recomme'x: hiT./fe' 'or another josifo'^ '-^ .ffic t^e aOM i (y n "Toor rar-t .
(4) rne e-^iovee's oe'-'orrFxarce -s ac:eciaoie, >*t *e*iec:s lone •eatncsses tnat ;an oe overcame .ithm a
D«rioa c^ SI" (hcnt.^s to a »ear.
(5) The e*Taioyee's ser^ormance e»nibits ae'mite seatnesses that cannot De corrected -ithm a oeriod of
Sia mentis To a year.
{!) The e>^(0vee nac a iimitec oooort^^ity to tho« aoilitv m this resD^ct.
*f;er tne racmq is co>^ieteo. disc.ss fOv^r rvaiuat'on Mith th« «Melovee so mat ;he enciovet unoMS haw he/she 's
meeting twe joo per'orifttnce sta'xiaras. C'«e the e^wioyee me oooortLnty to aaa retraces tn the stjace orovioed for that
DurDose. fh» oiscwssion ca'i serve as a 9uioe (o the e»*dOy#» »n real'snc :areer jianrmq.
>ff*OMM*a
JOS KIKMVEOU
1 a. "as ceaam a*^ oeo:* o* i^o-.eoqe o' je-^e'at oc c -oa t ' >%* , t>eta.
? r. "as eioertence ano <nowteaqe «e*oefl 'or ioe«'''e ;oo.
,.-> '•.arra;-,e. sescrttse fteiGs c* soecai cofoeteiYe ard , at aoo'' sor ■ a t e . carment c" 3eveioor»«tal p'^ogress ano "eeds m
r.rreni ,cci ,
:>--Nrs;
,3nri-A sacsgrowna as a svste*^ e'-qi'>ee'' ano ce'T ■ ' I ec la^^i-an * ' i-irs *<a»"ii strat;.' ciea^iy auai if'ed htm as an Office
SrSte*^ *CT"inist--a:o'" , -ti »oc«.ea?e o' '^et-o'i o*» ■ jn :or » i T^i-at ■ an a'« "tbi — ^e-^tat ' on has contriouteo 9'eatiy to Tie
ttfianno*^ a'va e^rtance'^n: .crt .« -a-e e^aqea ■ **• &*tt Tea' .an" t :ecrifica. »»miS i$ en* of hn greatest assets.
^nn -as Dee" >-c;?iS*.. 3: -fs; .■'5 a'^ tfC"* ;», c"a>'e^es ■• ia« 'aced p -un^^ing :-»e £50 aser net^ort at me
'tirancai ^Derations 3*' ct .;*- "as a^-eiaoeo ■" » tet-^n-cat ti < 1 1 1 :o a .evei -'■e'e ■'e -s '■eaov to shift us 'ac-s '3
Ticre =• a Swce-»-S3'v -z-.e.
2-3:, 13 ',?ase ■ ) c; :'; ;
204
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Resolution Trust Corporation
MEMORANDUM TO: Sara King. Director Department of Administrative Services
Denver Office
THROUGH:
FROM:
DATE:
RE:
CC;
Roger Schwierjohn, Acting Assistant Director, Asset Operations
Financial Service Center
Ruth Ann Oliver, Department Head. Automation/Conversion.
Asset Operations
Financial Service Center
November 6. 1992
John Waechter
Kim Carlson
As you may be aware. Asset Operations has had extensive problems with the Banyan
network since our move to Republic Pla: a. Asset Operations develops systems that
are used throughout the western geographical area. Because of our development
activities, our network needs and support from ISU are complex and critical. John
Waechter is the most knowledgeable person in ISU related to our systems and
network needs. Since Asset Operations' move to Republic four weeks ago, we have
had diligent support from the ISU staff to rectify our network problems. However
since the ISU personnel assigned to Republic do not have the knowledge that John
has of our systems, we continue to have problems.
John Waechter was at Republic yesterday and was able to solve the network
problems I was experiencing with my system. This took him about five minutes on
problems that I have been dealing with for four weeks. John is highly regarded by
everyone in Asset Operations, and we sorely miss his presence at Republic. ISU is
very fortunate to have someone of John's caliber as a member of its staff. I only
wish that John could work with us on an ongoing basis. We still have network
problems which we are confident that John could solve for us within a matter of days.
RTC NON-PUBLIC INTOR.M.ATION
'j~ I'-i ii . dw.LC J«'jO • Denver. Cotorauo iJZ^Z • j03-- ^1 -^^"O
Jcvur^eni lijiohn
205
S. OtuCl JTt€«Tii$ or«er»*r<q toecni ^wna^
iann ca^^tinuct :3 o« « «ituAOit «isct to ine CarDoraCion. fi« tt • ««rv Mara vorttr and can o* eot^cto on to eanoictt «ftv
tISi )iv«n o "tM. »it 9rt«t ttrtt of ntjnor it ttD»Ct«ily tODrvcitttd. «• n«t orovvn niAsctf to M •» ticvuvnt Twwo^f
9* aur "et«a'-t suooer* :•«« *na ft* toocan raaoy to t»c« on •oditionai ti^crvitory tvp« •itiqnwnti. *is aort ttme it
•A esctiitnt reit modti ^or otner cMoiovt** in tn« Corporation.
Tnrct 3re«tcst caoaoUicitt (nufB*r tna lotttr)
iBtcsra jny cofnTentt *ou "•»• '« tne so«ce otto«. r«*«fr'
acKcn • tco«rate tn*e!.:
Of to tnt nijrDor «nd Ittttr of mc ictn you art di«cusstng, or
: ^ot ^«vi««M cnis so'vtctca rating ana 't nai o«*n oi«cws««d witn m*. I vouid likt a coov oiaced 'r> »y <Ti*rit
Srsnotion *Me (rirce on*> *«s • <io. (Oniy fmDioy««« wto na«« or aioect 70 tftaoltin a mert; sromotion filt >n t»c n*ar
_*ut,re tnovn3^i":;e 'es).
rr
(c-Z-S^
ou kisn. ^ou nav *oa yowr cwnnenes on cms evaluation:
V \ i^^ Cixri
\
CI* you ai-e acie '.3 aoc S'jniticant co"«enti Mt*4 on to*jr otrjonai ino«ie09t o* T«e emoiove^'t per fcrtnanc*. or
ects^t'ii, yOu tncu.c 30 S3. :* *o>^ *oe jnv -i>-;atvg ryry^Tt. -etjrn t?>t tvaiuat^on ts :?»» f-oioyt«'» -(wieoiate
s-cfw'SSf . -e/s"* -ii; s'^O" r*^* 'orm tc tn* c<noie*«« ritea, «no ji«« nim/ft»r »notn«r oooortt/ii tv to corwent in tfta
ss4:c iS0'*e. :
tvif^^Xi on cms tvaLac^o" «-e as fOl\o>t:
-
^'^-
1 -i-LE .
1 v_ '."-.
/^.
• ^^-H.., ji
- . ; -
r^T^f-Ti ;•
•*• i*:rnc
f-e s-oe-^'^:'
-.; £■ s = >. .==
'"■■
■! =!?! - ■:■•;■
206
^. juDC£i«iT JUS ptcsiev SOlvllC
2 ». Cats to tf>« roct 0* tn* d^coica vmI maitft soi^< prooo««(*. 3«cisioni.
2 8. ^cesee* arooMie ra^'ieoi-e-KM o* •ct«o«» or "ecammenoatioos.
2 :. */i*ivJH $it-*tiort«. a«te'^t««s iisuci. gachtrs sufficient facts, ■•tqn* »iterni(ivt» trc •rrivt* at useful
:Qnciusion» in studies zr sta'*-rvo« ass'grjnents.
Jonn eaft'Ditt v«rv st'Of^q s^eolr" settrminjt ion «nd rtso(ution SKtllt. Nit in-acotn knowieoq* of tnt internal cocracton
3* rettpori servers. ^Cs ano oocrac"*? svste<fa en«oit 'tim to confront tn« most aifficutt orooiem «itn contiaence. .onn
IS :norouqn m :ne anaivsis :' arootr'm »rc is 3000 at seitctmg cnc a*st alternative tor a toiunsn. ;onn atmost aioavs
lets ftts swoerviior «ro- -"en t«»re irt issues tr>at tney n«eo to oe aoare of. '''ere fas not oe«n a technical srootem
tn«t jonn nas f^ot D«e" «o.e to res3i»e.
t. OAPTASILITT AM) CXEATtVITT
2 a- O'SOiavs creativity arxj a'lS'nality m attaining .on oojectwes.
2 t. «caots reafliiy to changes '« cragram airection ar m proceoures.
1 c. -"vfs an eitra trtz'". •'"?- :■? too '••cuires.
• c"" ^as ae'^nstratec tri«o**; ic*- * aDoiy^q s»ste«^ soi^jfon* to '•*tol*e technical :iaiienqes. tis *nowieoqe of
c--ico''«'':s. :**«•■ 'j-cr-fs, s-vj 1 ^f-tiv o' sr'soucts an :ne carter nas see" a ^i^^az.e asf. '.z ay '.tun. .onn 13$
seen .er# ea^e*- :3 -c*t .eg i^ow's an<j 3^,1 *er:^ sseciai e'^ort ta-arg meeting :ne joais o* I Su . "'s lantr-oution :3 £0P
:v3i -q s^oocrr soec**'Cai.y n :*e sr-a 3» rf , eco^ro^icat lonj is ji-eat-y aoorecacea. "'S rec^nica; e«oert'se las a^so
oe*n vfv fteio^ui »".-* a ^ae:-a. :-3iec: 'or :ie Ge<**rai »ccD«j^tinq Office.
tESPOiStaiLlTT A« !iOEPE«)eaa
3 J. Cd'-'-es Z\^: asi'9-r*'<ts ;-^ " n/"er ;t.**; SwCcest'uUy -or<t inaeoenoent ly ,
5 : s-ar-s .>ti -nce'srano -; ;3 :doos>'^9 ••*•» or oentaeies to accafci 1 sni^en; .
2 : Sees fac necessar* :*:r;s jet 3on».
2 :. Is sere-xaao-e. n :e'-^ :» 3re»e->ct sn (■»• lOO aria f»*»«ii»e use 0' tune.
' - icrects "esDansisi 1 1 ly ,
.cn can ae s«Dect(-: :: csrcie** "'s assiqnnw*"s ■':*» •'"•^i s***''*' • lort. *e «*or«s -eil maeoenoently as -ell as 'f^ a
'.ii'' e-vircnne-: .;^«-s "ea:* ;-s :: oooos ■ -«| • ■ ew» "^^o* 'i^y g^<— i"t , aossisiy z* rating a "egot 1 ar :nq s> ■ l ^ s c.ass.
-e 5 »e*-v rere'vaac;* anc -fsc;-* :.?. .o'"* «"0't» to lucoor; fe canwe-S'on :c t-e ">< sys:?^ ^ave seen an
aOT'' cat **sccr^ ■ i - . ■ : V "a" ** "ss sat'S''M wifout ne-e^^ng «r^ aoait'Dnai 3''»c:'cn •-am iis s;*oervis3P.
207
2. ^t<SUCTS
2 I. r^rnt «*t ca«Ditt». iigA-ouai itv o^o^jcth.
I a. ff'-OOUCfft Ifgt QU«ACitV of wore. 9r eQH«lt(M O^OlVCCa OUiCKlV.
J C. •■••{& OtMlintt.
jonn's «ort it cv«>»t«ntiv m*** »" aw4iity. "U tec^mcil knowltog* «(^*oiv« «>• t9 ivo.d cottlv errori reiutting in
tviCtM ogt«9ts trc inccr<-^joc lont C9 '^vtMon sflrv>e««. Jotn ft» don* • ti^tr joo o' k»«ein« p«ct «itn :nt mttntciv ne*«y
voiuiw of crv««»cciont «/« ceouvttt rtf nt% C9 rvtoend to. his wort in eoii««r*r9 cnt <IS •re >C laitt connvctton «•«
eactotionai. »'-oi«cc Artt c»«. 9«Miin«« nawf contitttATlv o*«n MC. Jonn't Mrit •tc««oc ac • praitet it 9tn«r«itv «
fir^«l QroouCC.
ICATIOi UII.LS
2 <. 3iioi«vt tciil <n srti cacfvttior of itfett. MAOCmQ to tnt Utcentr md siCu«cion, cttncv of tioretnon,
^ •T*»Cti*« >-!• of l.»«9w*9t.
2 9. C«n MaffSI ^rowoi *arm«ur.
3 :. •^■ttt w«it: n^'r'nq it citt^. eorrtcT, w^u orgtAi ttd, car«t<ct. aoeroertACt m tcy^t t^c 'v*n9u«9t. (In
43nn cc"«ntCP«-M «ftectw« iaffKiOieit i on iciltt >" trov^ tvtttnqt. «««!t«9S. ©rtinttorwinq tnd oUnniftq tcttiont.
S;ua*At fvoc* '9^ ts-ns iraie<ce tf'tcti«t ttsemnq tnUt •» tn« Intro ;9 OQS una i»rwn cc «•*«. jonn tnouio giv*
*t*.e«tio« :9 ttre^qt.«e"i'^9 ^>i •'■iti«9 Mtllt. ©•'■«#o« &<f ttctng tn« •rttmq si«%» offe''«d 5y Cjr«e' Oevetopwent. .onn
f*! isr>9 *n *mct»**^t j90 3* er*«=t'»«iv cami^icK 'nq tnt ivttffw n#«fli o* :p«» ftnirtcm Cotritioni staff, •cfi'*'!
csntricut lont m :-c forn of f*M&«Ck on d«o«rtn«At aoncitl f< ococvou/tt n«i M*n grcativ aoorecr«t«c.
2 «. .itft'« (im«oi*tf ofSirt' lat ion, 9«ta aian^ -ii** <••«•''«•'■%. »• 90*^ 9''*«8 -orK**, -^Mat otnerf potrtt of vn*.
2 a. Outticc -nr«o<«:c or^a^t tac »^. •<na 'ttoKt and cooo»<«tion of Dctrs. inanafcw^t afficats m otf«r oa^ti sf
^dlC. n ocntr sQcnetet. a^ gc'vrai auD(*<. (In «<«rrativ«. ttatt tvo* or- naturt or contaetsi.
:. 3<toia«s a «w.ii-*4neti and tomtf t« t^ai'* at^^t.
.snn -at ettaoi'tn^o 9ood -orti^q r^itttont/xD •■»• ei'»»»ii. •^^do*-!. and f^it eetri. ^a tt ft'^n-.v rttovcctd 's' ''U
:ec'^'*'cak toe'tse J'x: se'^t'Vvtr rova^n c^taMv t#»*"ca. Vr<i*'ai oot'tive canwwnts na-rt oaa" m»dt ov c.ientt m
sso^ec* at iQ" ^' .3""'t att'StaTe .onn a«« o»«m wkm/^ to fa"** ia»t«'' ■t«oe"'e'*e*c oe^ionnei n *c and nttwofi
::'^ce£:«. .s^'* -a* ie*- «•;*:: s'-a- at •"•Pd «(«.» '••*oor>di'^ la ^a* n#tct. ,onn 9ctt aionq •>;« ail of :^t oaooit ■^a
•9'-«$ • t« a^o •!* Du'.t an *c'?st<«e 'N«r*o'i a* tun^'cai 'r*ak^e«.
=::; :-i:.'j I'j^e ::
208
To:
C=:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John Waechter9INF0eRTC0EN
Barbara Shanqraw§Leqal-Corp9RTCDEN
Friday, March 12, 1993 15:56:10 MST
Y
EXHIBIT
I have been requested by D.C. to get into Bruce Pederson's word perfect. Please
copy into a directory for me what Bruce has in his word perfect.
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
ISU
Michael BrenteiNFOeRTCDENCO
Access to personal files
Wednesday, April 7, 1993 9:35:23 MOT
N
EXHIBIT
si^
PROCEDURES FOR FILE ACCESS
You may on occasion, receive requests from an RTC employee or Department head
for access to another enoloyee's personal files or subdirectory. DO NOT GRANT
OR ALLOW ANY LEVEL OF ACCESS TO THE REQUESTOR AND DO NOT VEIW ANY FILES
YOURSELF.
Inform the requestor to:
Provide a written request to Sara King or Dillard Sims. In the event that Sara
and Dillard are both unavailable, have the requestor direct the written reques;
to Kim Carlson.
Thank you
Michael
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
SubTect :
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John Waec.-.teraiSFO?RTCDE;J
Barbara .'JapieraoiG9RTCDEN
Thursday, April 8, 1993 13:02:06 MD"
Y
EXHIBIT
Sor.ething's been done.
li things don't improve or get •-
t worse, let ™e know.
209
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Dace:
Attach:
Certify:
Forvarded by:
John WaechterSIKFOeRTCDEN
Jaaes GardelieiNFOSRTCDENCO
Denver Post
Friday, April 30, 1993 10:47:23 MOT
N
EXHIBIT
Jonn,
Old you hear about the article in the Denver Post yesterday? Its about Legal
and illegal access to conpucers. I don't have a copy of the article but I'a
sure they won't be real hard to find.
You nay want to assune a low profile for the nean tiae. If anyone calls and
ask you questions refer them to Marte Swanson 556-5513.
Tried to get you but the class was already out. At least the door was close
and locked when Charlie tried to checic.
Later
Jinoo
210
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forvarded
,a*flRTCDE.NCO, John Waechter@IMFOeRTCDEN
Plaza MessenqereiHFO-12 2 5 9RTCDEN
REPUBLIC .MESSENGER§INFO-RE?eRTCDE.W
Denver Messenger?XNETeRTC0ENCO
File Cleanup
Wednesday, May 5, 1993 16:23:48 MOT
N
by:
From:
Michael BrenteiNFOeRTCDENCO
TO: All Denver Office Network Users
ISU requests all users to review their personal and group directories and
delete all unused or unwanted files. The networks are begining to experience
sluggish performance due to the large number of files being retained on each
server .
Please take a few :7iinutes and delete the unused or unwanted files in your
personal subdirectories and any E-Mails you have kept (especially those with
atcachnents) . You can print a copy of the E-mail before deleting. When deleting
files a good rule of t.hunb is: if you haven't used it in 3 monC-.s delete it:
For files you infrequently access but would like to keeo readily availacle,
you can copy or create backups onto diskettes. To reduce the tine it takes
and space needed to create these backups, there are data compression prograns
availaole that shrink files as r.uch as 90%. Please contact tne Helo Desk
(X6873) for assistance.
As a reainder to all users, every file on every server is backed up daily and
monthly. These backups are stored off-site as part of our Diaster Recovery
Plan. The daily backup tapes are rotated every' two weeks. Friday and aonth end
backup tapes are retained mdef inately . Additionally, all information used or
created as part of doing Corporation business is the property of the
Corporation. Federal agencies are required to retain "permanent cooies of all
E-rrail correspondence. Please note, RTC retains cooies of all files and E-Mail
correspondence even if a user has deleted the E-mail.
Your prompt attention is appreciated, thank you.
211
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
ISU
Janes Gardell§INFO#RTCDENCO
Staffing
Monday, May 17, 1993 11:50:27 MOT
EXHIBIT
A
2
I have staffing moves and additions to announce.
New from Anstec is Brad Crady. Brad will be perfoming network adnin duties
at Park Central. Brad comes to us fresh out of the Marines.
Welcome to RTC BRAD: '.III'.
This week Gloria Jimenez will be moving up to Republic and John Waechter
will move over to Park Central.
More about ARCO later.
Thanks ,
Jimbo
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John MaechteraiNFO?RTCDE.V
Sara King§A(iainistration3RTCDENC0
«ar< Swanson#ExecutiveiaRTCOENCO
James GardelieiNFOgRTCDENCO
Michael BrenteiNFOeRTCDENCO
re: Legal investigation
Tuesday, June 15, 1993 10:19:48 MDT
John,
apprLinatety iTooofto^conduc^ ^n'^n^^^^ "''' "^ ^rrivxng .n Denver
schedule to a^low f or%°n=°;;?^^LrtiSe";e'^!Sd"'^o^^ l^. lltllts:'''' '°^'
artPi?lL;^^;j!r^Sm^^r.n-n?!7^^!!7iir^Il^e^"f^:?^=^'^' ^^" ^- ---
m the PIN nuEoer 3794074. "^ * ^f-«- entering this number ente:
.••lichael
212
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Dace:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Pam JohnsoneLegal-Corp@RTCDEN
Gloria JimenezeiNFOeRTCDENCO
Roger M. NicolaieiNFO-1225eRTCDEN
James GardelieiNFOeRTCDENCO
SUPPORT
Wednesday, July 7, 1993 13:53:58 MDT
N
EXHIBIT
lO
Pam,
I apologize for the service getting the way it is. Indeed I was
already discussing with Gloria and Roger the need to better support
Legal before Legal brings it to ray attention. You beat me to it,
but not by much.
Starting this week I will be dedicating the services of Gloria to
your site for k day, every day. In addition to this I am getting
Gloria a portable pager so we are able to stay in touch. Roger is
still part of the solution for you. He will be on call from Gloria
to assist her during crunch times when needed and also back her up
when she is not here.
I have also asked Gloria to rework the RLIS printer configuration
that is giving you fits. It appears to be a communication problem
between t.he printer and the server room. Gloria will be swapping
out equipment to hopefully resolve this problem.
My goal is to give you quick complete service. Gloria is great at
network and user support and I think you'll be quite satisfied wit.*^
her assistance.
Let me know if this is OK.
Thank you,
Jim G.
213
To: Net Team
Cc: MB.iJL
Bcc:
From: James Garde 1 IS INFOeRTCDENCO
Subject: Weekend Coverage
Date: Tuesday, August 17, 1993 14:07:54 MDT
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by: John Waechterl#INFO-1225eRTCDEN
WEEKEND STANDBY COVERAGE
REPUBLIC PLAZA
The people at the FSC are now working extended hours on various
projects with a tight time line. In an effort to have the network
UD and available during these extended hours ISU has committed to
having WEEKEND STANDBY COVERAGE. This coverage is limited to na;)or
network problems. It does NOT cover printer toner, software support
or bad monitor. ONLY major network interruptions will be supported.
There is NO coverage on Holidays.
This coverage is for all weekends only thru November.
As stated this will be STANDBY COVERAGE. The person doing coverage
for the weekend will be available via beeper (loaner if necessary).
The support hours are from SAM to 5PM. Saturday and Sunday. Once
notified the person will Carbon Copy into the network to see if the
problem can be resolved remotely. If no*., the next seep is a visit
to the office to attempt to overcome th. problem (access key
provided if necessary) . If the problem cannot be resolved after
trying all possible solutions an attempt will be made to contact
Jim Garden" or Jon Bothwell for further instructions.
ACCESS via the ADMINLIST will be granted to those on standby
coverage.
This email is addressed to the following. These people will
volunteer for a weekend starting THIS weekend 8/21,22. First come.
First serve. All responses via email.
John Appleby
Brad Crady
Steve Duplessis
Gloria Jimenez
Bob Kaes
Roger Nicolai
Eddie O'Callaghan
New OSA
Yolanda Denton (upon returning)
Jon is making sure that all necessary reference material and
equipr.ent to initiate repairs will be available. This includes a
toolkit.
This coverage is well beyond the normal support we offer our users.
It is ISUs intention to support t.^ese extended hours pri.T.arily
because of the nature of t.'^.e projects the FSC staff has committed
ther.selvss tz .
Please respond AS.-.P so I can begin to put the schedule together.
Thanks for vour continued sucoort.
EXHIBIT
214
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Dace:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
ISU
James GardellglNFoeRTCDENCO
STAFF CHANGES
Wednesday, September 15, 1993 15:42:36 MDT
N
James GardelieiNFOeRTCDENCO
EXHIBIT
\2^
Comments by:
Forwarded to:
Comments:
James GardelieiNF09RTCDENC0
John Waechter§INFO-l225eRTCDEN
John,
The ISU list had your old address. It now has your INFO-1225
streettalk address.
Jinoo
[Original Message]
Today I have announced that starting tomorrow the following staff will be
reassigned.
Gloria is moving to the ARCO site permanently. Gloria has been taking care
of the Legal staff and now will take up residence there.
Roger is rnoving to Park Central. I have been running the day to day here
along with coordinating the gloual operation of the other sites. Roger will
now take over the day to day here lettincj ne devote full time to managing the
global concerns of the Denver sita. I tnmk this will help all of the Network
Team.
Harry is moving to 1225. With the lease at 1225 up in July '94 Harry has a
big job ahead of him in coordinating the move of this network. To where is
unknown at this time.
Thanks,
Jimbo
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John WaechtereiNFO-12259RTCDEN
Harry Mason^INFOgRTCDE.vco
Lila Renteria Willard@INFO-1225eRTCDEN
James Gardell?INFOeRTCDENCO
Reporting
Friday, September 17, 1993 12:26:54 MDT
N
John, Harry, Lila,
The daily operation of the 1225 site is a team effort between the t.hree of
you. You all have de.T.onstrated a high degree of tec.Tnical capaoilities m
solving the day to day proolems and assisting the users. Normal management
of the site is a shared responsabi lity between yourselves. When situations
arise where you need the attention of upper management please call on me for
cuidenace and answers. I will be glad to work with you on any of those issue.
Thanks,
Jir.bo
215
STATEMENT OF ROBERT M. TOBIAS
National President, National Treasury Employees Union
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee, thank you for holding this impor-
tant hearing on Whistleblowers at the Resolution Trust Corporation. As the exclu-
sive representative of Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation employees nationwide,
I am well aware of the problems facing banking employees at both the FDIC and
RTC. I am pleased to submit this written statement for the record.
First, let me begin by commending this Committee for the important changes that
it has made to the whistleblower provisions of the Federal Deposit Insurance Cor-
poration Improvement Act in the RTC Funding Bill. As a result of these proposed
changes, FDIC and RTC employees will now be protected when they report in-
stances of gross mismanagement, waste of funds, abuse of authority, or substantial
and specific dangers to public health or safety. In addition, the proposed changes
to the whistleblower provisions provide for a more equitable burden of proof for em-
ployees. These are indeed important changes which should encourage employees of
the Corporation to come forward and report waste, fraud and abuse.
I believe that two other legislative changes to the whistleblower provisions of the
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Improvement Act would enhance this legis-
lation. The first change pertains to when a banking employee will receive coverage
under the whistleblower provisions. Currently an employee receives coverage when
they have made a disclosure to any Federal banking agency or to the Attorney Gen-
eral. We believe that this is too narrow. The Whistleblower Statute, which generally
covers all employees of government agencies, excluding employees from government
corporations, protects employees' disclosures to any source. Under current law,
banking employees will not receive whistleblower protection if they disclose informa-
tion to the media or even to Congress. It makes sense to provide the same protec-
tions to banking employees as afforded to other government personnel.
The other change which we believe would encourage more banking employees to
come forward on allegations of waste, fraud and abuse pertains to attorneys fees.
Currently, a banking employee who prevails on a whistleblower allegation is not en-
titled to attorney fees. Many employees simply cannot afford to bring forth these
allegations. Moreover, other Federal employees who prevail on whistleblower allega-
tions Eire entitled to attorney fees. In this current climate of escalating legal costs,
it is important to provide a mechanism for banking employees to be reimbursed for
meritorious legal claims.
FDIC employees consistently inform us of their vulnerability concerning whistle-
blower allegations. In a survey prepared by NTEU the overwhelming majority of
Liquidation Grade (LG) employees (72 percent) responded that they would hesitate
to report incidents of waste, fraud or abuse for fear of non-renewal of their one year
appomtment. A significant portion (42 percent) of LGs are aware of incidents that
they believe might be waste, fraud or abuse in the liquidation of closed banks. We
need to provide greater security for employees at the FDIC to ensure they feel pro-
tected enough to oring whistleblower claims.
We recognize the changing times in the banking community. FDIC has plans for
a major consolidation and is downsizing its staff. The RTC will soon begin the "put
back process. During these periods of readjustments we believe it is essential that
the "new FDIC" be composed of employees who feel secure in their positions. That
security comes from a permanent workforce that is not constantly concerned with
losing its job. OPM recently revoked the Schedule A Hiring Authority for liquidation
grade employees at the FDIC. These temporary employees were charged with liq-
uidating miled banks. NTEU consistently contended that the FDIC was abusing its
hiring authority.
It is unclear what will now happen to these temporary employees. However, we
would strongly urge that these temporaiy employees positions oe replaced with per-
manent positions. A temporary workforce is simply not conducive to creating an en-
vironment were employees feel comfortable enough to bring forth concerns abuses
of the public trust in the workplace.
We look forward to working with this Committee and the FDIC on these impor-
tant issues and changes at the FDIC.
216
DONALD W WCGlC. J« MiCmiCAN CHAIRMAN
^•UL S SftHlANfS MANVLANO ALF0N5( U 0 AMATQ «fW V0«
CM»«iSTC?»-(« J 0000 CONMtCTiCUT ^Hit GAamm. TCXaS
JIM SASStA TCNNCSSEC CMmSIO^MfH S »O*t0 MtSSOUW
RlCMABO C SMllSY ALABAMA CONNIt MACK HORlOA
JOHN * •.(RBV MASSACHUSETTS L>UCH fAJHCLGTH NORTH CAR0*.INA
R-ChaRO H eRVAN NEVADA ROBERT » BENNETT UTAH
BAFBARA BOXER. CALIFORNIA Wll LIAM V ROTM JR DCLAWARt
b.s ^j.G-^THORSe CAMPBELL COLORADO MTt v OOMCNiCI NCW mCXiCO
CAROL MOStLCY 6RAUN ILLINOIS
RaFTT MuARAT WASHINGTON
lanited States Senate
COMMITTEE ON BANKING. HOUSING. AND
URBAN AFFAIRS
now/uw «. uCMai. Mrutuoui (TA>F ouucTo* WASMINOION. DC 20510-0075
September 29, 1993
The Honorable Janet Reno
Attorney General
U.S. Department of Justice
Washington, DC 20530
Dear Ms. Reno:
Last Thursday, the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and
Urban Affairs conducted a hearing on the operations of the Resolution Trust
Corporation focusing on allegations of waste, fraud and mismanagement
raised by current and former employees. Senator Metzenbaum who is not a
member of the Committee but has been very active in the oversight of the
operations of the RTC also attended the hearing. Additionally,
Congresswoman Schroeder presented testimony at the hearing.
The Committee heard stunning testimony from 13 witnesses from
across the United States, including Denver, Colorado; Atlanta, Georgia;
Dallas, Texas; Newport Beach and Costa Mesa, California; and Chicago,
Illinois. These witnesses, who testified under oath, detailed instances of
contractors overcharging the RTC or otherwise performing substandard
work with incompetent personnel; dupUcate or triplicate pajonents to
contractors by the RTC; misrepresentation of sales performance by the RTC
to Congress; RTC employees being reimbursed for personal travel expenses;
lack of diligence in the use of administrative subpoenas to investigate
potential professional liability claims, especially those involving failed Texas
institutions, likely resulting in claims not being discovered and filed;
questionable conduct by the RTC's Inspector General and sexual
discrimination by RTC managers. Additionally, several of the witnesses
testified to the retribution taken against them by RTC management for
their efforts to expose wrongdoing at the RTC.
A number of the allegations made by the RTC whistleblowers raise
the question as to whether actionable violations of law under your
217
jurisdiction may have taken place at the RTC and the RTC Inspector
General's office. These allegations include, but are not limited to,
contracting fraud, illegal steering of contracts by government personnel for
personal gain, concealment and destruction of evidence of improper or illegal
activity, retaliation against whistleblowers, and knowing provision of false
information to federal investigators and the Congress.
For your convenience, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the
hearing, a copy of the written testimony submitted by the witnesses, as well
as a copy of the videotape of the hearing for your review. Additionally, we
are providing a copy of the witness list and the telephone numbers of the
witnesses.
Given the serious nature of the allegations made under oath and the
apparent possibility of substantial recoveries for the government, we request
that the Department of Justice thoroughly review these materials in light of
applicable statutes. We request that the Department place particular
emphasis on matters handled by the fraud and public integrity sections of
the criminal division. We also believe it is important for the Department to
determine whether the potential for civil recoveries by the government may
be possible against RTC contractors who may have defrauded the
government, or provided substandard work. In addition, we request that
after you have completed this review, that you inform the Committee of any
action you deem appropriate in light of the facts provided to you and the
applicable statutes.
We appreciate your attention to this matter, and look forward to your
review of the testimony and related materials. We stand ready to meet with
you or otherwise assist you in this matter.
Sincerely,
J/
/Si!
John F. Kerry {y^ Howard M. Metzenbaum
' Member ' Chairman
Senate Committee on Senate Subcommittee on
Banking, Housing and Antitrust, Monopolies
Urban Affairs and Business Rights
//Z /yUU=^
Donald W. Riegle, JL
Chairman ^
Senate Cotnmjtte^ on
Banking, Housing and
Urban Aifairs
Enclosures
218
^AUl 5 S**»«*N*S M*flTL*NO *t«ONS* M 0*M*rO NEW YOfl"
CHHISTr^MtN J OCCO CUNNICfCUT •.l.C'»*MM ISI*S
j.M S*SStfl T(M*(:.i;t ChJ'SIGP^F* S BONO utssouw
rtlCMAKO C ShCLB* <M./.a*M» CO*-**:* fc"Ai.« 'LOBIO*
.•OMN f «(HflT W*SS*CMl-St rrS L*-C« **t«Cl.OTM NO«TM CAROLINA
(llCMA«0 M -JdYAN NtVAOfc aOoiBT » eiN«t|TT UT*M
BAASAPk 90XEM C*4.i;0KMA W^Li'MV ROTM J« OCLAWABC
BiN NIOHTHO^ISE CAUraC.L COcOtAOO P(Tc V OUMENlCl. NCW WCXICQ
c-«OLMosK(YoaALN u^No.s COMMITTEE ON BANKING. HOUSING. AND
fATTV MUAHAt. WASHINGTON
United States Senate
URBAN AFFAIRS
STCviN • MA««is sTM< omicTo" ••■o CMiF couNtu WASHINGTON DC 20510-6075
hOWMK) a. MfcNfU. MinJtLtCAM STA/f OtMCTQA
September 29, 1993
Mr. Stanley G. Tate
Tate Enterprises
1175 N.E. 125 Street
Suite 102
North Miami, Florida 33161
Dear Mr. Tate:
Last Thursday, the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and
Urban Affairs conducted a hearing on the operations of the Resolution Trust
Corporation focusing on allegations of waste, fraud and mismanagement
raised by current and former employees. Senator Metzenbaum who is not a
member of the Committee but has been very active in the oversight of the
operations of the RTC also attended the hearing. Additionally,
Congresswoman Schroeder presented testimony at the hearing.
The Committee heard stunning testimony from 13 witnesses from
across the United States including Denver, Colorado; Atlanta, Georgia;
Dallas, Texas; Newport Beach and Costa Mesa, CaUfomia; and Chicago,
Illinois. These witnesses, who testified imder oath, detailed instances of
contractors overcharging the RTC or otherwise performing substandard
work with incompetent personnel; duplicate or triplicate payments to
contractors by the RTC; misrepresentation of sales performance by the RTC
to Congress; RTC employees being reimbursed for personal travel expenses;
lack of dihgence in the use of administrative subpoenas to investigate
potential professional liability claims, especially those involving failed Texas
institutions, Ukely resulting in claims not being discovered and filed;
questionable conduct by the RTC's Inspector General and sexual
discrimination by RTC managers. Additionally, several of the witnesses
testified to the retribution taken against them by RTC management for
their efforts to expose wrongdoing at the RTC.
For your convenience, we are enclosing a copy of the transcript of the
hearing, a copy of the written testimony submitted by the witnesses, as well
as a copy of the videotape of the hearing for your review. Additionally, we
are providing a copy of the witness list and the telephone numbers of the
witnesses.
219
In light of the testimony presented to the Committee, we would urge
you to take the following actions prior to your confirmation hearing before
the Committee:
• Meet with each of the whistleblowers in person to
hear firsthand the matters presented to the
Committee and to have the opportunity to ask
questions of the whistleblowers.
• Make a commitment to assure that these and any
other whistleblowers who identify waste, fraud,
abuse or mismanagement at the RTC will not be
subject to retribution for reporting the wrongdoing.
• Undertake to thoroughly review and investigate all
of the charges and matters identified during the
September 23, 1993 hearing both as a nominee and,
if confirmed, as RTC CEO.
• Inform the Committee of what management,
personnel, or other changes you intend to implement
to make sure that the RTC is acting in the best
interests of the American taxpayer. Also, please
recommend any appropriate legislative changes that
the Congress should consider.
If there are other actions that you intend to recommend or undertake
after you have revie\yed the hearing record, please inform the Committee of
those initiatives.
. Donald W. Riegle,
/ Chairman
Senate Committee on
Banking, Housing and
Urban Affairs
, Sincerely,
/johnF. Kerry,
Member
Senate Committee on
Banking, Housing and
Urban Affairs
Howard M. Metzenbaum
Chairman
Senate Subcommittee on
Antitrust, Monopolies
and Business Rights
\
220
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION, OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
October 18, 1993
Dear Chairman Donald W. Riegle, Jr., Committee on Banking, Housing, and
Urban AfFairs: On September 23, 1993, your Committee held a hearing during
which an agent with me Office of Inspector General (OIG), Mr. Michael Koszola,
testified. Mr. Koszola made a number of allegations regarding the OIG to which this
letter responds.
Mr. Koszola, who testified at the hearing that he had little documentation to sup-
port his allegations, asserted that the OIG had investigated the Clinton family dur-
ing the presidential campaign; had sent agents to Denver to rewrite a report involv-
ing the Bush family; and had failed to investigate allegations against the former
Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC), Mr. Albert
Casey. The facts on these and other allegations he made are set forth below. I re-
spectfully request that this letter and the supporting documentation attached to it
be made part of the hearing record so that the public record on this matter is com-
plete.
Clinton Family Investigation
Mr. Koszola: "Before the Presidential election in 1992. the RTC /OIG was actively
seeking criminal or other negative information from RTC /OIG special agents on the
Clinton family."
There was no investigation of President Clinton or his family either prior to or
after the election, nor were we otherwise seeking any information about the Clinton
family. Mr. Koszola appears to be referring to an investigation we initiated following
receipt of a letter, dated November 19, 1992, from you in your capacity as Chair-
man, Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs. In your letter,
J'ou requested that my office investigate the possible misuse of RTC resources to col-
ect information about Presidential candidates. On July 9, 1993, we provided a copy
of the Report to you. (A copy of your letter and our subsequent letter to you trans-
mitting the Report of Investigation (ROD are provided as Enclosure 1.)
This investigation was initiated after the election, and focused on possible RTC
misconduct, as you requested, rather than on President Clinton or his family. We
believe this is a perfect example of Mr. Koszola's distortion of facts. Other examples
follow.
Allegation Involving the Bush Family
Mr. Koszola: ". . . top RTC /OIG officials were sent to the Denver regional IG's of-
fice in order to 'assisf other RTC /OIG special agents in writing a report of investiga-
tion involving the Bush family."
An OIG employee did go to our Denver office for the purpose of working with a
case agent to get a report rewritten. The "top" official was a desk officer (a staff
position) who traveled there during the period August 5-7, 1992, to participate in
preparing a report concerning RTC's involvement in the award of a contract for an
effort commonly known as "Western Storm;" the report had absolutely nothing to
do with the Bush family. As you know, the "Western Storm" project was the subject
of considerable Congressional interest. Following meetings we had with Congres-
sional and General Accounting Office (GAO) staf^^ we reviewed the draft report very
carefuUy to ensure that all issues were fully addressed. That ROI was submitted
to the Public Integrity Section of the Department of Justice on January 11, 1993.
Allegations Involving Former CEO Albert Casey
Mr. Koszola: "Sometime in mid-February, 1993, an anonymous male telephone call-
er stated that Patricia Patterson was buying RTC properties in Dallas as a straw
purchaser for Albert Casey. ..." Mr. Koszola testifiea that he provided this infor-
mation to his supervisor, George Sullivan, but that no investigation was initiated.
Allegations concerning Mr. Casey have been and are being investigated.
Contrary to Mr. Koszola's assertion that he told his supervisor of the matter con-
cerning Ms. Patterson and Mr. Casey, he did not. In fact, we were not aware of the
unsigned February 16, 1993, memorandum (Exhibit 4 to his testimony) until March
9, 1993, 3 weeks after it was dated.
Mr. Sullivan immediately faxed this document to OIG Headquarters, noting that
he had not received it but had inadvertently discovered it while looking in Mr.
Koszola's office for other records. Headquarters then assigned the matter to our Dal-
las office for investigation because of the geographic jurisdiction involved. That of-
221
fice's investigation commenced on March 11, 1993. We met with the Public Integrity
Section, Criminal Division, Department of Justice on March 17 to review the allega-
tion and plan the investigation.
At Public Integrity's request, we maintained control of the investigation because
Mr. Casey was no longer in charge of RTC. Since this is still an open investigation,
we cannot comment mrther, even thou^ Mr. Koszola has regrettably chosen to
bring the issue out into the public.
Ejuiibits 5 and 6 to Mr. Koszola's testimony before your Committee are further
examples of his less than candid remarks. The exhibits show that he checked with
his regional office on February 17, 1993 to determine if Patricia Patterson was in-
dexed in our system of records. The regional office responded that Ms. Patterson
was indeed indexed in our system of records for an earlier 1992 case. The case does
involve Mr. Casey and Ms. Patterson and an allegation different from the one Mr.
Koszola raised in his testimony. Because of the nature of the indexing sjrstem, any
OIG agent would know that this was an investigation opened in our Washington
Headquarters Office. Mr. Koszola should have shared his allegation with that office
to determine if the allegations were similar. This was not done.
The earlier 1992 case provides yet another example of a matter involving Mr.
Casey which was investigated. On March 31, 1992, the RTC OIG referred an allega-
tion concerning Mr. Casey to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and made
the Public Integrity Section aware of the referral on April 9, 1992. The OIG itself
did not investigate the charge because Mr. Casey was then the sitting CEO to whom
the Inspector General reports, and we wanted to avoid any appearance of a lack of
objectivity. Following the FBI investigation, the Public Integrity Section declined
prosecution on July 29, 1993, based on its determination that evidence was not
found to substantiate the allegations. Enclosure 2 contains the letters relating to
this matter.
Mr. Koszola: "Last year I received Information that Albert Casey, the former Chair-
man of the RTC, was involved in obtaining a million dollar plus contract for a com-
pany in which he had a personal and possibly financial interest. The name of the
company is First Gibraltar Realty Advisors located in Dallas and Irvine, Texas and
the contract involved the asset management of Trans Ohio S&L, a failed thrift."
According to information we received from Mr. Koszola's supervisors, they have
never been advised of these allegations. Mr. Koszola neither testified to nor provided
any written evidence that he gave such notification to his supervisors. During his
testimony, however, he provided a copy of a March 2, 1993, e-mail he sent to
Marisha Price, an RTC employee who is not in the OIG, asking for information on
First Gibraltar Realty Advisors. We never saw the e-mail before and note that no
one in the OIG was electronically provided a copy of the e-mail. This is the only
documentation to our knowledge which references First Gibraltar.
It should not escape notice that Mr. Koszola apparently chose to raise this issue
as significant during his testimony even though he acknowledges receiving the infor-
mation "last year" but apparently did not initiate investigative activity until March
2 of the following year. It is customary for an agent to reduce to writing any infor-
mation that he or she receives in the course of their work. All agent activity is to
be recorded in an Office of Investigation agent time tracking system under a case
or complaint number utilizing various work categories. Mr. Koszola did not charge
any time to such a complaint or case.
As a result of Mr. Koszola's testimony regarding First Gibraltar, my office has ini-
tiated an investigation.
Other Allegations
Mr. Koszola testified that he overheard Lew Sherman and Clark Blight "making
jokes" about shredding documents "all weekend" with the help of several other special
agents who later received "letters of exemplary service" for their activities. The case
referenced is the Jacobs matter.
Neither Mr. Blight nor Mr. Sherman nor anyone else spent all weekend shredding
documents relating to the Jacobs' case (or any other matter). The documents alleg-
edly "shredded" in the Jacobs' case are presently in our file room in Headquarters
and our Denver Office, which controlled the investigation and retains our official
file. These documents (thousands of pages) are available for your review.
During the Jacobs' investigation, we became aware of the existence of more than
30 boxes of records in RTC's Phoenix office. Because these boxes may have con-
tained information or evidence concerning the matters under investigation in the
Jacobs' case, we had agents travel to Phoenix to review the material in the boxes.
In order to quickly accomplish this, the agents worked through a weekend and we
76-818 0-94-8
222
recognized their extra efibrts with letters of appreciation. Mr. Koszola was asked to
draft the letters, and it was those drafts whioi he submitted with his testimony as
evidence that these agents were shredding documents all weekend in Washington.
To the contrary, these agents were working all weekend in Plioenix reviewing, not
shredding, documents. In fact two of the agents who received the letters have never
been to our Headquarters oflice and the third served on a rotational assignment
after the alleged shredding occurred.
Lastly, Mr. Koszola alleges that Messrs. Bli^t and Sherman joked about shred-
ding documents relating to the Jacobs' investigation. This allegation apparently
stems from the circumstances surrounding a rumor that a media reporter was in-
quiring about such shredding activities. The rumor was so absuni that Messrs.
Bli^t and Sherman laughed about it in the presence of Mr. Koszola, who appears
to have taken it seriously.
With regard to the shredder, itself, Mr. Koszola accurately reported that there
was a shredder in his oflice when he arrived the morning of August 24. Tiiis was
not a "borrowed" shredder but is one we own and which is normally stored in the
copier room. Shredding takes place during normal duty hours in the normal course
of business. We do not place material, such as old drafts or duplicate copies, in a
regular waste receptacle because it would be too easy for the documents to be im-
Eroperly removed. As the waste builds up, we periodically shred it. This material
ad been placed in the temporarily vacant oflice that was subsequently occupied by
Mr. Koszola on August 24 and had been shredded there the prior week. The shred-
der was returned to storage when Mr. Koszola occupied the vacant office.
Mr. Koszola: ". . . / found that whistleblowers at the RTC who brought matters
to the attention of the IG did not receive whistlehlower protection . . . I was specifi-
cally instructed by my supervisors . . . to avoid giving confidentiality to sources."
We cannot respond specifically because Mr. Koszola did not mention anyone fit-
ting that category during his testimony. In order to properly respond to this issue,
we will need more specific information. However, we nave always oeen and continue
to be aware of our responsibilities to protect the identities of employees who come
to our oflice with information, and have policies and procedures in place to do so.
The OIG automatically grants confidentiality to employees who furnish informa-
tion during investigations. As directed by the IG Act, tne identity of such employees
is not divulged unless it becomes inevitable during the course of the investigation
(see OIG Manual Chapter 110.3 Confidential Sources. Enclosure 3). However, au-
thority to protect whistleblowers is by statute given to the Oflice of Special Counsel
under the Whistlehlower Protection Act, not to Inspectors General. We have sup-
ported amending the Act to extend application to tne RTC, but Congress has not
done that.
Mr. Koszola was not told to avoid granting confidentiality. Instead, his super-
visors noted that almost all of the allegations he received seemed to come from 'Hin-
known sources." By their very nature, such sources cannot be contacted for addi-
tional information and their credibility cannot be established if questioned. For this
resison, Mr. Sherry, his second-line supervisor, believes he discussed this with Mr.
Koszola to encourage him to attempt to establish the identity of sources, even on
a confidential basis, to facilitate the investigation of allegations.
Mr. Koszola: ". . . agents at the RTC /OIG were instructed to rewrite reports they
had written . . . reports were altered in order to avoid potentially embarrassing or
politically sensitive disclosures." and he was "told by Clark Blight . . . that it was
the function of the Headquarters RTC I OIG to revise reports . . . to make sure thefyj
. . . looked favorable to Congress."
Agents are instructed to rewrite reports if they are incomplete or poorly written,
but not to avoid potentially embarrassing or politically sensitive disclosures. Mr.
Koszola provides no specific examples of such alterations, and I am unaware of any
such incidents.
Our policy on ROIs is found in OIG Manual Chapter 320.1 Preparation, Review
and Issuance of Reports of Investigation (Enclosure 4) and contains the procedures
we have established for review of reports by Regional Inspectors (Jeneral for Inves-
tigation (RIGI). Mr. Koszola's supervisors, Mr. Sullivan and Mr. Sheny, are un-
aware of any reports, including reports prepared by Mr. Koszola, which were altered
to avoid potentially embarrassing or politically sensitive disclosures.
With respect to Headquarters reviews of reports, the aforementioned policy on
ROIs provides that, except for certain significant cases, the ROIs will be submitted
to Headquarters concurrently with their issuance by the RIGIs to the Department
of Justice or RTC management. Hence, most reports are not received in OIG Head-
quarters until after they have been issued. As indicated in the policy, certain re-
223
ports, especially those which we know have Congressional interest or implications
at the national level, are reviewed at the Headquarters level prior to issuance to
ensure that they fully address the allegations and that they are written in a profes-
sional manner. If the reports do not meet these standards, they are returned to the
field for additional review and/or work. I would note, however, that fewer than 10
percent of the almost 400 ROIs issued by our Regional Oflices since the establish-
ment of the OIG have been subjected to such Headquarters review.
Mr. Koszola cites a specific example in which he alleges that Mr. Blight was in
the process of "revising one such report to Congressman Gonzalez . . . and that
he "would highlight areas of reports that were already approved and request that
the report be revised, rewritten, or changed to reflect a more favorable outcome."
During the period of time Mr. Koszola was in Headquarters on rotational detail
from August 24 throurfi September 11, 1992, we did provide investigative material
on the case involving Gerald Jacobs, former RTC General Counsel, to Congressman
Gonzalez. Our ROI had been issued on August 13, 1992, before Mr. Koszola s arrival
at Headquarters. Mr. Casey had sent the ROI to Congressman Gonzalez on August
20, and Congressman Gonzalez also asked for our case file. The "report to Congress-
man Gonzalez" to which Mr. Koszola referred was in fact a simple transmittal letter
sending unaltered case material relating to the previously issued ROI to Congress-
man Gonzalez. (See Enclosure 5.)
Mr. Koszola testified that RTC /OIG generated false case numbers to mislead Con-
gress by making it appear we were doing more than in actuality.
This statement is not correct. In rare instances, we have received allegations con-
cerning the same individual or group of individuals in more than one region and
complaint or investigative case mes are opened in each region. When appropriate,
such cases are consolidated into one case. This is not an attempt to inflate case sta-
tistics; rather, it is indicative of our comprehensive system for tracking allegations
and complaints received.
Mr. Koszola testified that OIG agents were told not to tell the truth to GAO;
Koszola was also told not to provide information to GAO concerning RTC employees
with criminal histories.
Neither Mr. Koszola nor any other OIG employee was ever told not to tell the
truth to GAO. To the contrary, the policy of this office is reflected in a July 1993,
communique where I specifically requested that all OIG employees cooperate with
GAO (see Enclosure 6).
It appears that Mr. Koszola is referringto an investigation where he was the ini-
tial case agent, but was later replaced. The investigation involved an employee of
an RTC contractor who had a criminal history. The criminal history was not discov-
ered by the contractor or RTC before the emoloyee began working on RTC matters.
Information concerning the person's history oecame publicly known and media in-
terest developed. Sometime after Mr. Koszola was replaced on the investigation, our
Chicago office received a telephone call from a person who identified himself as a
GAO mvestigator located in New Yorit. Our oflice was concerned that information
concerning the investigation might be improperly disclosed; therefore, the Chicago
office was told to direct the caller to the Assistant Inspector General for Investiga-
tion, Claris Bli^t, for further information. The individual did not subsequently con-
tact Mr. Blight.
Mr. Koszola alleged that thefts of RTC computer equipment were common in every
RTC office and estimated that RTC has lost over $1 million nationwide. Further,
"The RTC /OIG did not actively investigate the theft [of teleconferencing equipment
worth over $50,000] and delegated the investigation to the local police department."
Fm not sure what information Mr. Koszola used to base his estimate of $1 million
in computer thefts. We have opened eight investigations which concern the theft of
RTC computers, computer suipplies, or similar equipment. Three of the eight were
opened by our Kansas City office, the office to which Mr. Koszola ultimately reports.
Although it is difficult to place a monetary value on the equinment alleged to have
been stolen in these cases, it is well below $100,000. If Mr. Koszola has specific in-
formation supporting his belief in a more endemic problem, we would certainly be
interested in learning of it.
The theft of telecommunications equipment was brought to the attention of our
Chicago office on June 2, 1992. Based upon the information initially received, that
office determined that investigation of the theft properly belonged with the local po-
lice department, which typically has more resources for investigating theft of prop-
erty matters. The local police department opened an investigation and conducted
several interviews, but has not yet identifiea the responsible party. The investiga-
tion still remains an open matter with the local authorities.
224
Mr. Koszola testified that he made both written and oral presentations to his su-
pervisors to implement internal controls to deter thefts, but that he was rebuffed and
no such controls were ever implemented.
We are not aware of oral presentations made by Mr. Koszola detailing specific in-
ternal recommendations. Enclosure 7 does relate to what might be considered a
written presentation. Mr. Koszola does not mention any specific internal control rec-
ommencuttions but did offer to develop some. Neither of his supervisors followed up
on this offer. In retrospect, we probably should have providea him with more en-
couragement to do so.
Mr. Koszola testified that "after one of RTC's contractors pled guilty for theft of
RTC properties, I worked up the financial data on other areas of possible theft of
taxpayer assets by this company and asked the Regional IG to do an audit. Despite
the clearpotentidl for additional recoveries. Regional refused to do ^e audit."
The "KTC contractoi^ was actually an employee of a thrift institution, who di-
verted funds from a servicing account to a checking account for his own use. Mr.
Koszola prepared two memoranda for the signature of RIGI Sherry requesting audit
assistance but both were devoid of a Vork up [of] financial data" as he claims, and
referred to open rather than closed investigations, as he implies.
The requests for assistance were not rejected by Mr. Koszola's supervisors; how-
ever, they did request more information, including an evaluation of the reasons why
this matter should not be handled by investigators as a part of the open investiga-
tion, before referring the requests to the audit staff (see Enclosure 8). Mr. Koszola
did not supply the reouested information and it was assumed by his supervisors
that he no longer neeaed the assistance. In any event, Mr. Koszola did not make
an issue of it at the time. Requesting audit assistance is not unusual and is encour-
aged when that type of expertise can be used to further an investigation. Any such
requests need to be evaluated, however, in order to determine the amount and ex-
tent of required assistance and the priority with which it should be pursued.
Mr. Koszola testified that he tried to investigate 'reports of overbilling and sleeping
on the job by employees of another RTC contractor. Coopers & Lybrandf that he
"saw accountants sitting and reading non-government literature and being paid for
it by the RTC." He also asserts that his supervisor failed to initiate any action when
this was brought to his attention.
This matter was brought to Mr. Koszola's attention by an RTC employee, who wit-
nessed the problem. Foflowing preliminary review, Mr. Koszola provided verbal as-
surances to his supervisor that the issue had been addressed by RTC officials and
managers of Coopers & Lybrand, and the matter was closed.
The "sit and read" matter was subsequently referred to in media reports and as
a result we commenced an investigation on April 6, 1993. A Report was issued on
July 27, 1993. The investigation disclosed that two temportiry copy machine opera-
tors (not accountants) had oeen observed to occasionally have "down time" between
copying assignments. Additionally, the investigation disclosed that the employees
had. been released from employment and that RTC and Coopers & Lybrand had
taken reasonable steps to prevent further occurrences. Since this report hM Privacy
Act issues, we are not providing a copy as an enclosure to this letter at this tiipe;
however, we will provide a copy on request.
Mr. Koszola: "/ regularly see [legal] bills being paid by RTC without any docu-
mentation verifying that services had been performed."
From its inception, the RTC has used the services of a number of law finns for
suing directors and officers of former savings and loan institutions and to initiate
other legal actions relating to assets taken over from failed institutions. When RTC
was formed, its legal personnel reported to the General Counsel of the Federd De-
posit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), and FDIC's accounts payable system was used
to pay legal fee bills. These bills were paid after a fee bill technician reviewed the
bills. However, due to the enormous volume, the processing of payments slowed,
thus generating complaints fiiom law firms and others about the delays.
To address this problem, FDIC and RTC implemented an Accelerated Payment
Program. Under this program, the law firms provided certification that the bills
they were submitting had not been paid. Based on that certification, the bills were
paid without a review by the fee bill tedinician. Unfortunately, this program also
resulted in duplicate payments to several law firms. During the time the Acceler-
ated Payment Program was in effect, RTC was developing KTC's Legal Information
System (RLIS) to track legal matters, case budgets, and bilhng information. RTC
has now implemented the RLIS system which replaced the Accelerated Payment
Program. Now RTC's procedures require fee bill reviews before pajnment. All of these
facts have been reported in our Audit work (see Enclosure 9).
225
The OIG, using its own stafT, has completed or is in the process of completing au-
dits of eight law firms. In addition, the OIG has contracted with Independent Foiblic
Accounting firms (IPAs) to conduct audits of 50 additional law firms. The OIG is
also in the process of contracting with IPAs to conduct audits of another 50 law
firms. OIG audits of law firms entail reviewing the charaes for propriety, accuracy,
conformity with the contract terms, and refisonableness. In certain cases, our audits
disclosed that law firms have charged (1) higher rates than allowed in the contract,
(2) time without adequate support, (3) excessive time for legal research, (4) for em-
ployees not allowed in the contract, and (5) expenses in excess of what is allowed
m the contract or without adequate support. These matters are reported to manage-
ment for recoupment of overpayments.
Mr. Koszola testified that he had investigated allegations of false hilling by a law
firm; that, after "months of being stonewalled," by RTC's Professional Liability Sec-
tion (PLS), he had obtained a grand jury subpoena to get the documents; and that
the "RTC/OIG attempted to stop the subpoena from being served because it was too
embarrassing to subpoena the RTC IPLS according to RTC lOlG managers."
Mr. Koszola is inaccurate in his characterization of this investigation. He was as-
signed this matter on January 21, 1993. On February 8, 1993, Mr. Koszola con-
tacted Julie F. Yanda, RTC/PlS Chief, Kansas City, Kansas, and requested that all
fee bills be gathered and forwarded to him for three law firms.
This was a monumental task, as the records were located in various geographical
offices, and Ms. Yanda was keeping Mr. Koszola apprised of her efforts to obtain
the requested documents. Even so, on February 10, Mr. Koszola told Ms. Yanda he
thought she was "stonewalling" him. On February 22, 1993, Mr. Koszola faxed to
an Assistant United States Attorney (AUSA) a list of documents he wanted to re-
ceive under grand jury subpwena. Trie subpoena was served on approximately Feb-
ruary 24. On approximately March 15, 1993, Mr. Koszola received the subpoenaed
documents from Ms. Yanda s oflice.
Mr. Koszola was not "stonewalled" for months. Ms. Yanda was attempting to com-
ply with his request and was in frequent contact with him as to its status. His ini-
tial reauest for documents was voluminous. Even after the quantity of material re-
quested was pared down, Ms. Yanda's office still had to copy over 12,700 pages of
material to comply with the subpoena. With respect to timing, Mr. Koszola unUater-
ally sought the subpoena from the AUSA and the subpoena was issued and served
less than two and one-half weeks after he initially contacted Ms. Yanda.
In order to better understand the sequence of events on this matter, we have pro-
vided as Enclosure 10 a Report of Interview of Ms. Yanda which was taken on May
12, 1993. Also included in tne same Enclosure is a June 2, 1993, memorandum from
Mr. Sullivan to Mr. Sherry wherein Mr. Sullivan outlines his concerns about the is-
suance of the grand mry subpoena. The memorandum references a conversation
with Mr. KoszoFa which occurred after issuance of the subpoena and did not attempt
to thwart it.
There was also no need for Mr. Koszola to request the documents from RTC under
grand jury subpoena. The OIG has a right to gain access to virtually any record
maintained by KTC or its contractors during the course of our audits and investiga-
tions. Documents so obtained may be used in criminal, civil or administrative pro-
ceedings. By contrast, the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure (Rule 6(e)) place
strict limits which prohibit disclosure of material obtained in grand jury proceed-
ings. If prosecution is declined, documents obtained under a grand jury subpoena
generally cannot be used in noncriminal proceedings. The OIG wants to maintain
the ability to freely use evidence gathered in an investigation either civilly or ad-
ministratively should prosecution be declined. These valid reasons for preferring not
to use a grand jury subp>oena to obtain documents are well illustrated in this case:
prosecution has been declined. We now face Rule 6(e) limitations on use of docu-
ments, which were unnecessarily made a part of grand Jury proceedings, should the
Corporation wish to pursue civil or administrative remedies in this matter.
Mr. Koszola: "The chief of the legal section was involved with one law firm that
was awarded $3 million in fees. One contract that he was in the process of awarding
was $250,000. Two days after that contract was awarded, he began employment ne-
gotiations with the firm. "
This refers to the same investigation discussed in the previous section wherein
Mr. Koszola claims the RTC OIG attempted to stop a subpoena from being served.
As with the previous example, his information is not accurate and is misleading. We
discussed this matter with the same AUSA who issued the grand jury subpoena. He
advised us that, upon receipt of the subpoenaed documents, ne, met with Mr.
Koszola on March 19, 1993, to review the information. At that time, the AUSA indi-
226
cated to Mr. Koszola that there appeared to be "no case," meaning that the allega-
tions of criminal misconduct were not supported. It appears that Mr. Koszola knew
or should have known that the above statement about the chief of the legal section
was inaccurate at the time of his testimony.
Mr. Koszola testified that at the same time the OIG was ignorina major fraud
cases, it was "vigorously investigating an employee who was recyclingRTC trash and
using the money he received to buy coffee and doughnuts for other RTC employees."
The complaint referenced here was received on July 14, 1992. Mr. Koszola con-
ducted three telephonic interviews from August 4-5 and wrote up the results of his
activity on August 7. His review disclosed tJiere was no merit to opening an inves-
tigation and the complaint was closed. This was not a "vigorous investigation."
Mr. Koszola testified that he 'saw an IG's office that would insist that agents pur-
sue small [cases], like time and attendance cases of RTC employees. It was safer to
investigate penny ante matters and to find a lower-level worker who you could show
was a few hours off on his hours than to respond to the much more significant cases
of waste, fraud, abuse and wrongdoing involving millions of dollars."
As of September 18, 1993, we have opened more than 700 investigative cases. Of
those cases, only 10 — slightly more than 1 percent — have been opened on time and
attendance violations. In the meantime, our aeents have been involved in cases that
resulted in the indictment of approximately 100 individuals, the conviction to date
of 71, and millions in fines, restitution, and monetary recoveries. This has all been
accomplished by an organization that literally did not exist until early 1990.
Mr. Koszola testified that he was ordered by his supervisor to "discontinue any con-
tact with the Senate Banking Committee."
Mr. Sullivan states that at no time did he ever tell Mr. Koszola to discontinue
contact with the Senate Banking Committee. According to Mr. Sullivan, he has no
knowledge of when, with whom, or what discussions, iT any, Mr. Koszola had with
members of the Senate Banking Committee or their staffs.
Mr. Koszola testified that, since being placed on administrative leave, he has re-
ceived at least 10 threatening phone cal^.
Mr. Koszola seems to imply that the OIG is somehow responsible for the phone
calls. We did not make any harassing calls to him.
Exhibits
Mthough Mr. Koszola did not make this an issue during his testimony, he did in-
clude as Exhibit 10 to his prepared statement an unsigned March 15, 1993, memo-
randum to his supervisor concerning the removal and searching of records from his
ofilce. We believe that, since it was mcluded, it needs to be adoressed. Mr. Sullivan
reports that on March 9, 1993, Mr. Koszola was on sick leave. Mr. Sullivan was
looking for a document related to the "sit and read" issue discussed elsewhere in
this letter. While looking for that document, Mr. Sullivan came upon a box of
records which pertained to a case from which Mr. Koszola had been reassigned. Mr.
Koszola had earlier been directed to turn over all documents and records in his pos-
session concerning this investigation, so Mr. Sullivan took the box to give to the
case agent nresently assigned the investigation. When transferring those docu-
ments, Mr. Sullivan noticed that the box had other files, as well, which he then re-
turned to Mr. Koszola.
Administrative Leave
Mr. Koszola: He was locked out from work for the past several months.
Mr. Koszola has been placed on administrative leave. This matter was raised at
the hearing, with the implication that this may have been some form of retaliation
or harassment. In fact, as he well knows, Mr. Koszola is not on administrative leave
for any reason related to retaliation or harassment. Although Mr. Koszola has
raised this issue, privacy considerations prevent us from discussing it further at this
time without Mr. Koszola's consent or a request from the Committee. We stand
ready to respond to such a request and provide the additional information which
will assist the Committee in determining the veracity of this witness and his testi-
mony.
Other Issues
At the conclusion of the hearing on September 23, 1993, Mr. Koszola stated, "I
tried to refinance my house about six weeks ago and the RTC and the FDIC have
227
still refused, after several written reouests and oral requests, to verify that I have
been employed with them . . . And tney are interfering with a credit union where
I already have an account to get a lower interest rate."
228
0OMM.O w AKC*.! JO ««Cmk;*M C*UUllii*»
f*4K S SAJitAMf* MAirrUANO AlfQNSI M 0 AMAFO MMf vO««
CMMSTOMtfll J OOOO COWN(CTK:u» ^"^ QKAMU Tf«A$
M>N J OilON HUHOfS CM«STO#«l« » iO^O WI«SOU«
JMi SASSIN TINMSSet CO*<N.« M*C« »L0«0*
TlMPr SA«*0«0 <K>«T*« CAAOUMA WKiJAM V SOTX J* MOWAM
MCHAIIO C SMtLtT AUk«AMA ^TI V OOMfN^I WCW UCUCO
•Ot CHAHAM KO«iOA •»**<* LA«00» CASSCBAUM IAMSAS
:^r.',.r"Jls'^'S:J^. *~" '""'* '««'^''"- committee on banking, housing, and
MCKAM > ••»»« «vAo. URBAN AFFAIRS
lanitd States 3tnatE
sTfvta I M^Mif STAM o««<toa •>« OM> coumn.
uuua swrn M»u«.ic«>. sta« o««to« «Mi ccoMoiMi WASHINGTON. DC 205 1 0-607S
November 19, 1992
Hon. John J. Adair
RTC Inspector General
1735 North Lynn St.
Rosslyn, VA 22206
Mr. Robert D. Hoffinan
FDIC Inspector General
550 17th Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20429
Dear Inspector Generals Adair and Hoffinan:
The Washington Post on November 10, 1992, in a story which I enclose for
your review, reports that Ross Perot charged that Bush administration
officials had violated his privacy by culling information from his Navy
records as well as records with the Resolution Trust Corporation and the
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Earlier this year, a Houston
Chronicle story, which I also enclose for yoxir review, indicated that there
may have been a misuse of government resources, including by the RTC, to
collect information about Ross Perot.
Although there may prove to be benign explanations for both of these press
reports, I am deeply concerned that government resources may have been
utilized in a maimer that is inconsistent with the mission of the RTC and
the FDIC. While the press accounts are limited to potential problems
identified by independent candidate, Ross Perot, I would be interested to
know whether any other presidential candidates. Democratic, Republican or
Independent aspirants, were also subject to any scrutiny by the RTC or
FDIC.
Accordingly, I am asking each of you to report back to the Senate Banking
Committee within 3 months from the date of this letter with complete
229
accounts as to whether during the course of the presidential election year
there had been scrutiny by the RTC or FDIC of any potential candidate for
the office of the Presidency. Also, I would like a ftill explanation of the
allegations that are raised in the articles which I am enclosing for your
review.
SinccBely,
cc: Albert Casey, RTC CEO
Andrew Hove, FDIC Acting Chairman
4
NOV 1332
'-1 c /C--'-'"
o
1 1
1/
230
OFFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
July 9. 1993
The Honorable Donald W. Riegle, Jr.
Chairman, Committee on Banldng, Housing
and Urtan Atfain
United States Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510-6075
Dear Chairman Riegle:
You asked us to determine whether any presidential candidates were subject to
any scrutiny by the RTC. Your request followed a newspaper article published in
The Washingion Post on November 10, 1992. In that article, H. Ross Perot
charged that Bush administration officials had violated his privacy by culling
information from records at RTC, as well as two other agencies.
A copy of our Repon of Investigation and memorandum dated May 7, 1993 to
Roger C. Altman, Acting President and CEO, are e.iclosed for your informaiion.
Our investigation found that the Director. Office of Corporate Communications
(OCC), and two members of his staff, received inquiries from representatives of
the news media requesting information relative to the purchase of RTC assets by
Mr. Perot or his related companies. The Director instructed a member of his
staff to contact a Texas staff person to obtain the information. It appears that
only previous press releases detailing the sale of assets to H. Ross Perot, Jr. were
released. The stai'f also received an inquiry from the news media regarding asset
sales to President Bush, and no information was found. In addition, OCC was
queried by the media concerning Hillary Rodham Clinton, and a copy of the
Legal Services Agreement (a public document) between RTC and Rodham
Clinton's law rlrm may have been released to the news media.
Additionally, OCC received an inquiry from the news .media peraining to the
rent payments by a tenant in a property once owned by RTC. OCC presumed
that this request related to President Clinton. This inquiry was coorcinated with
the iwif of the F.-eecom of Information iFOI.^)/Pnvacy Act B.-anc.i, Office of -Jr.i
Secretary-, wno mstracied OCC .not to release My information regardi.'.g
individual tenants, and to inform the news meaia they would have to r"ile a FOL^
231
request to obtain the information. Prior to that instruction, the OCC continued to
seek the information to respond to the news media inquiry. The OCC did
vertjally obtain the information sought, but did not release any information to the
news media since they were told that a FOLA request was needed. The RTC
refused to confirm or deny the existence of such records in response to a
subsequent FOIA request.
It is our opinion that concerns about individual privacy were evident at the onset
of the tenant inquiries. It should also have been apparent that a tenant's personal
rental records were not publicly available information, which is the only
information OCC is authorized to release. Therefore, no attempts should have
been made by OCC to obtain the requested information, and the requester should
have been immediately directed to the FOIA/Privacy Act (PA) office.
We have also enclosed a copy of a Disposition Report, signed by Mr. AJtman, in
which he indicated his action on this case. Mr. Altman wrote Dennis F. Geer,
Vice President, Division of Administration and Corporate Relations, on July 1,
1993, directing that he review the OCC's methods of processing inquiries and
develop written internal prcx»lures to ensure compliance with stanjtory and
corporate mandates concerning release of information. We have also enclosed a
copy of Mr. Altman's memorandum to Mr. Geer.
Please call me on (703) 908-7801 if you should have any questions.
Sincerely yours.
CUoMv
John J. i4dair
Inspector General
Enclosures
232
Level 1—1 of 1 Story
Copyri^t 1992 The Houston Chronicle Publishing Company The Houston Chronicle
June 26, 1992, Friday, 2, STAR Edition
Section: A; Pg. 22
Lenctth: 357 words
Headline: Aiding in Perot probe was "routine," RTC says
Byune: ALAN BERNSTEIN, Houston Chronicle Political Writer; Staff
Keyword: Elections Presidential
Body: The Federal Government's Resolution Trust Corp. routinely searched its
Texas files for information on its own deals with Ross Perot in response to a report-
er's question, an RTC spokeswoman says.
The records search, completed this month, showed that the RTC's only trans-
actions with the likely independent presidential candidate took place last year and
were described in government news releases at the time, spokeswoman Sue Brown
said Thursday.
Brown said the internal examination of RTC files was conducted in response to
a Washington reporter's question about RTC dealings with the Dallas billionaire.
There was nothing unusual about the records search. Brown said. The agency,
which oversees the assets of faUed financial institutions, would answer such inquir-
ies about any landowner in about two weeks, she said.
Perot has charged that the Republican Party is conducting a "dirty tricks" cam-
paign against him that includes examining his late mother's will and other public
documents.
An anonymous caller identifying himself as an RTC employee and Perot supporter
told the Cnronicle this week that the RTC was "using government resources to try
and dig up dirt about Ross Perot."
But the RTC spokeswoman said the inquiry was limited to the RTC's own records
and was initiatea only to answer the reporter's question. "We were just responding
to a basic press inquiry," she said.
Perot's maverick candidacy has triggered widespread investigation into his back-
f'ound and business record by the nation's news media. Perot alleges that President
ush's campaign has joined tiie effort with "opposition research" and has purposely
distorted his record.
Certain Federal Government files are available to reporters and others through
formal requests made under the Freedom of Information Act.
But Brown said the R'TC regularly responds to less formal requests such as the
one that triggered the examination oi files about Perot.
Last year, Perot companies purchased millions of dollars worth of Dallas-area
land that had been owned by financial institutions now under RTC control.
233
Cf)
CO
|S5
%M
"^IJ^'I
8 s SI'
:2 3 ^ 3
ii
lO S.CU
IPI- ^■
lllil "
el
51
'2 E
234
o
o
Ph
8^-
2
1
miiu^
•^ Uw
l|
8 5 C 3-4 9 8
^
5| |2*^^P||| ^Jlsl!
235
of his diughten with a doctored
photognph, disrupt oer weddmc
and wiretap his btttincM o£5ce.
When first told of the passport
seardi festerday. Perot said: If I
said aajrthinc about it, everybody
would say Pm a paranoid investiga-
tor, wouldn't they? For all I know,
that's woat this is for — to cet me to
mak^a camment.*
He called the seardi of his pass-
port files Veird.' adding: 1 can't
think of anything duQer than my
passport reoords.'
In the interview, Perot also
charged that Bush administratioa
officials had violated his privacy by
culling iofonnatioo from his Navy
reoords as wdl as reoords with the
Resohitioo Trust Gxp. and Federal
Deposit Insuraoce Corp.
When the Sate Department's
seardi for records oa Qintoa was
disclosed last mooth, department
ofTidals said it was «*i^,|^)j(| ^
response to three FOIA reqoests
from news organtxatiaas i^i-inHi^
infonnatjoo on the DeoMcratic
presidential oominee receired ki
September. But department offi-
cials later acknowledged those re-
quesu had been improperly expe-
dited.
This prompted the Natioa mag^
azine to file a suit over the depart-
ment's failare to process an FOIA
request filed by one of the maga-
zine's editon three months earfi-
er — on June 22 — for material on
Perot. In an af6davit filed in re-
sponse to the suit on OcL 19. Frank
M. Machak. the department's kh
fomution and privacy coordinator,
made no mentioa of the OcL L3
seardi by McQerey for records on
PeroL
V.
/\.
f.J
,.3
236
Hosolution Trust Corporation
March 31, 1992
Mr. Robert M. Bryant
Special Agent in Charge
Washington Metropolitan Field Office
Federal Bureau of Investigation
1900 Half Street SW
Washington, DC 20535
Subject: Albert V. Casey (Chief Executive Officer)
Resolution Trust Corporation
Washington DC
Patricia M. Patterson (Borrower)
Dallas, Texas
Our file: WA-92-0012
Dear Mr. Bryant:
We have received an allegation involving Albert V. Casey, Chief
Executive Officer, Resolution Trust Corporation. The allegation
involves a potential violation of 18 USC 1014 and 2. Since Mr.
Casey is a Presidential appointee and the head of this agency, we
are forwarding the matter to you.
The allegation was received through our Hotline on March 27, 1992.
The enclosed "Record of RTC OIG Hotline Call" documents the
allegation. An anonymous caller alleged that Mr. Casey telephoned
Hugh McColl, President, NCNB (now Nations Bank) to use his position
to influence the treatment of a foreclosure on a loan to Patricia
M. Patterson, who is purportedly Mr. Casey's "girlfriend." The
caller alleged that Ms. Patterson's loan was restructured, saving
her $500,000. The caller alleged that Ms. Patterson has
significant assets which were "covered-up" in restructuring this
loan. In addition, it is alleged that forgiveness of the debt was
not reported to the IRS.
The Patterson loan appears to have been renegotiated through
AMRESCO, an NCNB subsidiary which handles the institution's bad
assets. AMRESCO is an RTC contractor.
1736 rtorth Lyrwi Street ■ Ro«^/n. Vlrgrio 22209
237
Mr. Robert M. Bryant
Page Two
March 31, 1992
We request that you advise us of the results of your inquiry.
Please call me on (703)908-7860, if you have any questions or need
assistance.
Sincerely,
Clark W. Blight \
Assistant Inspector General
for Investigation
238
Resolution Trust Corporation
April 9, 1992
Mr. WilUam A. Keefer
Acting Chief
Public Integrity Section
Department of Justice
P.O. Box 27321, Central Station
Washington, D.C. 20038
Dear Mr. Keefer:
We have received an allegation involving Albert V. Casey, Chief Executive Officer,
Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC). This letter is to advise you of this matter, since Mr.
Casey is a Presidential appointee and head of this agency.
In view of Mr. Casey's status, we forwarded the matter to the Federal Bureau of
Investigation (FBI), Washington Metropolitan Field Office. Enclosed is a copy of our
correspondence with the FBI.
Should you or members of your staff have any questions, please call me on (703) 908-7860.
Sincerely,
Clark W. Blight
Assistant Inspector General
for Investigation
Enclosure
cc: Mr. Robert M. Bryant
Federal Bureau of Investigation
1735 r-lcfth Lynn Street ■ Rossf/n. Virginia 22209
239
U. S. Departmcut of Justice
Washinpon, D.C 20S30
JUL 2 9 1993
Mr. Clark w. Blight
Assistant Inspector General
for Investigation
Office of Inspector General
Resolution Trust Corporation
173 5 North Lynn Street
Rosslyn, Virginia 22209
Dear Mr. Blight:
You referred to the Public Integrity Section anonymous
allegations concerning Albert V. Casey, the former Chief Executive
Officer of the Resolution Trust Corporation and Patricia Patterson,
a Texas businesswoman who is Casey's companion. These allegations
centered on Casey's use of his influence to secure a loan
renegotiation for Patterson.
We are closing this matter because investigation has failed to
substantiate the allegations. Should your office become aware of
further information relevant to the investigation, please feel free
to refer that information to us as well.
Thank you for your assistance with this matter.
Sincerely,
; Joseph E. Gangloff
lActing Chief
Public Integrity Section
Criminal Division
cc: Special Agent Janis Famous
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Thomas F. Cusick
Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
240
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION, OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
Policies and Procedures Manual
Part: I. Operations Policies and Procedures.
Section: OIG-130 General Management Policies and Procedures.
Chapter: 110.3 Confidential Sources.
1. Purpose. To provide policy and guidance on Oflice of Inspector General (OIG) Con-
fidential Sources (CS) and relating confidential documents.
2. Definitions
a. Confidential Source. Any person who provides information to the OIG on a con-
fidential basis.
b. Complainant. Any person who makes a complaint to the OIG concerning the
gossible existence of fraud, waste, or mismanagement affecting the Resolution Trust
iorporation's (RTC) programs and operations. There are three types of complain-
ants.
(1) Employee Complainant. Any RTC employee who makes a complaint to the
OIG.
(2) Public Complainant. Any person who is not an RTC employee who makes
a complaint to the OIG.
(3) Anonymous Complainant. A person who makes a complaint without disclos-
ing his/her identity.
c. Witness. Any individual, including an RTC employee, who provides information
or evidence; who testifies or is asked to be present at a transaction to testily to its
having taken place; or who has personal knowledge of something as evidence or
proof.
d. Contact. Generally, the Contact is the OIG staff member responsible for having
initially developed the CS. Contacts may introduce an alternate OIG Contact to the
CS.
3. Legislative Provisions
a. The Inspector General Act of 1978, as amended (5 U.S.C., App. 3, Section 7)
states the following:
(1) The Inspector General may receive and investigate complaints or informa-
tion from an employee of the establishment concerning the possible existence of
an activity constituting a violation of law, rules, or regulations, or mismanage-
ment, gross waste of funds, abuse of authority or a substantial and specific danger
to the public health and safety.
(2) The Inspector General shall not, afler receipt of a complaint or information
from an employee, disclose the identity of the employee without the consent of the
employee, unless the Inspector General determines such disclosure is unavoidable
during the course of the investigation.
(3) Any employee who has authority to take, direct others to take, recommend,
or approve any jjersonnel action, shall not, with respect to such authority, take
or threaten to take any action against any employee as a reprisal for making a
complaint or disclosing information to an hispector General, unless the complaint
was made or the information disclosed with the knowledge that it was false or
with wilUul disregard for its truth or falsity.
b. The Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989 does not apply to the RTC. However,
reprisEils against RTC employees for reporting fraud, waste, or mismanagement to
the OIG violate the Inspector General Act of 1978, as amended. Furthermore, such
action constitutes a violation of RTC's ethics provisions, RTC Circular 2410.1,
Standards of Ethical Conduct for RTC Employees.
4. Policy
a. The responsible Assistant Inspector General (AIG) may designate an individual
as a CS when conditions warrant such a designation. The AIG may delegate this
authority to senior OIG managers in the field and headquarters, as appropriate.
However, complainants and witnesses differ in their rights to confidentiality. The
following is OIG policy regarding confidentiality for the three types of complainants
and for witnesses:
(1) Employee Complainants. Pursuant to the Inspector General Act of 1978, as
amended, all RTC employee complainants automatically have confidential status
unless they waive it by consenting specifically to allow OIG to use their identities.
Confidentiality may also be waived by subsequent actions by the complainant. A
case-by-case determination as to such waivers must be made in consultation with
OIG Counsel.
241
(2) Public Complainants. Confidentiality should not be provided to public com-
plainants unless they specificcQly request it.
(3) Anonvmous Complainants. Anonymous complainants cannot be treated as
confidential sources because their identity has not been disclosed to the OIG.
However, in receiving their complaints, the OIG Contact should ask anonymous
complainants to identify themselves in order to facilitate an OIG inquiry. If iden-
tification is given, the complainant should be treated as appropriate under sub-
paragraph 1, 2, or 4.
(4) Witnesses. Confidentiality should not normally be provided to witnesses re-
garding information they submit in response to questions concerning an official
mquiry. However, if the witness initiates a complaint regarding a diftierent mat-
ter, confidentiality may be granted to the witness for that information only if the
witness is an RTC employee or requests confidentiality.
b. A Contact may ask a CS to provide information already in his/her possession,
or to provide information which comes to his/her attention concerning subjects of au-
thorized OIG activity.
c. It should never be expressed or implied to a CS that his/her identity will never
be released. The OIG staff shall not disclose the identity of any CS without the indi-
vidual's consent, unless the Inspector General determines such disclosure is un-
avoidable during the course of an audit or investigation.
d. Efforts should be made to independently verity the information provided by a
CS without jeopardizing the confidentiality of the CS.
e. The Contact should be alert to any situation that mi^t be construed as an
abuse of the CS's status and, if necessary, inform the CS of the following:
(1) The assistance of the CS is strictly voluntary;
(2) The CS's relationship with the OIG will not protect him/her from arrest or
prosecution for tiny violation of Federal, state, or local law; and/or
(3) The CS supply of information to the OIG does not make him/her an OIG
employee, nor should such a status ever be claimed by the CS.
f. In carrying out any request, the CS wUl not be encouraged or requested to par-
ticipate in any acts of violence, initiate or instigate a plan to commit criminal acts,
or use unlawful techniques to obtain information.
g. When a CS learns that persons involved in an OIG case intend to conmiit or
participate in a crime, or to cause harm to RTC's programs and operations, the CS
IS encouraged to immediately notify the OIG Contact or alternate.
h. No member of the OIG will disclose the identity of a CS without authorization
from Inspector General, pursuant to the Inspector General Act of 1978, as amended
(5 U.S.C, App. 3, Section 7 (b)).
5. Procedures. Each AIG is responsible for ensuring that, once approved^ a CS's
identity remains confidential. The AIG, or designee, is responsible for the following
procedures.
a. Designating CS
(1) The Contact should direct a written request to the responsible AIG, or des-
ignee (if appropriate), for authorization to designate an individual as a CS. If the
written request is mailed, only registered mail or ovemi^t maO should be used.
The written request should include the full identity of the CS with as much back-
ground information concerning the individual as possible and a brief justification
lor using the individual as a CS. The procedures lor recording hotline information
(Paragraph 6. c), outlined in our Hotline policy, OIG Policies and Procedures
Manual Chapter 110.2, satisfy these requirements. At most, only an original and
one copy of the written request should exist; no copies should be maintained in
the case files or workpapers. The responsible AIG, or designee, should maintain
the original and, if made, one copy in locked safes.
(2) If approved, the AIG, or designee, will assign, from their numerically
sequenced CS log, a designation code that will be used to refer to the CS. The
designation code should identify the OIG office, followed by CS to note that the
source is confidential and then a sequential number (e.g., ATL-I/CS/01 stands for
OIG Office of Investigation, Atlanta s first CS). The log, which must be secured
in a locked safe, should contain the true identity of the CS, designation code, case/
assignment number, and Contact's name.
b. Maintaining the Source's Confidentiality. CSs must not be identified by name,
gender, or other telling information which may lead another to deduce a CfS's true
identity. Any reference to the CS should be by the designation code only. This ap-
plies to all written communication — from preparing internal papers (i.e., case files,
work papers, etc.) to issuing relevant documents (i.e., reports, memorandum).
6. Contact. Questions regarding OIG guidance on this policy should be directed to
the AIG for Policy, Planning and Resources.
242
The exhibit identification will be stamped at the bottom right of each exhibit page,
whenever possible. Otherwise, the stamp will be placed on the exhibit page wher-
ever most convenient.
6. Review and Issuance of the ROI
a. Review 6v the RIGl or DAIGI
(1) 'Hie RIGI, DAIGI (Headgueirters), or his/her designee is responsible for re-
viewing and approving each ROI before it is issued by that office. The review
should De conducted to ensure that acceptable standards for investigative activity
have been met and that the ROI accurately reflects the results of the investiga-
tion. Special care should be taken to ensure that all investigative leads have been
addressed and that appropriate support exists for the information reported. Addi-
tionally, the reviewer should ensure that the report is written clearly and con-
cisely, without opinions of the writer, and that the report is free of spelling, gram-
matical and punctuation errors.
(2) Typically, a copy of the ROI wUl be submitted to the DAIGI (Field) at the
time it is issued. On a case-by-case basis, depending upon the sensitivity or sig-
nificance of the investigation, the Assistant Inspector General for Investigation
(AIGI) may require that a copy of the ROI be submitted to the DAIGI (Field),
prior to issuance.
D. Issuance of ROI for Prosecutive Consideration. ROIs issued for prosecutive con-
sideration should be accompanied by a transmittal letter from the RIGI or DAIGI
(HQ) to the responsible prosecutor. The RIGI or DAIGI (HQ) should follow up peri-
odically, if needed, until a prosecutive decision has been reached.
c. Issuance of ROI to RTC Management. ROIs issued to RTC management should
be sent with a transmittal memorandum from the RIGI or DAIGI (HQ) and a blank
Disposition Report (DR) (Attachment C). Within 60 days of issuance, the DR should
be completed by management and returned to the RIGI or DAIGI (Headquarters).
(1) Distribution of the ROI will vary depending on the subject matter, as out-
lined in paragraphs 6.c.(2) throu^ 6.c.(6). In addition to issuance of the original
ROI and DR, copies will be provided to the Director, Office of Administrative
Evaluation, RTC, Washington, DC, for appropriate routing to the various offices
required to take action. The offices whicn are to receive these copies should be
identified in the memorandum used to transmit the original ROI to management.
243 -'
OFHCE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION
September 11, 1992
Honoraiple Henry B. Gonzalez
Chairmar, Committee on Banking, Finance
and Urban Affairs
House of Representatives
Washington, D.C. 20515
Dear Mr. Chairman:
You recently sent a letter to Albert V. Casey, President and CEO, Resolution
Trust Corporation (RTC), asking for the Report of Investigation and complete
case r'lle of our investigation of former RTC General Counsel Gerald L. Jacobs.
Mr. Casey sent you the Repon of Investigation on August 20 and explained that
the balance of the matenal requested, the complete case tile, entailed a substandal
volume of material which my office would provide. A copy of much of the
material generated or accumulated dunng our investigation is enclosed. These
documents contain matenal which is not subject to disclosure under the Freedom
of Information Act, and is provided for your use as Chairman of the House
Committee on Banking, Finance and Urban Affairs.
We still have a substantial volume of material, largely records of Western
Savings and Loan Association, which we reviewed during our investigation and
are prepared to provide to you. However, because of the large volume of
material (approximately 36 file boxes) and the nature of some of it (personal
income tax returns, etc.), we would like :o meet with you or your staff to discuss
our investigation and arrange delivery, if necessary, of this additional matenai.
We would appreciate being contacted by a member of your staff to arrange such a
meeting. In the meantime, should you or members of your staff have any
questions. I am available to discuss this matter. I may be reached on
(703) 9O8-7S0O.
Sincerely yours.
/ /
John !. Adair
InsotfCtor General
l".>5 \. I.>uii Mr.-< • «.i.-l>o. 1 \ IIMV
Sill ITib S<r-i«. N" • "j-tuukinn. !«.' lOJli.n.l.ll
244
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
7roD:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
•OIG0RTCDC, •(JIGIQRTCDC, *9IG2(3RTCDC, •OIGaORTCDC, •QIGQRTCATLSOO,
*(JIGQRTCATLNOR, *QIG(3RTCDALIG, •giG-InveORTCDALGOI,,
•eiG-AuditeRTCDALGOL, •90IGQRTCDEH, •QOIGQRTCNB, •QIGQRTCKC,
Joan C. GreenQIGQRTCATL, Bobbie H. Ward(3IGQRTCATL
John J. AdairaiGORTCDC
GAO Review
Thursday, July 22, 1993 15:15:58 EDT
The General Accounting Office is beginning a review of RTC OIG operations.
All OIG staff should cooperate to the fullest extent in GAO's review.
We have pledged full cooperation to GAO and will allow them access to OIG
files. In the investigations portion of the review, GAO may be asking
qfuestions which relate to some of our open cases. If questions are asXed
which members of the investigative staff feel may adversely impact sensitive
investigative techniques, such as undercover operations or the confidentiality
of the investigation, please coordinate this first with your Headquarters
staff. We are worXing with GAO to preserve the confidentiality and integrity
of the investigation and address GAO's questions at the same time.
The following GAO personnel will be conducting the review:
Lowell Dodge
Koman Burrell
Terry Draver
John Pretwell
I thank you in advance for your cooperation.
245
To:
re:
Bcc:
"rom:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
George F. SuHivan«lG§RTCKCCHI
Daniel L. Sherry§iq§RTCKCMID
Michael J. Kos2ola§IG§RTCKCCHI
Wednesday, June 10, 1992 16:58:34 CDT
Y
There are reports of individuals removing computer equipment and other
electronic equipment from the CCO/RTC facility.
The security company is having a difficult time in determining
whether the individuals removing the equipment from the CCO are authorized to
remove the equipment.
There are no internal controls in place to prevent unauthorized removal of
equipment from the CCO facility. If you want me to suggest some procedures
to account for the removal of equipment from the building, please let me know.
Thanks
Mike
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Michael J. Koszola#IGiRTCKCCHI
GFSeiGeRTCKCCHI
Daniel L. Sherry §ig§RTCKC>IID
re:
Thursday, June 11, 1992 7:18:46 CDT
N
That goes a little beyond the scope of our job, but personally, George may
want to permit it.
,To:
Cc:
Bcc:
■ From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Michael J. KoszolaeiG9RTCKCCHI
George F. SullivaneiG§RTCKCCHI
re:Security Tranining
Thursday, June 11, 1992 10:37:53 CDT
DaA She°"'' ^^^ ^^^^ ^^ '^'^ function. Why was the original of this E-Mail cc
246
ISfIt
Resolution Trust Corporation
OfTlct of Inspector C«ocral
OfTk* of Ia*«sllc«'lo«
4900 M«in. Sum 700
Kinui Cir. M.i«un 64112
(116) MI.7I45
000) 36J0343.EJO. 7I4J
PAX: (»I61 36I-OT74
OFFICE
MEMORXMOUM
DATE:
June 26, 1992
TO:
Jude J. Gerstner
Regional Inspector General for Audit
FROM: Daniel L. Sherry,
Regional Inspector General for Investigation
SUBJECT: Audit Referral on possible Misappropriation of Funds
Due the SKOKIE FEDERAL RECEIVERSHIP File No.KC-92-0040
This case is assigned to Special Agent KOSZOLA who requests an
audit assist of the mortgage account that was being serviced by
AFFILIATED BANK, Chicago, Illinois, for the RESOLUTION TRUST
CORPORATION (RTC) .
GARY HAYGOOD, a former employee of both SKOKIE FEDERAL, Skolcie,
Illinois and AFFILIATED BANK, Chicago, Illinois, is suspected of
misappropriating the funds from a checking account at the
COLONIAL BANK (COLONIAL), Montgomery, Alabama.
The COLONIAL account was being used for servicing RTC assets in
Montgomery, Alabama. Loan payments that were collected on
properties in Montgomery, were deposited in the COLONIAL account.
HAYGOOD a signatory on the COLONIAL account was arrested for
theft of funds from the COLONIAL account and is awaiting judicial
action.
If you have any questions, please contact Special Agent KOSZOLA
at (708) 290-7746.
^,
7<Lc^ct (_, —
/Ve^i.
lA^UC-^ ^M0'~^
L »o
^\J Ox, t
u
cS I
247
m
Resolution Trust Corporation
Onioe of laspcctor General
4900 Maia, Sua 700
K>aM< C<r. MUoui Mill
dt«) 9M-TI4S
(100) 3»5-])4t.Eja. 714)
FAX: (II«) MI-0n4
OF?XCB KBMORAMOOK
DATE:
June 30, 1992
TO: Jude J. Gerstner
Regional Inspector General Cor Audit
FROM: Daniel L. Sherry,
Regional Inspector General for Investigation
SUBJECT: Audit Referral on Sale of $22. 8 million in Treasury
Indexed ARM Loans File Mo. KC-91-0040
This case is assigned to Special Agent Koszola who requests an
audit assist of the sale of Treasury indexed ARM loans that were
valued at approximately $22.8 million.
Allegedly two offers were made to purchase the loans, one of
which was for $17.3 million. The offers were allegedly rejected
for being unacceptable low bids. The day after the offers were
rejected in the CCO, the Treasury ARM loans valued at S22.8
million were sold for approximately S12.8 million from the KCO.
The case file does not reflect the purchaser of the loans.
If you have any questions, please contact Special Agent Koszola
at (708) 290-7746.
248
■ To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
GFS§IG§RTCKCCHI
Daniel L. Sherry? igeRTCKCMID
KC-91-0040 i KC-92-0040
Tuesday, June 30, 1992 10:16:06 CDT
I have memos dated June 3 0 and June 2 6 on the above cases that request audit
assistance from Jude Gerstner. They are both woefully short on justification
for even making the requests.
What are they concerning?
cases referred by Audit?
Can't we do the work ourselves? Did we get these
249
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION, OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
Date: July 1, 1992
To: Gerald Jacobs, Senior Vice President and General Counsel Division of Legal
Services
From: Sharon E. Vander Vennet, Assistant Inspector General for Audit
Subject: Controls Over RTC's L^al Services Agreements (A92-022)
This report presents the results of our nationwide audit of the Resolution Trust
Corporation's controls over legal services agreements. The scope of our audit encom-
passed the entire solicitation and retention process.
We conducted this audit to determine whether (1) RTC's use of legal services con-
tractors was in accordance with policy and guidance, (2) legal services agreements
were being used to circumvent normal contracting procedures, and (3) RTC was ef-
fectively and efficiently administering legal services agreements. To accomplish our
objectives, we performed audit work m Washington, each of RTC's regional offices,
and selected consolidated offices.
In brief, during the period of our review RTC was not complying with several im-
portant policies and procedures, including those covering competitive bidding of rou-
tine-type matters, outside counsel evaluations, and contracting with non-legal con-
tractors In addition, the Legal Division's information systems did not capture impor-
tant information or produce reports the Division needed to adequately manage its
operations in accordance with policies, procedures, and statutory requirements and
to ensure that it fulfilled its responsibihties. Also, the Legal Division review process
for outside counsel invoices and the program the Division used to pay these invoices
allowed overpajntnent of outside l^al counsel. Finally, the Division lacked adequate
controls to ensure that conflicts of interest were reported to appropriate levels and
those decisions were handled consistently and were properly documented.
As a result of our findings, we are making recommendations to improve compli-
ance with current policies and procedures and suggest new ones to improve the
Legal Division's operations. In addition, we are recommending internal control im-
provements and information system improvements.
On March 17, 1992, we provided a draft of this report to the RTC and FDIC Gen-
eral Counsels. Because several key events occurred subsequent to the coinpletion of
our fieldwork, such as the issuance of the FDIC's OIG report on the FmC Legal
Division ^ and the separation of RTC from FDIC, we agreed to gather additional in-
formation on initiatives taken since the conclusion of our fieldwork. We learned that
RTC has taken steps to improve its methodology for hiring outside counsel, imple-
mented its new management information system, revamped its payment system,
and developed a budget-based case management system. Information on these im-
provements is contained, as appropriate, throu^out this report.
The Inspector General Act ol 1978, as amended, requires us to report on the sta-
tus of management decisions on our recommendations in our semiannual reports to
Congress. The term "management decision" refers to management's evaluation of
the findings and recommendations included in an audit report and the issuance of
a written response that describes:
• specific corrective actions already taken,
• corrective eictions to be taken together with the expected completion dates of their
implementation,
• documentation that will confirm the completion of corrective actions,
• management's opinion on monetary benefits included in the report, and
• the reasons why a particular recommendation is not considered vaUd.
We received the Corporation's comments on our draft report on June 15, 1992,
and have included them as an appendix. The response to our May 4, 1992 draft re-
port, for the most part, describea the Corporation's management decisions on the
recommendations. Although we generally agree with the Corporation's plans on rec-
ommendations 1, 2, 6, 8, 9, 12, and 13; we need additional documentation describing
management's decisions before we can close the recommendations. Our evaluation
of the Corporation's comments discusses the specific additional information re-
quired. The response did not fully address recommendations 5, 7, and 14 and did
not address recommendations 10 or 11. The Division disagreed with recommenda-
tions 3 and 4. To ensure that we can respond to our reporting requirement, we re-
quest that the audit liaison provide the information on the management decisions
within 60 days after the date of this report.
^Thie report was prepared by Price Wateriiouse, a certified Public Accounting firm, under the
irection of the FDIC Office of Inspector General.
250
Executive Summary
The Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989
(FIRREA) established the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC) to resolve the savings
and loan industry crisis under the management of the Federal Deposit Insurance
Corporation (FDIC).^ In its role as manager, among other items, FDIC provided
legtd services to RTC through both its own in-house Legal Division and outside legal
counsel.^ Because FDIC's legal case load increased substantially with the passage
of FIRREA, the Legal Division began using outside counsel extensively and reported
spending $615 million on outside counsel in 1990. Both the Congress and the public
expressed concerns about these large expenditures.
Because of the concerns expressed and the large dollar amounts involved, we con-
ducted this audit of the Legal Division's use of outside counsel. Our audit was per-
formed from March 1991 to August 1991, and focused on the heaal Division's adher-
ence to policy and guidance; the efficiency and effectiveness of the processes to hire,
pay, and manage outside counsel; and the Division's use of outside counsel to enter
into contracts instead of using established RTC contracting procedures. We con-
ducted additional work in March and April 1992 to determine what changes the
RTC Legal Division had made since we completed our field work.
Results In Brief
In brief, during the period of our review RTC was not complying with several im-
portant policies and procedures, including those covering competitive bidding of rou-
tine-type matters, outside counsel evaluations, and contracting with non-legal con-
tractors. In addition, the Legal Division's information systems did not capture im-
portant information or produce reports the Division needed to adequately manage
its operations in accordance with policies, procedures, and statutoiy re<juirements
and to ensure that it fulfilled its responsibilities. Also, the Legal Division review
process for outside counsel invoices and the program the Division used to pay these
invoices allowed overpayment of outside legal counsel. Finally, the Division lacked
adequate controls to ensure that conflicts of interest were reported to appropriate
levels and those decisions were handled consistently and were properly documented.
Compliance with Policy and Procedures
In certain areas, the Legal Division did not adhere to established policy and guid-
ance which would have served it well. For example, the Division did not competi-
tively bid routine-tvpe legal matters, nor did it adhere to RTC contracting proce-
dures when it used its contracting authority to have outside counsel procure non-
legal services from non-legal contractors. Further, although recpiired to do so under
its own procedures, the Legal Division did not periodically evaluate outside counsel's
performance using as criteria cost-consciousness, responsiveness, case management,
knowledge of FDIC and its billing procedures, and budgeting.
As a result, the Legal Division aid not benefit from the potential cost savings as-
sociated with competition; did not provide fair and open competition, and may not
have used firms with the best possible qualifications. However, we learned as a re-
sult of reviewing recent RTC Legal Division policies and procedures that the Divi-
sion is attempting to provide for competition in retaining outside counsel. Because
these new initiatives remain relatively untested, we are recommending that RTC es-
tablish internal controls to ensure compliance with the new policies and procedures
on the competitive retention of outside counsel. We are also recommending that the
Division establish internal controls to ensure outside counsel evaluations are pre-
pared when required. In addition, we are recommending that the Division dis-
continue the practice of using outside counsel to hire non-legal contractors and im-
plement adequate internal controls to ensure future contracting is done in accord-
ance with RTC policies and procedures.
Management Information Systems
The Legal Division operated multiple, non-integrated management information
systems which did not provide sufiicient information. These systems were developed
before FIRREA was enacted and were not designed to handle the Division's in-
creased work load or to keep pace with the Division's changing information needs.
* Effective February 1, 1992, the Resolution Trust Corporation Refinancing, Restructuring and
Improvement Act of 1991 removed FDIC as RTC's exclusive manager and established a Chief
Executive OfiRcer to manage RTC.
3 On September 10, 1991, the Board of Directors' approved the creation of a separate RTC
Legal Division and appointed a General Counsel to head the Division effective September 22,
1991.
251
For example, the systems oould not provide data on the total dollars spent on legal
services or amounts paid to law firms over a 12-month period. Nor could the sys-
tems provide accurate information on the fitness and integrity of outside counsel or
real or potential conflicts of interest.
The Division needs suflicient and reliable information to manage its operations
and fulfill its responsibilities. It has undertaken some recent initiatives to improve
its systems such as implementing the RTC Legal Information System (RLIS). kLIS
has been designed to provide the Division with much needed information to aid it
in achieving its objectives. Nonetheless, we are recommending that the RTC Legal
Division assess its short- and long-term information needs ana develop a plan to ad-
dress those needs. In addition, the Division needs to develop sufficient standardized
reporting capability to ensure that it has the information necessary to manage out-
side counsel.
Invoice Processing Led to Overpayments
The review and payment processes the Legal Division used to analyze and pay
outside counsel invoices were not adequate to verify correctness or identify question-
able charges on invoices, nor did they ensure correct payment to outside counsel.
By implementing a payment program without an oversight mechanism to ensure the
effective functioning of the review process and without specific guidance to follow,
the Legal Division made numerous overpayments to outside counsel. The payment
program reduced the incentive for Legal Division staff to perform an adequate re-
view because, unlike the former system, staff were no longer required to: review and
approve invoices before outside counsel received payment. Furtner, the, Legal Divi-
sion's process for identifying overpayments involved a sampling methodology which
did not capture all overpayments made to outside counsel.
Under RLIS, only certain invoices are selected for review. In addition, RTC Legal
has not yet issued its own invoice review procedures. To improve invoice processing,
we are recommending that the RTC Legeu Division revise its invoice processing pro-
cedures, including ensuring approval of amendments to Legal Services Agreements,
training its staff responsible for reviewing invoices, and establishing an invoice proc-
essing oversight^ review mechanism.
Cost Controls Over Matters Referred to Outside Counsel
The Legal Division did not have adequate cost controls over those cases it referred
to outside counsel. The Division received cost and time estimates from outside coun-
sel and also received information relating to the progress counsel was making on
legal matters. It did not, however, routinely analjTte and monitor the costs associ-
ated with the matter or dieck their reasonableness. By not continuously analyzing
the information to ensure that the benefits of pursuing a matter outweigh its costs,
the Division may have incurred unnecessary expenses.
However, the RTC Legal Division has recently implemented a budget-based man-
agement information and payment system. Because budgets for each matter must
be submitted by outside counsel and reviewed and approved by the Division, better
cost control should be achieved. We believe that the RTC Legal Division should con-
sider incorporating internal control responsibilities into each manager's performance
standards.
Conflicts of Interest Were Not Adequately Documented and Communicated
The Legal Division did not have adequate internal controls to ensure that conflicts
of interest were reported to appropriate levels of Legal Division management. Fur-
ther, the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee policies were not sufficiently strin-
gent to prevent potential criticism of conflicts decisions and did not provide ade-
quate documentation for all its decisions. As a result, the Legal Division could be
subject to claims of favoritism and unfair treatment of outside counsel. We are rec-
ommending that the RTC Le^al Division develop and implement a system to cen-
tralljr reconi, report, and monitor all conflicts of mterest. As part of this system, the
Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee should document the rationale for its deci-
sions. In addition, we are recommending that the RTC Le^al Division evaluate the
Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee decision-making pohcies and procedures and
develop more stringent guidelines which would promote the use or firms without
conflicts of interest.
Chapter 1
Introduction
The Financial Institutions Reform, Recoveiy, and Enforcement Act of 1989
(FIRREA) appointed the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) as the Reso-
lution Trust Corporation's (RTC) exclusive manager. FDIC, in its capacity as RTC's
252
manager, provided RTC with legal counsel through the FDIC Legal Division."* The
Legal Division used outside counsel rather than in-house counsel as a means to pro-
vide RTC with most of its legal services for two reasons. First, the use of outside
counsel gave the Legal Division the abiUty to staiT legal matters without hiring
lai^e numbers of in-house attorneys. In addition, because RTC is scheduled to dis-
solve on December 31, 1996, a large number of attorneys are required for only a
few years. The FDIC Legal Division reported expenditures on outside counsel of
$615 million in 1990 for both FDIC and RTC legal services.
On January 30, 1991, Senator David Pryor requested the Office of Inspector Gen-
ertd to conduct an audit of the Legal Division's agreements with outside counsel.
His concerns related to Legal Division oversight of agreements with outside counsel,
competition for Legal Division work, and review of outside counsel invoices. Al-
though we had already planned to conduct an audit of legal services, we expanded
the audit work to address the Senator's concerns.
Objectives, Scope, and Methodology
The objectives of our audit were to determine whether (1) RTC's use of legal serv-
ices contractors was in accordance with policy and guidance, (2) legal services con-
tracts were being used to circumvent normal contracting procedures, and (3) RTC
was effectively and efficiently administering legal services agreements. Our audit
encompassed the entire solicitation and retention process, from selecting outside
counsel and assigning legal matters to them to paying outside counsel for services
rendered. We also included specific testing in our audit to address Senator Pryor's
concerns. Our review was limited to firms the Legal Division used during calendar
year 1990 and to documentation maintained at FDIC/RTC. We did not examine doc-
umentation maintained by the outside counsel or the payment of conservatorship in-
voices for legal services. We performed our work at Legal Division headquarters in
Washington, DC; Legal Division Offices in Atlanta, Dallas, Denver, and Kansas
City; and at 9 consolidated offices including the Mid-Atlantic, Metroplex, GuU" Coast,
Southern, Central Western, Coastal, Intermountain, North Central, Kansas City,
and Chicago Consolidated Offices. We conducted our audit from March through Au-
gust 1991, in accordance with generally accepted govenament auditing standards.
We also did follow-up work on certain issues in March and April 1992.
To accomplish our objectives, we interviewed Legal Division staff, and obtained,
reviewed, and evaluated documentation provided by FDIC/RTC. Specifically, we:
• Reviewed Legal Division policies and procedures for the selection and retention
and payment of outside counsel as established in the Division's Procedural Man-
ual, A Law Firm's Guide: How to be Considered for Retention by The FDIC and
RTC, Guide for Legal Representation, and various memorandums;
• Selected and reviewed a judgmental sample of 464 invoices and outside counsel
selection and retention documents at Legal Division offices in the Eastern, North
Central, Southwest, and Western regions and at the Legal Division's Washington,
DC headquarters to determine the level of compliance with policies and proce-
dures;
• Evaluated the Legal Division's policies and procedures pertaining to the selection,
retention, and payment of outside counsel to determine the completeness and ade-
quacy of the policies and procedures;
• Identified and evaluated the Legal Division's controls over outside counsel by
interviewing Legal Division staff and reviewing Legal Division policies and proce-
dures to determine whether these controls provided sufficient oversight and mon-
itoring of outside counsel; and
• Identified and evaluated the selection and retention process, the invoice process-
ing programs, and the management information systems by interviewing FDIC/
RTC staff and reviewing FDIC/RTC documents such as policies and procedures,
and reports by consultants and the FDIC Office of Inspector General to determine
whether the programs, processes, and systems efficiently and effectively met the
goals and needs of the Legal Division.
*On September 10, 1991, the Board of Directors approved the creation of a separate RTC
Legal Division and appointed a General Counsel to head the Division effective September 22,
1991. Effective February 1, 1992, the Resolution Trust Corporation Refinancing, Restructuring,
and Improvement Act of 1991 removed FDIC as RTC's exclusive manager and created a Chief
Executive Officer position to manage RTC. This report covers a period prior to these changes
in organization.
253
Legal Division Operations''
The Legal Division's mission is to provide FDIC/RTC with professional, com-
prehensive, and cost effective legal services and support through its nationwide staff
of 3,030 employees including 1,270 attorneys (as of June 30, 1991).® In addition to
its headquarters staff, the Legal Division supported FDIC/RTC with staff in regional
and consolidated offices throughout the United States. The Legal Division assisted
FDIC/TRTC in overseeing the operation of insured depository institutions, resolving
troubled and insolvent financial institutions, recovering and liquidating assets of in-
solvent financial institutions, prosecuting and defending matters related to FDIC/
RTC operations, and ensuring compliance with laws. To carry out its mission, the
Legal Division had five branches which reported to the General Counsel. One of the
branches — the RTC Branch — supported RTC in the development of uniform nation-
wide policies far resolutions and liquidations of failed institutions. Further, the RTC
Branch represented RTC in its corporate capacity in litigation, provided administra-
tive direction to field personnel, and coordinated and sujjervised litigation handled
in the field including the use of outside counsel.
Selection and Retention of Outside Counsel
The Legal Division's selection and retention process encompasses the period from
identifying potential outside counsel to perform work throu^ evaluating the actual
work periormed. Outside counsel who want to provide legal services to FDIC/RTC
must subscribe to the Legal Division's selection and retention process. Specific pro-
cedures in the selection and retention process include filing a contractor registration
request form, completing an interview with the Legal Division, and executing a
Legal Services Agreement. Once these steps have been completed, the Legal Divi-
sion adds the film to the List of Counsel Utilized (LCU) from which the firm may
be retained to perform Legal Division work. With few exceptions, only firms on the
LCU are eligible to receive work from FDIC/RTC
The Legal Division requires outside counsel interested in providing services to
FDIC/RTC to complete several steps. First, outside counsel must submit a Contrac-
tor Registration Request form which provides background information on the firm
to comply with FIRREA mandates that outside contractors meet minimum stand-
ards of competence, experience, integrity, and fitness. After approval of the registra-
tion request, the firms become registered contractors for FDIC/RTC. This status
does not ensure that the firms will receive work, only that they have certified that
they meet the minimum requirements. As of October 10, 1991, 8,082 legal firms had
completed this process and were registered on the Contractor Database.
The Legal Division then distributes the information submitted by the firms to the
Legal Division regional offices. If regional Legal Division staff want to use a firm,
for example, because of the firm's expertise, the staff will interview the representa-
tives from the firm. Upon completion of a successful interview, the staff submit a
memorandum to the Legal Division's headquarters in Washington requesting ap-
proval to use the firm.
If headquarters approves the firm for use, the firm is then requested to execute
a Legal Services Agreement (LSA) with the Legal Division. The LSA is not a con-
tract, but rather an offer to perform services which incorporates Legal Division poli-
cies and procedures with wnich outside counsel are expected to comply. The LSA
also identifies the outside counsel's staff who may work on RTC legal matters and
trlGir 1*8. tcs
Finally, afi^r the firm has executed an LSA, it is added to the LCU. The LCU
is updated to reflect the addition or termination of firms or other changes and is
distributed monthly to the regions. As of December 4, 1991, the LCU contained the
names of over 3,500 outside counsel who could potentially receive FDIC/RTC work.
The Legal Division requires that outside counsel report conflicts of interest from
the onset of the selection and retention process throiignout the performance of legal
services for FDIC/RTC. If any actual or potential conflicts of interest arise, the firms
are required to immediately report them. Firms usually disclose conflicts to the
Legal Division regional staff who send a memorandum to the Outside Counsel Con-
flirts Committee in Washington recommending treatment of the conflict. The Out-
*This section reflects Legal Division operations during the period of audit work — March
through August 1991.
"As a result of the September 10, 1991, Board of Directors decision to separate RTC Legal
from the FDIC L^al Ehvision, the nationwide staff was divided between the two corpwrations.
'The LCU is a database which contains basic information on the outside counsel such as the
firms' addresses, contact jserson, and phone numbers and is intended to be used by the regions
to select approved legal firms.
*The Contractor database contains information on contractors from their Contractor Registra-
tion Request form.
76-818 0-94-9
254
side Counsel Conflicts Committee considers the regional recommendation, but ulti-
mately it decides how to treat the firm's conflict of interest and provides its decision
to the region.
To ensure that FDIC/RTC receive quality services from outside counsel, the Legal
Division reouires, at a minimum, the completion of (1) an oral evaluation of the firm
at the conclusion of a significant matter and (2) an annual written evaluation of
each firm. Legal Division staff are to evaluate firms based on cost consciousness,
responsiveness, case management, knowledge of FDIC procedures and issues, billing
procedures, and budgeting.
Payment of Outside Counsel
During 1990, FDIC/RTC used two different programs to pay outside counsel — the
Payment Authorization Voucher Program (PAV) and the Accelerated Pavment Pro-
gram (APP). Under both programs, FDIC's Division of Accounting and Corporate
&rvices (DACS) issued checks to pay outside counsel.® However, the programs dif-
fered in that the APP allowed outside counsel to receive pajnment before L«gal Divi-
sion review and approval of their invoices, whereas the PAV required review and
approval of invoices before payment. Regardless of when the Legal Division re-
viewed the invoices, the review process was the same. The process entailed verifying
mathematical accuracy and examining the invoices for inappropriate charges such
as secretarial overtime, first class airfare, or other inappropriate charges wnich the
Legal Division would disallow.
Under the PAV program, outside counsel submitted invoices directly to the Legal
Division for review and approval. After completing the review and approval process,
a payment authorization voucher and fee bill memorandum were forwarded to
DACS for payment (see Figure 1.1 for a depiction of the process).
Figure 1.1: Payment Authorization Voucher Program
OUTSiOC i-ECM.
H
oiyTstoe teo^ colkscl oecces sectvices ro t.< ^egai 3>vi$ion.
OUTSIOE L£0«. CCO«CL CSCATeS A SILL >:^ S€aviC£S aE*<:£B€0
TO n« ,8iM. OiyiSKX 'TO I.HI1.S rT "0 The C»epCE
AM3 A0Oa€SSe IO€NTI^|£0 IN THE ^.tKCtl-^fC OF
aO\>«£L UETTEP.
•OiC
I LCCAL Oivisto.
L
PO'C Division OP |
r -2epj,,^re j !»<«*res * oe<x ak) iMn.s <t to owts.o€ lSOl cx^^sel.
^-^5l■^e .=■>;.
The PAV review pTX)cess produced a backlog of invoices, thereby delaying payment
to outside counsel. As a result, the Legal Division and DACS implemented the APP
in October 1990. The Legal Division estimated a backlog of approximately 32,000
invoices before the APP was implemented. The APP allowed outside counsel to bill
®DACS does not pay conservatorBhips' outeide counsel — each conservatorship pays its own
legal expenses. However, the conservatorships submit the outside counsels* invoices to the L^al
Division for review and approval.
255
DACS directly and to receive payment before the Legal Division reviewed the
charges. Nonetheless, outside counsel were still required to submit an invoice to the
Legal Division for review and approval even though payment was made based on
the request sent to DACS. To identify overpayments, DACS and the Legal Division
planned to perform a reconciliation between the amounts paid by DACS and the
amounts approved by the Legal Division (see Figure 1.2 for a depiction of the proc-
ess).
Figure 1.2: Accelerated Payment Program
CX/TSioc COkXSEL SOCS
AN tIftfOlCE rO ThC i.eoL
DPvisiON FOP neviEv
ArA APPROVAL
r
OOTS'C*
couNsa.
ThC OivtSiOM OF ACCOUNTiiO
*»0 CCBP0O*t6 SHHvrCES
I
CM^S PATS OUrSiOC COUNS€L
POO PATUtNT
OiviSiOi OF
ACCOu»*T I «;
COPPCXUTC
SEOviCES
ooTsioe
COXSEl
QECCyCiLiATiON
MOCESS
ecTweeN t^*
AfcOCKTS P«lO
A^c aPPOOvEO
^
LEGAL DIVISION BILLS OUTSIDE CXl^CEl con OvEOPAYuems
»»c oi/Tsioe CDi*<seL sends a CtfCt to TmE lECal division
During the reconciliation process, the Legal Division planned to review a sample
of outside counsel invoices to determine whether any overpayments had been made.
If overpayments were identified, the Legal Division would request a refund from
outside counsel for the amount of overpayment. Outside counsel were required to
send refunds to the Legal Division's Adininistration Section in Washington, DC. The
reconciliation process began in the regions in May 1991.
Management Information Systems
The Legal Division used a system called the Case Management System (CMS) to
provide basic data on legal matters such as the name of the outside counsel as-
signed to the matter, the financial institution number, and the status of the matter.
This system was developed in the mid-1980's as a temporary measure to provide the
Division with data related primarily to tracking litigation matters. With the in-
creased diversity in the types of legal matters and the Corporations' growing infor-
mation needs, the Legal Division decided that CMS needed to be substantially re-
worked or replaced and decided to develop a new system. Both the Legal Division
and the RTC Branch of the Legal Division developed their own management infor-
mation systems. Because the RTC Branch believed that the Legal Division System-
Legal Division Information Management System (LDIMS) — would not be imple-
mented quickly enough for its needs, the Branch developed its own system — the
RTC Legal Information System (RLIS). The RTC Branch originally intended to use
RLIS to manage and track only those legal matters related to assets assigned to
asset management and disposition contractors. However, the Branch decided to ex-
pand the system to include all RTC legal matters. The RTC Legal Division began
initial implementation of RLIS on October 28, 1991.
256
Chapter 2
The Legal Division Did Not Comply with Important Policies
and Procedures
The Legal Division, and RTC in general, have several important policies and pro-
cedures with which the Legal Division was not compljring. Specifically, the Legal Di-
vision did not competitively bid routine-type legal matters as stated in its policy,
did not follow RTC contracting procedures m contracting with non-legal contractors
on behalf of an RTC Division, and did not evaluate outside counsel performance.
This non-compliance resulted from the Division's lack of internal controls, sufficient
guidance, and management support. As a result, the Legal Division may have paid
more for services than it should have, did not provide for fair and open competition
as required by FIRREA, and could be using firms with less than adequate qualifica-
tions.
Legal Division Did Not CoMPEnrnvELY Bid Routine Matters
The Legal Division did not use a competitive process to refer routine-type matters
to outside counsel during the period of our audit ending August 1991. The Legal
Division issued a policy statement dated May 1990, statmg that it would competi-
tively bid routine-type matters to outside counsel, but adequate procedures, incen-
tives, and internal controls were not in place to implement the policy. The Legal
Division has referred a significant amount of work to outside counsel, but did not
realize potential savings by allowing firms to compete for the work.
The Legal Division's A Law Firm's Guide: How To Be Considered for Retention
by the FuIC and RTC, stated that "The Corporation will use a competitive bidding
process within defined geographic areas in order to refer the following types of rou-
tine matters to outside counsel: (a) routine, nonjudicial foreclosures; and (b) collec-
tion litigation on assets valued under $10,000." Washington Legal stafi" responsible
for outside counsel activities stated that they believed the regional offices were fol-
lowing this guidance and using a competitive bidding process for routine-type mat-
ters.
Nonetheless, we found that competitive bidding was not being used by any of the
regional offices. We believe the Legal Division did not use a competitive oidding
process for its routine-type matters because the Division did not have specific proce-
dures to tell Legal Division attorneys how to compete bids. The guidance that was
available was not specific enough to be used as criteria to compete contracts for
legal services and was too limited in the types of matters which were to be competi-
tively bid. It did not define the competitive bidding process, the boundaries of geo-
graphic areas, or an inclusive list oi routine-type matters. Also, the Legal Division
regional offices did not have any incentives to use a competitive bid process and in-
ternal controls were not in place to ensure that staff competed routine work.
Evidence presented in a report dated February 1991, by the management consult-
ing firm of Altman, Weil, Pensa to the Legal Division indicated that the majority
of the work referred to outside counsel was routine and could have been competi-
tively bid.^° Altman, Weil, Pensa cited a form letter sent to law firms interested in
representing the Legal Division on RTC related matters in which the Regional
Counsel stated, ". . . RTC considers most legal services to be fungible and expects
(juality, competent work from any and every approved law firm retained, the nTC
intenos to enter Letter Agreements with those law firms ofliering the lowest rates
without regard to such intangible, nonquantifiable factors as firm reputation/sophis-
tication, size of firm, specialized sections/groups/departments within the firm, etc."
Altman, Weil, Pensa also reported that in its interviews with various RTC and
FDIC staff and management attorneys, "We were consistently told that the matters
were really not as complicated as they were thought to be at first blush; i.e., that
much of the work being sent to outside lawyers was truly commodity work. ... A
litigation counsel characterized it this way. The bulk of the work we refer to outside
counsel is routine.'"
From the comments made by the Legal Division's regional stafi", we believe a sig-
nificant amount of matters referred to outside counsel could be defined as routine
and could have been competitively bid.
Nonetheless, Altman, Weil, Pensa offered insight on the difficulties in defining
routine-type matters. They stated "attorneys sometimes tend to consider their cases
as more unique or complex than they often are. All lawyers, both in-house and in
private law firms, often and quite naturally assume that the matter they are han-
dling is less a commodity than it actually is." Without some definition as to what
^^ Report entitled Report and Recommendations on Outside Counsel Fees and Rate Structures
for the Legal Diuision of the Federal Deposit and Insurance Corporation, February 1991.
257
is considered a routine matter, we believe that most attorneys will be less likely to
consider any individual matter as routine.
In addition to lacking specific guidance, Legal Division oflices also had no incen-
tives to use a competitive bid process for matters referred to outside counsel. Ini-
tially, extra time is necessary to compete work to a group of bidders. Without incen-
tives to do so, regional offices will not expend the up-front commitment of resources
necessary to conduct effective competitive bid processes. Most matters have been re-
ferred individually to law firms with work to be performed on an hourly rate basis.
Making individual referrals requires less of an up-front commitment than identify-
ing groups of matters for bid, getting information to interested bidders, and evaluat-
ing bids received. A Legal Division regional office did not receive any recognition
for pursuing competitive contracts and did not realize any budgetary or operational
benefits for pursuing more cost effective contracting methods such as competitive
bidding.
In addition to a lack of specific procedures which explain how and what to com-
petitively bid and a lack of mcentives to do so, the Legal Division did not have ade-
quate internal controls to determine whether the requu^ment to use comjsetitive bid
processes was being followed. The Legal Division was unable to determine which re-
gions, if any, were using competitive bidding, and the extent of its use. The lack
of monitoring controls is best illustrated by the fact that a former Legal Division
Assistant General Counsel responsible for outside counsel issues at Washington
headauarters stated that he believed that the regions were using competitive bid-
ding, out in fact, the regions were not competitively bidding at all.
Since we completed our fieldwork, the RTC Legal Division has taken steps to im-
prove its methodology for hiring outside counsel^ issuing new policies and proce-
dures. In a December 24, 1991, directive, the RTCf Legal Division established three
processes for selection and engagement of outside counsel. One of these processes
requires the use of a Request lor Proposal Memorandum (RPM), identifying the Di-
vision's nAd for legal services, which is sent to approved outside counsel meeting
specific criteria to handle the matters. Once the Division receives responses from
outside counsel, a Legal Division panel reviews them and determines tne most ad-
vantageous proposal. Based on the panel's evaluation, the Legal Division selects out-
side counsel for the matter. The second type of process in the RTC Legal Division's
new policies and procedures includes the use oi Basic Ordering Agreements (BOA)
by the Division for large numbers of similar matters involving similar services. The
BOA's allow the Legal Division to retain one or more outside counsel through a sin-
gle contract to provide these services. The RTC Legal Division also outlined a third
process which ooes not provide for competition. Under this process, the Division re-
served the authority to engage firms needed, for example, to handle emergency situ-
ations orprovide expertise otherwise unobtainable.
The RTC Legal Division also issued new guidance for outside counsel in February
1992 superseding A Law Firm's Guide: How To Be Considered for Retention by the
FDIC and RTC. This new guide, RTC Guide for Outside Counsel, eliminates ref-
erences to specific instances where competitive bidding will be used but provides for
the use of alternative competitive rate structures such as flat, contingent, or other
innovative rate proposals.
Outside Counsel's Performance Not Routinely Evaluated
In general, the four regions and Legal Division headquarters were not evaluating
outside counsel in accordance with established policies and procedures. By not per-
forming these evaluations, the Legal Division did not ensure that the best qualified
legal firms were being used to perform Legal Division worit.
The Legal Division s Procedural Memorandum 1.17, Procedures for Evaluation of
Outside Counsel, requires periodic evaluations of outside counsel's performance. Ac-
cording to this memorandum, outside counsel should be evaluated based on cost con-
sciousness, responsiveness, case management, knowledge of FDIC procedures and
issues, billing procedures, and budgeting. Procedural Memorandum 1.17 requires
two types of evaluations as follows:
• Each regional office should ensure that the managing attorney of a case, in con-
junction with the regional counsel or designee, conducts an oral evaluation of out-
side counsel at the conclusion of each significant case. In addition, this oral eval-
uation should be conducted at the conclusion of a significant number or block of
routine cases, such as foreclosures, collection actions, and bankruptcies.
• Each regional counsel should conduct an annual, written evaluation of each firm.
Regional counsel should prepare the evaluation with the appropriate regional at-
torneys and the senior attorney at the consolidated field office with on-site respon-
sibility for the cases. Consideration should be given to the case-by-case evalua-
tions of the staff. In addition to the previously mentioned evaluation criteria, the
258
review should also encompass the current rate schedule with the firm. Further,
the reviewer should consider renegotiating rates based on relevant factors such
as volume of work, quality of legal services, and regional economic conditions. The
review should cover all concluded and pending matters. If a review of all firms
is too burdensome for the region. Procedural Memorandum 1.17 allows an alter-
native procedure that only firms with fees in excess of certain doUar amounts
need to be evaluated. The regional counsel should also establish a procedure
whereby a firm is evaluated whenever its billings reach a certain dollar amount
if it has not been evaluated within the preceding 12 months. At the conclusion
of the annual evaluation, the regional counsel or designee should complete the
Outside Counsel Evaluation Form and submit it to theXegal Division's Adminis-
tration and Operations Section.
The Assistant General Counsel, Professional Liability Section (PLS) for RTC, stat-
ed that he encouraged routine evaluations of firms handling PLS matters. Addition-
ally, PLS evaluations which were done were available to other Legal Division attor-
ne}^, and outside counsel were encouraged to review their own evaluations. PLS be-
lieved that the evaluation process was very beneficial in their working relationship
with outside counsel. However, evaluations had been prepared sporadically because
PLS's procedures did not provide for specific time frames for doing an evaluation
of outside counsel.
Other Legal Division staff stated that they were reluctant to perform and docu-
ment evaluations. They expressed concerns about the availability of the information
under the Freedom of Information Act and also because of potential liability issues.
Additionally, the Legal Division did not emphasize adherence to its policies and pro-
cedures as contained in Procedural Memorandum 1.17, Procedures for Evaluation of
Outside Counsel. Evaluations of contractor performance are a basic and critical part
of any contracting process. We do not believe any basis exists to exempt outside
counsel from this requirement.
Legal Division Used Its Contracting Authority to Circumvent
RTC Contracting Procedures
RTC Legal Division's Professional Liability Section did not comply with RTC con-
tracting rules and regulations when, on behalf of the RTC Investigations Branch,
it hired outside counsel to contract for non-legal services from non-legal contractors.
Specifically, there was not fair or consistent treatment of offerors of tne services ob-
tained, as required by FIRREA. Contractors registered on RTC's Contractor
Database who could provide the services being sought by the RTC Investigations
Branch did not receive adequate contracting consideration because outside counsel
was not required to follow KTC's contractor policies and procedures. Additionally,
there was no assurance that the sub-contractors hired by outside counsel met the
minimum standards of fitness and integrity. Further, an additional layer of contract
management was created which added an undeterminable amount of extra costs.
Also, the third party contracting placed the outside counsel in a conflict of interest
between their financial interests and determining the best course of action for RTC.
The Legal Division's Professional Liability Section (PLS) used its contracting au-
thority to circumvent normal RTC contracting procedures by hiring outside counsel
to contract with non-legal contractors for non-legal services. These services included
those of private investigators and asset search specialists. The non-leged contractors
were hired to augment RTC Investigations staff in their attempts to identify prob-
able cause for litigation against former officers and directors of failed institutions.
Outside counsel supervised and guided the non-legal contractors and billed the
Legal Division for tneir services. Once the non-legal contractors identified any po-
tential claims, the outside counsel that initially hired the non-legal contractor would
litigate the matter for the Legal Division.
FIRREA requires that RTC contract in an efficient manner and provide adequate
competition and fair and consistent treatment of all offerors. The Legal Division was
able to bypass the normal contracting process because RTC contractor selection pro-
cedures specifically exempted legal services (outside counsel) from the standard pro-
cedures. However, the services indirectly contracted for on behalf of RTC Investiga-
tions by the Legal Division were not legal services.
According to an RTC Investigations section chief at Washington headquarters, the
contracting arrangement between the Legal Division's PLS and RTC Investigations
developed because of concerns about confidential information being disseminated to
the puolic, a large number of failed institutions for which the statute of limitations
was expiring, and insufficient internal resources to investigate these institutions.
RTC Investigations did not believe that its contracting needs could be met through
normal RTC contracting procedures because RTC contracting procedures required
the release of confidential, institution-specific information to large numbers of po-
259
tential contractors. The RTC Investigations section chief believed release of the in-
formation would compromise potential litigation. RTC Investigations sought relief
through the RTC Executive Director's office by asking for a special contractmg waiv-
er granting it the authority to establish a Basic Ordering ACTeement with a limited
number ofcontractors bound by confidentiality agreements. The RTC Office of Con-
tracts opposed the arrangement and no other arrangement or relief was granted to
RTC Investigations.
While the contracting authority issue remained unresolved, RTC Investigations
had a considerable number of failed institutions for which the statute of limitation
was expiring. Approximately 200 failed institutions, most of which had failed before
RTC's formation, had not been investigated for possible litigation claims. In addi-
tion, RTC Investigations was not adequately stafled because it was just beginning
to hire and train its own personnel. Faced with a lairge backlog of failed institutions
which had not been investigated and concerns with the normal contracting proce-
dure, RTC Investigations sought relief through the Legal Division.
Although there were extenuating circumstances, using the contracting arrange-
ment between the Legal Division and RTC Investigations created several adverse
effects. First, fair and consistent treatment of all potential offerors was not assured
by the Legal Division. Further, an additional layer of contractor management was
added to the contracting process, resulting in adoitional expenditure of mnds to pay
the outside counsel for managing the non-legal contractors. Additionally, the Legal
IDivision introduced a potential conflict of interest by hiring outside counsel to deter-
mine whether grounds existed to litigate the case when the same outside counsel
would be paid to undertake that litigation.
PLS selected outside counsel from its own list of outside counsel which includes
firms that have not been approved for placement on the Legal Division's List of
Counsel Utilized. Also, the PLS hired outside counsel to perform a contract manage-
ment fianction and did not give ecjual consideration to all potential contractors who
had met the criteria to contract with RTC. In addition, the outside counsel were not
required to hire these non-legal contractors from the RTC Contractor Database.
Therefore, non-legal contractors who had completed the requirements to contract
with the RTC were not given adecjuate consideration. Those non-legal contractors
who worked with the outside counsel previously may have received an unfair advan-
tage over contractors on the RTC Contractor Database because they had worked
with the law firm before.
The use of outside counsel to hire and manage non-legal contractors added addi-
tional management oversight layers to the contracting process. All coordination ef-
forts between RTC Investigations staff and the non-legal contractors hired by out-
side counsel were conducted through the Legal Division and then through the out-
side counsel because only Legal Division stall could contact the outside counsel. An
RTC Investigator pointed out that there were occasions when the Legal Division
hired outside counsel to hire a non-legal contractor to perform an investigation of
a failed institution and RTC Investigations was unaware of the work being per-
formed and was unable to coordinate investigative efforts. The additional layers of
management oversight were inefficient and unnecessary.
The hiring of outside counsel to hire non-legal contractors was also an inefficient
use of RTC's limited resources. Outside counsel who hired non-legal contractors usu-
ally charged an hourly rate for managing and overseeing the non-legal contractors.
No controls or limits were in place governing how much could be bUled for these
services or how to verify the actual contractor oversight provided.
Hiring outside counsel to hire, non -legal contractors to determine whether the
Legal Division has reasons to litigate or pursue a claim against officers or directors
of a failed institution introduced a potential conflict of interest between the outside
counsel hired and RTC. When the Professional Liability Section hired outside coun-
sel to hire non-legal contractors, that outside counsel was also hired to litigate any
ftrofessional liability claims from failed institutions. This arrangement placed the
inns' financial interests in conflict with their ability to objectively investigate and
evaluate possible claims and actions against former directors and officers of failed
institutions.
The Legal Division did not have established procedures for outside counsel to
identify and bill the non-legal contractor fees and expenses to the Legal Division in
a standard or consistent manner. Some law firms billed the non-legal contractor fees
through the expense portion of their monthly invoice, while others had the non-legal
contractor bill the Legal Division directly. There are no accounting procedures re-
quiring these charges to be identified and recorded separately from regular legal
services fees and expenses. Without this distinction, RTC cannot determine how
much has been spent in contract management-related fees to outside counsel or
identify how much has been paid to non-legal contractors hired by outside counsel.
260
Recommendations
We recommend that the Senior Vice President and General Counsel, RTC Division
of Legal Services:
(1) Establish adeqruate internal controls, including monitoring procedures to en-
sure compliance witn the new policies and procedures on competitive retention of
outside counsel.
(2) Develop new procedures to clearly define when evaluations of outside counsel
are to be prepared and enforce adherence by establishing mechanisms to ensure
that evaluations are prepared.
(3) Discontinue the practice of using outside counsel to hire non-legal contractors.
(4) Implement adequate internal controls, such as policy statements prohibiting
third party contracting, to ensure adherence to RTC's established contracting poli-
cies and procedures when contracting for non-legal services.
Corporation Comments and OIG Evaluation
A summary of the Corporation's response to each of our recommendations and our
analysis follows:
Establish internal controls to ensure compliance with competitive reten-
tion policies and procedures (recommendation 1): The Division of Legal Serv-
ices has created a new organizational section entitled the Outside Counsel Manage-
ment Section. A group within that section, called the Policies and Procedures Unit,
is responsible for drafting, implementing, and overseeing the implementation of gen-
eral policies and procedures relating to the management of outside counsel. This
unit wUl perform visitations and weekly telephone conferences with field Legal
Services Coordinators, but it is unclear from the Division's response what specifi-
cally will be reviewed during these visits or teleconferences. In addition. Legal Serv-
ices Committees have been appointed in each field office, as well as at headquarters
in Washington. Among the duties outlined for these Committees include serving as
an oversight mechanism to monitor the selection and retention of outside counsel
and to ensure compliance with the competitive procedures. The institution of these
two groups addresses our recommendation, but to close our recommendation we wUl
need to review documentation on the specific responsibilities and duties of each
group.
Develop and enforce procedures on outside counsel evaluations (rec-
ommendation 2): The Division of Legal Services' Outside Counsel Management
Section plans to develop and implement procedures outlining specific requirements
for the evfduation of outside counsel. In addition, the Division plans to have the ini-
tial evaluations updated periodically, at least annually. Also, for monitoring pur-
poses, they intend to have the field offices report on the evaluations completed.
These actions by the Division should address our recommendation. We will need to
review those procedures and the steps the Division has taken to monitor evaluation
preparation to close the recommendation.
Discontinue the practice of using outside counsel to hire non-legal con-
tractors (recommendation 3): According to its response, the Division of Legal
Services determined that it has the delegated authority to hire non-legal contractors
through its outside counsel contracting agreements and intends to continue to do
so. In addition, the Senior Vice President and General Counsel provided several rea-
sons why the Division believes this contracting was necessary and justified. These
reasons include attorney-client confidentiality, expediency, and insuflicient numbers
of in-house investigators. As stated in our report, we agree that extenuating cir-
cumstances surrounded the need to obtain investigation services quickly. However,
we disagree that these reasons continue to be valid. For example, the Division of
Legal Services implies that a greater privilege attaches when a contract is passed
through an outside attorney than if the same investigation is done through standard
procedures. We do not believe this is true. Specifically, if an attorney, whether em-
ployed by RTC or as outside counsel, reviews a matter and determines that fiirther
investigation needs to be done in support of anticipated litigation, an equally valid
argument can be made that the investigation is a part of the attorney work product
whether the investigator was hired by KTC through its contracting process, or was
hired by outside counsel.
In addition, the Office of Investigations has been given the authority to use Basic
Ordering Agreements (BOA's) to contract for investigators. Therefore, because it will
be able to provide prompt and sufficient numbers of investigation services, the Legal
Division should discontinue the practice of using outside counsel to hire non-legal
contractors.
Implement internal controls to ensure adherence to RTC*s contracting
policies for non-legal services contracting (recommendation 4): As stated
261
above in recommendation 3, the Division does not intend to discontinue the practice
of using outside counsel to hire non-legal contractors, so the Division did not ad-
dress this recommendation concerning policies to ensure the practice does not hap-
pen.
Chapters
Legal Division Did Not Have Adequate Management Information Systems
The Legal Division's information systems did not capture important information
or produce reports the Division needed to adequately manage its operations in ac-
cordance with policies, procedures, and statutory requirements and to ensure that
it fulfills its responsibilities. The systems, for the most part, were developed before
FIRREA gave FDIC responsibility for insuring savings institutions, handling the
former Federal Savings and Loan Insuremce Corporation's receiverships, and man-
aging RTC. The Legal Division's systems were not designed to handle the workload
related to these added responsibilities nor were they designed to capture and report
information on various FIRREA requirements, such as those related to Minority/
Women Owned Businesses usage and the fitness and integrity of contractors. Fur-
ther, although the FDIC Legal Division had taken steps to improve its information
systems, its actions were not timely and, in some cases, were ad hoc. Additionally,
measures taken to ensure the integrity of the data collected or generated during
Legal Division efforts to improve its information systems were not adequate. We
also do not believe that all current and future information systems needs have been
adequately addressed. We recognize that the enactment of FIRREA placed a tre-
mendous burden on the Division, along with the rest of FDIC/RTC. However, plan-
ning, developing, and implementing adequate information systems is vital to the Di-
vision's success. ^
Shortcomings of Information Systems
The Legal Division had a large number of individual, non-integrated information
systems which could not reliably produce needed information. For example, the
Legal Division's systems could not provide needed financial related information such
as total dollars spent for legal services or amounts paid to individual law firms in
any 12 month period. Further, the List of Counsel Utilized database did not have
sufficient information to be used as a selection tool by Legal Division attorneys.
Also, conflict of interest information was not systematically compiled so that infor-
mation on conflicts rspwrted by outside counsel or from the Outside Counsel Con-
flicts Committee was available to Legal Division attorneys selecting outside counsel.
Moreover, the Legal Division's Case Management System did not contain adequate
information on outside counsel. Specifically, information on when a matter was re-
ferred to outside counsel, the extent women and minorities were involved in the
legEil work, and whether a firm was inherited counsel was not available.
According to the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Com-
mission, information systems are intrinsic to all control systems and affect a variety
of activities of an organization. Information systems include all the processes and
actions that identify, move, assemble, classify, record, report, and store information
that is needed in an organization to plan, monitor, and execute its activities. The
information system must be able to:
• identify economic events and other occurrences that significantly aflect the organi-
zation and its transactions,
• move information from a point of entry to the various users,
• relate various data to other relevant data,
• classify transactions to accurately reflect the nature of what is happening,
• organize and store the data,
• record the information in a manner that helps management control the entity's
activities, and
• produce reliable reports.
Additionally, the information must be delivered in a complete, accurate, and time-
ly fashion to those who need it and in appropriate levels of detail and analysis for
^^ Prior reports by both the FDIC Office of Inspector General and outside consultants have
cited similar problems. These reports were entitled Information Management Report for the
Legal Division, Part 1, Hildebrandt, Inc., September 26, 1991; and Report on the Legal Case
Management System, FDIC/OIG, March 9, 1990.
262
their use. The information must be stored so that it is available for later use or to
meet legal requirements.^^
Hie Legal Division needs information systems which can provide detailed com-
Erehensive data for them to manage their operations efficiently and effectively,
egal Division management must know and be able to substantiate whether they
are in compliance with certain statutory requirements, such as FIRREA's require-
ment to maximize to the fullest extent possible the use of women and minorities.
The Legal Division was unable to provide complete information regarding minority
and women participation in matters referred to outside counsel or to determine how
many matters have been referred to outside counsel or when these matters were re-
ferred. Legal Division management must also ensure that the Division is in compli-
ance with its own internal policies and procedures, such as the $2.5 million fee
cap.^^ Further, Legal Division management needs adequate information to manage
and control expenditures and to ensure that qualified outside counsel are selected
to handle legal matters.
Reliable Financial-Related Information Was Not Readily Available
The Legal Division was unable to reliably determine how much was spent for
legal services or the dollar amount of contractual commitments with outside counsel.
There was no centralized system to capture nationwide financial data. The Legal
Division systems captured only limited financial information supplied by outside
counsel. This information included the fees and expenses incurred to date and the
estimated fees and expenses required to complete the case.
The FDIC's general ledger system captured financial information on legal bills
paid by the Corporation. Some entities, such as conservatorships, pay legal bUls di-
rectly— not through FDIC's Accounts Payable Unit. Because tnese payments were
paid directly, the information was not captured in the FDIC general ledger. Accord-
ing to a joint FDIC/RTC news release, these direct paid expenses represented about
SOpercent of all FDIC/RTC legal expenditures.
The reliability of the information recorded in FDIC's general ledger system was
questionable because of three significant internal control weaknesses within the biU
paying process performed by FDIC's Division of Accounting and Corporate Services
CDACS). First, DACS did not have a control mechanism in place within its check
authorization system to identify payments approved for identical invoice numbers
until November 1990. Second, there was no control mechanism to verify whether a
matter being billed was actually authorized by the Legal Division. Lastly, DACS
paid invoices without requiring the vendor to provide a unique invoice number. In-
stead, DACS would "create" invoice numbers for the invoices. Each of the three in-
ternal control weaknesses identified introduced significant levels of risk that over-
payments or unauthorized payments could be made to outside contractors being
paid through the FDIC general ledger system. Moreover, DACS' ability to detect
overpayments and unauthorized payments to outside counsel was severely curtailed
because invoices received fix>m outside counsel were not logged in and tracked
through a single standardized system. As a consequence, neither the regional offices
nor headquarters were able to provide a single listing of all invoices received for re-
view and approval to compare against actual payments made to outside counsel.
Information not captured by FDIC's general ledger, sudi as payments made di-
rectly by conservatorships, was gathered through alternative methods. The reliabil-
ity of this information was also questionable. To gather information on 1990 legal
expenses not captured in FDIC's general ledger, the Legal Division sent information
requests to the conservatorships which directly paid legal expenses. The Division
asked the conservatorships to estimate amounts paid during the first three quarters
of 1990 and the anticipated amounts to be paid in the fourth quarter of 1990. The
Legal Division was unsure as to whether complete information was captured using
this method of data collection because a substantial number of the conservatorships
did not respond to the information request. The lack of reUable information regard-
ing payments made outside the FDIC general ledger system also made it impossible
for the Legal Division to reasonably determine how much had been paid to individ-
ual law firms. In an effort to comply with the Legal Division's $2.5 million cap pol-
icy, regional office personnel routinely called the individual law firms and asked
^Internal Control-Integrated Framework, Exposure Draft, March 12, 1991, Committee of
Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission.
"On February 13, 1991, the Legal Division established a policy which limited the fees outside
counsel could receive to $2.5 million in any 12 month period. Fees from RTC and FDIC are sepa-
rate for purposes of determining whether the cap has been reached. The Legal Division believed
that this policy would promote mere efficient and economical l^al services. Nonetheless, the fee
cap could be exceeded upon written a[^rova1 from designated FDIC c^cials.
263
how much the firm had been paid in the last 12 months before referring new mat-
ters to that firm.
Subsequent to the August 1991 completion of our field work, RTC Legal Division
implemented its management information system — RTC Legal Information System
(RLIS). This system is budget-based and requires outside counsel to submit a budget
of expected fees and expenses associated with an assigned matter to receive pay-
ment. On February 18, 1992, the RTC Legal Division established RLIS policies and
procedures. These procedures indicate that RLIS will provide the Legal Division
with a broader spectrum of much needed information. All invoices submitted by out-
side counsel, including those of firms providing services to conservatorships and
Standard Asset Management and Disposition Agreement contractors, must be sub-
mitted to the Legal Division to be recorded in RLIS. By recording this information
in RLIS, the Division should be able to more accurately determine the invoices re-
ceived and the related legal fees and expenses. Further, the procedures provide for
additional controls over outside counsel invoices, such as recjuiring a unique invoice
number. RLIS is set up to reject invoices with duplicate invoice numbers.
Because RLIS is a budget-based system, it should provide the Division with more
financial-related information and allow the Division to monitor estimated fees and
expenses and to ensure that matters and associated fees and expenses have been
approved by the Division. This information should enable the Division to monitor
and enforce the $2.5 million fee cap. However, RLIS currently has limited standard-
ized reporting capability which may hinder the Division's efforts in monitoring Legal
Division operations. While RLIS has ad hoc reporting capabilities to extract required
information, this technique is very time consuming; thus, less efficient.
LCU Database Did Not Provide Sufficient Information
Legal Division attorneys stated that they could not use the List of Counsel Uti-
lized as provided by headquarters to select outside counsel to represent the Legal
Division. The List of Counsel Utilized database included information on the firm's
location, telephone number, and contact person but did not include other necessary
information. Specifically, it did not include information on a firm's expertise, hourly
rates, conflicts of interest, or performance evaluations. As a result, many Legal Divi-
sion field attorneys did not use the List of Counsel Utilized when selecting firms.
Instead, they relied on their past experiences with firms with which they or their
colleagues were familiar. Further, the regions had developed their own unique list
of firms to compensate for not having an adequate national database. Regional lists,
such as the one in the Southwest Region, indicated the firms' rates and expertise.
In general, the firms on the regional lists were also on the headquarters List of
Counsel Utilized. At the headquarters level, PLS also maintained its own list of
firms which was supported by a unique database developed by PLS. This database
contained information as to whether a firm was restricted from receiving new work,
the firm's expertise, conflicts of interest, and performance evaluation. However, PLS'
list contained firms which were not on the LCU. Manv field attorneys called PLS
to obtain information on conflicts and outside counsel performance which is not
readily available to them through other means.
RLIS contains a database of outside counsel approved by the RTC Legal Division
to provide legal services. Legal Division personnel stated that this database or List
of Outside Counsel includes all firms who have executed an RTC Legal Services
Agreement. The database contains information such as a firm's office locations, serv-
ice area, contact information, and Federal Tax ID similar to information provided
by the old List of Counsel Utilized. However, the List of Outside Counsel provides
additional information such as the firm's rate structure and limited conflict of inter-
est information on outside counsel. Nonetheless, RLIS does not appear toprovide
information in two areas — a firm's expertise and performance evaluations. The RTC
Legal Division has recognized the need for firm expertise in RLIS and intends to
include this information in future RLIS enhancements. Readily available informa-
tion on a firm's performance also is crucial to ensure that only superior performing
firms render services to the Legal Division and ultimately to the Division's client —
RTC.
Conflict Of Interest Information Was Not Readily Available
No centralized system captured information on conflicts of interest and made the
information available to Legal Division attorneys referring matters to outside coun-
sel. Conflicts of interest reported by outside counsel were not logged in or tracked
centraUy.
Limited conflict of interest information, such as a brief recapitulation of the con-
flict and the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee (OCCC) decision, was maintained
by a member of the OCCC in a WordPerfect* file on his personal computer. Data
264
retrieval and processing under this arrangement was only marginally adequate be-
cause WordPerfect * is a word processing software package which is unable to orga-
nize raformation in a useful manner such as by type of conflict or by numbers of
conflicts for a particular firm. Additionally, there was no eflicient means for anyone,
other than the OCCC member or his secretary, to access these files because the in-
formation was resident and accessible only on the OCCC member's computer located
in his office or in the chronological paper files maintained by his secretary. As a
result, without an interface between other potential users of this information, such
as the preparers of the headquarters List of Counsel Utilized, the information only
benefited the immediate members of the OCCC.
Additionally, only information related to OCCC decisions was available in this
file. There were no systems in place to record self-reported conflicts received from
outside counsel. As a result, we were unable to determine how many self-reported
conflicts of interest were received and whether all self-reported conflicts were prop-
erly forwarded to the OCCC for consideration.
RLIS contains limited conflict of interest information. The system shows whether
or not a firm has a conflict and also provides a brief description of the conflict. How-
ever, after RLIS was implemented, tne Legal Division realized that the limited con-
flicts information to be contained in RLIS was not adequate for its purposes. Also,
RLIS would have required extensive changes to meet the Legal Division's needs
which would have been too costly. Therefore, the Legal Division decided to develop
another management information system to disseminate conflict of interest informa-
tion to all Division offices. The Division expects this system to be operational by Oc-
tober 1, 1992.
Case Management System Did Not Provide Sufficient, Reliable Information
The Legal Division could not determine whether all matters referred to outside
counsel were entered into the Case Management System (CMS). For matters en-
tered into CMS, the Legal Division could not determine the date the matter was
referred to outside counsel. The date a matter was actually referred to outside coun-
sel is an important internal control mechanism. This date is necessary to detect
such things as whether outside counsel billings reflect work done only after the mat-
ter was referred and whether Legal Division stafl" were referring new matters to
firms which may be restricted from receiving referrals — such as when the firm has
a conflict of interest pending before the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee. CMS
only captured the date that the CMS technician entered the case data into the sys-
tem, which according to the CMS Manager, often bears little relation to the date
the matter was referred. The only way to determine the actual date of referral was
to search the individual case files maintained by the individual Legal Division attor-
ney handling the matter. In an example provided by the CMS Manager, a matter
was referred to outside counsel in April 1989, but was not entered into CMS until
February 1991-22 months later. Because of this weakness, the Legal Division was
unable to determine the number of matters referred to outside counsel during 1990
and the date of referral.
The Legal Division was unable to provide complete information regarding minor-
ity and women contractors' participation in matters referred to outside counsel. Al-
though the Legal Division required minority and women participation information
to be reported on outside counsel's invoices, the receipt, reporting, and recording of
the information was not enforced. As a result, to obtain minority and women partici-
eation information, the Legal Division had to query two sources outside the Legal
livision for information. First, the Legal Division requested the DACS Accounts
Payable Branch to provide a report detailing the amounts paid to outside counsel
which are classified as minority or women owned businesses. Second, the Legal Di-
vision requested minority and women participation reports from outside counsel. Re-
sponse to these information requests from outside counsel was voluntary and only
about 60 percent of the outside counsel responded. There were no controls in place
to verify the reasonableness of the data received from outside counsel, short of au-
diting each outside counsel's response.
The Legal Division also could not adequately identify throu^ CMS inherited
counsel — those firms who were pursuing matters at the time an institution was
placed into receivership.
According to Legal Division procedures, no new matters were to be referred to in-
herited counsel without a Legm Services Agreement. Inherited counsel were to com-
plete only those matters they were working on at the time of the institution's receiv-
ership. CMS did not identify which counsel were inherited and how long thev had
been representing the Legal Division As a result, the Legal Division was unable to
determine whether a firm receiving payments was an innerited counsel, how long
inherited counsel had been representing the Legal Division without a Legal Services
265
Agreement, and whether inherited counsel were being referred new matters in viola-
tion of Legal Division procedures.
The February 18, 1992, RLIS Office Procedures Manual for RTC Le^al Matters
requires outside counsel, when submitting an invoice to the Legal Division, to com-
plete a form entitled "Legal Invoice for Fee & Expenses (LIF & E)." Information pro-
vided on this form includes fees billed by women and minority attorneys. The proce-
dures further provide that RLIS Data 'fechnicians, iipon receipt of the LIF&E, ex-
amine the document for missing information and, if necessary, return the invoice
documentation to outside counsel for proper completion. If properly implemented,
these procedures should provide the Division with more complete information on
women and minority participation.
The procedures also address inherited outside counsel. Upon intervention in a
failed institution. Legal Division personnel identify ongoing matters and the firms
handling these matters. If a firm is not listed in RLIS' List of Counsel, the firm is
then identified in RLIS as inherited. The procedures require that the firm not ac-
cept new matters until it has executed an RTC Legal Services Agreement. Further,
if no agreement is executed within 90 days of intervention, then the RTC attorney
in charge of the matter is required to transfer the matter to another firm.
iNFORNfATION SYSTEM NEEDS WERE NOT TiMELY Or EFFICIENTLY MET
The Legal Division's information needs were not met in a timely or efficient man-
ner. Further, long-range goal setting and strategic planning for such things as fu-
ture information needs, technological changes, cost controls, and data integrity had
not occurred. As a result, the Legal Division was beset by a proliferation of many
different information systems capturing the same information both within a region
and across the Nation. Without thorough planning and goal setting to address fu-
ture information needs and changes, the Leged Division will be destined to follow
a reactive role to its changing environment and risks periodic loss of control over
its abUity to meet its information requirements and respwnd to changes and chal-
lenges most efTectively.
Contractors were designing two major information systems for the Legal Division.
The first system is the Legal Division Information Management System (LDIMS),
which was solicited to address the needs of the various branches within the Legal
Division. LDIMS will not be available until late 1992. The second system was the
RTC Legal Information System (RLIS). Its original purpose was to enable the RTC
Branch to manage matters referred to outside counsel by Standard Asset Manage-
ment and Disposition Agreement (SAMDA) contractors, but it has now been ex-
panded to encompass all outside counsel information requirements.
Interviews with various management representatives of the RTC Branch revealed
that they were aware that monitoring and managing matters referred to the
SAMDA contractors required information that the Legal Division systems could not
provide. The RTC Branch information needs were immediate and could not wait
until LDIMS was in place — SAMDA contracts were being awarded and no LDIMS
completion date had been determined. According to RTC Legal Division staff, there
was no management support for a solution to this problem. As a result, a group of
RTC Branch attorneys contracted with Power Computing Corporation to design and
produce RLIS and obtained funds from the RTC Contractor Database budget to fund
the endeavor. The system design has undergone two major revisions since its incep-
tion. One change broadened the system application to include all RTC case informa-
tion needs, not just SAMDA contractor information requirements. The other change
incorporated an accounts payable module. The system was developed ad hoc, with-
out projjer technical oversight, and without adequate planning and support by Legal
Division management.
The challenges faced by the Legal Division to secure adequate information sys-
tems were complicated by the fact that throughout the Legal Division there was
very little control or standardization with regard to personal computer based soft-
ware applications. At every functional area, oetween regions and consolidated of-
fices, and not uncommonly, between Legal Division staff working at the same loca-
tion, different personal computer based systems have been developed on an ad hoc
basis to capture and process similar information. To illustrate, the Professional Li-
abilities Section referred matters to outside counsel yet it did not use CMS. Instead,
PLS maintained its own separate R-Base software application. This system provided
detailed information on the matters being pursued and the outside counsel being
used by PLS, but because R-Base is a software package which had not been ap-
proved for use by FDIC's Management Information Systems Branch (MISB), PLS
could not get technical support from MISB. Systems to capture and track important
information dilTered between regions and between consolidated offices.
266
In addition to a lack of control over personal computer based software applica-
tions, the Legal Division had not adequately addressed its current or future data
integrity needs. Without proper control over the quality of the information going
into CMS or the successor systems, funds and efforts to enhance or replace current
information systems may be expended needlessly. RTC Branch attorneys estimated
that approximately 75 percent of the information in CMS was RTC-related. How-
ever, tne RTC Branch stopped entering data into CMS and began recording new re-
ferrals into RLIS as of Ortober 28, 1991. RLIS had not been completed or tested
and training for the new system had not been completed.^* As a result, no parallel
system existed to which to compare data accuracy once RLIS had been completed
and tested. Instead, the Legal Division will have to continue to rely on outside coun-
sel to identify what matters they are woricing on and to provide the data required
to be input into RLIS. Because the adequacy of internal controls in place at each
individual outside counsel is unknown, the reliability of the data they provide is also
unknown.
Since the completion of our field work in August 1991, most of RLIS, including
the accounts payable module, has been implemented. The latest implementation
steps provide ftirther evidence of a lack of strategic planning, which resulted in
RLIS having limited standardized report generating capabilities and lack of sufli-
cient conflicts of interest information.
The RLIS report committee met for the first time on July 31, 1991, only 3 months
before RLIS was implemented. Because RLIS can produce few standardized reports,
ad hoc reporting must be performed to extract information for use by the Legal Divi-
sion in managing its operations. Legal Division personnel stated that information
had to be obtained using a query mnction which was extremely time-consuming.
Had the Legal Division identiiied the format and the information needed while de-
signing RLIS, a more efficient use of time and resources would have occurred and
the Division would have been able to more readily use the information in RLIS.
The Legal Division is also developing a new conflict of interest management infor-
mation system because the information in RLIS does not meet its needs. Had the
Legal Division identified needed conflicts information during the planning stages of
RLIS, the additional system might have been unnecessary.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The lack of adequate management support and planning of information systems
and needs left the Legal Division unable to produce reliable timely management in-
formation more than 2 years after the passage of FIRREA. Moreover, the lack of
adequate goals and planning casts doubt on the ultimate success of the Legal Divi-
sion's management information systems.
We recommend that the Senior Vice President and General Counsel work in con-
junction with RTCs Office of Corporate Information and the Software Development
Office to:
(5) Perform an assessment of immediate and long-term information needs to de-
velop sj)ecific short- and long-term goals and objectives for the Legal Division's in-
formation systems. Develop strategic plans for attaining these goals and objectives
and identity resources needed. Adequate internal controls should be identified for
these systems during this planning process.
(6) Develop sufficient standardized reporting capability so that the Division has
readily accessible information to monitor and manage outside counsel.
Corporation Comments and OIG Evaluation
A summary of the Corporation's response to each of our recommendations and our
analysis follows:
Develop specific ahort- and long-term infornuUion gygtemg goals and plans
to reach those goeUs (recommendation 5): Although the Division's, response does
not address performing a needs assessment or developing long-term plans, it does
state that the RLIS Steering Committee is responsible for evaluating the operations
of the system to plan for future enhancements and adjustments. In addition, in its
response, it states that the Committee continuely reviews the progress of the RLIS
database and the developing information needs of the Division.
Although we encourage the actions the Division is taking as outlined above, these
actions do not go far enough to ensure that the Division's systems will address its
needs not only today, but in the future. Because it had not conducted a needs as-
sessment before it developed RLIS, it is now having to develop an additional system
" RLIS Operations Workshop was conducted by the Centech Group for the Legal Division dur-
ing the last quarter of 1991. On February 18, 1992, the Legal Division issued pohcies and proce-
dures for using RLIS.
267
to track conflicts of interest information and having to make adjustments to the in-
formation RLJS is gathering to add necessary information fields. Therefore, we rec-
ommend that the Division aevelop systems goals and plans to reach those eoals.
Develop standardized reporting (recommendation 6): The Senior Vice Presi-
dent and General Counsel's response stated that RLIS is now capable of generating
standardized reports covering a variety of information. RLIS' increasing capability
to issue standardized reports addresses our recommendation. We will need to review
documentation showing the standardized reports to close our recommendation.
Chapter 4
Poor Controls Led to Overpayments
The Legal Division review process for outside counsel invoices and the program
the Division used to pay these invoices allowed overpayment of outside legal coun-
sel. The Division did not have an adequate oversight mechanism to ensure the effec-
tive fiinctioning of the review process and did not provide sufficient guidance to the
Legal Division staff responsible for performing the review. Additionally, one pro-
5am used to pay outside counsel invoices — the Accelerated Payment Program
PP) — did not allow all overpayments to be identified before or after they were
paid. Under the APP, outside legal counsel was paid before the Legal Division re-
viewed the outside counsel's invoices. Also, the APP post-payment review, or rec-
onciliation between the amount paid and the amount approved for payment by the
Legal Division, was only required on a sample of invoices and therefore, could not
identify all overpayments.
Invoice Review Process Was Not Adequate
The review process for outside counsel invoices was not adequate to verify correct-
ness and to identify inappropriate or questionable charges. We attribute this condi-
tion to the lack of an oversight mechanism and adequate guidance for Legal Divi-
sion staff responsible for performing the review and to the implementation of the
Accelerated Payment Program. The Accelerated Payment Program reduced the in-
centive for Legal Division personnel to perform an adequate review because invoices
no longer required review and approval for outside counsel to receive payments. The
lack of an adequate review of outside counsel invoices had resulted in potential over-
ayments to outside counsel. We identified almost $300,000 in charges submitted
_y outside counsel on invoices totaling $3.5 million which we believe to be question-
able. Further, the Legal Division had reported receiving from outside counsel over
$10 million in refunds due to overpayments — mostly duplicate payments — from No-
vember 1990 to September 1991.
The Legal Division, in a brochure provided to outside counsel entitled A Law
Firm's Guide: How to be Considered for Retention by The FDIC and RTC and the
Legal Services Agreement, outlined the charges that the Legal Division would not
pay. These charges include:
• a firm's educational or developmental cost associated with becoming familiar with
statutory and case law pertinent to FDIC and RTC;
• a firm's overhead expenses including (1) secretarial or clerical overtim^ unless
such overtime is occasioned by an emergency situation created by FDIC/RTC; (2)
charges relating to word processing or computer time, except actual charges for
WesUaw* or Lexis* which will be reimbursed; and (3) the preparation of fee bills;
• first class travel or luxury hotel accommodations;
• an amount above 50 percent of an attorney's rate when the attorney is in actual
travel status;
• photocopying charges exceeding $.15 per page;
• taxes exceeding actual cost and excess faxes;
• excess overnight mail; and
• ordinary postage charges.
Further, the Legal Division's Procedural Memorandum 1.10, Fee Bill Processing,
requires the supervising attorney to review invoices for reasonableness and cost con-
sciousness.
Nonetheless, the Legal Division in some instances did not (1) ensure the appro-
priateness of charges on outside counsel invoices, (2) verify the rates charged by out-
side counsel to the agreements establishing outside counsel rates, or (3) conduct any
review of outside counsel invoices. There were no controls in place to ensure that
expenses, such as legal research, were approved and a work product received by the
Legal Division. Although quantifying invoices with inappropriate charges was not
one of our initial objectives, we did identify and quantify inappropriate charges at
two Legal Division locations — headquarters and the North Central Region. In total,
we found almost $300,000 of questionable charges on invoices totaling approxi-
I
268
mately $3.5 million. Sixteen of 50 Washington invoices and 29 of 120 Kansas City
invoices contained questionable charges. Table 3.1 shows the questioned chaises by
location.
Table 3.1: Questioned Charges
if -QIIESTIObfEb CHARGES
'NORTH
CENTRAL,
.REGION
HEADQUARTERS
TOTAL
Research
556,850
517,034
573,884
Photocopying
35.167
74,156
109,323
Travel
24.873
16,726
41,599
Fax/Delivery/Postage
7,245
1,596
8,841
Senior Partner Participation
on Depositions
3.825
0
3,825
Telephone
2,713
1,160
3.873
Overtime
0
38,079
38,079
Temporarv Services
0
1,597
1,597
Business Meals
0
830
830
TOTAL
5130,673
5151,178
5281,851
In the Southwest Region, we identified questionable charges related to senior
gartner participation on depositions on 4 of 9 1 invoices reviewed and in the Western
egion, we identified charges for such particioation on 4 of 111 invoices. We also
found senior peirtner participation on 4 of 120 North Central Region invoices. Depo-
sitions involve recording an individual's statement under oath and are usually fairly
straightforward processes which may not generally require senior partner participa-
tion. However, because of the limited scope of our audit, we did not contact outside
counsel to determine whether or not these charges were appropriate. Regardless, re-
sponsibility for ensuring appropriateness rests with the Legal Division and in these
instances they did not question the charges. In the Western Region, we identified
a single invoice with over $24,000 of charges for a senior partner to attend deposi-
tions. The rates chareed by this firm were also in excess of the established hourly
rates by $80. In the Western Region, we also found that travel time was not billed
at 50 percent of the firms' established rate on 9 of 120 invoices, as required by Legal
Division policy.
In the Southwest Region and Washington headquarters, some invoices were not
reviewed by Legal Division staff. In the Gulf Coast Consolidated Office of the South-
west Region, invoices submitted by outside counsel for services rendered to
conservatorships which were less than $5,000 were not reviewed by Legal Division
staff. In headquarters, one fee bill technician of the four interviewed was not re-
viewing invoices at aU until the APP reconciliation process began. Although review
of all invoices is required under the APP, the Legal Division under the APP rec-
onciliation process required a review of only a sample of invoices. Therefore, by
waiting until the reconciliation process began, the fee bill technician would be re-
quired to review fewer invoices.
Also, outside counsel did not always have established billing rates with the Legal
Division as evidenced by an executed Legal Services Agreement (LSA). Even when
the Legal Division did have an executed LSA with outside counsel, the LSA was not
always located at the same office where the invoices were reviewed. Further, the
LSA was not used to ensure that outside counsel's fees agreed with the LSA. The
rates billed on the invoices did not always agree with the rates established within
the LSA. The Legal Division required outside counsel to execute a Legal Services
Agreement upon retention. This agreement discloses the names of the legal firm's
employees who may work on FDICmTC matters and their rates.
269
In our sample of 114 firms/*^ 69 percent either did not have an executed LSA with
the Legal Division or an LSA could not be located at the consolidated offices. In
some instances, the firms' LSAs were filed at FDIC offices, but copies were not filed
with RTC offices within the same region. Further, rates on sampled invoices did not
concur with the rates established in the LSA for more than 30 percent of the in-
voices in our sample which had LSAs. In other instances, the names and rates
charged by outside counsel could not be confirmed with the LSAs because the LSAs
did not include the names and rates of all outside counsel employees working on
FDIC/RTC Legal Division matters. Table 3.2 shows the results of our analysis by
location.
Table 3.2: Sampled Firms Without Legal Services Agreements and Sampled Invoices That
Disagreed With Available Legal Services Agreements
LOCATION
PERCENTAGE OF
FIRMS WITHOUT LSAs
PERCLNTAGE OF
INVOICES WHICH
DISAGREED Wil'H LSAs
Eastern Region
70%
35%
Southwest Region
52
7
Western Region
93
50
North Central Region
70
39
Headquarters
14
40
The Legal Division also did not ensure that legal counsel inherited from failed in-
stitutions executed a Legal Services Agreement before new Legal Division matters
were assigned to the firm. Because iriherited counsel did not always have agree-
ments with the Legal Division establishing rates and reimbursable expenses, the
rates paid by RTC may have been higher than rates established in the LSAs for
similar firms in the same geographic location.
Prudert business practice would dictate (1) an in-depth review of invoices to en-
sure that the charges are correct and (2) establishing rates/reimbursable expenses
with outside counsel by executing an agreement for services. The U.S. General Ac-
counting Office's Assessing Internal Controls in Performance Audits provides, as a
general standard, that internal control systems are to provide "reasonable assur-
ance" that the objectives of the systems will be accomplished. An objective of an in-
voice review process should be to ensure the correctness of the invoices and to iden-
tify any deficiencies. However, the Legal Division's review process did not provide
reasonable assurance that outside counsel invoices were correct.
We attribute the inadequacies of the invoice review process to several factors.
First, the Legal Division's procedures on invoice review, as stated in Procedural
Memorandum 1.10 Fee Bill Processing, were not adequate. These procedures did not
provide a comprehensive list of inappropriate charges, provide specific guidance on
performing invoice reviews, or require the use of the LSA to verify the names and
rates of outside counsel employees on the invoice.^® Further, the Legal Division did
not have an oversight mechanism to ensure that the review process was adequately
performed or to diagnose problems in the review process. Finally, under the Acceler-
ated Payment Program instituted by the Legal Division in October 1990 to expedite
payment of outside counsel invoices, invoices no longer had to be reviewed and ap-
proved by the Division for outside counsel to receive payment. This program re-
moved any incentive for the Legal Division staff to perform a thorough review of
the invoices because the firms received payment regardless of the results of the
Legal Division's review. By not ensuring the appropriateness of outside counsel ex-
penses, verifying outside counsel employees and their rates on the invoices to the
•^"The Legal Division considers each law firm office as a separate law firm. Each law firm
office is listed separately on the LCU. Therefore, our use of the term "firm" may include mul-
tiple offices of the same firm.
^*A Law Firm's Guide: How to be Considered for Retention by the FDIC and RTC provided
only limited guidance on inappropriate charges and was intended for external use.
270
LSAs, or reviewing invoices, overpayments of outside counsel have occurred and the
potential for significant undetected overpayments is great.
The Legal Division is reconciling, on a sample basis, the amounts paid to outside
counsel under the Accelerated Payment Program and the amounts approved for pay-
ment by the Legal Division to detect overpayments. The Legal Division is also pur-
suing collection efforts to recoup overpayments identified miring the reconciliation
f)rocess. The Legal Division reported receiving refunds totaling over $10 million
rom November 1990 to September 1991 from outside counseL
Subsequent to the completion of our fieldwork in August 1991, the RTC Legal Di-
vision implemented RLIS' payment module. During the last quarter of 1991, the
RTC Legal Division informed outside counsel that after January 1, 1992, the APP
would be discontinued.
Under RLIS, invoices exceeding $5,000 are required to be reviewed by Legal Divi-
sion personnel before payment. However, in certain instances, such as when the
Legal Division has concerns over a firm's billing practices or when the firm is han-
dling a significant matter, all invoices submitted by the firm may be selected for
review. Also, every 50th invoice is to be reviewed. In addition, according to Division
personnel, they have contracted with a firm to set up a statistically valid review
process.
Other changes have also occurred in the review process. In February 1992, the
RTC Legal Division issued the RTC Guide for Outside Counsel which identifies re-
imbursable and nonreimbursable charges. This guide has incorporated some of the
same charges identified in an earlier FDIC publication, A Law Firm's Guide: How
to be Considered for Retention by The FDIC and RTC. However, the RTC Legal Divi-
sion has not yet issued its own invoice review procedures and by default, still ad-
heres to FDIC Legal Division's Procedural Memorandum 1.10. As mentioned in
Chapter 4, Procedural Memorandum 1.10 was not adequate because the procedures
neither provided a comprehensive list of inappropriate charges nor specific guidance
on performing invoice reviews. To invprove the review process, the RTC Legal Divi-
sion intends to include a checklist in RLIS to document invoice review.
For those invoices required to be reviewed under RLIS, the invoice processing pro-
cedures require verification of the invoice rates to the Legal Services Agreement.
The procedures also require verification between the employees listed on tne invoice
and those listed in the Legal Services Agreement. In instances where employees on
the invoice do not agree with the Legal Services Agreement, the Legal Division wUl
request the firm to provide a new provider list.
The Accelerated Payment Program Allowed Overpayment of
Outside Counsel
The Accelerated Payment Program (APP) resulted in overpayment of outside
counsel. The APP did not allow the Legal Division to identify overpayments before
payment. Additionally, the APP reconciliation process used by the Legal Division
and DACS to retroactively review invoices does not provide for the identification and
collection of all overpayments to outside counsel.
As discussed in Cnapter 1, the Legal Division implemented the Accelerated Pay-
ment Program in October 1990 to expedite payment of the large backlog of outside
counsel invoices. The APP allowed outside counsel to submit a pajntnent request di-
rectly to DACS, without review by the Legal Division, and to receive payment for
the full amount requested. Outsiae counsel also had to submit an itemized invoice
to the Legal Division for review and approval. On October 31, 1991, the FDIC Legal
Division discontinued the use of the APP to pay outside legal counsel and imple-
mented the Legal Services Invoice Program on November 1, 1991.^'' The RTC Legal ^
Division discontinued the APP and implemented the RTC Legal Information Sys-
tem's payment module on January 1, 1992.
The Legal Division and DACS began a reconciliation program in May 1991 to
compare, on a sample basis, the amounts paid to outside counsel under the Acceler-
ated Payment Program to the amounts approved for payment by the Legal Division
to determine overpayments. DACS selected a random sample of paid invoices and
requested Legal Division staff in the regions to review these invoices to identify any
disallowed charges for the selected invoices. If any were found, Legal Division stan
were then to send demand letters to the outside counsel requesting that outside
counsel remit refunds to Legal Division headquarters.
" Invoices submitted by outride counsel for services rendered to FDIC or RTC in their receiv-
ership and corporate capacities were paid through the APP. Outside counsel invoices related to
con-arvatorship activities were not included in the APP — each individual conservatorship was
responsible for pajing its own invoices. However, conservatorships were required to submit out-
side counsel invoices to the Legal Division for review and approval.
271
In the Southwest Region, we found instances where outside counsel received pay-
ment through the APP to which they were not entitled. Because the reconciliation
process is based on a sampling methodology, the Legal Division will not be able to
determine aU instances where outside counsel received payment for which they were
not entitled. As a result, outside counsel will be overpaid by an undetermined
amount.
Specific instances of overpayment in the Southwest Region i^hided:
• Outside counsel submitted pavment requests to DACS whichTmluded current and
past due amounts although the Legal Division had instructed outside counsel to
exclude past due amounts on payment requests. Outside counsel received pay-
ment for the total amount requested to be paid, including past due amounts. They
also received payment for past due amounts on the previously submitted invoices.
This double -billing resulted in duplicate pa)nment of the amount billed as past
due. For example, we documented two legal firms that billed DACS for over
$3,000 in total for past due amounts. Because this amount had already been sub-
mitted to DACS for payment on previous oayment requests, the firms will receive
overpayment of over $3,000. Unless DACS selects these invoices for review under
the reconciliation process, the overpayment will not be detected or collected.
• Outside counsel submitted payment requests to DACS for services rendered to
conservatorships. One firm received payments totaling over $14,000 from DACS
which should have been paid by the conservatorship.
• Outside counsel submitted payment requests for charges that the Legal Division
disallowed under the Payment Authorization Voucher Program. This program was
the precursor to the APP and required that the Legal Division review and approve
£dl outside counsel invoices prior to payment by DACS. In one example, the Le^l
Division disallowed over $500 in fees for one firm. This firm later billed DACS
under the APP for the disallowed amount and received payment.
• Collection activities were not pursued for large amounts of disallowances identi-
fied by Legal Division stafF. One invoice, brought to our attention, contsdned dis-
tdlowances of $80,000. However, Legal Division staff did not pursue recouping
these costs. Meanwhile, the legal firm went out of business, which will cause the
Legal Division difficulties in recovering any funds.
Even though the examples represented are from the Southwest Re^on, we believe
the problems represented coula be systemic throughout all the regions because of
the weak internal controls in the review, approval, and payment of outside counsel
invoices. The U.S. General Accounting Office's Standards for Internal Controls in
the Federal Government requires, as general standards, that management maintain
and demonstrate a positive and supportive attitude toward internal controls and es-
tablish control objectives and control techniques. The Standards require an agency
to establish control objectives by cycle (in this case, the expenditure cycle) and to
establish mechanisms to ensure that the obiectives are achieved. Additionally, pru-
dent business practice would dictate a well designed review and pajnment program —
including a system of internal controls — ^to ensure the payment of only appropriate
charges. , r*. . • •
The cause of the internal control weaknesses stemmed from the Legal Division s
primary concern for expeditiously paying outside counsel. To address a backlog of
unpaid legal invoices, flie Legal Division and DACS implemented the Accelerated
Payment Program but did not ensure adecpiate internal controls for the risks of the
program because of this concern. Although the RTC Legal Division discontinued use
of the APP on January 1, 1992, because only a sample of APP payments will be
reviewed, all overpayments may not be detected.
Cost Controls Over Matters Referred to Outside Counsel Were
Not Adequate
The Legal Division did not have adecjuate controls in place to manage and contain
expenses for the large number of matters referred to outside counsel under FDIC's
Case Management System. The limited controls which the Legal Division did have
were not applied consistently or to the extent necessary to be effective. The Legal
Division used two methods of control over outside counsel — monthly status reports
and case budgets. However, neither of them were effective. The monthhr status re-
ports, in fact, were potentially very costly. The monthly status reports from outside
counsel provided estimates every month of the costs and time required to resolve
a particular matter. The status report also provided outside counsel s latest estimate
of its probability of success in the matter. Legal Division attorneys reviewed the
monthly status reports to monitor the progress of referred matters. However, the
Legal Division did not analyze the monthly status reports for significant changes
in costs, estimates of costs, or time to complete the matter and reports of exceptions
were not produced. Because the Legal Division did not prepare trend analysis excep-
272
tion reports on the status reports and because of the large volume of matters being
monitored by Legal Division attorneys, the monthly status reports' effectiveness as
a control mechamsm was very limited.
In addition to their limited effectiveness, the monthly status reports were also
costly. The Legal Division allowed outside counsel to bill for the preparation of the
monthly status reports, but did not provide definitive billing guidelines. As a result,
outside counsel buled a variety of flat rates and hourly rates for the preparation
of the reports. For example, in the Southwest Region, billing rates for the monthly
status reports ranged from $20 (flat fee) to $234.00 (which included a $9.00 charge
to deliver the status report and invoice to a local regional oflice). The Legal Division
estimated that it received about 81,000 invoices for RTC-related matters each
month. Using a conservative approach by assuming the Legal Division pedd $20 per
month for a status report on 81,000 monthly matters, the Legal Division would pay
nearly $19.5 million in 1 year to outside counsel for status reports on RTC-related
matters.
The Legal Division also used case budgets to control costs of matters referred to
outside counsel. The case budget was also a weak cost control mechanism because
the Legal Division did not require the consistent use of case budgets for every mat-
ter referred to outside counsel. Additionally, the criteria for determining when a
case budget was required were unclear. The FDIC's Guide for Legal Representation
stated that upon referral, outside counsel should submit with a case plan an esti-
mate of the following: ( 1) legal fees and expenses to judgment or other completion;
(2) the date judgment or completion was expected; and (3) the probability of success,
stated as a percentage. These estimates, wnich were updated monthly through sta-
tus reports, were used to determine whether an individual matter was cost-eiTective
and as a benchmark to measure progress. If the estimates were substantial, outside
counsel would be required to submit a budget. At a minimum, the budget was to
set forth major assumptions, conform to the case plan, identify specific phases of a
case, and estimate the cost of each phase.
The term "substantial" was too vague to determine when a case budget should
be prepared and further definitions or benchmarks for determining "substantial"
were not given in FDIC's Guide or procedural memorandum. Each Managing Attor-
ney relied on his/her professional judgment in determining what was substantial
and whether a case budget was adequate when prepared. As a result, the Legal Di-
vision did not have adequate and efiective cost controls in place to contain outside
counsel costs. In addition to potential cost savings not being realized, the Legal Di-
vision was also not taking fuU advantage of controls such as case budgets which
would provide greater overall management control over operations.
Since the Au^st 1991 completion of our fieldwork, the RTC Legal Division has
issued new pohcies and procedures concerning the use of status reports and case
budgets. The RTC Legal Division's new RTC Guide for Outside Counsel states that
RTC will not pay for the preparation of invoices or routine status reports. However,
in the Outside Counsel Ueskbook, the RTC Legal Division permits outside counsel
to bill up to 4 hours for preparation of the Division's Evaluation, Referral, and
Budget Form and case plan which identifies the strategy for pursuing and complet-
ing a matter.
In addition, RLIS is a budget-based system and requires completion of a budget
by outside counsel for each matter. Unless RLIS has a budget for a matter, invoices
submitted by the firms will not be paid. Inherent to budget-based systems, the abil-
ity to determine the budget's reasonableness is key in controlling costs. The RLIS
Office Procedures Manual for RTC Legal Matters provides that an RTC Attorney re-
view the budget submitted for reasonableness and obtain approval from a Super-
visory RTC Attorney for the budgeted amount. However, the procedures do not pro-
vide guidance on determining reasonableness. RTC Legal Division personnel indi-
cated that RTC attorneys would be provided one-half day of training on case budg-
ets. This Umited amount of guidance and training may not be adequate for a man-
agement information system whose primary cost controls rests, not in invoice re-
view, but in up-front case budgeting.
Recommendations
We recommend that the Senior Vice President and (jeneral Counsel:
7) Ensure that Legal Division personnel seek approval throu^ the RTC Legal Di-
vision's delegated authority for any staffing amendments or rate changes by outside
counsel to the Legal Services Agreements. Legal Division staff should not approve
for payment any invoice amount that pertains to services rendered by unapproved
outside counsel employees.
(8) Revise invoice processing procedures to incorporate a comprehensive list of in-
appropriate charges.
273
(9) Enhance and standardize training on the review process policies and proce-
dures to include reviewing invoices for accuracy and identifying prohibited charges
and determining the reasonableness of case budgets submittea by outside counsel.
(10) Establish an oversight/review mechanism to ensure that Legal Division staff
adhere to the invoice processing policies and procedures.
(11) Consider incorporating responsibility lor internal controls into each manage-
ment level employee's performance standards.
Corporation Comments and OIG Evaluation
A summary of the Corporation's response to each of our recommendations and our
analysis follows:
Ensure personnel seek approval for staffine amendments or rate chtuiges
(recommendation 7): Accoromg to the Divisions response, it will not pay an in-
voice charging rates different the those listed on the Legal Services A^ement
(LSA) or listing attorneys not identified on the LSA, unless approved by the appro-
Eriate authority. The Division's response does not fully address our recommendation
ecause it does not outline how it intends to prevent payment of invoices with unap-
proved changes. We will need to review documentation explaining how it intends to
do this before we can determine whether the planned actions address our rec-
ommendation.
Revise invoice processing procedures (recommendation 8): In his response,
the Senior Vice President and General Counsel said that the RTC Guide for Outside
Counsel identifies the inappropriate charges which RTC will not pay. The Division
also has developed an invoice review checklist for use by legal technicians and attor-
neys when reviewing invoices. The checklist should address our recommendation,
but we will need to review it.
Enhance and standardize invoice review training (recommendation 9):
Technicians are trained in their local offices on invoice review procedures. The Divi-
sion is in the process of training Division attorneys on invoice review procedures,
including instruction on evaluating budget reasonableness. The training outlined
should address our recommendation, but we will need to review the training manu-
als and schedules.
Establish an oversight/review mechanism, to ensure that staff adhere to in-
voice processing policies and procedures (recommendation 10): The Division
did not address this recommendation in its response.
Consider incorporating interned controls responsibility into each manage-
ment level employee's performtMnce stcmdards (recommendation 11): The Divi-
sion did not address this recommendation in its response.
Chapters
Conflicts of Interest Were Not Adequately Documented and Communicated
Legal Division policies and procedures require that conflicts be reported to the
Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee for disposition. Nonetheless, the regions did
not report all conflicts to the Committee. Poor controls over receipt of conflict disclo-
sures Dy outside counsel prevented the Committee from monitoring receipt of con-
flicts and ensuring they were forwarded to the Committee. By not forwarding con-
flicts to the Committee, inconsistencies in handling conflicts and claims of favoritism
could result. In addition, the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee's policies for ad-
dressing conflicts were not sufficiently stringent and permitted firms whose mem-
bers had substantial conflicts of interest to receive FDIC/RTC matters. While the
Committee adhered to its policies and FIRREA requirements, it should have held
these firms to hirfier standard, reducing the potential for criticism and providing
confidence that FDIC/RTC maintains the highest levels of accountability. Further,
the method of communicating conflicts decisions throughout the Legal Division did
not provide Division personnel responsible for retaining outside counsel with suffi-
cient information. The potential exists that the Legal Division could retain firms
with existing conflicts of^interest, resulting in criticism and claims of favoritism.
Policies Were Not Sufficiently Stringent to Prevent Potentlvl
Criticism of Conflict Decisions
The Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee granted waivers to firms whose employ-
ees defaulted on substantial loans from insured depository institutions, which rep-
resented bidders for RTC assets and wanted to represent the RTC on other matters,
and/or which regional Legal Division personnel recommended that a waiver be de-
nied. Although the Committee's decisions fell within its policies and procedures,
granting waivers to these firms and allowing them to receive additional FDIC/RTC
matters did not fulfill the spirit of FIRREA. Additionally, granting waivers to these
274
firms could give rise to claims of favoritism by other outside counsel who did not
have conflicts, yet did not receive any matters. Further, these waivers increased the
potential for public embarrassment and criticism by the Congress.
In one firm, a managing partner, who was also the liaison with FDIC, and an as-
sociate of the firm, defaulted as guarantor on a participation loan totaling over $i
million. The firm did not inform the Regional Counsel or the Outside Counsel Con-
flicts Committee of this default. However, the Legal Division's Professional Liability
Section was aware of the conflict of interest, according to a regional Legal Division
attorney, and continued to use the firm, including the managing partner. Further,
the Professional Liability Section had not taken or planned to take any action con-
cerning the firm's failure to disclose the conflict. The regional attorney later dis-
closed the firm's conflict of interest to the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee and
recommended that the Committee waive the conflict because the firm had many
years of experience with FDIC and was one of only two outside counsel approved
for the geographic area. The Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee acknowledged
that the firm was "in violation of RTC regulation for failing to disclose the nature
of the debts of certain firm members and associates, and the fact of bankruptcy of
one attorney." However, it waived the conflict subject to several conditions designed
to screen the partner from working on or benefiting from FDIC/RTC matters.
In another firm, two partners defaulted on loans with failed insured depository
institutions. Regional attorneys recommended to the Outside Counsel Conflicts
Committee that a conflict waiver not be granted and the firm not be retained as
approved counsel. One of the firm's senior partners was a director of a failed deposi-
tory institution and owed $600,000 to that institution. He was also a partner in sev-
eral other partnerships with defaulted loans totaling $475,000. Another of the firm's
partners defaulted on a loan that totaled $700,000 made to a partnership of which
ne was a member. The Committee decided to grant a waiver to the firm provided
that neither partner was on the firm's management committee or received any prof-
its related to FDIC/RTC matters.
In a third firm, several members had defaulted on loans to failed depository insti-
tutions. One partner was obligjated as a guarantor on a loan of approximately $5
million from a failed savings institution. Another partner who was on the fmn's
management committee was a guarantor and partner of a loan to a joint venture
totaling $700,000 which was in default. The Committee waived the conflicts subject
to removal of the partner from the management committee.
In another firm, a partner of a firm who was in default on nearly $4 million to
insured depository institutions received FDIC/RTC work. He was a "name part-
nei'^ ^® in a firm which received over $3 million in fees during 1990 from FDIC/RTC.
Even though this firm was retained by the Legal Division and working on Legal Di-
vision matters, it was not registered as a contractor for FDIC/RTC. When it did
apply to become a registered contractor, the firm disclosed the defaults of its name
fiartner. The Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee approved the registration of the
inn as a contractor subject to certain conditions including screening the partner
from FDIC/RTC matters and prohibiting the partner from sharing in earmngs or
profits related to FDIC.
Another firm wanted to represent RTC, but had four existing conflicts of interest
including the representation of several clients who were potential and actual bidders
for RTC assets. It applied for a conflict waiver and the Outside Counsel Conflicts
Committee granted the firm a conditional waiver which allowed the firm to rep-
resent the bidders for RTC assets.
In another instance, the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee voted to waive a
conflict of interest even though the Southeast Consolidated Oflice and the Eastern
Regional Office recommended against a waiver. A partner in the firm was a defend-
ant in a directors and ofiicers liability suit of a large failed savings institution and
the firm was a defendant in litigation involving a dilierent failed institution.
FIRREA prohibits from RTC service any individual who has caused a substantial
loss to Federal deposit insurance funds, but it does not prohibit the use of firms
whose members have caused losses. The Committee adhered to its procedures for
evaluating conflicts and either waived conflicts or erected walls to prevent individ-
uals in these firms from participating in FDIC/RTC matters and/or from receiving
any profits. However, these procedures are not sufficiently stringent. With approxi-
mately 1,800 firms available for matters and many other firms registered as RTC
contractors, the Legal Division has many options available for selecting firms, which
may not have conflicts of interest with the FDIC/RTC. In selecting firms for mat-
ters, the Legal Division needs to hold firms to a high standard to ensure that the
public maintains confidence in FDIC/RTC and that it does not appear that FDIC/
^*The name of this partner was included in the name of the firm.
275
RTC is rewarding firms whose members caused significant losses to the insurance
funds.
Not All Conflicts Were Reported to the Outside Counsel
Conflicts Committee
Regional Legal Division personnel were aware of conflicts of interest but did not
always forwara them to the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee for review. Also,
outside counsel did not report potential conflicts as required. Poor internal controls
over recording the receipt of reported conflicts in a region allowed conflicts reported
to the Regional Counsel to remain unnoticed by Washington headauarters and the
Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee. Further, because the Legal Division did not
take enforcement action against firms which did not report potential conflicts of in-
terest, firms had little incentive to report conflicts. As a result, firms with potential
conflicts continued to receive FDIC/RTC work.
In one example, the outside counsel reported a conflict of interest to a Legal Divi-
sion regional staff attorney who, in turn, referred the conflict to the Regional Coun-
sel. The firm was representing clients adverse to FDIC/RTC while simultaneously
representing the FDK!^TC in their receivership and conservatorship capacities. A
staff attorney stated that these conflicts were "never submitted to the Conflicts
Committee bJecause he [the Regional Counsel] saw no need. He does not feel any
of these conflicts are that serious emd since the firm is not approved or likely to
be, he did not believe we should go [to] the Committee with them. You may continue
to use the firm. . . ." However, according to Legal Division procedures "no conflict
can be waived on behalf of FDIC [RTC] except with the approval of the Committee
or its Chairman.
In another example, a firm did not notify the region of a conflict of interest involv-
ing the firm's representation of a high profile individual in the financial industry.
When discovered, the regional office recommended that a waiver be denied and the
firm be removed from the LCU. The Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee voted to
discontinue referring matters to this firm until the matter was resolved, but this
restriction was not indicated on the LCU.^® Further, as of December 5, 1991, the
Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee had not readdressed whether the firm should
be denied a waiver.
Legal Division policies and procedures did not address contractor enforcement
sanctions for firms failing to report conflicts of interest. As a result, little incentive
existed for firms to report conflicts. Further, the Legal Division did not take suffi-
cient action against firms once the omission was discovered.
Conflicts Information Not Adequately Communicated Throughout the
Legal Division
The Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee did not provide sufficient information
on conflicts to Legal Division staff responsible for retaining outside counsel. Without
sufficient information on conflict disposition, the attorneys responsible for awarding
leg^ matters to the firms could award matters to firms with existing conflicts.
The Legal Division provided information regarding conflict decisions through
three formal lines of communication — a memorandum from the Outside Counsel
Conflicts Committee to the regional attorney who referred the conflict to the com-
mittee, a summary or action agenda^ of the committee's decisions sent to each Re-
gional Counsel, and special indicators on the List of Counsel Utilized. However,
mese communication cnannels were used primarily to disseminate information after
the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee made a decision. No formal information
channels existed to inform Legal Division attorneys in various consolidated and re-
gional offices that a potential conflict existed and had been referred for consider-
ation. Without this communication link, the potential for other Legal Division attor-
neys to continue to refer matters to firms witli unresolved conflicts was high.
In addition, the action agenda did not provide sufficient information regarding
conditional waivers (waivers with restrictions) placed on the firm. The action agenda
only indicated whether or not a waiver was granted, but did not reveal the condi-
tions or restrictions established by the waiver. As a result, a conditional waiver was
ineffective and unenforceable because Legal Division staff responsible for hiring out-
side counsel were unaware of the conoitions/restrictions imposed by the waiver.
^The regional office placed a restriction on the regional LCU prohibiting future awards of
matters to the firm.
*° The action agenda is a listing of conflicts of interest discussed by the Outside Counsel Con-
flicts Committee. It is distributed to the members of the committee and serves as a summaiy
of their meeting. The law firm name, a brief description of the conflict, and the Committee's
decision is listed on the action agenda. No discussion or explanation is given for the Committee's
decision.
276
Therefore, outside counsel with conditional/restricted waivers could receive legal
matters for which a conflict existed. Further, the List of Counsel Utilized was not
updated with conflict information. Firms with conflicts or restrictions were not fuUy
iaentified. As a result, no firms in the LCU dated March 1991 were identified as
having a conflict or as restricted. No other conflicts were identified on the LCU. The
total number of firms which had unresolved conflicts or restrictions was unknown,
but we were aware of 32 firms which were denied waivers and restricted in their
ability to represent the Legal Division by the OCCC between November 27, 1990,
and February 21, 1991. Also, firms with unresolved conflicts were not removed from
the LCU. In one instance, a firm had a lar^e number of conflicts and still appeared
on the LCU without any notation of restriction.
By not adequately communicating conflicts to regional staff, the Legal Division
cannot ensure that firms with conflicts were not awarded FDIC/RTC legal matters.
Also, the Legal Division cannot ensure adherence to FIRREA and may be subject
to claims of favoritism by outside counsel who have not received any legal matters
and to public embarrassment from disclosure of firms' conflicts.
Recommendations
We recommend that the Senior Vice President and General Counsel:
(12) Ensure that the conflicts of interest system being developed to centrally
record, report, and monitor all conflicts of interest provides detailed conflict of inter-
est information to the regions including information on restrictions and conditions
for each conflict.
(13) Require that the Outside Counsel Conflicts Conmiittee document the ration-
ale for its decisions for each conflict of interest.
(14) Evaluate the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee's policies and procedures
for decision-making and develop more stringent guidelines which would promote the
use of firms without conflicts oi interest.
Corporation Comments and OIG Evaluation
A sununary of the Corporation's response to each of our recommendations and our
analysis follows:
Ensure that new conflicts of interest system provides detailed information
(recommendation 12): The Conflicts Tracking System (CTS) is scheduled to be im-
plemented October 1, 1992. The system will be designed to track each conflict waiv-
er request through all stages of resolution and provide information in the conflict
and the disposition by the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee. We will need to
review the information provided by the new system to determine whether it ade-
quately addresses our recommendation.
Require that the Outside Counsel Conflicts Committee docuntent the ra-
tionale for its decisions for each conflict of interest (recommendation 13):
The Division's response stated that it anticipated that the CTS would provide, in
an abbreviated form, the rationale for each Conflicts Committee decision. The re-
sponse addresses our recommendation, but we will need to review the extent of the
information provided in the rationale documentation before we can, close the rec-
ommendation.
Evcduate policies and procedures to develop more stringent guidelines
which would promote the use of firms without conflicts of interest (rec-
ommendation 14): The Senior Vice President and General Counsel in his response
said that our concept would be a drastic change from current policy and might im-
pact the availability of firms for use by FDIC and RTC and must be carefully consid-
ered. It is not clear from the response whether the Division intends to evaluate its
policies and procedures to determine whether such a change would be beneficial to
RTC.
277
APPENDIX
APPEIVfDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
MEKORAJTOOM TO:
n»OM:
DATE:
80BJECT:
^
Hatolution Tnjit Corpo/anon
Sharor. I. Vander Vennet
Assistant rnspector General for Audit
Gerald L. Jacobs G"^-^
Senior Vice Presidents and General Counsel
Division of Legal Services
June 11. 1992
Response of the RTC Division of Leqal Services
to the Inspector General's Audit Report
The attached report presents the response of the Division of
Legal Services of the Resolution Trust Corporation to the
recoEmendations =ade in the audit report entitled "Controls Over
RTC's Legal Services Agreements" ("the Report"). The Report
suBunarized the results of a nationwide audit of the RTC's controls
over leqal services aqreenents, encompassing the entire process for
solicitation and retention of outside counsel.
The Inspector General's audit vas performed from March 1991 to
August 19Sfl, prior to the creation of the separate RTC Legal
Division and the Outside Counsel Management Section. Consequently.
most of the concerns expressed by the Inspector General in the
Report refer to policies and procedures which .ere in effect prior
to the separation of the RTC and FDIC legal Divisions. Many of the
policies and procedures then in place have been reviewed and
considered. Subsequent to Septer.ber 1991, we have noved rapidly to
54
278
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
implenent new policies, procedures, and systems which will »ore
effectively address the managenent and inforsatior. needs of the RTC
Leaal Division.
We believe that the Report issued by the Inspector General on
these topics is incomplete, due to the outdated inforaation on
which it is based and the Inspector General's failure to thoroughly
study and understand the very significant changes and improvements
made by the Legal Division since September 1991. The Report
frequently cites conditions that no longer exist and does not fully
discuss the changes and improvements made by the Legal Division.
We have addressed the specific concerns raised by the Report
and have identified policies, procedures, and systems which have
been implemented since the separation of the FDIC and RTC Legal
Divisions. These initiatives, implemented subsequent to the
completion of the Inspector General's audit work, address the
concerns raised in the Report and are responsive to the
recomnendations made by the Inspector General. We would welcome
the opportunity to discuss the improvements made by the Legal
Division, and we invite the Inspector General to review the new
policies, procedures, and systems implemented by the RTC Legal
Division.
55
279
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
CyECl/TlVE SUMMARY
The msoecTor General's auOi! v»as oeriormec •••i'r Marcr. 199' to August 199 V wif
ooiv minimal ucxsate Most, i* no; au. o< tne concerns eicesseo cv me inspectof General ir
the Heoori nave Been remediec cv tne Legal Oivisicr. Nune'Ous steos r^i^t oeen taken tc
aooress concerns aoout ooiicies. oroceaures. ar-,o systems uimzea ov ;ne ^TC .egai Oivisior
ano tne selection ana retention of outsioe counsel
Wa believe that the Report issued by the insoector General on these topics •$
incomplete, due to the ovrtdated intormation on which it is based arv} the insoector Ger^ral's
failure to thorouflhlv study and understand the very significant changes ano improvements
made by the Legal Oivision sirKe September 1991. The Report treoueniiy cites conditiorts
that no longer exist ar«3 does nm fufly discuss the changes and improvements made by the
Legal Division.
Policies and Procedures Concemino Outside Counsel
inspecTor General's Concerns:
The Report expresses concern that the Legal Oivision does not use a competitrve
process to reler routine-type matters to outside counsel, that outside counsel are not being
evaluated m accordarxre with policies artd procedures, and that the Professional Liability
Section CPLS'l used its conuactmg authority to circumvent normal RTC contractirtg
procedures by hiring outside counsel to contract with investigators.
RTC Leoal Division Response:
Wa are confident that t^a Irupector General's concerns will be alleviated by policies
and procedures implemented by the Legal Division since September 1991. Wa have
implemented policies and procedives which mandate specific engagement processes, to
ensure a more competitive process for the selection of outside counsel. Additionally. Legal
Services Committees have been appointed to monitor the selection and retention of outside
counsel and to ensure compliance with the competitive procedures.
Under our current procedures, new law firms are evaluated and ranked before receivir^g
any referrals. Evaluations will be updated periodically. 3nd at a minimum, at least annually.
The Outside Counsel Management Section plans to develop and implement procedures
outlining specific requirements for the evaluation of outside counsel
In accordance with the Delegations of Authority, the RTC Legal Oivision may retain
outside counsel and approve payment of fees (or services incurred m connection with legal
maners. such as investigators. cor«ultants. appraisers, or other expens. The procedures
followed by PLS in allowing outside counsel to hire non-legal contractors are consistent with
RTC contracting guidelines.
Manaoement Information Systems
inseecior General's Concerns:
The Repoa raises numerous concerns about the afieauacv of the Legal Division's
56
280
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
intormaiioo systems, whicn concerns O'lr^afiv 'tier lo ine inlormetion Svsiems used Bfio» tc
the seoaration of the RTC Legal Oivisior
RTC Legal Division Response
We recogniied the limitations oi tne D'eviCL.s Sister's anc oesigneo oeveiooeo, anc
implemented tne RTC Legai miofmation System rflLiS* ic alleviate inese problems
RUS provides complete and reliable information aoout law firms, legal matters and their
associated expenditures: allows us to monitor compliance wan statutory reauiremems and
internal policies: provides standardized reoortirig capability: and serves as a tod to be utilized
in the selection cocess for outside counsel.
Protection Against Ovefpavments
Inspector General's Concerns:
The Report raises concerns about the adequacy of the review process for outside
counsel invoices ary) the cost controls over invoices submitted by outside counsel.
RTC Leoal Division Response:
RLIS is a comprehensive information system that provides us with information
necessary to monitor legal matter budgets and to effectively review invoices.
All invoices from outside counsel are tracked through a single standardized system,
allowing us to detect potential overpayments and unauthorized payments. In addition, RLIS
invoice review procedures provide for an ongoing review of selected invoices to uncover
improper charges. To ensure adherence to the invoice processing policies, we have developed
an invoice review checklist.
Conflicts of Interest
Inspector General's Concerns:
The Report expresses the concern that conflicts of interest information is not
adequately disseminated to RTC attorneys, that not all conflicts of interest are reponed lo the
Conflicts Comminea. and that the Conflicts Committees ooiicies for addressing conflicts are
not sufficiently stringent and create the potential for criticism.
RTC Leoal Division Response:
RLIS has the capability to (lag law lirms which have a conflict of interest and provide
such information nationwide. In order to provide complete information about conflicts and
decisions of the Conflicts Committee, we are developing the Conflicts Tracking System
CCTS-).
The implementation of the CTS will ensure prompt reporting of all conflicts ana timely
2
57
281
APPE^fDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
Oissemination o( Confdcxs CommiTtee aedSions in aoamon. me Condicts Unit recentivissuec
O'oceoures mat sifengtnen tne feoui'ement tof trie fieid offices to fo'wafo conflicts to the
Contiicis Commif^e -o' nvaive' oec-Sio~s ~"e jni; m»' asc ce '^noiementing periodic
visitations tc review :ieio ofuce comoiiance wnn conthcts ooncies anc oroceoures.
As acKnowieogec ir. tre Reoor: a: C ;-e waiver oecisions eiammeo m trie fleooa tell
within the Conflicts Committee s ooncies ana oroceoures ana witnm statutory Oounaaries.
It IS anticioatea that CTS will orovioe. m some 8t>0reviatea form, the rationale (or each
decision o< the Conflicts Committee to provioe guiOance to RTC attorneys.
We have addressed the specific concerns raised Dv the Reoori and have identified
policies, procedures, and systems which have Been implemented by the flTC Legal Division.
These initiatives, implemented subseouent to the completion of the Insoector General's audit
work, address the concerns raised m the Reoon ana are responsive to the recommendations
made by the Inspector General.
58
282
APPENDIX APPEIVDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
OOTLINZ
:. INTROOUCTION
i;. BACKCROL'NC
III. SUMMARY OF RTC INITIATIVES
Selection and Retention of Outside Counsel
Management Information Systecs
Payaent of Outside Counsel
IV. POLICIES AND PROCEDURES CONCERNING OUTSIDE COUNSEL
Competitive Bidding for Routine Matters
Evaluation of Outside Counsel's Perforaance
Legal Division Contracting Authority
V. MANAGEMENT INFORMATION SYSTEMS
Information Storage and Retrieval
Conflict of Interest Information
Meeting f\iture Information Needs
VI. PROTECTION AGAINST OVERPAYMENTS
Invoice Review Process and Cost Controls
Accelerated Payment Program
VII. CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
Communication of Conflicts Information
Reporting of Conflicts to the Conflicts Comniittee
Conflicts Comaiittee Decisions
Documentation of Conflicts Connittee Decisions
VIII. CONCLUSION
283
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
RESPOHSE OF THE RTC DIVISION OF LEGAL SERVICES
TO THE IHSPECTOR GENERAL'S XODIT REPORT
This report presents the response of the Division of Legal
Services of the Resolution Trust Corporation ("RTC") to the
recommendations made in the audit report prepared by the_ RTC Office
of Inspector General, entitled "Controls Over RTC's Legal Services
Agreements" ("the Report"). The Report suiunarized the results of
a nationwide audit of the RTC's controls over legal services
agreements, encompassing the entire process for solicitation and
retention of outside counsel.
The stated objectives of the audit were to determine whether
(1) the RTC's use of legal services contractors was in accordance
with policy and guidance; (2) legal services agreements were being
used to circumvent normal contracting procedures; and (3) the RTC
was effectively and efficiently administering legal services
agreements. The Office of Inspector General performed audit work
in Washington, each of the RTC's regional offices, and selected
consolidated offices.
I.
IWTRODDCTION
The Federal Hone Loan BanJc Act ("FHLBA") , as amended by the
Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of
1989 ("FIRREA"), established the Resolution Trust Corporation
("RTC") to help resolve the savings and loan industry crisis. The
FHLBA provided that the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
("FDIC") would serve as exclusive manager of the RTC and that the
RTC would use employees of the FDIC. Therefore, the FDIC Legal
Division provided legal support and services to the RTC through its
RTC Branch. On September 10, 1991, the FDIC Board of Directors
approved the creation of a separate RTC Division of Legal Services
("RTC Legal Division"), and appointed Gerald L. Jacobs as General
Counsel to head the Division effective September 22, 1991. The
relevant provisions of the Resolution Trust Corporation
Refinancing, Restructuring and Improvement Act of 1991, which
became effective on February 1, 1992, removed the FDIC as the RTC's
exclusive manager and empowered a Chief Executive Officer to manage
the RTC, thus, further separating the two entities.
The current RTC Legal Division provides comprehensive legal
services to the RTC and represents the RTC in its corporate,
conservatorship, and receivership capacities. The RTC Legal
Division uses outside counsel to provide advice and legal support
to the RTC. Outside counsel and the RTC Legal Division are engaged
in a cooperative effort to provide their client, the RTC, with
efficient and cost-effective legal services.
60
284
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
The Inspector General's audit was perfonned from March 1991 to
August 1991,. prior to the creation of the separate RTC Legal
Division and the outside Counsel Management Section. Although the
Inspector General gathered additional information in March and
April of 1992 on initiatives taken since the conclusion of the
field work, after being requested to do so by the Legal Division
following review of a draft of the Report, the majority of the
field work for the audit was performed prior to the separation of
the RTC and FDIC Legal Divisions. Consequently, most of the
concerns expressed by the Inspector General in the Report refer to
policies and procedures that were in effect prior to the separation
of the two Legal Divisions. Such concerns do not adequately
reflect significant changes and improvements to the RTC Legal
Division's practices and procedures which were put in place during
the period between September 1991 and the final date of the Report.
Since the creation of the RTC Legal Division, we have taken
numerous steps to address concerns about policies, procedures, and
systems utilized by the RTC Legal Division and the selection and
retention of outside counsel. We recognized that not all of the
policies and procedures in place at the time of the separation were
well adapted to the nature and volume of RTC operations.
Therefore, we have moved rapidly to implement new policies,
procedures, and systems which will more effectively address the
management and information needs of the RTC Legal Division.
Although we appreciate the efforts of the Inspector General to
evaluate the policies, procedures, and systems of the Legal
Division and value the observations and recommendations made by the
Inspector General, we want to ensure that the extensive efforts
already made by the Legal Division to deal with the issues
addressed in the Report are recognized. It should be pointed out
that the RTC did, on its own initiative, implement policies,
procedures, and systems subsequent to the separation from the FDIC
Legal Division, and subsequent to the completion of the audit work,
which addressed the concerns raised in the Report and which are
consistent with the recommendations made by the Inspector General.
While the Report is outdated in many respects, it nevertheless
provides confirmation that the concerns addressed by the Legal
Division were exactly the concerns that needed to be addressed, and
it also provides an opportunity to review the initiatives we have
undertaken already. Thus, the Report is a valuable tool for
measuring the progress made by the RTC Legal Division since its
inception in September 1991.
61
^
285
APPE^a)lX ^PPE^''^
rORPORATION COMMENTS
II.
BACKGROUND
«
In September 1990, approximately one year after the RTC was
established, the FDIC legal staff dedicated to the RTC consisted of
299 attorneys, 12 of whom were located in the Washington
headquarters, with the renainder in the regional and consolidated
offices. By the beginning of September 1990, the RTC had been
given control of 243 institutions in conservatorship with gross
assets of S118.7 billion, and hundreds of institutions to be
resolved. The RTC was forced to operate and organize at the same
time. The Legal Division simultaneously had to provide all
required legal services to support the client's extensive
activities, acquire and train staff, computerize, and put in place
all desired policies and procedures.
In order to keep pace with the rapidly increasing voluoe of
work, the legal staff was expanded. By September 1991, at the time
of the separation of the FDIC and RTC Legal Divisions, the RTC used
1,289 legal staff, of which 576 were attorneys. As of March 31,
1992, the RTC Legal Division consisted of 1,563 leqal staff, of
which 680 are attorneys.
In 1990, the RTC Legal Division utilized 937 outside law finos
for RTC matters. In 1991, the number of firms utilized by the RTC
Legal Division more than doubled to 1,986.
As of May 1, 1992, the List of Outside Counsel maintained in
the RTC Legal Information System ("RLIS") contained a total of
3,991 "performing" and "inherited" law firms. Of those firms,
2,333 are "performing," meaning that they have executed Legal
Service Agreements with the RTC, and 1,658 are "inherited," meaning
that the firm provided services to the institution at the time it
went into conservatorship and continues to perform services for
thaX institution.'
The most legally intensive matters, and matters, therefore,
which require significant use of outside counsel, are in the
professional liability area. As of May 8, 1992, 194 lawsuits were
pending against directors and officers, attorneys, accountants, and
other professionals for their roles in the failure of savings and
loan institutions. In addition, as of March 31, 1992, 670
professional liability claim investigations were ongoing, and the
Professional Liability Section had made 816 criminal referrals to
the Department of Justice.
' Although outside counsel listed on RLIS are available for
use by the RTC, they may not currently be active. By February 29,
1992, the RTC Legal Division already had utilized 1,341 law firms,
both performing and inherited, in 1992.
62
n^_oi Q r\ r\A
286
APPENDIX APPENDIX
rORPORATlON COMMENTS
The utilization of outside counsel under the direction of RTC
in-house le^al staff has been very effective in professional
liability matters. In 1991, cash recoveries and agreed to
settlements in professional liability cases totalled $104.6
million. The fees and expenses paid to outside counsel in
professional liability cases in 1991 totalled $25.8 million, or
approximately 25* of the recoveries and agreed to settlements.
Through March of 1992, cash recoveries in professional liability
cases already totalled nearly S27.3 million. Fees and expenses
through the first quarter of 1992 were S5.4 million, or
approximately 20t of the recoveries.
III.
SOMMART OF RTC INITIATIVES
During the period of the audit performed by the Inspector
General, the RTC Legal Division was one of five branches of the
FDIC Legal Division and, as such, followed FDIC policies and
procedures. Since September 1991, we have adopted and implemented
new policies, procedures, and systems in a number of areas.
Selection and Retention of outside Counsel
Due to the extensive utilization of outside counsel by the RTC
Legal Division, the selection and retention of outside counsel is
an important process which must be monitored and controlled through
established policies and procedures. The selection and retention
process encompasses the period from identifying potential outside
counsel through completion of legal matters. Recently, we
established a section within the Legal Division to oversee
utilization of outside counsel and implemented several new policies
and procedures for the selection and retention of outside counsel.
We created the Outside Counsel Management Section ("OCMS") as
part of the RTC Legal Division to provide internal controls and
guidance on aatters concerning outside counsel. oCMS consists of
several working groups which are designed to coordinate and oversee
the use of outside counsel by the RTC Legal Division, including a
Policies and Procedures Unit, a Conflicts Unit, and a Minority and
Women Outreach Unit.
Specifically, the Policies and Procedures Unit is responsible
for drafting, implementing, and overseeing the implementation of
general policies and procedures relating to the management of
outside counsel. Upon its creation, the Policies and Procedures
Unit took numerous steps to address concerns about the procedures
for the selection and retention of outside counsel, including
preparation of the RTC Guide for Outside Counsel f "RTC Guide* 1 .
63
287
APPE^a)IX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
The RTC Guide sets forth the basic policies and procedures for the
managesent of. outside counsel, as well as application procedures.
In addition, we have adopted and implemented the Policies and
Procedures for the Enaagenient of Outside Counsel and the Statement
of Policy and Procedures Concerning Limitations Upon the Use of
Outside Counsel, which limits generally the use of any particular
outside counsel.
We also recently created a Conflicts Unit within the Outside
Counsel Management Section, which is devoted to supporting the work
of the joint FDIC/RTC Outside Counsel Conflicts COBunittee
("Conflicts Committee") . The Conflicts Unit is responsible for the
development, implementation, and oversight of policies and
procedures pertaining to all aspects of outside counsel conflicts
of interest and ethics natters.
Management Information Systems
The management information system used by the FDIC/RTC Legal
Division to provide basic data on legal matters was the Case
Management System ("CMS") . CMS was completely separate and
independent of the payment system, and the quality of the data in
the CMS database was discovered over time to be inconsistent.
Additionally, the database which maintained the List of Counsel
Utilized ("LCU") did not provide sufficient information about
outside counsel to be used as a selection tool.
As noted in the Report, we recognized the weaknesses and
limitations of the CMS and LCU, and we determined that those
systems were not adequate to provide the level of information
management required by the RTC. We developed the RTC Legal
Information System ("RLIS") to enhance our control over legal
information and payments. RLIS is designed to alleviate the
problems associated with previous information systems and to
address our growing information needs.
RLIS is an information storage and retrieval database which
enables us to track and control legal matters and their associated
expenditures and gives us the ability to monitor and report on
management concerns. Information on law finns, referrals, women
and minority participation, significant issues, and specific legal
matters is collected in RLIS and is available to RTC staff in
Washington and in the field offices.
RLIS is a budget-based system which has invoice processing
procedures that require each outside counsel to submit a legal
matter budget for each matter it handles. Because all legal
referrals are on RLIS, this system allows us to monitor costs as
they are incurred and to evaluate on an on-going basis the
direction of the legal natter.
64
288
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
P«y»«nt of Outaid* Counsel
The Report identifies two different outside counsel payaent
programs that were used by the FDIC/RTC Legal Division in 1990:
the Payaent Authorization Voucher Program ("PAV") and the
Accelerated Payment Program ("APP") . Under the APP, payments were
made to outside counsel prior to review of the invoices submitted
by outside counsel, resulting in some overpayments. Recognizing
the problems associated with these payment programs, we
discontinued the use of both programs and developed RLIS, which now
provides the basis for the payment program for outside counsel.
IV.
POLICIES AMD PROCEDURES COMCEHMIMS O0T8IDB COOySEL
The Report raises several concerns about our compliance with
policies and procedures relating to the selection and retention of
outside counsel, which the Report alleges has resulted in a lack of
fair and open competition and a failure to realize potential
savings. The Report expresses concern that the Legal Division does
not use a competitive process to refer routine-type matters to
outside counsel. The Report recommends that we establish internal
controls to ensure compliance with procedures on competitive
retention of outside counsel.
The Report also expresses concern that because outside counsel
are not being evaluated in accordance with policies and procedures,
we do not ensure that the best qualified legal firms are being
utilized. The Report recommends that we develop procedures to
clearly define when evaluations of outside counsel are to be
prepared.
Finally, the Report addresses the RTC Legal Division's
procedure for hiring non-le<,'al contractors. Specifically, the
Report states that the Professional Liability Section ("PLS") used
its contracting authority to circumvent normal RTC contracting
procedures by hiring outside counsel to contract with non-legal
contractors for non-legal services. The Report recommends that we
discontinue the practice of using outside counsel to hire non-legal
contractors.
We are confident that the Inspector General's concerns will be
alleviated by the policies and procedures implemented since
September 1991 and that the Inspector General will support our
efforts. The following sets forth our current practices and
procedures.
The new RTC Guide sets forth the application procedures for
outside counsel. Each outside counsel :nust conplete and submit a
65
289
APPENDIX APPEiNfDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
registration form that provides bac)cground infomation on the fin,
including a statement of the firm's qualifications, fitness, and
integrity. TVie law firm also must provide an exhaustive narrative
statement about itself, highlighting areas of expertise or
specialization and providing specific information about the members
of the firm who have that expertise. For each attorney or
paraprof essional offered, the firm must provide rate information,
including both its usual rate and the proposed discount rate.
Evaluation of prospective outside counsel begins with a review
of the law firm's proposal to determine if it is within the
competitive range for legal services, either by specialty or
geographical area. Special emphasis, analogous to the contracting
department's awarding of bonus technical points, is placed on the
fulfillment of the RTC's commitment to Equal Opportunity and the
RTC Legal Division's Minority and Woman Outreach Program.
After interviewing the firm, RTC attorneys will recommend
whether the firm should be retained. The recommendation is
considered by the Assistant General Counsel or Regional Counsel who
has the authority to enter into an RTC Legal Services Agreement
("LSA") .
A law firm is retained by the execution of an LSA with the
RTC. This agreement binds a firm to provide thi RTC legal services
at the rate structure agreed upon for a period of two years.
However, no obligation exists on the part of the RTC to utilize the
services of the firm. The LSA incorporates Legal Division policies
and procedures with which outside counsel are expected to comply.
Upon execution of the LSA, the law firm is entered into RLIS and is
able to receive RTC work.
Competitive Bidding for Routine Matters
All referrals to outside counsel are based upon the
competitive application process in which law firms are rated,
reviewed, and evaluated for cost-effectiveness. The performance
of a technical and cost evaluation of a law firsi is a competitive
bidding procedure in all respects; however, there is no single
proposal due date for all law firms. Rather, proposals are
received and evaluated on a continuing basis. Also, the Legal
Division's practice of negotiating with outside counsel to obtain
services at discounted rates (in comparison to its standard rates)
accomplishes the sane goal of realizing savings that results from
direct competitive bidding.
In addition, we have always encouraged outside counsel to
offer competitive flat fees for routine legal natters. Each law
firm in its application indicates what types of routine matters it
IS prepared to handle on a flat fee basis. These natters include
deeds in lieu (per property), loan restructurings, foreclosures.
66
290
APPENDIX APPE^fDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
bankruptcy, lift stays, proofs of clains, forcible entry and
detainer actions, and ad valorem tax suits.
However, we also have developed and implenented policies and
procedures to ensure a competitive process for the selection of
outside counsel that is more closely analogous to the RTC's non-
legal contracting procedures. Through the implementation of new
engagement procedures, we are endeavoring to use a more competitive
bidding process for the selection of outside counsel.
The Policies and Procedures for the Engagement of Outside
Counsel ("Engagement Procedures'1 mandate specific bidding
processes for the engagement of outside counsel as to types of
legal services which are appropriate for this type of selection.
The Engagement Procedures outline three methods for the engagement
of outside counsel. The particular needs of the Legal Division
will dictate the method chosen.
The first method. Standard Selection, involves the competitive
selection and engagement of outside counsel to provide legal
services in connection with a complex or extensive matter or a
number of specific matters. The second method is the use of a
Basic Ordering Agreement ("BOA"), by which one or more outside
counsel are competitively retained to perform legal services in
connection with large numbers of similar matters involving
substantially similar types of services. The final method.
Specific Engagement, involves a process by which a single outside
counsel is solicited and retained to perform legal services in
connection with a specific matter or matters.
Pursuant to the engagement procedures, Legal Services
Committees have been appointed in each field office, as well as at
headquarters in Washington, to determine the need for outside
counsel and the extent to which engagements of outside counsel can
be competitively bid. The Legal Services Committees will serve as
an oversight mechanism to monitor the selection and retention of
outside counsel and to ensure compliance with the competitive
procedures. In addition, the Policies and Procedures Unit, through
its visitation program and weekly telephone conferences with the
Legal Services Coordinators, stays abreast of the latest
developments in the field to identify problems that arise and
ensure they are properly addressed.
Currently, we are reviewing our policies and procedures for
cocpetitive bidding in the engagement of outside counsel to
consider streamlining such policies and procedures in light of the
recent major revisions of the general RTC contracting procedures.
291
APPENDIX APPEiNOJIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
Evaluation of Outsida Counsel's Performance
Under our current procedures, new law firms are evaluated and
ranked before receiving any referrals. We expect that these
evaluations will be updated periodically, and at a minimum,
annually. We also plan to have our field offices report on the
evaluations they have done so that we can monitor these
evaluations. The Outside Counsel Management Section plans to
develop and implement procedures outlining specific requirements
for the evaluation of outside counsel.
In addition, the Professional Liability Section ("PLS") , which
handles some of the most complex and challenging RTC cases,
maintains a database of evaluations of outside counsel, which is
reviewed prior to assigning additional cases. These evaluations
are available to other Legal Division attorneys as well. Outside
counsel handling PLS cases are reviewed periodically, and at least
annually.
Finally, evaluations are performed on an informal basis. RTC
attorneys' experiences with outside counsel's responsiveness,
knowledge of substantive legal issues, and costs are shared with
other members of the legal staff. Unsatisfactory performance is
frequently dealt with informally by counseling of the firm and its
attorneys, diminution or halt in referrals, increased scrutiny of
fee bills, or even transfer of the work to another firm.
Legal Division Contracting Authority
The Report raises specific concerns about the failure of PLS
to comply with RTC contracting procedures by allowing outside
counsel to hire non-legal contractors. The Report charges that the
RTC procedures for hiring outside contractors and the RTC
qualifications for outside contractors are not followed. The
Inspector General raises the concern that not all qualified
contractors are considered and that potential offerors are not
given fair and consistent treatment. Finally, the Report charges
that extra costs are added by the additional layer of management
created when outside counsel hire non-legal contractors and that
this procedure also introduces a conflict of interest for outside
counsel.
In accordance with the Delegations of Authority, the RTC Legal
Division may retain outside counsel and approve payment of fees for
services incurred in connection with legal matters, such as
investigators, consultants, appraisers, or other experts. The
Legal Division is not legally obligated to follow RTC contracting
guidelines in contracting for such services.
PLS utilizes investigators, both in-house and outside, to
investigate potential claims against former officers and directors.
68
292
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMFNT<;
attorneys, accountants, and other professionals of failed
institutions Tor their roles in the failure of savings and loan
institutions. PLS follows the FOIC practice of relying initially
on in-house investigators, where possible, and then, when use of
outside investigators is necessary, hiring such investigators
through outside counsel.
It is imperative that the process of contracting for legal and
non-legal services be conducted in a manner that will protect the
confidentiality of attorney-client communications. He must balance
issues of contracting on the one hand with the possibility of
adversely affecting the RTC's legal rights and the preservation oC
statutory privileges on the other.
Having investigators work directly for outside counsel is the
common relationship in private litigation, because the wor)c done by
an investigator will be protected by the woric-product privilege if
it is done under the direction of an attorney. Whenever
investigators do not work directly for lawyers, it erodes our
ability to assert that the investigation was conducted at the
direction of an attorney and that, therefore, the worJc-product of
the investigator should be protected as the work-product of the
attorney. We must protect the work-product of investigators,
because the release of information discovered by investigators
could compromise potential litigation.
The need for outside investigators was and is very real. The
RTC had no investigative staff in some locations until a year and
one half after the first institutions were closed and the time
period for filing claims was. in some cases, half gone. RTC in-
house investigators also did not, initially, have the depth of
experience possessed by FDIC investigators.
Given such time constraints. Investigations and PLS began
hiring new in-house investigators and attorneys, respectively.
Still, faced with an ever-increasing caseload and impending filing
deadlines, it was necessary to hire additional outside
investigators with more training and expertise to assist in
investigating potential claims fully prior to the expiration of the
statute of limitations.
Investigations sought direct contracting authority to hire
outside investigators. However, such authority was not initially
forthcoming. Until fairly recently then, only two options existed
for obtaining access to outside resources: Investigations could
seek authority from the RTC Board to hire each outside contractor,
or outside counsel could hire them. PLS and Investigations
concluded that the most effective way to get potential claims fully
investigated prior to the expiration of the limitations period was
through outside counsel's hiring of trained investigators. We made
the conscious decision that hiring investigators through outside
counsel was preferable to failing to discover and bring valid
10
69
293
APPE^fDlX APPENDIX
rORPORATlON COMMENTS
lawsuits against the directors, officers, and other professionals
who had a large hand in bringing about the failure of the savings
and loans throughout the country- The magnitude of the RTC
caseload continues to prevent us from relying solely on in-house
resources or expertise to investigate all possible causes of action
against former directors and officers and other professionals of
failed thrifts.
In addition, although the Legal Division is not obligated to
follow RTC contracting guidelines, the procedures followed by PLS
in allowing outside counsel to hire non-legal contractors are
consistent with RTC contracting guidelines. Although a law firm
Bight recommend a particular outside investigator who had a good
track record with the firm, the final selection of outside
investigators is made by in-house staff. No unfair advantage is
given to non-legal contractors who previously have worked with the
fins.
In-house attorneys and investigators have final approval of
the process and, as in hiring the outside counsel, in-house
contractor lists and recomnendations are reviewed. Moreover,
several potential contractors are evaluated for each potential
contract. Non-legal contractors who have completed the
requirements to contract with the RTC are given adequate
consideration. RTC staff takes care to choose investigative firms
that have been qualified under the RTC contractor standards. PLS
hires investigators in much the same way it chooses outside
counsel: after careful review of possible servicers and
discussions with those people about their capabilities and prices.
In general, we have also found that it is more cost-effective
and efficient to allow outside counsel to retain non-legal
contractors, such as court reporters, messengers, copy services,
investigators and other services associated with the conduct of
litigation, without a formal solicitation and bid process which is
more time-consuming and costly. Outside counsel nonetheless are
directed to perform competitive analyses of non-legal contractors
prior to hiring in an effort to obtain the most cost-effective and
experienced service. Indeed, contrary to the Report's charge that
"PLS used its contracting authority to circumvent normal RTC
contracting procedures," the PLS procedures for hiring outside
contractors through outside counsel met the RTC contracting goals
of fairly considering and evaluating more than one offeror of
services for non-legal services contracts.
If a conflict of interest exists for outside counsel between
representing the RTC and directing investigators who may find
litigation that the outside counsel will then be paid to handle,
such conflict is the same that exists for any attorney when he is
asked to advise a client as to whether that client has a viable
cause of action. The incentive provided by the possibility that
the counsel would be retained to pursue the claim is fully
11
70
\
i
294
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
compatible with the obligation of every attorney to be zealous in
the pursuit of his client's interests. In fact, PLS recognizes
and relies on* the incentives inherent in having outside counsel
assist in evaluating potential causes of action to gain comfort
that all possible causes of action are fully explored.
Also, the process of pursuing PLS claims does not entail
having outside counsel or PLS perform the investigation. Osing
outside investigators that outside counsel retains at the RTC's
request, Investigations performs the actual investigations.
Outside counsel, on the other hand, are often hired to help in-
house counsel determine whether, in light of the facts, the RTC has
a valid claim, regardless of whether there are outside
investigators. Outside counsel's role is one of giving legal
advice and making recommendations on questions ranging froa state
law procedure to fiduciary relationships between directors and
professionals working for the thrift. The bottom line remains,
however, that in-house counsel has always been responsible for
making an independent reconnendation, based on the facts and the
law, as to the viability of a claim, before the RTC will file suit.
The guidance and direction provided to outside investigators
by outside counsel does not duplicate the management performed by
in-house investigators. Through supervising outside investigators,
in-house investigators are able to perform their responsibility of
gathering facts which support professional liability claims. PLS
attorneys, assisted by outside counsel, provide overall guidance on
the direction of the investigation and litigation. This approach
reflects a careful balancing of the need to have counsel provide
direction and guidance of PLS investigations against the desire to
maintain direct supervision of the performance of outside
contractors by in-house investigators.
V.
MANAGEMEKT IKypRKATION SYSTEMS
The Report raises numerous concerns about the Legal Division's
information systems. Specifically, the Report charges that the
information systems did not capture important information or
produce reports needed to manage our operations adequately in
accordance with policies, procedures, and statutory requirements.
The Report states that the systems were not designed to handle the
increased workload of the RTC or to report information on FIRREA
requirements, such as the usage of minority- and women-owned law
firms. The Report also ex-presses concern that conflict of interest
inforaation was not systenatically compiled and made available to
attorneys selecting outside counsel. The Report raises concerns
that steps to improve the information systems were not nade timely
and efficiently and that future needs xay not be adequately
12
295
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
addressed. The Report recomioends that we assess imaediate and
long-term information needs to develop goals for the infomation
systeo and that we develop strategic plans for achieving these
goals.
The concerns raised in the Report primarily refer to the
inforaation systems used by the FDIC/RTC Legal Division. We
recognized the limitations of the previous systems and designed,
developed, and implemented the RTC Legal Information System
("RLIS*) to alleviate these problems. We began implementation of
RLIS in October of 1991.
Inforaation Storage and Retrieval
First, the Report raises several specific concerns about the
accessibility and reliability of information maintained in the
information systems. The Report indicates that the information
systems were not capable of providing sufficient information about
outside counsel to be used as a selection tool. For example, the
systems did not provide information on when matters were referred;
the extent of minority and women participation; outside counsel's
expertise, hourly rates, and conflicts of interest; or whether
outside counsel was inherited. The Report indicates that complete
information regarding compliance with statutory requirements and
internal policies was not available. Also, the Report charges that
no centralized system existed to capture and tracX nationwide
financial data. The Report recommends that we develop standardized
reporting capability so that we have readily accessible inforaation
to monitor outside counsel.
Prior to review of a draft of the Report, the RTC Legal
Division recognized the same concerns as noted by the Inspector
General in the Report, and we toolc immediate and appropriate action
to improve our systems. As discussed more fully below, RLIS
provides complete and reliable information about law firms and
legal matters, allows us to monitor compliance with statutory
requirements and internal policies, and gives us standardized
reporting capability.
Law Firm Information. RLIS contains reliable and accessible
information about law firms, because it requires such information
to be completed during the application process. Before a law firm
may be utilized by the RTC for the assignment of new legal matters,
the firm must be listed on the RLIS database. Information required
for each firm includes whether the firm is minority- or women-
owned, the extent of minority and women participation in the firm,
conflicts of interest which may exist, the addresses of each office
and the areas in which each office is willing to do business, and,
after execution of an LSA, the firm's rate schedule.
RLIS has the capability to categorize law firms as performing,
13
72
296
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
inherited, conflicted, restricted or teminated. Outside counsel
who have executed a Leqal Services Agreement with the RTC are
identified on the RLIS database as "perfoming firms." Once a law
firm has executed an LSA, it is entered on RLIS and becomes
available for use as outside counsel.
Outside counsel who were utilized by a savings and loan
institution prior to intervention and continue to be utilized by
the institution in conservatorship are "inherited firms."
Inherited firms are allowed to complete matters they are working
on, but RLIS will not allow new matters to be assigned to such
firms unless they execute an LSA. If an inherited firm does not
execute an LSA within 90 days of intervention, then any matter on
which the firm is working is subject to transfer to another firm.
RLIS also has the capability to Identify firms as conflicted,
terminated, or restricted. Conflicted firms are those which have
a conflict of interest which has not been resolved or waived.
Restricted firms are firms which have reached the limit on legal
fees which may be paid to a law firm during any 12 month period.
New matters may not be assigned to any firm listed as conflicted,
terminated, or restricted.
Legal Matter Infonnation. RX,is also stores and tracks
information about specific legal matters. Detailed information
concerning the matter, the institution involved, and the type of
work to be performed must be entered in the RLIS database before a
law firm may be utilized by the RTC Legal Division on a particular
matter.
Also, before outside counsel is allowed to perform legal
services on a matter, they are required to prepare a budget for the
matter. Upon approval by the appropriate authority, as determined
in accordance with the Delegations of Authority, the budget for the
matter is entered into RLIS.
In addition, detailed Information on all RTC legal matters
handled by outside counsel and their associated expenditures,
including minority and women participation in the matter, must be
entered into RLIS as part of the invoice processing procedures. If
outside counsel does not provide this information when submitting
an invoice, the invoice is returned for completion before it will
be paid. As indicated in the Report, this procedure of requiring
information collection prior to payment should ensure maintenance
of complete information in the system.
Financial Infonnation. RLIS provides nationwide access to
financial information about specific legal matters, individual law
firms, and the expenditures associated with either matters or
firms. Each matter is assigned a unique Legal Division
Identification Number ("LDID") , which allows us to track the
invoices received and payments nade on specific matters and allows
14
73
297
APPENDIX APP^^^'^
rnRPORATION COMMENTS
us to ensure that ali payncnts have been approved. All invoices
froa outside counsel are tracked through a single standardized
system, allowing us to detect potential overpaynents and
unauthorized payments.
In contrast to previous information systems, financial
information on legal bills paid by conservatorships and SAMOA'S is
naintained in RLIS despite the fact that the bills are paid
directly by the conservatorship or SAMDA contractor. All invoices
submitted by outside counsel, including those employed by
conservatorships and SAMOA'S, must be recorded in RLIS.
Accessibility and Reporting of Information. AH of the
information collected in RLIS is available to RTC staff in
Washington and in the field offices. RLIS was designed to allow
access to law firm and legal matter information to all RTC
attorneys and to allow attorneys to browse through the information
maintained in the system. This easy access to a broad spectrum of
information allows RLIS to be utilized in the selection process for
outside counsel.
Additionally, we are able to generate numerous reports which
allow us to monitor not only specific legal matters and utilization
of outside counsel, but also specific issues of management concern.
With RLIS, we are able to determine the number of matters referred
to minority- and women-owned firms and provide information
regarding minority and women participation in matters to ensure
compliance with the statutory requirement to utilize minority- and
women-owned businesses to the maximum extent. We are also able to
track financial information relating to individual firms in order
to ensure compliance with the limit on legal fees outside counsel
may receive in any 12 month period.
Virtually all data collected in the RLIS database is
retrievable in report format. Specific reports which can be
generated in all offices by any person trained in using RLIS
include: (1) law firm detail reports, which are capable of listing
all firms, all firms in a specific location, performing firms,
inherited firms, and other combinations of the types of firms
included in RLIS; (2) law firm profiles, which provide detailed
information about an individual firm; (3) legal matter profiles,
which provide information about specific matters; (A) attorney
workload reports, which list the number and status of cases that
one attorney, one office or one firm is working on; (S)
contractors reports, which list the legal matters assigned to
SAMOA'S; (6) early warning reports, which identify system
functions, such as listing all matters which are missing budgets;
and (7) legal matter type reports, which list all legal matters in
a particular category, such as professional liability. These
standard reports can be generated by any RTC attorney in any
office. Currently, many additional standard reports are being
developed.
IS
74
298
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
In addition to these standard reports, it is also possible to
generate ad ttSS reports from RLIS. These a^ hSS reports allow us
to accomnodate quickly requests for infomation which is contained
an BUS, but which is not produced already on one of the standard
reports. For example, an sd b2£ report could be produced
Identifying all matters which have budgets exceeding SlOO 000
Although the length of tine needed to generate such a report
necessarily depends on the type and volume of inforaation
requested, judging from the requests we have had so far, most ad
tss reports can be produced in a time period ranging from a few
hours to a day and one half.
Conflict of Interest lataraatio^
Information identifying outside counsel who have an actual or
potential conflict of interest is contained in RLIS and available
to all Legal Division attorneys. Conflicts of interest information
reported from outside counsel is entered into RLIS by the office
where the conflict is reported. RLIS contains a process which will
flag a firm as having an actual or potential conflict of interest
as soon as such conflict is reported. The flag will remain until
the conflict of interest is either resolved or waived bv the
Conflicts Committee. This allows attorneys to deteraine if a
conflict of interest exists as part of the selection process for
outside counsel.
In addition to identifying firms which have a conflict of
interest, RLIS also may provide limited information about
restrictions on specific firms. If RLIS has flagged a firm as
having a conflict of interest, the conflicts comments section of
RLIS provides an opportunity to describe whether the firm has a
limited restriction or whether the firm is barred completely from
new natters. j •.•.«»
Meeting Future Information Needa
The RLIS Steering Committee, together with the RLIS staff in
Washington, oversees the operations of RLIS, establishes the
policies and procedures for working within the system, and
evaluates the operations of the system to plan for future
enhancements and adjustments. On February 28, 1992 we issued the
RLIS Office — Procedures Manual for RTC Legal WaffA»-.= uhich
establishes policies and procedures for the use and operation of
Additionally, each field office has an RLIS Coordinator who
is assisted by a staff of RLIS Legal Technicians. The RLIS
Coordinators oversee compliance with RLIS procedures in the field
offices.
16
75
299
APPE>fDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
The RLIS Steering Committee, together with the staff in
Washington, continually reviews the progress of the RLIS database
and the developing information needs of the Legal Division.
Throughout the process of implementing RLIS, we have determined
that certain adjustments to the system are necessary. Several
phases of adjustments have been implemented already, with the next
phase scheduled for early this Fall. Some of the changes which
have been made and which are scheduled to be made in the future
include adding fields for additional information that we have
determined to be important and making additional fields mandatory.
For example, we plan to include information about each firm's
expertise in a future enhancement of RLIS.
In addition, at the present time. Legal Division staff are
working along with the RLIS contractor to design and develop future
reports. For example, if we determine that requests for specific
ad hoc reports are made repeatedly, such ad hoc reports will be
added to the list of standard reports.
VI.
PROTECTIOM AGAINST OVERPAYMENTS
The Report raises concerns about the review process for
outside counsel invoices and the programs used to pay these
invoices. The Report charges that the invoice review process is
not adequate to verify correctness and to identify inappropriate
charges. The Report recommends that we revise the invoice
processing procedures to include a comprehensive list of
inappropriate charges and to ensure that staffing amendments or
rate changes are approved by the appropriate authority. The Report
also recommends that we enhance and standardize training on the
review process to include reviewing invoices for accuracy,
identifying prohibited charges, and detemining the reasonableness
of case budgets. The Report indicates that we do not have, and
recommends that we establish, an adequate oversight mechanism to
ensure that the review process is adequately performed. The Report
also charges that adequate cost controls are not in place to manage
and contain expenses for matters referred to outside counsel.
The Report criticizes the use of the Accelerated Payment
Program ("APP"), which resulted in some overpayments. The Report
also identifies weaknesses in the bill paying process performed by
the FDIC's Division of Accounting and Corporate Services ("DACS")
which resulted in some overpayments, including the lack of a
control mechanism to identify payments for identical invoice
numbers, the lack of verification of approval for payments, the
failure to require law firms to provide a unique invoice number,
and the lack of a single standardized system to track invoices.
17
76
300
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
Many of the concerns raised in the Report address the APP and
the bill paying process used by OACS, both of which are no longer
used by the RTC Legal Division. We recognized the problems created
by the APP and the bill paying process and have taken steps to
ensure that the new paynent system developed in RLIS and the
invoice review process correct such problens.
Invoice Review Process and Cost Controls
RUS is a comprehensive information storage and retrieval
system that provides us with information necessary to monitor legal
matter budgets and to effectively review invoices. Because RLIS is
a budget-based system, we are able to establish the projected cost
of a matter and tracic invoices and payments to ensure that
overpayments and unauthorized payments are avoided. Also, RLIS
gives us control over the cost-effectiveness of a proposed legal
action from its onset and allows us to make a management decision
on the best course of action to pursue based upon an accurate cost
projection.
Budgets. RLIS invoice processing procedures require every
outside counsel to submit a legal matter budget for each matter it
handles. After review by the supervising attorney, the budget must
be approved and signed by the appropriate RTC attorney. Authority
to approve legal matter budgets and changes in budgets is
determined in accordance with the Delegations of Authority. The
legal matter budget must be entered into RLIS before any payment to
the firm is made.
Throughout the duration of the matter, payment amounts are
tracked against budget amounts, and any invoice that is submitted
without a budget or is over budget will not be paid. If the
accumulated invoices for a matter exceed the budget, a new budget
must be submitted by outside counsel and approved by the
appropriate authority, before additional payment can be made.
Legal matter budgets are broken down into phases that have
estimated costs and completion times, estimated recovery and
judgment amounts, and success probabilities. Progress can be
monitored against the approved plan and budget. At the completion
of each budget phase, a performance history can be generated to
determine how well law firms manage matters. With RLIS, we can
monitor firms for their ability to handle a matter and work within
a reasonable budget.
Early warning reports can be run to alert us to potential
problens with legal natter budgets. One such report lists matters
whose cumulative invoice payTr.er.ts are nearing their budget limits.
Invoices. RLIS provides a single, standardized tracking
system for every invoice sucmitted by outside counsel. RLIS
18
301
APPE^fDIX APPENDIX
rORPORATlON COMMENTS
assigns a unique Legal Division Identification Number (LOID) to
each legal matter. Every invoice submitted for a particular matter
will be identified by that LDIO. Therefore, the invoice record
can be called up at any time to check on the status of an invoice.
In addition, in order to be paid, all invoices submitted under
RLIS must contain a unique invoice number assigned to the invoice
by the outside counsel. This prevents duplicate payments for
services. RLIS has a built-in control that prevents invoices with
duplicate invoice numbers or overlapping service dates from being
paid.
Invoice Review Process. RUS invoice review procedures
provide for an ongoing review of selected invoices by technicians,
paralegals, and supervising attorneys to uncover improper charges.
If invoice discrepancies are discovered, the supervising attorney
resolves them with the firm prior to payment of the invoice.
RLIS facilitates effective review because so much information
is maintained on RLIS and made accessible nationwide. For example,
the rates listed on an individual invoice may be compared easily to
the rates identified on the Legal Services Agreement, because LSA
rates are stored in the database. RLIS does not allow new matters
to be assigned to any firm which does not have a current LSA.
The first step of the invoice review process is the review by
RLIS legal technicians. All invoices are reviewed by legal
technicians for proper submission criteria prior to the data being
entered in RLIS. RLIS legal technicians are trained in each office
to review invoices for discrepancies.
In addition to the initial review by legal technicians, we
have adopted procedures for detailed review of specific invoices.
All invoices over S5,000 or overbudget are reviewed in detail by
the supervising attorney. Additionally, RLIS is designed to
electronically and randomly select every fiftieth invoice for
detailed review.
Internal flags can also be set in RLIS to force a detailed
review of all invoices for a specific matter or all invoices for a
specific firm. This procedure requires the supervising attorney to
review and approve the invoice before the firm can be paid.
A detailed review compares the fees charged on the invoice
with the fee schedule of the LSA and ensures that every attorney
identified as working on the matter is listed on the LSA. An
invoice charging rates different from those listed on the LSA or
listing attorneys not identified on the LSA will not be paid unless
approved by the appropriate authority.
Invoices are also reviewed to ensure that inappropriate
charges are not reimbursed. The RTC Guide for Outside Counsel
19
78
302
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
identifies inappropriate charges which will not be reimbursed by
the RTC, such as secretarial overtime, describes limitations on
certain charges, such as photocopying charges, and lists
restrictions on reimbursement for travel time. Inappropriate
charges included on an invoice will not be paid.
To ensure adherence to the invoice processing policies, we
have developed an invoice review checklist for use by legal
technicians and attorneys. Whenever an invoice is subject to a
detailed review, the invoice review checklist is completed,
indicating the reason for the detailed review and the specific
items which were reviewed. This detailed review checklist requires
a review of and lists specific items, including travel expenses,
meal expenses, parking expenses, word processing charges, and
duplicating expenses, which may include inappropriate charges.
All legal staff who review invoices are trained, or are in the
process of being trained, to identify prohibited charges and to
verify accuracy. The RLIS legal technicians are trained in invoice
review procedures in their respective offices. We are also in the
process of training Legal Division attorneys in invoice review
procedures. The attorney training, which was recently begun in
Washington, will continue into the summer. The attorney training
will include instruction on the reasonableness of budgets.
Accelerated Payment Program
The Accelerated Pai-ment Program ("APP") , a payment program
utilized by the FDIC/RTC Legal Division, allowed payment to outside
counsel prior to review of the invoice and resulted in some
overpaycents . We discontinued use of the APP on Decenber 31, 1991.
As described above, RLIS contains numerous procedures to prevent
overpayments or unauthorized payments from occurring: RLIS
contains built-in controls that prevent invoices with duplicate
invoice numbers and overlapping billing periods from being paid;
RLIS will not allow invoices which exceed the natter's budget to be
paid; RLIS provides for detailed review of select invoices; and,
with the exception of inherited firms, RLIS will not allow payment
of invoices submitted by outside counsel without a current Legal
Services Agreement.
Alt.*iough the APP has been discontinued, ue are in the process
of reconciling the amounts paid to outside counsel with the amounts
approved for payment by the Legal Division to detect any
overpayments. With the assistance of an outside contractor, we
will reconcile all payments made under the APP above a preset
dollar value and will pursue collection efforts for overpaiTnents.
20
79
303
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
▼II.
, CONFLICTS or mrniEST
Th« ReporC raises several concerns abouc compliance with
conflicts of interest policies and procedures. The Report
expresses the concern that information about conflicts of interest
is not adequately disseainated to RTC attorneys for use in the
selection and retention of outside counsel. The Report recooaends
that ve ensure that the conflicts of interest infomation system
currently bein^ developed provides detailed information about
conflicts of interest, including restrictions and conditions for
each conflict. The Report raises the concern that not all
conflicts of interest are reported to the Conflicts Committee,
which could potentially result in inconsistencies in handling
conflicts, and that our policies fail to address enforcement
sanctions for firms who fail to report conflicts of interest. The
Report also charges that the Conflicts Committee's policies for
addressing conflicts are not sufficiently stringent and create the
potential for criticism. The Report recommends that we develop
more stringent guidelines that promote the use of firms without
conflicts of interest. The Report also recommends that the
Conflicts Committee document the rationale for each of its
decisions.
r,^^^mlmication of Conflicts Information
As mentioned previously, one of the values of RLIS is its
capability to flag law firms which have a conflict of interest. The
RTC Guide for Outside Counsel notifies outside counsel of their
duty to disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest during
the application process, and of their continuing duty to report
conflicts of interest throughout their service to the RTC. The
conflicts coordinator for the office which receives the report of
the conflict of interest is responsible for ensuring that
infomation about the actual or potential conflict of interest is
entered in RLIS. The conflicts coordinator also submits waiver
requests to the Conflicts Committee and updates RLIS after
notification by the Committee of its decision. The conflict of
interest information listed in RLIS is available nationwide to all
Legal Division personnel.
Additionally, in order to provide more complete information
about conflicts of interest and decisions of the Conflicts
Connittee, we are developing an information system specifically for
conflicts of interest. The Conflicts Unit of the OCMS, in
conjunction with the RTC's Office of Systems Development, is
designing the RTC Legal Division's Conflicts Tracking System
("CTS") to ensure that conflicts of interest matters are promptly
reported by the field offices to the Conflicts Unit in Washington
and that such information is disseminated to the other field
21
80
304
APPENDIX APPENDIX
rnRPORATlON COMMENTS
offices. CTS will b« inplenented by October 1, 1992.
CTS will orqanize and monitor infomation regarding outside
counsel's conflicts of interest. The information for the database
will be gathered in a format which will promote consistency in
reporting of conflicts from the various offices and facilitate
review of conflict waiver requests by the Conflicts Committee. The
Conflicts Unit and RTC field offices will be able to access and/or
input infomation regarding the nature of outside counsel's
conflicts of interest, the financial institutions involved, the
field's recommendations to the Conflicts Committee, and the
decisions of the Conflicts Committee.
CTS will tracic each conflict of interest waiver request
through all stages of resolution, including notice of the conflict
from the law firm, the receipt of the waiver request, the
preparation of the field office recommendation, and the decision of
the Conflicts Committee (or other appropriate authority) .
Most importantly, implenentation of CTS will enable the
Conflicts Unit to disseminate the decisions of the Conflicts
Committee to all field offices in an easily accessible format
without undue delay. With the implementation of CTS, all RTC
offices will be able to receive the same information regarding
conflicts of interest for all law firms nationwide and use such
information in the selection and retention of outside counsel.
Currently, information about waiver decisions made by the
Conflicts Committee is distributed by the Conflicts Unit. The
Conflicts Unit distributes an action agenda to each regional office
following each Conflicts Committee meeting. The action agenda
lists the waiver requests considered by the Committee and their
disposition, and describes the conditions, if any, under which the
outside counsel requesting the waiver may continue to be utilized
by the Legal Division.
Report of Conflicts to the Conflicts Committee
Where outside counsel is not yet representing the RTC, Legal
Division policy requires that all conflicts of interest reported
prior to the execution of an LSA must be referred to the Conflicts
Committee, unless the Legal Division does not intend to execute an
LSA with such outside counsel for reasons other than the conflicts
of interest. Similarly, all conflicts of interest that are
reported during the course of RTC representation by outside counsel
nust be brought before the Conflicts Committee for resolution,
unless the conflict is resolved by outside counsel.
The implementation of the CTS will ensure prompt reporting of
all conflicts by the field offices to the Conflicts Unit and timely
dissemination of the decisions of the Conflicts Committee to the
22
81
305
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
field offices.
In addition, Che Conflicts Unit is undertaking several
initiatives to enhance coapliance with the existing FDIC/RTC
conflicts policy. Recently, the Conflicts Unit issued the Outside
Counsel Conflicts Procedures fConflicts Procedures"^ . that
strengthen the requirenent for the field offices to forward
conflicts or potential conflicts froa outside counsel to the
Conflicts CoBBittee for decisions regarding waiver. The Conflicts
Procedures provide specific sanctions against firms which fail to
report conflicts of interest. Outside counsel who fail to fully
disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest in a timely
manner may be subject to one or more of the following actions: (1)
a letter of reprimand; (2) a suspension of new referrals; (3) a
withdrawal of all pending matters; (4) the rescission or denial of
an LSA; and/or (5) a referral to the appropriate state licensing
authority.
The Unit will also be implementing periodic visitations for
the purpose of auditing field office compliance with conflicts
procedures and policies. In addition, each field office has a
conflicts coordinator who works closely with the Conflicts Unit's
staff to ensure uniform compliance with conflicts policies and
procedures.
Conflicts '7"""" '♦•■tee Deeisions
The Report raises a concern about potential criticism of
Conflicts Committee decisions and specifically addresses the
Conflicts Committee's decisions to grant waivers in several
instances to law firms whose employees defaulted on substantial
loans from insured depository institutions, firms which represented
bidders for RTC assets, and in cases where regional Legal Division
personnel recommended that a waiver be denied. Decisions on
conflict of interest issues are made by the joint FDIC/RTC
Conflicts Committee. while the Conflicts Committee carefully
considers the recoruaendation of the field staff ir. reaching its
decisions, the delegated authority to waive non-technical conflicts
rests with the Conflicts Committee.
The Report acknowledges that the waivers of personal conflicts
of interest in all of the cases examined were conditional in
nature. "Conditional" in these cases meant that the partner having
the conflict was required to resign from any canagement position
within the law firm or be denied participation in the management
decision-ir.aking process, and was further prohibited from working on
RTC contracts and sharing m the profits generated from such
contracts.
The Report also acknowledges that all of the waiver decisions
examined fell within the Conflicts Committee's policies and
23
82
306
APPENDIX APPENDIX
rngpriRATIDN COMMENTS
procedures, and recognizes that FIRREA only prohibits contracting
with any individual who has caused a substantial loss to federal
deposit insurance funds, and does not prevent the use of firms
whose members have caused such losses. Waivers of law firm
conflicts of interest are granted or denied by the Conflicts
Committee based on the requirements of FIRREA, the applicable
regulatory provisions, and the Guidelines of the FDIC/RTC with
Respect to Conflicts of Interest (dated May 2, 1990). As
acknowledged in the Report, all of the waiver decisions examined
fell within the Conflicts Committee's policies and procedures and
within statutory boundaries.
The RTC regulations governing conflicts of interest do not
compel mandatory disqualification of a contractor when an employee
of the firm has caused a substantial loss to a federal deposit
insurance fund, or when a firm has previously represented bidders
for RTC assets. Nevertheless, the RTC may determine, in its
discretion, that such circumstances warrant disqualification of the
firm. (If the individual causing the loss to a deposit insurance
fund has filed for bankruptcy, disqualification of the firm would
be prohibited.) With the implementation of RLIS and the
development of CTS, RTC attorneys are aware of actual and potential
conflicts of interest and may use such information in the selection
and retention of outside counsel.
Despite the separation of the RTC and FDIC Legal Divisions,
the Conflicts Committee is structured as a joint FDIC/RTC committee
so as to ensure uniformity of RTC and FDIC outside counsel
conflicts of interest decisions. Accordingly, policy changes
requiring a more stringent standard for waiving conflicts of
interest would significantly impact the Conflicts Committee's
decision-making processes and must be approved by the FDIC as well
as the RTC.
It may be permissible for the FDIC and RTC jointly to adopt
new conflicts policies setting forth a blanket rule that waiver
requests will be denied without exception under the circumstances
set forth in the Report. However, it would be a drastic change
from current policy. The impact of such a rule on the availability
of outside counsel to the RTC and FDIC must be carefully considered
before such a policy is implemented.
Documentation of Conflicts Committee Decisions
Currently, limited information about decisions made by the
Conflicts Committee is available nationwide in the RLIS database.
It is anticipated that the CTS will provide, in sone abbreviated
form, the rationale for each decision of the Conflicts Committee to
provide guidance to RTC attorneys. An abbreviated rationale for
the decision will assist attorneys in the selection and retention
of outside counsel and in drafting recommendations to the Conflicts
24
83
307
APPENDIX APPENDIX
CORPORATION COMMENTS
Comnittee in conneetion with waiver requests.
VIII.
COWCLOSIOM
The Inspector General's audit was performed fron March 1991 to
August 1991, prior to the creation of the separate RTC Legal
Division and the Outside Counsel Management Section.
Consequently, most of the concerns expressed by the Inspector
General in the Report refer to policies and procedures which were
in effect prior to the separation of the RTC and FDIC Legal
Divisions.
We recognized that not all of the policies and procedures in
place at the tine of the separation were well adapted to the nature
and volume of RTC operations. Therefore, we have moved rapidly to
implement new policies, procedures, and systems which will more
effectively addiress the management and information needs of the RTC
Legal Division. Although the Report provides confirmation that
concerns addressed by the Legal Division were exactly those which
should have been addressed, we want to ensure that the significant
changes and improvements already made by the Legal Division are
recognized. RTC Legal Division policies, procedures, and systems
implemented subsequent to both our separation from the FDIC Legal
Division and the completion of the audit work address the concerns
raised in the Report and are responsive to the recommendations made
by the Inspector General.
25
84
TfR
308
Resolution Trust Corporation
Office of Inspector General, Office of Investigation
JULIE F. YANDA, RTC, Professional Liability Section (PLS) Chief,
7400 West 110th Street, 3rd Floor, Overland Park, ks, telephone
number (314) 344-8437, on May 12, 1993, provided Special Agent
(S/A) Thomas LaCalamito and Assistant Regional Inspector General
Phillip L. Sprague copies of her electronic mail (e-mail) messages
she had retained regarding the request for records on AMERICAN
SECURITY FEDERAL SAVINGS & LOAN ASSOCIATION (AMERICAN SECimiTY) ,
JEFFREY B. LIEBERMAN, and the law firm of BARACK, FERAZZANO,
KIRSCHBAUM & PERLMAN (BARACK) . Examination of those e-mail
messages established the following:
Date To/From-Summarv of Contents
2/8/93- YANDA to SUE THOMPSON- requesting all fee bills be
gathered for IG and other documents regarding BARACK law
firm and two other law firms. YANDA said she needed it
"pronto. "
2/9/93- S/A MICHAEL KOSZOLA to YANDA- requesting the revised
budget increase concerning AMERICAN SECURITY. Also asked
whether payments were received by RTC on litigation.
2/9/93- YANDA to KOSZOLA- 2 page e-mail discussing information on
the 3 law firms he inquired about. States that legal is
pulling all this information for you and there are
literally hundreds of bills in RLIS, many of which she
believes are probably related to commercial, as opposed
to PLS, matters.
2/9/93- YANDA to KOSZOLA- she says, as included in her earlier
e-mail to him, she knows he wants documents and they are
working hard to get them. Files are in transit and
documents are numerous. Also, legal is in the midst of
a series of statute driven cases. She promises to do her
best.
2/9/93- KOSZOLA to YANDA- KOSZOLA names 6 institutions where
BARACK is involved and asks for copies for case plans,
budgets, and amendments on the six.
2/9/93- YANDA forwards KOSZOLA' s e-mail to SUE THOMPSON- to
request dates requested by KOSZOLA.
2/10/93- YANDA to KOSZOLA- dates each institution retained BARACK
was provided.
2/10/93- KOSZOLA to YANDA- asked if YANDA knows the estimated
value of the claim and legal fee budgeted for LEMONT
FEDERAL.
By: Sprague/LaCalamito
D«t« Ptepsred: 5/13/93
F.loNo: KC-93-0035
RTC 12200A31 Pag* I of 2
309
ROIA, KC-93-0035
2/10/93- YANDA to KOSZOLA- provides information on LEMONT. Told
him there was no *:isk value established yet on this case.
2/10/93- KOSZOLA to YANDA- Asking amount of damages at LEMONT,
what does RTC expect to recover at LEMONT. KOSZOLA says
he understands every RTC department is understaffed.
"The OIG is requesting, as soon as possible, the written
documentation by LIEBERMAN recommending or authorizing
BARACK to be hired for LEMONT and a copy of every budget
amendment that LIEBERMAN, as PLS chief, recommended or
approved for other ligation involving BARACK. Thanks"
2/10/93- YANDA to KOSZOLA- YANDA states to KOSZOLA that she is
doing the best she can with limited resources. States
she has mobilized all her support staff to accommodate
his request as soon as they can gather the enormous
amount of information and documentation he requested.
She informs him much of the material is in transit, but
she is copying what they have there. States she is
leaving the next day and will not be back until the
following Wednesday. Explains to him that most of the
case referrals were made by Washington prior to the
Chicago PLS office being established.
2/11/93- BOOZ to YANDA forwarded to KOSZOLA- Told KOSZOLA that
this was follow up to his question on 2/10/93. Loss
numbers will exceed bond amount of $2.7 million.
3/10/93- KOSZOLA to YANDA- asked if she would be able to meet
3/16/93 deadline, as set forward in the subpoena, to
obtain the BARACK records. "If you are not able to meet
the deadline, please notify me by 3/12/93."
3/10/93 §4:22 p.m. YANDA to KOSZOLA- States she has been steadily
working on this since his original request. The
paralegal who has been tracking down the voluminous
documents has been working on this as well. Says they
are doing their best to identify any gaps in the
information they have compiled thus far. She promised an
update the next day. States she already sent some of the
material to AUSA.
3/10/93 @4:47 p.m. KOSZOLA to YANDA- Stating if you sent
documents to AUSA, please send a copy to me. In the
future, please send the documents to me and a copy to the
AUSA.
3/10/93 §4:56 p.m. YANDA to KOSZOLA- States she does not think
she can make another copy for him on this short notice.
She further states "If you want to delay the production
date, which we are working feverishly to meet, please let
me know. I have no problem making you a copy, but copy
services around here are a prized, limited commodity!"
RTC 12200/01 Page 2 of 2
310
OFHCE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLl/riON TRUST
CORPORATION
OrTicc of InTcstigalion ■ North CentraJ Resion
DATE:
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
June 2, 1993
Daniel L. Sherry
Regional Inspector General for Investigation
George F. Sullivan yffY
Asst. Regional Inspector General for Investigation
S/A Koszola's GJ Subpoena to the RTC - KC-93-0035
The first time I was aware of a subpoena to the RTC Pi-S in Kansas City was
after it was faxed to them. I am not sure if it was the same day or a couple of
days later. S/A Koszoia was standing by the fax machine, and I engaged him in
conversation by inquiring how the LEEBERMAN investigation was progressing.
He advised me that he had not received the records he had requested from the
RTC and had subpoenaed them.
S/A Koszoia and I then had a conversation about the other methods which could
have been employed in order to achieve the same end. I pxDinted out to him that
we had a staff of investigators in KC who would have inquired why we were not
getting cooperation and determined the location of the requested records.
S/A Koszoia was then instructed to convert the complaint to a case. 1 expressed
my concern to S/A Koszoia that the information he described as having requested
from PLS was far beyond the scope of the investigation. He had requested
information relating to all of the billing oresenied by BARACK FERRAZZANO
KIRSCHBAUM AND PERLMAN for all of the litigation they had been doing for
the RTC. (This would have been volumes of records.) The information
preceded LIEBERMAN's arrival at the CCO and participation m awarding of the
contracts; therefore, it was not germane. Koszoia explained that the subpoena
was more restnctive than his onginal request of PLS.
I subsequently found a document in Koszola's records which was a memorandum
to the AUSA requesting the subpoena. The memorandum was never presented
for my review or discussion. It did not have my initials on it and, when it was
faxed or delivered to the AUSA, it violated office policy. I review everything
going out of the olTice. 1 do not recall anything more specific about the subpoena
itself, onlv the above descnbed circumstances surrounding it.
;S North»eit Po.'iJ Bl«d. ■ SoUt 9«0 • Flk Gtot; \"mj«f. rL rMOl
311
THE DEPUTY SECRETARY CF THE TREASURY
WASHINGTON
September 28, 1993
The Honorable Donald W. Riegle, Jr.
Chainnan
Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs
United States Senate
Washington, B.C. 20510
Dear Don:
Secretary Bentsen and I are deeply troubled by the allegations made by witnesses at the
RTC whistleblower hearing held last Thursday, September 23 before the Senate
Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs. Allegations of harassment,
retaliation against whistleblowers, EEO violations, inappropriate hiring practices,
contracting improprieties and the failure to aggressively prosecute legal claims against
wrongdoers are disturbing and we talce them very seriously.
At my direction, the PTC has beg\m to review and summarize the allegations specified
at last week's hearing. No matter what it takes, the RTC will get on top of these
problems.
I do want to say, however, that the RTC is in better shape now than when we inherited
it. There is now a chief financial officer, we have nominated a chief executive officer
and we are on the verge of selecting a general counsel. The contracting systems have
been thoroughly overhauled, as have the audit follow-up procedures, and the small
investor program and the affordable housing program are successes. Moreover, we have
strengthened the minorities and women's programs at the RTC. Speaking frankly, if we
hadn't made such changes, I don't think the House and Senate would have voted recently
to extend funding for the RTC.
Having said that, we can ail agree that there is much left to do, and we want to work
closely with you to accomplish it.
Let me address direcUy the whistleblower controversy. The Clinton Administration
strongly supports the rights of whistleblowers. No agency is perfect in this regard, and
the RTC undoubtedly can and must do better. We'll see that it does.
As you may know, I personally reviewed the whisdeblower case in Denver. Jean
Hanson, Treasury General Counsel, also delved into it in depth, and there was an RTC
I.G. report on the subject and the Treasury I.G. investigated it as well. We ail
concluded that no laws were broken, however, that isn't to say this situation was handled
appropriately and that it certainly should not serve as a model for future action. 1 had
earlier informed Congresswoman Schroeder of these conclusions.
312
~ 2 -
We are going to distribute a new memorandum to all employees that reaffirms the RTC's
policy of protecting whistleblowers against retaliation. The memorandum will state that
the RTC encourages the reporting of suspected wrongdoing and mismanagement and will
set forth a complaint channel that makes accessible even the most senior management
officials. The memorandum will emphasize that the RTC will not tolerate retaliatory acts
and will investigate and address appropriately all charges of such activity. In keeping
with our existing policy, we will take special care to ensure that any personnel or
administrative actions involving the witnesses who testified at last week's hearing have
independent merit and are not reprisals for whistleblowing.
Next, let me comment on the very serious and disturbing allegations surrounding the
Professional Liability Section.
As you know, the GAO's study of the RTC's PLS program, released two months ago,
found "no indication that RTC or PLS management sought to undermine the professional
liability work." The GAO did find some risk that future claims may suffer fi-om
inadequate staffing and the staffs lack of experience. In addition, the GAO pointed out
that, because RTC is a temporary agency, it is difficult to attract and retain PLS
attorneys and recommended that the RTC work with the FDIC to analyze and address
the staffing needs of the PLS program.
In the spirit of the "Thrift Depositor Protection Act" that recently passed the Senate, the
RTC has relied heavily on the GAO's conclusions in developing their approach to solving
the problems at PLS. Aggressive pursuit of wrongdoers is a high priority for this
Administration. In fact, it is an important part of the ten point management reform
program that the Secretary mandated and that I have been implementing in my capacity
as Interim CEO. We are discussing staffing issues with the Acting Chairman of the
FDIC.
One of the witnesses at the hearing suggested that PLS attorneys, particularly in Texas,
had failed to pursue numerous PLS cases because of inadequate investigations. This
assertion differs from the GAO's conclusion that its review of close-out memoranda
showed that decisions not to pursue cases were based on "good faith and plausible
litigation judgments." If, in fact, the GAO reached inaccurate conclusions, or reached
its conclusions on insufficient information, it might be appropriate that you give serious
consideration to directing the GAO to reassess its conclusions. We would like to discuss
this with you further, and explore alternative investigative possibilities.
We also are prepared to refer each allegation of misconduct, ftaud, or waste to the RTC
Inspector General. Any allegations that relate to the IG's office will be referred to the
Treasury's Inspector General. At the same time, the RTC stands ready to work with you
and Members of the Committee to discuss practical alternative review mechanisms
including investigation by the General Accounting Office when such action may be
deemed both reasonable and warranted.
313
- 3 -
More generally, our review of last week's allegations suggests three different categories.
The first involves those where the RTC has already have initiated reviews. These are
currently in the Inspector General's office, the Office of Ethics, the Office of Contractor
Oversight and Surveillance or with RTC senior management. The second category
involves matters which one of the offices listed above already has reviewed and where
the review is complete. We will now go back to see if the reviews and follow-up action
were sufficiently thorough.
There is a final category of charges, of course, which haven't been formally reviewed
before. In some cases, the RTC knew of the claim but didn't believe it warranted a
formal review. In other cases, the charge is brand new.
We will now investigate all three categories to determine if prior reviews were thorough,
if current reviews are proceeding as they should and to investigate the new allegations.
Let me emphasize that we take these complaints with utmost seriousness. We will
provide to you, as soon as possible, a list of every single claim and the status of our
review. I'm sure some of them are valid complaints and e}tpose weaknesses at the RTC.
I want to assure you that we will work closely with you to ensure that the problems
which your witnesses illuminated are remedied.
Best regards.
Sincerely,
Roger C. Altman
Interim CEO
314
October 7, 1993
The Honorable Donald W. Reigle, Jr.
Chairman
Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs
United States Senate
Washington D.C., 20510
Dear Mr. Reigle:
I have read the transcript of Thomas Burnside's testimony, a draft
response to some specific issues prepared by RTC Director of
Investigations Jim Dudine and several pieces of correspondence
which relate to the September 23 testimony.
After several days of agonizing over whether to write to you, I
have decided that I must express myself. My range of emotions,
over what has happened to the Investigations Department in RTC
Dallas, has varied from total disbelief to anger, to outrage to
insult.
First, there was the total lack of national policies, focus or
direction from the Washington DC Office of Investigations. Each
field office was left free to operate and develop policies and
procedures. (Little wonder the consolidations have been so
difficult.)
Then there was the lack of a cooperative spirit between the PLS
attorneys and the Investigators. I initially attributed it to a
difference in work ethics, but it later became obvious that there
continuous efforts by PLS Attorneys to thwart the completion of
full investigations.
We could literally spend days discussing the "could have beens" and
the ensuing scenarios regarding our investigations "if only" PLS
read our work products, had issued subpoenas, responded to a legal
question, advised Investigations early on of potential pitfalls,
had shared their knowledge with Investigations and listened to us
when we shared our knowledge with them! (PLS actually had the
nerve to accuse Investigations of working late to create
documentation showing the problems between PLS/Investigations. If
PLS bothered to look at any of the documentation when it was
originally sent to them, they could see that we did not have to
"create" this documentation, that there was a steady stream of
documentation going into their office, which was not acknowledged,
read or responded to.)
315
Then there was the first re-organization of the RTC in 1992. Input
on how to best implement the consolidation was not elicited from
the management staff. The information provided by the field
management regarding the manpower needs was found by Washington to
be overstated, but when pressed for assumptions, guidelines or
specific suggestions, Washington personnel could not respond.
(This is typical, field management was consistently criticized for
products, but when specific guidelines or assumptions were sought,
no answer was available.)
Dallas Management was not in support of the consolidation of the
offices, and believed it was at least a year too soon; however
because of the professional attitude, local management committed
time, staff and other resources to the consolidation effort.
Dallas Management was required to develop and implement their own
consolidation plans, work out the inconsistencies, absorb the case
load, and replace the investigators lost to consolidation. All
this, while trying to keep the Investigators focused on developing
cases and supporting litigation efforts I
Unfortunately, during this time frame (winter 1992-93) the
relationship between PLS/Investigations was extremely strained.
(The weekly management meetings had stopped and the investigators
were trying valiantly but futilely to get some PLS response.)
Then the ICING on the cake! ! Tom Burnside filed his grievance, and
asked me to be his representative. Having worked with Tom for
nearly 2 years, I found him to be very honest and a person of high
integrity. After learning of the basis for his grievance, I
immediately offered unconditional support. Dallas Management
recognized the risk we were taking, siding with an unpopular
individual against a group who could hurt the department's efforts
to reach their goal. Although the thought of retaliation had
crossed our minds, we had no clue that the results could be so
devastating.
As for the grievance, it never went anywhere. RTC management has
a knack for burying their head in the sand, and hoping that if a
problem is not acknowledged, it will go away. Ultimately, Tom
Burnside did go away, but he is not the problem. POOR management
is the problem.
And the relationship between PLS and Investigations got even
further strained. Dallas Management tried to inform the Washington
Investigations Management of the problems, however, the message
fell on deaf ears. Once again, the "avoidance management" theory
was practiced. Even a meeting of the Directors of Investigation
and the Vice Presidents of the four offices and Washington
Management could not offer any solutions. Once again, the highest
levels of management could not take a stand, to ensure that the
mission of the corporation was met. Washington Investigations
Management did not listen to Dallas Investigations Management, and
316
it became apparent that there would not be a fair hearing and
resolutions would be one-sided. I acknowledge that Dallas
Investigations is not perfect, and that there are some internal
problems, however, the flaws are not fatal.
Instead of fair hearing and an effort to resolve problems with
existing management, a team from Kansas City has decided that the
Dallas Management team must be restructured. Today it was official
that we will change from 3 managers to 9! The decisions were made
in a vacuum, almost no discussion was held with the Dallas
Management. There was no attempt to find out how and why the
Dallas office was structured, but an all out effort was made to
have the Dallas Management "mirror" that of Kansas City. It is now
obvious that the results of our investigative efforts are not
important. Dallas Investigations has been very successful in
recovering on our cases, we have a self-developed inventory system
that has no equal, we have experienced a minimal number of problems
in converting a national data base system and yet our office is
being "fixed". I do not believe that the changes are good for the
cases, the Department, the RTC and certainly not for the taxpayer!
Office productivity has slowed, and I have serious concern about
the ability to regain our momentum.
I have been told over and over that the PLS/Investigations ' war is
over. I agree, we have been in a cease-fire for several months.
There has been an uneasy but peaceful atmosphere; how can you have
a war when no-one is engaged? While the "war" may be over, there
certainly is not a healthy, cooperative spirit between the PLS
Attorneys and Investigators. There is still an exceedingly long
time for PLS follow-up to issues, there is bad legal advice given,
and there are still attempts to loop the investigators out of the
process. Certainly, there is not a high level of comfort in this
situation. I would rather witness an all out battle between the PLS
attorneys and investigators, at least then I know there is some
attempt at communication and action!
I have read Interim CEO Altman's Sept. 28, 1993 letter to you, in
it he mentions two specific issues that I want to address. The
first issue is the GAO review of closed out investigations. Mr.
Altman indicates that the review of the close out memos evidence
good faith and plausible litigation judgments. I suggest that
maybe the review was not as far reaching as it should have been.
I suggest that a complete, joint review of the entire investigative
file and the PLS file be performed, to ensure the close out was the
appropriate decision. I have been present at a meeting where a
Close Out Memorandum and an Authority to Sue Memorandum were
presented on the same institution. I understand that each memo
read well, and appeared well supported and plausible. How can it
be that two diametrically opposite plans of action on the same case
are simultaneously appropriate?
317
The second issue, is that the senior management of RTC is heading
the review of the allegations raised in testimony. I suggest that
an independent review be conducted, and that the field management
of the RTC offices be consulted. Dallas Investigations Management
has identified many problems, their peers have confirmed that many
of those same problems exist in their offices. I believe the fear
of retaliation has stymied the protestations and silenced many who
have identified problems and want real, workable solutions.
Through this letter, I believe I have identified a pattern, and I
believe it is that there is poor management at the RTC. Yes, that
is a broad brush, but in looking at the management of the
Investigations Office and the PLS, I have to conclude that poor
management is the root of many of our problems.
I have been a government employee for over 14 years, and this is
the first time I have worked in such a tumultuous environment. I
believe in the mission of the Investigation Department and have
been deeply committed to fulfilling that mission. For over three
years, I have been a Department Head in this Office, and I dearly
hope that we can continue to be successful. We have a very
experienced, dedicated staff in Dallas, who has survived a constant
barrage of negative feedback, continuous change and attacks on
their work and their integrity. Nobody and no office is perfect,
but if someone bothers to look closely at the Dallas Office of
Investigations, they will find that the staff here is trying to
fulfil the corporate mission, and not fulfil personal agendas. I
invite you to visit the Dallas Office, to meet with all levels of
staff and get a real taste of what is going on here.
Sincerely,
't
M )i
Diane M. Mendoza
Assistant Director - Investigations
318
GAO
I'nited States
General Accounting Office
Washington. DC. J0.S48
General Govemmeni Division
July 23, 1993
Mr. Bruce Pederson, Counsel
Resolution Trust Corporation
Dear wFr Pederson:
Enclosed is a copy of our final report entitled Thrift
Failures: Actions Needed to Stabilize RTC's Professional
Liability Program (GAO/GGD-9 3-105 ) that was released by the
Senate Banking Committee on July 19. The report discusses
how RTC's ill-conceived actions have demoralized and
disrupted the Professional Liability Section (PLS) program.
I personally wanted to send you a copy of the report and
thank you for all the help you gave GAO during our study.
Your insight into PLS's operations were invaluable as we
assessed the Section's staffing, litigation policies, and
pursuit of professional liability claims. Thank you again.
Sincerely yours.
Edward H. Stephenson,
Assistant Director
319
PATRICIA SCMROEDEH
120i a«*»wM MawM OM<i •<»*««
IMO lM*MB SiMtf
0«««f» CO Wltl
Congresffi of tljc ®nitcb States;
l^ouse of ^epresentattbed
«a«ljington. SC 20515-0601
»«MI3 SiaV'CCS C3MM — t:
CHAiavWOMlN So«COMW-T(t QS Ml''**'
"•STi.jlTlONS AND ««Cl. 't!
»0S' O'nci »N0 Civi.
SKViCI COMHirrtE
JUOiCiAMv COWMiTTCE
CHAiawOMlN StLlC" COMMiTTIt
ON ChilOMEN yOuTm *n0
lAMInES
COMOISSIONAL CAUCUS >0*
WOMEN S ISSUES CO-CnAlR
April 14, 1993
Bruce Pederson
Resolution Trust Corporation
707 17th street, P.O. Box 5410
Denver, CO 80217
Dear Bruce:
I just wanted to send you a personal note tp thank you for
your efforts to eliminate waste, fraud, and abuse at the
Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC) .
The information you provided to my office and to the House
and Senate Banking Committees is invaluable. You have raised
legitimate questions about the way that taxpayer money is
spent. Without employees like you, we would never cut
government waste. You are to be commended.
Keep up the good work!
Schrceder
Congresswoman
cc: Barbara Shangraw, Assistant General Counsel, Western
Regional Office
Richard Aboussie, General Counsel, RTC Washington
EXHIBIT
I Jt
THIS STATIONEP' •BiNTED ON •A»|l« MAOC O' MCCTCLEO fHI«S
320
EXHIBIT 2
CAVALLO PRIZE FOR MORAL COURAGE
ACCEPTANCE SPEECH
BRUCE J. PEDERSON
June 9, 1993
The strange twists and turns we call life bring us to places and circumstances far
beyond our wildest dreams. Call it fate, destiny, or serendipity. Three years ago, I
never would have imagined receiving a prestigious award tor moral courage. It re-
quired an unprecedented series of events: the greatest financial scandal in our na-
tion's history, my service as a manager with the Professional Liability Section
("PLS") of the Resolution Trust Corporation ("RTC"), and the unparalleled mis-
management at RTC which I attempted to expose during the past tortuous vear.
I don't regard my efforts as particularly ejctraordinary. I merely did what I felt
was ri^t. 1 revere the truth and am offended by those who seek to distort or de-
stroy it. The purest form of public service results from adhering to the truth. For
me, these beliefs lessened the burden of the hurtful price I paid for speaking out
on behalf of the taxpayer. Other whistleblowers have had far more taken from them.
Indeed, I am humbled by the substantial sacrifices made by other recipients and
nominees of this award.
A lot of people deserve my heartfelt thanks for this award. First, and foremost,
I want to express my deep appreciation to Michael Cavallo and the Cavallo Founda-
tion. Without his efforts and resources, there would be no award. The Cavallo Prize
for Moral Courage is a beacon which reminds us that people still do the right thing
even when the easier path leads in the opposite direction.
Second, I want to thank my dear mend, Jackie Taylor. During our past 18
months of hell spent in a bitter agency "turf war" and ensuing retaliation, Jackie
was my immediate partner in exposing RTC waste and abuse. Her support and en-
couragement when everything in our professional lives fell away was irreplaceable.
Most whistleblowers do not have the luxuiy of having a nearby colleague engaged
in the same activity. I am extremely gratenil for her presence in my life. Our col-
league, Brad Smolkin, also deserves praise for his support and brave testimony in
Congress last August.
Next, I want to thank those people who helped me disseminate the message that
the American taxpayer was being ripped off by the insane reorganization of the RTC
PLS. Many agency employees proviaed me with useful information. I won't publicly
acknowledge them by name because to do so would subject them to swift and pre-
dictable retaliation. 1 will, however, dedicate this award to Virginia McCrae, one of
mv former colleagues tmd a close friend. Ginny was an RTC PLS lawyer in Denver
wno passed away last July from a sudden heart attack at the a^e of 36. She joined
RTC PLS not long after I did and was instrumental in feeding information regard-
ing the crippled PLS Program to Jackie Taylor and myself after we had been kicked
out of our managerial positions. Despite great risk to ner standing within the Legal
Division, Ginny fearlessly chose to associate with us in public and confirm our fears
about the direction of the new PLS Program. She did so right up to the' day she
died. Ginny was the embodiment of moral courage.
My disclosure efforts were escorted by a collection of guardian angels who appear
as tne employees at the Government Accountability Project ("GAP"). Director Louis
Claik, Legal Director Tom Devine, Legislative Counsel Jeff Ruch, and others at
GAP were invaluable sources of legal, stratepc, and emotional support during the
past year. All were immensely helpful in guiding my preparation of congressional
testimony and surviving the ensuing waves of retaliation at the RTC. Without GAP,
many public and private sector whistleblowers would never be heard. GAPs work
honors truth and the public interest. It deserves your financial and moral support
now and always.
My efforts to speak the truth about the RTC also were immeasurably helped by
members of the media who followed the PLS reorganization. Recognition must go
to those reporters who advanced the story by analyzing the "spin control" offered
up by the RTC. Susan Sdimidt of The Washington Post, Jeff Gerth of The New York
Times, Marianne Lavelle and Sherry Sontag of The National Law Journal, Dick
Keil of the Associated Press, Steve Wilmsen of The Denver Post, John Rebchook of
the Rochf Mountain News, Jeff Barker of The Arizona Republic, Mike McGrath of
Denver Westward, Steve France of the Bank Lawyer Liability Reporter, and Michael
Hsu of the RTC Report, among others, all played an important role in the written
effort.
321
Special thanks also must go to CBS News Street Stories, Producer Glenn Silber,
reporter Jernr Bowen, analyst George Clyde and host Ed Bradley did a terrific job
of bringing this story into the living rooms of American taxpayers. Peter Boyle of
KBYG ana Dennis Burkhardt of KDEN, through their Denver radio talk shows, also
Srovided a valuable forum for the truth. I also anticipate that NBC News and pro-
ucer Jess Bushyhead will make use of my retaliation experience in an upcoming
First Person with Maria Shriver piece about employee privacy that will air in July.
This impressive collection of journalists exposes the fallacy of the RTC position
that what Jackie Taylor and I have to say about the PLS reorganization is of little
value to understanding agency operations and that no one is really interested in the
issue. I submit that millions of American taxpayers disagree. Mismanagement of
public programs, particularly on the huge scale of the RTC, never loses its
newsworthmess.
The next major category of people deserving my thanks are those who listened to
my message. Contrary to the RTC's "party bne that I was a malcontent bent on
merely complaining about the loss of my management position, there was a recep-
tive audience that found value and truth in what I had to say about the PLS Pro-
gram and the taxpayer's interests. The list is lengthy, but bears mentioning. It be-
gins with several members of the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housmg, and
Urban Affairs before whom I testified last August. These include its Chairman, Don-
ald Riegle and former Senator Tim Wirth. Senator Howard Metzenbaum also par-
ticipated in the committee's work regarding the RTC. Members of their staffs, in-
cluding Konrad Alt, Mike Perko, and Brian McTigue, worked long and hard to help
focus the spotlight of oversight on the RTC.
Other congressional offices which listened to my message included my representa-
tive in Congress, Patricia Schroeder, and Congressman Bruce Vento. Members of
their staffs devoted considerable time digesting what I had to say. These included
Doug Nelson and Neal Peterson.
I also want to thank the members of the U.S. General Accounting Office ("GAO")
who spent countless hours documenting the lack of rational planning and senseless
carnage caused by the PLS reorganization. Led by Assistant Comptroller General
Richard Fogel who took the time to personally debrief us in Denver, many GAO em-
ployees were involved. Chief among these were Henry Wray, Ed Stephenson, Drew
Valentine, Lynn Gibson, and Mary Lane Renninger. I anticipate that their final re-
port regarding the RTC PLS will corroborate many of the concerns Jackie and I
voiced last August.
Finally, members of my family and various friends deserve my gratitude for their
emotional support during these many grueling months. Your encouragement helped
keep me going when liie seemed very futile. This diverse group ranges from my
motner to my coworkers who shared that knowing nod or smile with me on one of
my darker days which told me that I was making a difference.
I wish to leave you with a few thoughts on "moral courage." After all, that concept
underlies the Cavallo Award. The dictionary variously defmes courage as the moral
strength to persevere and withstand fear or difliculty. As a word, courage has its
roots in the French word for heart, which is "coeur." Moral is defined to mean the
principles of ri^t and wrong. I beUeve that a person exhibiting moral courage dis-
places fear in order to point out the truth. That process begins in the heart and is
sustained by the spirit. It occurs in spite of the mind where lear resides.
Moral courage is paradoxical. It is universal yet difficult to manifest. Mustering
moral courage to speak the truth is not something reserved for special people other-
wise known as heroes. It is a quality inherent to all of us that patiently waits to
be released. Your potential is no different from mine. The only difference is that
people are out of touch with their moral courage in varving degrees.
To tap into moral courage each individual must shift from Tear driven conduct to
proactively advancing the truth. The process is not easy. In the case of whistle-
blowing, it cuts against years of conditioning designed to maintain a safe career
path and financial security. It also requires a person to weather, from day to day,
the many forms of retaliation which are limited only by the arrogance of hostile
management. Culpable managers wUl threaten or take away jobs, future pro-
motions, current responsibilities, grade or pay, office space, privacy, working rela-
tionships, and one's reputation. I endured many of these reprisals at the RTC. There
also exists the widespread perception that no effective legal protections exist for
those who speak out. Whistleblowing has been described as the "sound of profes-
sional suicide."
The most fonnidable obstacle to speaking the truth is not always apparent at first
glance. For me, the hardest part was the emotional devastation inflicted by manage-
ment's retaliation. My career of public service, the PLS work I loved and excelled
at during the past seven years, cherished working relationships with friends and
322
colleagues, privacy, and reputation were all yanked away or attacked. A big piece
of my identity was suddenly gone. I felt thrown ofF a secure location into a tettom-
less abyss, 'rtiese were the land of times contemplated by the Spanish mystic St.
John of the Cross when he wrote of the "daric ni^t of tibe soul." Fear constantly
attempted to hijack my decision making powers. Its offspring, loneliness and rejec-
tion, crept in as former friends and associates, fell away under the wei^t of
changed circumstances at work. The demons of self-doubt — "why did I do this,"
"what could have been," "what will people think," and "what will become of me" —
relentlessly returned to haunt at the times of greatest despair. For me, exercising
moral courage involved passage throu^ a test of fire. I needed perseverance and
mettle to survive the process.
So, how does one overcome fear in order to exhibit moral courage? Against all of
the foregoing disincentives, the process must begin somewhere. I submit that it com-
mences with the realization that truth has been violated in some significant fashion.
One is left with the bottom line conclusion. This is wrong." There is a very real
power to this event. It provides the advocate with the facts and understanding nec-
essary to expose the lie or distortion. In so doing, the truth becomes easy to defend.
It has its own seamless Integrity, eloquence and appeal. By contrast, management
"spin control" rings hollow when sounded by the truth.
Next, one must refuse to buy into the currency of fear used by culpable manage-
ment. Those hoping to cover up waste, incompetence, fraud or abuse anchor their
power base by intimidating employees with the risk of loss. This brutal system of
governance works only as long as the rank and file subscribe to it. When one or
more individuals stand up and refuse to allow fear of loss to dictate their actions,
management has lost its leverage to cover up the truth. This shift in power can
occur with one person, but works best with groups of people willing to speak out.
I believe that the RTC's ability to sweep the sordid story of the PLS debacle under
the rug was significantly impeded by the public stand which Jackie Taylor, Brad
Smolkin and I took last year. We chose to deal in a different currency and stuck
to our decision.
Next, one who Eispires to demonstrate moral courage must recognize that life fre-
quently cloaks opportunity inside a crisis. Instances where the truth is maligned are
actually invitations to make a positive change in government or industry. Being at
the epicenter of a coverup is life's way of calling one from the dugout to the batter's
box. Accept the call! To do otherwise, is to miss your calling at best, and to be a
part of the problem at worst. Be wary too, of the "cop outs" or rationalizations that
deter so many from reaching their moral courage. These include self-defeating
thoughts like, "Fve got a mortgage to pay; let someone else do it" and "I can't make
a difference anyway." Those statements are laced with fear and demonstrate an un-
willingness to take responsibility for self and the community we share. Mtmagers
with something to hide desperately hope that employees will believe these lies.
Finally, it helps to adopt one or more role models. Over the past year, I drew on
memories of my father, a former West Point officer, who taught me about "Thity,
Honor and Country" and doing the "right thing." I also related to the character
played by Al Pacino in the Oscar winning movie, "Scent of a Woman." He triumphed
in the end by overcoming a lifetime of fear to eloquently speak the truth in a setting
that was stacked against him.
Beyond the practical suggestions of how to overcome fear and tap moral courage,
I must point out that the process is a reward in itself. Those who persevere to reach
for the truth stand to receive several personal gifts. They can hold their heads hig^
knowing that they did not "sell out." They know themselves far better after being
tested throu^ adversity. They provide a role model and inspiration for others who
will follow in their footsteps on behalf of some other pivotal issue. I also would be
remiss if I did not point out that whistleblowers do msike a difference. One has only
to review the many positive changes in our society that began with the spark of re-
alization by a brave soul that things did not have to be a certain way. The truth
be said, there was a better, or more just way, to do things.
One such individual who saw things from a more truthful perspective was Ma-
hatma Gandhi. Throughout my adult life, I have attempted to en^race his teach-
ings. He once said, "My life is my message." My actions at the RTC are my latest
statement of who I am. Needless to say, I am thrilled and deeply honored to be rec-
ognized for living my message. From my heart, thank you one and all.
323
EXHIBIT 3
Key to Categories and Cross-References in Time Line of Abuse
Patterns of abuse are sometimes diflicult to recognize. This is especially true if
one only has knowledge of an instance or two of abuse standing alone. The Time
Line of Abuse of RTC Whistleblowers is a chronology of major events surrounding
Jackie Taylor's and Bruce Pederson's attempts to bring to the attention of public
officials for correction the significant harm and hirfi cost of the RTC's 1992 reorga-
nization of the Professional Liability Program. This time line graphically dem-
onstrates the relentless manner in which RTC management attempted to "kill the
messengers" instead of devoting their attention to correcting the problems.
For ease in reviewing the Time Line, columns have been set up entitled "Cat-
egory" and "Cross-Reference". These columns contain phrases to alert the reader to
the types of abuse involved in the specific entry. Phrases in the designation "Cat-
egorj^ is a description of the primary type of behavior described in that entiy. Be-
cause an event might involve more than one type of abusive behavior or RTC pro-
gram the "Cross Reference" column contains phrases to alert the reader to related
categories of abuse.
The key words and phrases used in the Time Line are defined as follows:
ANNOUNCEMENT— Events affecting the instances of abuse of programs and whis-
tleblowers, but which 8ire not specific items of abuse
ATTORNEY /CLIENT PRIVILEGE— Instances when RTC management violates oth-
ers attorney/client privileges
CA VALLO—Lastances related to Jackie's and Bruce's receipt of the 1993 Cavallo
Award for moral courage in government and business
COMPUTER— Entries which contain behavior affecting the use of RTC computers
DIRECTIVES— Policy and procedure announcements by RTC management
DOCUMENT SHREDDING— Events surrounding RTC Denver's shredding of RTC
documents
££0— Situations related to RTC Equal Employment Opportunity programs and pro-
cedures
FOIA — Instances surrounding Bruce's and Jackie's attempts to secure information
from the RTC under the Federal Freedom of Information Act
GRIEVANCE— Events surrounding the multiple grievance proceedings instituted by
Bruce and Jackie
HARASSMENT— Instances of abuse occurring prior to Bruce and Jackie contacting
Congress and occurrences of abusive behavior involving RTC personnel in addition
to Bruce and Jackie
JOSS— Matters relating to reassignment of RTC geographic locations, job titles and
duties
LEAVE TIME— Instances in which Bruce and Jackie are held to hypercritical or in-
correct applications of time and attendance rules
A£A/Z/— Instances of abuse relating to U.S. mail
MOVES— Instances of abuse relating to moving offices within the Denver area
RETALL\TION— Multiple types of abuse that arise after Jackie's and Bruce's initial
attempts to inform public oflicials in Congress of the wrongs occurring at the RTC
SLANDER— Those circumstances when members of RTC management slander
Bruce and Jackie
TELEPHONES— Instances of abuse involving telephones
THREATS TO EMPLOYEES— Instances when RTC management directly threaten
other RTC employees for their involvement with Jackie and Bruce
UNAUTH.COMP I UNAUTHORIZED COMPUTER ENTRANCE— Pronouncements
and specific actions related to break-ins of RTC employees' computers
324
E
m £
CD o
»$
It
(J o
O TJ
£ «
3 O
o o <«
fll
3 ^ (/»
c
o
in
««
£
^
-J
a
(/5
o
&
i/>
o»
c
01
c
u
^
6
tA
u
■D
5!
fll
5
C
a
-3
CO
n
«
0>
*«
™
Q
J5
= « s
* S S
8 5 J
E S »
•^ «) £
c 5 «
e 6 _
— — o
« m «
-J C ttl
- o ™ •
^, ^ Ifl 10
o Q. 3 ■€
« 5 w f
* o ^e E
^ c Q. o
£ S £ o>
* S,5 ^
§ o E i
• •>
S tf>
li
• J
I-
« ■■
" « e
E O.S
2 E£
— 00
= £ —
« 8 ?
— «• 5
M C to
^ W -- — —
£ t; >* S E
•- 3 ■! «
o. o
O la
£(f>
< o
Oi *>
CD 0/
^£
CD
m
ft) w .
C O (Q
< 3 «
= Q t)
ft""
£a ^
« s i
l| iS
c: gj 1)
" P -
^ t *
St ™
£ o -^
«^ V «
« 0.£
>. tr> ^
IK n 9
e 5 ^
S £ ja
S T> *>
o.g£
</) o t"
— I £ c
a = -6
I " s
<i-"^ o E
0.(/) (A lA
3 _1 5 o
T3 Q. « %
a o o "
E •= *
i <" o <"
s s a ?
^ 8.« E
^ l» c o
= S « m
4) ~ C "
y c «) w
JJ «) O _j
Q. E 4) 0.
? p * *
s c c a>
«j c o —
a> ») 5 T>
S Sen t
"5
a.
E
o
o
c
3
o
l» LL C „
c -c « y
a i- a ^
E £ -g «
tol^ £
5S3 E
•R S ° E
c S * e
4 ■* i-X
c !i =
o 5 o- 4
^ O 4) —
4> ^ ^ i:
4) ifl O o
£ 5 « r
e o 5 9
-£ f S^ Q.
5 S "
« !!! c
i-8 «.
3 o «
aE
?,t
S-2
= £ E
o o <n
a
8
'I
£ lA
= 1
1 " o
325
s I
u
5
o
i
o
SS
SI a-
326
(0
n
X
c
?2
• I
II
a c
11
o o
V u
1 =
S2
c c m
£ o 5 c 3
C « £ « JO
^ « a> c —
is srs
t » *^ c
(_) s Q. S c
t- n P c «
S^ ? - s
"^ « Is
01 ^- 5 '-' «
£ £ c E «>
e « 2 »
^ o
i| g
a. «> £
« c
n « ^
= S
Z
IS
£
2
v
a-o
« c
C IB
• s
f I
II
£ W
11
|S
l-i
jc n
S S
-9 - -
y or
£i2
Q.
Ki c i; •=
o tg tfi
3 5*
lie
* e 5
<= c ■=
^ 5 ■" 3 o
= £ lA U S
JS _ |» O IB
c n *> ° o
«> U V « £
c o 2 c ^
IB — CL 9
> « S f S
e _ (B
ess
IS
i> C
11
& in
o t>
&
■' ,- ? 5 S a p .
S 'S ■?
o £ £ o S
(05*^3
-> S Q IB a.
r^, IB C
2 E S
25 •
,-' • =
I o I
oil
» — c
- IB -
I ^
I- O IB
at
E £ » S
o •£ X
O O x> (B
^ "5 >* 0)
(D c a> —
2"" •= o
= ifi S
f g e 3
£ B E 5
o c §► *
0} C IS >k
■ft :z c • -
S C CB C 01
£ « C g C
" e||s
C 01 ■ < c
^ ?i ?l
O IB — IB
to 5 -o 5 .9
££ g£ ^
- el >-3
O £ IB J3 =
■o S 5
Sof
? = =
0) •= 0)
"O -o ™
IB c IB
E » £
<» S,
■c g" $
>■ C 0)
e s c
III
< E »>
o>
c
■o
£ s s
» 2 o
> • o>
01 0) g t-
£ ? 5-°
•D
O CB
E|
o « «
» « i * c »
5 £ S " " -
'q} n
0* N Q.
C £ E
s & o
^ o •>
0) » «
£ 5 $
g2 »!
1 = 21
■" S-g-o.
o • — '*
25
(S o
> E
«1
a. go
A tfl IB
£ 01 O)
— - IB
O £ £
= ■? 0.
0) I =
'= "I
c E-?
a » T>
2l-i5c
S -2 =
ie
- •: je 3
s 5 5 o
S
G 2 "o
5 « » b
in S * «
■? E jc a S
s S I £ S
•g tf. c 3 m
SS O i •!
IB IB 01
£ $ £
0. « o
0 3 <
™ <0 ?
-< E
JS Q. a
1 S c
— £ a
)B ^ S
Ol <B ^
££ u
«0 3
U ID ,
— 0) — •
0> 01 «
f^i
: (0
o> o < a
•K -5 a 3
U IB ? Ill
a ■= = —
-> IB o«
(/) » c -
-J Tj « a
Q. « S «
= _) — «
C OJ
If
0> "O
01
0> l» £
J? c **
O 01
§2
• « 5
£ a
° I « i
3 t « *
6 S-S o
* S S
(B a>
" E
o
w 9 •
IB Q. «
3 y i
— 3 CO
•> o -o
K S 3
3 C O
■O « •-
S " £
" o> >
3 Z £ i
o a (0 f
jc £ Iff (/)
O ti lA U
9^ f S
u o 10 a>
« c o
a 5! 01 —
£ c i a.
© o o c
O) o IB C
«i f S (S
E
I
ll I
2 « 5 3
_ " JC JC
" ai£ -o
IB IB fc V
er C * e
£ IB £ C
o> E I
IB « JC _
ri s 2
£ Z tf> o>
*; c « o
f S-c £
E Q- c X
e o v ~
££ E S
C IB » o
-.= •- IB c
J2eI5
3 jn o. s
"•5 o «
m ** C o
■= 0) oa c
«X|^
•J 0) •- —
0> T
•w ift ;^ —
O S I §.
o — >,
£ B u
Oi «A IB
S 01 A
5 £ 3
<» . a
« ^ 0)
£ £ £
a» IB r
IB > o
C £ CB
IB Q. o
P C
- n £ '^
IB ^ 4) J£
r 01 t £
S i * °-
I 8 *w
9oia
o ^ o o
0) (0 " —
— o -* o
£ a, « oi
O 3 f »
«> T) (0 C
*l- i
irS-5 8
U _ 01 I/-
ft O J£ 3
■§ C IB O
Q. S E S
0) l/» '5
JS $ £ n
■^ •" m 1"
' J£ JC IB ^
!« U C £
i£5
tf)
of E S
2£ ™-s
3
IB
s
J5
^
^
S
327
u
c
If)
tl N
w IB
a c
I 3
I
(0
E
w
I
o.
o
4) (0
3 w
o- o
11
s a - £
IS
" ;= ,-,
- ? i
0^ $
^E
w 9
a> Q.
O =:
*- lA
o> e
c <n
^ 5
o £
ui t Ji _
1/1 lA
C O
3 O.
^ a»
m £
o —
a T3
U
~> o
-D J
n V)
Sa
m £
A o
O £
^ o
E O
S I
c P
O jO
2 w
n s
I-
- a>
_o£
IT ™
10 c
u t
£ o
UJ c
|£
°J
£ ™
(D re
0) o
(J w
3 re
CD «/)
re o
c» *-
« m
— c
15
— Q.
> c «1
i-i S
S -"^
? i
3i £ ^
c -D J5
- c E
•o « «
« jc -<
to o c
2 c 5
» V S
T> t> a.
£ B S
V >- i.
c «> •
C ? 10
< I •
52-5
^ 10
a> S s o
o
El**
o
O c
•fc 1/1
n
■£= ?■
— * *!
_ «> £
m " _
> m £
2f ° S
«• - c 5
a 9
-c ci
2 -
S ■»
1°
E V
o ^
10
4) C
C 10 10
O S
S »
— (/>
£ «
oiE
E E
■p o
I *
»/> ? '^ -X. re ^ r^
a> j« (O O > « "
11
re 'y
re i/t
? 0-2
c 2" IS tS
Ol lO
01 >.
- a
10 c
II
4A <
fsl
E
c» re
2&
111
111
1.^
SI
(/) re
« £ "
C 01 £
^ £ <
o
-■- lO «
s ™ ■f
9 ??
Si*
« « 10
5 ° I
'o ^ re
10 «> £
f 9 *
£ > jt
3 ■— 10
°-2 5
- — F
S - -o
I T3 c
re ^ ™
*i =. m
o; lo §
- S °
^° "
•fc o 01
o 01 ■£
c 10 lO
lO t/5 *3
o> — I o
o a c
O 0^ P o
, . x; ^ re
S:? o -oS
°^ E S i.
^ 10 £ Oj
01 S 0, =
^ 3 ^ O
t- Q. re s
9?
328
e
S
1 1
u o
s
IT
I
£
o
a
I
u
£ ui
S UJ
8.6
« 8
u S:
■o a-
S5
9 " ■"
^ >: 5
o -o •
* ° I
c
o
a
«
E
c E
9 T3
^!
<" -o
JS £
O X
tn E
■^ c
Oj o
™ =
^ IT
<-> ?
3 0/
<S at
u fg ^
S — • i
a- S S^ >•
$ 9
is *
• » £ « o
c tt a> E £
= E £ "
o o 9
u o E
O J<
" If?
™ T5 ^
(« 5 §
££§
O S'^
UJ o> "»
.A • *"
5i
o S.
e £
< =
a!
E o
« S
5 -^
« a
• s -
■o c
2 c o
o 9 c
ill
• • £
Q. o £
Q £ I
S 3
o ^ «
> — <«
«> A 3
l« -
« a o
£ -o M
^ s ^
ill
O V
O "^ £ O"
9 °-^ ?
= «l o $
^ c - -
E f "
«l S 4> >
<«
if
£ 0-S5 £ S i c
E » o
o y o
re ^ re
— (£ -J
■2 5 g
? re 9
S 5 XR
C ft;
4> « 3
^ » cr
!^ o ^
lA C (J o>
= o *• S
«0 U •- fl)
■2 >"
5=9
£ £
£ *>
Q.£
IE
o o
« —
o re
•= Q.
4) re
re o>
£ 5
« re
£ re
«2
-*= CD
re —
3 o
°- E
^«
— t)
£ =
fi
si
lol
4> S ^
(V >. a
|5^
P- re
■D
C
i S g
> • i . 9 «j
■ a 5 5 5
5 «
!i
y o
11
« 2
S o
• 6 - *■
■£ re re >
5 e o _
J!^ •>£
X £ J£ s
** 5 «l w
E > • •
<3 c 'C
5 o S »
lA ^ Jf =
« « O V
c « re —
"- I/I c
£ re >> re
3 — re -.
£ TJ »> e
I 3^ O:
i * I - «
> - o re o
re ^£ c £
« !» ¥ o ifl
^ 9 i S 2
■g Q. o ac
« " I -> O ^
3 E ^ I/) i oj
4, ^ ft,
Q, ft> 4j
< o £
3 r. 3 £
^Se5?
^ — »i
'J'" oil
n
X
SIS
o> re
C £
<SS
o £
5 "
i^
K 2
II
— *>
•o g
tl c
0 >^
01 re
<n £
« i
S E
S «
Q-i:
« I-
£ o.
m E
S^
1.0
Ie
ft} (0
5 ?
2 »
£. -o
O T)
re o
II
0) tfl
C 01
_ o
a c
— o
II
£ I
0>£
re ***
E y
u. ^
c q:
u 0)
ids
il
E J
£ i
s. o
c c
01 3
1^
•*- c
c o
£ "J
re
= S
0) 01
o >
c O
E
01
■2- 3
a. ■" 3
01 01 -
O u £
- 9 9
§0:0=
0 ? —
01 ^ lA
Ifl C $
l!i
(T) O w
< = f
If^
a. *» -*-
o> X _
(T e
° &f
Ea::
I re re
* E *>
all
•=1^0 =
Q <
2f
3 3
O 9
y 2
< J£
01 o
£ S
is
E 01
o o
o c
re «i -c
■o 5 c
o£ ""
0 ^ 0)
< c^
re 0,
£ m -c
1 "5
re
0|
5
S?
(N
'^
(D
329
u
a.
o «
1 ^
5 E
«l o
q: u
S t3 " ■o
» 5| *
• o ° ^
o. o E c
«) « o ff
J5 ft
Eii
o o ■"
E
i8-
«> => « c 5
— — c o «
^ *» <" tfl ^
» y "5
^? I
«
c 9 2 s
^ !! S£
O O » 3
t B-l E
sS- 8
« s
S- ti «
S- *^ o
.• ■o it
I • o
- ? s
3 2?
o S a
< • £
. E
o 5 c
E I s 5ig o $
«> ? S. « 2
E « 2 S •
.— -5 *> »
2 E
§8
= • o
E «i
el
5 E
I
i .-D 41 »l
o
-I"
E 2 e
£ ° = I •
5 >, » Q. E
e o *= • u
5 C O -o c
• >- 2 °
£?5 o.i
c » - E c
* E = > *
> » >. V. ^
£ © - 4>
§ c£|£
o * S " §
c: c o.(r £
• S e
E oi£
est:
n tf ■£
o. a ?
«> - 3
I? I
e — o
£ = 6
o ^ =
0 (ft
3 — S s:
■ « £ 5
o £ 0) 7
c J. <j ^
• I E e-
• « § E
■I S= °
« a. >
" " 5
• °- ™^
^ "" ? a-
_ CO - o
^ »fl c «
• » (ft o
— « *-
s S §
lis
S f y
Q.-= C
E * °
= «< =
(« " n
-I E
(T CD (/>
O 3 £ -o
0 «/> ^ -o
£ _ »— Of
S " c §
5 X s o «;
J, Ol O O JJ
n Xfi (ft ^ tfi
s i oiS^
01 „ 5 e £
j5 O (T. ■>= ^
"^ § H ;?; °
i- 0) £ £
e1I|£
Is
W 3
•> c
£ c
»i
E o
£ =
a o
£ E
^ S
^^
£• c
3 OJ
* (ft
O m
c ai «
™ g >
tii
|<rt 4.
£^ §
I- °
Sis
• on
' S ift
5 So So I * 5
5£<»^-E!t2<»
!SLE(fl°S».^.
c:c^oS~*0
e-gEOeSjE
(ft B o ^ £ -o "
?*
* ' o
4) c a
C 4. e
©Of
£ = •-
*" « -.
= o ?
o 2 jc
- •.' (J
n c n
4> 4> -)
S- I" c
™ - 14
||S
ifl > d
« * CD
■§ £ *
x: t: —
<5 (4 o
■S -c -
^ (J T3
re c 4)
£ * i
3 « 4)
a (ft •o
^_ £ 2 3 (ft e
_ 3.16-0 g-f g>E
a4)"'Koi»^-
§2iS
C (0
*- x:
c -- •
«(»,ftoS^5T3
E
4J
Q
o 5 » >»
1 2 ,■5^ g.- c-S
««i»(ftoSsS'g
TjOS? 4)c 0°--
5^y 8-5 £ >-t c
(i, = 4) n u 5
' 4> t- S-ttc »> q: 4J
g(r »f l£ Q
"ftSsrcc'Sjft
,5™»,3ren!>.o
Q,'cC05'ft4(0
,S4>^4.>«>
(ftcC?>>.(ft*Q,^
:oQ.— Soc** —
BuT>Otje4)>S
^ s
o S
O 2.
sis
2
330
e
o
o
■o
§ 2 5 «.
"lis
n « c c
I (T O HI
S
o
•5
at i
utw
rz
a.
u
z
<s
T) a. . <•
• e • «
5 c I*: ^ e
3 ~ © • *•
" 2 a l2
lA Oft S « U
; JC > U «
Oft t) .^ 3 ^
S = — o
£ T3 C ■=
o 2 • -
= 3 c F
c S P S
""%%
IS 1
■s »
o
o «
i
5^« s
c « g 3
'O c o> a.
c * * ™
2 •= °^ JT
?•£ £ S
«; * u! «i
= ^5 I
_ Q. 0) t
™ ttJ ^ -n
y Q t- c
■= _ TO
>- 4) -O S
* Ji 0) S
< £ q: m
— c
<S 3
If;
•|:
>- a. I
• ^ J
S « !
c O) 1
V s :
«i —
c «; !
f> « ,
w 5 '
o c '
- ! '
3 J <
« O '
lij
a»
c ^
1*1
?! 2»
a <j ^
c€|£
E -S f
• o _ o
?« gff
C O c 3
" C E "
E at o o
C d —
= £ »
E 1
£ 3
- o
w c c
gEo
c =•
E 2
Is
■c «
E" £
■c — o
* w 2
TJ « a.
O 3 c
I- Q. J
a E 5
— o
?S 5 -
a3^£
S- o o I-
™ £^ o
S T3 • >
C 3 l»
I/) n u -c
? O £ a,
E £ r c
r 3 o s
=: t. S 5
5 £ Q. o
c >■ 3 ■o
f - "» f
e^ c
O V c
a< £ c «
oi *- o o>
« tr z: «
C 3 c C
n S^ « n
E ™ E E
e £
w 3
• o
£ «
II
at o
3 o
2 <»
£ g
££
•5 V)
Cnj 4)
0> tf)
» S <»
5.* 2
I Q- J
o
S" "> 6
■"me
T5 • <
0 S,
< t)
a-"
E O
^^
1 $
u £
o ^
^ o
^ S,
■o o
e c
^G
<? <
CD 4)
$£
^ (/)
O «>
j; E
u u c
n 01 o
-> w 5i
o «>
a>- a
■o oi E
i! e »;
n ^ a»
cr *
£ c
9 i
|g_
S 3 ^
4j ^ re
</i c ^
5. S Z 3 Q
S re
Is
1 I
£ Q
</> a,
* C.
m ~ ~
tA <^ Oi
«J o ^
£ tft u
H "
= V «i
2 E "
£ = <"
c re t>
S T3 o
w 3 re
$ o ->
c c !«
s X i
•° £ 2
°§ &
§ o s
_ re
O re i
.'^ E c
0) -^ ^
n 9> TO
-) x: i:
TO ti iC .
E * S £ - -"«
g-g 3S5Q|io
2?q._3b*oc
fE^£g.|j«o
Q.J££ 0»Q)^~ Oa^tj
£|oSr5-°<"
^ t e E ° ^ E , y ^ z, 5 ^ £
-°-ESiEl2"i'-£r
y" E ?5 "? «.. *i3<'o5
5 e
«!-£
lis
TO O ^
«> O ^
Jt *- ^
TO Ot ^
^ -O -D
£53
t/l « o
T3 > £
I'i
■- « c
5 EO
c UJ
C g c "
E
O) 4)
"■sEcc^c^tr
!5looe3o££
|s|iE«i|l
Ifl £.
■>~ V c
3 2 •£? Si= ^1
^'!&S£<J*«2
-i«i = oE^o»S
^ «i o « S £
re ?r «, 5 s «
E I «£ s 5Q
V
£ "O
o> o
l««re$orS^
^coiO.«,reC-
"><ioS|£-
111
c re «,
2 E 2
OI.
•c S £
p _
g>
S P 'o
S u) ™
2 re T3
" ? a
5 « !!
E — •D
J- re T5
< e "
€) ■= -
> lA £
Sol
= I o
£££""«- —
« B
" *;
2 s
I- re
q: -
5 E
£ «!
o re
o t
UJ s
LU O
li
5 *
tfi p
'!
» =
I
E^
O)
0)
Q. TO
o ~
«/» ~ "^
TO "5 **
-Cot
*: £! >
— ™ -f
— 0) c
!» i £
E o ^
■>.^ f
2o ™
E
S? — tri «)i E
piQ^u-yp
= t:^
M
re o re o
i! g re
g.£TD
r- Q. c
E p re
Z * &
C dj — -
atg 3
4j P 4; P 4>
< ^ — ^
re
E p
Q.Q oi££££ll >E->
re Q
re f
~ UJ a.
■JS £ ^
0. ° £
C T «)
5 P-£
2 * ^
5.0 S
■o —
$ re
— 01
7°1
01 ->'
3 0*
OJ u
a •a al. z.
•I c.
rel ^
O S
331
9
t
E
o
2
n
<0
(0
U
I
5 «<
q:
E ~
- c ~ £
> 2 S
; e ^^.
I oi «
ill'
.E<f
» 5 9
' V o
, Q.</)
■? S-o
0)
>
•So
S £ *
2 3°
:<5
! i
o
o ">
1 >-
c >
2 u
•o o
^ u
I o o
1. £
° 3
O
E
* "Z
> -^
9 o
— >*
re c
c n
0 „
il
u « o
3 tft ^
mis
re w o
01 9 ai
cj c o
C 4) 3
5 CO (5
? §£
O 5i i
g Ct u
o E re
< « E
X! £^
reg £
!5^ ^
a? 5
t— -c "C
— o
= »
>.T3
£
« t
O) <"
< ^
«
e E
^ •
£1?
•I
I >
(B O
5 E
"I
O 01
< "
O «)
*- o
?t
o o
E •
O I- (
in ™
e E
o -o
? — c >•
* re
£ £
O C
re c
Q. o
m
i/i
£ re
Q 1>
i re o
w P o
3 *" e
> £ *j
? s •»
« ^ S'
£3 £
• Eg
Is »
» ^s
£ tfl re
" S E
f S "
g £ °
? o §
-ll
i| 2 re
So,-
-C (ft ^
> ^ in
™ E £
x: 5 re
o '^ 1
! ^ c 5
300
! ° reo
. ^ (J _
j S o nj
0) 0)
o o
I-
c 5
0) OJ
re m «> f
— nj
3 o>
re e
:£^
£ Q.
£ 3
i 8
I?
O "
m «>
I/I «
in o
It
a. c
5£
• °
5 =
z o
o t
0 ^
I
£ »>
— «<
0) in
re S
= « .
o in
^1
p o
I °
E "y
c £o
? >- 5 "-
m "^ -o c
ii. O in
u. "' o re
o 4 r^ •=;
£ 5 >^ « S
o P o »! 5
£ c
" E s-S
r t J
o o
»/> o *^ * o
(/> — — ~
"I
a o
"D re
gs
it
e- Ml *-' .A J:
■51
Z E
£ o
9>~
E ?
E "
o i?
9 fe
in r;
« 4- Sin
re - »l S -
£ re i E
OJ re
^ £1
in a.
II
re 3
in o
3 c
>-" .
3 c SI
c a> 4>
- in j£
o £ 0
C Q. J
O OJ ^
■° " s
in *. o
«i re ■o
£ *" I
.111
E 3 CT
8 °^
p o
fc 0;
0) o
O «
_ a>
< 5.
^ re Q_ o
" 2 c i
* £ 9 0)
. in g o -^
; - §Po
' t ^ c 5
:« g-^ •
• ° ? » o
; ■" - 15 -
' o > « S
1 ^r§ s;
1 ■= o t re
C .- fli c
ra ra £: 0)
^ o *^ -
CD </) ^C
u 0) Q-
00* —
o »/> ™ t;
— o •- ™
o ??£
tr 3 0) </>
(D O «
5 ■" cc
in o c
£ ^ •
S 5 2
3 |£
« > T3
■o re S
■o £ 5
lir
15 " ?
c S -
£ re »
e E
U C 0)
5f8
4, 4, -
lA O) O
a> (Q c
£ S 2
E E «
O . 9
■= e £
?'9i£
o S •»
2- Q- °
°^c «
S ^t:?
|» o (r
•£ S c
C o «>
c e: CL
O »i o
!!! E *
tt) 3 c
a. c re
in
P E
in o
5£ S
J£ o J
P * re
in £ o
T3 o '^
a> in o
=> o.£
re in —
S ^ c
c 5 re
-I 5'
p " > >
0) ™ ' >
= in in o
p
re - -K c
2 1^ In t
" 01 "
OJ 0)
- 41
— *- i> -^
•- m S $
S £ a.™
re c» 2 ■"■
S"f :^
® « u
S'E jn^
" o> re Q^
S £|..
J£^ a£
P= o.'S
*- re 0'
5 S re u
Q. Q- O F
«) Q. m -fc
■o re > s
re|
a
332
91
c
o
i ■£
• &
« S
o2
UJ «
UJ X
3
UJ a
UJ I
_- •
a E
oS
UJ ■
ll
T •
a.
o
I
I
- f -o
c p ■¥
I? ?
■" c
II
$ UJ
O UJ
II
o £
;^ o
IS
o o
ffi i
£
c •>
« E
• * -
• 2 o
-s * o %
15
■s c
-Is
O €> C :
-i-
J2 £ ?•
^ " - " E O
?5
(0 -
o rT^ 5 = i!
?o
^ S
« -
& t>
E-£
• E
£ 5
S E
Q. ^
5f
»> E
2 8
"■ IB
« C
A O
— Ift
SOT
^ T3
= ? 5.=
2 — ¥ u i I-
:ll
. «
— a.
■ — «
> o a
■ — o
3 s
s s
5 2
(A O
El
O
E e I "
->e UJ ™ *-
i» '^ c «)
-) oi t) £
c = -o £
«) 15 — TJ
^ 1/1 t
S E o I
o ;S
O <B
£ o *
2 <
n
u
c » "
o S a.
as. E
4) O O
Cl Q. u
« 5
01 1>
< -5
a o
■Ok.*
rg S
n « o
E £ £
■o °-e
s ?r >
! > 2 c
■ -a 0 a
!' » o
1 *1 JC c
i I s "
.^^ ^
I J3 n CD
j» r. o
€§ »
« « £
« ^ =
ir" = ■"
Q. - •
ill
l°-
1 « ?
5ot o
« 0. «
£• I
£~V.
p * ^
££ ?
c c o
2- S o
• y -=
5 •§ «
• * E
Iff = (B
*s i
S •- £ o
™s » 2 >
H
I 1
^ T3 «> J2
" i &
>■ O <J
* —
0 s 2
$ e «
wO E
_i UJ 9
a UJ a.
■" a.
«) (D U
£ « 5.
ill
« C -}£
y tft re
re 2 ^
-> Q. «»
J2 re y
^■50
8 ??
» « C
ai a 0 £
<0 ^ ») c
o «
• 2
'I
SS.
2 E
• ?
<B C
«i UJ
f UJ
C lA
s'M
or
J£ o
(A •«
Ji •> £
n *' O
2 «> c
jc > in
3 a o
00'°
• « UJ re
^ • e
a c ic ^
O ?guj
: (/)
o *
* c ■= ■?
p * y 2
£ -o £ o
c d > m
O f »
d 5.
CD O
■5 o r s
- re 3 S-
O M re »
^E 5k i
at ^
= c
^ g
If
• o
E "
« ^
-o «
«. -c
c t-
»
• c
II
— «
-I re
2 E
« p
CD o ra
re £ Z
Sop
i £ c
o p JC
P
2« 2 • r ?r
E S
P 4)
•^ c
>- 9
re o
9 £
re J2
0 o
t>
p'
go.
E 2
P o
^ •>
re £
£ V
« E
Si
re 5
o 6
* J*
^ s
o $
So
ri
t) (A
O S
°-8
2 o
?c
? «
M ^
Q. ^ -¥ O
if
• —
re ti
e ^
i iS
~ «>
P 01
p E
^ $ S = -
r S * o re
£ii
o£
3 Q.~
— «>
» E
5 g °
2 2 p
"^E s _
e p $ re —
o " f £ ;
c t> £ u re
£ c t >" i
«vwv «/re3tfire
~)Pa f-uU-nT3
_ O
a> t-
o q:
f!
J'
</ ?
3 y m
o- g o
» w i.
p 5 S
P e» a
Q. 5 -=
■D o y
? r^ £
■c — - - '^
p e
P.C
u
S ™ »i
tn *A **
re <> £
c y o.
£ 2 E
V u o
.a (A o
g>
«D
333
u
c
i
en
^1
- -o E
^ • i**
£ S "
? • 5
• i 5
w5 r
in s
I
IT
o
UJ
S E
11
IK X
o
s
tl
IT
n
I
O
Ul
HI
a.
a.
a
o
a.
a
I
15
E •=;
is «
,5-5
111"
= -. o 2
S "
^ o .- Q.
O U IT (N
" • • TJ
S ■ - a
c 9
c ?
I*
E 5
IS
|2
O 111
ai£
c
E
e
o
l|
w *
o
a
in
«
O
■D i
) T3 o ? —
' S 2 S •"
• * • _J
-= • -^ 0-
^ — C 05
= •> * i.
a> w ^ 4>
P£ » £
■^ 1> V w
o S^S
" £ «i t
c f^ 2
« « ° *>
e "^ «; -
£ » S: c
S.£ >. o
b « «/> >
II
i S •?
>. tl o
— t ^
« w -c
•5 «^ «
a
£ o»
III
£: V> «>
Is ^
:5 >.
C £ tl
o !5 £
o t> *-
_ 3 1«
9 cr c
g * 5
*f ^
« $ o
&££
S£ E
tl ^
5 ^ -c
CD*- r
*i ™ re !!!
u tl tl re
(T* C = C
-J 0» Oi 3
a.
fM
s
y
334
n
•I _-
o
o
5 I
5 c
9 E
a in
•j; c
S I
UJ n
LU X
go:
o >■'
£ c
O. 01
• E
2Z
o
u
o
UJ
UJ
O
UJ
UJ
si
* o «
III
o ? <•
■^ s •
o ° c
UJ S !!
o 3 a
<5 O -s
•o 0) 5
5 I E
t s s
Is
I* c
c o
n ^
E "
_ 5,
n J3
CB O
« I-
— •>
» ■
o
^ a.
5! !5 i
E
O -
UJ ™
UJ 0)
E *
^ S
ra O' ^
■^ .«" S ^ r: 3 £
A
c ■=
E -
^ (/)
« O
o»uj
* UJ
J^ 01
0> £
II
£ E
111 re
5 E
Oi Oi
4j C 4> 0) O -
i 2
s ? g
£. T3 C
T «^ $
£ <• t
^ E E
O - e "
LU » o o
'^ ?s^
Oft — i ^ 0>
i « o ™
- " X 01
p o D "
r ^ - ui
ill'
jC t3
w * E
<» > ^
^ S O 0.
o> o ? E
C 3 ^ 01
O
UJ
UJ re
If
0;
01
^ -> ^
a. e
E a «
« £ ^
-CO)
^^ ^
0) ^ o
y o *"
•- CT OJ
^- 5
« 3 *- £ 2 —
o -) c »/i E 01
0) ^ 0> *- "O
- § « o O -
S " ^ C 111 o
9- "P £
y ra 2 -o
(V Q S _ W» TO
■S £ 3 E JC o
CD 3
»- 0> I/)
E ^
~ o>
O Vi
E 01
o F
^ 01
^ a.
« o
E > £
o UJ
01
« o
1/1 z:
3 re
re oi
U 01
0) =
£i re
V> *A
i£
O (A
^ >~^-5-S
3 " -O O a
*> £
2 i
£ >»
S •
Q. 01
Q. U
re OJ
■o *-
Ol T3 u £
C C (B O
(/) ^
S oiO
— c UJ
C -= UJ
3 re
? * >
^ U ^ n
© «i re re
S o o i ^
^ T3 -5
re 01 re
£
»! C 01 !" ^
2* ^ 0,
= £
lA
c re
re S 01
— o 2
'■o ^ c «
> 01
»! O >
I- °
o ^ S
u u =
- -) o
& 5
®
c
0)
E
o
(rt
T3
fS
4)
t/T
?
>
c
*-
^
3
J2
c
TO
a.
E
tt
O
o
s
^
o
V
5
*r
Ol
>-
c
n
3
c
c
a>
«
3
>
E
o
re
o
CL
O.
7)
tfj
O
c
£
re
«>
O
u
o
o
O
<A
U-
O
re
JC
or
a>
o
<
j::
>
c
CO
*
u-^
2
§
2 «
a. E
1^
^
re c
0 o
- 01
01 01
i/i «
E £
O w
^1
1^
Ore
a o
« c
£ 01
?^
O C 4, o
re 01 $ S
£ o c 01
3 _ 2 c
Q-c ° O
4( 4> '^ (ft
E 3 £ "
" n "
» S .. c
e 9 = o
■; 3 0) O
!5 ° " c
», J 0D<«
r re T3 ^
= 5". 3 ^
i? $ o 2
a. o c a.
E " " 0)
O 01 m ^
O C Jt —
^ 01 a 3
P o 2 9
0. £- 1; 01
3 -O (O ^
2 >" m
Oi S °-
E aj 5
? i !^ !0
IS
c T3 re
O Q. C
t 01 £
C O T3
S " C
" Ol E
S re 3
2 » *>
re o 4)
0 " ^
— 01 *-
E^ S
re (/) c
?< ^
5.§ re
-"Si"
J) 4 0)
1 s g
re £
II
rJ5i:i O^ 1/1 3
-So
01 01 -C
> i: Q.
S - o;
§1 S
01 01 3
<- - O
01 CT ,«
■S !^ •"
" ^ 01
lA = C
« 01 §
s ■^ E
lire
U 5 E
1- re o
ir c c
•^ 5 S
? o ■= 01
£ 01 o
3 _1 O
O. ^
01 ^ C
ti 8 *
» " Ol
01 S 2
•O (A u
0 C 01 01
01 01 -6 o
S E !A ™
01 c: -.
« 01 £ S
O re 5 01
Q. £ ^ u
I" ^-S^ =
S! irg-m
is£ §^
re 01 " •"
s o o c
3 c ii o
S «
01 ■"
« «
>■ E
o re
a.^
E 01
oj E
0 ■=
K UJ
c 01
?S
01 o
« <"
>.UJ
re (£
•D a
*" E
c£
£ *
J £
O TJ
— 01
T3 T3
* E
■o o
C O.
o «/>
a. 01
— r !/> ^
"D ^ D t/1
^ tJ "ol "O
™ 4) •- C
>. i: *- TO
■^ *- 4» re
4) ^ Ol c
T *r re E
*/) O 4^
•o O c "'^
E i/i o T3 2:
O 01
01 E
Q| ';i
in
S
S
335
«
E
It
It
« c
c o
a £
I 2
— ■ «
I
12
• c
(T O
- £
I-
• (C
a St.
e u c
^'-
f ft o
3 • a
r- O
i
3
O
o
I/I
o
o «
W£
^5
?i
I'
a. <•
E
a
\ ■> ■>
S Is
« w c
^ Id t
^ fp ff
o S S
o r -JS
« ^ «
ui E e
■5 2 o
E « o
■S T o>
£■% J
C o o
° = —
y - -D
Of tf) C
tft ^ re
re c re _
2 o J re
«
o ;;;
o S
Si
•■ o
S « re
JC «} at
fll .-^ ~
-> re !•
»i s >.
ij a-o
.«£■§
> > a>
ai »/> -^
4) <r ^
t/i re 5
c o o
5 o re
§ 6 E
^ c 5
E
. in
C -J
o a
at c
£ ^C — I
•9 > a
111
- l» o
e >■ —
a. * •>
o s *
Q. E u
« a
■a ~
(0
re
«!
ce
I X
tl
O
UJ
LU
•> £
c —
3 111
o
o
c
°o
f-F, «
x: 3
' 1.%
: _ c
, CB O
> o —
i ^ •
2 S JC o
w 5
a E «
T> O t>
o
UJ
UJ
£5 S
c
o
.s re
•I
It
*> a c *>
£ c c >
£ <m'
re S
-• c
*> c
c o
e an
V o
» £
A C
§ e o
C ~ JC
•= E "
c E re
o £ c
u XP <»
i S f^
« o5
o c <*
S re tfi _-
■^ u re 3
«i >. £ o
5 * €1 £
o £ re f
9- »> O t
»! o u oi.
T, to >. C
SO^ s,
(Q
S 3 9
w 0»
re i E
O Q
O _ £
Of £
ex a>
C >
= O
re "
u re
C 3
« O
a. ^ 41
• ~-K
: £ o> o
> E re
» 5 = ~>
; Ss^
1 ?« re
= «> «i
!? § ^
' (fl -. w
c £ "-
= ■= £
i> ^ tl
S = 5
o o o
nor
a o a
m £
^ re o
01 £
O o
TJ 5
3 U
re o
O T3
01
„ o o '°
" J3 01 O
■£ re W ~
S S 10 O
* re — 1 r^
= O to o
" "of
« 01 o
£ £ W
J S 5a
, £ ■o 01 „
OJ g (5 ^
Q 3 - re
_ re >. ^
- " ? ^
m = P re
01
a
„, - ... 01
re'
M V V^ —
re •- ^ 5;
» o t>
Sio-a
§11
o|£
UJ • E
UJ £ c
.«' o 2>
* c S
^ ? !
>. at 01
^55
$ C tfl
to 01 c
; 3 o
C o" IB
to to re
c I" 01
^ o ^
_ to
HI £
to •a n
i/i
— O _ ^ _
■2 -S ol '
= ^ re -
f to O c
re to •' 3
E * w o
5 -E £ e
c * to f
§>•$§
if ^ S
(D 4) "r u
■O to o .s
? S. " 7
I 0, si
■c c re —
S S S 3
to c to -o
^ re o> oi
o «- re ••-
■" C 0> to
to to w
E O
t c
E (0 re ^
? 9 c "o
i St*
•= S = =
T 01 06 o
^ a? §
£ S ■O £
CD O) t
E «> E 6
* to "*
Is"
3 re c
o u ™
<J to u,
ot£
UJ w
UJ n S
» S c
£ o ©
^ * "O
° :; «>
C 0) n
to £ (0
"I 9
c at re
re p 3
•o «> ■^
c re i»
= |-Q-:
i« £ *
s «t "^
9 » 3
^ S o
ui S "
UJ _ to
«< i -S
£ e? =
>> to o
to re t
g« 8
f 5 i,
to (A ±f '
3 a i
Q. to c-
F = E
o to .c
£ «"
^ c
to re
c o>
•D "
s S
™ t3
■^ re
£5
to *
£ j£
.? ■?
"*'"*-
o E
to
336
o
c
v>
Q.
«
■o
I
c o
<o J
2 S.
«- «
tf> a
= £
I/I «
o
1 = 1
O SQ
•5.2"-
E K> O
« ® ^
> (5 -5
$ir
o
<
C3
II
■» *
a.*
V X
o -^
O -D
" O
T5 **
c n TJ
e TJ £
i/> c o
^ • t3
= c 3
> o £
> j: in
c »/> c
o o -
-> £ lA
c ~
o ?
Qtn
(0 o)
£ ^ »
^ £ ■o
._ o ^
0) ~ J
o>£ V
5 e-^ >.
E SS «
O M Ji c
Q. U U n
n JO A 2
a
O
m
UJ
o.
E
o
u
o
UJ
8S
go
clU
a ui
f £
o c
0. £
_ «j
il
— o
u ra
0 i
c ^
■o o
<" ^
i/) Q-
- V
S 1«
•s^
-1 c
(5 E «
1 «. 9
" E "iS
S o ^ S
J£ C i/t lA
•K 5O 3
•Si * in E
- J? E 8
f (A S (A
£ £ n o
° E «- £
C ™ O O
" -^ -C
W9 lA 2
_J < — t
Q.O » S
O) V C c
E 2 »" lA
> 01 c -
»; • J> O
^ 3 •" oc
t) ^ "O "-
^ c «« c
0) n 01 3
= u c Q.
ra m ^ ^
c -> S »
5.? S o
« % (A C
C « V -
0 I y 5
O E 5 g
< «> X i
O S o E
•1 f
5
o
337
E
2 3
1?
e
u
O
o
c 2
O 03
I/) 4,
IB Q.
O V
if
Q. "O 5) (Q
2 * ?
E g §
S " -
•- c «.
U 3 3^
S a s
c u a.
- ~ •
w O 'S
c
£ S E
> u u
» « ^
c o t- 2
E g I 2
' 8 = f •
U.^-) u£ n^^ (0
- ». *
ttl I
o « —
go «
o I- t
c c 01
o o a
■ *'^ • •-
: -o to o
■ e I £
5 u» o
o «> —
$T3 O
O o §
O S: u
■oU2
go £
c "- 5
3 a M
O £ ^
C — o
o> «
l5
'I
Siu
lA i/i —
» « 2
a
I
6
8^1
e 1- ■=
c
<
^ u
c
w c £ lA tf) _
n lA 3 A (0 i^
9 o n «> V £
S S a
O A
« « c
*> - o
O f S
O 3 Q.
•- f •
55 Sod
sll
0) (0 n
S M ti
S « g
;;; s"
IT I o
£ 6 «>
•« iS
I i'J
e « _i I-
o a a (£
«
at «i
f (A
Ifl 3
$ o
Sx
2* ^
a e E
« S o
•|^
o -s !^
£ »> K
« fO «Q
_ 3 3
,°, ° ~>
c c b
(HOC
ffl >-^
111
£ <l F
=1 —J (0
Q. Q. m
Qi i.^
S
G
S
338
u
m
§
U
c • 6
« 5 e
q: I S
o
C c
8
%
u
(t
O
S
<0
c
«
ill
K
>•
c
o
.9
■
c
a.
E
o
u
O
tu
111
a
E
S
2|
c ^
c •
15
? c
M O
a IB
5 E
« o
S E o
3 II
E 3 c
a a. •
O _i •
S'S E
— 2 "
111
III
|s|
CO ~"
E ^ • «
o i> £ i
€> E ■ =
■2 « c S
• I— O-
■O }J <D «
3 <• « m
I-
.X •
"I
iS
|S
Si
o c
Z" Q.
• £
<l c t>
Q T3 •
-O CD
in c
«! E
^ E
•I «
3 »
m a
£ E
f e
rr "
f'- >.
£ *>
2£ 1-
> *- $
3 •
O £ T3
m O E Tj
O S »
OJ O «l
S >» O
o ™ *
S T3 Ol
^ £ Q J^
• i * S
5 = e x>
S E c «
we 5 y
£ n> * o
3 • f U
«J O x: (^
f I
m
_ c c
« o 3
1 -S o
C = "o
o a o
w „ o>
t> > "O
^ n 4)
O J£
* 1.
« IB S
— e c
C £ 4)
c «
« o £
(S o .±
C o 3
c * c
c m E
a e i
§• ?
"11
C w O
•? •
1 Ss
I * s
* IB C
s ""
E 5 =
™» 3
E » m
•"^ • ^
<D O «
m « "
« ^ y
t » o
CO g^
a 2 o
" c S
— OS
-■so
5 2 =
3 O »
< Po
= S •-
O J cr
yet-
I?
o S S e
s c
o a
S o
S Q. _ c o
o « *
•^ g S
2 « n
m E 0)
e£ §
c E 5
ceo
02 =
L> O ^
Ifl c O
g p *
3 e £
2£5,
S. o * '
V Z. >■
c c (0
o e ■o
e £ >. i5 £
e cf
^ 03
e
£5
°E
c o
II
SI
£i;
c f
e o
«i
= o
5 E
e E
o Jt
ai2 5
E CD I
^^ £
^ * 5
(D c w
£ e «
c c "
e o ^
e e ^
_ o e
o c u
i 2
c £ m
O) • C
— *~ «>
«££
si ?
a. <• :=
O = -o
"• E >
«> S.S
£ ?o
£ - e
* > a
■D sr
e c «
fo O (o
« -
a c
'^ e
T3 ^
» TJ
•= «
•5 -^
01 e
» i
> ">
0 a
TJ e —
1 ^ f
e ^ '^
CD e n
■00:=
<» o. 3
• • >-
^ e c
0—0
-> J3 E
e o "5
£ S =
~ 9 «
5> * c
3 > c
TJ e e
O C (A
0,0
e >-
y n
?i
1 s
I-
o a
SS.
> e
e £
o (/)
e
" e
u
c — y
g> o n e f
?1
c Ti)
o.|«
c £ •
m o c
S e CO
* ° ?
TJ ~ =
5 « £•
_ !» e
c e ^
o o o-
u, o «1
3 I/) IB
o c e
•K 0
e « u
c « »
e o ^
■" <0 T3
IB ^ e
ZS ^
" e IB
£ TJ w
5 > 5
« 2 £
c o i2
o = e
f IB u
o « c
< o a
«' e
IB e 3
,■5 5 O
O TJ _
e la
-100
;^ 9 o
£ 1:
c 5
5S
e -
51
"D IB
e -
E S
"I
e £
IB cj
» tr
~ i <M
2 ■^
= !B 5.
e ^ n
£ g> S
o £ IB
e ? -5
>^ TO
_ a* c
• ECO
~ re ™ e
• ec/j-D
U
u £
' T3 «;
: « re
=. E
re
CO
e e
X C IB
5 -if
= 3 c
«,(D O
IB J! c
3-S COCSODtjStj
£ IB a> e
3 Z c c
o" re o ^
m S?t; o
re 0; c X
Seg-S
S re <n T)
E e Q. re
o ■" >■ «
IB _ 2 o
-1 (B -^ re
la .-^
2
339
340
i
o
9 E
0) n
ir I
o
ill
I- °
|S s
So?
^Is
£ W >
o • •
lif
Iff
a a 2
« S-5
— y f» ^
(0 •> C X
0» (ft 3 ■
o • r
fc c 2 „
■= o •>
2 U «
m CO ._ — fc*r_,<0
|»yoeg«S
Zs«E«»cnS
- ° E •^111
^ Z'° *> mS - -
r- ^; t * ^
3- E
c t- ~ O
go: go
• 2 >.T1
T C «J 5
^ - - • *
5.TJO « g-Tm-
U 4) IV
nw -5
£ o c
fli c ~
" S E
CD a. £
n— ex:— "SS
o-ri E ■« i- S o -e
i^Elgs^SE
iEa>SEco3
> >.^-£»«>«)
««>»eEtg>i-D
3 C «) ?
O* €> (A «
— So"
5 * o ir
<• 8o "
S o "UJ
■o «SO
c ^ in a»
<••> = £
c o >< a
*= ?^ _ «>
E| ?!!!
• " S. c
£ • " •
°S^ I
c *- o o>
.9 £ <" 2
« > « «B
'^ £ F
5 c «
n n o
^ f- »•
« °^ e
o £ i
? j-i ^
2 o^-srs
11 r tr ■= o _
$ g,o
• < 2
E ?-
2 S
2 («
I ■£
. o
cn£
2 <U n £ ■-
« £
,-=|!Eil^
"=ȣ ^ t o s ;
? 521$ Si "15
- » ^^ ^
Eo.ES
F c a> m
i c 41 re
"One"
* Q- C i
(ft z c re
ill
Sew
5 e:2
1"!
O • o ,
Z " E'
O 5 03
= K _
«),_«)
■5 £ S"
c (s a
€> C ~
£ IB 2
~ « E
|S|
o. " 2
«. 5 S
sis
>-£ —
re « o
I- ii c
«•« o
3 >. C
2 E •
** -S jc
O w o
*» *f — » .
Q.CO
?5
re 5
J, o
- re ~
c E
o^
t »
^ in
I/) t)
re E
= o
■n u
* ?
tn 4)
■o £
c —
re re
«< —
■5 S
IS
111
V 5 a
" c c
2 <• •
m 'K €
. a ^
CT c iC
S S §
*. Oi o
E £ o
? Z. If)
o tn
S o
re 4>
o>
E £ i-
t. *- re
o c «i
S = o
Q » re
a
341
E
O
HI
— oi
c
9 ifi
ti
E
S Q.
IS
11
'- s " o £" S • - 22« •
(0 o. -
1 •
|g.|
in
§ s? ?cE °i e^^l
^''^o-iiii
O A 2 — ^
c « c £ CD
i!l5|
^ = • = c5
c ^ c —
» e « « ^
~ • S «
c •> 9 ■•
wool— ~"ooePS*-eo
-2ES-5i»Ee*5>
I s I ^ s ^ i y !^ 5 i « ° * ^ -^
Wat!
O < »
S</j°^S^iE-o5a->cn«.
•5 c
ffi £ .r o
E » IS
oca.
» 01
1
342
1
o
UJ
&
O
c *
9 E
« in
o
LU
£
LU
o
-5
c
C
tf)
o
w
x:
n
a.
u
S
i>
I
1-
e
e
I
f
O
t-
o 5°
C — It
« • -g
,^ (B •-
• ^ •
£ T3 S
o
-sis
I fc — i5
^ in n
'cfiS
I - o 2 «>
4> 4) CQ ^
» 4> Q. Q. O
o «) -C «
«) cr o> o
»,£- = «!
£ « £-5
fi 'S — *
■g 5 ^ y
--co
^ I/) Ot €)
o S! ™ o
S ? E t
2 3
o at
• <
£ C
~ O
O •
o
5- ?
o c
11
^ c
S f
■ s
U CD
a a.
> a.
■^^
° c
« a
• 'S
u c
3 c
in g.|
" °l
i • =
Oft 3 «
• ° ^
a VI 2
IS
ID ^ •"
a>
o
o
c
IB
s i
§1
•> o
E S go
Sc g£
■o « « t
^ ' So
S S C -K
- *" o Q
" c *
•- «• A n
« T5
en v
- »i
c
O 0
So?
C -D S
5 S ■"
X) "O X)
O ^ tf>
(9 ft)
C £
o
w' »J tf, (0 »)
E o - £ £
fl) •- t; -^ (-1
E o
«) —
^ c
9 o
to (A
S ii
1 5
e £
Bill
© -e -^
m <B 5 ^
■i f = e
is ^ o
■silo
«.""" =
£ in LU <u
o>t- a c
— o £ 5
< O S <
??
? »>
I** C
C (0
o Ob
C O
*o a>
c •
I-
• s
*> -S
c
E ^
£- *>
« 2
«> Ol «
-^ 2 E ,
' * T^
u5 » ^
e e *
S E 5
I o re
TJ O
!^ Si
° E -S
o» « o
E £ J
■° IB e
li
o »
= E ( 1
t) o h-
e 3 «
l-^Sfl^l'^S *
a
^ £ -^
S 2 5
i E c ■=
»«? P c
> fe O
: O Oft c
1 > » I
l5"
« 7
£ E
Wt sS « $«
E E
" o
5 a t o
- S E e
i^l
o E
O c
» E
E 2e
£ « Ul
Q.£ (J
TJ -D t-
(O Oj —
9 o
£
II
- £
E **
S "
a. o
0) J«
Q. (0
•5 vt
n I/I O
" 3 !C
-O £ ^
<i !« £
w oj 0)
n » Q.
2- o £
«l o. o
> £ o
EC-
o 5 •
o E -c
■er c •)
(0 o
'^
o "
Si u
2 T3
t= c
E "
' i
I c -
I ® jc O
' t> O I—
[^ °a
I jl
_ e —
w >- •
o 2 y
o S E
»o o
r C E O
Pi
sll
» ,« ;
o -? u
«| S
M?
E S •
■o <
« £
E o
< =
V i
■c O
$ <« T3 O
Id t
S; O
P * Sir
O TJ
O. C
in i
Sit
A TO
s ^
3 C
§ E
O •
- o.
S «
S«
ifi o
Se
IT «
•_ a
o <
£ TJ
O C ^ •r
■^ P u °
% E li *
IB •- tr c
« « -^ o
3 ^ 10 Q
IB O
» O
if
• ^ o o
p 2! p c
o OJ *-
£ O) B U
t) - *- 2
— ^ *- flj
E 5 «) m
F £ -c
O ..
< —
O TO
^ TO S"^
■*^ = l#t <V --_
c " J.: tS ?
O TO
t £
2 2 E
- S S 5
g, TO O „ TJ
"5^1 %
a. TO
E i;
4, c
o c
TO 4)
-J a.
TO IB T"
— I «» ^
O I- -o
^^ s
at u n
So*!
» 5 «!
E "
S 9
b cr
g * " ^
«) ^ 0) -f^
£ S 3 £
3 E 5 g
O TO 4> ,_
-o en > o)
" < ° -c
* TJ E
^ s.%
- aJ • 5
o t c m
T= O « c
IB TO
«>
343
01
K
a.
« a.
13
5
t
e
I
<
o
344
a
c
•)
E
o
l« IK
c 2
K o =>
n -S o
I S O
Q. 0)
• E
5 I
o
u
3
«
tr
O
ui
V
o
C IS
??
a. ig
o n
E m
S u
™ CD
(ft o>
5 <«
UJ T3
C ^
• •!
t> £ -
^ S>
est:
c 2 •
S ^ <J
t ?"
1,0-
t S "
^11
«> -o s
5 S E
«> • 2
i i S
i2 - o>
c aa o
o = «
«°^
« ^ c
3 ^ o
o -1 ^
E S «
tow
o -^ o
c o —
«) O u
i« o tr
S S •
all
?■= 9
• -?
£ g S
r SO-
ill
aS o
■at :>.
w «- n
o « E
■" ?
5 o S
c 5 E
• 0)0
% ^ ** o
■c S O 3
c • O o
■€ -c "' ai
* 2 O Hi
3 3 t •
o o Q^ £
■o -c » tr
«• • £ o
||5 i-
o*- • •>
»a|s
I? E
^ e S
"5 « E
V £
a. u
«) ID tf)
£a)
o ^
S «£
T> «> •=
S g t:
A LU -C
2.^ ^
o» C <«
C 3 4,
JC V O
" ^ » o
C O ™ o
*- > O)
« >. _ c
111 I
fft
c
E
"S * ^
- c 8 £
c « c
3 .C -
0—0
ID "D
UJ ^ JC
i»0 ""
£ UJ «
? e -D
«^ £ ^
■^ p £
CO o >
—> ^ Xi
~ c -^
>■ » o
&
• -
C Q.
u £
^^
•I
" «
f> a.
^ E
o °
e °-
o o
3 at
(D «
o •!
■C ^ o
-* « £
So."
"e|
ti °' i a
x: ■" t) c
U S g 2
5 * « «
£ffi
CL _(5
<J o • -o
^ in u. B
^ o »■"
d> § 0 -o
c (0 tt> Q)
• "* €> C
— 3 -° 9
S-° » «»
Illf
e £ i. -
§|S£
(ft (ft CD O
O c >-o '
fc S J= «.
•r .^ -D (ft .
. • ° O 2
£ S- 5
> — ra S « '
» J « 2 :
:'S 2 *?.
^ = u <•:
I jf ift a (J
S .c ^ ff
Irs*
?£ § o
(0 (ft :: ~
■c -D CD c J
s § s $:
£ o
(ft -o
-O -^ £
s a •
n B u
< a
« E
• «>
SI'S -^2
© (0 c . ©
-1 _ r\ Irt *i
SIS
E E
•p P
• o
U -5 •"
< ^ •
■p c i
t- « a>
(ft « ift
° 3 £
c c *
c CD «>
ES£
•3 c*
811
(A Gl C
O -1 t
o i ^
O ffi
? c • o '
i i£ ?
E 5
c«
ra
V
0
0)
0
3
c
m
T3
E
^
(0
0
01
3
A
0
0
x:
EO
0
c
0
4)
C
0
c
0
.c
(ft
CO
5
1—
q:
E ::
o o
O Ift
^8
_ i
O A
- c 9
o E ~
c ? = -
• » E o =
E*
si
ai CO
> o
CO •>
« C
•^ O
(ft £
« O.
0 *
E'S
5.°
o «
Q. 4)
E M 3
•O Q.
c i
" t> o
«> u c
(J c o
^ " s
*» 2 »«
S £ >"
5 t; «>
» o "
0 0.(0
— (ft £
l/t ^ ^
C T3 O
5£i
< T3 £
O
<
. «
O E
££i
C ^ CO
- J •
In
f ^
> a
>. (0
2 «
3 «
C (ft
O 0)
o c
0) c
0\ 35
o
o
345
s
u
<
o
E
s «
Si
11=
v
E
«
S «
Si
Xl=
S: o s
cs o.
E o E
o c o
U 3 O
C
e
I
o
o
I
I
6
o
£1
o
o
S
I
2
: W c
o _
• 5. «
is 5
m
is.
(T 2 TJ
>.? =
: « ai
? • =
£ m o
1^?
^1^
a o a
i|r'
lis
VI n !>
e E o
c ? ^
£?•§
s ^ =
5 ^ $
™ " ™
-> E -)
^ IS
5 E *
J g ••6
•lis
_ S a
iSg e
• Sot
« = -'
!!€ o-
<= o S
s « «
•> "" £
o S >.
E %.o
l/l 3 «
£I|
oiSi
E ■" o.
jc • c
o -2 S
E S «
OT -^ 5
T) 15 S
2 S «-
= s^
$ m £
SI
If
S t>
3 C
31
So
- a
? « .
£■=
o
1/)
JC
II
E
3
§2
0^
J5 CD
c
; T3
' 9
i a.
51
££
c £
< S
U. «g
« -»
— T3
I-
3 •
So
« 5 u
3 ^ ».
ffi £ £
££|
(!) _
« S a <
zlS,\
Eif '
■ox-',
So|;
1 » S '
£ c £ <
|'&
50- s ;
o 5 Z
3 y •
^!-
" • •>
t) « CB
o c
c _
a.£ x:
Si i
3 t «
IB £ i
c 5
— %i
E
>. c t
a.
« ti a
(^5 ?
•o "
= Si
3 0>
g> a)
a: !: M
E t
E o
oo
< £
0|
?
CM
S
346
347
£
e
— i
^ 3
c c
E o
flJ ^
S £
n
z
e
o
a.
Z
5
* <6
0) tn
1^
O Ob
£ C
41 *£
» c
' -o in
I o 0)
: *" £
: S a
\ a. =
>n 9
^ * I
Cjl o
•^ to
i £
3 5
1 =
O !5
"1
2'
CD £ c =
5 o
-^ c
a- "o
£ •5
I m >
: §.«>
> »o
) t) <
^f
o: 8
c u
o n
c >-
Hi
i-o E
• s 8
6 E »
s " =
££ £
o c o
i/l — —
2 « x
si"
= s !
5° %
%,'° o
IT = t;
CA = •=
c
»
e E -
•> ^ «,
f m p
i It E
c E o
- <» •-
S^ £
=> £ c
■o r i
tl i
£ !• ■o
o S «
3 » £
£ to i
> _ a
> c Q.
in «< 3
c c ••
O-S £
» s °
1 ^ »
c i •
- ifl
III
t» c
9 n
■S S 2
COS
?« "
5 a
*>a
££ •
g£ E
^ S Si
5£ ?
-f £ S
s « :^
.- £ i
a
Iff
t &.
O c o
(— * 3
«-£
III
5 O m
LU £
s ? >• «
«> o *< o
i eu E
O Q.-0 =
O •> « ^
OtT3 m C
fel5
CD
V" -
»i 1— CI
£ (T £
I £?
Qj If* F
o ni ,„
■o •?; • f
a> <£ >
5 I 2
If a> re
2 gr
C
£ «. - -
« o iS t«
** « -" o
W
£ 2 CL ^
3 2 o m
T> «) 3 S
», _ 4, —
U 3 T3 C
3 x> n n
m S £ -o
^ o 4ft 2
s2 §■=
fc oi -
CD
C 01 u
c = ™
^?
c J
o a> t/>
>■ > £
£ § *
« s -
» 5 ^
5 «; S
<0 £ in
» Ei
tf> — a>
^ o tft
CO c 3
: 5 O
<" s -c
S "»• c
o o" 2
se 3
•no
tJ N £
Set
JO O) re
g-o -=
P S! -i"
.« en 1
«) a 3
t^ 01 rfl
.*" £ i
■c re (/-,
"0 - •-
CD o l;
■o - i
uj CD en
9
o
348
2
u
X
I)
E
■A
in
!■ »
<i E
li-
o
S • o ,
o _i
I-
O Q.»^ o ^
" CO
m a
• «
£5
IS
-> b>
T3 «
C —
<• n
• E
u a
? S
£1 a
■p «
») £ TJ
•'" S
c < o
« O £
to c S
2 » e
j; n
9o|S
c £
£ o
3 T
*- O
ES
> _j
D CI
P ?
S Q.
e o.
O 3
Q. <»
It r!
II
0»Q CD J5
E4S
I •
3 lA
O 3
E
C7) O
i E
m -o i/t ^ Si
^ %-/ *5
loS
Q- >.-C
« -a «
III
H-
s 8?
t « IB
" " S
c fl> s
J5 »ff w-
! 5?
i -I
t « -c.
tfl 0) I/)
■O > TJ
c E c
E ^ E
« «l «l
T3 ^ T3
</) O (A
^ l« ^
« -> a>
x: TJ £
u c o
c « c
o a» o
o 3 o
<A CD I/I
m
: m o
TJ 1-
— 4) «
o||
»0 o
. Z a a,
I o £ c
» <5 i» ^
* = c
*" in 5
T3
: J i -
E «
ff in
£ *
in o
* in £
£ o
£ c
t- 2 cn
»E
£ 5
5 •
f "
s m
2 I
a «
•I
"o in
c t=
» O)
m c
in n
a Q.
o a>
5i
* s
S E
i E c «
in o n
I c » c
'o 2 s
' ^ i "
"» " £ '
1 - o> o '
3 P 9 •
:!" Si
O T5 e '
•' n o- '
3 0^
« ™ in
= T. ^
5 c
•■S i
in « —
Mm*)
Ti ■» i
m " —
" TJ <S
_ S E ■
C TJ 5 ,
rS
* -D «
£ SS
3 "B 5
° S °
o re ■£
£ « «
t- a E
OJ -Q o>
3 "5 re
•n S =
in § IB
£ o o»
u> m g
a c 3
in u Q-
? 9 €>
= « E
ris
c " i
E in >
«i » $
3 o> «
o c <" 5
9 « « o
e-Ef -^
* - « c
■n O « 3
in
!2 • r ¥
S-- re *
> t «( T3
— Sac
c • " ^
|Ofl
y ir Ti F
* «j 3
*ll
T3 _
V O
-. - -S » " <0
£ 5 re 9- ~ £
•^ re
c £
eE
3 S
o ~
o
c i
9 c
■6 £
y o
2* fl> t— '
c * "■
re > «
I/) s
Wo —
* £ —
-c <» c
o =>
(r O re
~> J c m
c ~ • re
• o E 5
$= 3 c
S g 9
Vi f^ ^
« >« £ 2
^ a. u Q.
O O 3 >t
C U i/> 4J
> w
n o
■^ >.
>^ «)
II
re re
= 01
* E
o —
2 CO
'^
c re
re i/i
Q> re
re (J
-> in
o m
■^ in
TJ C
c re
E o >■
a> — t>
TJ « c
c § o
e E re
mo —
« » <n
> ■5 _i
J) — c
in CM O
* o «!
O «Q
aO E
£ -= >^
o "c iS
< 3 in
re in
c J 41
I! re a
«<«;« —
i2 5 re c
ft fll ♦- —
» S. » o
m m e i;
«) re > *
I ^ I o
TJ «! e ■£
:?£ «1
5 » "B e
£ o .c
— CVS
•5<n 1:3
ssfl
a o £ »
o £ r»
??l i
> iS &«
^ 2 m J,
S >-t: o
re TJ 0 <p
E re
;> 01—
01 c o
S3*
•g « t
lit
O OJ
3 E c
?|l
5 re »
s|l
i $ - s i 11
- 5 2-0 I re g
2^'| =
?- o«
fe ^ c m
= 3 2 re
i o 3 i
Z £ A re
cr E -
> "> o
c £ o
CM
01 o
349
o
o
u
o
IS
le-
ss?
o E «
P • £
g>c E
* £ E
■5 « 3
0 €> «
* • w
i as
lis
iH
1 ^-2
5£ a.
• o E
O) Ott CO
E E J
e
E
S ?£.
«l C V
e IS ^
E E g
2 « E
• ?t
E— •
_ © t
i^l
c • *
o u s
a « E
Is ?
f is
o. in 6
E <• S
ft o
O o 5
s °-
eI
II
a E
= »
•I
O E
o
E a
5 « -c
E y —
> O 3
c ^ o
o V n
o jC <«
o o «
ill
S £■
i
> 5; >
Q « Q
< It a
CD t) "O
1 tii
w E e
« E M
i 3 w
O IB CD
" £ —
'^ E-g
o o 5
Z - ^
o i -D
o> ai >.
- 0- =
•- r: "I
m E :;
i> o t^
^ o 3
• E S
lA
If
ill '
"- 0-5 c !
« 3 " « (
<
o
V £
a 6
3 O
* •»
£ <»
in ^
u>
W
£ 0
LI t^
■? o
3 ^
(0 4)
£ u
O c * 1
i= <» E
lis-
^ » £
4> tM n
?^ E
™ « — '
E S°-
-"So
I*
O «
£ E
£ It
> c
« 3
« <
< c
t i
SI
U >-'
^ «<
«! £
™ i« c
03-0
2 ? £
CD ^ O.
c c -
n C Q)
c » >
o -c c
E g'Q
- ^ c
2 5 >.
"go
ill
3^0
n
e£|
O o «
S Sf
sr J
a £ «,
S £ £
i2
3 •
(B jO
£fc£
o c
£ s:«
? - IS
s^ «
u o. "
< t>:
U :;^ It
It 0» i:
S a>«
->£ E £
It ^ c
? S£
I' C IB
• O tj
U « 3
2 •> t
1/1*0-
t> o o
^ O. £
3 w ^
S' s *
« ? £
£ -e
o c
E 0
n </)
EIB
c •
c in
o o
f o.
■c £0
£ E It
\ii C. ^
at (0 CD lA
SEE"
O •§ It £
■" * ^ £
£ ° 2 e
- t/l HI ^
o o -. u,
>- 9-
^£
2 «
(/> Ob
il
— s
:-2 p " s
s » ss
5 £ O a o =
■b ■=
•rr It (
9> I
It
£ g
•O
-5 <
&:
E 3
• £
3 " i m —
■c 2 E
c g 5 £
£ I E o
O <0 »1 "
3 4. ^ «<
CD CT «> ■=
QfS
^ i 5
o o a.
*> -K -
' «> >
05 a c
_j «> €>
Q. E Q
o -
o
T3 —
>• 3
So
i?6|
•g w (o -
" _J -i =
Eaa
>■ ^ 0 «
£ c C^ *
! e « o ".
" — CD E
It J- 1 It
It * e >
« c — o
It It o> S
lils
3 £ SiS
€l
?£
= in
E £
■^ Q.
•0 w
c -
It o
So
(/I i=
coo
3 O u
- C It
t» © — )
I « -o
o>E £
)' « n
! C 4»
^ s
E?
« E
41
E •
o
o
«j »; XI
E t> >•
It tf) "o
— 10
S 4>
"£ CD
4> n
S£
tt£
$ o
5JP
SiS E
o «>
O £
'I
w «. IC
10 « 10
• »1 5
«> £ It
S? 5
£"8 >-
i •= «>
• £ E
It 10 "o
= 10 -n
It It S
0 -o ™
c »! c
- £ «<
l?l
01 ™ 01
^ CT ^
£ 'io -6
> 01 c
E I "
3 >.£
1:1
£ 2 g
^ "^
V i: u
3 Jt £
= S "•
^ It £
O i It O OD 5
o
350
2
e
e .9
o
S
t
o _
O "g
2 •<
1 ?-x
a ■$
1"S *
§ S«
jU t, o
o c »
2 I y-
(S t -
^^£
?li
2 $ "
10 - 2
S • E
03 O 0)
|li
Q- A — '
•n — •'^
£ - "
s s =
E » a
2 I S
E ^m
— — o
O £ "
II
(ft tf»
= i
0 £ c '
1 t -
£ >-£
o a p
S-E r
t S S
£ °«d
ii
m -
^ t>
5"
o.
= <»
"S £
•s •
If
SI
f • 9
Ceo.
« £ 3
e *■ ■o
— 99
"> s —
n O 10
O U 3
U O 9
<!>-'>
>. e e
£-2 5.
(ft
S-5
— <B
£ -D -O
^ *' —
E 'J «
tl 3 U
= m
IS
•• o
o *"
• 5
11
fig
•o >
Ok
la
5 !!
6 S
p a
•1
s e
(E 2
o S
£ •
H TJ C
a £ £
2 B ^ J
S S So S
■o O • c S
Su|o8
m c .«> O o
It! «•
S) Ol.
■o
« S -o o
a £
® -s;
fx —
^ c
n
3 oa
m c
I «
£-5
•a y
• 5 t «>
c O o o
y 1 SiS^
a 01 c ,
V c= ^
S E «)
— «
9 □> ^ 'O
II
IB U
IS
£ t>
Of •*
= ^ £ „ E
£ B.?E o
E • S E •
<D £ (B O £
>■ * ? ^ 2
u
e
c
£ <» — *
I £ 3 a
«
:5l
E s
p S-
™ <0
e o
flj =
?^o
« Si -o
s= 5 «
o o u o>
C 01 ^ «
• £ ?
OK c
5 E ■"
p o "•
«< 9
in a
S o £ e -
>" " E£2
> o O c £
o 9- «> TJ o)
E^ £ c
ecu*™
9 ?« c 9*
- « its
§£f II
«i —
« -
11
2 « tA
=>€ 8
i • i
g,£o
f Io-
ns
g q: >■
— »i o
I- ^
" *. J
« — tl
a o «i «
a^ e 'C
£ 2 - O
» ? EO
ll E<
— - o ..
o Q O g
£ °^ «> i
'I »^
c " « r
£ £ - <»
c ^ £ c
10 £ d b
■«. -o -o £
u e o> 5
C «» C O"
CD o _j. ji
™ ■£ a 3
e S c <"
J2 o - -
t> o £ «
£ o 3 c
w E " Q
c £ « o
^ K " <
o = g,*
^ f J*
4» -=
5 * £
tfl 3 TJ
^8i
£ o VI
c ^ £
" !j "
r » »
£ 5 =
^ (D 2
o n
n
K !^ £
* -> «
« S -
c 2
o 3 a>
o. m "r
s^l
2- .O
c >-
41 •- «>
S «> £
j: £ —
o t: «
T)
" 3 »
a
£ -pa
S
Jl
iSiS
£
>> u n
o.
•5.O.'
Ol
E EU
c
S ^ £< iS
a o
o
S
i
351
K
Q.
s
s
X
o
a
•
U
> fi i o •
' * - II
lie*'
= 3 o • «
> •■ O • ?
£ < £ g
c •$
rllit
; c |R£«
I - t p >
' •» — 5 •> O
i o £ e o ^
_ OS c S
» E 5 >•
• C
I i
SS!2«
o »- > "
-• £S
£ot5
£ « ■
: ?«£y-
i-p g s «
r Q to £ ?
; J. $ as
>£ c S >.
! • « ^ S
. -D C 5 «)
: ■» o m "
* fl) — ^ fc
' T3 -^ •- ''
( f:^ «/) (0 Cl>
1 S «: £ t
£ ■ £
St- Qi
- « 3 -D -S =
CD • -O C « $
C -C • c C • «>
o o 5 E - 5 E
C «> 8 TJ i2 S -^
* • 5 c O o.
c »
I 5 £ S 5
•> 9 — - 2 lu >"
|lliH =
o-^ •> e o ■ -
S <o » £ c S >•
«, "g " - - ^ 5
ill*'
c • o ■
I £ * S (
5 : O «
,-. tl * 3 I
•• I- 1 *
• <!<»'
= 0) > .,
0 2|l
E t) = «
o£ S S
1 S •-&
SQ-
Q.T3
« «
<§£
O £
<!
£ 1
*. (0
: 5 » *>
0> fj
£ i; o E -
o '^ ~> = « ■" S
C ' T. ^ ^ O a
y « « t) c ^ -
«) g >. «1 "» <? »
Q. 5 " t «< £
E -6 I? o " <-> _
o S o S, ^^5 ?
u n SI "Oj < £
■o -o -^
o = c £
*- ™ re
« «> «> ^
g-CEO) ^
5! E S '
c °5 J
* o o
£ <»
c
£ o
i 1
E HI
o S
" a
2. c
t °
O V*
« 2
c o
n 0;
£■6 0
E o
e T3
£ re
Sl
II
11
?li
III
Q. * C
l« i! £
< • T3
^ »« O
" £ «
E 5.i
o t>
£ U re
?! O ^
«> (, c
2.£ »
S o S
re c 2
C O CD
* «; S
O = «
•- T) re
■S '2 *
© re ^
^ c -2
ID t *-
■R 5 TJ
^ K «J
« ,. a.
•> 5 o
£ o c
fill
re o !£ o
u V O II)
t " -2- o
^ to <fl —
S Q- 9 j:
2 y S &
5 D 5. >-
S"- « s
_ h- i« n
5 S 4 E
c •
re -g
9 O
re -o
= c
«>«)"? ^
'^ -.^ re •
^ * « «>
1 « 3 "i
^ ef
TJ x: 5
« — >
^ s *
■D C
re o
£o 5$* •
t; n* S
S = ^ ^ 2 ' c
o « c 2 /=^ £ 2
■C XI
!l
• o
3 f
c m
« re
o «>
in m
4) (0
O 3
_ _ E
•^?
9 Sf
Sol
• ci(/)
• £«'
£=5°-
o re c
E re £
o *
^ O
««>«<«
2 ££
o re "
- 2 *
i o>
« * E
» c 2
■o re c
©■05
o t» re
E *! _
» re E
X 01
a?
O) V
c E
iA« ^cD£S£a)-i
rei S
q; o
o>
9
o
352
a
K
8
S
u
E
a
X
n
I
a
I
c
E
Z
5
S
01
e
e
I
u
• O «,£
S <>
c «
a. 4)
2! "
ti »
o «
< tfi
ll
a> «
£ c
• t>
u c
1» t-
|o
t> <
O «
o£
^ P
=1 5°
=1 4. ■?
O -> 0>
" o S
• p •>
sB »
s. •■ -
_ •- xs
s 5 -
i - s
e <" £
!5
• E
5 <e
<^ 3
* 9
TE 1-1 ^
S «
I!
S C o.
S o •«
^ _ •>
Ifl
«> E S
» i o
«; o <
» ^ £
- c «
•o • E
w o £
tf> 5 c
im o
T -S i
o ?::
• I
£ S
-= £
li
a c
o
■o ^ o
' o •
■o «> •>
c W «
s £ tn
JC o ^
1^ s
Sec
% o c
o a c
c 2 »i
2 * S"
V ^. W
« « V
II?
O >.je S
?l?
o —
^ c o
SIS.?
o^ a. t
^^-i
8*1 *
•5 S. 2 j»
€> « " 5
S! ^ E •
o S c *;
(1 « (B O
• 5 < S
o t! g » o * g
K
o
i E
1 £
t> o «
c -o —
O «> Oi
c ? i
« i £
ti «i «;
c' g
CB 9 o
• 5 "
c o (r
^ * £
• o- o
•8 I
« B. 7
s ■£" "
• § o-
i O >■
o > c
s 2 IS
-?!
s S »
*** O ^ O *'
5 *
a = E
a>
n k, o-
o o c
Sit
» ad)
* ""T
£-0 0
— c •-
o « >.
lis
0 0)0
SI g"
<. J3 Z
Q.iS "5 t
sSSf
2 • SI
s^f If
i " ^ «.
S so
IB £ £
£ C »
a $ «)
- *fi
c
S?o
tit
£ 4
_ <" c
s c s
> <e —
ci
b —
11
£ S <^ «>
* • S's
o'S ® P
«! * (n""
£ ^ w o
o = • •!
c £ e o
" o JZ
«; £ 6 «>
u <• Z a
i <" — =
— " "• <» « =
£ • •«= -2 ;
s fc- »■ *> '
S !3 o ^ <
gtr £ « -
Z *>*- £ •
i') >* n £ I
ii> o S o f
O 2 C »l I
2-0 S S j
a- t p c
w X _ ^ I
£ 8-c $
3 «> «> t-
°-~ B i :
O m ~ - '
*2o 5 :
*£
£ >.
n c
• 2
1 =
1$
«> S.
3 II
w ~
n 15
^ t/t
i« £
c •-
10 i/i ^
eat
in ^ u
«> 3 £
o = 2
s; s s.
d *! •-
K £ £
2 «.
4) — a
2£Sf
sirs
2£
S- 6
01 0)
■= S £ c -
7 c - ° "
i E 5 «
5. -5 * -5
y o £ c
Q » £ « ™
,- S ? 0) -
E £ ? "^
£ s; r £
^ .1^ in ^
tP S — — C £
C £
So
« —
? I ?
■5 S> 5 -o
z a M «^
Q.-> a 3
a « o 2
<» S • •"
O 3 c <"
1.5 JtI
nil
oS|S
-■5 v> o
^ ^ jC tf)
S E 2 o
O 01 •= c
c o> c £
c £ £ 01
a 5 a "S
>.E E .m
Q $ £0:
I «5
< £ a
01 5
01 u c
? 8<«
a - J
01 c 0)
o « c
3 A o
(D 2 £
o o- c
~ — o
S E S
ti ^ c
> c a
•£ 0)
«n
c - "»
$1 =
A £ ti
_ O £
* c —
>' a in
•- .^ JC
O a> in
a —
O. o
i
353
«
K
a.
354
i|
lit 2
<• •■
w c
<g o
I O
o
c
€
ui
p
a.
ill
g • •
K c u "
• ■6 2 S
° 8" "
5 8 o -
£ * «> c
► £ > <•
• -a S •
*: £ » 2
• p ^ <"
■ s
• c
2 w
2 « I <6
O'
1
.-<? s
£ tj = o
= ° io
2 cot
sto £
£ = c y
c o ^ o
o « .-r -^
o » . '-'
u
« o
S«
3 f^
A £
so:
'I
• £
°€
SI
35
X
3
IT
o t>
o
tt
■o -
« «= B
« - ^ w
S n . Ol
a
" £
_ e
o
g5-t
e^4
o o § £ * »
E • £ _
-11
: Xi Q.
ml
9 o| $
O < ad
5 i
u c
0 c
7 S£
4! -c u
5 n »
> o ^
C o £
£^3
en o *
E c c
01 o 5
c ^ e»
c *> "
0*5 =
o -> ^
la
SI
«l c
f 5
? • §5-
• • 8 3 <e
» «> M E
I £ £ «
•S ^ ? "
_ f E >
S* o * *,
- §? *
* * p S
c •» " ?
tw E *
* ir -S i
J s2
•" JC ■!
QUO
P • 5
« ^ O"
!!! £ «■
« g 4>
0» > P
"PS
£ • p
« 11 ^
E « t
_ o> o
£ e »
III
« 5 £
-I
-I
e «
•= E
u P
-> 9
lis
« = c
-J 5 £
- E -
p w £
|1
• c o
p _ p
8 ? S-sS
! S2 ot>
■P p 2 ^
5 *
«> o
o o
« <* o
?£-o
e £ «
R P »
o c u
O
<
p t/l
Ob 01
S «
p £
I "
E 01
-'I
^1 o
c p S
sis
1 * <=
" • 9
<» £ o
■" « £
22 9
o 5 01 c
■o » £ o
p § ^ ■"
» £ 2 S
S *> e '2
i £ ' ,P
i! a E 01
-Is I
a. 3 A f
a. tf) ® -M
" <(i £ *
£ 01 - E
l« U 01 _
CS P £ C
J » — 0)
■s ? * E
t = * ?
— W " w ^ U C
<» 3 £ Ol k U S
! ? p ,s ? 5 ^
01 I/)
0) *
^g
01 3
E o
11
lit o
<» is
01 ^
If
21
01
£
c o
£ e
* i
2 o c
E u £
« E
« </>
if
£ S E
O £ Oi
™5
> o °
O -P 1/1
p p -^
£ £ §
a. Q. i
£ 0 c ..
S »S E
^£«g
_ £ i« 0)
•O 5 01 p :
o. » •(T •
E = O 0,
O T3 t-
o c q;
SO
$ o
^8
Ol P
n ~
C 01
if
01 0>
2 >-i
o o
Si'
fQ s
^2
t*
■o 2
2 E
S2
« »
a £
» o
•< ^
€ 5
IS
4> -O
Ol
01 P
— 01 c
-|«
«i t n
£ >-'o >■
" D ° »
£ p lA p
sr * o
> <• -S e
p £ « ■•
9 » «
u £ £
aj r
« u i ^
£ J> n n
§p^ ^
2 s •• *
c (!)
C E TJ _
p « • £
™ —
£ U
Pi
tfl
•d£^»£82S
iti««ic'!-SS
lis s
J Ji «>
» X -S t:
2.^ J P
CI O M A
« £ « u
O T5
a.
c E
0; 01
*2
*^ 3
£ ^ n c u
p ■" •= :
- 01 >--h
55 * S
£ « £ ->
0 S Ol o
•= 8 ">
•> 9- 3 01
«) 9- CO 01
3 3 u S-
'in
1 ^S E
nil
£ « -5 £
" 2 p-
« > O gj
E S c S,
1*24
Olf - i
S 3 S O.
1S£5
|2 $ p
©•-co
2* » U •=
"I s i
^l«2
o ''^•5 £
f ,5 ^ £
01 01 c
" t 9
3 01 P
(£ £ E
P c
- 1
c £
01 c
E 5
c
355
9 E
(0
I
£
o
c
2
«
rr
O £
£ * o
2. F =
• ¥
o ^
«> 3
O Q.
■o <I>
™ E
■c o
u
•>
tf>
a
1
T3
ft)
3
ft)
t3
•
ft)
o
(0
£
0)
o
c
>
C
a
o
c
tf)
£
2
a
•D
3
tn
C
^
o
3
O
«>
1
o.
ft)
£
2
(/I
O
o
c
o
^
in
3
yi
E
m
T3
01
5
5
n
tf)
tn
0)
«>
o
01
1—
ft)
£ n
c O
• U
a<
•* a>
■If
•> w
o n
= o
<» £
e ™
£ o
£ <^
y =
£i ft)
etc = —
O .. O in ^
■e *
c ■o
41 ^
o ^
Q. 4>
— £
3 O)^
5 o o
C 01
01 c
"O 0^
0>
3
1
O"
(A
c
OJ
re
E
o
re
to
■o
o>
%
^
(/)
D
U
"?
O
<
C
E2 c
3 w O
a: sr
u o
•- <
a: .,
C O 3
- UJ ^
o • O
c -a
£ -6
re </» O
o reO
t, "*
5 01 »
•5 -=£
™ i! —
?L:
£ v
-) re re
!» -
£ o »>
oi o =
< g>*fl
ft> - O)
x: -C tn
»— *ft t/i
re ft)
g c 0)
"5 I/)
— o
3 ^
O 0)
St ^ E
O- 3
•' -S
^ ^ re re
* -c ., s;
"I ^ !! -
c S i a
^ -3 -O
JS O 3
re *" o
•Si
>• " 5
« *- "Si
m * O
■2 -a «
5 c £
I " *
- '^ 5
c o ^
Mt ft) ^
F = r
re £
Ol u
«> £
_ «>
c
£m
re
^ 0>
S «>
= s
a. o.
' E •
; O
C Z fc S
o
If «
c £ o
= is i= ft
0> 01 o
( 1 E *
O - T3 -
< T3 re c
■5 o S i^
■S E
re "O
ft) — c ^ c
Ol o ^ ft) o tn o
1/1 5) *- ■• '" '"
ft) a» (i>
£ cc £
E oi "
i o 0) c o
■rr rt m
O
OL «
a. o
n ft?
1°^
c O Q
.t2„
75 ■*! ■O
s " >■
,9- = «>
") « -o
111 ii
o
« o
->c in
o in
re o>
~> o
2 ? E 1 S
•- — c w o
ill
3 O —
O
Ol
O -D
2 re
o xi
^ o
li
fl
- c
lA O
9 3
S «'»
(A "O
^8
»> e
SI
o. >_
E £
0) 3
ft)
£ E
c o
o i
re ^
^1
S 2
re 3
^ o
re u
^ <5
?l
"» re
— 0)
^ x:
° c
°^ S
o •"
a T
^ re
re -c
^ >.
5l
i
j::
re
Is
J
£
c
c
o
o
Q>
tf>
£
lA
£
■c
o
ft)
re
O-
a
a
tf)
3
0)
£
« »> -
* ^ 0)
o» «- >
C = 0)
-,-, ™ Q
^ I 3
a; c re =
-•SI
o <- ^ c o
*- 4) *- C j;
OQ.tr
< r re
?•' «r i- i^ =
lA a £ a
^ 01 «;
(A
^ 1/1
» o
fl
™ 5:
— 01
= >
jr o
o «
S J
m o
•o o
o re
" S
re -D
S S
3 01
5 c
== a.
T3 OJ
>» re
01 Ol
c £ 5
2 o E
ifl -^ _
- E "
0 " T>
— _ re
"Ore,-:
re O Q)
£ s- -
c to u
E w lA
tr o ft)
re = -
&"£
"o t re
_ 01 —
m jz ifi
CT *' re
01 01 s
«; 6> c
£ 0) ^
c .c E
ra 0) ^
i? ^
S| s;
Q. b tf)
CL ft) ^
re -D i:
^ ft) ™ :
— n c
« " J)
£«)(«'
if ^
• £ s
C 0^ o
O) ^ "
c i ™
re ? "
t S «>
« S 5
"" 3 >
re " I
a-o ^
01 re -,
_ _ 01
£1X1
01 01
-* o
« S. E
re o; »
E -^
_ S O
« S £
C (11 — )
ft> o -•
0> 3 ft)
■osS
(U ^ I/)
Ul
Q- 0) 5
re .Q <
5 re
o -^
— o>
re I '^
356
Q.
i
u
1- I
o
I
0)1
Ql
■5 S c
3 2 <g
° s e
c c c
> » t>
I « s
ill
«) >. o
n c «
o o <«
— • o "
: « £ o <
I CB • = J
; • -O S :
o = ' I
i 2 i •/
!t3 S c <
C 3 « J
; " « o '
i £ i 5 I
. o o < I
seSs
i 5- £
a» in
« '2
(0 o
' ?
5 2
£ 3
o »
^ c
>• *^
E.-S
iM.
c TJ a»
<» « c
$22
* ° 2
a £
5 «>
<o =
^ i
81
'jJ e 5
0) a>
£ V
o ^ _
m • ?
•> * -<
" 5 o
5 S u)
0, " o
£ (/) £
— a, a.
c c «i
"EI
; «; «i
; 4 -E
ceo
9 C CI
" o *
^ ^ ~
Sf s
e i -
§? I
■c -c S
nil
2 u.
Wat:
£•£ -
- 5 °
5 XI c
w ff w
« S 5
«, o. J
T) ai 0)
« 2 '^
• CO
=: * •!
155
2 IS
-S o c
o a. F
« £ g
«/ s o
■^ £ s
»— — £
•» — TO
$ m CO
• •
£ E
oS
S 5
o?
ti •-
y c
^ •
s J-
o S
o?
Z. ■
« •>
«> •>
- o o-
5 $ <
5 15
V c u-
£ S !^
pi
5 E <-)
u o ^
■o E -°
W X ®
* «> s
O T, •
• is?
2 5 2. o
• > «>
« • a •
3 c £ i
E -iS-
3 • 2
o£ ?S
TJ •; « 5
5 5 P =
CM ™
a> >•
• e B> J
£ j> >-:
o • ? J
-£01
o * t-
^ E <r
on®
m O. x: .
c * •
* >■ ?
?f :::■
o ^"^ £ S
a t O. m S «<
O "• «
- E O p
• » « t
cS£ $
^ £ " -o
>i- O •
' « •- «5
•gag
> s » •
C C £ Q.
€ F >•£
£ £ « o
i; c «> 01
_ • q: >
■s o 2
1 is £
£ OT «
3£ T3 «>
^ ^ C C
(D $ (Q (C
<0 w
*£
1 S 5 ?
- » •€ *
5 6 * =
|8lm
> fo a ^
V tfi t^ *^
• S $ 5
< tJ £ £■■
f i-3 2
« "o ^ o)■
Q. c *■ ^
<S 3 C
2 S •
^ C 3
§1 s
8 £ I
? o <»
(DOS
c 01
— c
tf> 01
so
II
Si rj
o' ;:
9
357
0 E
TO m
1 "
£ o
■s o»
u e S
o ^
c » e
S -^
£ o c
£ ^ <0
</) TO >,
C 2
O «
t = IB
sfs
g 12 o
w I- c
£^ S
C o -
o _ *>
in 0) £
i|s
Ml
2 i:^ TO
E c ■^
2 5 £
■gS£
TO O 3
-1 < ^
I 2
*" £
« VI
^ TO
O ^
^O
£2
M
*D *-
^ •
0) n
> 3
= 0)
a. o
lA ^
- (/>
t/) 0)
«)
>- (/)
■5 *
u *"
Q. >
•« 75
a 5
o C
lo
< (T
« • J
£ £ o
13 •
?l I
TO O ^
— 9 in
5 8-2
I « u;
If"
p o a>
«, «> 5
fll
- Q. in
CO Q «
-^'
■D — O)
" " £
4, << C
= lA U
u 3 fc
TO O ^
™ TO ■C
- £ t
^ it JZ
a o $
so
C T)
C C
^ c
o c
■o c
tl »
tf) «
« x>
T3 •
« if
lA 1/1
S e:3
$ «JJ
S £a
£! o> «,
e » ^
£ 3 -^
— TO c
<B O ^
TO e £
*f I
S 5 -
TO (A
U 3
o o £
D - > »/>
oa cz «> TO
■rJ #1. O
E TO JC
£ — ■»
TO «) -)
c O -E
TO U »
k- — (A
$ 5 c
0) a>
TO
O TO •
TO <fl Z i5 o
O S ~
o £
— 9
o « »
• ^ E
- o>S
lA C T5
£ t3 "■
^ Q. TO ^ TO
Q. £ ^
V O o
Ill
S I £
o ® m
— Em
i TO «,-
•c >o i;
0 f S
c « S
1 ■" »
TO £
lA it
S>«>
>- 0}
V c
c
■t. lA
a £
« TO O
^ E TO
IT
O *- £
TO O)
~1 C _
£ o o
_ E >.
" ci re
— £ T)
» S £
C TO >- —
E JA O
i; TO O
i 3 -O <A
■ "1 ^
f. I
*« 3 <? £
m
E E
c ® 5
in
O 4>
O In
O i
V TO
£ O
^— ._
«. »!
iA x:
3 T3
U 0)
O -c
S ■» 9
^ E 'i"
i §5
= 0) o
E ^S
•5 E TO
■° JS T3
>- C «l
r- at >
C «> %
o c £
w >
E 4!
o 3 S
O »! CO
o- «! «>
SI TO £
<" !? ™
JOE
^11
m ^ rJ
J5 E
TO C
>- 2
«> o
£ E
o ^
^1
c -^
TO C
O O
E u
o «
3 U
O £
lA (A
Q> jf a.
"•DC
2 c «)
m TO 0)
o c a>
o fc j:
S. ui oi
O 4j c
o c -o
■g£ !;!
■= £ Q.
4! -2 « -z: r. i
£ ^ o» o, *r
r ° d £
. Z O ~
_ T) "O
0, £ TO
E — T3
TO * *
C. £ 5
fl^ o u
O S J
TO "D tA
~ C c
fl> TO 3
•t "§£
*" ^ ^
(A O «^ C
^ >^ £ TO
^ "^ •» T,
E S
c O
TO
S O
_ E
01 £
E -"^
a 0
£ 1, O „ j: J»
(_) JA O
c TO -=
£ «< «;
01 £ O
•= H)
£ <
O C TO
<A J£ A)
3 5"
IA c CD
TO ». y
<» s-s
«" £ -s
3 >- §
£ £u
o TO J;
< o.?
£ £ c
> 9 V
£ o J,
Q 5 £
ml £
■o P »>
»l~
^ 0) S
o O ~
-> a °
° £ I
|S«
££&
TO x: i
(A 1 «
Hi
C 0) -1£
c E u
» IS I
S «) ^
£ c «j
f ?f
£ TO 5
4,-C *
> >. >.
O 0} 1^
E £ £
S CO
358
I
e
o
<5
= o iS -c
c c l/> ^
4ft
o { e
E « o
o — ^
•o B JC
Coo
5 » *
° I g.
SS c
<; o £
< -D t—
0) o
£ o
:=5
• S
E »
E ^
o S
o _
o c
> s «. 8
£ «
£ E
S o
T3 C
• s.
5 ?•■£
ill
>. *0 0)
? Ss
Oj U Q>
c n -
- -> «
» 0.-=
S - s
c " -
5 « 1/1
° — S;
So"
O o c
^ S £
(/> CI i/l
o 2
e -
"If
of
»« -£ i
o E e '
a c
Ol
" ■s —
^ ™
i« ^ -o
*! 01 «
^ T3 ^
!i j; £
3 •O
5,=
U OB
re jc
IB O
en c
r; <»
O E
O Z.
of
*i o
o-i
O tf>
0 *"
S O
jcO
5 «
5 5
£ ^
C -)
1 t
o S n !
o (0 s *
A ■= ^ I
i; Tj
£ -o '2
2^ S
«!»=«,
£ Q o»i
— « c o
E -c £ iS
»l s s
5=50
§ * 5 S
o o = »
»<"•=£
& C 3 S
O C 5 01
- 5 « (J
£ £ £ °
9 Q.5 3
Si ^
.lis
a. >
« •
" s « «
• 8 e «
- * =™ S i
- o E "
« s •=
OS ^ = r
■5 5« I
5,3 SO
S^ E £ =
-. r- ii> •-
- a. 3 <
§ I 2.'
re - 5.0
O) f o
c o c
I !! tf>
ff) o. re
1- t -^
w - o
i; i/i i, — w ^ TO
-; r a 3 re re =
o
re =
« ? - I
— 4; rt c
4A •-
Sill
a o o «,
"lis
b </> 5,—
n K 3: £1
fo c
5 £ » K
i o o *
e ° c <»
o o H e
e v a £
" = -o e-
fl> c >
0 £ (5 JS
> « 3 (0
1 S m E
w ? i« re
s sl£
2 •" *" S
c 5 ° ?
s I =_ «
«< r 5 »i
" ti A p
CD o ~ tr
E 4
E a
o-c
.(• o
■D a
•13"
o
a> —
c a>
■5 E
52
S^
85
K -
< o
«> in
£ o
•52
■3 §
oi
$ c
o o
E «>
0/ V
= >.
oS
s o.
;; E
i •
o ""
3 a>
l££
•c
>- S
o i
£^
< CD
o E
C TJ
<" 5 *
«1 flj —
E «!
« « I
CD £ « -g
'- — 00
_ E m y
* -3 ■5: u
E » £ 2
i • E<n
Q. O « «
" a Z Z.
- o £ ^
m ~ ^ c
?E «,i^
» S o s"
S »iQ-
E « t: £
». = S E
« $ " o
^ -^ c r*
* £ ? y
•C — 3 2
t- » n CO
jt — O c
* o is -o
t o 7 It
S: P a> u
o «£ °
I") —
a>
359
9 E
s; s =
Oi or I
Si O
n UJ
U ixi
<
o
^u
c
CD s
e S"-*
o -=
1%
O.J2
" • s ?5 • I
— o
"2 S |.aS _
o ~ a J E E 9
e y 2^8 8
• ■§ * ? O • i:
s = S fc « o o
•c * « c Q J
8 5 2
guj w O
^8
• o UJ •
" « = c
? 5
Z. "J
-si"
a • o
^ 3
" E
•> n .
I *" .T" *£
5 a s
^ 3 «1
C g Ol —
o • c ^ _
5,1- iS »= c s >
5o :» ? eS I
* °^ ro s -at
- re m £ -^
I £ t
tA
1^ «> •=
= t: O
n n (/)
< u
U 41 » =_ SI C
Ol tt* o> c t ^ _
- -^ C "' *i t
-^ I ™ S :- t 8
•» 5 5 5
• 5 s§
~ a ^ •
S E-c-o
5 ■ c •
sill
"o e S i!
£ a » -D
« § I 15
— 0) C ■£
» i/t « -^
l-S ?
O • Jt o
*? "I
y « » o
o « " *
°1 ?^ i §
Is?
E c e
elf
R ° 8
|?°
• c O
E£
£5
• E
• £
o
■° - ° _
• ? ■£ <» .
■^ a" E I
1 £1°!
S - ifi
•- 3 o £ !
.V £- n c ^
• u> £ 9 i
,-= e c i» ]
W o - c '
2 B S -K J
8| « •>:
u E ® c
O 3 •- (D
tt S £ j» :
a 0 £ • J
£ « o ra ,
s^.!|
■c ■£ e <»
-= e =- a>
c E "o £ :
o a> ra ^
£ 2 « -c ■
o *- t ^
>' E C *"
at A n 0)
• ^ i ^
«> — «1
"? •
IS = E
« o o
E o «
« «) 3
£ -C 3
c y o
5 * *
? o £
1^ *
» E
y E
o o
< <
O O
< »i
a, c c "/^ Ol
- tf, a ™ -
tfl o o o
i« a 2 £ c I. 2
_ o • E » £ re
in UJ 0/ r
*- re
!f, "> *"
S re £
A; ° " ■$■
- >
o y e 2
o CD c
E S-y -o
o > y ■y
re t)
T3 £
2: r > w
■c £ > a
^ O t= Q-
= < = :
loll
1^ a I
C — 3 -§
V — in <
•c re 0)
— o re >*
o " a c
re £ & o
^ S *> fl)
c 2 o -5
->" O" I ^
c -o in
CD
3 °
C Ol ^ S
©Co
(/)
360
<
o
o
9, E
O t
Ui Z
E
IS
I
4/ CL
If
5 <
Or
a.
V. "re
<
O
a
<
C
<^ Ji If i Q
2 -D - 5 •
oii: a * —
^ > ^ C 1/1
"js Is s
•:; 5 1 « £
0. 2 S £ Q.
%> */
S >
E «
3 !»
<» C
?: -c
^ t: V «
2 o i =
a _ o *
c w " *
o 1 ^ E
^ > (A 0)
tilt
8|li
5 £ 0, £
s £ i; -
a< ^ o "D
O) c jf ^
m £ < re
O ^ 3
S-s •
ll§,
•6 *
c c
t> —
a €>
^ 3
s e
1« 3
_ n
a i £
?^?
a (r •
(N «| <^
I
y _^
? • £ *
C 3 4) «j
O 3 C Q.
" g ft Q.
o 2 3 •
c o
-o €, r
O -^
O > 3 !/>
r £ 5 c
- > 4.
O J t 1
iff
3 J5 -D
o y re
»ft «> -c
i5 c */>
« « c
-» o» **
T3 « ■§
C ft; >
"3 i (%
tr (J O)
c
0^ «- rg
Q. ^f •-
(t 3 X
_3 i ■=
— C </)
J£ e -c
u> o *"
«> 3 if
3^(5 *
= £ o
o o u
c a. ^
< 2 5
• O €» C
s • « ^
fill
O E «> w
fill
£ K OI O
c © t c
i< c ?
to Si
J"- • -
J *£o
y - o t
° £ 1 ^
< ^ »-2
5 £ |S
u. o tt^
* 2 S -
- o ^ o
<» " £ ~
£ * 9 IT
** »- « 1/1
«, u c re
L> C w ^
^ ^ ^ —
d) T = re
* ^
« ^ -
— C ft.
ft» re £
£ o o>
~ c c
o "5 I
• -O €>
s it|
t *< -^
£ £ «
> »:
> y o
■1 r- .K ^.
K •
o o
I
o i o
< a •/*
E- re
- ** S
— £ re
3r £
£ ° s
r • £
S J g
re r 5
I' -
* ?. i
S 2 !i
■pro
<" >
n s
— 01
— »
c o
o «
5 E
"^
S £
• £
i/i >
£« c «,
8 £
re £ o>
■o o 1 ■
41 — 3 •
_ - c »f t:
" re o c 0. ■
s £ a o c
a> re
£ c
1 c
£ 2
• S
^ TO
Oj tf' 11'
(A
i E
E S
C 4
«n w 4)
re fc - t
■= re O t
re *? c —
t-5 " »
in 4> *
c £ n */!
S tf. * 9
■> '^ * T
. re ^ o
re c £ 4i
S o 5 S
S uj £ o
^ 41 - *
4, £ w «;
£ C 1 £
° £ °l
illo
ki U ^ Jt
re o (c
e s. >- c
41 >. ^ U
Mil
«- = o re
£!£!£€
>■ J. o S
o g-
t 4.
>- it
i/> O
i a
«S
•o c
c re
u 4*
l|i
IT re
5 J
* ?
c
I 5
E i
0 Ol
1 !;
* TO
- P
o. i
re &
1/1 c
ft| s
I/) 0^
ir
ft* ft
S £
i 1
3 ai "^
£ ^ £
*- o re
1 £ £
£ > re
i?£
4> U IT
« i re
(/» 4« (/I
«- *" S
" 5 E
|t R
£ -X o.
g s "
£ 5 -
&*l
oil
O ™ c
^ «- fti
o *> c
* £ ft.
* <« S^ s
:;;£ i 2
4< 1/1 c ;
c X o c
§ -£ ■= 2
1^ ^^
«8 E =
£c^ I 5
SH?
O » 41 4.
< C £ £
9 »-
a. E
o A
5 -o
'I
re -O
^ — re
5 f, re
re re o
re J" -o
§5 &
lire
S * ^
■c i A
Tj re 13
41 i c
lA o TO
£ 5 e
i-2 ^
iS c o
- ° 1
4; ^ S
c re J'
b o> ii
£i "
y s 2
■^ Sl
U V w
re Q> ft/
-1 Q. >
C c *"
1 1 ^
gore
flJ re a>
C .o i<i
I Ell
E 5;
— o
IT
4/
o
c. 5 -
O '■
361
o
a
S C
n ix
u; a.
•c •» - ^ -i,
i c
' 3 VI
i5f
I «
i^ E
o _
5 o
in -o oi
«> V 2
VI > g»o
■R E >■ t
c -g » o
I <• E 5
•o • o •
« £ "- £
C IB O —
o « - "
4, J O It
S f U VI
^ n c <•
O £ IB S
oil?
liJ e E „
• e S«
£ 0. -6 -
t « (fl c
9 E £ £
4 «.
a, ^ a. H
o
0 £ o J
c <» ^ *^
- VI »•
II
(B a
E °-
— »
a c
If
•- VI
IS
c «
s E
2 *"
8|
■i £
V) p
f * £
E ?|
©•DO
■^ • -C
° E S
VI o ^
5 ^ •
«« O £
(0 ,. at
§ "i
0> «/) c
° S E
-iJ-i'iS-^-r*-
O
-* " Ti -<
V o a i2
S SJi!
E
E
^ E i,
:f fl. v^
CD G S
<» 'vi
tfi t>
» v
" 2-
c o
f a
^ «>
"s :?
5 o
Ot o
S >.(M
lis
o i« 5
1« ^
• 3
01 u
11
= C
II
VJ V)
01 o
ti E
II
TO _
E •
n c
>- y,^ *> ^
0> 0> £
= i O
« "D w
VI >- *
- o >
"> — 9
B ° X
(E Q.D
n o>
E .« £
° £ c
TO — «>
o> « S
£ £ o>
? 5 E
0) CB C
Q. E c
° % t
c >- o
f |5
re t
1°
Q. u
« O
£ LU
1st
I o£
"D J» v>
« u O
0> £
E 1-
VI
Oi
si "
y^ I
O S o.
<• 01 0< VI
ra r- r- _
c pi
^x E i I
Ol > -
^ (J P"
K •
£ JC £ in
01 Q-
— O
c o
i »
c b
o -o
01 E
re o>
= E
£ 0.
t- = ?;
5 5 s S°
o
2 q; o
2 ' S
m £ c
oj C7I r
11-°
cr V re
= - ^
° S 5
r X >"
o o !?
^ ~ >.
■° °Z
VI c ™
- in t
O 3
0 in
a. 3
01 9
II
o
•D 0<
Q 5
JC re
' *" V 1-..
ft) >- c >
^ ^ O 4)
•? f 0. >.
^ 0) c OJ
y &S.I
o " ^ -=
Q. "« re re
J a o< E
? i f ^
0 E £ o
■= c oj re
re 3 o. =
* Tl « 'i-
re g 0) o
S re o Q.
01 c 01 ™
— VI " c
3 rr >. t
a. in
5 *
c a
■£ E
c re
i o
£ E
I •^
Ol *"
C IN
■= a
o> ■
01 *-
E o
* T
O 01
c JC
* IT
E o
g"
o c
O 3
St
re ?
^ o
II
01 i
u ^
9 c
CD 5
i: .^
" 0.
)= v> = C
£ - u =
0) c -
— O 01
£ = E
E m E
£ «- 8
c * !?
9 w w
¥ E £
S ojE
E £(M
O 3 0>
re viR
E !5rN ■
>-£ ^
o £ o
i 2-^
Vi s ^ ■
0) re 3
£ 01 -
£ o
< ^
E?
re a>
«.. 3
Ol »■
, > " - %
i« o< i iS J
Oi <k u tn .
I-* ^_ 3 Jt
3 c ** ? w
m K S t «
^ ^ ^ -
Ol
0 -o
^1
01 5
VI o
« c
O ■«
O 3
LU O
O O
0 ""
Z t
01 Jt
^ (J
S^
• T3
-i re
TO 4r
~> U
■D 3
^?
a> TO
r a*
o ?
O - c
a. 01 o
Q.X> Q.
3 _ U)
VI C 01
?Ere
re T t
X — X) o>
X XI ^
; ; s"^
Ol r- l"»
, 3 C ^
O O -
lis
^- £
— ^ 4/
C 0< r
C £ 1
< £5
TO —
362
s
a:,
c
9
I
G
0^
E
TO
IT
a.
Oi
•r
re
4>
«
i'
o!
(T
X
9 e s
— n ^
o
I! c
c
UJ
OI
<
363
S: %
9 E
re ^
% re
r
f
«
- 1
-^ J?
If
18
o O
> UJ
O
lij
UJ
e
S >- •" <^ 5
|5s;
« • c
• > c
o c
« g «
— — ^ (N
° E 2°
cr C © _
its
i 9 S
is
• CO
(D o <S
-£ «
e < £
^ $ c o- w re
a c
<x "- > e
■2 • T^ --
_ " -> T) -
c E
re *
- -s - £ = "" =
= 9>
S D -K O
la " o£ S£
Lu s; _ J?
^ T3
«)«£• —
5 S
•o ^ = P £
re o
Q. 5
E £
o S
u a.
O 5
LU ^
LU e
•- X
« —
O in
!|
o >
la
» s
re 3 •£ .-
O
LU .
> 9
o
o c
— o
9 o 9 i/>
D £ ?. E '
= ^ :: (J ±
re
o£
^ >"
w >■
re re
If) v^
Si
s ~
c o
9 1^
^ re
re ->
E m
5*
£ I
1^
Z »
o £
•O t; o -
o c re ■"
c - c 0)
c o t J£
5 £•£ -
»f S S
5 = S£
■§£ S£
~ •* = S
£ 0>:i ^
e UJ o
Ji 2 *^
re e O
-> i UJ
<n u UJ
E ■!? 0.
5 T3
S re
> e
? f - i •
Q. re
o —
u
<• e
• E
^ re
re ■=
-D •
re u
o S
O o
So
o> E
- £
o —
■^ -^ -'
re'-Q.
WGD >
, a c
■i >:°
0) n c
Q. —
» F.
o>
c o
o </5 «;
£ -I •"
o Q- m
_ S »
•- >-'S
>- c °
c o >
o re o
to OL O
re c
o CD £
£ E
O
UJ
UJ
«
re
O E
LU jK-o
UJ £ re
S w £ ? 5 E 2
J 5
o ^ o
in Q *- - ..
t/) Q. 3 (/> O.
E
o 9
o —
re
E
J£ ci « ®
Sll E
tf. •!? o
S - J2
o re c
£ X at
« -r •=
« !^ „ ,.
E Jx E
£ o ™ 5
£ ? £ c
X ^ "51
" o >
0) in re
S g-l £
~* h )/) lA
ft £ is >~
T3 «, <; P
re 5 !» Q.
E &E E
» o - *
sr||
re £ e o
"^ E £ ^
£ w in «
T, •» = *
m " » ■
5 » ft S
ft M O
ft X '-' ft
O — c JD
C C O .,s
ft o S S
|5q- 8
£ i > ft
c Sb t-* re
t-^— -:--x:reft
t; ffi -r- re X ft ~>
c * ^ E ft j£ o
ft ^ £ X -c "^
* » «;
5 £ E
S -D ft
ft ft ^
> ft
4 o re
o -D
ft
B t £ > 5.
^ in
re ft
CD a.
re o
S. £
*|e
Eir:
E <• £ 9
°k" ft
" ft ^ I
X — ft CT
■^ > C _
*" c "* *
O S » o
* >*- —
ft ® "cn-
C — >.
'in re re ft
in c o c
S o o o
°- " ^ S
ft " f,
£ - * S
£ re * ST
V ^ w Jt
« " S^ m
-S £ ? "
Ol J? c ft
£ §Z £
^ S o m
2 c
3 ft
O E T3
1 - s,s
ui S ™ JO
8222
o £ -o
O -D S. C
J t^ "> $
■£ re in ft
c in ft ">
O ft ft c
^ T) >. ft
re o -C
m x: 0, ft
ft P " X
O £ ° is
r • X
15 ft £ —
t; -c •- ft
re T3 ; jc
'^ 7= ft o
of 2--!;
C ft O j-
!!! O E J
ft c * X
i 9 U "
= o •" i
S ft 0= -
ft CO c OS
i<" :: i
rea « 2
ft * ft ft
in ^- ^ re
° S" ft ^
5 « o -
a £ 2 £
I*
X 5
t: re
5 o.
£ o
ft "^
E I
re S
c *
l=:
■"- re
"S s
13 ft
■» X
re £
ft
C
1 £
m J5
X °-
._ ft
ft >.
4= ft
re c
>- o
ft ">
° ?r' ^
Q. ft
■>- re E
re
oi
oi E
re _
re t3)
£ «;
o
£ 5
O
364
Ol
E
3
O
o
O
Sea
Sec
III
« 5 S
«! «Q £
(T I <fl
O
ID
Ul
IB C
I'
— w
<
0 >
01 Q
O
UJ
LU
o
S
"5
o
o
c S O ~
ll
«» -
u n
3 U
_ o
•" . .-
OS*
3 -O U
r f ?•
^Ml
S go
.«• x> O
• 3 lU
O Ui
c •
1 ^
• Z.
^ x;
" £ -^
o *>
I I
I s
5 ?
£5
o E
II
£ £
" - «
f ?f
•o«
■* n *
^ E >
Is S
-=^ o
o ^ p
t> £ £
E °-
■ O c c
-> 111 3 5
-Ul o s.
o • *-• o
E e UJ 5
£ E • •
c • £ —
E ~
II
T. S ^- a -
^ -^ o
o % <s
£ S ?
: • o
3 _
= ■
■5 E
i- 5
if
8|
0'='
UJ «
UJ -
£ o
»■«;•=•» =
~ £
1 re o »!
9i
a.
If
y E
a: S
f 1
— ™
1/1 c
^ °
? 1
^1
— o
3 O
> ^Z
■s S
II
UJ p .£
» e E
£ i/i V
— c <•
o 3 w
— 00
CO*-
503
(I Ul o
E Ul £
5 e-5
c — 0
£ £ >
0* 4) (B
> = u
a o «;
f- re V
£ a o «
E.St,
-o o. <• c
£ «
|£
E S
5 ^
m c
o ~
UJ
UJ
ol
« «
« fO
P
E o
if
E o
E o
• o. 5
I E E
s o o
o a»
■O 3
ll
• ■5
"is
" ° o
£^^
T> c !C
» B H
O - ti
£ o £
S c 2
E 5«!
n ^ c
_ e <•
io8
£ fZ
oj c
>. » a
o£ «.
o-x) y
E » t
c ■ •
0) TJ -C
E « E
»|2
•Is,
T3 E 0>
» E
n °> o
Ol " o>
• m TJ
£ c «
c "5 "
« Gb E
Q « <-
o
-:?_■£
c, tf) a
||£
CI £ (B
**^
c c •
!» O »
• f •
Q. « c
le -It o
- o €)
i£^E
c ? r
? c «
t (o £
?* s
c e i» _
<e £ tr ~
E " «> o
— O T3
* £ «; e
^ n — 3
O
c u>
01 -—
■C c
«< 3
• o
e — -o
C «> "O
3 U 0.
O c *"
o £ c
5 * ?
o s; s
U £ £
" t 8
£ £ »
re § ™
- a, <C
O c ii
c £ re
C S 5
re ? tfi o
a>& re —
* 5 i T3
o JC «> Si
— u 01 S
l« (D >^ (^
o>~> p re
E **» Q. T5
c £ S c
re (/) i: re
(/> 0) J£
CS T; lA I/)
E «- 2 -2
E3 ™
O E
Ul u
UJ —
_ re
• 2.
C «<
III
coo
S^ S.
• £ O
2 - UJ
t> E UJ
• £ e
re >. ;
£ E -D
(0 *f 0)
»1 * *
IB £ c
01 ... re
c re _c
S £ Ol
1?°
c «i
° I
2^
a. o
c z:
.» o.
» E
£ o
01 X
Q. re
c u
J3 ^^
15
» —
f E
a> p
T* ^
» 0
■c a
-o o>
ID O
£ o
^1
re ^
£ -o
a> 0)
€ J
re m
-> »
■C o c
Oj Ol ^
JOE
£?|
0/ E a
^ ^ 9:
•— u O
(0 o
li
I'
c re
If* .
(J o>
^ n
^ s
i 5
" o
1 ?
■^ o
I
2
«>
So
5 K
" o
— c
re o
o £
II
D c
o 5
re *-
C T, „
-^ O §
• — 2.
■^ - E
o
I-
I — ^
5 £
0 c
• ^ ft
01 O)
o *-
1<
re O
o> u
u re
i! t re Q.
5 ii
S S
0, o
Q, 0)
a. -
re 0)
0 Q.
^"
01 t-
re £
»> Z.
^ 5
o o
re ^
>■ S
0 E
«. £
m 01
ri
re c ii "D
O ~
a
£
365
o
O
UJ
ill
I
c
o
n
1
K
n €>
I IT
Q.
E
o
(J
9 E
tr I
3
«; O
0| u-
■A ~ S E »
g 5 £ « J3
9 - ^ • £
' "^ 8 S » "
'^ c i, ? ^ c
o « ° - <» -
O
111
UJ
I!
o a.
, "> C • T3 «
cc-s « ?• i;
« w O c « ~
£ • X> « TJ C
■;! t "D E "> _
? ^ ^ - ~ *
IIS.f||
® tfi ^ ** u a»
01 o 3 ci S _
i £ i c £ w
tr 4» ifl a>^ »
J o S £ •«. -5
^ttll?'! 5
c S •£ -o o o
n a> %i i/t -n _,
^ S E " £ *r>
5 <= si^ia
I'* ~ c iS 2 = f^
; ? ± ■« a?"
5 S ? - E^S o
? ^ s s « £ s
O fti "^ C CR 3 «
0-5 - U O £ T>
o ■^ U § S. fi ;
u 4- ™ o- _ o> i5
^ o i ^ 111 a o.
^ c. 4 >- u. <"< £
« o
c "
t3 E
°!
LU •
UJ «
I*
■S E
|5
Els
o »
o c
I s
o s
^ I
I
E
5 ■ 5
E
o
O
*1
o £
o. -
• £
= e £
IB a> ^
— Iff c
F O o
• » s
o.
E
o
o
O
LU
UJ
* «;
•a-
O w c
£ 0) CQ
£ > :>^ o
S O. fti
" *^ «\ n
"ill
* _
i E f
— OH
o o u!
>-"0 c
- -fe c o
* - - ■= O)
- • i .
O 3 «>
J= — O
o <0 *~
: (/)
« E
•> o
m
>- 2
«» c «
« £ * •
o "£
■o 5 o
ill
O o ■
^s
£e£
£ i» =
• ^ ::^
S c O E
O $
til u
O *-
«8
2 o
: o o
_™ — o
» 5 E
a £ $
E £ ?
•^ o V
» o
E Q.
* E
?*
c «
c > o
— to
o n 0)
» £ 5
in </■ o
_j ft' o
a o. a<
4 ^
•5 <»
o o
5 5 « g -5
^U£ 5
o£ £ g
OS|o
Ills
2 « o c
A "D A) C
•g » &
" 3 9 >•
S c "^
E o II
n 5
^ o
*- E f
1/. (- -^
£ £ < S £ C
S^ E .
- o o
£5 8
S 2 ■= S
o 2 2 o
c» > 3 t:
c .> »ft 3
S <» "
«S£S!
E a Tj ^
O ■" V> :
u m fl) IV
«i c P <=
- o ^ a>
jt n Qt Q.
o o — ^
« c «< 3
-'So."
o E = ">
■^ E = c
T) O C »|
Co: (T
O w 01 -13
Q- «^ — «
O u o 1/
2 s $ S
- £ * f
S O ? 5
" 1? ^ <->
r ? S "^-o
C •> c o ^
« a « ■" c:
E o -o S e
g.Eci o
"-^ 80- £
E-o S ^:S
g>? 2 o^
F ^ £ P -c
E £ ai ?
§ F E ° S
cU o 5"^
8 ?!, s'^
■^^ * -I-
O C tfi « C
i Oj ^ 0/ Oi
-"='!£ f
« 4, « g a
5 </: S « C
i/t o
i^ E
^£
gl
i o
to I/)
— «l
m •-
«' =
^ F
o fc
^5
■o E
$2
5 »
*- 3
C "=
S5
F »
O fO
Ci "^ £
•^ ■£ ^
S I c
£ * o
S 'S »>
tr — £
01 S ol
A O £
E i *
® O OI(J
E « C K
fo w o a>
« • f £
S s °^
I • 5 °
* C
1/1
(IS u
p
O UJ
UJ UJ
UJ(j
o c i5
c o a
n> oi E
tfl C o
0* X (J
5 >" ■=
^ flj 10
15 E
O (0
0) CL in
I -
«> O
•^ a.
o
re a>
o «) E
a
£
o -• -•
366
IT
lit
ol
11
U D Ui
O
5
i £
a> V
« ^ I
c re
s s I
(J C :
2 •
O o
U
tr
o. n
a £
re «.
I o o t ■'^
s • ~ -^
= -"2.
>.£-. <•
c o ° "5
c2 ?;.^
I tJ z
a> u o ?
^ c c t/t
o» o c •-
o r
s: 1- S o
-o re
re g
Si O
re
E
O 2
or
O" *- 01 5;
E 5
re a
£ 9.1
ai a. t
re
° re ~
n "o t~
'^ re 'o
«, "> e
^^ re
•c c - «,
£ 9 - "
E I ™ ?
re *" */> o
i|-s
5 £ -
I &5
re S' ^
a* ft)
" -^ r
— re o
g = tD
^4 "
0) re r>
^ "O O)
™ I?
«- I ?
M " I
c: re re
CD LU T?
C _ o
O 3
f *■£
l» =
1 ? »
« "-S
™ ._ o
3 3 re
Wo-)
' F r=
s «» S
' c ? ?
i 8 ■" »>
; 5 S o
1 O ~ flj
£i:
1/1 -o
Q. =
E 5
5 5^ «
Z re
< £
« ttl
«- " -^
re o ?
C
U.'
a £
3 o
C O
£ o
o Q
* c
i S I E »
I- o
>- a.
ttj I/"
■c ~ £
t ttl
tt) 4^ (/)
£ ^ ™
"F ?
c t «,
o o c
— i« re
2- «< E
I! a a'
re $ «
•i: „ tt)
CT re ■£
c ^
CTi2 re
C t/i ttJ
™ T - re
« • ?
g i ^£
•^5
ll^
a tt> tt>
re — ®
tt. Ol S
— — 1,
0, c >
u _ 01
c ^
tr
ttl w t
IP m tt,
- 4, ^
Q. 3 -
- t/l c
J "C £
«< ttl ;
S £ :'
° ?
o
I?
> ttl
O ttl
"- £
>< 1/1
S § §
re s «(
O ■"? 3
'^ f- 7
— ttl x;
TJ U O
»■ £ '
o re -
r > tt,
o -c £
— re
i' ^ ?
s
o
UJ o »■
U E £
o x; I
S -c "
Z C jt
Q. re -
E* "
!f F
o ttl f
u 2 S'
c I re
'to
ttl t o
E ,/. -5
■F "=- u
O ttl
^ re ^
™ U «.
c — Jt
re o ™
S « ^
" U ttl
■^■5 1
«, ».
a. 5
o u in
X *r 01
> - u>
> ttl 3
t/i X c
JC O
S >' -"
re ^ ^
£ t c
a|>£
- So.
°^ i
*- Q re
Et-
" s s
re E -
I/. ^ ttl
"O 1/1 ,c
c tt —
Jl IT O
— ttl
c -^
re o
c .^
re w
> "- ■
re xft
°^ i
Ol re re
£ 01 X
? *- Ol
^ ^ c
>■ ttl Ol
S£<-^
?5 ?
>-'^ >
c re £
Ol IT ,r>
£ re 5
ET3
0 Oj o
° •£ 'i
-? £ -t
01 (J
- Ol ■;
C i C
367
9
a
A
S
u
E
X
e
e
I
u
Xn 5 "
e = o
9- no
E &::
(0 ^ ^
i: ») l»
I" £
• c t
^S s
CD >
c •
S c
u u
^ ID
Mi
« c
<S £
c •
•5 "
>■ o
t) -5 >
£ TJ O
U £ ~
C O "^
~ 3 •
_>.TJ jC
2 o o
5 u ■=
• f 8 S o
illli
E »i i.3
I
<
O
;£ o s ».
€> ^ O
2 £ c
»&. c ^
2 e 5 2
~ ■ 2 o
• o o •-
2 = s o
£ > S =
~ « «> £
llll
• > ^ £
3 £ «> C
• « £
2z E E
3 • s a
• S
2 •
ffi
o
p
?^ E •
a
e «
»%
I ?
<
e Q
I 5
o «,
o =
E {
c 2
e J »
o»|
— e c
o x: ti
* ° 1
£ o o
n "^ Q.
«l c <
A. O •_
o <-> o
3 t> t,
m £ 9
ai o
E Z
E 0.
O' T3
q; re
U
re
^ T3
o =
o re
I/I t
= E
c o
S »
S c
81
o-c
o o
a o
t/> i/i
? =
c 2
re (/I
6 *
a.?
10 > u
E s 5
c u
«> o
o>
I C > u
_ _ c
>- re S o
= 3 cnc
C IS 01 <
f c - _
5 3 « *
Q. w c c
a « o c
■O $ 0) ;■
re o 3 »•
£ £ 70.
«> _
2 3 = S «.
m o 3 > g
lilil
!S • &S 2
c M o = £
• - £ £ o
E !S t ^ S
Sit- to'
« c i §^r
re 9iS p £
E re $ i c
£ I " I
Is &*
• « • •
— * a> «
a -^ »"•=
" •= o
■S w ■= O
Elffl
£^|E
</ c « a
•o re o («
£: £ £ 5
Q- 2
• o
^E
= «:
S Sa£c=
£ o
■^ ft
«, o
•- «
o £
c O
^ o.
t «
O «
c £
9 •«
■R £
S c
o- o
*l
£ t>
o
« <
• o
£ °
ti ;
Q. ^
o 2
*" 3
E y
•=3 CD
E 1
s 5
368
c
I
S
I
IE
a
'S
o
?«l-l
III
HI
r • s
2-° =
S fo o-
3a> c
SS 8
^ S •
> o i
|-«
• s«
0 S I
gf I
^^!
811
1 s 2
s 3 5
» « g
(T a.£
« •> ;^
05s
» $ a
£ 5> S!
Q
•^ C
E S I •
I
It d
£«
• 3
_ •
c u
> o
C tt
9-9
t
2 S
»>
3 O
ffi c
«
£ (A
J «
«l ^
2 i5
t> 3
o r
< re
its
> E S «
» e • »
I — £ "
^|1
• o S
IS I
^f -
« « *
I j °
•0 ~ •
*>^ ^
£ c (/)
"* »_
- O t)
o» »_ o
C A C
•6£ -S
a? 8
S "> o
C T) "
5 SS
* ■» »
Its
CSS
■2 S »
o O 3
° :;; E
« O c
R o o
Q. O u
^ > £
• c c
•c Z o
- w o
£ •?
So*"
CSQ.
5.<3 O
^££
$ 3<«,
g oy
€» £ ^~
D 5 0:
^ » ^ P ~
5 E • * S
ir - €> -
o'S ^
o » -o
S = =
2 3 J
S. £ >■
« ** €>
5»
e £
ii
J -eg
• s ■•
S £ y
• at
■^ 3 s
tf> le s
^11
a£ 5
o. * p
•" is £
■» " IB
n • '
— o c
10 O O
re g'i
r>£ o O
<» • ^
<« J iJ
s p 5
u o c
^?^
a> £ e
u 2 "
c « c
n «i re
> S >
= » =
» « •"
i» » jg
■" • £
a. "» J
j« » *
fS^
ui
0»-D 5
"D -C -„
g" c >
S re LU
• «Z
C (A Q)
E S S
re o c
>< S o
• "^^ 3
C = T>
5 S S
= ? •
a,Si Si
*> - a
00
369
»
o
s %
o I
I
a ^
E 5
o t.
u tr
z
2
3
O
C
O
a
E
o
c
3
O
•5 5t
Q. c =
= s •■
n a. «
O E u
* i °
^1^
= -19
o
» »-
E u e
T) c >
5 2"
0*0
CI % o u
a. «> 5 o
9 S C Q
e *" "5 £
* o
s; ^
a, »
- c 5 (»
i.» e ?
? (5 t £
so cS
X o>
_ -o
'Co
U
(-
(T
c
>
•
«> «-
9 n
«i S
o
£ £ *
«> - o
o c -
5 ^ S
^ E E
«■. - -e •^
* o c ^,
£ tf. 5 o.,,
£ 3 = C U
?"^ I s I
u o c re S
cr «>
£ *
J? =
e $
IB *
» -o
o *
o i
w
u
« * £
e£ ?
<*S
c • •
8 • ■
W £ £
t- * •
K • £
c o —
o ■= £
« p *
ill
c 8 £
£ « w
S|S
0) >
fa?
( tfi V
c «, (,
2|
« £
• £
u ^
5 c o
« 9 o
-•f
O 3 P
£ f «
if S
i S g
o 2 •
Si?
- 1 *
ill
e c « "
3 £ S
t: — Q.
o * _
a. a. K
c 5
Si
O c
Si • «
^r *C ni re _c ^
E W
If
x: c
c o
9 ■"
SS
•|
89
u c
ai
c ■ —
oO
z. •
il
C A
.A 9
< a
• S • '
C (, s
O to S m
•g c 8 e
S " c »
sis S-
i o • °^.
i • 9 -B
c ^ 5 •
*> « O -n
■ • « i
«> C t- If
S* O _ t
3 c w £
ffl ft 0 $
r^- E
C ft) o
c c
il
o i
u ^
<• ^
w ft
^ ft
0 2
c c
9 ^
1 ft
* o S: 3 ^
« S ft ^ ft
O C -. ~
i E ^ c
» c i o
Ob u £ u
ft
•- o
O ft
»—
IT ft
t 3
o S
£ ft ft
C 3 3
r\ o- 1^
^ E E
O o o
^ U (J
(r ft
ft ~
£ o
E £
S S ft
— So
i <• E
E j£ E
2 " o
o « _
C . 3
5 S o
S ft a
oi oi a
£ £ ^
— ■5. ft
°ts
>- " O
■c ft S
ft ft ft
SV (J u
ft o "*
'■Oft
ft >-•=
y ft
ft £ 01
*:'
S 9 3,
■O ft, jj
« c o
ft (C ^
3 ft ft
- ~ 3
Xi rr cr
ft t
o: c
O
370
I-
n X
Joe
E S 2
o o «
o o a
a
E
o
u
£
I
c
o
c
I?
eS
8?
• !•
^£
mo
£ o
c —
^ S
So
£ a
o c
= •
o
as? 5
«>°£ ^
• • o o
3£«»£-
• S • -a
• »« g
S£o c
s J? "
o " £ x:
• * ? ^
«- 9 n ^ B
o • • " -
c
"° • • ?«#
S g E I S o E
- ' O • < u 5
■So?*»c»5«)»^C3uE£
• Q.P
-I
£J ••
c ■£ £
^ S «.?
« -° ? •
5 » o •
"O £ 5 £
o 3 "S >.
So
• ^ S£ •£
a -So
c •
5 " E I I
£•5^152
E S -^ * ex: o
" S 2 • 5 *" "
2r-z
Q. « -^ =
«
I £
2£
Q. c
£
o
J» 4 £
u -5 ** >.
c o o •
© J3 z! £
« ■ ^
£ T) «»
£ K
>■£
X ^ jc Q) p x: XI
S2S = «"»Z^1
© n
?i
O
-* -. * z ■
\\n-
> E °
«, U <» (5 .
i ?£ si
: £ o o o
O Q. X3 "^ 3 £ £
lilUli
t cS i ? s °
E • TJ 8 - » <->
£ 9 (D n c ■=
** c» aa£ «) ™ «
•5 ?« !» E «■£
S t C >. 3 XI ^
«> C m ^-E O^ C -S
sEcSEY'^c
? Si? $ S-c c a
II III Is s
II
:? &
a T>
— OB
« •
£ •
c £
c o
Eg
9» E
■ >.
If
^£
« o
ii
£l
l/> (A
o
_ »
■^ •
" c
9 C
TJ •
C £
5 ^ O
e " *
3 • ^
£ € ?
9 ^ F
5?
• o
I -
> (I
c •
- £
5 *
? 5.
• £
£ >-
• TJ
■= «|
*l
m 1
• E §>
S^i
E E£
o <• ?>
of o
III
ill
o> c ,.
3 t •
< O >
2 c E
w «> «,
-t£ oax3
' T5 X3 =
I 3 « J
^ o m
o> »i H
C 1(1 ^
= 3 a,
n n c
«> o ^
■^ ^ E
«, CD ra
£^2
^ I"
— » c
01 •^ n
<=■ 41 ?
O ? fc
" '^ ~
C9
CD «, r s
o • c "=
" c 2 ?
E » IS
c t/t c v>
E "
O 3 i «>
»> t C C
TJ t 3
5 ^^
1 e £■
|£?
1 g!E
2 5 •
ID ■-' 11
E£ «^
10
£ w •- o
o£g£
f S ^ '
$ "s •
" £ <• «
^^* i
u,<n «i o
? £ £ '
S£ E -
«i - •- «i
0 >» T- Ul
°l :• ?
01 oj ■?
cS E 5
"2 E £
\^°^%
^ *' ? 4^
4* I/) Of O)
X O = c
»- C CT t
c 3
1^
f c
£ «
TJ -J
Is
I!
<• 5 o S
3 J -■«
E • <j
£ » T,
5 e|
• £ ?
• »r 2
g O 01
« S E
° Is
S" «
01 01
c 2 c
™ f! 4
■= -o J-J5
£ £ >
«> P TJ
= « "
« «; If
-> 2 Oi
-O 0/ O-
c •£ o
>- o
f> *
(A O
a* ^
c •
!l
a £
o y
"° *
0 >
oS
E •>
1 8
0 •
* -
■d£
? i
•I c
TJ
" *> !«
c £ 01
o >, o
~ 2
Q.
-■52
CD $ a
£feS
» o
c c
• £
£ ? - i£ E
Z 5
o -
Ev
ID
O
01
o
M
O T3
If ^
3 2 5»
» ° 0)
Sl£
"f E
5 I S
^ I'
S -> •
^ g °
w -o
01 4> •>
u £ "5
- OJ I
c i
See
2 5 S S
■^ o *
^ Q. £
£ 3 S
E o XI
E-g i
2 «; £
a, u CT
? re 3
Q ^
371
o
«
s
u
I
c
o
3
372
I I
i
O
« U • S TJ
£ g
= • 3
(S w lA
*- l/> ®
C 3 •-
e o £
• S i3
^ -o £
? 'S *
8l|
^ c •
■o -S 5 a
10 CO IB ~>
9=28
c c ti
m g o r
5 o ^ c ^
o £ o o
a> « ■— n
I /
lA
n >. .
o
u) S* *o
«! - E
3 «
=: a«(j
" n £ *
™ "O ^ £
(l> c ^--s
c -o - -^
2 1
u
«
O
^ S: *- O O
- - c > c
c J 5
§1 ^
i I- = =
> _ <o c
) £ c o
) o o o
: c -o °
- £ = i
If Se
: S S o
: «, ™ "
c = "
o 5 o
-- e t)
' « » „
07*
£ - -5
c o.
«i "
e £
c S =
c s^ s
= I c
„ - c -c
» t5 - "
•) 9 c ~
S Q. O "
- ali
■g.-f »
" « JC £
o o - e
— • c e
« « S o
«1 ^ » o
t- S o c
Is o °
3 " $ ■"
O = ° «
8s§|
* = 6 >^
c O O (0
3 O i XI
* a> IB
I •*
re — _^
"So
e o <o
^ c ->
00 u -
C <0 >.
S e g
■D • £
■COS
? C B
(0 o
o
«l
il
II
C IB
10 o
-> £
S E
S o
CD <"
5 S
V re
£ 5
e "- •- !i
iB<n "g
" • ™
£ t- 3
C IB E
re c t
core
i§^
1^1
<A O Ob
0) " t>
JZ 9) ^
c E »
— <• •)
t; •« t
re e <o
i £ 5
e E o
o o i
• o OT
re "2 -
£ IB 0.
re 0) w
0^ ~ 4>
u «>
II
£ 1
01 S
O -C
0 O
Q. C
» 9
5 w
1 «'
5i £
Oft "D
C c
T3 "
» E
-I
g E
re 3
2. "
o £
c *^ .
tf> <
S "5
£ re
I- u>
l|
o re
S o
s 5
|e
0 c
9 >/» «,
iS o £
o £ S
-D 4)
(9 U)
^ C
So
C ^ T3
E • O
Si £ o
2 c S
• o ;
|«»
^ |3 c
i- o
5 -o
"O —
0)
c c
51
a -
£ o
IB
3 C
T) 3
5 c 3 c '^ 3
e
X £
5>c
IB re
• c
% s
|S
E £
?^
a> o
£ Q-
c S
I?
,8
re o
If
II
9 lA
E E
IB 4t
? *
i^
Q. C
— (0
n t>
— o
O 3
J?
.0 g
■ IB -
re IB
■c »
.J. IB
re IB
rtl
i.o S
£ ■!?) -^
$ * !5
?«■;;
££ £
«! S c
0 re ■§
E(/) >
- Q- ?^
a> -^ *
— T3 5
C C C
1 " •
— «> =
o c ti
c re £
* £ *
?£ 3
re Q. o
• r E
o i> £
g S- IB
tt £ T3
Fie
e t £
— ©
S «» re
IB O ^
re a> o
Hi " *
O 3 ^
3 or o
E 2 S
S ^-*
a 0} u
S £ "
£ « —
&* I
IB e ^
■c£ *
c — «
-c ? £
I CTU
Sll
>» o g
-I-
Els
X IB re
S ™^
S tr
— re £
CO.*
E * E
E o F
<» a 5
X re re
•- e £
? 5
•^ £ e "
5 S - *
° s
i iZ
■D -o ^ c
re 5 IB c
c e g J
Sg 8-5
f llo
? i ! »
-C XI c -g
IB o E •>
re
T3
0
u
D
*
^
"j
re
■0
0
re
1
re
6
£
5
(A
i
0
0
c
0
0
*0
E
C
3
»
re
«>
u
^
0;
£
c
Oj
€>
* £ i
5 = =
IB > J
£ g O
a> a> —
f f ?
f U •" ;„
_ (r " 3
^ "- X I/*
s * •- i?
re ^ 0;
£ t: "o K
IB "O > O
o E S o
5| So
i-l ?£
O O- *> a
0 »-°£
o£| o
PI
2 F o
y o £ "»
> fe c re
o=''8 *
il !!£
i E o *
* C 4) IB
1 f C£
^ 00 e
c J re "
" e * *
* > > £
y E "K *
5 i " -c
o s
373
n
Ol I
E
■
a
I
c
o
IS
7d
'S
K
e
E
w
w
O «>
u. <r
ol •R
S] ™
CO' »
Ol (T
I
C5
< e a>
5o£g
(0^ -^
8 e 8 I I
w fi « • S
O ti) " " c
c o c £ "
• • > S
W » £ |(E
*- c »i
0 5t>£ I
5 I 3 ° -C
^ £ 0) S> C
° So I e
• E « * £
£ c 0. * c
• " » t I
<?££€-
E T. -^ 2 o
■o » o «< 3
• " $^ o
-n ts > •- *
1 o ? Sf
1" ^ El
!°^|^"
o £ > o 5 '-
I t c " !5 e ^
• Q. (0 E o ■£ o
S< o>o fc^
son 3 T!
TO O » y 5 U
I- ■
e
iB
c
S • •
-- is-
"» i 2 m p
o „
II
c
^ fi 5
•» t^ s •
- a." £
£ i •
IS "
t" t» _
= 11
•£f
s • ^ s c y
g|Bo 2-S
> o c I- £ a
O S si ?£
f-l|il
•c • ~ o -r o
■ Z ^ Q. S «»■
5i^SE|,5
^ >; • • r o V
• • X • o * S
£ E 8£ 5£ «
lliilli
•- g " o 5 <o -
o c g £ » 8 5
— OC « Q- — «> Q.
c
- o
■o —
•S S c»
^ O c
t>
i
0»>€>€>-*C-5= S£
^ (ft «^ r- "■ _ Z«
5 If
° S
• "' £ °- -D r
IB C k 1 r* I)
g-pc^asiFT-s^
" = '^ O m C
U. CD O -
u- *^ u n «> u
•«, <^ 'E. o e
S m — -c ft
■S " "o — i)
-■ fc "> " 2
O K 01 -o o
SaSgesEg
= w y »- 3 o
llg^S^tE^t
X e — c
S ?, « S * S E - -
- 2 Q. c o — !K "• «i
» > Q. c o — »
iloSls^
■ o S
a)££mQ.Egc-^,
■p55;=<»o- = jTSi«
o *
• £",*"= o 5
I- C S (B t C O
QT n Ol o o n c
S «> ¥ i« 2 _
— *- w w r; 4/)
SS£
3 «* -B ^
/-^ ii» i C C
"■OS.
K?^=£5ssr^Qt^E
fl5?Ea£«£5c:7
i5 i« >- o
o 5
a
a
374
£
til
I/)
5 e
S E
I K
o
a S -c
l«5
^ »
o -o « at
5 6
U ~
" S
t> O
C/) T3
re E
-I o
in ^
c I-
b (J
o n
o£
re Q^
c o>
o S
■=1 5 1/1
< t
< t
e c «
tn C c
W C :^
(J (0 re
» s «
■o re "D
111
S o c
S w e
Q. • c
re t _
• " I
^ II) 2
"is
a I tB
E - re
0 ift -c
" £ *"
„ O 10
" s ?
r- re ^
J, U -D
S re-S
re oj £
■c tf) I/)
- O JO
1 5 ?
£ lA o
IT 3 c
to t/l 3
£5
= c
re s
t - «, $
CL J re u
g *-"
o I- ^ . — .
r o o «
8 £<" 8
S 5 • ■*
• •> i £
J O - re
C Iff — m
» TJ >. >
.- C ^ O
O O ^ <fl
* S- y £
5 $ « o
TJ
IS
lis
•• ?
nil
« tJ o §^
■e 5 c 10
? a?s
re S|i^
e := t ^
e re ?£
■P -c. 2 .0;
n re
o> £ a>
OS o e
° Ir
£2 e
a> c >
0) » >
= "?
SIS'
» " s
£ o c
j^ c «)
tt* .A 0*
° " «
^ « 5
4> tr -ac
? ^ u
E I?
u t/i t _
01 m 5 3
I/I re ^ in
^ " s
• c J i=
■a Ji o
u) ti = £
■^ 5;
° I
1/t
•a ^ 6
3 ^ :z: t»
■D * 41 5
re 5-^ u
5 ^ a <•
«> I/)
re 3 75
-core-,
?£ m ■o
> ♦* re r
J? co-c 5
^ E < «,
111*
e5w^
S - «^
a3f ?
■S - 5
2 - ?'
>« r c re
£ 1 2 t^
r — E c
o Q-_ i?
£ " i« *
-5 re
S S
o «
£ c
_ re
3 E
5 ."
< re
— D
01 c
01 tr
Q. »
e £
o
U _
'>^ 0.
5 E
£ "
0) re
C 0> 01
1/1 *-
a oj 01 £
3 ^ > 5
m t- o s
E
o
,/ 0. If
ifl o >-
!< ^
3 ^ O
O Oi li:
" £ o
o O <
c 0) o>
C £ £
0) a
375
o
o
a.
E
o
o
re
X
a
P •
^ E C c "g c
* ■" J? tr c
5 -> "- i o. -6 ».
1 "» ". E ? S S
» e i» o t'r i»
£ O c t) rt fi •-
P 3 f> ^ O •- o
• • £: 3
£ £ e «
,-»• S
S — - —
V « Office
• S • a •
c E c c °-
£ « » c £
?|2 S E • fi
s c S - * €> S
O i= -S
v •* o *- ^ _
S ^ '^ o a. •
« fl) T^ ~^ c o
ti) <B
c "• >■
" gS I E
S o = * ~
O
^ VJ ^^ *
• e • g o
«> • t ° •> "5
«' 3 S o O ■?
.£S2
0>€ C 3 ~ = 5
- "- o »; £
c O
■ °« s I a.
9
a,
"I
01
O
^ 2 Q-a 8 J, =
* X. t 7 " $ =
■£ 5 — o> 5 Z
^ - O 01 "^ c
»y F^ 0, ? s
Sir ? 5 S I 5.
? «- ^ * " f o
S Sf
S O tr L/ ^
■SB • 52
o < o S •
2 5 c „ -o
■o £ o a ■o
s^ " i !
5| • ?g
» i B « -
•! « c we
• * $- °
!£»««£
r 5, f 5 9
o _ « 5. 3
* «- c e :€
c o •- t
0 O 2i <A o
■r « I 2 Q
*« O) tt> ^
£*■"&!«
01 n 2 ?
EO£ 3 $
0, Jr 3 § il
?; E
c
5 wC
lilflll
• 2.SO 2 I o
o • obO
V ? o u-
Is,
I <« z
</> <
O —
c O
0>
3
U
T3
n
g i; c
) ^ O tt £
£ £ —
« o o> •= ■= e JJ
£a5* E S"
&|«l£iB-5
•o — 2
* * ? °--s-
« ^ u. u
0.-0 c .9
o E £ o
E
o fv
i' If o
>.8 a o £ ir
1 S t' z * £ .«
illsijl-
II Sis ill
p-OOyjJ^J 01
t- 5..0 liJ «, $ O w
J»9-^lu2«>0)'S:
= Eoia)5ȣ
c(jSnc-=Tj£
S»3(n-g>-y
3 C O O ■ -t £ Q.
o2§0(ogo-5rS
01
IT
ai
01
a
01 o
0.01
2 •*=
«i
- ?5 !•?■■
t» o
o 5 S I o
n tf) o o>
= a>(J
" w
01
«o^.'"ij'" »"i ?y
5 " o|^ g S * o
E>Q.^"-5.>«ir
<-:=reO>Q:reSs
- o
Oi n
o ->
t T3
O C
U «
►:: o<
q: ^
(J m
Q £
§1
^ c
Si
o S
•= to
Oi X
re 3
O
01 Oi
£ *■ Ol
— 01 o c
^ J? Ob f
2 o J <• J-
0-— « E o-
E?f - 5
O » "- 01 -rj
« 3 = « >« 5
■£^"?i|
~r -c -.cog
- — 01 « o •"
«i£ > 01 '2
0 o c E ; S
if E e of
^ ? ^ • «= ii
X c **! XJ u>
« £ 01 S S jK
01 *: £ x: ^ »
tf> .C 01 VI 01 «■
£^ £ E jf
E E = - " S
X o > * £ *-
01 o « 2 t^ e
S • IT = <« -^
§££ S2S
t ° ™S J jr
» > £ f «i £
Oj „ 01 o ^
» E S 3 s
\
376
o
Ol
E
«
I
c
o
5
H
I
c
o
n
E
o
o
o *>
15
- *
Si
X:
o
O
lu
UJ
o
? o8
~ "^ •»
O -O 3
— €> O
"" O >
i • S
c c a.
o
* c 3
J S 9
o « 2
c o S
s 3 a
Sen •
• ^ o
r"8
o 9
•at- IB
» ££
S| S
2 E e
o
' n
1 -
51 •?
a -1
5 £ s
2. ^ -c
? •) 3
c j: in
o c »l
— o JJ
? §• •>
!» T> •
i/i n £
— •> ■—
£ n c
« J3 «
Q. « U
E 1 Ml
o Ir
lU o =
> s
E * •
• T> £
£ *> ti
§-i
w E o 5
•S fi !• E
§ ?1S
" 111
€> C S
ly s
o
9 O • (■ lA
y • £ ■= ■£
u p
II
= S •
S||
« ^ 'o
a; lA a>
g 5 E
? "^ tfi
*z a> '41
^ « 0 5. «fl —
«B » y
« o. • £ ^ c
?. -, o o _ v;
t) c
= T
»- o
V V c *- ■= ^
€> o • E S T>
£i5 o E 2 E
I
« o
» « 2 r
X--C _ o
o — ^ t
E E * *
• O • £
P " S. c
»- •> o ~
0^ ■6 0. u)
~ i/>
_ «
o ? 2 S
n
U
(r
«— T) Q^ w
• C C in
g 9 fc IS
^ b w —
J2 £ •"
S^ *
y • E
t O 2
r. •) <»
o £ S
|e E
<" « i/j
o E "S
* -S »:
■= 9 o in
* ^- S
f = 5 J
Jt o re
u = a> ^
re re -^ —
-5 > t— tn
5 ^ ? o -o
™ 2 ^ a e »-£
• 01 t e ^ ^ ^
us £ o S •= E
iS « w » c a> o
^ P o ~> » c o
(/>*-— T3 ? =^ *^
O «» t C 1? " "
S£i g 5,J«
t E E re " e •>
° 5 E £ S 0£
5 °^ S 5 S.5
" S ■= ? S.'S 3
5 tti _ 5
Its ? I
i >* I- I °£
S * 5 £ 5 §£
c «> e i» V g u
»E o r "S »-°
CE E i E ? s'S
0) T3 o re c 2 «
£ re -t: X o — i
V- £ £ 4» o y "c
s eo I
C ^ lA
• £ O F
c S « £
"• c a ^
■» r; = °
^ « I £
0 S " S
*- in * ?
"=■ £-6 °
|?^£
O T3 "S >■
E e <» -o
o >» «, u
■f ~ 5 re
$ Bm c
o n
* o
x: o
Z. *>
o -c
— OT
1^
*> S
O ™
3 -^
o Xb
tl
o
>—
>. t re
* E £
a> o
— o U
o q:
3 ■=
9 "»
o» I-
< re
□: re tl
re tn •*
III
0) o ^
3 a «'
9 E ^
a 01 £
« * ^
~ « o
111
§■£ c
I o o
W c £
is Q. n
c F «=
E E <»
§5 E
I c ™
$ «> i
Co-'
o t •-
U 01 cc
^ o>
o A
«J5
0 *
SI
01 o
J. 3 £r
18
|5
E _
9 0
« •^ — eg
re ere
S S •=* •>
tl & u> 0) -•"
o>™ 3 - u
E » O •" (5
£ i 5 £ <
• y 5 3 01
o » t E >-
3 o. e £ t —
" -c !; E F
-sill-
re c £0 c»(_) in
S c E «)< >.
litlsl
"- S E c «> >
to D w - y ?
O.D 3 jȣ g
S f ' » E =
» «> O O o ffi
« E y o
9 o
e ? ? £
E 0^ -^ =
_S - in «)
5 £ o £
0, o £ o<
~ u V 7 w 01
n <
re o
•> o
> "^
£ Vi
u £
S 3
, er
0> 0)
CD £
s I ■§ I i I
c 0* o> 0* ? —
C £ t ■£ >- S
re «>
Q 5
377
IB
a.
c
i
o
a
E
o
O
e
o
o
E
<
O
LLI
5 <"
_ !»
c C
n d
is
I?
f I
' S
• 2
3 T^
III O
> »
rl
IS'
•
o a
> ^
S -S
I " a
*E-
a> o
e 2
s >-
JC c
^•5
O «> o
J o
£ 03 5
■o E
c o
O T3
4'
- - -s •=
c
O
I
jr •= « ^
^^1
•lis
U » c
• ^ r:
£if c
«< K t
5 ■" o
£ m •-
« O £
5 $?
Ill
ill
» ? 8
E • c
ȣ J
|S|
= ll
£ « <^
jE 5 o
C C O'
TO >. a-
1 c ■?
■52
t «
ee e
'■5 e
o <»> c
w a> =•
|s|
o 3 «
t»c c
E p
s|!
Ill
ess
o *" ■
£(D
n
"s
* c
f 2
I 8 i ?
E «
- "S
c o
« •
5 «
,1
o o
o 2 <^
Ego
££ B
l»i
S c —
* ■§ S
£ c e
K C
0/ A
t ft tf)
Is?
%2 ?
3 e
F 0.
- 3
2£
c »
C <D
2 -^
01 —
? 0
5 £
«> «
S»
-' 0
•o —
*> 2.
JS 1 -D
- E c^
£ ? «
*^ ft
= " ft - S X
at r= A O A s
• •
5 ^ -
III
c -> ^
«> TJ —
3|1
C = c
300
», C 10
S :; *
m S O-
il »
Is §
— "* Q.
a>4^ «
a> ^ £
-So,
c o "
» (/> o
° £ •«
£ P I"
"X o "
" £ "
c< w tl
O X u
n o n
= £ " _
f; '^ £ £
1 i-O o>
^ jc ^-^ rf(
•= c o
■" i« ift O
Ills
ml
o _
£ C ft
1^
§ 5 c
^ «J <»
meg
l|o
o go:
" ° *
0:
= •- r» <*
c »
<s o
1 o.
e?
S 1- £ c »
E S
85
2 tt
o j«
tf) n
• E
" s -
c * c
a<
«>
c
£
a.
CO
Oj
€>
If)
JC
0)
B
C
0
tf>
c
8
0
•0
Oi
c
8
X
—
tfi
c
ffi
0
5
£
4r
£
0
%i
Qcr
«i o c
^ I— Ml
|2|
•» = X
— * o
« " ui
t in uj
c 5 0-
* £f
u Of o
<9 3 c
— > a *c
«' £ .
o _ ■
" l_
£ o »
? o
C IS
n ft ft
So.
E (fi
fe2
E *»
oS
: Lu i»
: >. a>
. (0 c
; ■o -6
I ft c
;£ £
ft ^ If) 7r »
^ n ft i: o
a c ' c 3
* o JS a ^
lit
m
^%°
111
o S ^
" E S
So g
£|^
• • -
E s|
a. u °
'^ • ft
£ 2 £
"5 ?
« Q. 2
E E S
O 8 S
5 UJ ■S
>— ft c
R £ ■"
« 2 ■=
^-o «'
''if;
i I Si
c 4 3
5-
= ft
j£
• «>
§£
!2-o
H£
ft —
u >>
ft -c
- «
«- £ 5
•c « »
? c *
5 8 ^
o •> o
tl 5 »
tf o ^
* I S
<• ft ^
£■51
o
ID
(J
a
u
^^
ft ft
0 a
ft w
w •
>. 3
ir
n o
ft u
(^ ft
2f
tf> £
4 §
1 £
ID C ^
C O lA
3^3
o « o
O "5 a
UJ ^ o
1 = 1
£?I
= E E
15 5
f •§!
o »r t
<)5
ft
o.
ft
o
c E
O sr
U <
c
378
I
t> o E
t 52
E 2 "
o • •>
a.
E
6
c
2
I o
nl c
E
o
O
E
Q.
E
o
U
IT
o
U
o E
c o
c u
(A C
•d£
< -s
£ ^
V —
O 5
O E
£ »
o£
C •
m «.
c o
i S
C IB A
• • »
If 5
= S -
lis
«« • »
E £ •
ill
Pi
O 3 S
*" (0 O
T3 O Q.
^ P^
3 £ o
fs.
— o <•
£ "D <■ o
ell?
e «> * ^
• 3
ii
- 2"-*
i 8 s
h- m E
• 7 c
'£ ~ "
E °-0
£ 9 "So
^ o ^ 3 ^
£ o o o 2
- o» •
• 9 ^
|£ ^
t* 8
^ Q. W
P UJ
5 5 »o
o> S E o
e ^ 9 -K
« i V ,"-,
^ ^ m « o •^
—
a.
u
a
i o
CD O
^ «
E « 5
111
* 8 *
J_ flJ IT
o c ?
« o £
a- 1
,S5
ai -n IB
<p n O
_ 3 «B
5 2''
- § S
>. tf) 3
Q. to ^ «
c '^ 5 c
= »* *"
^ 2. « «
» -
— c « »->
re 3 c w
t= o ?, t:
o — »• re
a "' "" ti
»> 5 -S -^
C • O o
•- r- "' dJ
5« ^ o
? £ £ S
Us
E •» "S
* «i >-
tit
||s
is.
§•1
e»S o
III
o re >;
c ~ 1)
re c
o <^ "
E "> o •
^ "" 3
re 10 a
V o E E
O _ t) o
2 e ^ u
(D £re^
in 3 c £
■i(S es
• w e c
" o a -
U c ■g re
O • «'
<<« g£
•I |£
5-§,
-o <»
S- *>
o >
Q. »
!^
■o _
o *
u c
3 S
So
m
re »
o £
C l»
II
Is
ii
ai re
> ->
c " «!
" c ~
^ ™ ©
?o o
* 3^£
5 ?»
t - c
3 ■2-5
Q. re ^
3 *-
O -o
re
IT C
ri
Q re
* S c
|ii
Q. in d
't.4£
£ E o
lA
5?
c o
< S in £ o>
< £
t, o
£u
o Q
fie™
0) £ _
<.) in 0,
3 re >
_ £ o
ai-c ■=
• $ o
*- — "^
2 o s
— ^ «
m re £
£ "5 o
If?
a> tn >
EO) re
3 i
'£ "^ •
is Ol £
in c in
?" o
S • -
• 01 o
of*
«! E =
• - »
o E e
ra o o
5 re
T3 in 3
!C ? o
£ _ re
r; c in
3 «> "
o E 8;
" S. "
X ™ —
O c
^ 3 o
C c c
•CO
o —
o re $
Irl
II?
5*5
Z >- tr
.ere
o ^ a
Ol*" re
E c in
T) o re
Is s
t« C 3
t ra n
^ ? •
•) o -'-
•* - «
o w ?
£ -J *
t^ (N O
'^ S i
° ?■ 1
si?
O) C u
£.•6 "
c re re
o o> i,
O e w
4 re £
i i *
^ r^ ^
h- o< r.
* ^
£ S<
£ EO
^ o u.
c s v>
l« *
— So
$ £-5
0» fQ
c ^
o
■go ^
n «> n
c £ *
E re'
5 E
c o
el
o e
E £
1^
9 "
m 3
o e
gl
re S
rllf
^ 5 e c
2 £ o c
P c tr re
> C — a,
O O £ S
re = - ™
>.£■"' -c
e-E • o
^ ~ in jc
I- e * »
JC 3 *
e s
a
CT.
379
n
t
a.
6
o
(J
Q.
E
o
o
o
I
o
o
a.
6
o
O
5
u
ill
■ a.»
§ a £
tf* (V in
!! E E
Cms
re g" o
? ||
E „ J
O c -o
<D fa
e o> «
£ • E e
o •" 5 *
is ot
» a E S
E ? 1|
•= Q o 'o
II
II
• 2i
oi X Q
o a>
S £
0> Q.
11
2 IS C Id
E — a c
O ll> n O
" E t; ■=
> « s g
ft 5> C ■«
p o re £
o £ tt •
= |S|
E of 1
re " c "
S; o e E
u >.0 re
|lf I
*!=£
n, n oj o.
7 ^ £ E
>. C r O
IT re i: o
(D C
w g
-> s
Q. re
re -c
c s
U T3
£ re
** o>
a< u
re =
'CD
4/1 »
£|
O O'
! s-
O 3.
£ E
• •= —
y 5 c
CO-
f f "S
i • -
S s !
S «i e
c a ®
£ > •
is'"
gi §
o 3 (n
*— re c
IT (o re
• » £
£ o 9
S E £
tr o o>
it S
$ £>-^
jc 3 fc
o»^ re
9 re =
I/) a> >
§ A u
I c »
J- « 5
» o 2
m O (A
— ** c
o « a
OS"
ft*
o jo -5
"> o -^
Si E g
Us
£ re J
J «, I-
o? £
O i» 2
* $ E
flj re o
p • ^
0 re a«
»> . 3
— 4) CD
i» tr —
01 2 o
-So
'!■§
= o ».
ffi i? £
O O £ E •£
o
E
O O
4A Qt
■60
0) o
£ JS
O —
re CI
S 2
"1^
o c>
c 3
CI tfl OJ
re -e o
$ o 5
C t" o
3 0; £
$ "
?£ E £■
9 o i
£ - >
« c o
J » 01
- E -o
O C> Cl
^ <" c
§-l
1^ "
|s.|
•o g, re
; ™ E X
O a>
■oaS
s 5 £
5i^
ego
re -o r
£0.0
0/ 2 "
Oft
c >- 2:
■o E =
S E
1^
o >>
« •»
It
|8
re ^
Ie
E 5
0-
I 5 ./I
»gs
•- «/ a>
c _ — ■
3 re c '
Ere >
_ £ Ci ■
8- «.
i. c "
O 01 c
c £ c
= 1^
OS*"
iS V Oi
fl) ^ t '
E re o
- o> o
o * ■=
c T, re
— i/>
c E
o —
S c
c =
e|-
3 S: ift
y ^ S
i|8
u o ^
_^ Of tX)
a, ■"
If?
Ci r; -5 = re
tfi 5 re re r
Z. = c
fc c P
*£E
m c -
c re
S »>
o e V
re 3 c.
II
gj i/i u
$ -f
S so
^ CI >- > P £ S
t: > = re = m (fl
Ci ~
■^ E
tti
S t> re
■O 0^0 :
re o c< ■
o ? S.
- *: o
S 2 "
5 u! c
«B e J; ;
^ « E
re a. "
i ^ E ■
= £ c '
0. ?
380
n
c
IT
i
o
a
S
<«
o
E
o
u
E
o
u
#1
o
o
r • "
J' o £ -
^ E oi $ c
o ^ c » e
S-D S E
o •' n n o.
™ ° S" s I
2: ® 9 3 «
c — f* ^ ^
- » »fl 3 o
« ° « «.
> _.
a
o
2 3 C J3
CD CI Ji <
o
o
E
a>
E
«/>
E I
1 1
CO n
X (J ^ J3
O — O
£ (£ e n
3 «) c «;
•§£ « a
« ?■" "
O !» t 0.
'^ 3 ^ -
< V s -
£■? o «
• C C 3
*-^ p a> r
* O S !«
_ *- 4>
? 013
°"S I
!? ™ R
e S* "
o. S i»
- _ "»
o e u
- i» 3
lie
asl
in a> n
ti c «>
- «< S
e ^ •
c o>£
o 1 r
c tJ o
n < —
< \ <"
i^£ $
« E S
c 3
O -D B
-c ? 5
§ E g
01 o
5
a
a
381
Si
E
o
O
f i
o
O
UJ
g o i »
> " c €>
^ t^ O O.
^ • O O
5 re J E
£ -o -^
c
c 5 ™ 5
15 " » - ■*
$ O w
"^ °
..mo
o _ o
B- *
c £ i ^
0 — o
£ o p o
' >" 5 ™ £
, If n n o>
; -^ -o -^ S
c re f e
1 -^ -i £
, re 0) re o
'?"■«!
g E e •»
> -r I/) U 1)
; ? i 2£
' £ *■ CO o,
' £ o s c
' I * ^ o
; " I re "
O 0) c
S - o
t ^o
■o -o 00
e C r,
P £ u>
si?
* o?
* a »
u » 2
££ »
£ i E
o o o
E 2
Z 3
4) O
Oix:
CO rts
fD
d J3 (t o) x;
o
£ *n
l|s
a> ? ->
§ |£
1^ *
? i-o
- c e
• 5 g
tr 3 o
- c °
<» t 13
« o n
c u -c
€> » Q
>. " q:
III
So?
< E £ -
O J£ re ^
■» * -^ a
■e -o o E
> • £ o
5 X o u
S = * "
o o Q. 2
CD
■? ■- £
ilir
*w <-^ *- 2:
f '-' «J i)
oj a> IT .
5,y £ t
t: Ia " £
o 3 ^ t
O — ) "O ^
(55 «
i« u
re ;£
_ *
O.X
1i
O 4>
It
^£
e >
IM ^
re c
£ «>
T3 ^
C »
re X
g °
o £
O S
UJ "
LU »
o —
^1
£ S
4)
. o>
^ "D
E oU
re IS O
s y c
•s § £
E E ?
* E £
jc o t/t
■^^ u re
«. s *
re o "5
t o ^
o re "O
k- Qj w
£ E £
7 I/) Oj
* 5 E
-^ 5 ==
tj „ u
re ? o
-J t -D
IT ±^
O
a f
51 »
C _
o re
CO -D
£ f
«> S-
£ o B o
e 9 i
re o
E t
T5 £
£ C
ID re
o
••^
£ u ,
re !;
4, ^ (,
X "D £
— q> —
Ol OIX)
C C C
I lu
- »,o
m - <
-^ "D —
Ss£
5? ?
e ;;;£
CO Jc
re
•J "J
E J
2 ■£
*- •- jt
£ re ^ <J
_ o
o "
- "re
* c -o
S O 0)
n ^
¥ re
= O ^
^^
CD —
S|
o -o
t re
O i
ft
2 "
O o
"£
ti o
£ i»
^1
SuJ
u
" ^ -s
0)0?
X — t
III
(J tn 0)
- = s
o t o-
i; 5 s
Q. > i
tf)
o
-)
a
re
c
o
o
1/1
O
o
c
Jf
0;
£
(/t
3
I
«
O
O)
"D
S
T3
s -fc ^
D O c
- •" a
!r J »
o « i
U V U
0) o T3
^ "J Si
IP re 5
c £ re
T5 0>
« 0) X
re > *-
* 0)
re f
£ i
® i
^ a '"
Q. re ^
>-•;=
££
s ■?
01
- ^ ^
•- £ £
0( Oi c
o c o
^ » o.
If c :^
o re o
* m ''1
re o
> re 01
^ a
01 01 c —
£ £ re UJ
* c O a
E 9 c c
O — o o
>" " ■S.-K,
1/1 — c c
£ S !?
Q ~
a
a
382
c'
•
o
e
n
9
"S
•*
«
o
a
ill
c o «
£ » 9
— aiS
n o. 3
Ei! ?
« B ir
c c z
CO o *
«i -o £
y » "2
P c •
in 9"-
•o ■? "5
• , o
« u o
IT c
T3 T3 -
a> ^ o
</>$>/)
S E
SO
ft
£1
O •
S- ■ e *
ffi
o- o
S £
• £ « a»
^ ~ -5 S
0 CB
• C
^E
• o
1^
o o
O.T3
2- E
£ "
* 2
-) T3
?|
_ C
E ^
» 3
5 C
• ;
n Q.
c o
9 a
» -
n o
1^
• £
~ c
o £
•2§
U
S 5 «
£ 4, o
^£ y
1 1 ^
«><»«£
a
5|
C 9/
• =
S-5
c a;
^ •
•o -o
a n
i S
n (0
£ £
s fc xj «< t.
"SO*"
o o —
o 5 i
e e "
e £ U
•- o 2
£ 0- (J
i£f
o > <v
ifl
S: ®
E S "
— t> CB
SSE
It!
« « s
« m >
~ • _
X c =
2 £ O
o »
Q.X £
lis
« 3
C —
u
o
. c
c n
3 C £
O o
<B C *
O — a>
4. a
I- O -D
1^
II
O O
■ T>
go
O Gb
"5. C :
p e S
« s »
>■€ •
jr : 3
= •■§■
E c ^
c o -=
o «i s
2 c i«
» E 9
Q. E »
3 o s
B a
§ E 5
= o c-
"a
o
£ ^
ILI X
Is
9 ^
O £
e —
m
U 5
E 5
e £
■o o
1^
Q- «
£ ■=
ait:
II
II
- i
© o
1 H
^|o
J etr
(f 5|
ll °
Sic
S! (» ?
Hi E
0 O B
!!> e tt>
i g Q
Sag
fl- ' ?
u 1 «
1 ° -
CD c 1-
E5
rS<
o
'^'^
<=^ a
fS
E oj
!S v
If
c S
° E
tl
S|l
n «) E
^ m c
*« 4. S;
w ^ O
111
« c c
m b m
•o ? c
c in
* !!! i.
. «> Oi
ii 5 o
E ra
T> o
." S « ■
- P*
jc S _
o «
lit
* s t^ ■
Sao,
2 5 ?■
•C S cr'
= 1 ^
■5 Cf
o £ o
— o o
5 E c
" -R ~
o 5 «
^^ •- re
>. 3 o>
S c *
n re 01
i_ re o
7 ii <»
£ Q.-'
S i5 ?
■E oi »
S E e
s; |m
C
r E 3
0) Q.
Q
re £
- o - 2
I? c y
^ - u
£ r =
™ £ o
0, a i^
■^ y -
IS u £
£ ?
I <
Oi
1 ^C
— ?
I " o
in re «
J3 - c*
o " a
VB -o "
"- E
"££
m IT C
£ C O
£2^
K S O
SEf
^?^
Eft"
U 3 =
>• re ft;
re gii -c
U 0/ O'
•D £ £
3 IT *-
~i o ^
9 a i/>
5 9 c.
■r c re
re « re
•o «J £
£ g-u
C i *~
re re K
«i -<> -=
o Oj 5
3 T3 c
m !!; 5
■o e *" «i
t E 21
re o £ _
i -z-
S.
c
5
a
o
383
a.
o
o
o
1
a:
e
o
II
5 E
t^ "° g ■ *
? a
o c
a E
E •=
— o
• c
E o
1 I
» E
4'|f
I?
li
3 IS
« -
Q. — >
O ?
5 S
0) V
c p
ift CD
*" z.
U C
in re
T3 *
5; y
w • *1 £
- t © ■
I o|
c a. «
£li
III
t> ■^ z
-* E
i OS <5
° 2 S
si|
O
l.£
■o ■
• P c
'Dae
• ? £
E S o
.«• s
gf ^-
2 o •« J
£¥£?
E • ^ o
: a at
9
c o. » £ £
n c • 3 X)
^•!=
E a ^
s s
c
E
jg t -g O
oS 5 2
- " I »
e • ■ E
■^ ^ n
S 2 o •?
£•1
eI •
W > o
-ICC
Ct e o
f ?1
o. E £
c -o «
° £ E
o O 5
- < a
<• • >-
5 j: c
!5 « "
•5 S «
>-o •
c c
• —
= «
_ »
<• E
— IT
■52
si
85
c o
O IK
'■^ B
<• s
^^
s 2
i
« £
Ol
^1
£ <
« 1 =
° « o
e 5: 5
a> « ^
- o -
3 -
S I 3 5.
w m n
™ E £ o
?£ £ £
I^ ^ " -^
e o 3 ^
re
> y =
l/t
11^
E E
.•^ •
cot
•- «> —
u> • -
o « c 9
= — u 3
ft o
I/) o
c 9-
«i «
Xo 4)
E^
>> c
« n
E >^
££
» 8
•^
1_ in
s8
06 »
06 M
If
2£
9 "
oie
c c
a s
« E
c
E
o •
T3 3
• "
O c
^ ^ o E
- c £
:2 c E
^ « Si
c g
o E
E|
U) o
g Q-
> £
£ *•
£
' o o
c a.
re O'
E^
o o
<M O
■<>£€>
?5
lA
E 5
<l o
£ I-
■£: Q. * -
E°f^ -)[r3in <^i/icr
^ o o ^
«2 I "
O -D J >-
C 01 ^ C
-^ CL P O
i2 «^
"? •*
O <? = o
9--^ £ re
- ° » o
■t. 2 5 T3
^ 3 t a.
o o O JC
re ^ c ■=
-1 Ki re S
JC
*z ^
E 3 — »
• n re c
3 ^ £ 5
o » -t
i«>£ "»
"■i O It
«• o c re
O " T3 fc
~ £ - ^
■o 5 ^ °
» e ? §
re £ re w
S; E •
'hi
5 S • ?
•>£ «£
• c ??
■^ *« o»t
" ? c „
re c n -p
~> -S -c S
_ w i\ —
o
LU
LU
8o
5 111
a w
»>£
1°
re A
E §
O lA
P £
i- *
If
SE^I
f -^ «
o re $ E
"o *; w E
re • o o
o ° > "
c Ul » >
E lil 5 •
l2 "5
c £ -J O
re * ° S
£ E c g
§ E ? a
o- 5 t ^
• c y
c o c
o E £ 5
5.-R >.y
■q e D-'o
?r i $
9 o c re
O. 06 « -C
" 2 « £
sIIe
!5 01 ^ o
£ £ o 5.
0) - 5 o
~ S aO
= E - LU
re 5 o LU
£ == ra »
J re c £
c 5 f J5
■^ O LU
* I
*• E
■5 £
ni O
^ I c »
Oj U X9
5< £ -o u
9 ^ re •-
Q.£ 5 or
41
re c
■o o.
3 i
E E
is
0 ~
■? §
O) re
?B
01 c
c ^
O c
T3 S
t O
^ re
il
«> *
3 e
CT^
0) —
^ "D
CI *)
0 >
^i
o5
LU o
LU c
c =
"is
-s " =
5^ ^
o ^
* * 5;
-Q c o
■5 ™ 1
£ Q. "
u c 01
2 o E
= u Xfi
So §
». UJ o-
- LU »)
01 ^ -
^ 01 c
o -c Ol
re n *
-> £ ^
01 e-
a
384
ID
o.
i
s
o
o
s
'S
u
8t£«
o ^ 2 a. 9 -
c O O " = «
•■5*2*0
f> • • -o • o
a« -I €.2
II
£ g
£ c
-o S
I -5
O I
o £ U s
■O " O S
O
111
UJ
c E a
§■" :i
C c c .
'S s -2
• c <»
i
Ok
c
o
o
O
LU
Ul.
<J
• i
$
. - ,' f I ^ f
£ •£ cl f «
; o u> 6 — - ~
• a
1!
* ' • i €
£lf?f s
U
* s
£ 9 •» • S^
•llii»
S E SS
u -, E ^
-> w *- m
^ £ «
i=5
« «
f <•
b r
■» — o ~* o
2 o. » -o 5 o
5 E $ » — •
o « S « £ -°
Q. 01 (fl o ^ •g
r s
o c
O 3
i- •
It
II
Iff
"^ ««
c o
o i
£ o
e o
a
•> !2
m
III
.2 5 E -
-•lie
•D ^ -O S 5.
S a c • »
■ • = £ •
2'|l|8
• £ = 8:1
e le c -S
£ £ o c
2 2 2 £
II
£b|?
r o » e
""» o g
E c • e
!- • c
• £ 9
^ ^ o
o c
o 3 «; o «
ofsEis5wS2»at
= 1 c 2 §
« ^ e 8 *
I ' S I 2
' ^ " (XI
II
Z c
c O
• o
e E
o «
■5 •
s u
$ "2
« S
£ «
^ &
c c
n O'
3 t:
O" re
HI
«> U o
o c-
J£ £ «
"■ » a,
(0 (0 O)
• al
i E „
o si
UJ ~ E
UJ s »
•=■ • A
I- _] LJ
o
a. »
>. 2
0 «
2 5
01 E
E £
E 1,
— OS
E
6| E I"
* E » o.
•2 §•;
|S?£
e E " re
E " § I
0 £ o -c
»<"
3 eg
1 E
fi S ?|
o S5 E
c t* o
|o e ,
ll ^^
E i
S •
I 5
I/) -
C
UJ
UJ
E
o
o (5
UJ ^
UJ v>
> «
§£ ?• «LU
Z. n oT '^ V £
£ •= =* 2 S c
c $ 0) <= S -
S = S •? -o -g
w ? r >.£
= c — • ■o o
•§£_»•
lA OJ «- ^ tf) A
-O > O O It ■"
C C C £ ^ O
2.8s 8 • J;
S^ I •^ =
i S * S55
c • O i £ «
" ^ O - 5 ^
Ec °Er'°°T5
tf> " 2 flj o o
}! iio"£-?E
j3 -i-^<-o.i:2u
o
385
n
a.
u
c
o
E
o
u
q:
e
o
O
UJ
•
£ « — i» n
E 5 I gZ
■= • o o.»
lO t— — ^ K
~ f ^ c
? 6 ■" » •
■£2 t" E
~ = S c £
» a.— n —
<• E
J^~ £ £
« s^ *" -5
-o o « <S
"D *- ^ ^
. £ C >. 3
' !i >« c £
a> oj ©
■£ V
« cfl ^
f: j: -a n
c ui
U)
11
■ O
E c
£ ■>
c ~
i5
9 <D
£ <
CD **
o >.
E •
Et5
5 •
E !!
• a>
£ ■>
-CD
of
£ •
II
I?
O I/)
V !?
5 s
° I
E vS
3 £ »-
S o r^'
s i »
•o » 5
• • —
= ^ °
-O ^ j:
5 w o
■C (S ig
« I -
Sao.
a> ^ ti
» 5 I
>• s t
3 S 0^
• "o i ^
5 • " » 2
£ :? ? -S >■
e 5 « S £
" &•" « 5
n (0 (A fo CT
"" 5 * « ®
§1
g « c ?
(fl — -
» S E
S £ • »
5 c » -5
c
■g° ^ S
o • 9 a.
.o £ c c
w - • o
e e W U
n c 0 ^
E S EK
»o S •
c — 5 -c
E €) Q. j»
g «>
?~»
3 J? c
O . ff
E « «,
ui c «>
Is E
? 8 2
E « g^
o E S
w '- «
5« £
1- E ■"
o
» 0) »"
«. £ ££
£ - J) c
. 0) a> ra
>- 41 01 ^
£ o o o
w C- C- —
~ t. c. t>
-O 0) Oi C
re "
«.£
£ o
°§
e UJ 2
o y
51
in =
* 2
3 CO
tr -,
»l 2
■Si;
■s S ™
8 S-S
« • g
£ - £
c c ™
O r^ £i
o o* in
' r— w .t _,
• aw"
£ • £ S
^ - U Z 3
' f ^ 3 3 ^
Q: _ » «
'5S S 9
— —50
' S 5 ,^ >
' ■o £ J^ -
; « -S-S-D
' CD n (s c
I e X. o "
- ■? Otjd
1 i« £ w =
P •? «> «
E *= t: «>
■S &■ o x:
: o f 0) re
; ™" * £
> ?££ E
! § I $ -IC
S * ® c
» £ » W
<«<-'£>■
■D O ^- C
ss
^ o in
O o tr
O -6
w S c a
o -X 9 c
f ^S ?
■S "" W 5
re o _j «=
^ » « c
— .c > 0)
o - c n
re * J, £
I** j^ £ _-
J 16 < u
O TO T3
F — O
O (A -O
U) 3 ^
is E
ore*
" -o >
0} a> —
O re 5
9 5-
re re re
_j m E
a.
o
0 li- c
£ e u
E -:?
3 J re
^ o ^
E Z^
in 0) c
£ -c »;
"o tr £
C 3 Q.
re o c
""■So
a) " u
in <n c
• = L
£ o =
~ "^ S
3 ? c
l:o|
■o P in
-On
rem™
01 re ">
£ 0) 3
"S o c
c -o o. ^
§re o in
£ — 0)
Tni ^°
•^ I E- ".
° CO • I
5= ol
o 0) fi £
O ^ "O -
E V * ™
3 0* re c
c > 01 o
o ° o- -
o = a re
.£ re re c
C0> GO
0| ^
a
386
8
e
^
>
» •>
O i
Og
-I?
n c ^
? « •
• JC o
^11
CE O «i
>; "• p
^ i -
S " o
2 c Q.
w -o £
^ * "R
(■ o
2 X >.
1^1
ill
« £ <»
?• f
_l TJ S
*; jt e
c o ■-
o n 4)
?:-
o|8
o ?"
^ S £
f E £
■n
■o<
C • '
a 9 _
-'"5 '^
<|°
B S *
ill
£ • ■?
::"° •
o « g
■ 3 •
"i «
c o x:
° E 2
c * e 5
«> o *"
- ■= I
- s »
• • .»
? • g
Ef ?
^5 II
gf §
> • -o
O -c c
E£-
c c
s ^ -
lie
U 9 to
u 03
s «
ii
flJ ^^ !^
aGD -)
2-^ *
X 3 a
2 p g
« Ii
s 5_-
2 S f
O tl B
o o »-
C 3 O
> c 3
o <o u
■5£o.
— 31 C
S Q.
• c
W i-£
, £ (fl^
£ -C • S
- 8 £ 3
- S E ■"
■ c t s
c o •= H
■^ s ?l
rM -5 - ?
"|^§
5g|l
£ £ ~ 5
t: >-"B £
3 > « ^
* 2 E E
1 E i '
■o S 5 -
>. .- 2 »
^ c
u «
S E
-I
e "
• V
c (•
E «=
c ■ P
O ■ o
!§•
? £ • I
" Q. 2 •> ».
S « 3 i»
!&£ $ S
las $ .
i "^ S o S
i^E^Ml
< Z
n
If
• s
£ e
c a.
° E
c -
o c
X £
■D
«
E
•> T)
3 a
^E o S
« - 5 oi 5
» 2 n -J
u o. .a Q.
°-? 3
a SB
£ CO n
• o • •- _
• -c g £
Et:i*
• I S£ 5
tt - Q. E E
-:? -280
? I f - o
£ »5 8&
n u S 00 £
= <» S ~. —
n > o o c
5 Q. 2 E o
° ? 1 2 S
2 &£ •-
g fS £ ^
(0 ; o o> n
c « E o
0) o re > a>
:r ai iS > ^^
ma 2 i i
<» ■5.
£ E
~ f>
•- c
3 ^
tr re
re 2
■o ;;
1°
a »
Sx
a *
• S
Q. 2
~ <»
S "o
» -c
w >.
2 •
r^
sl_
"5 i
S • o
I -o O
«£«
X » «>
o • o
• oS
£= 2 <%
•^■^
£a^
re £ •£>
• >.-o
t> £ •
_ • O
re c ifl
^ 2 5
re n s
s ■?; ^
t:
o
«
rr •
o £
• C
" -J
e Q.
CD ~
O ~
f • a
o ■£ —
S e »
fc •- c
Q. O O
>" '!^ =
o c o
a. o ^
lA » _
>" ^ .1
• c £
a ~ iS
« c »
•* to
ill
-5 •
E- S
c (T Q.
" U U3
0) c «)
i gl
3 ^^
n re o
y 2 01
re Q. 5:
— 3 £
£a £ £ S
1 o
e *
& o
O Q.
p 5
X a
• £
If
■D O
c a.
re 1/1
£ 2
£ <»
II
E e
O i
o o
« •; O
P « * W
tf> P • JI
« e £ -
T3 T3
. .. - S
(DC* in
P -c re a
u> in
P £
Q.
_ «l
Hit
S • 9>
9- 3
2 -c
« •
ir 3 t
255
s 2
«-o — Q-
£ ■= S e
(A
3
P
« «
-, " 3
T3 -)
il
C »
c e
c o
p 3
§e
ff 3
• S
0--2
(/) re
2-p
e « _
w E
28 u
g 2 o5
o -^ 4) re
™ _ • s
• P = T3
£ o> 0) ii
s- 1-
^ (ft >« (B
tn 5 • >■
?! Ere $
^ 3 re ™
_ oi-= 2
c c >-
E c c c
c -o 5 jc
O • X =
r^ «i ». «)
S E c <"
» ., ^ S
3 s
Pa,-
^£^2
GD
1>
P _
(/) re
■c
"■ 3 S E
o ^ 2: -^
3 re ,« 0)
<^o.S£
» E • c
in c — 0
p £ ?r
"OS
3 5 " «!^
A X > CD
™ *- re ^^
^ re j= 0)
>.irare52'=£
i t"
j_ re T3 ^
?" In -6 S
0| ~
o
o
387
1-1
<
o
o
in
O
ui
UJ
o
o
a.
<
O
o
a
"I
oi
O
£ a
"tr = 4) tfl
O ttJ ^ -
tf> 40 -^ ^
0) -O ^ 4) ^
«> -a
re 0, J
%6
o ^
UJ Oj
1, -5
y E -
III
re
o o
? UJ n
4) t o>
0, e «;
£ "^ u
*_ > 4;
0; O £
Sap
- £ 2
^il
i <u^
? _ _
</! 9 -o
4j 9 c 1/ r
? ro 0, t ^
a,: u
388
EXHIBIT 4
Office Memorandum
Resolution Trust Corporation
MEMORANDUM TO: Barbara A. Shangraw, Assistant General Counsel
FROM: Bruce J. Pederson, Counsel
DATE: May 6, 1993
Use of Corporate Faciuties
I am responding to your memorandum of April 26, 1993 concerning my use of cor-
porate facilities.* A copy is attached as Exhioit "A." Your memorandum purported
to confirm the contents of a conversation we had in your office on April 23, 1993
regarding your clandestine review of my WordPerfect files and further warned me
of potential disciplinary action if I used any corporate facilities for personal matters
in the future.
Three major subjects need to be addressed: (1) your unauthorized entiy into my
computer; (2) general use of corporate facilities by RTC employees; and (3) morale
witMn the office. I also wish to notify you that your ill-advised search may have
violated various criminal statutes, my constitutional rights, and important public
policies. At a minimum, your search creates the appearance of heavy-handed retalia-
tion against a whistleblower.
I. Your Unauthorized Entry Into My Computer
Based on several sources, including your own words, I understand that you se-
cretly gained access to my computer WordPerfect files without my consent sometime
on or about March 12, 1993.
A. Factual Background
What follows is my full and complete understanding of events.
1. The Catalyst
Your break -in was allegedly triggered by an electronic mail message ("E-Mail")
which I wrote on February 24, 1993. According to you, it was found lying on a print-
er somewhere in the Denver Legal Division office. My E-Mail, attached as Exhibit
"B," attempted to provide current information regarding the future of the RTC to
several fellow employees. It also criticized the bonuses received by RTC manage-
ment and summarized congressional testimony given by then CEO Albert Casey re-
garding his proposals for abolishing the RTC "by the end of 1993. The timing of the
closing of the KTC is a subject of great concern to agency eimiloyees as they face
the arduous task of finding new jobs with FDIC or elsewhere. The recipients of this
E-Mail were all too familiar with the experience of unexpectedly losing their jobs.
Each recipient had been ousted from the RTC in May of 1992 and temporarily "put
back" to the FDIC last summer. My E-Mail had an attachment entitled
"Casey3.Mis." It consisted of two articles published by the Bureau of National Af-
fairs, Inc. ("BNA") regarding CEO Casey's testimony. A copy appears as Ejdiibit "C."
An employee you have not identified retrieved the E-Mail from the printer and
brought tne copy to your attention. You then forwarded it to someone in the Wash-
ington, D.C. RTC Office. I assume that the person was a member of senior manage-
ment in your reporting line (i.e., an Associate General Counsel or the Acting Gen-
eral Counsel).^ You then allegedly received instructions from Washington, D.C. to
access my computer and its WordPerfect files.
2. The Break-In
Your clandestine operation into my computer began with your E-Mail dated
March 12, 1993. It was sent to John Waechter, a computer services employee ("In-
formation Services Unit" or *ISU"). Based on alleged instructions from Warfiington,
D.C. headquarters, you directed him to enter my computer and directly copy into
your computer aU of my WordPerfect files and directories. A copy of your edict is
attached as Exhibit "E." Fearing for his job, Mr. Waechter reluctantly complied with
your recjuest.
^I actually received your memorandum sometime mid-aflemoon on Tuesday, April 27, 1993.
'On April 27, 1993, I sent an E-Mail to Acting General Counsel Richard Aboussie asking
whether he was the person who instructed you to enter into my computer. He received and os-
tensibly read my E-Mail the following day. To date, he has yet to send a reply. Copies of my
E-Mail and the confirmation of receipt are attached as Exhibit "D."
389
At the time you initiated your unauthorized search of my computer, it contained
correspondence, memoranda, and other communications with the RTC Office of In-
spector General ("OIG"), the U.S. General Accounting Office ("GAO"), and key con-
gressional officials with oversight jurisdiction over KTC operations. These items
were generated at their request and in coi^unction with official inquiries into RTC
programs and use of appropriated funds.
At no time was I ever consulted about my E-Mail, dated February 24, 1993, or
asked for my consent to your invasion of my computer. In addition, you never took
the simple step of asking me for a copy of the attachment to the E-Mail which so
captivated your interest.
3. Ensuing Investigations and Reprisals
After your unauthorized entry into my computer, the RTC OIG opened an official
investigation into the propriety of your actions and the instructions you received
from Washington, D.C. Word of the OIG investigation somehow reached you. Your
response was to attempt to have Mr. Waechter fired for allegedly notifying me and
Jadcie Taylor of your break -in. You further accused him of feing a "friendr of ours.
I understand that your initial efforts did not meet with success insofar as Mr.
Waechter's supervisors, RTC employees who are not part of the Legal Division in
Denver, do not report to you. They also may have reco^zed the impropriety of ter-
minating an employee during the pendency of an official OIG investigation regard-
ing this matter. Nonetheless, I believe that you are continuing your efforts to seek
Mr. Waechter's termination.
4. Our Meeting
On April 23, 1993, I was summoned by your secretary to report to your office at
3:00 PJVI. She would not tell me what was on your agenda. I reported as requested
and joined you and Senior Counsel Ellis Merritt in a meeting that lasted approxi-
mately 20 minutes. Mr. Merritt appeared to function as a witness for you.
Once we were seated, you advised me that the subject of the meeting was my use
of corporate facilities. You told me, for the first time, that you had entered my com-
puter WordPerfect files and found several "personal matters." This caused you to
seek my assurances that I would not use RTC computers for personal matters in
the future. When I asked for examples of the personal items in question you pro-
vided three vague references. These were a Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA'')
complaint, "letters to friends," and "something about a town home."
Using the scant information you volunteered concerning what you read in my
WordPerfect files, I attempted to explain why I thouj^t there was a business nexus
with these items. For example, the FOIA complaint was prepared (and filed) in an
effort to obtain documents relevant to my pending grievance which had languished
at the hands of the RTC since August of 1992. Letters to friends likely included sen-
ior FDIC officials who I consider to be friends and with whom I stay in touch re-
garding RTC operations and potential FDIC job opportunities should RTC
recommence its "put back" program for GG employees. I don't believe that we came
to any agreements as to what constitutes "personal" in this case. I agreed that if
I was uncertain in the future, I would consult with my supervisor (Michael Nelson)
or his supervisor (Mr. Merritt).
At the meeting, I asked you what authority entitled you to enter my computer
WordPerfect files without my consent. You replied, "managerial prerogative." I ex-
f tressed concern over privacy issues triggered oy employer searches of employee of-
ices and referred to legal research I performed while previously employed at the
OIG at the U.S. Department of Commerce. You responded by volunteering that the
U.S. Attorney's Office in Washington, D.C. had approved your search of mv com-
puter.^ I concluded my comments by suggesting tnat Messrs. Nelson and Merritt
simply ask me for access to my computer the next time you had an interest in its
contents.
B. Legal and Policy Issues
Your invasion of my computer WordPerfect files raises a number of serious legal
issues. Criminal statutes designed to prevent illegal wiretaps may have been vio-
lated. My Federal and State constitutional, statutoiy, and common law privacy
rights may have been breached. At a minimum, public policies for enhancing effec-
tive oversight over RTC operations clearly were contravened. Criminal penalties,
civil liability, and administrative action could result.
^ I do not know what fact patterns were used to arrive at their conclusions and whether their
input was reduced to writing.
390
1. Criminal Statutes
The major Federal wiretap law, Title HI of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe
Street Act of ISSS,* was amended in 1986 by the Electronic Communications Pri-
vacy Act of 1986 CTECPA") to cover computers and electronic mail.' The ECPA was
intended to protect electronically stored communications from unauthorized access
and dissemination. Unless you somehow qualify for one of the law's exceptions, your
conduct may have violated this statute.
The exceptions found at 18 U.S.C. §270 1(c), or in pre-ECPA case law, do not ap-
pear to condone your search.^ In general, such exceptions are narrowly construed
by the courts so as to preserve the protective intent of the statute. In aadition, your
search was not done wdth my consent or pursuant to an appropriate warrant, sub-
poena, or court order. Apphcation of the "employer-owned systems" exception to
your search would gut the legislative intent of trie ECPA, ignore key legislative his-
tory, and abuse the likely purpose of the exception {i.e., permit retrieved of stored
communications that were maintained for back-up purposes only). The "property
protection" and "business extension' exceptions also seem intended for vastly dii-
lerent circumstances such as narrow employer intrusions by appropriate ofUcials de-
signed to deal with suspected employee theft, abuse or sabotage of computer sys-
tems, hardware and software performance, ana qualiW control checks.
Even if your search ar^guably qualified for any of tne foregoing ECPA exceptions,
its scope was so broad as to extinjguish the entitlement to the exception. Court cases
approving employer intrusions into employee privacy have done so when the em-
g layer's legitimate search was carefully limited. Thus, searches ui)held by the courts
ave focused on transactional information (sender and receiver identities; commu-
nication patterns) rather than the contents of the communications. In this case, as-
suming you could legally search my WordPerfect (P:) directory for the "Ca8ey3.Mis"
attachment, you could only do so legally if you avoided perusing the other docu-
ments in my computer.
2. Civil Prohibitions
It is beyond the scope of this memorandum to fully set forth all of the potential
civil liability arising from your invasion of my computer. Numerous constitutional
provisions, statutes, and common law theories are involved. Nonetheless, prelimi-
nary legal research and facts known to me at present support a persuasive case that
my constitutional and civil ri^ts were violated by your conduct. Your intrusion into
my computer files does not appear to have legal support when key factors such as
notice, consent, justification and scope are considered.
It is worthwhile to focus on the supreme law of the land, the U.S. Constitution,
The Fourth Amendment affords me protection against unreasonable searches and
seizures. Several cases evaluating the propriety of employer seardies have found
that public employees may have privaiA^ interests in tneir physical ofQces and in
their words, both oral and vrritten, whicn are used in telephone conversations, cor-
respondence, and other forms of communication. Evaluating each case on its facts,
the courts have atten^>ted to balance an employee's legitimate expectation of pri-
vagr against the reasonableness of the employer's search. In applying that test, the
U.S. Supreme Court held that government employees retain protection against un-
reasonable searches and seizures by governmental supervisors. O'Connor v. Chrtega,
480 U.S. 709, 107 S.a. 1492, 94 L£d:2d 714 (1987).
It is telling to evaluate your conduct using the factors employed by Ort^a and
its progeny. Three pivotal factors emerge: (1) were the privacy expectations of the
employee reasonable; (2) did the employer have a reasonable basis for initiating the
search; and (3) was the employer's search reasonable in scope? The facts known at
present fully support the conclusion tiiat you and the person instructing you to in-
vade my computer violated my constitutional ri^ts. Your ill-advised seardi tram-
pled into an area of hi^ privacy expectations. You did this without a legitimate
purpose and with nonexistent limits. In short, you conducted a retaliatory "fishing
expedition." Consequently, any information that you did seize pursuant to your im-
proper search is tainted. I expect that you are familiar with the "fruit of the poison-
ous tree" doctrine found in seardi and seizure cases.
(a) My Privacy Expectations
My high expectation of privacy regarding the contents of my computer was rea-
son{u>le. Numerous factors contributed to that belief. These include the computer
* 18 U.S.C. 552510-20.
"18U.S.C. 552701-11.
•See, Tumer-Baumhait, The Employer's Right to Read Employee E-Mail: Protecting Property
or Personal Prying? 6 Labor Lawyer 923, 92&-929 (1992).
391
system itself, the absence of publicized RTC policies regarding computer eaves-
dropping, and statements to you regarding my expectations.
Several features inherent to my computer support an expectation of privacy. First,
I need a password to access my computer. It is known only to me and the ISU office.
By design, you do not have it. Second, my computer keyboard features a "delete"
function which allows me to eliminate material prior to review by another person.
Third, a message appears on my computer screen each time I sign on notifying me
that "Hinauthorized access" to the computer is prohibited by public law (copy at-
tached as Exhibit "F"). In fact, I am to report access without my consent to a "secu-
rity officer." Fourth, I have private WordPerfect files for my own use. Once a docu-
ment is typed, I can store it in a secure file which only I can access (e^., P: drive
or A: drive, or it can be placed in a communal file (J: drive). Indeed, when I log
in, my screen tells me that the P: drive is "private." A copy appears as Exhibit "G."
Finally, government ownership of the computer itself does not preclude employee ex-
pectations of privacy .''
RTC policies and work place procedures do not erode my high privacy expecta-
tions regarding the contents of my computer. The RTC has never published and dis-
seminated a comprehensive agency-wide computer monitoring and search policy to
its employees.® Nor has the agency asked me to sign any kind of waiver regarding
the privacy of my computer's contents. I never gave any actual or implied consent
to your intrusion. Indeed, I had no inkling that your covert conduct could occur
based on the facts involved.
Conversely, Jackie Taylor and I repeatedly put you on notice of our privacy expec-
tations regarding communications and files at work. On September 9, 1992, I sent
you an E-Mail expressing concern over potential physical and electronic surveil-
lance. Your reply denied any personal knowledge of eavesdropping but failed to ad-
dress RTC policies in this area. On October 9, 1992, Jackie Taylor sent you an E-
Mail reflecting our privacy interests in our files. This was done in res^nse to sug-
gestions from Mr. Bernard Brodsky that he was going to visit our offices (then in
exile across town from you) and search through our files for PLS-related materials.
We never received a definitive reply from you laying out what areas were subject
to warrantless searches (i.e., our computer WordPerfect files), l^ese E-Mails are at-
tached as Exhibit "H." In short, we went on record regarding our privacy expecta-
tions. You did not.
In February you had another opportunity to warn us that you somehow had legal
authority to search our offices or their contents at any time. When I pressed the
privacy issue of why our mail was opened and screened, even when marked "per-
sonal and confidential," you had Mr. Merritt send me RTC Memorandum #92-MG-
06 which provided that mail addressed to RTC employees (except certain offices
such as the Investigations Department) was subject to being opened in an effort to
retrieve cash and negotiable instruments.*
The RTC had yet another chance to comment on employee privacy expectations
in connection with a Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA") request which Jackie
Taylor and I submitted on September 12, 1992. Copies of the initial request and our
appeal are attached as Exhibit "I." On two occasions, the agency responded to our
request by stating that no information existed regarding any physical, electronic, or
telephone surveillance that had been conducted on us. These replies are attached
as Exhibit "J." 1°
Finally, it is worth mentioning that a law enforcement agency likely supports the
reasonableness of my privacy expectations. Althourfi I do not pretend to speak for
the RTC OIG, it is my understanding that the OIG takes the position that search
warrants are required before OIG Special Agents can access RTC employee comput-
ers.
''Privacy interests protected by the Fourth Amendment do not turn on the ownership of the
premises or equdpment The Fourth Amendment protects people, not areas. Rakas v. Illinois,
439 U.S. 128 (1978); Katz v. UnUed StaUs, 389 U.S. 347 (1967).
*The RTC Directive Circular you provided, entitled "Microcomputer Security Policy," is ana-
lyzed separately in Section II-D of this memorandum. The Circular fails to oCTset all of the com-
puter system features which promote an expectation of privacy.
^It was never explained to me why a personal letter unrelated to RTC business would nec-
essarily contain cash, and if so, why the RTC would claim ownership of the money. Nonetheless,
assuming a compelling need to verify contents, I was never told why having a mail room em-
ployee witness my opening of personal mail addressed to me would not be acceptable.
^°The final denial by the RTC, dated April 16, 1993, raises the interesting issue of how the
agency could still maintain that no responsive records were in existence when your E-Mail of
March 12, 1993 directing the break-in had been in existence for over a month.
392
(b) Reasonable Basis for Your Seardi
Unless 3^ou withheld information from me in the April 23, 1993 meeting, your
stated basis for invading my computer without my consent was the E-Mail I wrote
that was found lying on a printer somewhere in the otBce. The contents of the E-
Mail did not furnish you with a reasonable justification for conducting your unau-
thorized search of my WordPerfect files. I merely exercised mv First Amendment
ri^ts regarding work-related issues. Your irritation with my E-Mail, eiUier because
it was contraiy to management's *party line" or disclosed information that you
wanted to suppress from rank and file employees, was a poor excuse for what you
did.
Ortega teaches that my E-Mail had to prompt your search either for reasonable
non-investigatoiy work-related reasons or for investigatory woik-related reasons.
Your explanation fails to satisfy either prong. Non-investigatoiy woik-related
searches usually occur when an employer needs to obtain a doaiment, pertinent to
the agency's business, from an employee's office when the employee is absent. In
this case, my E-Mail and its attachment were not documents vital to your conduct
of RTC business. Moreover, you already had the E-Mail in your possession. If you
wanted a copy of the attachment, all you had to do was ask me or one of the recipi-
ents. Instead, you waited several di^s before surreptitiously breaking into my
WordPerfect files, a location for which I had a reasonable expectation of privacy.
With respect to an investigatory work -related search designed to uncover em-
ployee misfeasance, nothing in my E-Mail provided you with a reasonable suspicion
that I was engaging in misconduct or incompetent oehavior. The text of my E-Mail
discussed congressional testimony by then CEO Case>| regarding his proposal to stay
on as CEO and phase out the agency. That subject is oi great interest to all RTC
employees and is regularly discussed in all kinds of interna agency documents. RTC
management frequently distributes copies of testimonv by CEO Casey and other
agency officials (e.g., Acting General Counsel Richard Aboussie) to RTC employees.
There is nothing inherent to this topic that raised a reasonable suspicion of misfea-
sance on my part. This is the minimum requirement which enables tiie government
to prevail, when it does, in search and seizure litigation involving public employees.
The only other area that had to be of interest to you was the referenced attach-
ment to my E-Mail. It was entitled 'X^aseyS.Mis.'' On its face, the title hardly con-
jures up a sudden need to surreptitiously break into my computer WordPerfect file
to find out what constitutes the attachment. In fact, as you later found out, the item
was most benign. It consisted of two BNA articles regarding CEO Casey's congres-
sional testimony. If you wanted to retrieve a copy, I would have gladly providedyou
with one upon your request. You would not have encountered any delays or poten-
tial legEd exposure. I was not out of the office for any prolonged time between Feb-
ruary 24, 1993, the day when I composed and sent the E-Mau, and March 12, 1993,
the probable date of your break-in. In short, you hcul over two weeks in which to
ask me for a copy of the attadiment. You also could have asked any one of the six
E-Mail recipients for a copy since they all received the attachment in question.
The implausible nature of your excuse for breaking into my computer also raises
the issue of disparate treatment, otherwise known as retaliation. Wny did you select
my computer for a search when you could have obtained the pivotal attachment
from any of the recipients' computers? Counting myself and the six recipients, there
were seven people and computers you could turn to for the attachment.
On a broader reprisal front, one is compelled to pose several obvious qpiestions.
Have any other emplovees under your supervision been subject to secret coinputer
searches? Were these based on a need to retrieve document or reasonable indica-
tions of employee misfeasance? Conversely, have these or similar fact patterns not
resulted in searches of emplovee computers? As discussed below in Section II-E, nu-
merous examples of personal use of corporate facilities abound in our office. Does
each instanc:e result in a surreptitious search of the employee's computer? If not,
why not?
In sum, there was no reasonable basis to single me out for an unauthorized
search of my computer. Based on the four comers of my E-Mail, you had no plau-
sible suspicion that you would find anything in my computer that would warrant
the invasion you conunissionecL In addition, if the attacnment to the E-Mail was
truly the focrus of your interest, there was no reason why you could not simply ask
me or one of the recipients for a copy. Your stated rationale is so weak that I am
presumptively convinced that I was singled out for this unicpie form of retaliation.
(c) Reasonable Scope of Your Search
The sc»pe of your search, reviewing all of my WordPerfec;t files, was irrational and
overly intrusive. If your stated purpose for the break-in was to investigate my E-
Mail because it somehow smacked of facility abuse, then you should have reviewed
393
my E-Mail mailbox. That was the clear nexus. Yet, by your own admissions in our
meeting on April 23, 1993, you failed to do the loeical thing. Instead, you claimed
that your search was confined to my WordPerfect files.
If the attachment to my E-Mail was the basis and objective of your break-in to
my WordPerfect files, then you should have asked me for a copy. That was the least
intrusive option for dealing with an area fraueht with privaty interests, "niis ap-
proach is the obvious course of action in a "good faith" and professional working en-
vironment.
Assuming there was a legal basis for entering my computer, you needed to confine
your seareh to locating and copying the attacnment labeled "Ca8ey3AIis." It was
clearly labeled and easy to locate. There was no legitimate explanation for reviewing
dozens of WordPerfect files, especially when the attachment proved to be so benign.
Perhaps you were disappointed that you had failed to "^t the goods" on me, and
felt compelled to press on in the hopes of finding something you could use to trump
up charges agednst me.
Beyond the U.S. Constitution, there are a full panoply of civil theories and rem-
edies designed to address your conduct. These include Federal civil ri^ts statutes,*^
whistleblower protection statutes, ^^ civil portions of criminal statutes previously dis-
cussed, and common law torts governing invasions of privacy.'^* In several instances,
}>arallel provisions exist under Colorado law. Considerations of length prevent a
uller discussion of these topics in this memorandum.
3. Policy Coi%sideration8
Your invasion of my computer WordPerfect files compromised the integrity of im-
portant law enforcement and oversight woik. It also gutted the agency policy of en-
couraging knowledgeable employees to come forward with concerns about waste,
fraud and abuse without compromising the information or their employment status.
Your arbitrary intrusion into my WordPerfect files gave you access to materials
I prepared and sent to key oversight entities. These included the RTC OIG, the U.S.
GAO, the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, and oth-
ers with official oversight responsibility over KTC programs and employees. Your re-
view compromised the integrity of official oversight efforts insofar as these officials
may not want their targets to nave access to case sensitive information.
The RTC Acting General Counsel, Richard Aboussie, endorsed this position in his
niemuorandum to all Legal Division employees on August 27, 1992. Attached as Ex-
hibit "K," the memorandum recpiires agency employees to "fully cooperate" with
RTC OIG investigations. It further warns that, "[gjiven the nature of GIG investiga-
tions, it is inappropriate to discuss the investigation with anyone other than the
OIG representatives." You even issued a similar warning to our office in December
of 1992, stressing the fact that "IG investigations are oonfidentitd." A copy is at-
tached as Exhibit "L." You contravened Mr. Aboussie's memorandum and your own
instructions by accessing materials pertinent to ongoing OIG probes without the au-
thorization of the OIG.
Perhaps you see nothing wrong with this warped procedure given several inci-
dents last summer when '^rsonal and confidential" mail pertaining to Equal Em-
ployment Opportunity proceecUngs initiated by Jackie Taylor which involved you as
a target were opened or reviewed by your managers. I liken this situation to feeding
FBI counter-intelligence work to foreign government operatives.
In addition to directly threatening the work of oversight entities, your invasion
of my computer also sends a distuH)ing "chilling effect" to RTC employees who may
wish to report waste, fraud and abuse. Few, if any, employees will oe willing to en-
gage in this important activity if they are subject to some sort of retaliation, such
as your search of their computers. Important sources of information will dry up in
direct response to your intimidating artions. Exhibit "M" contains a letter to agency
employees from the RTC Inspector General, John J. Adair, reflecting the importance
of employee cooperation with OIG work. In addition, Mr. Aboussie s memorandum,
attached as Exhibit "K," implements these poliqr concerns in the Legal Division by
clearly stating that the Inspector General Act 'prohibits any reprisal against any
enaployee for disclosing information to the Inspector General."
Finally, your retaliatory conduct violates the admonitions of Senator Donald W.
Riegle, Jr., the Chairman of the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and
Urban AffEiirs. On August 11, 1992, Chairman Riegle repeatedly warned RTC offi-
cials about retaliating against me, Jackie Taylor and another whistleblower who tes-
"f.^., 42 U.S.C. 51983.
"At least two statutes may be applicable to RTC employees. These are 12 U.S.C. i 183 Ij and
12 U.S.C. 5 1441a(q).
" Elxamples include 'intrusions into a person's seclusion" and "defamation."
394
tilled that day. In his opening remarks, the Chairman stated that he would person-
ally do everything in his power to ensure that the witnesses suffered no reprisals.^^
Later, Senator Riegle noted that:
"[tjhis committee will use every resource at its command to see to it that there
are no reprisals at any time by anyone against vou for speaking. ... I assure
you that uiere will be no invisible person in the bureaucracy that targets any of
you that gets away with it. That just will not be tolerated by this committee. And
anybody tnat attempts that will find that the full force of our efforts vdll be di-
rected Uieir way." *"
Lest there was any doubt, the Chairman continued:
'Tou're not going to be left out there because anybody that targets you, I intend
to tai^t. We're just not going to have that. I don't believe in Government of that
sort, of vindictive conduct and we're not going to have it directed at you." ^*
Senator Riegle concluded his remarks on this subject by requesting immediate no-
tification of harassment.^'' He also pointed to promises by CEO Casey and then
FDIC Chairman William Taylor that there woula be no repriseds.^^ Last fall, Jackie
Taylor and I provided you with a copy of these statements bv Chairman Rie^e.
Your search of my computer for no legitimate reason and your efforts to unfairly
terminate Mr. Waechter all fly in the face of Chairman Riegle's blunt warnings and
promises by CEO Casey. As such, your conduct is inconsistent with their positions
and arguably breaches applicable whistleblower protection statutes.
n. General Prospective Use of Corporate Facilities
Your memorandum of April 26, 1993 expanded well beyond the subject of com-
f>uter use that was addressed at our April 23, 1993 meeting. Without any predicate
acts involving me, you further warned against the personal '^ise of corporate facili-
ties in any fashion, be it . . . telephone, copy machines, typewriters, ete." (emphasis
added). You attached copies of the following documents: 5 C.F.R. § 263S.704 C^se
of Government Property*); 5 CFM. §2635.705 ("Use of Oflicial Time"); RTC Direc-
tive Circular 1210.8 ("Disposition of Corpmrate Documentary Materials and Personal
Papers"); RTC Directive Circular 1360.1 ("Microcomputer Security Policy"); and RTC
Directive Circular 2410.1 ("Extensions of Credit").
Each document is discussed below. In general, I believe that I have substantially
complied with these items.^* I intend to continue doing so. Moreover, several of
these documents are irrelevant to this discussion or actually undercut your position
by permitting personal uses of government equipment or facilities. I also consider
your absolute position prohibiting personal use of corporate facilities "in any fash-
ion" to be impossible to defend as a practical matter and a fiction in li^t of current
practices which occur in our office.
A. 5 C.FJl. §2635.704 ("USE OF GOVERNMENT PROPERTY")
This provision requires executive branch employees to protect and conserve gov-
ernment property by using it only for authorized purposes. I believe that I have ex-
ercised reasonable stewardship of the RTC equipment entrusted to me. I always
have attempted to confine my major uses to business purposes. For example, I have
never abused property by using franked envelopes or rental vehicles for personal
business, nor have I operated a private business out of my RTC ofiice.
I will admit to de minimis personal use of government property when I have made
personal local telephone calls. Of course, that practice is condoned by the subject
^* Consolidation of the Professional Liability Section of the RTC Legal Division, 1992: Hearings
Before the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, 102nd Cong., 2nd Sess.
at 2 (August 11, 1992).
"»W. at36.
"W. at 67.
" He stated, "I want you to keep me apprised and I want jrou to call me, I want you to come
and see me at any time there's any indication that you're b^ng harassed or not treated fairly,
or that there's anybody else in an equivalent situation that you know about, because we're not
going to stand for that, and it should never happen in any case." Id. at 67.
" I've gotten the assurance from Mr. Casey here in the flesh today, and from Mr. Taylor in
writing, that there's not going to be reprisals. And I want to make sure that evei>foody lives
up to their promises in that area." Id. Copies of the written promises are attached as Exhibit
'^." CEO Casey himself testified that, 1 want to assure the committee and everybody else, that
certainly, there will be absdutely no retaliation against the witnesses, in any case . . . you have
my personal pledge.* Id. at 15.
^The provisions from the Code of Federal R^ulations, the "Standards of Ethical Conduct For
Employees of the Executive Branch," became effective on February 3, 1993.
395
ethics provision.^ I also have used office pens, pencils, paper clips and rubber bands
when doing office projects at home on my own unreimbursed time. Conversely, I
mistakenly commingled similar materials which were mine when I did office work
at home. Needless to say, I have not kept a rigorous accounting of the whereabouts
of these inexpensive materials. I am certain that I am not alone in these practices.
The examples provided to illustrate this C.FJl. provision demonstrate that abso-
lute prohibitions are impossible or undesirable. Personal telephone caUs and the use
of word processors and photocopying machines are permitted in certain cir-
cumstances when restricted in volume or there is a shared interest in the activity
between the employee and the agency.
B. 5 C.FJl. §2635.705 CTJSE OF OFFICIAL TiME")
Subpart (a) of this companion provision requires government employees to "use
official time in an honest effort to perform official duties." I believe that I have hon-
ored that standard. In fact, the RTC has benefited from dozens of hours of uncom-
pensated overtime that I have donated. A check of sign-out records at the security
desk in our building will confirm the fact that I regularly put in nine hour days.
On some occasions, I stay until 8:00 or 9:00 P.M. I also have invested time in some
work-related projects ^^ adfter hours at home.
Your memorandum accused me of composing allegedly personal items in my
WordPerfect file during business hours. You should know that the stated date and
time in the WordPerfect directories is not always synonymous with composition. For
example, if one accesses a document in order to remember its contents, it is possible
to shortly thereafter exit that file and trigger the current date and time for when
the review occurred. Neither would be probative for showing when the document
was first created or substantially edited. In short, all your print out is capable of
proving is when I last "looked" at a particular document.
Subpart (b) concerns use of a subordinate's time for inappropriate purposes. I do
not believe that issue is relevant to recent events involving my computer. My
present work duties in the Special Projects Section have not required me to make
significant use of the support staff, much less ask them to do improper assignments.
If an)i,hing, the inappropriate use of subordinates is an issue raised by your order
to Mr. Waechter to enter and copy my WordPerfect files. Assuming your mstruction
was improper, then you may be in violation of this provision and subject to adminis-
trative action.
C. RTC Directive Circular 1210.8 ("Disposition of Corporate Documentary
Materials and Personal Papers")
This directive defines the differences between corporate records and personal pa-
pers. Although I presume you attached it to your memorandum because it deals
with personal papers, the directive has little to do with use of corporate facilities
for personal purposes.^ Instead, it governs how one type of personal property (i.e.,
paper) is to be stored in an employee's office. AU the directive requires is that cor-
porate records be filed separately from personed papers. By now, I have achieved
substantial compliance after restoring order to my files following the chaos engen-
dered by four forced moves around downtown Denver between May of 1992 and Jan-
uary of 1993.23
This directive actually undercuts your position that agency employees are not en-
titled to use corporate facilities for any personal use. The directive clearly tfikes no-
tice of the blurred distinction between one's personal and woric environments by ap-
proving employee use of corporate facilities (i.e., offices) to retain private pajpers. It
even provides approved examples such as materitds relating to private affairs or
outside business pursuits, professional aflUiations, diaries, journals, and personal
notes. By doing so, the directive recognizes the privacy interest inherent to private
materials. It even goes so far as to suggest redaction of personal matters from offi-
cial information when both appear in the same document.
**• I have charged personal long distance telephone calls to my own credit card. This practice
is condoned by the same directive you provided — 5 C.F.R. §2635.704(bX2).
2^ These pertain to relocation benefit paperwork, unpaid travel vouchers, and grievance as-
si^ments.
^The directive also sufTers from infirm draftsmanship. Ita "Scope" in paragraph two is lim-
ited to "all Corporation employees upon separation." Thus, the language suggests that the direc-
tive is not binoing on individual employees until they leave the RTC. I assume applicability to
me for purpoees of this memorandum.
^ It also is worth noting that the directive did not become eflFective until afler two of the
moves you ordered. Consequently, I was forced to achieve compliance with a new policy afler
already sustaining two disruptive moves.
396
D. RTC Directive Circular 1360.1 ("Microcomputer Security Poucy")
This directive provides a security policy for RTC computers. I believe that I am
in compliance wim this pronouncement, llie directive, however, fails to give you the
authorization for your search of my computer. Certain portions turtually increase
emplovee expectations of privacy regarding computers while other sections that
vaguely refer to monitoring fail to ofiSet those hei^^tened expectations. In addition.
Directive Circular #1210.8 concerning personal papers further erodes agency efforts
to suggest that employees have no expectations of privacy regarding their comput-
ers, .^reer all, if an employee can store personal information in RTC offices, why not
in RTC computers?
Directive Circular #1360.1 inflates employee privacy expectations regarding com-
puters in several ways. First, the numerous security tips create the impression for
the employee that computers are highly protected means of storing information.
There are admonitions concerning secure communication linkage, log off practices,
access control mechanisms, passwords, screen viewing and unauthorized nersons.
Second, the directive creates a system of "computer poUce" known as the Office of
Corporate Information ("OCF) Security Unit. There also are ADP Security Ofiicers
created in individual offices to ensure security for computers.
At the same time, the directive fails to warn employees that their computers may
not be private storehouses of information. There only are brief references to enforce-
ment 01 the directive in paragraph seven entitled, '(Assurance Procedures." Subpart
(b) merely says that "each Division/Office ADP Security Officer will continuously
monitor, and OCI wUl randomly monitor compliance with microcomputer security
policv." Nothing is said about actual search procedures for employee computer
WordPerfect files. Under what circumstances will searches occur? Who will do
them? Will the employee be notified in advance and asked for consent? This is a
far cry from the ideal: a comprehensive policy statement disseminated by an em-
ployer to all employees defining the circumstances under which monitoring of com-
puter contents will occur. The employer's authority and methods should be defined
so that the privacy expectations created by passwords and other security measures
are tempered.
The final issue crea^d by the directive governing computer security is whether
you had authority to order the search of my computer. Given the directive's warning
that each employee is only to access data and systems they are authorized to enter
as well as provisions for computer police" jurisdiction and reporting of policy viola-
tions to these security officers, your role in searching my computer may have vio-
lated this very directive. OCI omcials or security ofncers should have ordered and
conducted any permissible searches.
E. RTC Directive Circular 2410.1 ("Extensions of Credit")
This directive appears totally irrelevant to use of corporate facilities. It pertains
to extensions of credit from prohibited creditors. I hereby deny any accusation that
I have ever obtained credit from improper sources. The Ethics Office never has ob-
jected to the contents of my financial disclosure forms.
F. Inconsistent Enforcement of Your Impossible Position
Your absolute prohibition on all personal use of corporate facilities is a fiction.
Such an approach is unrealistic, undesirable because enforcement would severely re-
duce employee morale, and not contemplated by RTC directives.
The dissent to the Ortega case provides a thoughtful explanation of why it is im-
possible to neatly separate office business from personal affairs.^ "It is, unfortu-
nately, all too true that the workplace has become another home for most working
Americans. Many employees spend the better pfiot of their days and much of their
evenings at work." Id. at 1509. As a result, the private lives of employees must
intersect with the workplace when personal matters are handled at the ofuce.
No wise manager would seek to ban all personal use of corporate facilities. Astute
employers tjrpicwly permit certain employee activities which are more personal in
nature than totedly work related. These make the work environment more enjoyable
and productive. Social functions which serve to bolster employee morale but which
do not produce tangible work are a good example. For that reason, realistic employ-
ers allow, if not encourage, employees to celebrate birthdays and other special
events (baby showers, (Christmas holiday season, ete.) with decorations and appro-
priate ceremonies. The recent birthday decorations in the work areas for Paulyn
Foster and Francine Ramirez are good examples. In April, one of the conference
rooms was used for a baby shower. Other examples include bake sales, the office
** O'Connor v. Ortega, 107 S.Ct. at 1509-10. Joining the dissent authored by Justice
Blackmun were Justices BrHinan, Marshall, and Stevens.
397
improvement committee, pot hick lundies, and personal notices on office bulletin
boards. Most, if not all, of these events are planned or set up on "company time"
and consume official woric space.
Employees also are permitted to bring in personal objects such as plants, family
pictures, and other decorations althou^ none of the foregoing serve any clearly
measurable business purpose and mav actually take up space on office mmiture
that could be used for more work-related purposes such as stacking documents.
Your office is no different from anv other RTC employee's office. It, too, contains
personal objects such as art wozk, plants, and mementos.
Finally, it bears mentioning again that certain of the directives attached to your
memorandum support the position that certain personal uses of government facili-
ties or equipment are acceptable. These include j>ersonal telephone calls using RTC
equipment and storage of personal papers in RTC offices.
m. Office Morale
Your memorandum asserts in closing that office morale stands to suffer when
some employees are allowed to violate agency directives and others are not. You
refer to equal treatment for all.
These comments are ironic at best. Your own conduct contradicts your position by
reinforcingthe popular perception that a double standard rules the Denver Legal
Division office. Management can do as it pleases. It can rummage through an em-
ployee's computer files, whether or not the search is leral, consistent with agency
directives, or moral. Employees in disfavor, however, are neld to hyper-technical en-
forcement of "rules" as it suits management's ulterior agendas.
More importantly, a telling case can be made that poor management practices are
the single greatest cause of low morale at this field ofiice. Indeed, your conduct since
May of 1992, both as a Transition Team" member and then as Assistant General
"Counsel for the Legal Division at this site, has substantially eroded employee mo-
rale.
Since the disastrous reorganization, all Legal Division employees, professional and
support staff alike, have lived in fear that any action on their part that might dis-
please you or your subordinate managers would result in pumtive treatment. The
infamous "put oack prop-am" was eloquent evidence that those in arbitrary disfavor
stand to lose their positions and reputations for no objective performance-related
reason. Subsequent promotion and administrative practices have reinforced that
perception. Not a single former "put back" has been selected for a management posi-
tion despite at least five vacancies since last November. The example you made of
me and Jackie Taylor with forced moves, physical exile bom the buUcung, and re-
ductions in duties and responsibilities was not lost on our colleagues in the office.
Meanwhile, a patronage system appears to function wherein those in favor who still
remain in-house are promoted and popular "alumni" in private practice are re-
warded with lucrative legal work.
Your latest error in judgment, if I may be charitable, is your invasion of my com-
puter. It is easy to predict a severe setback in office morme when employees learn
that management has broken into a colleague's computer without a reasonable
basis.^* Privacy is a bedrock interest of great concern to all citizens.^® Can un-
founded surprise searches of desk drawers, credenzas, cabinets, purses, and brief-
cases be far behind?
IV. Conclusion
Since joining the RTC in Denver in March of 1991, I have been pro^^ssively ma-
ligned by those intent on conducting a "turf war" within the Legal Division. I en-
deavored to defend myself and my program (Professional Liability) with the truth.
Those efforts were met with your "put oadc" decision last May, second class treat-
ment throughout the summer, and overt retaliation since my testimony before the
U.S. Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs. I took those events in
stride reconciling myself to the reality that insecure people cannot tolerate respect-
ful dissent and competing views on policy matters. My goal, throughout these many
months, wsis to assist interested parties wdth the task of rebuildmg the RTC after
the disastrous reorganization of 1992.
^ Recent newspaper accounts of couueru expressed by Rep. Patricia Schroeder are attached
as Exhibit "O."
^"The employer-employee relationship is a special and fundamental one in our society and
no other relationship, except perhaps marriage, preoccupies daily aflairs so completely." Decker,
Employment Privacy Law for the 1990k, 15 Pepperdine L. Rev. 651, 554 (1988). Indeed, sev-
eral commentators believe that "private may be the principal employment law theme of the
IQQOs." Howe, Minding Your Business: Employer Liability for Invasion of Privacy, 7 The Labor
Lawyer 315, 317 (1991).
398
The most recent example of retaliation, your invasion of my entire WordPerfect
files for no legitimate reason, is not sometning I am willing to overlook. Criminal
statutes, civil liberties, and important public policies are aU involved. The invasion
of my computer occurred under a set of facts that are highly unfavorable to you:
no pre-existing RTC computer eavesdropping policies, no steps to reduce my expec-
tations of privacy, a full scale "fishing expedition' without reasonable basis or de-
fined scope, and an extensive track record of retaliation against me for my whistle-
blowing activities. Your superior sullied himself and the agency with the break-in
order; you did yourself no favors by blindly obeying it. A lawyer, as an "oflicer of
the court," knows better than to issue or implement potentially iUegal or improper
orders.
399
EXHIBITS
"A" through "O"
MEMORANDUM •(): Bruce Pederson
Counsel
FROM: Barbara A. Shangraw/L^
AssisHant General Counsel
DATE: April 26, 1993
SUBJECT: Use of Corporate Facilities
This memo is to confirm the conversation we had on April 23 which
addressed your use of corporate facilities for personal use. I
discussed with you the basis for my concern that you were using the
computers for your personal use, i.e. the E mail which referenced
Mr. Casey and was found at a printer and brought to my attention.
We also discussed the personal items that I then found on your
directory including a personal letter in which you gave out the 800
number for this office so that your friends could call, a letter
that relates to personal business regarding your to%mhome, your
FOIA complaint, etc. The time at which you composed some of the
matters also shows that you are using business hours to conduct
personal business.
We discussed in our meeting the issue of what is considered
personal and you agreed that if there was a question in your mind
of whether you consider something personal in nature, you would
raise it with your Section Chief or with Ellis Merritt. Please
note that your use of corporate facilities in any fashion, be it
computers, telephone, copy machines, typewriters, etc. for personal
use in the future could subject you to disciplinary actions. The
use of these corporate facilities violates 5 C.F.R. Part 2635.704,
RTC Directive Circular 1210.8, RTC Circular 2410.1 and RTC
Directive Circular 1360.1. Attached are copies if you wish to read
them again.
It is important to morale within the office to treat people
equally. Since others are required to follow corporate policies
and directives, it is difficult to manage any office if some are
allowed to violate those policies.
EXHIBIT
>_JL
400
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Sutsject:
Dace:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
T«d AragoneL«9«l-LitfRTC0EN
Krisa D. Hogan^Legal-LitfRTCQEN
Jack Clough9LcgaJ.-Corp«RTCDEN
Battye V. FaraerfLagal-LitSRTCDEN
G«orgia J. Dinsnore9I>«gal-Assets#RTC0Q(
Jackie Taylor#Legal-Asseta*RTCDEN
Bruce Ped«rson#L«gal-Corp9RTC0EN
Casey Shenanigans
Wednesday, February 24, 1993 12:04:05 MST
CASEY3.MIS
N
Greetings fellow "Putback Alumni." Please print the attachment at your
convenience. It contains information that RTC management DOES NOT want you t
know. Casey testified yesterday before a subcommittee of the House Banking
Committee. He lobbied to keep his job so he can make YOU unemployed by
December. Meanwhile, he and his cronies in D.C. are rewarding themselves wit
over a million dollars in "bonuses" for their efforts to strip you of your
job. What a bunch. Does anyone want to bet that Barbara S. will deny knowin
anything about this travesty? I welcome your thoughts.
Bruce
(your eyes and ears back east)
EXHISn*
t B
401
Cppyrighc 1993 Th« Bursau of National Affairs, Inc.
Daily Raport For Exaeutivaa
February 24, 1993, Wednesday
1993 DCR 35 d29
SECTION: REGULATION, ECONOMICS AND LAW; 35.
LENGTH: 1364 words
HEADLINE: RTC, CASEY WILL STAY ON IF CONGRESS AGREES TO SHUT DOWN AGENCY AT
YEAREND
BODY:
Albert Casey, chief executive officer of the Resolution Trust
Corporation, told members of a House Banking subcommittee Feb. 23 that he
would withdraw his resignation and stay on at his post if Congress accepted his
plan to shut down the agency at the end of this year.
Casey, who was responding to questions from Rep. Floyd Flake (D-NY), chairman
of the newly formed Subcommittee on General Oversight, Investigations and the
Resolution of Failed Financial Institutions, said that, in any case, he would
remain at the RTC helm until a successor was found and confirmed to the
position.
Casey's resignation, announced Feb. 17, is effective April 1 (32 DER A-16,
2/19/93). He plans to resume his teaching career at the business school of
Southern Methodist University, in Texas in the fall.
"I could stay until the school term begins to handle any crisis," he said.
Casey, a Republican, is a political appointee, and says he expects to be
replaced by the new administration with a Democrat. However, the subcommittee is
considering whether it might be better to ask Casey to stay on an extra eight
months to oversee the sunsetting of his agency.
The subcommittee chairman told SNA that any atten.pt to pass an RTC funding
bill this session must include assurances to members that the agency will close
this year and, therefore, will not be back to ask for more money.
The RTC has been without funds to pay for the sale of failed thrifts since
Congress voted down a S 42 billion funding bill on April 1, 1992. Now, a revised
estimate from the agency says S 25 billion will do the job.
However, recent scandals, such as the RTC's high-priced contract with Price
Waterhouse for photocopying services, have exacerbated the problem of getting
funding votes. Flake said.
"If there was a vote today, a funding bill could pass the Banking Committee,
but it would not get through the whole Congress," Flake said.
What will make a difference, he said, would be to tell members that the RTC
"will go out of business this year."
EXHIBIT
« c
]
) 402
PAGE 3
f Dally Report For Executives, February 24, 1993
Not Everyone Believes in Early Sunset
This view of sunsetting the agency this year was not shared, however, by Rep.
Charles Schumer (D-NY), a member of the House Banking Committee but not the
oversight subcommittee-
While visiting the hearing, Schumer said that it might be a terrible mistake
to either scrap the agency and start a new one — as Rep. Bruce Vento (D-Minn) has
suggested — or follow through on any fixed termination date. The RTC is
required by law to shut down by Dec. 31, 1996.
In either case, changing the status quo would disrupt employees and the work
they are trying to do, Schumer said. If the RTC is folded into the Federal
Deposit Insurance Corp., as Casey has suggested, it might set off turf battles
or simple disagreements that cause further disruptions between RTC and FDIC
personnel, he said.
Casey told the subcommittee that if the RTC finished up this year, it would
transfer its legal and asset sales divisions to the FDIC. RTC officials expect
to have about S 40 billion to S 60 billion in assets remaining to be sold at the
end of 1993. Its legal work "will go on forever," he said.
Richard Aboussie, RTC acting general counsel, said at the hearing that the
agency has about 65,000 open legal matters right now, which are not all law
suits. These include transactions, closings, and examinations of contracts, he
said.
If it closed down, the RTC would save taxpayers about $ 360 million
annually in salaries alone, Casey said.
Rep. Toby Roth (R-Wis), the subcommittee's ranking Republican, asked Casey to
submit a detailed copy of the RTC's plan to close down operations by the end
of the year.
Both Flake and Roth also said they supported adding a provision to an RTC
funding bill that would change the agency's governing structure so that the
president and chief executive officer was no longer a "sole member corporation,"
without whom the agency shuts down.
Casey said Congress set the RTC up that way to keep it independent from the
Treasury Department, but added that he agreed it should be changed so that the
senior vice presidents have the authority to keep the agency running without
him.
Excessive Bonuses Questioned
Rep. Stephen Neal (D-NC), chairman of the financial institutions subcommittee
of the Banking Committee, visited the hearing to ask Casey about the excessive
bonuses he paid 136 RTC executive level employees earlier this year for their
work in 1992.
Although he realizes that bonuses are a "legitimate management tool," Neal
said he had an obligation to get Casey's explanation on the record.
403
I Daily Report For Executives, February 24, 1993
PAGE
Neal said that he learned that 32 RTC employees received bonuses of more
than S 10,000, of which five were greater than S 20,000, and two were more than
S 25,000.
Total bonuses, paid in 1993 for 1992 performance, totaled over S 1 million,
Neal said, compared to the 1991 performance payout of S 444,000.
Casey acknowledged the bonuses, saying that the greatest amounts went to
himself, who was paid less than the amount he agreed to, and his two senior vice
presidents, who he said saved taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars.
Casey Defends Sales and Contracts
Casey also defended the RTC's sales strategies, saying that without
high-volume sales methods such as securitization and portfolio sales, the RTC
would not be able to meet its statutory 1996 sunset date, nor maximize returns
for taxpayers. Mounting holding and asset management costs would offset
improvements in price, if any, from slower, retail sales methods, Casey said.
As required by the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement
Act of 1989, the RTC relies on the services of the private sector for the
performance of most of its activities. The agency has issued more than 100,000
contracts with estimated fees of about S 3 billion since its inception.
"This extensive use of private sector contractors, while necessary, exposes
the RTC to waste, fraud and abuse," Casey said.
"The corporation has therefore given the highest priority to establishing an
internal control structure to monitor the awarding of its contracts and the
performance of its contractors to ensure full performance at a fair price."
Price Waterhouse Contract
The Price Waterhouse contract for work done at HomeFed Bank in California
"does not represent a system breakdown," Casey said.
While conceding that some mistakes were made in the issuance of the task
order for this contract, Casey said that it was awarded competitively, the work
was extensively overseen by RTC employees, and the work fulfilled the
requirements of the contract.
The renegotiated contract with Price Waterhouse, announced Feb. 17, is
expected to result in savings of $ 4 million, Casey said, bringing the total
bill to about 5 20 million. As he told the Senate Banking Committee Feb. 19, the
RTC chief said that this will reduce photocopying charges from 67 cents a page
to 37 cents a page.
In hindsight, Casey said, it would have been wise to renegotiate the contract
terms at the time the agency realized that the scope of the contract was
expanded beyond its original understanding.
Also, he said, the agency should have included a "not to exceed" clause in
the contract that set a limit on expenditures without further review and
approval. The RTC's contracting procedures require such clauses, Casey said,
"and this experience will not be repeated."
404
Daily Report For Executives, February 24, 1993
PACE
Casey also defended the RTC against allegations that it has a "get it done
at any cost attitude" about case resolutions or asset sales. While there have
been isolated cases where RTC procedures have not been followed, "in most
cases, this has been due to honest mistakes, not a desire to cut corners to get
things done," he said.
In response to a question, Casey acknowledged that the RTC received a claim
from HomeFed's holding company — which is in bankruptcy — as a creditor, alleging
that the agency, as receiver of HomeFed Bank, undervalued real estate owned,
which cost the holding company S 5 billion.
An RTC spokeswoman said that the credit claim was filed Oct. 13, 1992, and
the agency has six months to respond.
405
• PACE 6
2IID STORY of L«v«l 1 princ«d in FULL format.
Copyright (c) The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc., 1993
BNA BANKING DAILY
Feb. 24, 1993
LENGTH: 14 S9 words
TEXT:
RTC
CASEY WILL STAY ON AT RTC IF CONGRESS
AGREES TO SHUT DOWN AGENCY AT YEAREND
WASHINGTON (BNA) — Albert Casey, chief executive of the thrift cleanup
agency, told members of a House Banking subcommittee Feb. 23 that he would
withdraw his resignation and stay on at his post if Congress accepted his
plan to shut down the agency at the end of this year.
Casey, who was responding to questions from Rep. Floyd Flake (D-NY),
chairman of the newly formed Subcommittee on General Oversight,
Investigations and the Resolution of Failed Financial Institutions, said
that, in any case, he would remain at the RTC helm until a successor was
found and confirmed to the position.
Casey's resignation, announced Feb. 17, is effective April 1 (60 BBR 230,
2/22/93). In the fall, he plans to resume his teaching career at the business
school of Southern Methodist University, in Texas.
"I could stay until the school term begins to handle any crisis," he said.
Casey, a Republican, is a political appointee, and says he expects to be
replaced by the new administration with a Democrat. However, the subcommittee
is considering whether it might be better to ask Casey to stay on an extra
eight months to oversee the sunsetting of his agency.
The subcommittee chairman told BNA that any attempt to pass an RTC funding
bill this session must include assurances to members that the agency will
close this year and, therefore, will not be back to ask for more money.
The RTC has been without funds to pay for the sale of failed thrifts since
Congress voted down a S42 billion funding bill on April 1, 1992. Now, a
revised estimate from the agency says S25 billion will do the job.
However, recent scandals, such as the RTC's high-priced contract with
Price Waterhouse for photocopying services, have exacerbated the problem of
getting funding votes. Flake said.
"If there was a vote today, a funding bill could pass the (Banking)
Committee, but it would not get through the whole Congress," Flake said.
What will make a difference, he said, would be to tell members that the
RTC "will go out of business this year."
Not Everyone Believes in Early Sunset
406
• PAGE 7
BNA BANKING DAILY (c) BNA, Inc. Fab. 24, 1993
This view of sunsetcing the agency this year was not shared, however, by
Rep. Charles Schumer (D-NY), a member of the House Banking Committee but not
the oversight subcommittee.
While visiting the hearing, Schumer said that it might be a terrible
mistake to either scrap the agency and start a new one — as Rep. Bruce Vento
(D-Minn) has suggested (60 BBR 171, 2/8/93) — or follow through on any fixed
termination date. (The RTC is required by law to shut down by Dec. 31, 1996.)
In either case, changing the status quo would disrupt employees and the
work they are trying to do, Schumer said. If the RTC is folded into the
Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., as Casey has suggested, it might set off
turf battles or simply honest disagreements that cause further disruptions
between RTC and FDIC personnel, he said.
Casey explained to the subcommittee that if the RTC finished up this year,
it would transfer its legal and asset sales divisions to the FDIC. RTC
officials expect to have about S40 billion to $50 billion in assets remaining
to be sold at year-end 1993. And its legal work "will go on forever," he said.
Richard Aboussie, RTC acting general counsel, said at the hearing that the
agency has about 65,000 open legal matters right now, which are not all law
suits. These include transactions, closings, and examinations of contracts,
he said.
If it closed down, the RTC would save taxpayers about S360 million
annually in salaries alone, Casey said.
Rep. Toby Roth (R-Wis), the subcommittee's ranking Republican, asked Casey
to submit a detailed copy of the RTC's plan to close down operations by
year-end .
Both Flake and Roth also said they supported adding a provision to an RTC
funding bill that would change the agency's governing structure so that the
person who was president and chief executive officer was no longer a "sole
member corporation," without whom, the agency shuts down.
Casey explained that Congress set the RTC up that way to keep it
independent from the Treasury Department, but added that he agreed it should
be changed so that the senior vice presidents have the authority to keep the
agency running without him.
Excessive Bonuses Questioned
Rep. Stephen Neal (D-NC) , chairman of the financial institutions
subcommittee of the Banking Committee, visited the hearing to ask Casey about
the excessive bonuses he paid 136 RTC executive level employees earlier this
year for their work in 1992.
Although he realizes that bonuses are a "legitimate management tool," Neal
said he had an obligation to get Casey's explanation on the record.
Neal said that he learned that 32 RTC employees received bonuses of more
than 310,000, of which five were greater than 320,000, and two were more than
407
PACE
BNA BANKING DAILY (C) SNA, Inc. Feb. 24, 1993
S2S,000.
Total bonuaca, paid in 1993 for 1992 performance, totaled over SI million,
Neal aaid, compared to the 1991 performance payout of S444,000.
Caaey acknowledged the generous bonuses, saying that the greatest amounts
went to himself, who was paid less than the amount he agreed to, and his two
senior vice presidents, whom he said saved taxpayers hundreds of milliona
with the work they did.
Casey Defends Sales and Contracts
Casey also defended the RTC's sales strategies, saying that without
high-volume sales methods such as securitization and portfolio sales, the RTC
would not be able to meet its statutory 1996 sunset date, nor maximize
returns for taxpayers. Mounting holding and asset management costs would
offset improvements in price, if any, from slower, retail sales methods,
Caaey said.
As required by the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and
Enforcement Act of 1989, the RTC relies on the services of the private sector
for the performance of most of its activities. The agency has issued more
than 100,000 contracts with estimated fees of about $3 billion since its
inception.
"This extensive use of private sector contractors, while necessary,
exposes the RTC to waste, fraud and abuse," Caaey said.
"The Corporation has therefore given the highest priority to establishing
an internal control structure to monitor the awarding of its contracts and
Che performance of its contractors to ensure full performance at a fair
price. "
Price Waterhouse Contract
The Price Waterhouse contract for work done at HomeFed Bank in California
"does not represent a system breakdown," Casey said.
While admitting that some mistakes were made in the issuance of the task
order for this contract, Casey said that it was awarded competitively, the
work was extensively overseen by RTC employees, and the work fulfilled the
requirements of the contract.
The renegotiated contract with Price Waterhouse, announced Feb. 17, is
expected to result in savings of S4 million, Casey said, bringing the total
bill to about S20 million. As he told the Senate Banking Committee Feb. 19,
the RTC chief said that this will reduce photocopying charges from 67 cents a
page to 37 cants a page.
In hindsight, Casey said, it would have been wise to renegotiate the
contract terms at the time the agency realized that the scope of the contract
was expanded beyond its original understanding.
Also, he said, the agency should have included a "not to exceed" clause
in the contract that set a limit on expenditures without further review and
408
PACE 9
■ BNA BANKING DAILY (c) SNA, Inc. Feb. 24, 1993
approval. The RTC's contracting procedures require such clauses, Casey said,
"and this experience will not be repeated."
Casey also defended the RTC against allegations that it has a "get it done
at any cost attitude" about case resolutions or asset sales. While there have
been isolated cases where RTC procedures have not been followed, "in most
cases, this has been due to honest mistakes, not a desire to cut corners to
get things done," he said.
In response to a question, Casey acknowledged that the RTC received a
claim from HomeFed's holding company — which is in bankruptcy— as a creditor,
alleging that the agency, as receiver of HomeFed Bank, undervalued real
estate owned, which cost the holding company S5 billion.
An RTC spokeswoman said that the credit claim was filed Oct. 13, 1992, and
the agency has six months to respond.
409
To: Richard T. Aboussie«Legal-sc#RTCDC
Cc:
Bcc: I
From: Bruca PedersonfLegal-Corp6RTCDEN
Subject: Inquiry
Date: Tuesday, April 27, 1993 16:29:37 MDT
Attach:
Certify: V
Forwarded by:
I am writing to respectfully ask whether you were the Washington, D.C.
official who requested that Assistant General Counsel Barbara Shangraw gain
access to my computer and review ny word perfect files. I believe that this
action was initiated on or about March 12, 1993. Thank you.
Bruce Pederson
To: Bruce Pederson#Legal-Corp§RTCDEN
Cc:
Bcc:
Fro»: MSeRTCDC21§SERVERS
Subject: Confirmation of Receipt
Date: Wednesday, April 26, 1993 5:22:33 MDT
Attach :
Certify:
Forwarded by:
To: Richard T. Aboussie#Legal-sc§RTCDC
Cc:
Subject: Inquiry
The above message has been received by:
Richard T. AboussieeLegal-sc§RTCDC
EXHiBrr
IP
410
To:
Cc:
Bcc: '
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John WaechtereiMFOeRTCDEN
Barbara Shangraw«L«9al-Corp0RTCOEN
Friday, March 12, 1993 15:56:10 MST
Y
EXHIBfT
£
I have been requested by D.C. to get inco Bruce Pede.rson's vrord perfect,
copy into a directory for me what Bruce has in his word perfect.
Plea:
.*..* WARNING
UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS TO THIS UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT COMPUTER
SYSTEM AND/OR SOFTWARE IS PROHIBITED BY PUBLIC LAW 98-473.
Public Law 98-473, Chapter XXI, Paragraph 1030 states that,
"Whoever knowingly accesses a computer without authorization,
or having knowingly accessed a computer with authorization,
...obtains..., uses, modifies, destroys, or discloses..., or
prevents authorized use of (data or a computer owned by or
operated for) the Government of the United States ... shall be
punished (by)... a f ine. .. or ... imprisonment. "
The punishments range up to 3100,000 and 10 years, depending
upon the nature and extent of the violation.
REPORT UNAUTHORIZED USE OR ACCESS TO YOUR SECURITY OFFICER
* * * ♦ *
WARNING
Press any key to continue
You are logging in as Bruce Pederson§Legal-CorD§RTCDEN.
EXHIBIT
It's Wednesday, i-:ay 5, 1993 15:29:47 MDT.
I'our last login was on Wednesday, .'lay 5, 1S93 9: IS: 30 MDT.
Drive P: => Fs?rivate43DEN04@RTCDEN
Drive J: => FsLglConmoniaDEN'04?RTCDEN
Drive S: => FsApplic4@DEM0-4eRTC::EN
PC color: => ON
Printer LPTl: => PSR38 . 01@DEN04@RTCDEN
Mail service => Post Of f iceeRTCDEN04gServers
You have 2 new .mail nessages. Use t.'ie MAIL program to read them
411
To:
Cc:
Bcc: I
From:
Subject:
Dace:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Barbara Shangraw^Legal-CorpeRTCDEN
JacKie Taylor«Legal-Proj9RTCDEKRF
Bruce PederseneLegal-ProjflRTCOENRF
Trust
Wednesday, Septeaber 9, 1992 15:34:59 MDT
I want to continue on with our efforts to engender greater trust of one
another. Towards that end, I have a short list of questions that I would like
to pose. They arise from concerns expressed by professional colleagues,
friends, and legal counsel; as well as from occasional yet inexplicable
circumstances which stand out. The questions are intended to include Jackie
Taylor and me (the collective "we" in the questions) .
1. Have we been the subject of physical surveillance at any time
since 1/1/92?
2. Have our electronic mail boxes been monitored, and their contents read,
for incoming or outgoing EMail traffic at any time since 1/1/92?
3. Have our telephones been tapped or monitored at any time since 1/1/92?
4. Has our personal mail been ooened, screened, or withheld at any time since
1/1/92?
In the spirit of full disclosure, I need to tell you that I am planning to also
send a Freedom of Information Act request to the RTC which will touch on many
of these issues. I am prepared to trust your answers but need to hold the
agency to a position. For example, you may not be in a position to know what
Jeff did during his tenure or what Legal Division officials in Washington, D.C.
have done without notice to you. In short, the FOIA request is intended to put
the agency on record.
I hope you understand the spirit in which this EMAIL request is sent to
you. I am attempting to "clear the air." So much hurt and distrust has
arisen in the past 120 days. I know of no other means of dealing with this
problem. Thanks.
Sruce
412
To: Bernard Brods)ty#Legal-Lit§RTCDEN
Cc: Albert V. Casey §CEO?RTCDC
Sichard T. AboussieeLegal-sc§RTCDC
Ira H. Par)cer§Legal-liteRTCDC
I Thomas L. Hindes^Legal-plsgRTCDC
Mark Gabrellian§Legal-pls#RTCDC
James Densmore@Executive@RTCD£N
Jon Karlson§Executive3RTCDENC0
Barbara ShangrawgLegal-CorpgRTCDEN
Robert Ward§Legal-Lit§RTCDEN
James R. DudineeOper-invgRTCDC
Ron Schiraeinvestigations^RTCDEN
John J. Adair§IG§RTCDC, Wayne Zigler§OIG@RTCDEN
See:
From: Jackie Taylor§Legal-Proj§RTCDENRF
Subject: Your Documents Assignments
Date: Monday, October 19, 1992 17:00:11 MDT
Attach:
Certify: Y
Forwarded by:
You have stated that you intend to stop by our offices Tuesday morning at 9am
to "inspecr our files", thus sparing us the requirement of transporting them
to your office and presumably from preparing an index. You, as a manager, are
welcome to stop by anytime you wish. Please, however, be advised that we have
not yet commenced an inventory of the documents, therefore, your visit is
inconvenient and premature. We have not been allowed sufficient time to
prepare an inventory due to the fact that we have been diligently preparing
our written response to your written demands concerning the handling of PLS
cases. _j
Furthermore, be advised that neither of us will grant you our permission to^^
rummage through our files, desks, offices, etc. on your own. Because of the
circumstances of the many forced moves we have been through since the
reorganization, many of our files have been commingled with personal papers.
We seek to separate the two categories of documents. Until we have had an
opportunity to do so, we have an expectation of privacy to the majority of
files in our offices.
Please let us know how you would like to proceed. Our recommendation is that
we be permitted to complete our reply to Mr. Casey's testimony before we are
forced to do this extensive document assignment. Our reply to the testimony is
a tine sensitive project with a fast approaching deadline. You have been given
tile fact specific information you requested regarding our earlier testimony.
That was the most time sensitive matter you have assigned to us. We believe
that any other prioritization will constitute an effort to block us from
preparing a response by keeping us so busy with going through documents in our
offices that we are effectively blocked from complying with the Senate's
request. We think that most reasonable persons, including Chairman Riegle,
would interpret this as a sign of retaliation, something both he and CEO Casey
have said will not happen.
We will await your E.Mail response on Tuesday morning. Thank you.
Sruce and Jackie
?.S. For the benefit of the OIG officials who continue to be copied on this
exchange of e-mails, we have recently met with and continue to fully cooperate
with representatives of the OIG in their investigation of PLS and review of
the Fact Sheet.
413
To: Bruce Pedersen#L«gal-Proj§RTCDENRP
Cc:
Bcc: ^
Froa: Barbara Shangraw?Legal-CorpeRTCDEN
Subject: re: Trust
Data: Friday, September 11, 1992 11:33:34 MDT
Attach:
Certify: Y
Forwarded by:
Obviously, I can only respond regarding what I know.
I am not aware of any physical surveillance.
I am not aware of any £ mail monitoring.
I am not aware of any phone tapping.
I have instructed those who process your mail to send you anything marked
personal and confidential unopened. If there were items that were not so
marked, they were opened. If there was an item marked personal and
confidential that was opened, that is contrary to any directions that I have
given.
I can't speak for the IG or the GAO or any other entity out there nor can I
speak to anything of which I have no knowledge.
414
September 12, 1992
Resolution Trust Corporation
FOIA/PA Branch
International Place
173 5 North Lynn Street
Rosslyn, Virginia 22209
Dear Sir or Madam:
This letter is a request, pursuant to the Freedom of Information
Act and the Privacy Act (if applicable), for information contained
in the categories listed in the second paragraph of this letter.
The request covers any pertinent information maintained in hard
copy records (such as memoranda, reports, files, printed electronic
mail messages, notes, work papers), stored electronic mail
messages, computer directories and tapes, or floppy disks.
The requested categories of information are:
1. TELEPHONE MOMITORING.
Any and all information pertaining to the monitoring of the RTC
office telephones used by Bruce J. Pederson and Jacqueline P.
Taylor. These numbers are designated as (303) 291-3503, (303) 620-
8153, and (303) 291-5838 for Bruce J. Pederson; and (303) 291-4744,
(303) 620-8140, (303) 291-5718, and (303) 556-6711 for Jacqueline
P. Taylor. Monitoring is defined to mean the tracking of incoming
and/or outgoing calls by telephone number, quantity, or length of
call; and/or actual eavesdropping to listen to the contents of a
conversation. Specifically, we seek information relating to:
A. Who recommended monitoring our work telephones.
B. Who approved any monitor ing activity.
C. Dates when the monitoring was in effect.
D. Who performed the monitoring.
E. What information was gathered from the nonitoring.
We believe that such information may be contained in written
memoranda prepared by senior Legal Division officials, telephone
logs or files maintained by receptionists, and files genej-ated by
employees in the RTC Office of Inspector General.
EXHIBFT
415
-2-
2. ELECTRONIC MESSAGE MOKITORIKG.
Any and all information pertaining to the monitoring of the RTC
electronic mailboxes used by Bruce J. Pederson and Jacqueline P.
Taylor. These are currently designated by the "street talk" names
of Bruce Pedersen§Legal-Proj§RTCDENRF and Jackie Taylor §Legal-
Proj§RTCDENRF. This request also includes monitoring of any prior
"street talk" names used since January 1, 1992. Monitoring is
defined to mean the tracking of incoming and/or outgoing electronic
mail messages by sender, recipient, or quantity; and/or actual
eavesdropping by reviewing the contents of the electronic mail
messages. Specifically, we seek information relating to:
A. Who recommended monitoring our electronic mailboxes.
B. Who approved any monitoring activity.
C. Dates when the monitoring was in effect.
D. Who performed the monitoring.
E. What information was gathered from the monitoring.
We believe that such information may be contained in written
memoranda prepared by senior Legal Division officials, logs or
files maintained by ISU personnel, and files generated by employees
of the RTC Office of Inspector General.
3. MAIL MONITORING.
Any and all information pertaining to the monitoring of any
incoming mail addressed to Bruce J. Pederson and Jacqueline P.
Taylor. The primary address used on the mail is: RTC-Legal
Division, 1225 17th Street, Denver, CO 80209. This request also is
intended to encompass any other Denver metropolitan area addresses
used by the RTC (e.g. . 707 17th Street, Denver, CO 80209) .
Monitoring is defined to mean tracking of incoming mail by sender,
contents or quantity; and/ or the actual opening of the mail for a
review of the contents. Specifically, we seek information relating
to:
A. Who recommended monitoring our incoming mail.
B. Who approved any monitoring activity.
C. Dates when the monitoring was in effect.
D. Who performed the monitoring.
E. What information was gathered from the monitoring.
416
• -3-
We bell«v« that such information aay b« contained in written
nemoranda prepared by senior Legal Division officials, logs or
files maintained by mail room personnel, and files generated by
employees of the RTC Office of Inspector General.
4. PHYSICAL SroVBILIAMCg.
Any and all information pertaining to the monitoring of the
physical presence of Bruce J. Pederson and Jacqpieline P. Taylor in
the course of their RTC employment at the Republic Plaza or ARCO
Tower offices. Monitoring is defined to mean the physical
surveillance of Bruce J. Pederson or Jacqueline P. Taylor for the
purpose of ascertaining the location and ostensible activity of
these employees. Specifically, we seek information relating to:
A. Who recommended physical surveillance.
B. Who approved any surveillance activity.
C. Dates when physical surveillance was in effect.
D. Who performed the surveillance.
E. What information was gathered from the surveillance.
We believe that such information may be contained in written
memoranda prepared by senior Legal Division officials, logs or
files maintained by non-legal personnel sharing floor space with
Bruce J. Pederson or Jacqueline P. Taylor, and files generated by
employees of the RTC Office of Inspector General.
We look forward to a timely reply within the statutory response
period. Please let us know in advance whether search and/or
copying costs will exceed $25.00. Thank you for your assistance.
We can be reached at the addresses and telephone numbers which
follow our signatures.
Sincerely,
•5^-<v^v^4,- ,y**T^^^ '■ "^''
n
Bruce J. Pederson Jacqueline P. Taylor
175 South Jackson #1 P.O. Box 4077
Denver, CO 80209 31739 Quarter Horse Rd.
Work (303) 291-3503 Evergreen, CO 80439
Home (303) 394-3948 Work (303) 291-4744
Home (303) 674-9864
417
March 17, 1993
RTC Office of the Secretary
FOIA/PA Branch
1735 N. Lynn Street
Rosslyn, VA 22209
Re: Appeal for RTC FOIA /92-1101
Dear Mr. Lindexmuth:
We have received yoiir notification, dated February 19, 1993, that
no agency records responsive to the siibject FOIA request have been
found. This letter constitutes our appeal, under the Freedoa of
Inforaation Act, of your conclusion. It is tlaely subaitted within
thirty days of your initial determination.
We believe that agency records responsive to our FOIA request do
exist. 0\ir request should be interpreted in the following Banner:
We seeX records depicting any decisions by any RTC employee to
monitor us (i.e. . our use of telephones, electronic mail or other
computer data bases, regular mails, physical comings and goings).
Such records would include any decisions by RTC personnel to access
regularly maintained information (such as call detail reports, word
perfect contents, electronic mailbox contents, telephone message
logs, etc.) using our names, telephone numbers, computer streettalX
designations, etc. Such records would also include decisions by
RTC personnel to trac)c our whereabouts within the office. At this
time, we are not seeking the underlying databases.
It would be most productive to search Legal Division files in
Washington, D.C. and Denver, Colorado. The following individuals
would be most likely to possess responsive records: Richard
Aboussie, Ira Parker, Gleon Curtis, Barbara Shangraw, Robert Ward,
Ellis Merritt, Herb Messite, Michael Nelson, and Deanna Whisman.
Other offices within RTC which deal with various modes of
communication may also have such documents in their possession
(e.g. . administrative support units for the Legal Division,
Information Services Units ("ISU") , and mail rooms).
We also respectfully ask that the Acting General Counsel, Richard
Aboussie, be recused from ruling on this appeal. His conduct may
very well be implicated by the records sought in this FOIA request.
418
-2-
If you have any questions, please contact us at the teleohone
nuabers listed below our signatures. Thank you in advance for
processing our FOIA request, as further defined in this letter.
Bruce J. Pederson
175 S. Jackson St. /I
Denver, CO 80209
(303) 291-4651 Work
(303) 394-3948 Hone
^cqueline P. Taylor
P. O. Box 4077
Evergreen, CO 80439
(303) 291-4773 Work
(303) 674-9864 Hoae
419
RTC
tttmtvfmm fy»>f g«#»*»«wa<t
173S ■. 1.1«w txrmmX
toutm, V* ZZ20*
(703) «ai-«1M
■ TO nuosoa or
ACT (rozA) or
PKTTXCT ACT (PA) RZQOZST
uuoLirrzoii TsasT corpo&atzov
tie Mu ■ n-noi
I 'Inat
j«c^»Hw y. Jwrim- md Iw J.
•tliwF^t^rUr
1». 199J
■o <iwci r^cw^ i*Ai<ct to t^ raouxt h«v^ OMn loc«tad. If wu conaidvr t*i« « awttsl. ■•« >«rt 11. C.
vmrm locifd foe ppfticwa of tfw r^quwt. (>•» ea— nti — ettow, >>rt 1-1 ind Otft ll.C.)
■o oalltlarwl
focwui MAfoet to tlM roQjooc how* bo«i localod.
otod rocordi pro ovo< latoio throw^w lootwr oUaMe dturibution pr^r— (too c^Bonto ooctivM.
niU conflrao tout Offo^Hnt wttft scoff of cKo roiA/V* Imft tfiot v«j ctorHlod or roformilotod yoi^ r««joot to
bo for tho foco«Ui ooocrlboa in tho eoMont* ooction boioM or th« octotf>od acporidliCtoo).
Tho roquoot hoa boon roforrod for
by onothor oson. » ,
tocoroi ot^ioct to tho r
(••o cooaonts ooction).
•t Kovo boon roforrod to th* roooonolbio nonc>(«oo) for roviow ond diroct roooonoo.
Afoncv I w,u<tM OiAjoct to tho roojoot thot oro idontlffod boiow or on tho attocfvod A£pondix(io«} oro or wil( bo
onUoelo for public inMvction ond capr>n« ot ITO loodint looo, 90) 17tll St., I.W., uoonlniton, O.C. 20U4-
00O1. Notxn oro froH 9 o.a. Co i D.a. Nondoy throu^ frfday, and tA* tolofifMno n^otr lo (202) 4)A>0940. M
aadictonai acttvi on your port it nocooaary. THo loodin* Ioob staff viU aoao tlM acvrocrioto eopioo and ■■■i
CtMB to you occovontod by an invoico for a dL»(ication fo* of twonCY eonca par pava.
Tho b<d oyHory cnot y«u oflrood to oecopt in a conworoocton otch o a^Bor of mf otaff k..j <■ ancloood or
' lo ovo(lab(o for public inaooccion and cooyinf at CM ITC loadtn« looo. ooo Soetlon 9.
10.
11.
12.
Sponcy rocoroa Idantlftod boiow or qn cfio attachod aapand1«( loo) aro ancloood.
Eneioood ia tr\ ifwoico for rpqLiaH procoooinp faoo (— o attod^od)
J L
fK« oo»aant in aacosa of actual fo«a hi (I bo roftfvlod in tho Mo^t of \
PMT II.A iiFocwriai V1TBCLD rata na).ic nmrmwt
Corcam inforwotion in tho roojoatod rocordi la boine oithhold froa public diacloouro purouonc to tho a>aivtian<a)
daocribod in ond for tuo rooaon(al Itatod In Oart II. • of thia rooponoa. ^^
InMsadl aa yaw i aiiMir tmt aiAalttad iaificty, w aro i aapmilint itlei Ikia ain(lo, canaalldalad loTtor, a«»aaaad to yau boai.
Us ka»a Incorprvtod yaw ravjoat to bo for no i-| racar* rolotina Co olloaad lolo^sw anitorln*, olactronic Bit aooaaao
aanitorlm, aoU aonlcorirq, nl (Sryoical ax-aaillanca diraccod aoocificallr ot oidtor or bat* o< you otkaraio* than in am
m^itmry oo»-*o br rlrtua of ymr i^iloiajii raloliononip oith tho ITC. T)u, o.i., call drtall nvorco (iMIc* Hot CM t<H,
^ration sM tolsKMM im^bor callod fr^ ^c* tolwnm tolt in no ITC), aloctranic i*u*aaa rautlnaly tracslna oil fo^v^l
m Blllnas incaatni ta Ika Oamar Fiold Offica, 9>ano aaoaaaaa natod by otMr asMoyaaa In yaw Mum ■ ar on y««'
baSMlf, and poller atataama rapardlm Mil roia |» iiusa m >ora canaiMrad Co bo bo nasi CM aova of yatf- i asaoc. tfa * not
poiHaaa ony aaaia i ioljwiM ra^HWiwa Co yata* rai—c oo incorprvlod. H yau aia* Co i aiMot occaao Co call *ta(l raporta for
pwcicular colau»»a naoais or Co foraii» cmsminp ollovad aanitorim ond su->aillanca octiyltiaa not apoclflcally dirocTod
oc oitJwr or baO of y«i, yau aay oiAoic o rm, FOU raojaat for tMt intaroacim. ^laaaa ba airload. %i a or. CMC
ilo diraet oases aay M aasaciocod aicn snr Stan rai*
SiV«n«-o, Aiof, POIA/M Irwirt
ITC 1023/03 (2-93)
420
USTOMI TO TOIX OS tX KIQOUT
«l-ii*i
MCT It. I i»»i.icaau UMHio
l<car« KAjact t* Om rt^mtt ttMt ar* OMcrtbad an tM <ne(*Md <«pand1a(l*sl ar* bain* iritMMld partlallr ar Miallr wnar
«>• «M»tl»» »^ tar ma rn Mt fart* b»la», piraiant te CTw fOlk a« > u.l.C. WiZtb) «r »« >« at S u.t.C. HSiaOl.
1. THa atttJiald Infaf tian U pranaftY claaattlad px-nant ta U»CMtli»« Ordar. m»TIM IbKI)
2. Tl>a althkald lnfara«t>a« falataa aalalr to tM lnt»'-»l
a«t»a wicmc. a. (bid)
1. Tha atttinald ^n«e^^^l^^ l« icacmcallY aiaaptad fi-aa pi^He dtacla
br tua atatuta Indlcataa: tx. (b){3>
4, TIM altMwld Infaraatlan U • trada aacrat ar
(a) Indleatad: PS»Tiai (bl(tl
clal ar financial InfarMtlan OMC la halna MitklMid far tIM
"+-
Tlia In^araaticn la canaldarad ta taa a trada aacr
' Blaclaaur* at t«>a Infaraatlan aould llkatr tmm* aaaatamlal
ttar mi tMa Inforvatlan.
I Olacloaw^ »i tM Ifrfaraatlan aauld llkaly laoair tM nc'a abllltr t« oDUln aiallar lirtaraatlan In tM ftitva
! ana/er l^lr ttia ttC'l pratrM a«<aetl»afa«.
S. TM althMId lnfar«atian eanalata el lntar-a«aney ar Intra-
durint lltlpatlaw. CXPPTlai (bxl) >ap(ltacla prtvllada!
tbat ar« nat aMikaMa tkrai^ dtainiiri
i ballbaratlva praeaaa prlvlla^a. (TM prWIlafa (1) ara'a»*adM avan. frank Intamal dlarralana «i aartari af
I policy; (2) protactt adalnat praaatva diaclaaura af pnainid padclaa; and (3) pracacta aaainat pi«<lc canfiMix
t tMt raaulta fr^ dlaeiaai«^ af i liiui'a and ratlanalaa that itmrm naf In fact uttlaatalT tna iratf^A af an aaan i i
) aetlan.) Utar* ttw racarm ara altKMId In tMIr antirarr, ttM facta ara InaatrleaMv IntarTainad alHi tM
daMbaratJYa Inforaattcn mo ralaaaa af t^a facta aoutd parait an ir^ract inmirr Inra tM* datlbaratlva aracaaa.)
' »ttamar-ellant prlvHaaa. (TM prlYllaaa oratacta canfldantlal eaoMjrtcatlawa batnaan an attamay and ellant.)
' C iMirilal prWIlaaa. (TM pri»lla»a prataeta tM ITC fr«« bain* »laead at a
titlaa dti
a.)
6. Tha vUNhald infooMdan U aia^t fnm piAtlc dtacla
^^Marrancad Invaaion of privacv. EUlVTtOk (b)(*l
It* dfaelaatra aould canatltuta a ctaarlv
7. TM altfiMld Infarvallan aaa eoivltad far lara anfa
E«f»T10« (b)(T)
aid U bain* aftPkaU far tka raaiiwta) Indleatad.
I Diaclaaura eauld raa
t aeaoa, dlractlan, an
! nwTiai (7)(*)
onably ba ajwaetad ta Intarfara altk mt
l9am mi anfiirr—iif affarta and tfaja
It cautd raoaal tM
affaru.
• Olacloatf^ eauld ra
! (7)(C1
Ply ba axpactad ta canatltuta an <
cad Iniaaian af paraanai priyacy. (OSTla
TM Infaraatlan conaiata af naaiaa af indlyiduala «id atltar infaraatlan tka diacia
aaoactad to ra»aal iaantttiaa of canfldantlal aaurcaa. dB^TIOd (DCPI
af idildi cautd i
TM infar^tian la eontainad in or ratatad ta aaaatnatian. aparatina ar canditlan i^af U mn a financial Inatltutist.
Ea^Dtlon (b)(t)
Diaclaaura af tM aatarial, wad la data«vina ojallf leatiana far faoaral
oojaetiyltv or falmaaa of tM orecaaa. Eaaaptiai (t)(6)
a^aiaanr ar nr^irll, aautd i
PMT II.C
■IC
Any anial aav ba woaalad to tha (TC't fianaral Cotfsal aithin 10 dava of racaioc af tbla raaoanaa. MDaala auat ba laaaitlad [
in arllina ara ahauld ba addraaaad ta tM ITC'a Office af tM lacratary. fOIJl/ni tranea. 173S 1. lyan ttraat. laaatfn. V* j
22209. Tha lattar vd anoalooa anauid claarlv ba labalad aa a W)U agpaal. '
ITC 1021/03 (2-9I) aa«a 2
421
ReSOLUTION TKUST CORPOBATION
Roolviaf TW CriM
Ratsring The Caofldcacc
April 16, 1993
Ms. Jacqueline P. Taylor
Mr. Bruce Pederson
c/o Ms. Jacqueline Taylor
P.O. Box 4077
31739 Quarter Horse Road
Evergreen, CO 80439
Re: Freedom of Information Act Appeal No. RTC-93-AQ07
D^ar Ms. Taylor and Mr. Pederson:
This is in response to your letter of March 17, 1993, appealing the
RTC's response to your request for documents pursuant to the Freedom
of Information Act ("FOIA"), 5 U.S.C. S 552, as amended.
By letter dated September 12, 1992, you jointly submitted a FOIA
request for information pertaining to telephone monitoring,
electronic mail monitoring, mail monitoring and physical
surveillance. Specifically, you sought information relating to:
a) who recommended monitoring; b) who approved monitoring; c) dates
when monitoring was in effect; d) who performed monitoring; and e)
the information gathered from monitoring, for each category of
monitoring.
In its decision dated February 19, 1993, the RTC FOIA/PA Branch
informed you that no agency records responsive to your request could
be located. The response also advised that the RTC had "interpreted
your request to be for agency records relating to [such alleged
activities] directed specifically at either or both of you otherwise
than in the ordinary course by virtue of your employment
relationship with the RTC," and excluded therefore such records as
routine call detail reports, mail tracking reports, etc. (With
regard to records generated by, or in the possession of, the Office
of the Inspector General, I am informed that you have received a
response directly from that office.)
On March 17, 1993, you appealed the RTC's "no record" response. In
your appeal letter, you requested that we interpret your FOIA
request to include "records depicting any decisions by any RTC
employee to monitor us (i.e. . our use of telephones, electronic mail
aoi 17m Sn—t. N.W. Washington. D.C. 204»
422
or other computer data bases, regular mails, physical comings and
goings)." You also suggested the names of several employees whose
files you suggested "would be most likely to possess responsive
records."
An agency is required to conduct a search for requested records,
using methods which can be reasonably expected to produce the
information requested. Oalesbv v. Department of the Armv. 920 F.2d
57, 68 (D.C. Cir. 1990). A search is not unreasonable simply
because it fails to produce all relevant material. Meeropol v.
Meese. 790 F.2d 942, 952-53 (D.C. Cir. 1986). In that regard, I
note that, despite your assertion of a belief that "agency records
responsive to our request do exist," you provide no information in
your appeal letter regarding the existence or identification of even
one such record. Based on the information you supplied and the
existing administrative record, this office investigated the
circumstances of the initial searches for information as of February
19, 1993, and determined that those searches were reasonable.
Moreover, subsequent queries were made of the individuals mentioned
in your appeal letter and no records within the scope of your
request were located. Accordingly, I find that the RTC's "no
record" response was appropriate.
With regard to the portion of your appeal letter referring to "other
computer data bases," I note that your September 12, 1992, request
letter was quite specific in indicating which records were sought.
The only mention of electronically maintained records were
"electronic messages." No searches were conducted for records other
than those so noted. If you wish to submit a request for
information concerning records pertaining to the monitoring of
"other computer data bases" you may contact the FOIA/PA Branch
directly, in writing, and a new request will be opened.
Inasmuch as my action on your appeal does not constitute a complete
grant of access, I am required by statute to inform you of your
right to obtain judicial review. Such review is available to you
in the United States District Court for the District in which you
reside or in the United States District Court for the District of
Columbia. 5 U.S.C. S 552(a)(4)(B).
Sincerely,
Grant G. Moy,
Senior CounseJ
Department of Corporate Affairs
Division of Legal Services
423
^i:5 2 8 m2
H^solution Trust Corporation
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
DATE:
All Legal Division Employees
Richard T. Ahoussie /jT^Tj^
Acting Senior Vice President "^
and General Counsel
Cooperation with GIG Investigation
August 27, 1992
The Inspector General has the authority under the Inspector General
Act and FIRREA to conduct audits and investigations of the programs
and operations of the Resolution Trust Corporation. Albert V.
Casey, Chief Executive Officer, has specifically requested that the
Inspector General investigate allegations regarding the conduct of
the Corporation's professional liability litigation. That
investigation is now underway.
As always, it is the responsibility of all Corporation employees to
fully cooperate with the OIG investigation and promptly provide all
requested information to authorized OIG representatives. Given the
nature of OIG investigations, it is inappropriate to discuss the
investigation with anyone other than the OIG representatives.
Communications with an attorney for the purpose of giving or
seeking legal advise, and communications between a bargaining unit
member and union representative for the purpose of obtaining
representation are not prohibited by this admonition.
You should also be aware that the Inspector General Act
specifically guarantees the Inspector General right of access to
all documents available to the Corporation, and prohibits any
reprisal against any employee for disclosing information to the
Inspector General.
Thank you for your cooperation.
RTA/jc
cc: Albert V. Casey
EXHIBIT
II K
424
To:
Cc: f
Dec:
From:
Subject:
Data:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
•etegaliRTCDEN, •ei*gal-Xs»et««RTCDEN, *eLegal-Corp«RTCDDl
•«L«gal-LiteRTCDEN, •«L«gal-ProjeRTC0ENR5
Barbara Shangraw^Legal-CorpeRTCOEN
IG
Tuesday, December 22, 1992 10:03:41 MST
I would like to reiterate again the need for all within this office to fully
cooperate with the office of the Inspector General. Please be straightforward
and provide all documentation that they request. If you are unsure what they
are asking, please ask for clarification.
Also, please note that IG investigations are confidential. Please restrict
your discussions of matters under investigation, especially to those outside
of the agency.
EXHIBIT
I L
425
OFFICE OF
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
RESOLimON TRUST
CORPORATION
December 1992
Dear fellow RTC employee:
Two yean ago. the Office of Inspector General established a nationwide toll-free
hotline (1-800-833-3310) to receive complaints and allegations of fraud, waste,
abuse, and mismanagement in RTC programs and activities. Thanks to your
calls, we have miuaied almost 300 invesagaQons and inquiries about reported
wrongdoing, and of the ones completed. 23 percent have been substanuated.
These cases include:
-an RTC official who improperly accepted a gift from a contractor,
—a managing agent submitting false travel vouchers;
—a development company misrepresenting itself as non-profit;
—an employee who flagrantly abused work hours; and
— mdividuals who purchased affordable housing as investments.
In each case, correcuve measures have been taken.
We want to thank you for making these calls to us. With your continued
assistance, we can help ensure that RTC is free of the type of fraud and abuse
that led to the savings and loan debacle. I am enclosing a pamphlet that explains
our hotline operaaon in more detail and a card that can be put into your rolodex
for easy reference. We appreciate your interest m an effecuve, economical, and
efficient RTC.
Sincerely,
(JjOiCUL/W
John J. Adair
Inspector General
1735 >. Lr»« S«f»« • »—il)«. VA liJM
SOI I7ik StTM. VW ■ WhJuhcum. DC :»4J4-O001
426
Ilclpl iulit
Fraiul, Waste, and
IMisnianagcment at
IMC
1-800-833-3310
HOTLINE
• '.illiT may rpmain niwnvinnui or cnnriilinii.il
OFllfKOr
INSPECTOR
GENERAL
HKSOI.l IIONTUVST
COHPOHATION
427
You Can Hel^ Fight Fraud, Waste, and MisiQanagementl
1-800-833-3310
HSTLINE
RTC OFFICE OF INSPECIOR GENERAL
Olflce of Inapector Gcnerml
Attn: HOTLINE
RfMlullon TViut Corporation
Inlematlonal Place, Suite 1 100
1736 North Lynn Street
RoMlyn, VA 22209
The OIG Hotline u sta/Ted MondayFnd«y from Sam to 4 p m . Eastern Time
Messages may be leFt on an answering machine afler hours
U you suspect fmud. WM»e, abuae, or (pismaiiaffeinepl iii^M fflC proiRia or .-. Vv
'. by an RTC oontraclor, call or write the HotUae of contact (Hijf pf yte^(oUowrtpg£.." .iV/
[ Inrpcctor General locationa;. -J ; . )y ■'■■:j::'-:^yt/V^:^^^:;^^^^^
•; -.^fl^^r:
I^reittiatliui '4O4-MS-670Q; J
Audit 4(M-88I-6ISS •'
J KaaiaaClty'- Jpvn^lnttoj^'-VBW WfrTI'^ :
■ '■\ -".•■•:■ •-■•=:>ii4a \ .r.:'>:HBV96».7l4fV
-DsUaa .: inwMtiiBHoav aM-443-28oa— . , -. " ' .- ..:■. ; . ■ -•■.•;;-:' .; , y. ' ";-
Audit i\i-H3-2Blf' Headquarter. lliT«rtlgatj<ip.;.apj-4i».4S4»
Denver Invatlptloa 303-301-5850. .;-•.:■:•'-•.- ■■:'' ".
. A«dlt 303-2SI-SBSa •■■■.• .-. ' -V^- ■..'••" ;-.,Vv
428
B
ffice of Inspector General
Th* Onke of Inspector General (OIG)
mducU independent (nd objective audits
nd invcalifstiona of RTC operations and
■ntractora in order tod) improve RTCs
Jficiency and elTectiveness. and (21 detect
nd prevent fraud, waste, abuse, and mis-
lanafement in RTC programs
The Inspector General (IGI is appointed by
;ie President of the United States and cnn-
rmed by the Senate The IG wotkx under
.le general supervision of the RTC President
nd Chief Executive Officer and the ThriD
lepositor Protection Oversifihi B<Htcd Chuir-
lan and reports to the ConxrefA im the per-
■cmance of RTC programs and nperatinns
ilten. OIG reports include recommendations
ir changes. Aiao. if rriminal wrongdoing or
ther improper activity is found, the OIG
■orka with the Department of Justice and
iher organixationa to ensure that appropri-
te judicial and corrective actnns are taken.
udits, Investigations, and
I Other Initiatives
The OIG has a comprehensive, nationwide
rogram for auditing and mvestigating RTCs
iCtivilies. Audita cover a variety of issues
nchjding: aaaet management, contracting,
onaervatorship operations, resolution
ictivity, financial and administrative activi-
les, and information systema. Inventigationa
have focused on alleged criminal or otherwiae
prohibited activities involving RTC contrac-
tors, employees, vendors, and other individu-
als and group* who participate in RTC
programs and nperatiuna.
The OIG also perform.s quality reviews of
accounting firm audits uf various RTC
contrsctors; and reviews proposed RTC
regulations, directives, and legislation to
ensure that ( 1 1 RTC directives and n>gula-
tionx are consi-slent with existing laws and
(21 sufTicienl internal controls, necrssary to
prevent fraud, waste, abuse, and mi^m<lniig«■
ment will lie built into RTC program iipera-
Unns
IG Hotline
The OIG nperutrs a toll free, nationwide
Hotline ( 1 MM) H.l.t'.'Uin) tu facililiite report-
ing incidents of fraud, waste, abuse, and
mismanagement within RTC and contractor
operations It is an employee's responsibdity
to report suspected instances of fraud, waste,
abuse, and mismanagement in RTC pro-
grams or operations The OIG Hotline makes
it easier for RTC empbyees, contractors, and
others to report incidents of fraud, waste,
abuse, and mismanagement that threaten
the success of RTC
ow Does It Work?
When a call is placed to the toll-free
number, the caller is asked to provide details
429
lo • Hotline SUIT membar. Anyone can raport
inrormation openly, anonyraoiuly, or confi-
dentially.
OIG olTicials carefully review each hotjine
complaint lo determine if it warranla review
or inveetigBtinn. If criminal activity, or other
serious wrongdoing is alleged, an OIG
investigator or auditor ia assigned to punue
the complaint Other matters may be re-
ferred to RTC management to review the
circumstances surrounding the complaint
and report findings and cnrreclive actions to
the OIG
hat Should Be Reported?
Any situation that involves suspected
fraud, waala, abuae, or anamanaganent of
RTC pmgrams. operations, and resources
should he reported to the OIG Hotline
Examples nf problems that should be re-
ported include:
■ contract and procurement fraud or collu-
sion;
II bribery and acceptance of gratuities;
I miamanageroenl;
■ misuse, embeztlement. or theft of govern-
ment property or funds;
■ amployce misconduct such as misuse of
ofTicial position and acceptance nf unau-
thorized gifVs. and
■ other unethical or illegal activities.
■
0 Hotline Callers
Remain Confidential?
Confidentiality is grmnted la anyone
reporting a problem to the Hotline, subject I
the provisions of Section 7(b) of the lnspecUi<
General Act of 1978. This provision require^
that the identity of etnptoyees not be dis-
ckaed without the employee's consent or
unless the Inspector General determines th^i
discloeurc is unavoidable in the course of th<
investigation OIG operational controb
ensure that the identity of Hotline sources i>
protected, and the Inspector General Act
prohibits reprisal actiona against federal
employees A csller may also remain anony
mous. if desired
•. tkeReiolulhti'Truilborpo- ■
- ration iinu tttahUihtd by Ihe
y'\'liii6Miiln,'mhiiate,and'.
'■ ' -.ntolvefdilei §avtn'g§ and
/'(' iaanii/Biiil ^ ; •.., ■; •:,
'.tii iricovii-}^aftrftin<U-
^' /ftitmlheinanagtmthi. :
k y1-V^.
430
kmolution Tnsgt Cotporntion
Auguat 6, 1992
MZKQRANDUK TOt Bruoa Pedcrson
Bradlay SnoUcin
Jaoquelina Taylor
FROH:
RZ:
Albert V. Camay
Presidant and CZO
Augiist 11, 1992 App«aranae
Sena^a BanJcin? Coaitlttea
Tha Sonata Banlcing CosBlttaa haa aa)(ad that yon appaar to provida
taatisony in Waablngton, D.C. on Taaaday, August 11 at 10:00
a.m. , in roan 534 or tha 6anata Dirkaen Banata Off lea Building.
A oopy of tha latter raquaating your prasanca is attacbad.
It ia tha fir» policy of tha Raaolution Trtiat Corporation to
cooparata fully and forthrightly vlth Congrasa in tha condoot of
tha lattar'a ovarsight actlvitlea, and I urga you to approach tha
CoB&ittaa in that spirit. Lat na assura you that your appaaranoa
will not hava any baaring on your aaploy»ant status with tha HTC.
It will not b« necessary for you to suJnit your writtan marks
to us for prior raviaw or olaaranca. Should you wish for us to
photocopy your testimony and/or arrange tor its physical deliycry
to tha CoBmittaa, howavar, please contact Pater Knight at (202)
416>2116.
Thank you.
Attachment
EXHIBIT
I M
Ml ITU
NW ■ WiMHinym. DC SOAU-QOOI
431
© FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE CORPORATION
OFFICE Of The Chairman
August 7, 1992
Honorable Donald W. Riegle, Jr.
Chairman
CoBffiittee on Banking, Housing,
and Urban Affairs
United States Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510
Dear Hr. Chairman:
Thank you for your recent letter concerning testimony by
employees of the Resolution Trust Corporation at the Committee's
August 11 hearing concerning RTC's civil litigation efforts.
As part of internal personnel policy and procedural
guidance distributed to all Federal Deposit Insurance Corpora-
tion managers and supervisors, the Corporation sets forth prin-
ciples with respect to the equitable treatment of all FDIC
employees. One of these principles guarantees "protection of
employees against reprisal for lawful disclosures of informa-
tion...." In addition, various other Corporation personnel
policies reaffirm this principle.
The FDIC will conduct itself in accordance with its
policies and procedures.
Sincerely,
William Taylor
Chairman
432
THE Denver POCT
Bailout
agency
critics
harassed?
RTC bosses accused
of improper actions
By St«v»n Wllmsmi
Resolution Trust Corp. manag-
ers may have impiloperly broken
into confidential computer files
kept by an employee who criti-
cized the savings and loan bailout
agency and aided investigations
into waste and abuse, according to
a letter written by Colorado Rep.
Pat Scfaroeder.
In a letter to Treasury Secretary
Lloyd Bentsen and RTC
Chairman
Roger Altman,
Sdiroeder. D-
Colo., said au-
thorities may
have accessed
electronic cop-
ies of corre-
spondence be-
tween Bruce
Pederson. an
RTC attorney
who has testi-
fied before Schro«der
h^.
Congress about RTC problems,
and investigators for the General
Accounting Office and tiie Office
of the Inspector General.
RTC managers also may h^ve
broken into computer files kept -by
Jackie Taylor, another RTC attor-
ney who has exposed troubles in
the agency, Schroeder said.
"I am extremely conceiued that
management may have broken in-
to the computers of two RTC whia-
tleblowers." Schroeder said in the
letter, dated April 21. 1993.
"This action can only be seen-as
reuliation against Mr. Pedenon
and Ms. Taylor for blowing the
whistle. It may constitute an ille-
gal wire-up or an illegal search
and seizure. It surely sends a chill-
ing message to potential whistle-
blowers at the RTC."
The letter asks Bentsen and Alt-
man to investigate the charges.
"You must send a message to
nunagement that you will not tol-
erate this kind of harassment aod
a message to federal employees
that they can expose waste, frand
and abuse without fear of retalia-
tion," said Schroeder. ^
433
Schr oeder calls for investigation
of alleged RTC computer hreak-in
ByJohnRtbehook Peteioo ind Tayior, hw-
NemRmiEsiauEdU^ ~ r^-.^^ tte RTC last yor
r.cwniwcr'iiTTr.rrrr testified bcfore Congre»,
Rep., Pat Schroeder said diarging that tbe zgeocy ivas
Wednesday she is calhng for an bz in going after lawyers, w>
investigation of management at mumauu, offioers and others
the Resolution Trust Corp/s respooaiUe for the ^ihire of
Denver office for allegedly savings and loms.
breaking into the computers of Schroeder said their compot-
two **whistleblowers. " ers oootained correspondences.
In April 21 letters to Roger documents and comnumicatio^
' Altman, chairman of the RTC, with Coogresaiooal offices,
and Lloyd Bentsen. treasury "This action can only be seen
secretary, the Colorado Demo- as retaliation against Mr. P«-
crat said she is "extremely con- derson and Ms. Tayior for bbw-
cemed" that management may ing the whistle." Schroeder
have broken into the computers, said. "It may ooostxtute an iDe-
of Bruce Pederson and Jacque- gal wireup or an Ole^ search
line Taylor. and seizure.
»,
434
To:
Cc: ,
Bcc:
Fron:
Sub3ect:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
aoiG@RTC^^F
Bjuce Pedersoni§Legal-Corpi§RTCDEM
Jackie Taylor§Legal-Assets@RTCDEN
Monday, February 8, 1993 10:26:19 MST
V
What is a good time to talk this week regarding the copies I dropped off?
Also, is the IG convinced that our e-mails to the IG are confidential? How
about our telephone calls? I have been hearing "rumors" lately concerning
confidentiality of communications (or lack thereof) regarding RTC field offices
e-mails and telephones. Certainly, the staff in multiple locations continues
to express their fears along these lines. If they are not completely
confidential from surveillance or "taps" it would seem that communicating with
the IG by these methods actually would be harmful to the security and
confidentiality of any investigation.
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Sub;]ect:
Data:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Jackie Taylor§Legal-Assets@RTCDEN
_ _JOIG?RTCJ
re: Meeting
Monday, February 8, 1993 10:43:00 MST
Wednesday through Friday looks good. Pick a date and time and let ne know.
Re: E-mails and phones--If anyone has EVIDENCE that anything illegal is going
on with either means of communication, I would hope they would express their
concerns, along with the evidence to us — because we're not just talking "nosey,'
we're talking multiple felonies if we have evidence phone or computer
"tapping" is taking place. Wire-tapping is not authorized unless you have a
court order, and computer "tapping" constitutes an illegal search absent a
subooena .
435
To: ^^■■^■q|Bl9aoiG@RTCS^
Cc: ?ruce Peaerson^Legai-Corp#RTCOEM
Be-:
Fron: Jackie Taylor§Legal-Assets§RTCDEN
Siiojecr: re: Meeting
Date: Monday, February 8, 1993 11:03:49 MST
Attach:
Certify: Y
Forwarded by:
It will have to be Friday morning that we meet. I am booked most of the rest o:
the week.
I understand the legalities of what you are saying. I did not intend to inply
I have any evidence of anything. I would have to be a much more technically
oriented person than I am to be able to even have an understanding of how one
would begin to gather evidence of that nature. I was just asking a question
and' passing on office gossip. So many people that talk to me are very worried
about that issue. I answer them as you have answered me, but that doesn't
seen to alleviate their concerns. They seem to be looking for an official
pronouncement that "NO THESE THINGS ARE NOT HAPPENING" rather than the anwer
both you and I have given, which is "IT IS AGAINST THE LAW TO DO THIS. IF YOU
HAVE PROOF IT IS BEING DONE, TELL THE IG". Oh well, I needed to ask for my
own peace of mind also. My confidence and trust level in legal management
perfoming honestly and ethically in this type of matter is not very high after
what I have been through ever the last year. See you on Friday morning. I
will come over there or call.
436
To:
I
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Bruce PedersoniLegal-CorpeRTCDEN
Jackie Taylor§Legal-Assets§RTCDEN
^OIGlRTCf
WA-92-0028
Friday, February 12, 1993 13:13:32 MST
I had a talk with my boss ^PlMHB^^ following the interview X had with you
this morning. 4HBmmP^would like to write a letter to 4MlHB^Ba^B^«>/ho is
in charge of administration for Legal, and pass onto ^BHBIP^ for his action
briefly what your complaints were to me this morning.
To do that we obviously need to identify either both or one of you as the
complainant.
And just so we're on the same wave length, here's whatj
attention to:
'would call-
1. Opening of mail marked personal and confidential for Bruce
2. Passing around of mail marked personal and confidential for Bruce
3. Unanswered grievance by Larry Brock for Bruce
4. Comings and goings being clocked for Jackie
5. Legal administration refusing to give access to time and attendance, job
description records to both Jackie and EEO
6. People with info on above afraid to come forward because of reprisals
By E-mail, let me know if you agree to let us use your name(s) with Karlson.
437
To: •■■■■MapB^^olGeRTClM^
Cc: Jackie Tayior§Legal-Assecs§RTCDEN
Bcc:
From: Bruce Pederson§Legal-Corp§RTCDEN
Subject: re: WA-92-0028
Date: Tuesday, February 16, 1993 9:48:17 MST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
We would like to see the following list of issues raised by^^^lyin a letter
to^BHHBHto* The first six are from your EMail to us.
1. Opening nail marked confidential and personal.
2. Leaving confidential mail on management's desk.
3. Unanswered grievance for Bruce.
4. Clocking Jackie's attendance.
5. Legal admin, refusal to give Jackie info/records.
6. Intimidation of employees for being seen with us.
7. Denial of Jackie's AWS day when she is on business travel,
(management also denied comp and overtime pay) Call Jackie for
details if needed.
8. Denial of Bruce 's request for restoration of 35 hours of forfeited
annual leave from 1991.
9. Management efforts to impose itself between us and OIG and GAO officials
and members of Congressional staffs.
We appreciate your willingness to pursue these issues on our behalf. Please
call or EMail me if you need additional information. I also plan to write !■
^HlMBr regarding the mail issue by tomorrow. I plan to make passing
reference to some of the above issues which affect me.
Thanks!
Bruce
438
REClIVED
JUL 2 6 1933
BESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
RaoJnnf Tht Criua
Rcitorini Tlw Confidence
July 23, 1993
James A. Clark, Esq.
Baker 6 Hosteller
303 East 17th Avenue, Suite 1100
Denver, CO., 80208-1264
Dear Mr. Clark:
As you are aware, on January, 1993, I wrote you a letter regarding
the relationship between Jeffrey North of your firm, and legal
matters involving the Resolution Trust Corporation. A copy of that
letter is attached for your reference.
Based on conversations between members of my staff and employees of
the Office of the Inspector Genera j., it is now my understanding that
the ongoing investigation relates only to matters which arose in the
former Western Region of RTC, which included the Denver, Phoenix and
Newport Beach offices. However, RTC management has received no
report on the results of the investigation.
I am concerned that, the conditions I imposed on Mr. North and the
firm have been in place for more than six months without any
indication that t^ ^ investigation will soon come to a conclusion or
be terminated. I recognize, therefore, that it is appropriate to
reconsider the scope of the conditions in the light of the length
of time in whicn the investigation has been ongoing.
I continue to be concerned that Mr. North be screened off from any
matter that might bear a relationship to matters which were pending
while he was RTC Regional Counsel for the Western Region. In order
that the RTC can be fully protected, I would like the firm to
continue to screen Mr. North from any work or matter that relates
to the former Western Region, or that arose out of matters within
the purview of any of the existing Denver or Newport Beach Field
Offices (including those relating to operations or accounting work),
or any thrift for which those offices are responsible.
However, in my view, Mr. North need no longer be screened off from
matters assigned to Baker & Hostetler fey any of the other field
EXHIBIT
h
aoi ]?m srriMf. n.w. wa^vxjton. D.a 20434
D
439
Janes A. Clark, Esq.
Page Two
July 23, 1993
offices (Atlanta, Dallas, Valley Forge or Kansas City) or the
Washington office, providing
1. They do not meet the criteria described above (regarding
work related to the fomer Western Region, ind
2. Mr. North had no role whatsoever in soliciting the work
for Baker & Hostetler after he joined the firm, and
3. Mr. North had no role whatsoever in recommending or
assigning the work to Baker t Hostetler while he was an employee of
RTC.
At this time, and until the situation changes, it is no longer
necessary for RTC to avoid having Mr. North work on any matter. As
a general proposition, there is no objection to having him working
on matters from which he will not be screened, under the criteria
described above. I am mindful, however, that when the results of
the investigation are reported to RTC management, a more complete
screen may have to be reimposed. Therefore, before Mr. North may
work on any specific RTC matter, the firm should obtain the express
written permission of the field Assistant General Counsel. Also all
relevant RTC requirements relating to legal services agreements,
including the scheduling of Mr. North's billing rate in RLIS, must
be met.
Given the nature of the investigation, please ask that attorneys
other than Mr. North conduct direct communications on behalf of the
firm, with any RTC employees regarding RTC matters. I prefer that
Mr. North be asked not to do so. This will ensure that no new
incidents or allegations arise while the investigation is ongoing.
Like you, I am hopaful that the investigation will be concluded with
dispatch, and that none of the limitations described above will be
necessary in the future.
Sin. arely yours,
Richard T. Aboussie '^'
Acting General Counsel
cc: John Woodrum
E. Glion Curtis
Sally Ridenour
Thomas Luck
David Swiss
Arturo Vera-Rojas
Barbara Shangraw
Neil B. Van Winkle
440
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
*§legal-assets§rtcden
*^legal-corp#rtcden
"^i legal- lit irtcden
*eiegal-proj§rtcden
Colleen LarseniLegal-CorpiRTCDEN
Welcome
Friday, Septeinber 17, 1993 8:49:35 MDT
N
Please welcome the following employees to the Legal Division:
EXT NAME ROOM SECTION TITLE
3586
Baldwin, Dana M.
3500
4684
Dallin, Angela L.
3847
4789
McLaurin, Randolph A.
3736B
4672
Posey, Mar)c E.
3833
4722
Ramirez, Norma L.
3736A
4766
Reyes, Marie
3725C
4674
Rhodes, Rhonda L.
3827
4788
Schreiber, Lisa G.
3736D
Veltri, Patricia S.
Wollman, Jamie B.
3817E
4706
3860
Adnin/Whisman
Lit/Unger
Assets /Boelte
00 Mgmt/Enright
Assets/ Boelte
Assets /Vaughan
Lit/Lincoln
Assets /Mess ite
Lit/Lincoln
Lit/Miller
File ClerJt
Legal Tech
Legal Tech
Attorney
Secretary
Secretary
Attorney
Paralegal
Legal Tech
Attorney
Dana Baldwin, Randy McLaurin, Rhonda Rhodes, Patricia Veltri and Jamie Wollman
will be joining us from private industry. Angela Dallin, Mark Posey, Norma
Ramirez, Marie Reyes and Lisa Schreiber are transferring from the FDIC.
441
SUPPLEiMENT TO THE STATEMENT OF
Thomas J. Bumside
TO THE SENATE COM^^TTEE
ON BANKING, HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
SEPTEMBER 30, 1993
I. RTC USE OF SUBPOENAS IN TEXAS
A. THE IMPORTANCE OF SUBPOENAS
As discussed in my earlier testimony, the administrative subpoena power is the RTC's most
powerful tool in investigating and pursuing S&L wrongdoers. With subpoenas, the RTC can
"follow the money trail" before ever making a decision on whether to pursue the claim. The
successful trace of the "money trail" in Texas has resulted in most of the large recoveries.
Perhaps more important, the aggressive use of subpoenas has resulted in the pursuit of highly
culpable defendants while avoiding those cases involving less egregious conduct by those on
the fringe of the S&L decision-making.
(1) Financial Impact of Subpoenas on Texas Claims. The RTC Texas field offices
in Dallas, San Antonio, and Houston and the Dallas regional office handled the investigations
of 129 failed S&L's. In 99 of those cases, the RTC failed to issue any admmistrative
subpoenas from 1989 until 1993. In another 30 cases, the RTC engaged in some very limited
subpoena usage. The RTC only aggressively used subpoenas (15 or more subpoenas per
S&L) in 5 % of its cases. The following table illustrates the use of subpoenas in Texas RTC
thrifts:
s
0
1 to 2
3 to 5
RTC Texas Subpoenas
^1
^1
n
m
m
■
-
1
n
■
I
c
I
1
3
M
etc 8
9 to 11
1 2 to 1 i
Over 1 4
■
i
I
1
1
0
10
20
30
40 50 60
70
80
90
100
PaMd S&L •
442
The failure to issue any subpoenas in 99 Texas S&L's becomes even more shocking when
contrasted with the distribution of recoveries according to subpoena usage. The RTC only
aggressively used subpoenas in 5 % of its investigations; those seven investigations resulted
in 93% of the Texas field 'recoveries.
RTC TEXAS RECOVERIES BY SUBPOENA USAGE
Zero subpoenas
1 to 1 4 subpoenas
I
I
99 Texas
S&Ls
30 Texas
S&L's
over 1 4 subpoenas
7 Texas S&L's
10 20 30 40 50
Recoveries in Millions
60
70
80
' Washington D.C. retained direct control over an additional seven thrifts in Texas. I
believe that several of those investigations used few, if any, subpoenas. Since Dallas did not
track Washington subpoenas, however, I had insufficient information to include the D.C.
cases in this analysis. Similarly, 1 could not analyze the Texas S&L's under FDIC control. I
also believe that the FDIC had a low usage rate for subpoenas m Texas. The RTC and FDIC
undoubtedly would be delighted to provide those figures to the Subcommittee if asked.
443
(2) Intangible Impact of Subpoenas on Texas Claims. The statistics only tell part of
the story. The real importance of subpoenas comes when the RTC obtains the critical
evidence needed to bust open a case. For example, the aggressive use of subpoenas
generated the following items of proof on Texas RTC cases:
► An accountant's workpapers that revealed that two officers received eighteen
million dollars in eighteen months;
► An investment banker's file that described an S&L owner's unsuccessful
attempts to sell his real estate companies before he "sold" the companies to the
S&L for S70 million in cash and stock;
► Real estate records that proved that a developer "bought" raw land for S13
million on a Friday and "sold" it to the S&L for S26 million on Monday. (The
RTC sold the land for about two million six years later)
•■ A key witness who placed the thrift owner at a negotiating table in a Dallas
airport when none of the S&L records placed the owner anywhere near the
transaction;
•■ Bank records of a Texas lawyer who laundered three million dollars of S&L
loan proceeds so that the owner of the S&L could retain control of the S&L
for another two years at an additional taxpayer cost of one hundred million
dollars;
Not all subpoenas result in a home run. Often, the pursuit of the money trail is a tedious
tracing of money from person to person until you identify everyone who was unjustly
ennched by the transaction. In either case, however, the evidence gives the RTC an almost
overwhelming advantage at the negotiating table or in the court room. Imagine having the
tesumony and records of one hundred witnesses before even tiling the lawsuit. In one such
case, the potential defendants faced with the prospect of defending against such a
well-prepared RTC collectively paid the RTC over S12 million without ever taking a
deposiuon.
It is no accident that 93 % of all RTC Texas field recoveries came in the few cases where the
RTC aggressively subpoenaed evidence before suing. Likewise, it is not surprising that the
RTC found "no evidence" of merit or net worth in most of the 99 cases in which it never
issued a subpoena.
n. THE 1992 REORGAMZATION
The RTC Inspector General's report on the 1992 PLS purge provides a chilling portrait of
senior RTC managers who destroyed the Professional Liability program in a quest for
444
personal power and revenge. The impact of the reorganization nationally was devastating.
"Overall, PLS lost approximately 50 percent of its experienced trained attorneys, replaced
three of its top four senior field managers, and transferred 43 % of its caseload from one
attorney to another."
The impact of the reorganization in Dallas is even more dramatic. Between May of 1992
and October of 1993, the RTC has transferred almost 100% of its Texas caseload to attorneys
hired after the 1992 reorganization. Almost 80% of the PLS line attorneys currently in
Dallas joined the program since March of this year. Two attorneys from Kansas City have
assumed control over Dallas PLS and are frantically applying Band-Aids to a program that
lacked any supervision for over a year. Despite the disintegration of the Texas program,
however, the RTC still proudly boasts that its "increased staffing" proves its continuing
commitment to the program!
I
The 1992 purge of PLS directly effected the use of subpoenas on Texas cases. On June 1,
1992, the statutes of limitations on Texas S&L's with 64% of the total assets under RTC
control were still alive. Yet, the use of subpoenas on Texas investigations dropped to almost
zero. Indeed, excluding my subpoenas, Texas RTC lawyers issued only ten subpoenas for the
seven months following the reorganization.
140 -r
TEXAS SUBPOENAS ISSUED BY QUARTER
1992 Reorganization
445
The natural question that flows from the devastation of such a politically sensitive program is:
What motivated the crippling purge?
Avoiding far more insidious motives, the RTC Inspector General found that an "internal
struggle" or "friction" between PLS and the rest of the Legal Division "appeared to have
been a significant factor in staffing decisions" in the 1992 reorganization:
"The former General Counsel's motive for returning career employees may
have been well intended. However, in reality, other senior Legal Division
managers used the process to return PLS employees they did not want without
regard to the intent of the "put back" process or the professional liability work
that remained to be done. The Legal Division's process for selecting
employees to be returned to FDIC was subjective and poor;y managed. Legal
Division managers met on May 5, 1992, and, using the newly developed
organization chart, selected who they wanted to fill the various attorney
positions in the six field supersites. This was characterized by one attendee as
a meeting to get rid of people they did not want. The former general Counsel
did not get involved with this process.
Selections for PLS groups were made without using criteria, standards, or
guidelines and without regard for the workload. In the Denver and Atlanta
regions, where relations between the PLS and the top Legal Division
management were already strained, "put back" decisions had the appearance
of management taking an opportunity to return PLS employees that were not
perceived as "team players. " In several cases, it appears that senior
management based staffing and put back decisions on prior working
relationships and did not use analysis of office staffing needs or expected
workload to make PLS staffing decisions."
Also, some management decisions involving reassignment of PLS attorneys
appear to have been based on personal preferences rather than a reasoned
agenda for minimizing the effects of the reorganization on the PLS workload.
In Atlanta and Denver, as discussed previously, PLS managers and regional
counsel had been at odds regarding management of the PLS. These
differences, more than concerns for the nrofessinnal liahilitv nmeram itself
seemed to have influenced staffing decisions. "
We have yet to see any of these RTC legal managers who destroyed a program for personal
power suffer any consequences for their actions. Most of the managers remain in control at
the RTC or are seeking refuge from taxpayer wrath at the FDIC. How can such legal
managers who crippled the RTC for personal reasons go unpunished? Does the label "just
turf battles" somehow exonerate legal managers from responsibility for the fate of the RTC
Professional Liability program?
446
in. FAILURE TO ACT AS A TEAM
The Investigations Unit in Dallas is the heart and soul of the remaining Texas cases. The
collective experience of the investigative staff is one of the chief remaining assets of the
Texas program. Many investigators have between ten and twenty years "hands-on"
experience with Texas S&L's and bring invaluable insight into accounting, regulatory,
lending, real estate, and other specialized areas crucial to the development of viable claims.
Additionally, the almost complete turnover in Dallas PLS lawyers has forced the Dallas
investigators to become the last remaining effective RTC supervision of the cases. Simply
stated, the Investigations Unit is the RTC's "institutional memory" on the Texas cases.
Perhaps more important, the Dallas investigators have become the RTC's conscience on the
Texas cases. Rather than blindly promoting a rigid "aggressive-conservative" litmus test to
professional liability decisions, they sought to examine the facts of each case on its merits. If
they saw a case they believed was improperly filed, they attempted to stop it. Conversely,
they resisted the closure of cases without adequate investigation. Now, they have dared to
protest the systemic collapse of the Texas cases — whether because of gross mismanagement
or otherwise — by cooperating with the GAO and this Subcommittee in their investigations of
the Texas problems.
The cooperation has its price. Almost one year after the PLS purge of 1992, the RTC
Investigations Unit apparently has begun its own purge. As punishment for the Dallas
cooperation with the United States Senate and the Government Accounting Office inquiries,
the RTC managers have "reorganized" Dallas Investigations. RTC Director of
Investigations James Dudine has sent a "shadow" management team from Washington and
Kansas City to Dallas and more than doubled the size of the Dallas Investigations'
management group. The old managers have now found their staff cut by 75%.
Further, Dudine has endorsed the Legal Division's efforts to "shun" the Investigations
management who first reported the Dallas debacle within the RTC and, then later to GAO
and Congress. In July, Dudine overtly sought to "...explore options available to insulate
Jones and Mendoza from direct contact and 'client-like' responsibility over PLS case. "
As if isolation is not enough, RTC management has now descended upon Dallas
Investigations in search of "leaks" or, as is more common here in Missouri, "broken levees
on the Mississippi."
Meanwhile, subpoenas are not issued. Cases languish. And experienced RTC employees
increase efforts to leave the devastated Texas program. History repeats itself.
447
eeSOlUTION TBUST COIfPOIfATION
KdalvlBi Th* Criiit
Sf«orin| The CoaRdtace
March 23, 1993
Thomas Hindes
Assistant General Counsel
Professional Liability Section
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
1717 H Street, 10th Floor
Washington, D.C. 20006
Re: Resignation in Protest
Dear Tom:
For the reasons set forth in my memoranda of March 18, 1993 and
March 3, 1993, I do not believe that I can work effectively for the
Resolution Trust Corporation auiy longer. Accordingly, I hereby
submit my resignation from the RTC as of April 4, 1993 (or at some
other mutually acceptable date.)
I attach the memoranda of March 18 and 3 as an integral part of
this resignation letter and strongly urge you to look into this
matter further. As we discussed, I would like to have an exit
interview with you in Washington to explain more fully my views on
the situation down here and the reasons for my resignation in
protest. Please advise me of a convenient time for such exit
interview.
I look forward to our meeting.
Sincerely yours,
Thomas ff\ Bumside
Enclosure
cc: William DePugh (with enclosures)
Diane Mendoza "
Chris Jones "
Mark Gaibrellian "
Arturo Vera-Rojas "
David Stockwell "
D. Rex Taylor "
Mark Greenwald " \
Bruce Pederson "
Thomas Bambrick ■
Wayne Fogle "
John Adair "
Edward Stephenson "
448
BACKGROUND ON TEXAS'S S&L's
A Never Ending Story
An Introduction to the
S&L Symposium
by
G. Christian Hill
Despite the hundreds of acticles written about the
c;iuses and implications of the thrift debacle, it re-
mains a disaster with a continuing capacity to surprise
»t\d confound. Several hundred savings and loan aS'
sociations (S&Ls) considered likely to survive just a
year ago are now failir\g or distressed. Reliable esti-
mates of the total 1 0-year cost of resolving failed S&Ls
■ire now more than double the $157 billion predicted
in August 1989.
There is a widespread misunderstanding of the
history and future of this financially cataclysmic event,
partly because those respot«ible for it — thrift opera-
tors, regulators, accountants, and politicians, among
others — have assiduously sought to minimize and
misrepresent their contributions to the problem. They
have tended to blame each other — accurately as it
turns out — for negligence, delay, and deferral.
But this invidious process has obscured the more
fundamental flaws, in the way our financial system
operates and the way it is politically administered,
that fostered the thrift debacle. Because several of the
Mr HiS u i>ie Son Ftannjco Bureau Oief of The Wall Street
louTuI He hai coveted Ovifi asutt unce 1979.
root causes of the debacle have not been addressed,
the intended solution to the crisis, the Financial Re-
form, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989
(RRREA), is no more than a stop-gap measure. More-
over, it falls fat shoa of paying for the losses that will
actually be incurred over the next decade. FIRREA 11
is apt to be near the top of Congress's political agenda
by fall 1991.
Thus, the Stanford Law 9 PoUc^ Review's sytnpo-
sium on the thrift debacle is a particularly timely and
useful exercise. Much remains to be done in terms of
policy makit\g and assessir^ causes and costs. Many
of the articles assembled here illuminate the likely
problenw of the future by distinguishing between sec-
ondary and primary causes of the thrift crisis.
There is common agreement that the biggest mis-
takes leading to the thrift crisis were the decisiotu by
the Federal Home Loan Bank Board (FHLBB), from
1980 to 1989, to allow savings at^ loan associations
to operate with little or no capital, and the FHLBB's
inability to supervise these ittstitutions as they ran
amuck. The amazing and perverse history of capital
forbearance is well summariied in the presentation of
William Black, general counsel for the Federal Home
SPRING 1990
21
449
\
C.CHRISTIAN HILL
Loan Bank of San Francisco, in his paper, "Ending
Ovir lorebcarers' Forbearances." From 1980 to 1982,
through a series of accounting deceits, the bank hoard
under thcn-chairman Richard Pratt ictually turned
losses into assets, allowing essentially ins-^lvent SdiLs
to continue to operate. Yet no provisions were made
for the huge increases in supervision required by such
a policy.
Some commentators give credit to a subsequent
chairman, Edwin Cray, for trying to reverse tl.e process
of deception from 1984 to 1987, but members of
Mr. Cray's own staff concede that his efforts were too
little, too late, and too politically ineffectual. They
say that he himself attempted to suppress studies in
early 1985 showing the thrifts' deposit insurance fund
was insolvent. (Mr. Cray provides his own inierpre-
tation of events in an article in this symposium.)
Under the last chairman, M. Danny Wall, more
financial alchemy was practiced, this time to "resolve"
insolvent thrifts by writing a 10-year blank check for
their losses in assisted sales, using notes that obli-
gated the Federal Savings and Loan Insurance Cor-
poration (FSLIC) to pay money it didn't have. Mr.
Wall repeatedly denied that the insurance fund was
bankrupt, in the face of overwhelming evidence dat-
ing all the way back to early 1985. (A director of the
Federal Home Loan Bank in Cincinnati wrote in 1985
thai "some of my colleagues worry that the FSLIC is
broke. 1 don't worry. 1 know it's broke.") The failure
to adequately supervise S&Ls lasted right up to the
passage of FIRREA in August, allowing S&Ls such as
Lincoln Savings, Columbia Savings, and Centrust
Savings to place huge new bets on junk bonds and
direct real estate investments, and to rack up huge
new losses, as late as the second quaner of 1989.
Mr. Black notes that the "problem with this kind
of deceit is that the regulatory agency comes to be-
lieve Its own lies." But that is perhaps a too chari-
table view of what happened to these regulators. They
often knew lies from truth, but felt beholden to the
political administration that appointed them to keep
a lid on the problems. They also realized that Con-
gress Itself, in the thrall of lobbyists and campaign
contributors, was not receptive to radical solutions.
The capital forbearances, the lack of supervision,
and the misrepresentations to the public were driven
by the most fundamental cause o( all — a flawed po-
. litical process. The articles by Mr. Gray, Joseph
Crundfest, Michael Waldman, and Thomas Romer
and Barry Wemgast, taken ti>gether, give a well-
rounded view of the compliciry of the administration
and Congress in the crisis. (Congressmen who led
the effon to include forbearances in the 1985 FSLIC
recapitalization legislation now pillory regulator^ Uir
delays in closing down thrifts.)
Even Charles Keating, Lincoln's chairman, h.is a
telling point in noting that the patronage system re-
sulted in the appointment of two FHLBB chairmen,
Mr. Gray and Mr. Wall, whose only qualification was
the assiduousness with which they served their po-
litical bosses. (In his own paper for the symposium.
The C^est for Truth," Mr. Keating draws the con-
clusion that these inexperienced regulators then de-
stroyed the value of thrift assets by seizing innocent
institutions, a conclusion unsupported by any other
examination of the failures of the thrifts he names.
In fact; most evidence suggests the opposite to be
true — their inexperience led them to delay acting
against the named institutions until their losses haj
mounted to huge sums.)
There are at least three other primary cau5e> cf
the thrift debacle that typically receive little atten-
tion, but are examined in the symposium's presenta-
tions. The first IS the lack of current market inform.i-
tion about the value of assets owned by the ihnti
industry. Regulators, investors, and thrift. operator>
often have little idea of the losses built into different
assets, because these assets are valued on their hi.<-
torical cost rather than their current market value
As Mr. Crundfest, Donald Simonson and Ceor<;i.
Hempel, and Charles Schumer and J. Brian Grah.un
point out in their respective anicles, the failure ti'
develop systematic models to estimate current values
left regulators in the dark, and to this day makes ju-
p>ervision and reform of the deposit insurance system
difficult.
Such reform is necessary, though, for depo>ii
insurance is unique to the United States and is thv
root cause of many of the thrift industry's problem^.
as Messrs. Schumer and Graham and James B.irili
and R. Dan Brumbaugh note in their accompanynvj
pieces. As long as S&.Ls can easily attract funds be-
cause they are insured, regulators will be hard-pressevi
to supervise them. But beyond that, it is dep«>>i'
insurance that has led to the most pressing problem
for depository institutions: the tremendous ovcrc.i-
pacity of lenders, driving down margins .ind enci-uf-
aging the pursuit of risky loans.
One of the most effective ways to cure the pf"'^'
lenw created by insurance is to iiibjcct thrifts to the
discipline of the financial markets by forcing them t>'
either co-insure a small fraction of e.nch deposit «i'"
private insurance companies or raise subordinated M'"'
or other capital in (hose markets. The scmcinv -'<
22
STANFORL") LAM' Ck POLICY RE\ it^"^
450
^StVER ENDING STORY
„i,(irors .mJ investors woulJ eliminate much of the
il-ility "(^ opcmtors to take p^M^t risks, hut co-insur-
.\\v:< by the i»iirkets is only possible if the markets
li.ivc enoiinl^ rixkJ, current informntion for r.ition^il
.kciiion milking.
Finally, there is a common underestimation of
uu'ther primary cause of the thrift debacle — the
i-\ii'iu to which the mortgage market is moribund.
AKuit 1 ,500 S&.Ls excel at i.^suing mortgages, mainly
Kv.iusc they are well-capitali:ed, low-cost providers
m Mirly healthy markets. The strength of these irwti-
tiiiions is not widely understood. But the roughly
|.k.\X)other S&.Ls — a total twice that of the thrifts in
Table 1. Cost Estimates of ttie Ttirifl Rescue for 1989-1999
(Billions of Dollors)
L'as of Funds
Zero-coupons to repay non-Treasury debt
Interest on non-Treasury debt''
OIJ case expense
New case expense (cases after Jan. 1990)
Savings Association Imurance Fund
Administrative costs
Interest on working capital debt
Lost tax revenues from FSLIC deals
Treasury interest
TOTAL
SouTcts of Funds
Proceeds from non-Treasury bonds
Proceeds from receiverships, asset sales
Thrift premium income
FHLB contributions
Miscellaneous revenue, including bank
insurance premiums, more FHLB funds
Treasury funds
TOTAL
Date of Estimate
July 1989 May 1990'
S60
$11.0
563
92.7
49.5
es.c
74.0
124.0
88
8.8
2.8
19.0'
0.0
28.0"
0.0
9.0-
0.0
95.8''
S197.4
$197.4
• Assumes that new-case expense increases by $50 billion, resulting in an additional
J jO billion o( RTC bonds, and iKat non-Treasury sources are found to pay for the
>ddiiional non-Treasury inieresi experue.
Aiiumes non-Treasury borrowing at 8. 75% aiMJ Treasury' Iwiowing at 8.5%, in
roughly equal annual amounts over the first s« years, to finance all revenue
shortfalls. The interest rate assumptioiu are conservatively tew.
' New General Accounting Office estimares.
SOURCE; CjkuUlions based on repom by tlu: Offict of Managnnrni and Budget, ibt
CVnrtal Accouming Office, and <he U.S League of Savinp Insiinniont.
conservatorship and on the rejulators' "watch list"— ^
are having a very tough time earning profits on
mortgages.
Their expenses arc tixi high and their margins on
loans arc too low for two reasons: 1) ferocious
competition fostered by the gtwcmment mortgage
agencies, Cinnie Mae. Fannie Mac, and Freddie Mac;
2) the need for the F<>deral Reserve Board to keep
short-term rates relatively high compared to long-
term rates, reducing the spread between deposit costs
and mortgage yields. (This need did not exist before
the abolition of interest-rate ceilings on savings in
1980-1981.)
As Messrs. Barth and Brum-
^^^^—^^— baugh note in their article, "hold-
ing mongages in savings and loan
portfolios has been unprofitable, on
average, since 1984." The group
of marginally profitable mortgage
lenders is at risk of slowly being
ground into insolvency, a trend
that encourages some to manipu-
late their assets to fake earnings,
in the end increasing the cost of
the thrift cleanup. A common '
example of asset manipulation is
gams trading, the selling of good
assets to generate profits while
keeping the worst assets on the
books at historical costs. Centrust
Savings, for instance, reported
capital right up until the time it
was sei:ed by regulators early this
year, but gains trading has turned
the institution into a hollow husk,
with real assets worth $2 billion
less than liabilities. Even more
ominously, this group of weaklings
will quickly self-immolate when
(not iO short-term rates signifi-
cantly exceed long-term rates for a
considerable length of time.
FIRREA only addresses one
fundamental cause of the thrift
debacle — the lack of capital. It
does not reform the political proc-
ess and, in effect, increases politi-
cal influeiKC over regulatory deci-
sions by placing the Office of Thrift
Supervision (OTS) and the Reso-
lution Trust Corporation (RTC)
under the control of the Treasury.
I
$456.3
$57.1
$107.1
21.7
21.7
30.9
30.9
5.1
5.1
4.6
41.0
78Q
250.5
$456.3
SPRING 1990
23
451
C. CHRISTIAN HILL
The new OTS director, nominated by
President Bush, is a former labor lawyer
with even less direct experience than his
ill-fated predecessors. FIRREA does not
provide for mark-to-market accounting
systems, nor for deposit insurance reform.
FIRREA actually increases SSiLs'
exposure to the mortgage market by rais-
ing the amount of required mortgage-re-
lated assets from 65 percent to 70 percent
while prohibiting even savvy, healthy
thrifts from making many other forms of
investment. By devaluing the thrift
charter in this and other ways, FIRREA
greatly increases the costs of closing and
selling S&.Ls.
The Bush administration, in the time-
honored tradition of FHLBB chairmen, has
consistently misrepresented and underestimated the
cost of the thrift rescue. When the rescue plan was
officially unveiled early last year, the administration
said the plan would provide $90 billion. Later, the
Office of Management and Budget said the legisla-
tion would cost $157 billion, but that figure excluded
off-budget spending that raised the total to $197
billion.
It IS now clear that even this amount is grossly
inadequate. The RTC has already allocated $44 bil-
lion of its budgeted $50 billion to resolve the first
group of cases, with another 300 to 600 cases coming
down the pike. Messrs. Barth and Brumbaugh calcu-
late that, based on the historical costs of closing down
thrifts, the ultimate tab for cases resolved after 1988
could range from $140 billion to as high as $190
billion. Moreover, other cost estimates, such as those
for administration and financing thrift-assistance
agreements completed prior to 1989, have ballooned.
Table 1 shows how another $50 billion of RTC
costs, when added to other costs, results in likely to-
tal spending over the next decade of nearly $360
billion. As the table indicates, die Bush administra-
tion estimated, using optimistic assumptions about
income sources, that the thrift industry could finance
roughly 60 percent of the $197 billion originally
budgeted for the cleanup. But the Treasury will have
to pay for most of the overrun beyond $197 billion.
The cost of the thrift rescue is being financed
with a combination of U.S. Treasury debt and non-
Treasury debt (issued by the Resolution Funding
Corporation), a distinction discussed by Kenneth
Ryder in his article. Because the financing is with
30- to 40-year bonds, interest costs will continue
Table 2. Cost of the Thrift Rescue
Over 40 Years: 1989-2029
(Billions of Dollars)
1989-1999 Costs (from Table 1)
Non-Treasury Debt, 2000-2029
Treasury Debt, 2000-2029
Total 40 Year Cost
$456.3
274.8
638.8
$1369.9
NOTE: Calculation auume that all cost] except inietcM end by 1999. It
exclude) the interest cosu of borrowing to pay Treasury interest (i e., the
compounding effect of paying interest on interest).
nearly to the year 2030, reaching a grotesque total ^1l
more than $1 trillion. (See Table 2.)
As the head of the General Accounting Office
said in early April, the funding provided under
FIRREA amounted to a level that would allow the
Bush administration to meet politically sensitive defi-
cit-reduction goals and had little to do with the
amount actually needed to close and sell insolvent
thrifts. Now, as in previous years, the lack of liquidity
is driving regulators to delaying tactics. The RTC
has recently conceded that it may defer handling the
most expensive cases in the future, selling the lea.-t
insolvent thtifts first. There is some evidence, m
Messrs. Barth and Brumbaugh point out, that the
OTS is delaying transfer of more basket cases to the
RTC. As a strategy, it may be proper to defer resolu-
tion of adequately supervised S&iLs, but the admini-
stration should not try to use this method to hide the
actual costs of the program.
The huge funding shortfall has significant polici
implications. It suggests that a tax increase is neces-
sary to avoid the onerous interest charges associates
with financing through the federal deficit, which in
effect requires paying interest on interest, compound-
ing ultimate costs. It suggests that the commercial
banks' deposit insurance fund may be expropriated m
some point to help finance the cleanup, as will aJJi-
tional income of healthy thrifts and their federal hop't'
loan banks.
In sum, as Messrs. Barth and Brumbaugh .iccu-
rarely predict. RRREA as both a funding vehicle <fn>'
a policy instrument "will soon be recogni:ed as one
more mutation of the problem. " ♦
24
ST.^NFORD LAW & POLICY RE\ l'"'-^
452
Stuck With the Tab . . . Part HI:
The S&L Bailout Continues
Lara Thyagarajan
Legislative Assistant
Northeast-Midwest Congressional Coalition
May 1993
RECEP'T'^ ""^1 «? in--^
453
Stuck with the Tab . . . Again
The savings and loan bailout is now in its seventh year. Since 1986 the
federal government has closed, merged, or stabilized 654 insolvent thrifts at an
estimated cost of $122.80 billion. No doubt the bailout has been the nation's
largest financial disaster. Less well understood is that the bailout transferred
enormous wesdth from the Northeast-Midwest region to Texas and a few other
Sunbelt states.
Although Texas pays just 6.1 percent of the nation's taxes, the state's
insolvent S&Ls have accounted for 41.2 percent of the bailout's total costs from
1986 to 1992. The 18 states of the Northeast-Midwest region, in contrast, shoulder
46.5 percent of the tax burden but were responsible for only 15.3 percent of the
costs.
The Congressional Budget Office and the Congressional Research Service
estimate that the American taxpayer will pick up at least 70 percent of the bailout
costs, with the remainder covered by insurance premiums from the thrift industry.
Thus, of the $122.80 billion in total costs, the nation's taxpayers have paid $85.96
billion. The single state of Texas, responsible for $50.59 billion of the cost of thrift
resolutions, will pay only S5.28 billion. (The next most burdensome state,
California, shouldered S15.70 billion of the blame and $11.48 billion of the burden.)
Stuck with the tab were the 18 northeastern and midwestern states, which were
responsible for S 18.82 billion of the 1986-92 cost, but which paid S40.00 billion of
the bailout.
Texans point to the collapse of oil prices in the 1980s and the accompanying
regional recession as the primary cause of their S&L industry's woes. National
policies deregulating the thrift industry, they say, encouraged a tolerance for high
risks that turned into disaster when the collapse came. And they argue that the
nation came to the aid of both New York City and Chrysler Corp. when they
reached the financial brink.
Yet plenty of other states suffered economically in the 1980s, but their S&Ls
didn't become basket cases. Texas simply dropped the regulatory reins on its
state-chartered SiStLs, encouraging an orgy of speculative and insupportable
investment. While depositors surely must be protected, no one should overlook the
fact that Texas thrifts sponsored, in essence, an economic development program for
which the rest of the country- must pay. Finally, the federal government made
money from both the Chrysler and New York City bailouts, while the S&L bailout
will cost taxpayers more than SlOO billion.
Sorihcasi-Midivesi Hepon
454
The Blame and the Burden Tor the S&L Crisis
(in thousands of dollars)
Percent
Percent
of 1992
Burden
Total Blame
of U.S.
U.S. Tax
of the
1986-1992
ToUl
Burden
S&L Crisis'
New EnglaDd
Coooecticut
145.639
0.12
1.99
1.710.612
Maine
13.957
0.01
0.42
361,034
Masuchusetts
1.452.947
1.18
2.92
2.510.043
New Hampshire
19.592
0.02
0.49
421.206
Rhode Isbod
10.475
0.01
0.42
361.034
Vermont
0
O.OO
0.21
180.517
Total
1.642.610
U4
6.44
5.535.849
Nfid-Allantic
Delaware
0
0.00
0J4
292.265
Maryland
833.793
0.68
2.28
1.959.897
New Jersey
3.214.203
2.62
4.42
3.799.449
New York
3.056.039
2.49
8.72
7,495.746
Pennsylvania
2.801.367
2.28
4.82
4.143,291
Total
9.905.402
8.07
20J8
17.690,647
MJdwest
Illinois
4.025.579
3.28
5.22
4,487.132
Indiana
180.109
0.15
1.94
1,667.631
Iowa
611.389
0.50
0.97
833.816
Michigan
220.726
0.18
3.73
3.206.322
Minnesota
1.176.268
0.96
1.78
1.530.095
Ohio
956.017
0.78
4.07
3.498.588
Wisconsin
100.706
0.08
1.81
1.555.883
Total
7.270.794
5.92
19.51
16.770.871
South
Alabama
378.373
0.31
1.21
1.040.121
Arkansas
3.042.S92
2.48
0.67
575.935
District of Columbia
n,a
n.a
0.31
266.477
Florida
8.647.791
7.04
5.20
4,469.940
Georgia
670.616
0.55
2.29
1.968.493
Kentuck-y
226.073
0.18
l.IO
945.564
Louisiana
3.8S0.605
3.16
1.23
1.057.313
Mississippi
627.513
0.51
0.62
532.954
North Carolina
397.773
0.32
2.26
1.942.705
Oklahoma
2.443. S98
1.99
0.99
851.008
South Carolina
111.165
0.09
1.06
911.180
Tennessee
339.996
0.23
1.62
1.392.558
Texas
50.5S7.i;4
41 IV
6.14
5.277.968
Virginia
2.066.5o5
163
255
2.191.990
West Virginia
94.446
0.08
0.49
421.206
Total
73.514.S30
59 87
27.74
23.845.411
\ortheaii-Midiveit Report
455
Estimated Present Value Cost of RTC Thrift Resolutions
(in thousands of dollars)
ToUl
Cost
1986-1989
1990
1991
1992
1986-1992
New England
Conneciicut
0
34.994
48,549
62.096
145.639
Maine
0
0
13.957
0
13.957
Massachusetts
0
899.913
553.034
0
1.452.947
New Hampshire
0
0
19.592
0
19,592
Rhode Island
0
0
0
10.475
10.475
Vermont
0
0
0
0
0
Total
0
934,907
635.132
72.571
1.642.610
Mid-Atlantic
Delaware
0
0
0
0
0
Maryland
69,000
376.805
372.653
15.335
833.793
New Jersey
285.000
70.803
2.710.893
147.507
3.214,203
New York
59.000
1.776.080
743,952
477.007
3.056,039
Pennsylvania
720.000
332,758
1,559,505
189.104
2,801,367
Total
1.133,000
2,556,446
5.387,003
828.953
9.905.402
Midwest
Illinois
2.611.000
749.516
549.809
115.254
4.025,579
Indiana
145,000
34,415
0
694
180,109
Iowa
446,000
47,446
106.304
11.639
611,389
Michigan
188,000
31,058
0
1.668
220.726
Minnesota
299.000
872.710
4,558
0
1.176.268
Ohio
380,000
266.074
306.876
3.067
956.017
Wisconsin
0
86.192
0
14.514
100.706
Total
4,069,000
2.087.411
967.547
146,836
7.270.794
South
Alabama
17,000
267.901
23,892
69,580
378.373
Arkansas
845,000
619.541
1,556,794
21,557
3.042.892
District of Columbia
n/a
n.'a
n/a
n./a
n/a
Florida
2.527.000
2.252.368
2,440,712
1,427.711
8.647.791
Georgia
20.000
262.073
.309,049
79,494
670.616
Kcniuck-y
177.000
3.149
45,924
0
226.073
Louisiana
1.511,000
1.048.933
874,725
445.947
3.880,605
Mississippi
14.000
588.S67
224.646
0
627,5 13
North Carolina
77,000
107,530
131.616
81,627
397,773
Oklahoma
1,665,000
250,345
400,833
127,720
2.443.898
South Carolina
2,000
0
109.165
0
111.165
Tennessee
34.000
108.503
27,188
170,305
339,996
Texas
29,674.000
10,42S,.'65
10.129.648
355.111
50,587,124
Virginia
171,000
94,737
401,^80
1.398.94S
2,066.565
West Virginia
81.000
13.446
0
0
94,446
Total
.^6.815.000
15.S45.:5S
16.676.072
4,178.000
73,514,830
Morlheast-Midwen lioDon
456
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
■Mtoriag Tbc CttSdcaeB
Office of Investigations
Proj TBSS /teport on Professional Conduct Invstlgathns
1993 Semi-Annual Report
June 30. 1993
457
R rC CIVIL RECOVERY REPORT
Intitution
[ft ;<tt»albnaJ Uablirty Rftcovericia .-1
City
Ai Q B«nl(, F.S.B.
AE Q Bank, F.S.B.
AlilneFS&LA
Af tbAiudof S&LA
Ar >ertc«n Home S&L
At terlcan Piortoar
At Wftoan Savtngt^Colorado
At lertcan Savingi/Colorado
At terican Security FS&LA
At MTican S«cudty FS&LA
Ar lerlcan 6&LA of Brazoria
At lerifirst FS&LA
At mtntsx FS&LA
At terlMao Savings Bank
At ;tibr Savings Assoc
Bs DC Iowa FSB
Be noPlus FSA
Bs fKPIus FSA
Be DcPlus FSA
B« ncPIUS FSA
Be icPlus FSA
Be njamin Franklin FSA
Bcotf SA
BetarSA
BflcarSA
Bacar&A
BU ck Hawk 8ALA
Bh « Vaney FS&U
BheVansy FS&LA
BU • Valley FS&LA
C« juas Cantrai
Cj pitol Federal
C^mennlaJSa
CcitarS&LA
Ccfitral Texas 8&L
C« iTiust FSB
Ce iTrust FSB
Ce itury Federal
C« nury Federal
AB>uquorqua
Albuquerque
Steamboat
Tamarac
Edmonton
Orlando
Colorado Spngs
Colorado Spngs
Chicago
Chicago
Lake Jackson
Miami
Miami
HIDsboro
Kansas City
Cedar Rapids
Pasadena
Pasadena
Pasadena
Pasaderui
Pasadena
Houston
San Antonio
San Antonio
San Antonio
San Antor\k>
Rock Island
Kansas City
Kansas City
Kansas City
San Juan
Aurora
Greenville
CUftOft
Waco
Miami
Miami
Trenton
Trenton
St
NM
NM
CO
FL
OK
FL
CO
CO
IL
IL
TX
FL
a
IL
KS
lA
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
IL
MO
MO
MO
PR
CO
TX
NJ
TX
FL
n.
TN
TH
Appendix 1
Claim Type Furtds Received
D&O
Bond
Officer
Accountant
D&O/Attomey
Accountant
Attorney
D&O/Att
Commodhlas
Securities
D&O
Bond
Accountant
O&O
Bond
D&O
D&O
D&O
Other
Accountant
Other
Bond
D&O
D&O
D&O
Accountant
D&O
D&O
D&O
D&O
Accountant
Aooourrtant
Securities
SecurWea
D&O
Other
Indemnity
Bond/D&O
Accountant
VI C Offio* oflavwtlg»ttnn> 1903 Scai-Aaoaal Kcport
2.000
S10.000
714
20.000
asfi.ooo
35.820,000
1,700,000
1,900.000
76.000
926.894
400,000
668,718
3,802,500
226,008
257,363
8,760
160.000
300.000
2,500,000
3,550,000
6,000,000
2,150,000
550,000
2,700,000
3,250,000
43,600,000
175,000
5.000
6,000
105,000
6,070,000
1,010,000
1,497,600
166.600
1.000,000
961.657
15.000,000
660,000
825.000
15
458
RT C CIVIL RECOVERY REPORT
Incttution
Cen :ufy Saving*
Chll loo(A« FS&U
City S«v<no*. FSB
CoU nial F8
Coll mbft S«vln0s Amo&
Con P9d Savinga Bank
ConmdfceFSA
Con meroa FSA
Corr moftwftaJth FSA
CocT munKy S&LA
Con «rd)a Fed«r«l
Coo iOf d-UtMny Fad S&U
Com InentaJ FSLA
Cro9 vo«d« S&L
Dep i8it Trust SB
Dapi alt Trust SB
Dd« rat 6&L
£a«t Toxaa S&LA
BPimBA
ElysimFSB
Ente pdM FS&LA
Enta pds« F3&LA
Enia pd<« FSUA
FamlyB&LA
Fade ral SB or Virginia
RdeltyFS&Uk
Fidel ty F6&LA
PIdeltyS&tA
Final dalFS
FIrat Knnapona SB, FSB
FIrat -SB
Brat -SB of Kansaa
FIrct 'SUA
FVat -6&LA of Atlanta
First -S&Uk-Colorado Sprlnga
First =S&LA of l.argo
First 4otwO(1i6av1nga
First Uvtng-tndapandorwa
FIrat >taUSB
First ^tata SB
!•
CRy SI
Baytown TX
Ctfoncotha n.
Badmlnstar NJ
RoMfla Part NJ
Wabstar TX
BavarlyHUls CA
Uwol MA
San Antonio TX
San Antonio TX
Houston TX
Fond du Uo Wl
(Anting IC
Monroavilla PA
Edmond OK
Cneootah OK
Monroa LA
Monroa LA
SaKLakaCity UT
Tylac TX
BPaso TX
HotMksn NJ
Marraro LA
Mansro LA
Marraro LA
Saatita WA
Fana Church > VA
Gala^burg IL
(Saiaaburg IL
PortAnftur TX
JopBn MO
Annapolla MO
Otamondvffla WY
Weatngton KS
Uatvam aR
ADanu QA
Colorado Sprlnga CO
Largo Ft
LoaAngaiaa CA
indapendanco MO
Mountain Homa AA
Mountain Konw AR
Appendix I
Claim lypa Punda Raoalvad
Bond
DftO
o&o
Sacultitta
Bond
Bond
DAO
D&O
BroicUab
Appralaar
Attorney
Otttar
Atlomay
Attomay
Bond
Othar
O&O
D&O
Seouitiaa
O&O
Bond
Attornay
Bond
Bond
Securitiaa
Attornay
D&O
Securitiaa
D&O
D&O
Attorney
Bond
D&O
D&O
D&O
D40
Bond
D&O
Bond
Appralsar
O&O
1,035,000
10,000
4*7409
84,000
M,900
18.750,000
24.000'
S20,0OO
9.700,000
1M.0OO
920,000
131,500
50.000
25,000
85,000
151,527
750.000
700,000
2.248.400
15,000
941.573
500
700,000
700,000
48400
43.480
60.000
280.800
600.000
100,000
200,000
430.000
118,000
380.000
774.887
13.500
725,000
108448
705,000
550.000
1,800.000
RTC Office of iBvwtiplsaM 1993 Saai-AvMl y^T^a
459
rVc civil recovery report
Ifii ttuntoo
Gi maa SUA
0(mCity&&LA
Gc rmontown Trust
Gl Savlngt Assoc.
Gr Mt Atlantic SB, FSB
Gr )at Ptaina FSA
Ha llmark,N. American
Ha Imart.N. American
H6 iderson Home
Hu watha F8A
HU Finandal, 8A
Ho T>a FS&U
Hone F8&LA
Ho no Ownert Savings Bank
Ho ne 8A of Kansas City
Ho TM Savings Bank FSB
lUtr o(s SavV^gs Bank
lm| >erlat Fodorai Savings
Imi wrtaJ Federal Savings
Imi »erial Federal Savings
L&i idnuuk Savings Bank
UbMtyvUleFS&LA
UnxinFS&LA
Unx>inFS&LA
Un»(nFS4)LA
IJn»(nF5&LA
Un»lnFS&LA ,
Un »(n FS&LA
UnsinFS&U
Unx>lnFS&LA
Ur> »ln FS&t>
UnxXnFS&LA
Un»lnFS&LA
Ur^xXnF8&l>
Lln»)lnF8&LA
Lk^«lnF8&LA
Un»(nFS&U
UnxXnFS&Uk
Un»lnFS&LA
Un xXn FS&LA
Un xjln FS4LA /
RTi : Office of bvMtiptiaDa 1993 Semt-Asauii ttfott
CKy St
Qamelt KS
Quincy IL
Germaruown TN
San Antonio TX
Manteo NC
Waatherford OK
Plano/San Antonio TX
Plano/San Antonio TX
Henderson KY
Hiawatha KS
Red HUl PA
Algona lA
Algona lA
Burlington MA
Kansas City MO
Salt Lake Ctty UT
Peorta • IL
SanOlego CA
San Diego CA
Son Olego CA
Hot Springs AR
Ubertyville IL
Irvine CA
Irvine CA
Irvina CA
Irvkie CA
Irvine CA
Irvine CA
Irvine CA
Irvine CA
Inlrw CA
Inrlne CA
Irvine CA
bvkw CA
, bvina' CA
/ Irvinel CA
Irvine CA
livtne CA
Irvine CA
Irvine CA
MLCarmel TN
Appendix 1
CtalmType Rinds Received
D&O
D&O
D&O
Attorney
Bond
Accountant
Bond
Accountant
Bond
Bond
O&O
Bond
D&O
Securities
Bond
Bond
Appraiser
Securities
Bond
Accountant
D&O
O&O
D&O
D&O
D&O
Attorney
Attorney
Appraiser
Attomey
D&O
D&O
Aooountartf
Other
Attorney
Other
Other
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
Accountant
D&O
62^00
160,000
700.000
1,ftS0,000
126465
34e.0OO
100,000
650.000
ZTS.OOO
50.643
36,957
25,000
100,000
MS.OOO
60.265
2.800,000
. 22.000
1.833,523
6,000,000
10,420,000
297,552
6,600,000
19,000
16,000
80,000
60,000
350.000
643.342
600,000
1,658.408
2.522,4<1
S.038A41
4,001339
6,025397
6,d«8,5«7
8^46.285
7,600.000
20,000,000
29.401,811
37357,006
200,000
17
460
R TC CIVIL RECOVERY REPORT
InitJtutlon
M t<S»oo Guaranty Savinga
M Jbu Savlngi Bank
M iraBank P*<l«rBj SavlnQt
M iritSaM SA
Ml Iwut Fedaral Saving*
Mi iweat Federal Savino*
Ml l-KATua* S&U
Ml iaiislppi Saving!
Ml »«Isslppl Savings
N« w Atneni S&U
N( w Braunf e(a S&LA
N< w Guaranty FS&Uk
Ni a Valley PedaraJ Sav.
Nil i Vallay F«deraJ Sav.
Hi i Valley Fe<J9r&l Sav.
Nc nil American FSA
Nc «r<ln Savings
Pe )pla« Bank (or Savings
Pe >p(«a Federal Savings
Pa >p<e« FSB
Pe >ples Heritage
Pd >plea Heritage
Pe >ples Heriuge
Pe )ptaa Herluge
Pe iples Heritage
Pe >ples Heritage
Plr«F8&LA
PIr la FS&1>
PIT It F8UA
PIT la F8&U
Pre gressive FSB
Re )ubnc Bank fof Savtngt
Re lource Savings
RO'OiPalm
Ro 'ai PaJtn
Ro 'al Palm
Ro «JPalm
Sai JadntoSA
Se( urtty Savings
Sio a Valley S&LA
Sot tneastem FSB
1«
City SI
Auguita AR
CoaUMesa CA
Pttoentt AZ
Houston . TX
Minneapolis MN
MlnneapoOs MN
VflchiU KS
Btte«v1D« MS
Batatvine MS
New Athens IL
New Bfaunfels TX
Taylor Ml
ScoUbluff NE
Scotsblutf NE
SootsbMf NE
San Antonio TX
North RIcMand TX
Sireatar ' IL
Banleavills OK
Hampton VA
Sailna KS
Banna KS
Salha KS
SaBna KS
Sailna KS
Sanna KS
Tucson AZ
TUCtOA AZ
Tucson AZ
Tucson AZ
NatcWtochee LA
Oaekson MS
Deniaon TX
West Palm Beach FL
West Palm Beacn R
West Palm Beach PL
West Palm Beach FL
Houston TX
Walsrtuiy CT
Cheroks* lA
Charlotte NC
Appendix I
Claim Typa Rinda Reoetved
Aooouniant
Aooountam
Bond
Aocountant
OftO/GTA
Att/GTA
D&O
DAO
O&O
Secuildea
Bond
D&O
Appraiser
Attorney
Anomey
Bond
Bond
Bond
Aocountant
O&O
Attorney
D&O
D&O
D&O
O&O
D&O
Other
Other
Other
Aocountant
Bond
Accountant
D&O
D&O
Aocountant
O&O
AQocney
Attorney
Aooountant
Bervl
Accountant
1.02S,000
330.000
1.1S8,e41
2,010,000
4,as7,a5i
•.778.7M
47.500
100,000
500.000
03.600
17.500
1.2S0.117
281.522
SOO.OOO
B87.000
17.500
300,000
: 510,000
17.S00
615,000
25,000
137,600
137.500
163/408
eso.ooo
2,850,000
25.000
66.28S
68,600
4.730,000
525,000
135.000
121.750
53.47»
060410
1,011.441
8,457.577
25,000
430.000
875.000
630.000
RTC Office of InvMtiisdaai 1993 Seai-Aaswl Report
461
fItc civil recovery report
IfKtItution
6i <MI*top SA
9 M Mutiiil F8&U
Gi tt0«nan FSB
& n Savtnot Aseoo., FA
Si in Savtogs Auoc., FA
8< n SUta Savings
Tl i^>ertand FSA
T( ivU 8&LA
Tr dent Faderal
Ui Ited FSB
Ui Ited Saving* of America
Ui Jtad SavinQS of America
U( Ked Savings of AmsrV»
U( Ivarslty Savings
Vi (ley Savings Banl(
Vi n«y Savings Bank
V( rmortt Federal
VttortaSA
VI Jon Banc Savings
W ishlngton Savings
W >stam Gulf S&L
W )«tem S&U
W inamsburg FSMJk
Baaumont TX
Jadcson MS
Watartoo U
Kansas City KB
KansuClty K8
Soonsdala AZ
Nacogdochss TX
San Antonio TX
Anolu Haitor NJ
Vlanna VA
Clilcago IL
Chicago IL
MelMurna PL
Houston TX
RosweU NM
Roswafl Nlyl
Tlmonlum MO
San Antonio TX
langsvUe TX
Stoddon CA
BayCtty TX
Phoanix AZ
Salt Lsiia City UT
PUB Rsoov^ry Total
[ot W9l Btmiiam LaiD<)efl-retatedj<acoMBrtea"a5=r>?r"^
)rlxai
Drfaxai Funds (combined)
Dr uel Furtds (combined)
Or ml Rinds (combined)
Dr »xat - Reorganization
Dr txal > Reorganization
Dr ixai - Reorganization
Or Dcel • Reorganization
Ci nTottt FSB
C< nTruat FSB
Cc fnmorwealth FB&LA
Cc rnmorrwealtti FSALA
Cclunibia Savtnga
B >asoSA
Rl C OfrWa of lavactitatiaM 1993 Scou-AbsuiI Raport
Mlan^
Miami
FlLauderdala
FlLauderdala
BavertyHUs
BPaso
FL
R.
FL
FL
CA
TX
Appendix I
Ctakntypa Funda Received
Saoudtlas
Bond
Bond
D&O
D&O
O&O
D&O
Seouhdea
Seountlaa
Attorney
D&O
Bond
Accountant
Bond
D&O
O&O
.Bond
Accountant
Securitlas
Bor\d
D&O
Other
Bond
Securttlaa
Securttiaa
SeoudHea
4U.000
a9o;ffis
125,000
2,000
100,000
2,890,000
276,000
4«.eoo
166,600
25.000
aa.ooo
125,000
1.690.000
5,500,000
3.000
38,000
250.000
3.840,000
52,000
470,000
214,000
1,365.000
1.000.000
40S.S20.045
43.151.688
1.600.000
12.876,763
11.743.934
3.837426
9.634,078
172,600.000
4.668,618
299.314
6.000.000
634.376
600.000
266,470
19
462
HOW BIG IS THE S&L BAILOUT? BUSH ESTIMATE v. REALITY
The Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC), the agency responsible for cleaning up the nation's
ailing thrift industry, is coming before Congress yet again to ask for more: taxpayer dollars. Tliis
time the Adminislraljon is requesting S42 billion, and is claiming that this latest installment will
be enough to finish the cleanup job. But ihe RTC has been consistendy wrong so far. The task
of the RTC is far from over, and with the stagnant economy persisting there is ever)' reason to
believe that the thrift crisis wiU continue. How many of our tiix dollars are going to pay for the
greed, .speculation, and self-dealing that occurred in the thrift industry in the Roaring 80's?
The Magnitude of the Bailout "^^"■"^
.■Cost to the taxpayer to
♦ Congiiess has authorized S88 billion for the RTC, •■Clean up some of the
;~ more notorious failed
♦ $15 billion is added 10 the budget each year to pay S&Ls (In billions):
interest on the S&L Bailout,
-Lincoln S&L $2.3
♦ The RTC has borrowed $53.8 billion in "working Centrust S&L $2.5
capital," which is the money borrowed from the Siverado S&L $2
Treasury against RTC assets to provide liquidity, , Venion S&L $L3 • ^
And, the RTC has requested $42 billion more for 1992.
(note: these figures do not include either: J) S67 billion in sweetheart deals made by the
regulators in 1988 to cover up the size of the crisis in an election year, or 2) the accrued interest
costs from borrowing all the money to pay for the bailout which roughly triples the cost of the
bailout.)
Bush Administration Estimates At Odds with Most Other Experts
The entire history of the S&L crisis has been one of wildly skewed and often inaccurate
cost estimates by the Rcaean and Bush Adminisuaiions. The current funding request is no
different. While the Bush administration has lowered its estimate of the ov. .'all cost from $160
to $130 billion, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). for example, has steadfastly held to '\\s
$215 billion projection. Here's a sampling of various cuimaies of the cost to taxpayers:
Albcn V, Casey, CEO of the RTC, in 1992 •- J130 billion wiUioui InteresL
William Seidman. Former Director of RTC. in 1991 •• $220 billion without Interest.
Congressional Budget Office -- $215 billion i.n 1990 dollars without Interest.
General Accounting Office -- $.S00 billion for total clean up of the S&L crisis with interest.
Economists convened by tlie .Stanford Law and Policy Review -• $1.37 trillion with Interest.
463
3m. funding the bailout through Treasury Department borrowing is much more expensive
than paying for it now. As a result of this deficit financing, taxpayers will be forced to pay
billions of dollars extra each year in interest payments alone.
According to a team of economists assembled by the 5;t/infnrH I ^w and Pnitt^y
Rgyjew. the total cost of the S&L bailout over forty years could amount to $1.3 trillion. Of
that mind-boggling sum. over S913 billion will be used to pay iutcresL The upsurge in federal
borrowing has already helped keep interest rates high.
Sscflnd. borrowing the funds to pay for the bailout -- and then relying on the existing tax
code to pay back the loan places the burden on the backs of the middle class and poor. Average
citizens neither caused nor benefifled from the policies that led to the industry's collapse. They
did not benefit from the widespread looting of the S&Ls. nor did they benefit from the
unprecedented wave of financial deregulation. Those in upper economic income brackets did
benefit from these policies, through higher interest payments and expanded investment choices.
But most families arc net debtors, who suffer when real interest rates rise. Whatever benefits
they gain from greater interest on savings accounts was overwhelmed by the higher interest they
had to pay on their houses, cars, credit cards, and student loans. Average citizens should not get
stuck with paying for fiascos they neither caused nor profiled from.
Third, it is utterly irresponsible for the government to undertake this new monumental
spending without regard to the impact on the federal budget deficit. TTie amount to be used this
year -• $80 billion •• is larger than the annual budgets of every federal cabinet department except
the Department of Defense and the Department of Health and Human Services. Indeed, under
the Budget Enforcement Act of 1990. when new spending is proposed -• for education, child
care, transportation, or law enforcement - it must be accompanied by new revenue to pay for it.
But the S&L bailout and the bank bailout have thus far been treated as if they were minor
tfichnicallUes, instead of the massive new government spending that they are. Late last year,
Congress hastily passed the funding legislation with few reforms.
Recommendation
All financial hailout'; should he funded on a "pav-a-S-vou-f o" hasis. The Administration
should be required to provide a plan to raise the necessary funds for financial bailouts. When the
Administration formally requests additional funding for the RTC. Congress should require that it
be accompanied with a plan to raise the revenues to pay for it just as all other funding requests
for government programs require. No new funds should be authorircd until the Administration
presents its plan to pay for the bailout in the same year as Congress authorized the funds for it.
120 HUl. G Chn»u«n Stjnfnr.^ 1 ^w .»1 Pnlicv Wcvifw 'A hltyer Pndint Rlprr. An tauaaafioB Tft Th« SAL Kvmpn»tum '
Spnng IWO.
42
464
A number of factors call tnc Rui;h Arimlnistntlon's estimate Into question. There are few
Indications thai the economic condition of the thrifts has changed •• they arc still undercapjuUzed and are
sun holding real estate that Is decreasing in value. More spccincatly:
♦ The Administration underestimates the number of ihrltts that will fail; CBO cstlmaics are 400 to
500 higher than Office of Thrift Supervision.
« The feeble sales record of the RTC. which the LA Times estimated lost 40 cents on Uie
dollar, guarantees even greater taxpayer backed costj.
• As the sale of assets winds down, the RTC will get an even lower rate of return as It sells less
atiractivc assets.
« The cost esumate does not include the interest co.fts on Uie 30 year KIC bonds
which fund the bailout and roughly inple the costs.
Bailout Cost Estimates Have Proven Unreliable;
Administration Minimizes Costs During Election Years
Year
Administration's
Hsii mated Co.st
(billioas)
Authorized Fund.s
(In billions)
Adniinisrration Comment
1988
$0
$0
M. Ouay Wtll;'W( u< wiihin raibai dirtoot ol
teiourcti tvultMc **
1989
$50
$50
Forntfr RTC l^irector. D«v1d CooIm;"S50 hiUioo
npreacDU ihe cumM oost o< Tillit| Ihe hole"
1990
$130
$0
1991
$160
S38
Willitm SiulRuofWe IM acxhiii ihu ikould
CAuae u< lo re^ii« uur ofiaioo thai SiO bltlioo of
■ddlUoflii lo<i (ua^ •pp«tn lO b« wtflCKB (or the
RTCi iK«ii.-
1992
$130
$0
Albert V. C4ie)r:'We woo'l conx beck fof m««."*
(* 9i Preiidealiil elecuon)
The Admlnlttratlon Make* lu Case In Mid May
Albert V. Casey
'If they would just give us S42 billion, we believe it will be cnougb to rmisb Uie job. We won't
come hack for more "
John E. Robson, Deputy Seoetary of the Treasury
"I hope Alt right: I'd hate to go back to Congress again.'
The House Banking Committee Responds Dubiously
Chairman. Rep Henry B Gon/ilei (D-TX)
"The Adiiunisu-ation bas experienced great difficulty keeping Its numbers svaigbt on tbe savings and loan
cleanup. ci(her by design or incompotrnce The hisiory of missed projectloos may make it diilicult to
restore tbe agency's credibility."
Rep. Jim l.each (K-IA.)
"Based on past expencnce. Congress applies limited credibility lo Government estimates."
Rep. Bruce Venio (D-MN)
"I ihink Uiey're definitely trying lo gloss over it in the election year."
Far inor« information contact Sherry Ettloon Bt Public Citii«n't CongT»n Watch (202) 546-4996
465
Total R«eev*ridB
Accountants
5
D & 0
13
Bond
Attorney
Appraiser
Other
Total Texas
37
$ 53,940,000
$ 9,995,750
$ 9,156,500
$ 1,675,000
$ 150,000
S IS.SlQ.HOfl
$ 90,426,050
ft* ^> 3m<
466
RECEIVED -LrOuP -083
OIRECT DIAL
(214)969-1246
Thompson & Knight
A pnorrssiONAi conPonATiON
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELORS
1700 PACIFIC AVENUE • SUITE 3100
DALLAS. TEXAS 7S;0I'<(«]
12141 9««'17O0 AUSTIN
FAX (2M1 »«9 1751 FOOT WORTH
HOUSTON
September 17, 1993
Mr. Thomas J. Bumside
Reinert, Duree & Crane
812 N. Collins
Laclede's Landing
St. Louis. Missouri 63102-2174
Dear Tom:
After the rather hurried ending of our conversation this morning, I reflected on the major
conclusions or principles that I can mention that might help you in your testimony before the
Senate Banking Committee. I will add only two to those we discussed.
The first is that, as a defense lawyer, I would much rather deal with a competent and
prepared adversary such as you. I feel this leads to reasonable settlements of cases that should
be settled, the opportunity for a decision not to file suits that should not be filed and an early
undersunding of siniations where it is inevitable that suit must be filed and litigation pursued.
Conversely, it is extremely frustrating (and it happens most of the time) to deal with anomeys
who are not prepared, not knowledgeable on the facts, merely posturing, want a minimum of
$100 million to settle, no matter what the facts, etc. My reaction as a defense lawyer is that it
is impossible to settle or even have a reasonable discussion in these situations and therefore, I
simply prepare to litigate.
The other major principle is somewhat unrelated. I mentioned to you that I feel many
RTC lawyers are not aware of the U.S. v. Bereer injunction not to engage in a "win at any cost"
approach to litigation. It is very troublesome to me when RTC lawyers, expressly or impliedly
use the litigation resources of the federal government to attempt to pressure settlements, as
opposed to using the facts of the case and legal theories that arise from the facts. A related
principle is that I believe the RTC should not file lawsuits solely because it thinks it can win or
because it believes it can extract money; instead, the lawsuit should have a reasonable moral
justification as well. I believe the RTC has recently filed several litigations that it will not win
and that have no moral justification. One of the worst examples is a suit in which the major
complaint is an alleged lack of due diligence by an institution that acquired Dallas Federal
Savings & Loan Association. There is no claim of fraud, ultra vires or other malfeasance;
467
Thompson & Knight —
Mr. Thomas J. Bumside
September 17, 1993
Page 2
instead it is simply a claim of negligent underwriting. There are several reasons why I think this
claim has no mora! justification, apart from the fact that the RTC might get to the jury a fact
question as to whether the directors committed negligence against the instiaition in the due
diligeiKc process. First, the Federal Home Loan Bank Board insisted on the usual rebuttal of
control agreement. This effectively limited substantially the amount of due diligence that could
be done. Second, it is bound to have known much more about Dallas Federal than the acquirer
knew or could have learned as a result of any amount of due diligence, and it approved the
merger. Third, it is undisputed that as a result of the merger there were very substantial cost
savings by closing of office, firing of redundant personnel, etc. In effect, the acquirer took
Dallas Federal off the government's hands and subsuntially reduced the ultimate loss to the
government. The RTC attorneys say this does not matter, we are simply asserting a cause of
action standing in the shoes of the acquiring corporation. In my view, this overall approach
lacks moral justification.
Most citizens (including lawyers who defend these cases) applaud the efforts of the FDIC
and RTC to pursue claims where there has been real misconduct. Such claims should be
pursued vigorously. However, when these agencies bring lawsuits that are ill-conceived, ill-
prepared or lack moral justification, it simply erodes people's confidence and trust in their
government and its agencies. The short term problem of finding competent and successful
directors to serve on boards is well known. I think the longer term problem may ultimately be
far more harmful - a permanent change in the anitude of citizens toward their government and
its agencies and officials.
I hope this is of some help to you, Tom, in your testimony next week.
Very truly yours.
ScJhuyl^ B. Ma
Marshall
SBM:mae
468
1 • Inl-tBritad Litxq«tion
n ■ PLS «tty h«« dacxdad « caaa axiats
S > PLS «tty suspacta a c*a« axiats
N B PLS atty has dacided no casa aniati
C > Officially Closed
' 6 lank or "-" • Unknown
FIN Institution State Si:a
sc
-34.
so
60.7
TN
63.
TN
20.4
TN
17.
TN
108.
TN
218.
TN
88.6
TN
64.
TN
1063.3
TN
42.8
TN
8.
TX
573.
TX
3S.
TX
213.
TX
153.
TX
21.
TX
125.1
TX
35.8
TX
107.9
TX
128.
TX
633.
TX
94.
TX
71.7
TX
40.
TX
87.
TX
230O.
TX
624.
TX
4000.
TX
33.
TX
528.
TX
436.1
TX
104.
TX
202.
T»
16.
TX
61.
TX
123.
TX
67.
TX
34.
TX
217.
TX
36.
TX
74.
TX
778.
TX
150O.
TX
232.
. Fidality Bond Claim
. .Accountant Malpractica
. . . Attorney Malfiractlca
.... Security Broker
Comm. Broker
Appraiser
Crim Referra
Hi Profile
OTS Da
_______ __ 08/02/91
SYSSNNS YY 03/09/91
YVINNNN YN 03/09/89
_C--- NN 02/08/91
SNNNNNN YN 02/01/91
MCMMCCN YT 03/09/89
CCCCCCC YN 07/20/89
SCCSCCC YN 03/09/90
nCCSCCC f H OT/09/89
SSS---- -- 04/19/91
SC--- YN 08/03/90
CCCNNNN YN 03/09/89
MCNSSNS Y- 03/02/89
CCCNNNN Y- 04/06/89
ICSSNNN Y- 03/09/89
NCNNNNN Y- 03/09/89
CCCCCCC N- 08/03/90
SCNNSNN Y- 12/07/90
S.CNSNNS N-. H/30/90
■■ >3^C^S>N-N-NN^Nl- 08/31/90
SCNNNNN -- 11/30/89
SCSSSNS YN 03/09/89
N C N N N N_N N - 03/09/89
I AfCS'tH^H'-n-fi-S^f- 01/04/90
SNNSNNN Y- 03/09/89
3 fH c H n n N N-ett^ 04/06/e9
nCMNNNN YY 03/09/89
SCSSNNS YY 03/02/89
nCNNMNn YY 02/08/89
SN-S--- -- 05/31/91
SCSSNNS Y- 07/27/89
NCSNNNN YY 08/01/89
NCNNSSN N- 04/06/89
-l-nCNMNNN tO-l 04/06/89
-- 08/l«»/91
NRNNNNN Y- 03/09/89
SCSSSSS YY 01/11/90
CCCCCC- -- 03/09/Q9
SCSSSN- -- 03/22/91
SSSSSSN YY 1O/26/90
I I N N N N N Y - 03/09/89
NNNNSNN Y- 12/21/89
nCSSRNS YN 03/02/89
HNnriNNn yn 03/09/8«;
CCCNNNN -- 03/09/89
e
469
K«v I i • Suit Authorized
I ■ Inharitad Litigation
M ■ PLS «tty ha* dacidvd m c««« •Mist*
S ■ PLS «tty su«p*cts « cas* CKists
'J ■ PLS atty has decided no case eMisti
C - Offtciallv Closed
Blank or
■ Unknown
FIN Institution
State Size
TX
62.6
TX
64.
TX
43.
TX
216.
TX
68.7
TX
1233.
TX
51.
TX
229.
TX
803.
TX
88.
TX
1100.
TX
104.8
TX
89.
TX
9'?.
TX
103.
'TX^rf&T'T
TX
17.
TX
68.7
TX
SO.
TX
88.
TX
274.
TX
174.
TX
447.1
TX
38.
TX
34.
TX
2500.
TX
3493.5
TX
65.
TX
229.
TX
35.
TX
64.
TX
87.
TX-
- 49.6
:/rX-^S20««
TX
139.
TX
184.
TX
92.
TX
13.5
TX
41.
TX
9120.2
TX
85.6
TX
309.1
TX
140.
TX
32.
TX
99.
Directors fc Officers
. Fidelity Bond Claii*
•' . Accountant Malpractice
'. ." . Attorney Malpractice
.... Security Broker
Comm. Broker
Appraiser
Crim Referral
Hi Profile
GTS Da
CCCCNNN -- Ol/ia/90
RCCNNNN 03/02/89
NCNNNNN Y- 07/09/6?
07/19/91
SCCNNNN N- 01/18/90
SCCCCCC -- 05/31/91
SCNSNNN V- 04/0o/B9
tCSSNNN Y- 03/16/8-?
SCSNNNN YY 08/10/99
nCNSNNN Y- 03/02.- 89
SC-S--- y- 04/06/89
*SCS---- Y- 06/01/90
-SSNSNNS YY 07/27/89
"SSNSNNS YY 07/27/89
f3f?tSSa2i>titCN:- - - 07/13/90
'^^iS-'R-N N •~S.^l*-H^V-'«-<y2All&/.%fi .
NCNNNNN Y -"03/02/89
CCCCCCC Y- 01/26/90
CCCNNNN 04/06/89
CCCNNNN 03/02/89
•'S C-9 S N N S.- Y r 09/21/89
SCNSNNY 05/25/9.:i
^nCS. SNNS YY 04/06/89
SCSNNNN 03/10/89
YCNNNNN Y- 03/16/8O
SCSNNNS YN 03/02/89
SNSSS-S -V 11/30/90
SCNNNNN Y- 03/16/69
CCCNNNN 03/16/69
NCNNNNN N- 03/16/69
NCNNNNN -- 03/09/3=
CCCNNNN OT/02/69
S^C N S N N N Y_- _0a/17/6?
'S C'S S S N N Y"-'ll/T0/39
NCSNSNN N- 03/16/8°
nCNNNNS Y- 03/09/69
NCNNNNN Y- 01/13/9"
HCNSNNN Y- 03/02/6?
NNNNNNN YY 04/26/91
CCCCCNN 08/10/4:.
SCCNNNN Y- 10/19/89
SCNSNNN Y- 08/17/35
'SNNNNNN 09/21/90
SCNNNNN -- 04/20/9V
M
470
V ■ Suit Authorised
I ■ Inharit*d Litigatlorr -
n - FLS «tty hat decided • cas* vxistB
S > PLS atty suspscts a case eMlats
'N ■ PLS attv h*« decided no case ettist'
C ■ Officially Closed
Blank or "-" - Unknown
"IN Institution
State Si=e
TX
112.
TX
C89.
TX
49.
TX
143.
TX
367.
TX
482. .
TX
140.
TX
17.
TX
43.1
TX
288.
TX
67.
TX
110.3
TX
93.
TX
89.
TX
220.
TX
89.9
TX
744.1
TX
235.5
TX
280.
MTjtMi. "* ^/^^ a
TX
67.7
TX
148.
TX
179.8
TX
38.7
TX
134,
TX
70.8
TX
383.
TX
52.
TX
171.
TX
298.
TX
54.4
TX
265.
TX
87.6
TX
47.
TX
. 985.
TX
17.
TX
29.
TX
25.7
TX
166.
TX
27.3
TX
140.
TX
152.
TX
52.
TX
124.
TX
109.
Directors % Officers
. Fidelity Bond Claim
. . Accountant Malpractice
. . . Attorney Malpractice
I .... Security BroKer
Conrn. Broker
Appraiser
Crim Pceferr*;
Hi Profile
OTS Da
ICSSNN- Y- 07/13/89
SNSS- 09/20/91
MCNNNNN Y- 03/ 16/89
^inrrBiN'N N n nr- oe/24/8';
ISCNNNYN -- 09/21/6'
•< a S S 8 N N S'mMb- 09/»7/«<>
CCCNNNN Y- 04/06/3"
SCSNNNN Y- ll/09-«?i.
7,<S'^C:TiCS£MZMU.S3aBE" 07/27/39
MCNNNNN -- 03/16/89
__ _ __ 07/ 12/91
SCSNNNN V- 06/08/90
CCCCCCC -- 03/09/89
MNNMCCC -- 03/09/89
__ 10/11/91
CCCNNNN -- 03/16/90
SNSSSNS N- 01/04/91
SCSNNNN Y- O5/25/90
-■_ 09/27/91
■■ifeB.n. fi..B..j»>w»6 "■ r)or24y-9r>
NCNNNNN -- H/30/9:i
CCCCCCC Y- 09/21/89
NCNNNNY -- 05/ 13/9.;.
NCNNNNN -- 09/ 14/9" •
f.WC H'H'tTHNr - - 09/21/8T
SCSSN N S Y - 05/ 19/9.:
**ti*^''^T<'H"HtTITMTliyT- 07/i3/8<=
CCCCCNN -- 03/16/6=
CCCCCCC -Y 09/ 14/6=
NCSINNN Y- 03/16/6=^
CCNNSNN -- 1 1/30/9 •
M C_S N N N S Y - 03/02/8"
tiS'C N' N S N N. IB- ll/30/8«=
SCNNNNR Y- 03/l«>/6=
YCSYNNN YN O2/07/8-
CCCNNNN -- 04/06/6=
NCNNNNN -- 03/16/8=
CCCNNNN -- 08/17/6=
^ S- Y S S»N N S ,Y.-Y 07/27/6 =
C C .C.N^N.NN - - 08/ 17/8=
i^tfgS^WSPijnihn^ - 04/06/6 =
^CSSNNN N- 09/21-9
NCNNNNN Y- OZ.'.'^/i
MCNNNNN Y- 03/lfc/e
SCNNNNN -- 03/16/6
a«
471
»«rt r - Suit Authorized Oir.ctor. «i Officer.
I - Inherited Litigation . Fidality Bond Cl«i«
n - PLS *tty h«» docidad « c«** •Mists . . Accountant n«lpr«ctic»
, S - F-LS «tty su«p*cts « c«s« exists . . . Attorney Malpractice
N - PLS atty has decided no case exists .... Security troker
C - Officially Closed Comm. Broker
Blank or "-" - Unknown Appraiser
• • Crim Referr,.
FIN Institution State Sise Hi Frofil<r
OTS Da
TX 214. CCCNNNN NN IX/l^/S-^
T« ZBo.a scssNNN s- or/2r/9.:
TX 142. SCSSNNN -- 09/ll/9<
TX 52.1 MCSNNNNN- 0-/16/e«
TX ^29.8 SCNSS N- 06/29/9.
TX 85. C C C N N N N Y - 03/09/S'
TX 119. YCNYNNy Y- <:ij/09/a';
TX 2600. riRSNNNS YN 02/i>8/e=
TX 16.2 CCCCCCC -- 01/26/9.:
TX 582. SCSSNNN Y- 10/19/S";
TX 882.85 SCS.SNNS YY 06/29/8'
TX 75. CCCNNNN 0-/09/8':
TX 66. C C C N N R N Y Y 03/02/8'?
TX 137. SCNNNN- Y- 03/09/8*
TX 121.6 ^S C N N - 06/29/9'
UT 2000. tINNNNNN YY 02/17/8=
UT 229. SSSSSSS -N 02/10/8<
UT... 16. SYSNN NN 07/05/9<:
UT 229. CCCNNNN 02/17/8=
UT 381. SMSSSNSY- 01/26/9.
VA 600. SCCCSNC YN 12/08/3=
VA 9. NCNNNNNNN 03/30/8=
VA 1298.9 , ___•..___ _N 02/01/9]
VA 837. CCCCCCC NN 10/19/9.
VA 25. SCNCCCC YN 06/29/8"^
VA 278. SCSCSSC NN 10/19/8-
VA 399. CCCCCCC YN 03/02/-*.
VA 50. _s------N 05/03/9:
VA 2120. 8N--NN- -- 01/25/9;
VA 452. SN-S-SS YY 07/31/9.
WA 101.4 SNNNSSS NN 02/08/9:
WA 166. SCSNSSN NN 02/23/9.
WA 1900. . CCCNNNN NN 03/31/8^
WI 170. SYSI S YN 02/l7/e=
WI 93. CCCCCCS NN 03/30/8=
HI 152.89 SNSNSSS NN 07/12/9:
WV _________ 09/13/9:
WV 3^.9 -SS- SY- 02/23/9.
WV 77. S SS 02/23/9.
WV 23. SnSSS Y- 11/29/8'
WY 262.7 SCSNNNS NN 02/23/9'
WY 12.8 SSSSNNS YN 08/10/9'
WY 32. NNNNNNNNN 07/26/9
472
TEXAS SUBPOENAS
To:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Sharon HowardeLEGAL^RTCDAI,
Bradley M. SvollcintLEGALeRTCATL
Julie F. Yanda§LEGAL§RTCKC
Bruce Pederson^LegaieRTCDEN
*§legal-plseRTCDC
§Legal-pls§RTCDC
Financial subpoenas
Friday, May 1, 1992 8:26:06 CDT
N
Sharon HowardeLEGAL§RTCDAL
fn^oJ^^? ? true believer in sending D40 target- subpoenas for financial
i?n^n4°" ^"^IJ®^^ *f °^***'' things). In my case, we had paid some
$20,000 for a DiO asset search that turned up $8 million in assets.
Lhnn«nL*?J Mrginal case. In March, I sent out fairly simple financial
««o^«^ K ^""^ returns, financials, and other asset information. While not
everyone has responded, so far, this subpoena has turned up well over SlOO
million in assets. Suddenly, the case looks big.
I suggest that you try it, if you haven't already.
To:
Cc:
r-
B
FIwA:
Subject:
Date:
Attach :
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Susan TibollaeLegal-plseRTCDC
Sharon Howard eLEGALeRTCDAL
Suzanne RigbyeLegal-plsiRTCDC
Thomas BurnsideeLEGALeRTCOAL
re: NO. OF SUBPOENAS ISSUED IN 1991
Thursday, January 30, 1992 12:43:21 CST
N
Our records show the following Orders of Investigations and subpoenas were
issued in 1991:
Orders of Investigation Subpoenas
SWRO
MCO
GCCO
SCO
Total
11
5
13
27
56
180
41
3
13
237
TOtaj. 56 237
Our CFO's will double-check to make sure that we are not missing any Orders or
Subpoenas .
473
To:
Ce:
Be'*
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Susan TiboLl«eLegal-pls«RTCDC
Sharon HowardCLEGALCRTCDXL
Suzanne Ri9by9Legal>pIs9RTCDC
Thomas Burnside«LEGAI4RTC0AI.
Thursday, January 30, 1992 13:25:54 CST
We received confimation on the MCO fiqwcmM for Orders of Investigations and
Subpoenas. SVTRO is also correct. SCO has 20 (not 13) subpoenas. GCCO has also
confirmed our figures. The new total for subpoenas is 244 (not237)
To:
Cc:
V<.om:
Subject:
Date:
Attach;
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Susan TibolIaeLegal-plsCRTCOC
Sharon HowardeLEGALCRTCOAL
Suzanne RigbyeLegal-pIsfRTCOC
Thomas Burns ide«LBGAL«RTCOAL
re: KO. OF SUBPOENAS ISSUED IN 1991
Thursday, January 30, 1992 12:43:21 CST
N
Our records show the following Orders of Investigations and subpoenas were
issued in 1991:
SWRO
MCO
GCCO
SCO
Total
Orders of Investigation Subpoenas
11 180
S 41
27 ^ 13
56 *^ 237
Our CEO's will double-check to make sure that we are not missing any Orders or
Subpoenas.
itfc
474
Xesolution Trust Corporation
Metroplex Consolidated Oflice
PLS
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
R*:
MEMO
Rex Taylor
Section Chief
PLS - Dallas
Olga Villela
Paralegal Specialist.
PLS - Dallas
June 23, 1992
Senate Request for Me. of Subpoenas Issued by PLS in 1992
BAUftA
(NCO)
Jan.
Feb.
Har.
J^r.
May
June
(1)
(8)
(0)
(0)
(2)
(2) (as of June 19)
(SWRO]
Jan
(1)
Feb.
(0)
Mar.
(0)
Apr.
(1)
May
(0)
June (18) (as of Jxine 19)
SAM AMTOWTQ
Jan. (16)
Feb.
Mar.
Apr.
May
(12)
(8)
(38)
(9)
June (1) (as of June 19)
BATOM
ROOCE
Jan.
(71)
Feb.
(35)
Mar.
(0)
Apr.
(58)
May
(50)
June
1)
3S00 Mmpir Atrmue. I2rft Floor. Dtllm%. Texmf 75219 (214) 443-2300
475
To:
Cc: ,
Bcc:
F-ob:
iject:
bate:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Kimberly M. Thorne§Legal-pls*RTCDC
Rex TayloreLEG2eRTC0ALMET
Olga VillelaeLEG2§RTCDAU<ET
re: Monthly Subpoena Count
Monday, July 20, 1992 11:18:16 COT
Following is the infomation you requested:
(Dallas Regional and MCO offices are now coabined; however, Z listed
the subpoenas separately. If you want to coabine thea, please do so.)
OALIAS
(MCO)
Jan. (1)
(SWRO)
(1)
(SAM ANTONIO)
(16)
(BATON ROUGE)
(71)
(HOOSTON)
(0)
Feb. (8)
(0)
(12)
(35)
(0)
Mar. (0)
(0)
(8)
(0)
(0)
Apr. (0)
(1)
(38)
(58)
(0)
May (2)
(0)
(9)
(50)
(0)
June (2)
(18)
(6)
(3)
(0)
476
3S^
<9
3
s
a
•
e
ft
(k
o
c
en
•
•
•
•
•
t
r
5
.
,
^
'
«
'..
<> .
'
v
s
.-
s
(^
<u
Ck
Q^
a
(k
Q^
Ck
Qs
\
c
c
■ ?
c
o
C
O
c
o
o
o
(T
o
9
0
c
<r
CI
1
<^
;: c
<3
o
o
lb
o
<
c
«
u
I
u
I
e a
\l
s
o
c
o
u
•
O
X
I
u
-;
^ .a
• ■»C
P s4
u 1 ?
e 3 J
U vi9-
S ^
:
*
=
-
-
:
:
:
:
c
2 ^
«/■
«
■5
s i
5 \^
3 c
3 '
i
•
J
*
-
#
*
s
t
I
t
■ «
a d
o
I
c
o
f
I
K
477
i
e
J
•
•
««.
>>
^
a
en ^
X
'.
1
t ^
^
I <i
;
s
i ^
u
^
<^
1 Qi
<k
1
^
» c^
-J
c
9
c
V
8:5
r-
c
o
or
o
o
CVi
3
vo
Of CT
c o
a
o
U
e
o
e
a
s
u
e
0
•
3
O
X
I
X
u
ri3
- o
3 ^
o
a
0
9
\r.
%
o
o
I
76-818 0-94-16
478
I
0 a f>-
21 ^
i o
1
i
<
r
^
S i ^2
e
Qs
V
Qi
K
n
<c
0
n
c
Q
a:
m
o
Of
o
/)
<I
n
C
•
V
q
vDcJ
■» it
ST O
Q
s
e
0
e
<
c
— m
o •
• s
5 r
■ V
• a
S 5
,
S
•
1
<
1
2
u
•
r
f
#■
*
f
0
*
if
2
/
•
i
•
e
1
5
«<
w
O
i
*
^
#4
f
S
1
0
•
a
«
■c
1
479
•4
■
e a s.
I
2
1
9
i
^
c
\0
■^
^
vc
X
n
/I
ex
-^
^
^
I
Q
I
(v Q<:
o
o
V)
■c
o
<x.
(V
I
o
w
Q
c-
cc
o
cr
c
o
c
<
I
u
B
e
■
9
O
X
e a
• a
I
nr
c
5 Qi
1
I CI
} CX
5 ^ c6
I
a
480
S
e
I 5°
1
Q
o
o
^-
^
•
•
\n
o
\r
•
o
vi
•
«
o
•
•
O
v'
•
1
r
I/O
o
•)
a:
•
O
V)
a:
•
•
1
•
s, -
o
>S
c
vi
c
e
c
c
I
s
€
il
Z
•
s
2 f
1
« J
a
J
■a
(2;
c
S
«
1
r
«
S
0
«
^ 1
?
*
1
'1
I
•i
V^
#
«
•
•
■s
5 J
I
I
o
481
I
c
.4 V
ii
1
S I
S
e
^»
CV
*
•
•
*
ji
•
•■
•
«
«
<
0
1
*
\
o
•
«
■JO
^
:
s
»
1
CI
0
Q
o
CO
O
\^
0-
Q<
c
1
1
(L
1
\r.
..CE
1
cr
o
o
CC
O
o
1*
c
o
e
<
c
a
u
i
a
o
k.
U
c
o
e ■
9 *)
3^
li.
L
V
?
^
— 1
«
ft
a F
11
Of 3:
'.
♦ vi
1 X
^
tf
«
s
V
<c
« ^
' V/
4
\r\
e ^
>;
t
k
J
a s
00
s
•
■5
o
J
ci
■a
%
2
c
«
V
vJ
X
c
«
I
I
482
S
e
•4
ii
9 O-
0=
o
<x.
o
I
V"
■
a
V]
Q
Q
a!
Oi
o
v/
<3:
a:
Q^
o
^
a
<r
e
u
e
o
e
<
c
M
•
M
I
e
u
e
o
w
•
I
0 •
5r--
g
1
S <: V
■ 1 "5
tf
c
»
4
«
£
•
3
s
«
s
3 J J^
S S«^
e
a
e
1 ?
:j od
** 2
" OC
0
•
t
r
*
t
*
i
*
f
^
a
I
I
483
i
e
»4
1 ~
in
o
ex.
^
o
I
o
V
V)
M
0-
c
V)
\ri in
^^
s
a.
c
o
u
e
s
M
I
«< ■
0 ■
• a
9::
I
s
c
e
*>
*>
It
l«3
<v
5 Q^-5a
U
^V1
c^d; Q(<
/r"^
^o^
J u
: oi
J
\^
a
c
o
1
K
I
K
484
- £
^.
•J
e
22
.MA ^
r-
c
o-
o
c
o
<r:
o
a:
^
■^
^
o
I
I
c
\/:
Q^
CL
in
o
<x
v^
0-
Q^
c
u
e
o
e
<
e
c
e
s
I
o
O
a ^
8 "3
(3
5 U/
t 3
V
c
<
QL
If ^
0. 5
c2
a o
5 I
0 «
\^
-)
i^
<r fl
f 2
t ft
a
I
o
I
c
0
I
485
Oi
8
1
s
•
•
•
•
tu
,
O
(.1
Oi
«
_
u
^
^
-<
^
<
<
5
^
—
<?
3
<*
H
o
1
<
1
^
•*
<
1
o
-
X
s;
"?
-*
^
\:
^
^
1
0!
Q^
1
1
Otf
cv!
o
c
1
1
-
^ ,„^
CO
^
U3,
:$
J
CC
1
1
V)
a:
-
f\i
i-
^
c
o
e
a
10
■
V)
O
k
u
c
o
3
O
0 ■
8"
X
I
ft t»
a
4>
4i
■
>
oC
c
o3
i
o
c
o
I
486
^4
I
oS :§
5 ^
2 =
It
!
I
E
g
^ ^
^
N
D
S!
v/:
V
I
\/1
a:
•
«
•
•
-
Ok
Q
5
1
en
1
•
•
X
1
r
^
^
-
0
•
•
Ck
^
<•<
Ci:
5
1
3
^
>
V.
1
1
CE
<x
e
o
t*
e
<
w
t
M
I
i
•:
0 2
2^
41
c
J;' «-j
vi
d
0
c
■>
^-» •a
^ •
i2S
si^iR
o
e
1
1
I
oO><r
rtJj
<r «
f I
a 3
\0
3
CO
«
c
e
487
I
e a >
• « N
9
1
<v
•
•
•
•
•
^
d
d
#
•
ct
^
^
•?
-5;
«
'.
*
X
1
nr
:
^
J
^
2
^
^
5
Q.
^
5
5
^
§
Q
Or-
1
Ck!
,
•^
>.
e^
tf
or
s«
vO
\r
v:
\o
v/O
•<
1
"^
-
or
ex
cc
<x
cc
a:
cc
ex
vO
c
o
c
• a
3^
c
e
u
■
a
o
I
o
k.
fi J? VI
a
1^
O
i ^
o
1
f
a
J
•
:
1 ^
1 3
£cr5
_ <
'
5 *u
«' !
S ^
\0
V^
5 :5
3
•
O
•
•
«
2
Q:
:3
S G^
?0l
J
»
^
r \
•
c
0
?
o
488
8 ^
2
9 I
s
e
I
»
<k
0:
If
ft'
rr
Of
C;
Pi
1
6
ex
c
c
2
Qi
>/1
^
V
^
T
X
^
^
^
"J
f
V
>
e
e
w
I
01
I
11
e
I
z
«
2
•
V
■»
1 1
S£ *
il
<
^
•C . V
«- *«i
c
QC
2aM
«.
«
» a
•-
S
«
«
a
r
0 o
«
S 3
«
V3
a u
^
S
1 J
'
«
b
»■
(J
4.
*
CO
•
J
«
•
&>
«
489
i
e
/
•o
^
>t
-»
.
,
•
r
:jt
J
«
,
IH •>
«
♦
«
•
2l :>
^
1 "^
«
>
»
0
r
i ^
S
0
s
»
5
5
5 <j
f
1 ^
cU
Ck
(ii
Q.:
Q^
^
1
(^
<k
<v
(k
9 <^
1 -J:
6
<r
1^
0-
1
1 v/)
\/5
.. ex
vi
CE
V)
ex
\0
CE
V]
CE
c
o
c
3
O
•:
• «
Si!'
(
I
s
§ £ \4
4» < c
S^ ^
- 2
«
S
21 ?
»
s
•
#
3
•
»
g v/1
S 3
B J
:5 a
•
«
«< 0
^
•
•
«
•
« c5
•
o
i
a
I
o
M
O
C
o
I
490
m4
I
e a >
8
S I
§
(i^
1 ^
r
I
vi
vi
i
^5
V)
s
V)
I
O
VI
e
Q^
c
o
4>
e
g
U
e
e
41
I
e ■
■ »
r?
ii^
•
ft
s
5-
•
S£ ?
,
4
'"
*^s
#
•
S- ^
^<i!00
1 "Q
I 'i
t i
s
■«
«
»
«
a c|
^
•
«
«
«
«
a
O
o
I
■
e
0
I
491
i
e
1
H
•
•
,
•H
\
o
y
^
^
a
*
r
5? ^
t
<
•
i
o
ai 0
1
0
,
O
^
t
^
w
4
i
.,
»
c
2 a
<
«
£
a-
ta
1 ^
(L
t
r-
/C
8 "^
^
r;;
r;
r^
cr
-a
d.
<
<»
1 v^
V]
ex
\0
^0
1
a:
>
^
«
cr
cr
c
o
c
<d
(0
I
10
u
c
o
I
o a
a
a a
Si:
-2
-?
?5
<-i^
g| ^
f
■9 1
13 I
»\ Or
'.
i
«
--
u
C5
«
'-
*
♦
8 '5
S -J
a ^
s
•
V
*
4
(
J
«
%
-
-
o
k.
U
Q
I
C
0
•
K
I
492
I
5ll
1
6
f
i
o
<x
c
^
^
<x
V)
PC
1
t
<50
^
^
^
V
cr
^
J
I
I
V)
<
v>
I
a-
I
v/]
C
I
•2:
I
i
e
§
e
«
c
e
e ■-
ll
I
g
e
2
Ci
8 VI
5 !
V -1
C<
o
I
o
I
c
e
r
493
I
•»
■r
»<
w*
1
^
»I1
J
t
o
1
6
^
■
^
: <
^
Z ^0
1
*
I
0
« >
^
1 .
A
^
-0
1
<Q
1
1
7
o
\
0
vO
v:
\r
\r\
<r.
CE
cc
d
^
^
^
a
it
o
o
CE
o
V)
o
^
^
CE
G
NO
CC
e
e
u
e
e
it
■
•:
0
£
I
d
2
0
^^
^
c
! 0
^
o
*
^ VI
1 ^
X
'-
■s
•'
^
<
V
8
NT
<f
{
<C
vi
N^
■
■
J
J
«
s
•
15
J
o
a:
w
;
»
t
1
a
o
Q
I
c
o
f
I
494
S
m4
e
■
^
^
^
<J
^
2
r»
-Q
,0
1
0-
6
o
—
^
?
1
ex
>.
o
^
NJ
CE
o
I
NT)
az
^
V
a:
I
-«5
f
>3
cc
V)
a:
I
9C
V)
a:
c
cc
e
I
g
u
c
e
■
3
e
%t m
0 •
il
?
s
{•£
-?
Et
a
»•
5^ ^
ft
-5^
^ 3
3 i °
X
•2
V
A <£
IT
e
S V
5 c
V^
2 a
o
• (F
<:
2
** up
<
•2
X.
3 (^
-J
o
I
M
o
o ■
V §
« -4
V1«
495
'•4
ii
1
i
i
I
5.
I
^
^
^.
I
«)
^
I
^
^
^
L>i
^ ^
■^
^
^
i
I
-?
t
^.
i^
^
^
^
<
I
I
■ -s- S
e
u
0
i
e
a
«
e
e
*>
•
3
e
%4 •'
•:
■ »
! ^
2 ^
"a
"5
^
.1
b
^
^
V-
^
5
>
^
>
^
;?5
8 ^
"5
i
^
1
3
^
1
«
"1
5 1
V
r»5
^
•^s^
^
^
<^
^
4
Vk
-:5
u
a
I
0
W
o
c
o
I
496
f
5J i
21 '
i
a
M
V)
I
i
>
^
4
I
^
\
I-.1
^
^
v/n
S
i. 3.
^
5' ^>
^
I.
-^
r^:
\.
A
:^.
<4s
-J
i
1
^
Vi
■'J
^
1 ^
I
^
i
t
^
r
V)
I
^
V
I
c
o
i
e
■
i
09
I
■
i
x
%
§
I
2 H
I
^
■A
5^
vX
5
H
»*?
.1^
^
f^
>
^
^
J
J
5
a
^
^
^
^
V
\J
1
J
^
^
N
^
^
^3
a
I
O
«
I
497
*4
I
1
1
I-
0>^
j;?
I
0
t
t
>^
i
1
«0
.'^
111
Q
I
I
V)
X
. <
V)
I
10
o
e
e
0
^ 5
4
^
^
e
w
e
2
I
I
X
I
f
2
r
A \J1
^
i
'^
^
t^
VP
^
r
^ .V
VJ
«
c
J
4
V-M
v/
i
I
o
I
i
0
498
I
»
•*
K
•4
1 A
d
in
»
-s.
^
•i
1 <^
I ^
J
*•
«
^
^
u
1 .
^
vQ
V?
\r.
vO
>0
6
1
^
^
v:
<X
CE
cr
cr
^I
cc
^
^
1
<
^
^
X
^
tp
«>
S^
^
-c
-,
•
<
<
^
-*
Vl
^
s
^0
1
in
1
1
/)
^
?
^
"^J
VI
cr
VI
»
VO
\n
ex
cc
cc
cr
CE
c
e
o
4>
e
■
IS
g
u
e
o
X
I
X
I
g
u
tl
M
J
J
^ -
fc I
*■
£ <
H^-
<
"V
4
^-
II
<
■>,
<
4
^
I %
c
1 ^
V
2 t
/ .
w
J
«
•
•
0
x^
s
4
<
#
2
I
o
I
7
I
499
o.
»i.
y
*'
<1f
^
^
X
11^
•
•4
^
<
«
10
-5
1
5 ^
«>
^
11
1^
>
<
■>
>
«
'.
--
4
--
'-
a^
1 V)
mm r
\ (f
/)
v:
1
vO
Vl
^
\r
V
vn
1
VI
\\
o
r-
n
1
IN
1
^
fN
^
^
1
^
t
^
^
o
a:
V)
q:
ft!
1
1
a:
1
1
e
u
0
e
e
u
e
e
tt
a
3
£5
X
I
§
n
<l
^*J
•
- s <
*<r ^
.
3 w-2
?^2
«
«
«
*
(
»
«
«
<
«
s
4
V
i 1
u
V
t
i
«
#
J J
■4
«
«
^
«
^
•
♦
2
I
o
I
I
500
S
i
^
pt
H
1 i
^
ii-<
^
^
il^
^
--5
■s.
1 ^
<i
5 ^
-^
',
■s
n
^
u
<0
1
v^
v^
1 ^
' 1
1
(V
1
>
ns
in
\n
vn
v^
1
cc
CE
CE
q:
ct
•:
SI
mm
X
<x
v;
<3
t
X
-%
\r.
1 1
c
o
e
m
s
" 0
B U-
S V.
o 0
K i
(O
(.
2
5 J
5 i
2 V^
^
«
•
J
J
-
i
t
:
'.
%
<I
C
V
-J
5 S
J t:
^
1
k
Ll
5 '
*
*
^
1
I
\/5
i
*
a
*
',
1
2
I
o
I
e
e
— ^
I
501
1 a
m f
6 ->
I ^
e
I
^
^
0-
^ -J J
1
e
o
v:
a:
^0
I
V)
q:
\r
^ ^
vn
CI
'^
•^
^
^
0<
J3
^
^
<^
^
^
>
-:»
>
>
r
^
r
^
••
-
^
•V
VI
vO
vO
*
1
3
2
c
Q
t^
1
I
v:
a:
<x
<I
<r
g
B
O
e
I
g
U
e
s
m
I
I
X
I
e
c
\
2
e
1
2
2 !
*
V
a
^
«
c
«
<
7
J
J
o
1
LJ
<x
—
cv
3
f
s
8
O
8 ^
V*
<;
>4
•
V
K
^
1
S ?
w
•
t
<
^
s
■
2 d?
»
^
01
«
*
€
*
1
502
S
e
^
^
^
\^
^
X
«
^
v>
i in
♦
-
-
^
^
o
•0
>0
X
vT)
=
t
u
1 ■
a O
a "O
V
vO
v/;
-^
v/n
Vl
^
cc
t
oc;
Qc
1
c
r^
^
i
I
o
1
to
*
1
1 \^
6 CL
XT
1
vi
cc
c
2
£
CC
cc-
o
a.
V)
1
c
o
e
<
c
a
CO
IS
I
s
u
e
e
tl
a
9
o
X
%t a
e a
^ ^ _i
Es
t
n
)-
e
5 J
5
4< J
a
V
|(
-■
o
Jv^
«
^
s
i
'■■
J
o
'-
'.
"-
8 c
a
J
2
>
^
2 ^
(T
c5
1
V
2
o
Vl
3
#
•
«
b
J
c£
*
*
«
« ^
^
J
^>
v/
1
o
I
a
I
I
503
e
•4
OB ^
ill
1
>0
d:
\
s
V2
I
X
^
J
v^
^
<>
^
^
^
a:
V;
>0^
I
T
cr
^
t
in
I
<^i
a
a:
I
V
e
o
u
i
e
■
i
s
u
•:
IS
^ ^
^ J
-J
-J ^
i
I
X
I
S
•' F
. K
<3
f ^
s ^
V
2 i
d
it
•
*
J
« <j
^
1
^
s
«
^
\
2 ^
si
0
•
-
<
<•
«t
<>c
\^
1 -z,!
^
V
2
■?
^ 1
2 ,1
"5
•
•
w
>
t
f
-
#
«
U
}
^
i
^
s
«
o
I
o
504
p4
f
ii ^
1
s
^
^
^
^
I
V)
<3C
on
ex
vo
I
I
V)
cr
y:
CD
>0
ci:
cr
-0
10
^
\r V]
o
>
0-
rr
(V
e
o
e
I
e
u
e
I
%« ■ .
^ ^ -J o
?
§
e
1 i
w
2 c!
1
4
1 ^
V
1
■J
4
(.
1 ,1
(^
0(
2
\/l
p4
2
o
I
c
o
I
505
«4
ii V)
i
» f ^
s
§
I
«3
£1
m
V)
•:
>
V
4
J -J
<x
w^
%
o
^
>
■J
u
<:
oc
IT
(V
I
V
or
o
c
«
e
u
s
■
I
X
<
h
X
5
«
>
« ^
3
■J
s
i.
2 ol
<
<
^
•
1
<
*
#
%
«
>
^ l
- ^
< X
3 «
S -i
_j
-J
1 )
a ^
9
0
1
i
u
0 «
«
«
V
^
tf
s
a
S
o
I
2
O
506
1
t
i
i
9^
I
ii
1
I
V
V)
NT
v:
v;
q:
t
CE
I
I
0-
vn
n
I
NT
CC
I
CE
a:
q:
(V
vi
s
e
«
e
I
e •
|3^ ^
J
2
■X
8
-J
X
I
i
I
a
e
e
X
507
1 %
1
tf 1 <-T
s
e
«:
«
ju
>3
>2
V)
f
%
^
^
in
vi
^
I
V)
^5
S
VI
<i a: <x
^ (^
V
I
I
IS
<x
^9
N
I
VI
a:
^ ^
§
e
a
a
I
«
e
u
\ i
2
■X
u
-J
t
I
a
I
V
1
f
508
§
i
•
,
•
^
*«
•
"
*
^
H
rt
u
^
,
%
r
^
f
s
jjo
v3
1
1 ^
i 1
*1
1
0
t
*
*•
•_
(
1 ^
Ck
^
^
di
Qi
^
^
3 ^
Or-
"^
1
>
3 "^
r
«r
IT
OO
nr
or
fO
f ^
V)
V)
vi
v^
\0
vn
VI
* cr
<x
cr
cc
■ en
CE
cr
<c
N.
• •
•
il
^
^-«
,
e \.
• «
I
41 «^
c
* J
X
2c^
2
*
s
m
t
»
t
«
^
8 <:
9-
•5 *
\
a J
t
^
t
*
%
t
g
u
u
B
0
■
X
X
I
I
o
I
2
O
I
509
-IN
il ^
i
i
t
\
i
.1
o
5
tl
2
■1 «
■r 2
H
>
.
t
n
£
"■
"*
s .^
*n
3
2 J
^
>
-
"^
-
^
i
J
--
=
J
•
4
-
i
m i
-
4
J
J
e
i 5
3
o
a
J
V
^
1
J
1 1
w
2
4
V
a '*
i
s
^
*.
«
*-
^
-
i
^
■J
■h^
i
■^
f ^
i
ii
J ^
^
e
76-818 0-94-17
510
I
i
e
I
•8 <^
• «
11
s
to
e-
O
N
.y
r
c
O
ii
cr
-3
o
-0
J-
a
,■0
<o
5
o
o
II
rCi
-a.
(0
ii
3-
O
ti <^
-J
r ,■ .^
2
3
J
i
I
\-
J
3 J-
< .
/ =
J,
<
I-
u
J-
V—*
4-
r
^
qJ
%
i|
>
>
s
/
4
.
f
♦
<
J
i
^
511
I..
I
i
I
«)
^O'
c Q
0
«-
n
r ^
r-
o
fl
i»
■J
J-
o
IV
a
^
^
o
•0
o-
O
ti
. N
<0
.f •?
(0
(<■
^0-
(O
^ >
o
h
o •
il
.J
■i.
-J
r
a
«
."a
.0
-
<
<
■<
'i
C
^
^
p*
^
f-
i
i
\-
*
1
v3
i
J
<
<£
»
n
^
u.
U
i
J
*
CB
j;
i
J.
9
^
li
i
i
•
I
5 ■"
J
6
u
i 1
S
i
X
^
^
Ml
• ^
^
^
C
«
a
^
f^
-
-"
ii
"i
J
->
o
•«,
^
vi
-"
Z
J
^
J
J
J
^
^
512
*. 1*
1
in]
i 3
c
i
^
^
^
(J
ih
-J
-J
4
-J
4 i
3
AS
r
s
5
«
3
i
m
^
S
d
4
-
s
4
J
a
>
4
I
%
2
•i
•
1
W
1
i
■
•
-
-
1
;
*
J
t
S
M
<
«
•
s
•
V
1
-
513
.3 ^
u
as.
re
-J
1- ^ >,
I
ft
:J
r
u
\
a
I
<r
O
2
o ■
n
^ ^
■»
5 b
4< «
-i:
.
* i
«i
2 i
h
1 ^
>
c
c
3
I
5 ■:
1
i
a i
i
514
o*. 22 63 o* 5* REORGANIZATIONS "o*
OM HUMMN tiMB ce«e«itt
Congress of the ttitited States
Hfluc or 'Rf^ruoicfitlDes
COMMrrree on OOVOWMeNT^OKRATIONt
eeiMii-iui
MMMMIIMnulM
April 13. im
Hon. Rofer C AJtman
Deputy SeoeUry of tbe TVusuty tod
latertffl Oitef Executive OfBcer
lUtoiutioc Trust Corporttioa
801 • 17th Street, N.W.
Wufamgton,DC WM
Dear Deputy Secretaiy Altnua:
The purpote of this lett£r is to set forth some preliminaiy eonfieras tbout tbe
poslbie adverse impact oo curreot RTC iovesdgatioiu into faOed SALi ansiiig from the
docnre of certain RTC 6eid ofBees and to urge that you w the RTC Oveni(bt Board look
into this dtuatlon to determine wtietber these ooaoenis may oerit nof ttmpmuy or
pennaaent reaediai action.
The Commerce, Coosumer, and Monetaiy ASain Subcoooittee has been
oooduedog a preUminAry Inquiiy into tbe impact of mdi Seid ofBoe dosiap on RTC
investigations tor possible D&O liability, professioaal liabQlqr, and fidelity bond daios and
also the purvoit of criminal activity (for possibie referral to tbe Justiee Oepartmeot). Ti*
Suboonunittee staff has interviewed a mimber of individuals wbo have provided, tad hu
has therefore developed but not yet veriiSed, the fbQowiag lafonnatioo:
-Fnt, with one apparent exoeptioo, very few of the RTC investigators in the field
ofBces which have been or are going to be doaed soen wQUng to transfer to
regional RTC offloes; instead the regiooal oflBoes have apparently had to hire new
mostly relatively inej^Krienced iovesdgaton who toty need 6 to 12 mooths to
fafflilLarize themselves with the investigative Set in hundreds of faOed S&L casea;
-Second, this could lead to tlgniScaat delays in inwestiptions and oonsequent filing
of lawsuits (which eui be a poblem is view of tbe 3 year stttute of UmltatlocM);
-Third, with numerous boaes of docunems in transit and documents not readDy
tvaOable and with new invesdpton asdgned to tbe casea, fee counsel taxjf
eooounter difBculda in pursuing these cases expeditiously: and
-Fourth, the savinp resulting from the dosinp of at least some of these ofBoes
may be iSusoiy; fbr example, we have bees told that over 300 eontnctors have
beat hired in the Baton Rouge office alone, to take over the woik of RTC
515
employees tad thit Tampa RTC Investiguon have been detailed to the Atlaou
ofSce, in preparation for the dosing of the Tampa ofBoe, all at great per diem and
travel costs.
It appears that the upcoming cloture of the RTC Invectigations' offices Id Houston
(no*- planned for May 1993), Baton Rouge (in June 1993), and Tampa (date unknovni)
may mean that any such adverse impacts may cootinue.
The Subcommittee's inquiry is at a very early stage, and we have not heard from
aU sides in this matter, so we are not in a position to render any condtisive findings as to
whether RTC lawsuits and criminal referrals have been and will be adversely impacted by
such dosores. While normally we would await the completion of the Subcommittee's
investigatioa and bold a hearing to air all sides, I am sotsewhat concerned that by the time
we were to hold a bearing, it could be too late.
For that reason, I believe it would be appropriate for yoa or the Oversight Board
to look into this matter now and determine whether any change^ temporary or permanent,
arc needed concerning the RTCj imminent closures of RTC Investigations' offices and
also whether any action is necessary to remedy the impaa oo cases from closures which
have already occurred, to ameliorate any such possible advene impacts.
I would appredate a response to this letter and also a briefing of Subcommittee
staff by May 3, 1993. Please feel free to have your staff or Oversight Board staff conuct
Subcommittee Senior Counsel Stephen McSpadden or Chief Counsel Thomas KahzL
Thank you for your cooperation.
John M. Sprmtt, Jr.
cc Peter Monroe
President
RTC Oversight Board
516
IMPORTANCE OF TEAMWORK
To:
Bcc:
Pron:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John T. Reynolds^legaiertcdalsou
Bradley M. Elbelneieqaliertcdalgul
Rex Taylor#le929rtcdalBet, Thomas Burnslde^legaltrtcdal
Carolyn P. PerryeLEGAL«RTCATLBAY
Arturo Vera-Rojas9LEGALeRTCDAL
Reorganization Transition
Thursday, April 16, 1992 14:05:11 CDT
To facilitate the Bovement of case files in the new reorganized
structure it would be wise, while support help still exists, to box up and
inventory all files in cases where total closeouts have been drafted and
signed. We can then hold then in storage until we Icnow where to ship these
docunents. As to 1993-1994 statute cases, those cases in which we have merit
and money already established, we should think about hiring counsel. As to
1992 cases, I expect that the current attorney will have completed asset
searches on the targets and made a determination regarding whether to proceed
with suit by now and has made arrangements to hire counsel in the meritorious
cases. Conversely they should be working on closeouts of the non-meritorious
92 cases as well. Those 94 and late 93 cases not falling into the above
category should also likely be inventoried and boxed by thrift in preparation
for the attrition factor between now and September, (non-active cases only) .
Once the final selections are made, whoever is Section Chief will then have
the responsibility of reassigning the cases which will then have to be worked
on a priority basis
517
V
To: Thomas BurnaldeiLEGALeRTCOAL
Cc:
Bcc: ,
Fr' : ..y§Legal-pls§RTCDC
Su-^ect: re: BEXAR/EY/TOLLING III
Date: Sunday, February 23, 1992 13:40:09 CST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
No — I intend to keep pushing the defendant class idea — we are already
using it in — and Bill and Jerry are only concerned if we name
all of the partners individually by name. They like the class approach. By
the way, no thanks are necessary for the work this case has required of ne so
far — this is part of our implicit deal — I support you here and you support
me there. Besides, I'm always going to be patient with creative, intelligent
efforts like those you've displayed on this case.
How soon will I get BancPlus back? I noticed that a copy of my corrections
was in the package I received from Sharon recently — but I did not see the
corrected memo. We're going to be on the fast track again, aren't we? To
answer your question — I think we may want to have a draft assignment and
memo accompany the ATS memo, so that I can start that process earlier. JVT
advised me that I couldn't do anything on Bexar until Friday because Graham was
out of town — but now I wonder if having the memo waiting on his desk wouldn't
have been better.
Thanks for your and Sharon's appreciation of the drama of my getting the
a-^ignment from Seelig — I enjoyed pulling it out of the fire. Every thing I
c now is accompanied by so much planned effort, it felt good to find out that
I can still get the agency to move on a "simple" crisis. Did you know how many
stops '..^ . were pulling out? Apparently ' had been calling JVT
trying to get him to do something ... but it wasn't in^iil I asked JVT whether I
should call the Chairman that he suggested calling Seelig might be a better
first choice. I think he thought I would do it.
518
/^
To:
r
Cc:
Bcc:
Froa:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify;
Foxvarded by;
Roberta H. CI ar*, Anne E. Meroney§legal-PLS§RTCATLMID
Thomas BurnsideeLegaieRTCDAL
LaVern A. Pritchard8LegaieRTCKCNOR,R. Lee Andersen
April A. Breslaw, Christopher A. Byrne, James P. Clark
Roberta H. Clark, David G. Eisenstein, Kathleen Flake
Mira N. Mar shall, Manuel A. Palau, Suzanne Rigby
Harold M. Sklar, Robert J. Soffer.Jon A. Stewart, Susan Tibolla
Sharon D. Zissman, Bradley M. SmolkineLEGAL§RTCATL
Julie F. YandaeLEGALeRTCKC, Sharon HowardeLEGALeRTCDAL
Bruce Pederson§Legal§RTCOEN
:•*- I .-pis
Tolling Agreements
Thursday, February 27,
1992 S:22:37 CST
X believe you should all be aware of Tom Burnside's achievement in negotiating
a tolling agreement with Ernst & Young in the BankPLUS matter. The tolling
agreement is the result of long term negotiations between Tom and EY, and
represents a real breakthrough for us. It is a very favorable document that
?urport8 to bind not only EY, but its partners personally. More
mportantly, EY has recognized that this tolling agreement is a model for
other cases — they simply offered me the same deal as the final BankPLUS
agreement, except that I could choose the dates for the tolling commitments to
end.
f 'Y those of you who have dealt with EY can appreciate what a turn around in
t..eir attitude this represents. Together with Suzanne Rigby 's work on the
subpoena enforcement, Tom's efforts seem to have developed some respect for
our ability to coordinate what we are doing, and to take and hold tough
negotiating positions. Maybe this means we will be able to waste less time on
meaningless preliminary fencing.
All of you who have EY cases, and those of you who have tolling issues
involving other firms, will want copies of the BancPLUS agreement. I plan to
use it as the basis for discussions today with Peat Marwick. I will make
it available to everyone here in DC; those elsewhere can contact me or Too.
(Of course I'm volunteering Tom without consulting him.) In addition, I plan
to circulate in the next couple of days a package with the materials
I have on defensive class actions against partnerships, including a draft
complaint and back-up materials.
519
To:
Cc:
Thomas Burns ide9I>EGM<eRTCDAL
Bcc:
Froa:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
EY Tolling Agreemenc
Friday, February 28, 1992
8:34:23 CST
Ton —
CONGRATULATIONS 1 1 Do you walk on water now? You've done a tremendous job.
It's nice to know that WDC recognizes and appreciates what you've
accomplished.
Since . drafted you for assistance, I
tolling agreement that you used with EY.
throughout our region.
Take care — and enjoy the limelight.
'd like to ask for a copy of the
I'll make sure it gets circulated
To:
Cc:
Bc^
Fr
Su. ^ect:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Thomas B\irnsideiLEGAL§RTCDAL
Sharon HowardSLEGALiRTCDAL
John B. BeatySLegal-plseRTCDC
JLegal-plsiRTCDC
re: EY Tolling Agreement
Sunday, March 1, 1992 9:17:25 CST
N
Thanks for the helpful explanation of the status of the EY tollino anreement.
"— is struggling to work out the details of his
defendant class - your combined efforts will really contribute to RTC's
ability to prosecute accountant liability claims vigorously.
and I are Impressed with what you have been doing, and felt that you
deserve credit and recognition for what you have accomplished.
520
To: Thomas Burns IdcfLBGALCRTCOAL
Cc:
"-c: I
jm: - T - ^ 'tLftgal-plsCRTCOC
Subject: re; "Say xc ain"t so"
Date: Monday, April 13, 1992 14:38:18 COT
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
Thanks, Tom. Working with you has been a real pleasure. Our paths will
continue to cross, I aa sure. X asked for a May 3 release date - but the
crisis here may result in some slippage. Before long, RTC will sunset and
be folded back into FDIC. Since I am likely to handle PLS appeals, we will no
doubt work together again. Meanwhile, good luck and best wishes - you are
mzJcing a gigantic contribution PLS - just wish we could ^et you involved in
the EY coordination effort. John says you are swasped with cases, GT
coordination, and a Pru Bache project/memo.
To: Robert T. St8ples(Inv«stfRTCOALG0L
Beth M. HilliaasCZnvesttRTCOAIiGXn.
Salvatore BemardinofZMVEST«RTCATLBAY
Salvatore BemardinoCZnvttsttMCOALSOL
: E. Heal FindleyCZnvestfRTCOALCUL
James L. AdamseZnvestCRTCOAIiCOL
Janes Conroy«XNV«RTCOALKET, Chris JonesfEXECeRTCOAL
Chris Jones#Zl(V«RTCOALIIET
Bcc:
Prom: Thomas BumsidetLBGALCRTCDAL
Subject; DLJ settlement
Date: Monday, June 8, X992 12:01:57 COT
Attach;
Certify: M
Forwarded by;
DLJ has agreed to settle BancPlus for $2.5 million. Investigations in
general— and Bob, Beth, and Sam in particular deserve a large portion of the
credit for bringing this oortion of the case to a position wh»<-« we could get
the recovery. Now on to r . ,-■ . -*
521
To: Thomas L. Hlndes0Legal-pls0RTCOC
Cc: ' Mark Gabrellian§Legal-lit§RTCDC
Bcc: Thomas Burnslde6LEGAL§RTCDAL
7b: -pis
> .oject: Accounting Expertise
Date: Monday, June 8, 1992 9:13:56 COT
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
If one of the candidates for PLS vacancies bows out, ■^oxi may wish to consider
bringing Tom Burnside of the Dallas office up to Washington. He has
concentrated on accountant liability claims in the former Southwest Region and
has developed several good claims against EY. From what I have seen, his work
is outstanding. He does a good job of detecting the warts in potential
claims - a valuable trait. His work is creative and solid: for example, he
agresssively pursued an insurance fund claim arising out of Bexar and received
an assignment of the claim from the FDIC as manager of the funds. This novel
but thoroughly documented claim will be one of the more attractive RTC claims
that RTC can propound in seeking a global settlement with EY. Tom has
volunteered to help pull together claims information for our discussions with
EY and is an energetic and cooperative team member. Because of his in depth
understanding of accountant liability he would make a valuable contribution to
the nationwide PLS effort if he were recruited to help with accounting claims.
Naturally, he has substantial experience with other professional liability
claims as well - but I am particularly impressed with his expertise re
accounting Issues.
522
To:
Bcc:
From;
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John T. Reynolds* l«9al«rtcdaleou
Bradley K. ElbeinClegallCrtcdalgul
Rex Tayloreieg2«rtcdalset,ThOBa8 Bumslde91egal«rtcdal
JlB CoopereEXECeRTCOAL.JaaeB Conroy«INVeRTCDAU(ET
Thoaas L. KindesCLegal-plsCRTCOC
David G. EisensteineLegal-plseRTCDC
Mark GabrellianCLegal-plseRTCOC
Sharon HovardCLEGALeRTCOAL
DliJ Settlement
Tuesday, June 9. 1992 9:27:35 CDT
David G. Bisenstein^Legal-plseRTCDC
Comments by: David G. Eisensteinei«gal-plseRTCDC
Forwarded to: Thomas BumsideeLECALfRTCDAI,
Comments :
Great work, Tom. On the pro tanto/pro rata you might want to talJc
to Gene Comey who is doing a bi^ case in OK on bow to bind all the
parties that may want contribution down the road.
[Original Message]
Congratulations goes to Tom Bumside who played hardball with Donaldson
Lufkin i Jenrette on a claim arising out of BancPlus. The original settlement
meeting I attended with DLJ in Dallas, the settlement number discussed was
'~00,000. Several weeks later, the settlement number was up to $2.1 million
ich received serious consideration. Tom was adamant however, that after
discounting the claim to present value and discounting it for litigation
risks, that $2.5 million was the right number to se'-tle the claim. DLJ
ultimately capitulated and a settlement memo is being drafted although there
are a number of outstanding issues such as seeking a ruling from the Court
regarding pro tanto vs. pro rata settlement credit and what we do with the
unnamed EY defendants to bind them to the settlement credit ruling. He will
have recouped all costs of case preparation to date and funded the future
litigation costs against the other defendants with this settlement.
CONGRATULATIONS TOM I
523
To I Diana HaadozmiHTVinTCDKUaX
] Jaaa* ConroyeiNveRTCOALMET
Htlllaa J. DaPugbeiNVESXeRTCATLSOU
Rax Tayloret£02eRTC0ALKET
Bcci
rroBi Thoaaa Bumaida0XJ:OAI,eRTCOAL
Subjactt Natroplolltan
Datai Tuaaday, July 31, 1992 ISilSiOS COX
Attach!
Cartifyt N
Porwardad byi
This probably falls within the 'Tall aa what I don't alraady knOM cataqory..."
but I wanted to foraally acknowledge what a great job Karen did on the ATS
preparation and the Investigation leading up to it. Karen willingly gave
whatever time It took to get the job done and her insight waa critical to the
final product. Often Karen served as the primary coordinator of the
inveatigation and with respect to Rad, she acted as the day-to-day supervisor.
Indeed, Karen waa the one who aoat frequently kept the case aoving when
everyone else becaae diatracted on other projects. Karen was extraordinarily
goal oriented, organized, self-aotivated and eager in the Inveatigation/
ATS process and should be coaaended for her work on Metropolitan. Quite
frankly, the caae would not have been developed without her efforta.
524
T»l Has Tarler«I.Ba3CRTCDALMBX
Cet I
CI
Mil Tboius BumBld*«LCaJa.CKTCOKL
Subjacti Orartla*
Data I Saturday, July 3S, 1993 7iSai47 COT
Attach I
Cartlfyi M
PorMardad byi
In viaw of ear diffaring poaltlona ragacdlag orartlaa/coaptlaa and In ordar
to proparly davalop ay eaaoa, I will saithar aspact aor raquaat ovartlaa or
eoaptiaa in tha futnra. Z will still «M>rk auch additional houra that ara
aacaaaary to proparly invaatigato and haadlo ay easaa aa part of ay
profasaional raaponsibility .
X do hava soaa additional obaarvatioaa ragarding your ovartiaa/coaptiaa
rulasi
(1) Orartlaa ia not tha aquivalant of coaptiaa. I raqnastad coaptiaa to
that I could partially coapansata ay faaily for tha avaninga and Maakanda I
was Morking to davalop ay caaos. Obrlonaly, a faw astra dollara in a paychack
doas not sarva auch pnrposo.
(3) Z find tha eencapt of ovartiaa aa appliad to profaasionala to ba
daaaanlng. Z work as auch aa 30 astra houra a waak whan 1 aa working on an ATS
lo or othar aajor projoct. Z willingly put auch tiaa in bacauaa of a sania
o( profaasional prida and in ordar to obtain tha aatisfaction of doing tha
baat job Z can. Z do not and will not put in such houra for tha $5 to $15/hour
ovartiaa. My tiaa ia ««rth aora than that and Z would rathar donata or -aaf
tha tiaa.
(3) Z also find tha eoncapt of 'aaking for paraission* to work tha
hours aacassary to proparly davalep a easa to ba antithatical to profassional
athies. Brary attomay auat aaka tha paraonal dacisien en tha aaount of tiaa
Bacassary to aaat hia or her own ataadarda aa trail as general etandards. No
attorney can abdicate inch decision. Xndeed, Z beliara that a PX.S attomay
that confinaa hia or her work houra to a * 40 hour week' on a regular basis
will and up cloaing-ent caaaa that ahould be brought bacauaa of the ascusa
that *wa did not have enough tiae or evidence.* AltematiTely, insufficient
investigation aight reaolt ia suite that ahould not be brought.
(4) Z find it ironic that in the laat aonth or ae, Z have aubaittad two
Authority to Sua aaaos and two Authority to Settle aeaos that have received
virtually no subatantive rnaaant froa you but yet you want to tightly control
ovartiae/coaptiae requests.
Zn sxiaaary, Z view thia aattar as cloaed. Z will not trouble yon any further
with coaptiaa requests and tha KIC will still receive ay continued efforts in
developing and pursuing aeritorioua, coat-effective caaaa. Zta a *win-win*
situation for you and tha KXC.
525
TOi
Ce:
Bee:
Proa;
Sub j act:
Data:
Xttachi
Cartify:
ronrarded by:
Thoaaa Burns ld«aLEGXL(lRTCDAL
R«Z TayloraLEG2(IRTCDAU(ET
> Thoaaa L. HindasdLagal-plsQRTCDC
Mark GabrallianQtagal-plsQRTCDC
BancPlus
Wednesday, September 2, 1992 9:36:09 CDT
M
Thank you for the revised analysis section on the settleaent
reeomaendation meao for the Donaldson, Lufkin 6 Jenrette claia. I've reviewed
it with Ton Hindes who has given the go-ahead, close the deal. Oood work.
Sbi
cei
Bcci
From I
Subjacti
Data I
Attach I
Cartifri
Forwardad byi
ThoiMS Bunaida«LSaAL«XXCDUi
Kas XarlorCLSaStltXCOUJCR. -
ThOiua L. Bindaa<I.a9al-plB«ltXCI>C
Mark aabralliaaCI,a9ai-plBCItXCOC
BancPlus
Hadaaaday, Octobar 7, 1993 lli3Si33 COX
Oood Mork oa tha BancPlua aattlaaanta and tha racn— ■odatlen mmmau. X
hara ravlaMad and inltialad all thraa and aa paaaiag thaa on to Toa Blndaa.
526
To: Williaa J. DePugh«INV§RTCDALMET
I Diane MendozaeiNV@RTCDALMET, Chris JoneseiNVeRTCOALMET
Cc: Rex TayloreLEG2§RTCDALMET
Bcc:
From: Thomas Burnside@LEGAL9RTCDAL
Subject: Murray
Date: Thursday, November 5, 1992 7:13:02 CST
Attach :
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
I want to commend Mike Shuler for his extraordinary efforts in developing the
accountincr claim in Murray Savings. Mike provided the expertise, long hours,
and "passion" needed to push the claim through the system; the claim would not
have been developed without his efforts. Examples of Mike's work include:
— He personally reviewed workpapers in order to focus the work of
outside consultants and fee counsel. This work paid off in the first
couple of meetings with a consultant that we were using for the first
time. The consultant was sloppy and careless in his review of the
workpapers and financial statements. Mike immediately detected the
problems and we were able to replace the consultant in a timely
manner.
— Mike continually challenged the consultants, fee counsel and myself
on our views of the case and effectively communicated his "outrage"
with the problems with the audit. Such outrage is essential to the
ultimate success to a lawsuit or settlement discussions in the it
transforms seemingly arcane technical areas into a moral crusade.
He refused to let anyone to just go through "the motions."
— He put in countless hours — including weekends and long days — to
ensure a workproduct that met his standards. Vfhile Mike strived to
properly delegate work where appropriate, he willingly pitched in
when he saw others (including myself) struggling.
I could continue with other examples but one thought probably summarizes my
thoughts
I have dealt with numerous consultants, fee counsel, and others in
developing accounting malpractice cases. Some were very good; some
were terrible. If I could have only one person to help me on
developing such a case it would be Mike Shuler.
527
To:
Cc: •
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by;
Milllam J. D«PU9h«INV«RTCDAIXET
Chris Jones«INVeRTCOALMET, Diane MendozaeiNV«RTCDALMET
Rex TayloreLEGZeRTCDXLMET
Thonas BurnsideeLEGALeRTCDAL
Murray
Thursday, November S, 1992 8:07:22 CST
I would like to commend Mary Jo Baldwin for her work on Murray. Mary Jo has
had a dual role in Murray and has been outstanding in both. Most recently, she
has been assistinc^ Mike Shuler on the accounting claim. Even though the
accounting investigation was not "her job", she willingly pitched in to
deve-op the claim even if it meant weekend work. Her insights and help
really made a difference. On a lighter note she was so insistent that we
meet the November 4 deadline, that she camped out at fee counsel's office
in order to ensure that the attorneys (including me) came to conclusion on the
project. Nobody was "going to mess with" Mary Jo in failing to meet the
deadline 1
Mary Jo has made the most difference in her role as Lead Investigator on the
director's and officer's claim. I received responsibility for Murray after the
filing of the suit and the initial wave of discovery. Accordingly, I was not
in a position to adequately review our factual responses. Mary Jo filled the
void and spent an enormous amount of time working on the answers to discovery.
In that capacity, she was very proactive and took a leadership position in
coordinating the discovery. She deftly balanced the needs of fee counsel to
appear cooperative in responding to discovery with the strain of such responses
on internal RTC resources.
In summary, Mary Jo has been a superb lead investigator on Murray. Her blend
of hard work, dedication, organization, and leadership have transformed a
potential problem into a (relatively) smooth case.
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Date:
Attach :
Certify:
Forwarded by:
James P. ClarkSLegal-plsSRTCDC
Neysa L. Day«LEGAL-PLS§RTCKC
B.J. HickerteLEGAL-PLSeRTCKC
Jann L. Harley€LegaieRTCKCCHI
Thomas BumsideiLEGALCRTCDAL
eLECAL-PLS. -
Pru Bache ATS
Tuesday, December 1, 1992 9:11:33 CST
N
Jim —
Our Acting AGC signed off on the PruBache ATSettle Memo. I've gotten the
green light from the business side, so as soon as JT gets back into the office
(he's in Chicago today), we'll have the memo formally approved at this level.
Tom, thanks for the fine work you did on this case. I really enjoyed reading
your memo, and I admired the skill and analysis you obviously had put into
this case. Take care.
528
To; <CLEGAL-PLS
Cc:
Bcc:
From: Thoaas Burnslde9LEGALeRTCDAL
Subject: SF 171
Date: Wednesday, December 9, 1992 15:40:26 CST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by: <
I am sending you the attachnents to my 171 (I skipped the form itself) .
I appreciate your willingness to act as a reference. I posted for the DC PLS
slots as well as any PLS slots outside of Dallas. Z am also going to make a
pitch for a lateral transfer to DC as a Senior Attorney if they need me sooner
than the end of the posting process (or aftervardl). In any event, you may get
a call (that would be a good signl) and I wanted you to have my resume and
performance evaluation if you were called. Anyways, I'm pretty proud of my last
two years. Its not bad for a midwestern fidelity and surety lawyer.
FYI — ^' - has gone to bat for me in DC. While she has spoken with Tom
Hindes, I think the key is Mark Gabrellian. Mark has responsibility for Dallas
and has reviewed at least some of my work product. If he wants me, I think
they will make room for me; if not, I don't stand a chance. In all modesty,
however, I would gladly base my chances on my work product.
One other touchy point — the region down here is going down hill fast. We have
lost Asher out of Houston and the Baton Rouge and San Antonio attorneys are not
happy about the move. I'll let you get Carl's feelings direct but Rex really
gave him a raw deal. The bottom line is that DC miaht not b« to eager to take
me unless they realize that keeping me down here with Rex will not work in the
long term (why would I use "RTC" and "longterm" in the same sentence?!). On
the other hand, I don't want to appear to give an ultimatum since I really
like what I am doing and do not want to appear disgruntled.
I would appreciate your "read" on the situation and any suggestions that you
: have.
P.S. Doesn't it seem like an eternity since we joined the RTC? Who ever would
have imagined all that transpired. Yet, for all the grief, I think we were
given the professional opportunity of a lifetime. It will be hard to go back
to normal cases! 11 Take care.
might have.
529
To: Chris JoncsCINVCRTCOALMET
Cc: J
Bcc;
Froa: ThoDas Burns ideCLEGXLCRTCDAL
Subject: Bexar
Date: Monday, December 21, 1992 9:06:39 CST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
Z would like to conaend Don Hoods and Wayne Kalina for their hard work and
dedication in developing the Bexar Savings professional liability claims. As
the Lead Investiagtor on Bexar for almost two years, Don did an extraordinary
job in managing investigators and outside consultants as well as document
control. Don's experience and insight also helped us focus upon issues that we
might otherwise have missed.
As the San Antonio Accountant Liability Investigator, Wayne was instrumental
in supervising the accounting consultants in both substantive and budget
areas. Wayne's experience and insight was essential for an independent
evaluation of Kenneth Leventhol's work product.
Both Don and Wayne willingly gave the "extra effort" that such a large claim
needed in order to be effectively pursued and such efforts were a substantial
factor in the RTC recovery against Ernst ( Young and probable recoveries
aaainst the directors and officers. Total recoveries on the Bexar professional
liability claims are expected to exceed $50 million.
/
530
To: - -=-^LECAL-PLSt ^iv
Cc: I
Bcc:
From: Thomas Burnslcle@LEGALiRTCDAL
Subject; re:
Date: Friday, January 15, 1993 12:25:49 CST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by;
Thanks for the Info. I need to figure out what I want to do in the next few
years before Z maXe a moving decision. Also, Mimi has a fair amount of input
on the decision since she does not want to caravan around the country from one
RTC posting to another without some legitimate career goals in mind. (She
doesn't think that moving away from a particular boss is an adequate
career goal by itself she does think that DC would be a good move)
In any event, it looks as if the rosters will force me to make at least some
preliminary decisions in the very near future. I will keep you posted and
probably bounce some ideas off you.
P.S. Mimi and I are expecting our fourth child 1
To: Thomas BurnsldetlJGALSRTCDAL
Cc:
Bcc:
From: . -pls(
Subject: PruBache Glory
Date: Sunday, January 24, 1993 17:39:55 CST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
Torn, I wasn't trying to hog all the glory in hot topics discussion of the
PruBache settlement. I wrote a longer version featuring you and Loughran.
They did a nice job of editing it but took out any mention of you.
Anyway, according to our figures, you appear to be PLS's biggest breadwinner.
531
To: Thomas J. Burnside«DAL-LEGAL12C§RTCDAL
Cc: '
Bcc:
From: . .-PLS
Subject:
Date: Thursday, March 4, 1993 18:05:14 CST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
Tom — you would hate it here. • is working us to death — but we are loving
every minute. I have meant to tell you for months what fine work I thought
you did on the Pru-Bache settlement— both substantively and in coordinating
the process. That was quite an undertaking, yet the process was handled so
smoothly. I don't think anyone in the world has any illusions about your
singlehandedly putting the deal together. Z guarantee you received no help
from me.
As crazy as it gets here, and it does — I truly believe now that life is
actually crazier elsewhere 1
To: " .... -PLSt
Cc: - - .
Bcc *
Prom: Thomas J. BurnsideeDAI.-LECAL12CeRTCDAL
Subject: re:
Date: Monday, March 15, 1993 9:15:28 CST
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by:
Thanks for the news. I need a little time to make the decision. The question
is not whether I leave here but where do I go?
I had to postpone my trip to St Louis until Friday because the GAO is coming
to Dallas on weds, and Thurs of this week (unless the snow storm delays them.)
I'm glad they are moving so quickly — I would like to resolve as much (or
perhaps all) of the situation down here as possible before I leave.
Please let me know your timetable for a decision. The start date from my
perspective would probably be mid-April although early April is possible.
I will touch base with you next Monday to let you know how it went in St
Louis. At this point. It looks like I will be leaving the RTC but I have been
"flip-flopping** all month.
532
BURNSIDE GRIEVANCE RECORD
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
Prom:
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
John H. LomaxeEXECeRTCOAL
E. Glion CurtiseLegal-sc§RTCDC
E. Glion Curtis#Legal-ExeceRTCKC
Arturo A. Vera-Rojas§DAL-LEGAIil5A§RTCDAL
Rex Taylor§LEG2eRTCDALMET
David A. Stoc)cwell§DAL-LEGAL12AfRTCDAI.
Thonas J. Burnside§DAL-LEGAL12CfRTCDAL
Grievance against Messrs, Taylor and Vera-Rojas
Wednesday, March 3, 1993 14:31:21 CST
N
Earlier this afternoon, I distributed a nemorandua entitled:
"Step One Rebuttal and Step Two Appeal of
the February 5 Grievance against AGO Vera-Rojas
and Section Chief Taylor
and
Report of Improper Conduct by RTC Employees
under your Supervision."
AGC Vera-Rojas would not respond to my request that he identify his
immediate superior (s) so I have sent the memo to you based upon my
information and belief that you jointly are such superiors. If I am incorrect,
could you please identify the correct person(s) who should receive the memo
and let me know so that I may send a copy of the memo to them as well.
533
RETALIATION AGAINST DALLAS INVESTIGATIONS
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From;
Subject:
Date:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
James R. Dudine§Oper-inv@RTCDC
Chris Jones#FSC-INVEST3§RTCDAL
William J. DePugh§FSC-INVEST2§RTCDAL
PLS/ Investigations problems
Thursday, April 22, 1993 15:12:42 CDT
N
I recommend that the OIG Audit function be assigned to identify,
analyze, and document the perceived problems between PLS and Investigations in
the Dallas Territories. I can think of no other solution to this matter since
a solution does not seem at hand. My attempts to reconcile are apparently not
received as being in good faith and this is affecting the operation.
534
RTC
MtSOlUTIOM TKUST COK^OPATION
B«nMa(TWOWs
KalaH>( TW C«and«ac(
aoxsnsAnaojieusDaiir
P.O. ••• «SMS. on Fvi« Nit K4, lu. <M
!>-■-, -r 7n<S4»if ■ ]|4.Ma-UM ■ FAX 114-Mt.wn
MEMORANDUM
TO: Janes R. Dudlne
Director of Investigations
FROM: Willian J. DePugh
Director, Field Investigations
DATE: July 19, 1993
SUBJECT: Dallas Investigations Management
Based on our telephone conversation on Friday, July 16, 1993 I am
concerned and grieved that you would discuss Dallas organization,
personnel and staffing natters with members of Kansas City
Investigations and Washington P.L.S. management without consulting
with, or notifying me or my direct supervisor, Jim Messec, Vice
President for Operations and Accounting.
I was not aware that you perceived problems in FSC or
Investigations management since you have not addressed them to us.
Dallas has statistics that are equal to the other offices and has
a number of high profile litigation cases going forward. It
appears that you are depending on PLS information rather than the
Dallas FSC data.
In the absence of any manual, books of procedures or standardizing
policies from your office, each office is functioning according to
their own plans of organization and case needs. I believe Dallas
achievements will attest to my management team's skill and
dedication.
Based on Friday's conversation, our previous conversation regarding
what I provided GAO (congressional oversight) concerning PLS
problems and the rampant rumor that you want Kansas City
Investigation management to replace Dallas management, I must
conclude that your actions are an attempt to retaliate against
Dallas for revealing PLS problems and asking for organization and
staffing remedies. At a minimum, your actions have embarrassed us
and diminished our professional status among our peers.
I believe that I am following my mission statement and position
benchmark. Unless formerly notified otherwise, I will continue to
do so under the direct supervision of Jim Messec, Vice President
for the Dallas Operations and Accounting.
cc: Jim R. Messec
535
RESOLUTION TRUST CORPORATION
KcwMac TW CrW(
Rotariaf IW CaafUcaee
MEMORANDUM
TO; Jaaes R. Dudine
Director of Investigations
FROM: Diane M. Mendoza
Assistant Director, Dallas Investigations
DATE: July 20, 1993
SUBJECT: Dallas Investigations Management
This morning. Vice President "for Operations and Accounting Jim
Messec shared with me an e-mail message (copy attached) . That
message was sent to him this morning by you, and contained a
reference to me which causes me great concern. The reference is
"... explore options available to insulate Jones and Mendosa from
direct contact and "client-like" responsibility o er (sic) PLS
cases."
As I stated, this phrase caused me great concern, as the RTC
"benchmark" for my position [Department Head (Investigations), LC-
301-15] contains several references which require interaction and
direct contact with PLS. They are as follows:
"Directs and coordinates the investigative activity at the
Field Office site; has overall responsibility for supervision of
investigation and clerical personnel assigned to the unit; has
responsibility for establishing the practical criteria to develop
a claim and for planning program activities to ensure optimal
recovery by the RTC on insurance policies and claims; reviews and
makes recommendations concerning the viability of claims.
Reviews and evaluates complex legal documents for development
of lawsuits; identifies privileged documents; assists local coussal
in litigation; subsequently, serves as witaess at depositions aad
trials in capacity of official record holder of the depository of
information for each claim.
Coordinates information between the liquidation/consolidation
site, Field Office, Legal OivisioD, and investigators from the
insurance companies; must work very closely with the Legal Division
«303 Fo/vo Pvti Rati. Sutt 600. 0*«ac TX T5t3S B00-rB2-46T4 iU-902-3426
536
To:
Cc: >
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Dace:
Attach:
Certify:
Forwarded by
William J. DePugh«FSC-INVEST2«RTCDAL
Jim R. Me8Sec«FSC-EXEC«RTCDAL
James R. Dudine«Oper-inv«RTCDC
re: Meeting
Tuesday, July 20, 1993 7:30:38 CDT
N
Bill, Che sscenario you present in you July 19 memo to me is way off Che marlc.
I requested a meeting with you to accomplish the following objectives and to
atten^t to fit these objectives into your personal plans and timetables:
1. Get your unoguivocal commitment to establish a cooperative program
with PLS in Dallas.
2. Discuss ways to minimize the potential for resurfacing old
animosities, e.g. explore options available to insulate Jones and Mendoza from
direct contact and "client-like" responsibility o er PLS cases.
3. Begin to inject a Blue Ribbon type process in the Dallas office,
Kansas City has the most fully developed and successfull program, therefore,
either KC people could come to Dallas for a while to get the program started
or you and othersw could visit KC to get acclimated to the process. This is
an important goal and like it or not KC has done well with this approach.
Your reference to rampant rumors about a KC takeover stem from, I
suppose, contingency plans discussed as options in the event you did not
return from your medical leave or decided to retire at the end of this year
537
To:
Cc:
Bcc:
From:
Subject:
Dace:
Atcach:
Certify:
Forwarded by:
Anne M. H. SlgcrstadABXBCVRTCDAL
ThomaB Bainbric)c«ADMZN«RTCSAL
William J. DePugh«FSC-INVBST2«RTCDAL
L. Richard lorioaiDveBtigationsaRTCKCMIO
Michael R. Vanvalkenburg«InveBtigation8«RTCKCMZD
Donald A. Sweeter8«InveBCigations«RTCKCMID
Department Head Positions
Friday, August 6, 1993 12:19:48 COT
N
Reorganization lines of authority and control have placed the Dallas
Office of Investigations Office under the Kansas City Office of Investigations.
On behalf of L. Richard lorio, Kansas City Office. Field Investigations Officer
and William J. DePugh, Dallas Office. Field Investigations Officer
it is requested that six (6) internally posted Supervisory Investigator IiG-14
positions be posted for Dallas Co Open August 9, 1993 and to run the minimum
time for internal positions to run.
The selecting officials for these positions will be Mike R. Van Valkenburg,
Manager. Field Investigations and Mr. L. Richard lorio with the Kansas City
Office and Mr. William J. DePugh. Field Investigations Officer.
Mr. Van Valkenburg will be temporarily assigned to the Dallas Office
for an indefinite period of time.
Mr. DePugh can be reached Hon 06/09 and Tues 08/10 in Kansas City at
(816) 968-7212.
538
To: Anna M. KautzmancOper-lnvaRTCDC
Cc: ,
BCC:
From: Michael R. VanvaUcenburg«INVEST-2«RTCKC
Subject: re: Geez
Date: Wednesday, September 1. 1993 9:12:25 CDT
Attach:
Certify: N
Forwarded by: Anna M. Kautzinan«Oper-inv«RTCDC
Conments by: Anna M. KautzinanttOper-invttRTCDC
Forwarded to: William J. DePugh«FSC-INVEST2«RTCDAL
Ccnnients :
FYl
[Original Message]
Got your e-mail, I agree with everything you said. I got word that my e-mail
to Richard which was forwarded to Dudine had been ciculated or has been
discussed with some of the Investigators. This was the e-mail where I
addressed Arturo's comnents about Investigations. At the time X wrote that
e-mail I thought the problem was 50 - 50 with PLS and Investigations. Now
after all I have read and been exposed to, I believe the problems were more
80% PI,S and 20% Investigations. I think that some of the Investigators and
maybe Chris and Diane ( if they have been told about or read about my memo to
Richard) have the wrong idea about how I feel about Investigations in Dallas.
Onward and upward!
539
J
n
ih
\ il
!!
is
'..
:*
w
%
i :
\Vi
Mf
ft
Hil
ill
ii!
lilt
iji
'i
a
I
f
si!
c ■ «
1
II
f|i
ihiflii
Hi
liiil
^1 !h il
rrliS'sJE'is;
li
iiiilfll
-\\\
'I'
ii
f
II
rif
r
L.!.M!'
o
76-816 0-94 (544)
BOSTON PUBLIC LIBRARY
1 1 II nil I
3 9999 05982 001 7
ISBN 0-16-043945-0
9 780160"439452'
90000